Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
00
Institution of Chemical Engineers
Trans IChemE, Vol 76, Part A, November 1998
quilibrium data on the absorption of CO2 in aqueous solutions of single and mixed
amine was analysed using the Modi ed Kent Eisenberg model. The experimental value
of the equilibrium constant for the formation of carbamate, instead of the tted value as
usually used by other investigators, was applied in the analysis. Data on CO2 loading in
aqueous solutions of DEA and MDEA at various temperature (303323 K) and CO2 partial
pressure (0.09100 kPa) obtained from a stirred reactor was tted to generate the different
parameters in the model. Using these constants, the model was applied to predict the CO2
loading in solutions of DEA and MDEA reported in the literature. Prediction was also made on
the loading in solutions of mixed DEA/MDEA obtained from experiments conducted over a
range of composition (DEA:MDEA 0 1) at different temperatures of 303323 K, as well as
those reported in the literature. In all cases, it was found that the model was able to give a
relatively good CO2 loading over a wide range of operating conditions both in solutions of
single and mixed amine using the constants generated from single amine experiments. It also
suggested that the experimental value of the equilibrium constant for the formation of
carbamate obtained from an earlier work can be taken as the true value for the reaction.
Keywords: blended amine; DEA; MDEA; carbon dioxide; absorption
INTRODUCTION
962
HAJI-SULAIMAN et al.
K1
RR NH
RR NCOO
CO2
H2 O
HCO3
H2 O
K5
K4
H2 O
K3
RR NH
HCO 3
CO3
OH
H
K2
HCO3
RR NH
RR NH2
RN NCOO
6
CO2 balance:
a RR NH
HCO3
RR NCOO
CO3
PCO2 /HCO2
Charge balance:
RR NH2
HCO3
RR NCOO
2 CO3
8
where a is the gas loading. The concentration of carbon
dioxide in the liquid phase can be estimated from Henry s
law, i.e.
PCO2
HCO2 CO2 .
EQUILIBRIUM DATA OF CO2 IN AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS OF DEA, MDEA AND THEIR MIXTURES
963
Range of
validity (C)
6.776904
13.8328
66.8007
35.4819
36.7816
22.4773
11.4519
0
0
0
0
0
0
0.010454
48.7594
87.39717
439.709
220.067
235.482
140.932
94.4914
080
2060
3058
0225
0225
0225
0225
K1, DEA 17
K1, MDEA 18
K2 10
K4 19
K3 19
K5 19
HCO219
3071.15
8483.95
17067.2
12431.7
12092.1
13445.9
6789.04
concentration. Thus
K i Ki F i
10
The dependency of the equilibrium constant, Ki , as well as
the Henry s constant, H, with temperature is expressed as
Ki or H
ai/T
b i ln T ci T d i
11
fi
PCO
2
g i ln PCO2
h i PCO2
ji
RR NH
k i ln RR NH
m i RR NH
12
13
PCO2
HCO2
K 1, DEA K 2, DEA K3 K4
K 2, DEA RR NH
K 2, DEA PCO2
H
K 1, DEA
H HCO2
RR NH
A H
B H
PCO2
K4
HCO2
PCO2
RR NH K 1, DEA K 2, DEA
HCO2
RR NH
H
14
C H
D H
K 1, MDEA
K3 PCO2
K5
PCO2
HCO2
2 K3 K4
2 K 1, MDEA K3
K5
RR NH
K3 K4
H
K4
where
K5
PCO 2
K4
HCO2
P2CO2
HCO2
15
K 1, DEA
PCO2
K 1, DEA K 2, DEA
HCO2
PCO2
HCO2
R2 NH
K 1, DEA K 2, DEA K2
K 1, DEA K 2, DEA K4
PCO2
HCO2
PCO2
HCO 2 H
2 K 1, DEA K3 K4
K 1, MDEA K5
K 1, MDEA K3
PCO2
HCO2
PCO2
HCO2
K 1, MDEA
K3 PCO2
H
RR NH
K5
PCO2
H HCO2
PCO2
HCO2
16
964
HAJI-SULAIMAN et al.
gi ln PCO2
ki ln RR NH
17
Formation of carbamate
ji
18
RR NH
Values of these parameters that best t the observed data
with mean residual squares respectively equal to 6.3 10 4
and 9.2 10 4 for aqueous solutions of MDEA and DEA
are given in Table 3. Equation (13) (and equation (15)) is
very sensitive to the initial guess. However, by limiting
the possible root within the range of pH for loaded and
fresh solutions which lies respectively between 7 and 11, the
equation converged to a nal solution within a few
iterations. Using the generated parameters, predicted CO2
loadings were compared with the data of Lee et al.12,13 for
Fi
gi ln PCO2
EQUILIBRIUM DATA OF CO2 IN AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS OF DEA, MDEA AND THEIR MIXTURES
965
Table 2. Experimental and calculated carbon dioxide loading in aqueous solutions of DEA and MDEA.
2M DEA
4M DEA
CO2 Loading a
(mol/mol)
aexpt
PCO2 (kPa)
T
0.098
0.492
1.119
5.355
10.726
32.527
54.213
10.085
T
0.095
0.474
1.039
5.265
10.665
32.147
53.829
104.0.727
T
0.090
0.449
1.040
5.110
10.035
30.358
50.763
98.170
T
1.064
3.130
4.802
10.535
29.756
48.370
95.830
T
1.064
3.069
5.176
10.029
10.349
47.520
93.956
T
0.997
2.938
4.761
9.725
28.435
44.136
91.514
CO2 Loading a
(mol/mol)
acalc
PCO2 (kPa)
303K
0.183
0.325
0.388
0.521
0.591
0.699
0.730
0.786
0.177
0.324
0.393
0.500
0.544
0.631
0.685
0.760
0.098
0.986
4.893
9.863
29.358
48.931
98.628
313 K
0.172
0.278
0.320
0.459
0.538
0.597
0.662
0.727
0.117
0.252
0.325
0.462
0.514
0.604
0.655
0.732
0.095
0.951
5.259
10.413
30.987
52.568
102.119
323 K
0.133
0.152
0.272
0.398
0.473
0.546
0.611
0.688
0.080
0.178
0.256
0.411
0.471
0.567
0.616
0.694
0.095
0.903
4.514
9.028
27.032
46.305
98.673
303 K
0.114
0.244
0.333
0.483
0.673
0.793
0.880
0.112
0.234
0.300
0.452
0.691
0.799
0.905
0.099
0.984
4.918
9.853
29.509
49.100
98.200
313 K
0.103
0.197
0.267
0.374
0.603
0.688
0.805
0.091
0.177
0.243
0.353
0.585
0.698
0.837
0.095
0.954
4.762
9.523
28.521
47.535
95.234
323 K
0.079
0.148
0.194
0.298
0.471
0.590
0.726
0.065
0.133
0.180
0.275
0.483
0.585
0.752
0.090
0.901
4.514
9.028
27.084
45.139
90.279
aexpt
acalc
303 K
0.061
0.309
0.471
0.524
0.588
0.633
0.671
0.131
0.345
0.462
0.505
0.582
0.650
0.687
313 K
0.091
0.281
0.441
0.499
0.561
0.599
0.639
0.087
0.270
0.425
0.477
0.561
0.597
0.674
323 K
0.081
0.193
0.344
0.445
0.498
0.517
0.601
0.054
0.197
0.354
0.419
0.517
0.565
0.641
303 K
0.027
0.061
0.149
0.284
0.516
0.633
0.761
0.014
0.067
0.185
0.276
0.480
0.601
0.758
313 K
0.015
0.052
0.086
0.190
0.384
0.513
0.654
0.011
0.049
0.136
0.207
0.391
0.495
0.653
323 K
0.010
0.037
0.084
0.151
0.251
0.363
0.516
0.007
0.035
0.103
0.159
0.308
0.400
0.548
gi
ji
ki
0.4559
0.002386
0.03628
0
2.88
0
0.2584
0
0.6262
966
HAJI-SULAIMAN et al.
EQUILIBRIUM DATA OF CO2 IN AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS OF DEA, MDEA AND THEIR MIXTURES
A z 2i
bi
j bij
19
The equation considers both short and long range interactions of the different species in the system. The contribution
from the second term on the right hand side of the above
equation which represents the long range interaction has
been found to be small10 and can be ignored. Thus for
practical purposes it can be taken that the activity coef cient
only depends on the electrical charges of the species, z, and
the ionic strength of the solution, I, which in turn depend on
the concentration of all ionic species in the system and the
electrical charges of these species. A and bi in the equation
are constants. Regardless of the type, all protonated amines
possess electrical charges of 1. Thus, from the theoretical
view point, the presence of different amine will not affect
Trans IChemE, Vol 76, Part A, November 1998
967
968
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
HAJI-SULAIMAN et al.
systems using the electrolyte NRTL equation, Ind Eng Chem Res, 28:
1060.
Haji-Sulaiman, M. Z. and Aroua, M. K., 1996, Equilibrium of CO2 in
aqueous diethanolamine (DEA) and amino methyl propanol (AMP)
solutions. Chem Eng Comm, 140: 157.
Hu, W. and Chakma, A., 1990, Modelling of equilibrium solubility of
CO2 in aqueous amino methyl propanol (AMP) solutions, Chem Eng
Comm, 94: 53.
Kritpiphat, W. and Tontiwachwuthikul, P., 1996, New modi ed KentIsenberg model for predicting carbon dioxide solubility in aqueous
2-amino-2-methyl-1-propanol (AMP) solutions. Chem Eng Comm,
144: 73.
Haji-Sulaiman, M. Z., Aroua, M. K., Pervez, M. I., 1996, Equilibrium
concentration pro les of species in CO2 -alkanolamine-water systems,
Gas Sep Purif, 9(2): 125.
Aroua, M. K., Benamor, A. and Haji-Sulaiman, M. Z., 1997,
Temperature dependency of the equilibrium constant for the formation
of carbamate from diethanolamine, J Chem Eng Data, 42: 692.
Numerical Recipes in FORTRAN, 1986, (Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, England). (1986).
Lee, J. I., Otto, F. D. and Mather, A. E., 1972, Solubility of carbon
dioxide in aqueous dethanolamine solutions at high pressures, J Chem
Eng Data, 17: 465.
Lee, J. I., Otto, F. D. and Mather, A. E., 1974, Solubility of mixtures of
carbon dioxide and hydrogen sulphide in aqueous diethanolamine
solutions, Can J Chem Eng, 52: 125.
Jou, F. Y., Mather, A. E. and Otto, F. D., 1982, Solubility of H2 S and
CO2 in aqueous methyldiethanolamine solutions, Ind Eng Chem
Process Des Dev, 21: 539.
Austgen, D. M. and Rochelle, G. T., 1991, Model of vaporliquid
16.
17.
18.
19.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Financial support for this work was provided by the Ministry of Science,
Technology and Environment, Malaysia through the Seventh Malaysia Plan
IRPA Research Grant.
ADDRESS
Correspondence concerning this paper should be addressed to
Dr M. H. Haji-Sulaiman, Department of Chemical Engineering, University
of Malaya, 5063 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. (E-mail: mzaki@fk.um.edu.my).
The manuscript was communicated via our International Editor for
Japan, Professor Seiichiro Koda. It was received 18 February 1998 and
accepted for publication after revision 22 June 1998.