Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Mehmet KIRGZOLU
Faik KKL
1. INTRUDUCTION
It is obviously seen that the firm in the white goods sector has established new networks
and innovative works with emphasis on R&D and technology. Vestel is one of the biggest
company which has huge production facility and significant market share both in Turkey
and abroad with its own brand. Other firms in the same sector has become really
important innovative firms as well, like Arelik, Arnica Senur, etc.
2. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
a. GDP (Gross Domestic Produce)
Annual Gross Domestic Product was 1 416 817 Million TL. at current prices. Annual gross
domestic product in 2012 increased by 9.2% and reached to 1 416 817 Million Turkish
Liras current prices, increased by 2.2% and reached to 117 754 Million Turkish Liras at
constant prices.
GDP by production approach increased by 4.0% compared to previous year in 2013 and
reached to 122 388 Million TL at constant prices and increased by 10.2% and reached to
1 561 510 Million TL at current prices.
The nine months growth rate of gross domestic product increased by 2.8% in the third
quarter of 2014 and reached to 93 billion 733 million Turkish Liras at constant prices. The
nine months growth rate of gross domestic product increased by 11.9% in the third
quarter of 2014 and reached to 1 trillion 296 billion 774 million Turkish Liras at current
prices. [1]
b.
Trade Deficit
In November 2012; exports increased by 24,8% and reached to 13 829 Million Dollars
and imports increased by 12,5% and reached to 20 986 Million Dollars compared with
November 2011. At the same month, foreign trade deficit decreased from 7 571 Million
Dollar to 7 158 Million Dollars.
In November 2013; exports were 14 252 Million Dollars with a 3.6% increase and
imports were 21 403 Million Dollars with a 2.2% increase compared with November
2012.
In November 2014; exports were 13 billion 132 million dollars with a 7.5% decrease
and imports were 21 billion 448 million dollars with a 0.2% increase compared with
November 2013. [1]
c.
Budget Deficit
In December 2013, budget was 18,5 billion TL deficit while budget deficit 29,4 billion
TL in December 2012. The budget deficit was 22.7 billion TL in January-December 2014,
while it was 18.5 billion TL in January-December 2013. [2]
d.
Interest Rate
The interest rate in Turkey between the years 2012-2014 is shown in the graph below.
[3]
e.
Unemployment Rate
Unemployment rates between the years 2012 - 2014 are in the table (with the
values of beginning and end of the year) and shown in the graph.[3]
Unemployment
Rate
2012
2013
2014
9,2
9,7 - 9,1
9,2 - 10,7
SECTOR ANALYSIS
a. About The White Goods Industry
3.
c.Energy Label
Energy label is designed to provide consumers with accurate, recognisable and
comparable information on domestic household products regarding energy
consumption, performance and other essential characteristics.
It allows consumers to identify how energy efficient a product actually is and to assess
a products potential to reduce energy costs.
The label is uniform for all products in a given category. Consumers can compare
easily the characteristics of appliances in a given category such as energy or water
consumption, or capacity.
The label initially classified products from A to G, A being the most efficient energy
class and G the least efficient.
Turkish legislation introduces three additional classes, A+, A++ and A+++, can be
added to the current A to G classification scale to adapt to technological developments
and to allow further product differentiation in terms of energy efficiency.
Coloured arrows differentiate energy efficient from lower energy efficient products:
dark green indicates a highly efficient product and red a low efficient product.
Refrigerator
- 7 classes maximum from A+++ to D
- Coloured arrows are used to differentiate energy efficient from lower energy
efficient products: dark green indicates a highly efficient product and red a low efficient
product
- Pictograms highlight selected performances and characteristics:
- Annual energy consumption in kW
- Capacity of all storage compartments in litres
- Capacity of frozen food storage compartments in litres
- Noise emissions in decibels
- The energy class is based on the energy efficiency index which takes into
account:
- The annual energy consumption
- The volume
- The lowest temperature of different compartments
Other factors affecting this index are the type of construction (built in or free
standing) and the availability of frost free feature.
Washing Machine
- 7 classes maximum: from A+++ to D
- Coloured arrows are used to differentiate energy efficient from lower energy
efficient products: dark green indicates a highly efficient product and red a low efficient
product
- Pictograms highlight selected performances and characteristics:
- Annual energy consumption in kWh
- Noise emissions in decibels
- Spin-drying efficiency class
- Capacity in kilograms
- Annual water consumption in litres
- The annual energy & water consumptions, and the spin-drying efficiency class
indicated on the label, are calculated on the basis of:
- 60C cotton programme at full and partial load
- 40C cotton programme at partial load
- Left-on mode and in off-mode
- Values for the annual water consumption and the spin-drying efficiency class are
based on the same set of washing cycles as the energy consumption data
- All washing machines with a rated capacity greater than 3 kg, must have an A
class washing performance. Washing performance is then no longer indicated on the
label.
Dishwasher
- 7 classes: A+++ to D
- Coloured arrows are used to differentiate energy efficient from lower energy
efficient products: dark green indicates a highly efficient product and red a low efficient
product
- Pictograms highlight selected performances and characteristics:
- Annual energy consumption in kWh
- Noise emissions in decibels
- Capacity in place settings
- Drying efficiency class
- Annual water consumption in litres (no longer per cycle)
- The energy class is measured from:
Air conditioner
- 7 classes: A to G
- Coloured arrows are used to differentiate energy efficient from lower energy
efficient products: dark green indicates a highly efficient product and red a low efficient
product
- Air conditioner performances and characteristics are shown on the label:
- Annual energy consumption, kWh in cooling mode
- The Energy Efficiency Ratio of the appliance in cooling / heating
mode at full load
Shareholders
Vestel Elektronik*
Other
Public Shares
Total
(%)
68,53
0,00
31,47
100,00
Bosch : (Bosch,Siemens,Profilo)
There are some shortages in sales points and the amount of necessary products
cannot be provided.
The absence in electronics group, not producing TVs or cell phones.
Ariston : (Ariston,Indesit)
Lack of home appliances and electronics group
It is less than the competitors' advertising and promotional activities
10
6.RATIO ANALYSIS
Financial ratios are the most common and widespread tools used to analyse a
business' financial standing. Ratios are easy to understand and simple to compute. They
can also be used to compare different companies in different industries. Since a ratio is
simply a mathematically comparison based on proportions, big and small companies can
be use ratios to compare their financial information. In a sense, financial ratios don't take
into consideration the size of a company or the industry. Ratios are just a raw
computation of financial position and performance. In the below we see tables of Vestel
(VESBE) for the last 3 years balance sheet and Arcelik (ARCLK) balance sheet for 2014.
2012
2013
2014
ARCEL
K
2014
221.283
324.125
229.782
2.124.946
27.218
18.576
163.711
1.621.221
Current Assets
954.766
963.168
1.145.537
8.471.757
Fixed Assets
360.461
389.755
403.900
3.923.248
VESTEL
Assets
Inventories
Cash
Total Assets
12.395.
005
Liabilities
Total Short Term Lia.
720.139
556.330
649.202
4.430.803
103.832
255.789
237.672
3.565.504
Total Liabilities
823.971
812.119
886.874
7.996.30
7
Total Equity
491.256
540.804
662.563
4.398.698
376.000
292.000
119.000
12.395.
005
4.768
Depreciation
63.790
74.367
84.070
346.293
Interest Expenses
23.555
24.338
17.245
314.010
52.412
178.459
300.337
3.978.832
Gross Profit
11
Operating Profit/Loss
-28.875
127.424
149.666
968.789
-3.580
127.000
150.000
731.622
-17.505
53.451
152.159
1.001.832
Net Income
-17.544
52.689
131.177
637.978
1.830.965
1.850.236
2.036.804
8.535.201
Sales
2.143.000
2.028.695
2.337.141
12.514.03
3
685.525
603.408
708.307
4.433.898
413.000
452.000
556.000
1.781.442
Shares Outstanding
190.000
190.000
190.000
676.000
0.10
0.13
0.15
722.799
EBIT
*All the values are in bin TL and taken from www.isteyatirim.com [5].
2012
2013
ARCELI
K
2014
2014
VESTEL
RATIOS
1. Liquidity Ratios
Formulas
Current Ratio
1,33
1,73
1,76
1,91
Quick Ratio
1,02
1,15
1,41
1,43
Cash Ratio
0,04
0,03
0,25
0,37
234.6
27
406.8
38
0,29
0,22
0,08
0,00
Debt/Equity Ratio
0,77
0,54
0,18
0,00
Equity multiplier
1,77
1,54
1,18
1,00
-0,15
5,22
8,70
2,33
2,56
8,27
13,57
3,43
8,27
5,71
8,86
4,02
496.3 4.040.9
35
54
2. Debt Ratios
3. Asset Management
Ratios
Inventory Turnover
12
44,11
63,94
41,18
90,87
Accounts Receivable
Turnover
Sales / Account
Receivable
3,13
3,36
3,30
2,82
116,7
6
108,5
6
110,6
2
129,32
1,63
1,50
1,51
1,01
Profit Margin
-0,01
0,03
0,06
0,05
Return on Asset
-0,01
0,04
0,08
0,05
Return of Equity
-0,04
0,10
0,20
0,15
22,5
19,70
11,10
12,10
-0,09
0,28
0,69
0,94
2,2
2,6
3,55
4,55
2,59
2,85
3,49
6,51
4. Profitability Ratios
5. Market Value
Ratios
Price / Earnings Ratio
Earnings Per Share (EPS)
Market to Book Ratio
Book Value Per Share
a. Liquidity Ratios
Current Ratio
The current ratio is the most basic liquidity test. It signifies a company's ability to
meet its short-term liabilities with its short-term assets. A current ratio greater than or
equal to one indicates that current assets should be able to satisfy near-term obligations.
A current ratio of less than one may mean the firm has liquidity issues. It should be at
least 2 for the companies. As we see from the table the current ratio of Vestel is
improving year by year and Arceliks liquidity is higher than Vestel.
Quick Ratio
The quick ratio is a tougher test of liquidity than the current ratio. It eliminates
certain current assets such as inventory and prepaid expenses that may be more difficult
to convert to cash. Like the current ratio, having a quick ratio above one means a
company should have little problem with liquidity. The higher the ratio, the more liquid it
is, and the better able the company will be to ride out any downturn in its business. As
Vestels quick ratio is improving it is good for the company and Arcelik quick ratio are
higher than Vestels which shows us Arceliks situation is better than Vestels.
Cash Ratio
The ratio of a company's total cash and cash equivalents to its current liabilities. It
should be at least 0.5 however Vestels and Arceliks cash ratio is less than 0.5 which are
not good.
As it is higher it is better for the company. As bigger it is, the liquidity of the firm is
bigger. As Vestels net working capital is increasing it is good for the company. In
comparison with Arcelik net working capital Vestels is very low.
Current Ratio
1.20
Ratios
Quick Ratio
Cash Ratio
1.00
0.80
0.60
0.40
0.20
0.00
2012
2013
2014
b. Debt Ratios
Total Debt Ratio
Debt Ratio is a financial ratio that indicates the percentage of a company's assets
that are provided via debt. It needs to be a low value for the companies. As we see from
the tables Vestels Debt Ratios are deteriorating and Arceliks debt ratio is zero which is
very good for it.
Debt/Equity Ratio
A measure of a company's financial leverage calculated by dividing its total
liabilities by stockholders' equity. It indicates what proportion of equity and debt the
company is using to finance its assets. It needs to be a low value for the company. As
Vestels debt equity ratio is deteriorating, it is good for the company. However in
comparison with Arcelik we see that Arceliks Debt Equity ratio is zero which is better
than Vestel.
Equity multiplier
The ratio of a companys total assets to its stockholders equity. The equity
multiplier is a measurement of a companys financial leverage. Companies finance the
purchase of assets either through equity or debt, so a high equity multiplier indicates that
a larger portion of asset financing is being done through debt. The multiplier is a variation
of the debt ratio. We can say the same things with the debt equity ratios above.
14
Ratios
12.00
10.00
Debt/Equity Ratio
Times Interest Earned
8.00
6.00
4.00
2.00
0.00
2012
-2.00
2013
2014
15
The days' sales in accounts receivable ratio, also known as the number of
days of receivables, tells you the average number of days it takes to collect an account
receivable. Since the days' sales in accounts receivable is an average, you need to be
careful when using it.The calculation for determining the days' sales in accounts
receivable is the number of days in the year (usually 360 or 365 days is used) divided by
the accounts receivable turnover ratio for a specific year. This ratio is about 110 days for
Vestel and we see it is stable. Moreover this ratio of Vestel better than Arcelik which is
129,3.
Ratios
7.00
Inventory Turnover
6.00
Accounts Receivable
Turnover
5.00
4.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
2012
2013
2014
d. Profitability Ratios
Profit Margin
A ratio of profitability calculated as net income divided by revenues, or net profits
divided by sales. It measures how much out of every dollar of sales a company actually
keeps in earnings. Vestels profit margin is improving for last three years. Vestels and
Arceliks profit margin is almost same for the 2014.
Return on Asset
An indicator of how profitable a company is relative to its total assets. ROA gives
an idea as to how efficient management is at using its assets to generate earnings.
Calculated by dividing a company's annual earnings by its total assets, ROA is displayed
as a percentage. Sometimes this is referred to as "return on investment". When we look
at the ratios Vestels values are improving as the time passes. Vestels ratio is better
than Arceliks for 2014.
16
Return of Equity
The amount of net income returned as a percentage of shareholders equity. Return
on equity measures a corporation's profitability by revealing how much profit a company
generates with the money shareholders have invested. Vestels return of equity ratios are
improving as the time passes. Vestels ratio is better than Arceliks for 2014.
Profibility Ratios
0.25
0.20
0.15
Profit Margin
Return on Asset
Ratios
Return of Equity
0.10
0.05
0.00
2012
2013
2014
-0.05
17
we look at book values per shares Vestels ratios are improving, but Arcelik 2014 ratio is
greater than Vestels 2014 book value per share ratio.
19
Price / Earnings Ratio
Earnings Per Share (EPS)
14
Ratios
-1
2012
2013
2014
7.REFERENCES
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
www.turkstat.gov.tr
www.bumko.gov.tr
www.tradingeconomics.com
www.vestel.com.tr
www.isteyatirim.com
www.investopedia.com/terms
18