Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 79

Failure of a (probably the largest

in the world ) timber falsework

The Sand bridge

Common method for concrete


bridge construction

however
in order to create as little disturbance as
possible to the ship traffic during construction,
a new erection method was adopted
The falsework, a timber arch construction with
span of 250m was constructed on the shore
and then shipped to the building place

Proposed bridge construction method

The longest concrete arch bridge of the world, at the time


of construction (1939). Span length: 247,5 m
(during shipping, a tension tie was used to take the horizontal trust)

Detail of the abutment


(construction phase)

Background
The works started in April 1938
Collapse of the timber falsework in 31 August
1939
The timber falsework failed during concreting
18 fatalities

Background
The works started in April 1938
Collapse of the timber falsework in 31 August
1939
The timber falsework failed during concreting
18 fatalities
(On September 1 (the day after the collapse) Hitler declared
war on Poland. Therefore, the news about the collapse of the
Sand Bridge did not reach the big headlines and it was soon
forgotten by the general public).

Cross section of the falsework arch

Main reasons of the collapse


Most probable out-of-plane buckling of the
arch falsework
Buckling caused by insufficient transversal
stiffness of the arches
Misjudgment concerning the stiffness of
nailed planks

The bridge was finally rebuilt in 1943, however,


now using a timber falsework supported all
along its length

The timber falsework used for the second attempt (and this
time successful) to bridge the river ngermanlven at Sand

The Sand bridge

Importance of right form

Spaghetti structure competition:


span:1 m
weight: < 1 kg
failure load: ver 450 kg!

Royal Albert Bridge, Saltash, 1899

fish-belly beams

Axial force N and bending moment diagrams caused by uniformly


distributed load (L= 75m, hmax=9m, load 2,5 kN/m2)

N
N in the vertical struts is negligible (almost zero)

Traversina bridce, switzerland (span:56 m)

New traversina bridge

The suspension
cable is tensioned

Timber walkway
(upside down arch)
Is loaded in compression

The stiffness of the


system increases
significantly

Nya traversina bridge

Structures that carry the load mainly


in tension

Stress-ribbon bridge: steel tension tie of steel


+ concrete deck

Stress ribbon timber bridge in Essing, Germany

Stress ribbon timber bridge in Erlebnis, Germany,


span: 225 m

A special suspension bridge


Steel plate 40x200

A special suspension bridge

Feldbach / austria
built: 1998

Truss without lower chord: simple


node connections

Diagonals are always subjected to tensile forces,


regardless the load position

Truss bridge in Austria

Arch bridges

Deck arch in Brans, Sweden

Brans 2007, Ltot 130m, B = 5,3m. Bgens spnnvid 50m

Through arch bridge in Kinna, Sweden

Kinna 2008, Ltot 40 m, B = 3m

Half- through arch bridge in Hgerns,


Sweden

Hgerns 2007, Ltot 42m, B = 3,5m. Bgens spnnvid 34m

Bridge Hgerns, elevation and plan

Cross section

Hinges

At the
springing
At the apex

Details

Suspension of the deck

Connection arch-hanger

Static system

Buckling of arches

Out-of-plane buckling
of slender arches

Out-of-plane buckling

Buckling length (out-of-plane)

Second order analysis

Isoleringsmatta

Fretheim Bridge
- a three-hinged arch with steel tension tie
38 m

Fretheim Bro

An interesting system which is extremly


efficient in reducing the bending moments in
the arch the network arch

The Brandanger steel network arch in western Norway. Span 220m.


The worlds most slender arch bridge

Traditional vs. network

traditional through arch bridge

Network through arch bridge

Reduction of bending moments in the arch

Inclined hangers distribute patch load into a wider part


of the arch

Influence line for bending moment at the


most stressed cross section

Truss and trussed arch bridges

Connection with slotted-in plates and


dowels

Olimpic games in Hamar, 1994


Span: 71 m
Design Load for the lower chord: 7000 kN!!

Skubbergsenga bridge a zero-hinged


trussed arch

Total length
Arch span

40 m
32 m

Bridge width
Building year

4m
1997

Tynset bridge
- a two-hinged trussed arch bridge (max span: 71m)

Tynset bru bygger 2001

Tynset bridge

preassembly of the
trussed arch in the
factory

Tynset bridge

To increase the out-ofplane stability:


- K-shaped bracing
- Wider cross section at
the springings of the
arch
- Moment stiff
connection for out-ofplane bending

Flisa Bridge

Total length
Bridge width
Span
Bulding year

197 m
9,0 m
70 m
2003

Flisa bridge
The low weight made it
possible to reuse the old
supports

The same
statical
system

Flisa bridge

Rena Bridge

Designed for military


load

Concrete deck, but


not in composite
action (the deck can
freely slide on the
top of the timber
truss)
Max load: 110 ton!!

8mm plate, 10mm slots, 12mm dowel

The gap is filled up with a mortar


(akrylat). The transmission of
compression occurs through contact.
The dowels transmit only shear.

Concrete deck not in composite action. Longitudinal movements


of : free. Lateral movement: restrained.

Rena Bridge

Max span: 45m

Three recent bridge projects

LVSBACKA BRIDGE

LVSBACKA BRIDGE

CHALLENGES OF THE SUPERSTRUCTURE LVSBACKA BRIDGE, Peter


Jacobsson et al.

LVSBACKA BRIDGE

The Anaklia Pedestrian Bridge in Georgia

The Anaklia Pedestrian Bridge in Georgia

Timber-frame Construction: HESS TIMBER, Kleinheubach


Load Assumptions, Structural Engineering Calculation, Design: Leonhardt, Andr & Partner ,
Stuttgart

The deck

The deck

Tretten bridge, Norway

A 148m long 2-lanes timber bridge

Tretten bridge, Norway

Tretten Bridge Timber and Steel in Harmony, John Are Hrstad-Evjen et al (2013)

Combination of timber and weathering steel


(COR-TEN)

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi