Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content
in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.
For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
M.E. Sharpe, Inc. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Journal of Marketing Theory and
Practice.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 94.200.175.246 on Sat, 16 Aug 2014 14:21:59 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Dale S. Rogers
ofNevada
University
RudolfLeuschner
ofNevada
University
research
andtheory
hasincludedinvestigation
intotransportation
andrelatedsubjects.Thisresearch
has
Traditionally,
marketing
evolvedmuchinthelastfewyears.Researchers
havebegunto focuson a broadening
ofthetransportation
fieldthatincludes
newerconceptssuchas logisticsandsupplychainmanagement.
Inthispaper,theevolution
oftransportation
andsupply
logistics,
chainmanagement
researchoverthelast IS yearsis comparedto similarresearchfromthepreviousIS yearsas catalogedby
Professor
RichardJonesinthepremiere
issueoftheJournalofMarketing
tochronicle
TheoryandPractice.Thispaperattempts
theevolution
from
tologisticstosupplychainmanagement
sinceintheJournalofMarketing
and
transportation
Theory Practice
was established.
INTRODUCTION
In 1992,Professor
RichardJonesofTrinity
wrote
University
anarticle
titledTransportation:
andProspective
Retrospective
forthe firstissue of the Journalof Marketing
Theoryand
Practicedescribing
theevolution
oftransportation
research
and
academicprograms.
He usedacademicresearchpublishedin
the Transportation
Journalas thekeyunderpinning
of the
field.In thisarticlehe describedtransportation
researchand
how itevolvedfroma strongfocuson themilitary,
rail,and
economicimplications,
to a morecomprehensive
view of a
wholesystem
thatwas focusedon different
issuesthaninthe
past. He details the journey from a focus solely on
and transportation
modes to a emphasison
transportation
"logistics"whichincludesa largersystemview of sourcing,
anddistribution
manufacturing,
(Jones,1992).
60
BACKGROUND
ProfessorJones" paper was based on an analysisof the
ofTransportation
Journal
over20 yearsfrom1972to 1991.It
eacharticlein23 categoriesin orderto trackthe
categorized
shiftin modalorientation.
In orderto trackthechangeshe
thefirst
fifteen
compared
years(1972-1986)tothemorerecent
five(1987-1991).Duringthistimetherewas a considerable
research.The analysis
changein thefocusof transportation
showedthattherewas a shiftfromrail transportation
and
intermodal
towards
moremotorearnersandair
transportation
fromthe firsttime.AnothershiftProfessor
transportation
Joneschronicledwas fromregulatory,
policyand demand
articlestowardslaborandmanagement
issues.He notedthat
thequantitative
orientation
becamea lot moreimportant
in
lateryearsas the numberof quantitatively
based research
almostdoubledbetweenthefirstandsecondperiod.Another
JournalofMarketing
THEORY AND PRACTICE
This content downloaded from 94.200.175.246 on Sat, 16 Aug 2014 14:21:59 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
of
interesting
change was the increasedimportance
issuesduring
thelatertimeperiod.Therewas
international
with
ofarticles
twice
international
thepercentage
topics
nearly
in
the
first.
time
that
there
was
Thisseems
inthesecond
period
arenowsourceand
as itis clearthatmany
products
prescient
ofNorth
ofoutside
America
manufacture
(Jones,
1992).
to logisticsand supplychain
Because of the evolution
to
Professor
Jones"work
we
decided
replicate
management,
articles
from
Journal
Business
the
overthe
of
Logistics
using
last15years.
LOGISTICS VERSUS SCM
shiftfroma conceptof
issue In orderto showtheparadigm
ofProfessor
Thesecondsection
Jones
paperintheinitial
we
wasa lookinto Logisticsto a conceptof SupplyChainManagement,
oftheJournal
ofmarketing
andpractice
theory
theuse of thetermsLogisticsand SupplyChain
thefuture
oftransportation
Jones(1992)identified tracked
research.
inthearticle
titlesoftheJournal
research
thathe believedwere Management
ofBusiness
keytopicsintransportation
in the future. Logistics.
We believethisis a veiygoodwaytoshowhow
goingto becomeincreasingly
important
ofSupply
haveembraced
theconcept
Chain
researchers
hazardousmaterials, much
""Green""topics,like environment,
inFigure1 below,moreauthors
As is depicted
and energy
are identified
as beinggood potential Management.
safety,
inhispaper, beganto support
theshiftin conceptfrom"logistics"
to
Asa result
oftheanalysis
research
opportunities.
in thelate 1990"s.It is also
are "supply-chain
healsosuggests
that
andinternational
research
management"
productivity
tonotethatthetermSupplyChainManagement
in thefuture.
Looking interesting
important
goingto be increasingly
butalsoa
itseemshewascorrect.
Therehasbeena lotof wasnotjustevery
backwards,
playfortheword""logistics,""
term.
into"green"topicsincluding
a largeamountof broadening
research
inreverse
thatbeganwithanenvironmental
research
logistics
andarticle
titles
intheJournal
Theusageoftheterm
andTIbben-Lembke,
bent.(Rogers
1999)
logistics
in
1997.
70% ofthe
Business
More
than
of
Logistics
peaked
in
first
issue
of
the
Journal
the
in
areaheoutlined
as beinga goodfuture
research
Business
Another
articles
of
topic
Logistics
A thattimeelectronic
waselectronic
datainterchange.
data 1997 containedthe word "logistics"in the title.That
Itappeared
hasdeclined
sincethen,
whileatthesametimethe
wasnotyetwidely
thatEDI
percentage
interchange
adopted.
forthemanagement
andorganization
helda lotofpotential
of usageoftheterm
hasincreased.
"supply-chain
management"
the
of
Since
number
articles
The
1999,
including
customer-supplier
relationships. positive
potential
impact
"supply-chain
ofEDI couldbe partially
at thattime.However, management"
inthetitlehasranged
between
20% and35%.
observed
WideWebwerenot Thisdataispresented
intabular
liketheInternet
form
inTable1.
andWorld
developments
understood
wasnot
atthetime.
Browser
generally
technology
- Logistics
available.
yetcommercially
OriginofTerminology
thatpublishestheJournalof Business
isstillanimportant
factor.
Becauseofthemove The organization
Transportation
is moreimportant
towards
than Logistics,the Council of SupplyChain Management
transportation
globalization,
theterm
ever.Muchoftheproducts
hasdefined
as follows:
wewearorusecomefrom
outside Professionals,
logistics
Thecomputer
theUnited
States.
thispaperwaswritten
onand
is thatpartofSupplyChain
Logistics
Management
alltheaccompanying
werefabricated
inAsiaand
peripherals
that
andcontrols
the
Management plans,implements,
totheUnitedStates.Globalization
hasmadethe
transported
effective
forward
and reverseflowand
efficient,
oftransportation
muchmorecomplex.
management
ofgoods,services
andrelatedinformation
storage
betweenthe pointof originand the pointof
Thecomplexity
oftransportation
of
andinthemanagement
consumptionin order to meet customers'
hasbecome
theartandscienceoflogistics.
Sincethe
product
requirements,
(http://www.cscmp.org/
timethattheJonesarticlewaspublished
in theJournal
of
Website/AboutCSCMP/Definitions/Definitions.as
andPractice
in1992,there
hasbeenmuch
Marketing,
Theory
CSCMP2005)
on
and
chain
which
has
emphasis logistics supply management
evolved
Itis interesting
tonotethattheprofessional
from
thescienceoftransportation.
that
partly
organization
the
above
its
name
in
definition
changed
developed
January
2005 fromthe Councilof LogisticsManagement
OBJECTIVE
to the
Councilof SupplyChainManagement
This
Professionals.
Theintention
ofthispaperistopickupnearwhere
thenamebecausea continually
tochange
Professor group
decided
larger
Jones
leavesoff.AsProfessor
Jones
notesinhisarticle,
ofitsmembership
there portion
wasinvolved
inactivities
outside
wasa movement
intheacademic
andpractitioner
communities thetraditional
oflogistics.
to
Whileitisclearly
purview
risky
from
wehaveseen changethenameof an organization
towards
Sincethen,
anddiscardall ofthe
transportation
logistics.
a continued
onlogistics
thedevelopment brandvaluebuiltupovertheyears,
theCouncilthought
that
emphasis
alongwith
ofa newterm
chainmanagement."
thechangewas required
becauseofthedifference
between
"supply
andsupply
chainmanagement.
logistics
Fall2004 61
This content downloaded from 94.200.175.246 on Sat, 16 Aug 2014 14:21:59 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
FIGUREI
USE OF THE TERMS "LOGISTICS" AND "SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT" IN JBL ARTICLE TITLES
1990-2004
80%.
Logistics
/ '
/
'
,%
**
^^v
"*
^*
J .. ,*^, **,.-,*
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
<* * ^ -*'
,- .- M-.
1995
1996
1997
V-
199S
- SupplyChain
Management
-j
#
.-
1999
,-
2000
.-
2001
.-
2002
.-
2003
.-
2004
Yftir
TABLE 1
TERMS LOGISTICS VERSUS SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
IN ARTICLE TITLES
1990
27.78%
0.00%
1991
43.48%
4.35%
1992
39.13%
4.35%
1993
36.84%
0.00%
1994
42.31%
0.00%
1995
50.00%
7.69%
1996
38.46%
7.69%
1997
72.73%
0.00%
1998
45.83%
8.33%
1999
28.57%
19.05%
2000
57.14%
28.57%
2001
35.00%
35.00%
2002
42.86%
21.43%
2003
17.39%
34.78%
2004
20.00%
25.00%
TOTAL
40.18%
12.58%
62
Theoriginoftheterm""logistics""goesbackto 18thcentury
ina book
France.Theconceptoflogisticswas first
introduced
Baron
a
of
De
staff
officer
Jomini,
Napoleon,entitled,
by
""TheArtofWar""publishedin 1836. Theterm""logistics""
the
was derivedfromthetitleofone ofNapoleon'sgenerals,
were
General
des
The
duties
of
this
officer
Major
Logis.
of trooplodgingand
limitedto themanagement
originally
forwar
realized
camppreparation.
They
properpreparation
tosuccessonthebattlefield.
Soonthis
wasthecriticalelement
generals.
positionbecameone ofNapoleon'smostimportant
The baronsaidthat
Bywayofillustration,
logisticsconsistsofthewaysandmeans
which
the
through
plans of strategiesand tactics are
is thedecisionas towhereactionis to
accomplished.
Strategy
themovement
ofthetroops
takeplace.Logisticsencompasses
therein.
to thesceneoftheactionandtheirsupport
(Holmes,
1953)
OriginofTerminology
-SupplyChain Management
Theoriginoftheterm"supplychainmanagement"
appearsto
in theearly1980's(Oliveret al,
be theworkof consultants
becomea widelyusedterm.While
1982).Ithas subsequently
hassupplanted
thedefinitions
differ,
supplychainmanagement
the term"logistics"to some extent.Untilrecently,
most
interestedparties (Cooper, 1998), viewed supply chain
as beinga synonym
forlogisticsmanagement.
management
and
Professionals
The CouncilofSupplyChainManagement
in
field
have
academics
and
consultants
the
many
working
tendedto definelogisticsmanagement
broadlyto include
and
exterior
entities
tothefirm
customers,
including
suppliers,
suchas third-party
servicesupportfirms
companies.
logistics
Most academics and practitionersviewed logistics
JournalofMarketing
THEORY AND PRACTICE
This content downloaded from 94.200.175.246 on Sat, 16 Aug 2014 14:21:59 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
3PL/Outsourcing
the
Journal
in
Business
of
publishing
Logistics.
Historical/
Academic/
Framework
Customer
Thesecondlargestnumber
ofarticleswas classifiedas having
Service
coretopicof Inventory
Some of thisresearch
Distribution
Management.
Education
Severalof thearticles
deals withsafetystockoptimization.
Cost
includedin this classificationand focused on reducing
Financial/
costs.
Cross-Functional
Teams
andcutting
inventories
Inter-Department/
International
had increasedin
Overthepast 15 yearsotherclassifications
Inventory
Management
Performance.
It is interesting
thatmanyauthorshave elected
Organization/
Management
Performance
side. This couldmeanthattheconceptof
costmanagement
Procurement/
Chain
Managementis movingfroma focus on
Purchasing
Supply
Six
a
Process
to
Severalof these
Quality/ Sigma/
operations morestrategic
Management
perspective.
Social Responsibility
servicecompeting
againstanotherfirm"s,butitis oftenone
chain
competing
Strategy
supply
againstanother
supplychain.
Information
Systems
Technology/
as a focusof articles.Among
Sometopicsemergedrecently
Transportation
CustomerService,Education,Social
theseare Partnerships,
Warehousing
Fall 2004
This content downloaded from 94.200.175.246 on Sat, 16 Aug 2014 14:21:59 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
63
TABLE 2
ARTICLE CATEGORIES COMPARED 1990-1999AND 2000-2004
ArticleCategory
1990-1999
2000-2004
Total
Modeling/Heuristics/
DecisionSupport/
LocationAnalysis
15.79%
7.14%
13.19%
Inventory
Management
10.09%
9.18%
9.82%
Academic/Historical/
Framework
7.02%
8.16%
7.36%
Partnerships/Alliances
5.26%
11.22%
7.06%
Organization/
Management
7.46%
5.10%
6.75%
Customer
Service
4.82%
9.18%
6.13%
Technology/
Information
Systems
6.58%
5.10%
6.13%
Education
3.95%
10.20%
5.83%
International
3.95%
6.12%
4.60%
Transportation
5.26%
3.06%
4.60%
Strategy
4.39%
4.08%
4.29%
3PL/Outsourcing
3.95%
4.08%
3.99%
Performance
3.51%
4.08%
3.68%
Other
4.82%
1.02%
3.68%
Distribution
2.19%
1.02%
1.84%
Financial/Cost
2.63%
0.00%
1.84%
Procurement/
Purchasing
2.19%
1.02%
1.84%
InterDepartment/CrossFunctional
Teams
0.88%
3.06%
ReverseLogistics
0.88%
3.06%
1.53%
Social Responsibility
0.44%
4.08%
1.53%
Warehousing
2.19%
0.00%
1.53%
Quality/Six
Sigma/Process
Management
1.75%
0.00%
1.23%
1.53%
Teams.Thesetopicsmaynotbe completely
new,buttheyhave
in thelastfewyears.Thismightbe in
gainedmoreattention
partduetothefactthatothersupplychainmanagement
topics
appearto be at least partiallysolved and thesenew topics
requiremorediscussionandattention.
Outsourcingis anotherfocus of severalarticlesas it has
64
becomemoreimportant
as morecompaniesoutsourcethenand
chain
activities.(Rogers,
logistics
supply
management
Research
on
is
moreattention
as
2004)
partnershipsgetting
well.(Lambert,2004) Companiescontinueto integrate
their
andbackwards.Thisintegration
supplychainbothforwards
leadstomorecomplexoperations
as thoseoperations
needto
be coordinated
acrossthesupplychain.Thus,morecomplex
research
supplychainscreatemoreproblemsand interesting
The
same
is
true
for
as
cross-functional
teams,
opportunities.
morefirms
to
better
chains.
struggle develop
integrated
supply
Othernewareassuchas ReverseLogisticshavealso become
thebackward
topicsforresearchas a newfocuson managing
flowofproducts
hasemerged.
Thisemergence
wasdrivenfirst
or greenissues,buttheunderstanding
that
byenvironmental
cancreatecostsavingshas
goodreverselogisticsmanagement
intothisarea.In someindustries
returns
drive
spurred
inquiry
profitability.
(RogersandTIbben-Lembke,
1999)
Social Responsibility
is also a relativelynew topic. It is
thatit wouldhave been includedand a logisticsor
unlikely
supplychain ManagementJournal10 or 15 years ago.
therehavebeena fewresearchers
thathad
However,recently
and theaffect
begunto discussissuessuchas sustainability
callsupplychain.Sociallyresponsible
behavioris increasingly
inthis
expectedbybusinessesandthereis a lotofopportunity
areaforgood academicresearch.
CONCLUSIONS
Eventhoughtherehas beenan amazingamountofchangein
the 13 years thatthe Journalof MarketingTheoryand
Practicehas beenpublished,
itis likelythatthenextseveral
will
continue
to
see
a
years
largeamountofchange.Professor
Jonesnotesthat:
The transportation
fieldhas experienced
a majorupheavalin
thelasttwo decades.Whilethemagnitude
of thechangeis
alreadypatentlymanifestin the transportation
literature,
shouldconcludethatthefield
scholars,withlittleprompting
remainsfraught
withopportunities
to undertake
meaningful
research.(Jones,1992)
Theword"transportation"
from
theabovesectionofProfessor
Jones" articlecould todaybe replacedby "logistics"and
It is clearthattherateofchange
"supply-chain
management."
Jonesnotedthathadtakenplaceinthetransportation
fieldhas
notsloweddown.And,itseemslikelythatthepace ofchange
willcontainyou.In 15 years,we canexpectthatjournalssuch
as the Journalof BusinessLogisticsand the Journalof
Marketing
TheoryandPracticewillbe examining
topicsthat
itis difficult
forus to forecast
now.
will continueto growas logistics,
Publishingopportunities
andmarketing
andpractice
supply-chain
management,
theory
mature.Therearemorejournalsdevotedto thesetopicsthen
JournalofMarketing
THEORY AND PRACTICE
This content downloaded from 94.200.175.246 on Sat, 16 Aug 2014 14:21:59 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
of new
theoriesand thedevelopment
established
marketing
of
business
the
that
theories
improve understanding
marketing
practicesand the predictionof business behavior and
" Whilethe
toevolve,
outcomes.
topicsdiscussedwillcontinue
thisoverallobjectiveshouldremainconstant.
REFERENCES
APICS (2001), ""Basics of SupplyChain Management,"" Lambert,
Douglas M. (2004). ""SupplyChainManagement,
Review Course, Participant
CPIM Certification
Performance,""Supply
Processes, Partnerships,
ChainManagement
Sarasota,Florida.
Institute,
Guide,Version2.1, Alexandira,VA: APICS, The
EducationalSocietyforResourceManagement.
Monczka,RobertM.,RobertJ.TrentandRobertB. Handfield
and SupplyChainManagement,
CLM (1998), Presentedat the annual businessmeeting,
(1998), Purchasing
WesternCollegePublishing.
OH: SouthCouncilof LogisticsManagement,
Cincinatic,
Anaheim,CA,
is postedattheCLMfs
October,1998.Thedefinition
Oliver,R. Keithand Michael D. Webber(1982), "Supplyhomepage:www.CLMl.org
Chain Management:Logistics Catches Up with
Strategy,"Outlook,cit. MartinG. Christopher,
CooperMarthaC, Douglas M. Lambertand JanusD. Pagh,
TheStrategic
Issue,London:Chapmanand
Logistics,
"SupplyChain Management:More Than a New
1992.
Journalof
Name forLogistics,"TheInternational
Hall,
8(1): 1-14.
LogisticsManagement,
Trendsand
Rogers, Dale S. (2004). IWLA Third-Party
the
International
Practices
to
Distribution
O.
J.
""Introduction
Study,publishedby
Holmes,
(1953),
Warehouseand LogisticsAssociation.ParieRidge,
CollegeoftheArmedForces,
Logistics,""Industrial
EL
D.C.
Washington,
and
J.Richard(1992),""Transportation:
Jones,
Retrospective
The
Journal
ofMarketing Theory
Prospective,""
andPractice.1(1): 40-49.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Chain
anda professor
ofSupply
forLogistics
istheDirector
oftheCenter
StateUniversity)
DaleRogers(PhD
Management
Michigan
a
Executive
of
the
Reverse
the
is
also
chairman
at
the
ofNevada.
He
Council,
organization
professional
Logistics
University
Management
andDirector
of
Director
as a Project
Prior
toentering
Daleworked
ofreverse
devoted
totheimprovement
academia,
logistics
practices.
andmanufacturing
at
inmaterial
He hasalsobeenemployed
andsoftware
fora logistics
management
company.
Marketing
consulting
isa consultant
toseveral
ofGeneral
Motors.
Dr.Rogers
Division
with
theOldsmobile
theHarris
andasaninstructor
leading
Corporation,
Trends
ofthe1999bookGoingBackwards:
Reverse
inseveral
andistheco-author
firms.Dale
haspublished
Logistics
logistics
journals
booksonlogistics.
andPractices
andtwoprevious
AUTHORBIOGRAPHY
andhis
Reno.Rudiis a native
ofGermany
assistant
attheUniversity
anda research
RudiLeuschner
is anMBAcandidate
ofNevada,
tennis
for
onesingles
hewasthenumber
Reno.As anundergraduate
is from
theUniversity
ofNevada,
player
undergraduate
degree
Executive
Council
fortheReverse
holdsalsoa fellowship
UNR.He currently
Logistics
Fall 2004
This content downloaded from 94.200.175.246 on Sat, 16 Aug 2014 14:21:59 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
65