&OWJSPONFOUBM
5FTUJOH

GPS
-BVODI
BOE
4QBDF
7FIJDMFT
4QBDF
TZTUFNT
NVTU
FOEVSF
B
QIZTJDBMMZ
TUSFTTGVM
KPVSOFZ
GSPN
UIF


MBVODIQBE
UP
UIFJS
mOBM
EFTUJOBUJPOT
"EFRVBUF
UFTUJOH
DBO
IFMQ



FOTVSF
UIFZ
TVSWJWF
UIF
USJQ

&SXJO
1FSM
5IJOI
%P
"MBO
1FUFSTPO
BOE
+PIO
8FMDI

HESTRUCTURALDESIGNOFSPACESYSTEMSISDICTATEDBY
THERIGORSOFTHELIFTOFFANDASCENTENVIRONMENTSDUR
INGLAUNCHASWELLASTHEEXTREMETHERMALCONDITIONS
ANDOPERATIONALREQUIREMENTSOFSPACECRAFTEQUIPMENTAND
PAYLOADSONORBIT!TLIFTOFFANDFORTHENEXTSEVERALSECONDS
THEINTENSESOUNDGENERATEDBYTHEPROPULSIONSYSTEMEXERTS
SIGNIlCANTACOUSTICPRESSUREONTHEENTIREVEHICLE4HISPRESSURE
INDUCESVIBRATIONEXTERNALLYANDINTERNALLYINTHESPACEVEHICLE
STRUCTURES)NADDITIONTHEVEHICLEEXPERIENCESINTENSEVIBRA
TIONSGENERATEDBYENGINEIGNITIONSSTEADY STATEOPERATION
ANDENGINESHUTDOWNSASWELLASSUDDENTRANSIENTSORhSHOCKSv
GENERATEDBYSOLIDROCKETMOTORJETTISONSEPARATIONOFSTAGES
ANDFAIRINGSANDON ORBITDEPLOYMENTSOFSOLARARRAYSANDPAY
LOADS3PACEVEHICLESWILLALSOEXPERIENCEWIDEmUCTUATIONSIN
TEMPERATUREFROMTHETIMETHEYLEAVETHELAUNCHPADTOTHETIME
THEYSETTLEINTOORBIT"OTHINDIVIDUALLYANDINCOMBINATIONTHE
MECHANICALENVIRONMENTSOFPRESSUREVIBRATIONSHOCKAND
THERMALGRADIENTSIMPOSEDESIGNREQUIREMENTSONMANYSTRUC
TURALCOMPONENTS%NSURINGTHESURVIVABILITYOFTHEDELICATE
HARDWAREPOSESCHALLENGESTHATCANBEMETONLYBYEXTENSIVE
PREmIGHTTESTSENCOMPASSINGACOUSTICSHOCKVIBRATIONAND
THERMALENVIRONMENTS
%NVIRONMENTALTESTINGISPERFORMEDATVARYINGMAGNITUDES
ANDDURATIONSTOVERIFYTHEDESIGNOFSPACESYSTEMSANDTO
SCREENmIGHTHARDWAREFORQUALITYOFWORKMANSHIP4HElRST
STEPINTHISPROCESSISTHEDElNITIONOFTHEMAXIMUMEXPECTED
ENVIRONMENTSDURINGLAUNCHANDON ORBITOPERATION$ATAFROM
PREVIOUSmIGHTSANDGROUNDTESTSAREANALYZEDTOGENERATEPRE
DICTIONSFORASPECIlCMISSION4HESEENVIRONMENTSARETHEN
mOWEDDOWNFROMTHESPACEVEHICLELEVELTOTHEVARIOUSSUBSYS
TEMSANDCOMPONENTSFORUSEASDESIGNREQUIREMENTSANDLATER
ASTESTREQUIREMENTS
!EROSPACEPERFORMSACRUCIALROLEFORTHEGOVERNMENTIN
ENSURINGTHATTHESEENVIRONMENTSAREPROPERLYDElNEDANDTHE
DESIGNQUALIlCATIONTESTSANDTHEHARDWAREACCEPTANCETESTSARE
PROPERLYPLANNEDANDCARRIEDOUT"YREVIEWINGTESTREQUIRE
MENTSANDANALYSISMETHODOLOGIESFOREXAMPLE!EROSPACE

HELPSVERIFYTHATTHERESULTSWILLBEACCURATEANDMEANINGFUL
2EVIEWINGTHEMAXIMUMPREDICTEDENVIRONMENTSENSURESTHAT
SPACESYSTEMSAREDESIGNEDTOWITHSTANDTHERIGORSOFmIGHT
2EVIEWINGTESTPLANSHELPSDEVELOPPERCEPTIVETESTPROCEDURES
/BSERVINGTHETESTSBUILDSCONlDENCETHATTHEYWERECONDUCTED
ACCORDINGTOSPECIlCATION2EVIEWINGTHETESTDATAPROVIDESAN
INDEPENDENTVALIDATIONOFTHERESULTS!RCHIVINGANDCATALOGING
TESTDATAHELPSTESTPLANNERSENSURETHATTESTMETHODSREmECTTHE
CURRENTSTATEOFTHEART!NDOFCOURSEBYOBSERVINGTESTANOMA
LIES!EROSPACERETAINSRELEVANTLESSONSFORFUTUREPROGRAMSINA
CONTINUOUSCYCLEDRIVINGTOWARDIMPROVEDRELIABILITYOFSPACE
SYSTEMS

"DPVTUJD
5FTUJOH
!PRINCIPALSOURCEOFDYNAMICLOADINGOFSPACEVEHICLESOC
CURSDURINGLIFTOFFANDDURINGATMOSPHERICmIGHTATMAXIMUM
DYNAMICPRESSURE)TISCAUSEDBYTHEINTENSEACOUSTICPRESSURE
GENERATEDBYTURBULENTMIXINGOFEXHAUSTGASESFROMTHEMAIN
ENGINESANDROCKETMOTORSWITHTHEAMBIENTATMOSPHERE
4HISACOUSTICEXCITATIONSTARTSWHENTHEMAINENGINEISIG
NITEDANDLASTSAPPROXIMATELYTOSECONDS)GNITIONPRODUCES
ANEXHAUSTPLUMETHATEXERTSACOUSTICPRESSUREONTHELAUNCH
PADANDREmECTSBACKTOTHESPACEVEHICLETOINDUCEVIBRATION
4HEMAGNITUDEOFTHEEXHAUSTPLUMEANDTHEAMOUNTOFPRES
SUREITEXERTSDEPENDSONFACTORSSUCHASENGINETHRUSTEXITVE
LOCITYENGINENOZZLEDIAMETERLOCATIONOFSTRUCTURESANDDUCT
CONlGURATION!STHESPEEDOFTHELAUNCHVEHICLEINCREASESTHE
RELATIVEVELOCITYBETWEENTHEVEHICLEANDTHEAMBIENTATMO
SPHEREGENERATESmUCTUATINGPRESSURESINATURBULENTBOUNDARY
LAYERBETWEENTHEEXTERIORSURFACEANDTHEATMOSPHERE!STHE
VEHICLETRAVERSESTHESPEEDOFSOUNDTHESO CALLEDREGIONOF
TRANSONICmIGHTANDSHORTLYTHEREAFTERTHEREGIONOFMAXIMUM
DYNAMICPRESSURETHEAIRmOWTOGETHERWITHAERODYNAMIC
SHOCKWAVESTHATATTACHOSCILLATEANDREATTACHCAUSEACOUSTIC
EXCITATIONSCOMPARABLETOLIFTOFFBUTWITHDIFFERENTFREQUENCY
CHARACTERISTICS4HESOUNDPRESSUREANDITSINDUCEDVIBRATION
ARERANDOMINCHARACTER4HESPECTRAUSEDTOASSESSDAMAGE




 




4IME

-EASUREDDYNAMICACCELERATIONS


-AIN
ENGINE
FIRING


-AIN
ENGINE
CUTOFF
TRANSIENT


3TAGE))
IGNITION
TRANSIENT






&AIRING
SEPARATION
TRANSIENT




3TAGE))
ENGINEFIRING


3TAGE))
ENGINECUTOFF
TRANSIENT




3PACECRAFT
0AYLOAD
SEPARATION 3OLARARRAY
TRANSIENT DEPLOYMENT DEPLOYMENT
TRANSIENT
TRANSIENT

0ERIODSOF3IGNIFICANT$YNAMIC%XCITATION

 3OLIDMOTOR
SEPARATION
TRANSIENT

 4RANSONIC
ANDMAX1




 ,IFTOFF
 )GNITION
"
UZQJDBM
%FMUB
**
NJTTJPO
QSPmMF
BOE
UIF
BTTPDJBUFE
BDDFMFSBUJPOT
EVF
UP
BDPVTUJD

WJCSBUJPO
BOE
TIPDL
FOWJSPONFOUT
EVSJOH
MJGUP
USBOTPOJD
BOE
NBYJNVNEZOBNJD
QSFTTVSF
NBY
2

nJHIU
NBJO
FOHJOF
DVUP
TFDPOEBSZ
FOHJOF
DVUP
TUBHF
TFQBSB
UJPO
QBZMPBE
GBJSJOH
TFQBSBUJPO
BOE
TQBDFDSBGU
TFQBSBUJPO
5IF
BDDFMFSBUJPO
UJNF

POTENTIALAREEXPRESSEDINTERMSOFPRESSURE
ANDACCELERATIONORCONVERTEDINTOCOMMONLY
USEDUNITSOFDECIBELSANDPOWERSPECTRAL
DENSITYRESPECTIVELY4HESESPECTRAUSUALLY
SPANTHERANGEOFFREQUENCIESFROMTO
HERTZ
!COUSTICTESTINGOFSPACEVEHICLESOR
MAJORSUBSYSTEMSSTRIVESTOSIMULATETHE
ACOUSTICPRESSUREEXPECTEDDURINGLIFTOFFAND
SUBSEQUENTMISSIONPHASES3PACEVEHICLES
ALSOCONTAINCOMPLEXCOMPONENTSTHATARE
SUSCEPTIBLETOACOUSTICNOISEANDTHESEMUST
BETESTEDTOENSUREALLPOTENTIALFAILUREMODES
ANDWORKMANSHIPDEFECTSHAVEBEENPROP
ERLYSCREENEDOUTPRIORTOSYSTEMINTEGRATION
)NATYPICALACOUSTICTESTTHETESTSPECIMEN
ISPOSITIONEDINANACOUSTICCHAMBER4HE
CHAMBERISALARGEROOMWITHTHICKWALLSAND
ASMOOTHINTERIORSURFACETHATPERMITSHIGH
REVERBERATION4HETESTARTICLEISPLACEDONA
lXTUREORSUSPENDEDFROMBUNGEECORDS)N
SOMECASESTHETESTITEMMAYBEATTACHED
TOLARGERMETALPLATESTOSIMULATEACTUAL

r
$SPTTMJOL
'BMM


IJTUPSZ
JT
QSPDFTTFE
GPS
FBDI
TJHOJmDBOU
EZOBNJD
FWFOU
BOE
USBOTGPSNFE
JOUP

GSFRVFODZ
QMPUT
SFQSFTFOUJOH
BDPVTUJDQSFTTVSF
MFWFMT
WJCSBUJPO
BOE
TIPDL
TQFDUSB

UIBU
BSF
VTFE
UP
FTUBCMJTI
GVUVSF
SFRVJSFNFOUT
BOE
BTTFTT
EBNBHF
QPUFOUJBM
UP
UIF

MBVODI
BOE
TQBDF
WFIJDMF

MOUNTINGONTHESPACECRAFTSTRUCTURETHEREBY
CREATINGAMOREREALISTICPROlLEOFTHEINTER
FACEVIBRATION,OUDSPEAKERSORHORNSSUP
PLYTHEACOUSTICENERGYWITHFOURORMORE
MICROPHONESSTRATEGICALLYPLACEDTOCONTROL
ANDRECORDTHESOUNDLEVELWITHINTHEROOM
.UMEROUSACCELERATIONTRANSDUCERSAREIN
STALLEDONTHETESTITEMTOMEASURETHEMOTION
INDUCEDBYTHEACOUSTICPRESSUREINTOTHE
ITEMSCRITICALCOMPONENTS-ANYOFTHESE
CRITICALCOMPONENTSAREALSOFUNCTIONALLY
MONITOREDDURINGTHETEST4HEMEASUREMENTS
ARECOMPAREDWITHTHEAPPROPRIATEDESIGN
SPECIlCATIONSFORTHECOMPONENTSTOASSESS
THEIRQUALIlCATIONFORmIGHT!EROSPACECON
TRIBUTESTOTHESEACTIVITIESBYPROVIDINGAN
INDEPENDENTREVIEWOFTHETESTMEASUREMENTS
TOENSURETHEIRVALIDITYANDBYCOMPARING
THEMWITHTHEDESIGNSPECIlCATIONANDTHE
PREVIOUSLYPREDICTEDLEVELSTOENSURETHE
DESIGNADEQUACYOFTHECOMPONENTS)NCASE
OFATESTFAILURE!EROSPACEPERFORMSTHE

NECESSARYANALYSISTOHELPIDENTIFYTHEROOT
CAUSEANDAPPROPRIATEMITIGATION
4HEACOUSTICTESTLEVELSFORAPARTICULAR
SPACEVEHICLEORSUBSYSTEMAREUSUALLYDE
RIVEDFROMMEASUREMENTOFDATAONSIMILAR
STRUCTURESONPASTmIGHTSANDGROUNDTESTS
!EROSPACEMAINTAINSANEXTENSIVEDATABASE
OFmIGHTANDGROUND TESTINFORMATION4HIS
COMPILATIONISAUNIQUERESOURCEMADEPOS
SIBLEBY!EROSPACESACCESSTOAWIDERANGE
OFLAUNCHVEHICLEANDSATELLITEPROGRAMDATA
!EROSPACEUSESTHEDATABASETOPREDICTTHE
TESTLEVELSINTHEEARLYSTAGESOFTHEPROGRAM
ANDINADVANCEOFTHEACOUSTICTEST4HIS
PROVIDESTHEPROGRAMEARLYAWARENESSOFTHE
STRUCTURALACOUSTICREQUIREMENTSFORCOM
PONENTDESIGNSOTHATANYDElCIENCYCANBE
ADDRESSEDPRIORTOTHEACTUALTESTS)FSUF
lCIENTDATAARENOTAVAILABLEINTHEDATABASE
ANALYTICALTOOLSSUCHASSTATISTICALENERGY
ANALYSISFORFREQUENCIESABOVEHERTZ
ANDlNITE ELEMENTANDBOUNDARY ELEMENT
METHODSFORFREQUENCIESBELOWHERTZARE

0OWERSPECTRALDENSITY

3OUNDPRESSURELEVELS
DECIBELS

SOMETIMESUSEDTODERIVETESTLEVELS4HEPRE

DICTEDACOUSTICENVIRONMENTISADJUSTEDUSING
5ZQJDBM
BDPVTUJD
UFTU
MFWFM

VTFE
UP
TJNVMBUF
UIF

STATISTICALMETHODSTODERIVEAMAXIMUMPRE

MBVODI
WFIJDMF
FOWJSPO
DICTEDmIGHTENVIRONMENT-ARGINISADDED
NFOU
5IF
TQFDUSVN
JT


TOENSURETHATTHEHARDWAREISSUFlCIENTLY
EJWJEFE
JOUP
PDUBWF

ROBUSTANDTOACCOUNTFORANALYTICALUNCER
CBOET
BOE
UIF
TPVOE


QSFTTVSF
MFWFM
JT
TQFDJmFE

TAINTIESINTHEDERIVATIONOFTHEENVIRONMENT
GPS
FBDI
CBOE
JO
EFDJCFMT


ANDDESIGNOFTHEHARDWARE!TYPICALQUALI
5IF
GSFRVFODZ
SBOHF
JT

lCATIONMARGINISDECIBELSORFOURTIMES

UZQJDBMMZ
GSPN

UP
 

IFSU[
THEENERGYOFTHEMAXIMUMPREDICTEDENVI

RONMENT4HETESTLASTSATLEASTMINUTETO




ESTABLISHADURATIONMARGINOFFOURTIMESTHE
/CTAVEFREQUENCYHERTZ
EXPOSUREINmIGHT!DDITIONALTESTTIMEMAY
-AXIMUMPREDICTEDACOUSTICLEVELFORLIFTOFF
-AXIMUMPREDICTEDACOUSTICLEVELFORTRANSONICMAX1
BEACCUMULATEDDEPENDINGONTHEPROGRAM
-AXIMUMWORKMANSHIPREQUIREMENTFORACOUSTICTEST
REQUIREMENTS(ARDWARETHATISSUSCEPTIBLETO
4YPICALACOUSTICTESTLEVELISASMOOTHENVELOPEPLUSD"MARGIN
THEACOUSTIC PRESSURELOADINGAREITEMSWITH
LARGESURFACESANDLOWMASSDENSITYSUCHAS
COMPOSITEMATERIALSOLARARRAYSANDANTENNA THERESONANTFREQUENCIESTHATWOULDEXISTIN
TESTINGEXPERIENCEANDCONSIDERATIONOF
REmECTORS4HESECOMPOSITESTRUCTURESMAY
INTERFACECONSTRAINTS
THEmIGHT MOUNTINGCONlGURATION
HAVEDESIGNORWORKMANSHIPDElCIENCIES
!SINTHECASEOFACOUSTICTESTINGHERITAGE
WHICHRESULTINBONDORMATERIALFAILURES
4IPDL
5FTUJOH
mIGHTANDTESTDATAAREUSEDTOPREDICTVIBRA
3TAGEFAIRINGANDVEHICLESEPARATIONSARE
TIONTESTLEVELSANDANALYTICALMETHODSARE
7JCSBUJPO
5FTUJOH
SOMETIMESUSEDTODEVELOPTRANSFERFUNCTIONS OFTENACCOMPLISHEDBYMEANSOFPYROTECHNIC
!STHELAUNCHVEHICLELIFTSOFFFROMTHESTAND
DEVICESSUCHASEXPLOSIVEBOLTSSEPARATION
TOSCALEHERITAGEDATATONEWHARDWARECON
ANDTHROUGHOUTPOWEREDmIGHTTHEVIBRA
lGURATIONS)NMOSTCASESTHEPREDICTEDENVI NUTSBOLTCUTTERSEXPANDING TUBESEPARATION
TIONCAUSEDBYTHEOPERATINGENGINESEXCITES
RONMENTSAREVERIlEDLATERWITHSYSTEM LEVEL SYSTEMSCLAMPBANDSORDNANCETHRUSTERS
THEVEHICLEANDSPACECRAFTSTRUCTURE!DDI
ANDPRESSURIZEDBELLOWS7HENACTIVATED
ACOUSTICTESTSANDROCKETENGINESTATIClRE
TIONALVIBRATIONISCAUSEDBYTHEmUCTUATING
THESEDEVICESPRODUCEPOWERFULSHOCKSTHAT
TESTS!SWITHACOUSTICTESTINGA DECIBEL
ACOUSTICPRESSUREEXPERIENCEDDURINGLIFTOFF
CANDAMAGEEQUIPMENTANDSTRUCTURES4HE
MARGINISTYPICALLYADDEDTOTHEMAXIMUM
TRANSONICmIGHTANDTHEMAXIMUM DYNAMIC
PREDICTEDENVIRONMENT3TRUCTURALFAILURESOF CHARACTERISTICSOFTHESESHOCKSDEPENDON
PRESSUREPHASEOFmIGHT
THEPARTICULARSEPARATIONMECHANISMBUT
PIECEPARTSUNITASSEMBLIESANDSECONDARY
6IBRATIONTESTINGHELPSDEMONSTRATETHAT
ANDPRIMARYSPACEVEHICLESTRUCTURESCANAND THEENERGYSPECTRUMISUSUALLYCONCENTRATED
HARDWARECANWITHSTANDTHESECONDITIONS
ATORABOVEHERTZANDISMEASUREDINA
DOOCCURFROMVIBRATION INDUCEDSTRESSAND
2ANDOMVIBRATIONTESTSARECONDUCTEDON
MATERIALFATIGUE&AILURESOFINADEQUATELYDE FREQUENCYRANGEOFTOHERTZ!
ANELECTRODYNAMICVIBRATIONMACHINEOR
SIGNEDORPOORLYMANUFACTUREDORASSEMBLED TYPICALSHOCKRESPONSESPECTRUMPLOTISUSED
hSHAKERvWHICHCONSISTSOFAMOUNTINGTABLE
STRUCTURALINTERFACESARECOMMONLYREVEALED TOGAUGETHEDAMAGEPOTENTIALOFAGIVEN
FORTHETESTITEMRIGIDLYATTACHEDTOADRIVE
SEPARATIONEVENT
!EROSPACEPERSONNELUSINGPREDICTIVE
COILARMATURE!CONTROLSYSTEMENERGIZES
3EPARATIONSORDEPLOYMENTSGENERATE
SOFTWAREPROVIDEANALYSISCONlRMATIONFOR
THESHAKERTOTHEDESIREDVIBRATIONLEVEL
OPTIMALINSTRUMENTATIONFORVIBRATIONTESTING BRIEFIMPULSIVELOADSEVENIFNOPYROTECHNIC
&EEDBACKFORTHECONTROLSYSTEMISPROVIDED
DEVICESAREUSED.ONEXPLOSIVEINITIATORS
!EROSPACECONlRMSHARDWARETESTPERCEP
BYASERIESOFACCELEROMETERSWHICHARE
MAYPRODUCESIGNIlCANTSHOCKLEVELSSIMPLY
TIVENESSANDEFFECTIVENESSWITHANALYSIS
MOUNTEDATTHEBASEOFTHETESTITEMATLOCA
TIONSTHATCORRESPONDTOWHERETHELAUNCH
VEHICLEADAPTERWOULDBEATTACHED4WO
5ZQJDBM
WJCSBUJPO
UFTU


MFWFM
VTFE
UP
TJNVMBUF

CONTROLAPPROACHESCANBEUSEDTOPROVIDERE
UIF
MBVODI
WFIJDMF
FO
ALISTICSTRUCTURALRESPONSES-OSTSPACECRAFT

WJSPONFOU
"
EFDJCFM

VIBRATIONTESTSUSERESPONSE LIMITINGMAJOR
RVBMJmDBUJPO
NBSHJO
JT

UZQJDBMMZ
BEEFE
UP
UIF


APPENDAGEACCELERATIONSTOREDUCEINPUTAT
NBYJNVN
QSFEJDUFE

DISCRETEFREQUENCIESSOASNOTTOCAUSEUNRE
FOWJSPONFOU
UP
FOTVSF


ALISTICFAILURES&ORTESTSTRUCTURESTHATEXHIBIT
UIBU
UIF
IBSEXBSF
JT
TVG
mDJFOUMZ
SPCVTU
DISTINCTLIGHTLYDAMPEDRESONANCESONA

SHAKERFORCELIMITINGISUSEDINCONJUNCTION
WITHINPUTVIBRATIONTOCONTROLTHESHAKER





)NTHEFORCE LIMITINGAPPROACHTRANSDUCERS
&REQUENCYHERTZ
THATMEASURETHEINPUTFORCEAREMOUNTEDBE
-AXIMUMPREDICTEDVIBRATIONLEVELFORLIFTOFF
TWEENTHETESTITEMANDTHESHAKER4HEGOAL
-AXIMUMPREDICTEDVIBRATIONLEVELFORTRANSONICMAX1
ISTOREDUCETHERESPONSEOFTHETESTITEMATITS
-AXIMUMWORKMANSHIPREQUIREMENTFORVIBRATIONTEST
RESONANTFREQUENCIESONTHESHAKERTOREPLI
4YPICALVIBRATIONTESTLEVELISASMOOTHENVELOPEPLUSD"MARGIN
CATETHERESPONSEATTHECOMBINEDSYSTEMAT
$SPTTMJOL
'BMM

r




.FBTVSFE
BDDFMFSBUJPO

UJNF
IJTUPSJFT
BSF
VTFE

UP
EFSJWF
TIPDL
UFTU
SF
RVJSFNFOUT




n
n
n
      

4IPDL
MFWFMT
BSF
TQFDJ
mFE
BT
TIPDL
SFTQPOTF

TQFDUSB
EFmOFE
PWFS
B

GSFRVFODZ
SBOHF
5IF

TIPDL
SFTQPOTF
TQFD
USB
VTFT
UIF
SFTQPOTF

PG
TJOHMFEFHSFFPG
GSFFEPN
PTDJMMBUPST

DPNQVUFE
JO

PD
UBWF
CBOET
UP
DPOWFSU

UIF
UJNF
IJTUPSZ
UP
UIF

GSFRVFODZ
EPNBJO











THROUGHTHERELEASEOFSTRUCTURALSTRAIN%X
PERIENCEHASSHOWNTHATSHOCKCANINDUCEA
HARDORINTERMITTENTFAILUREOREXACERBATEA
LATENTDEFECT#OMMONLYENCOUNTEREDHARD
WAREFAILURESINCLUDERELAYTRANSFERCRACKING
OFPARTSDISLODGINGOFCONTAMINANTSAND
CRACKINGOFSOLDERATCIRCUIT BOARDINTERFACES
5NIT LEVELSHOCKTESTSAREACCOMPLISHED
USINGONEOFSEVERALMETHODSWHICHGEN
ERALLYENTAILSECURINGTHECOMPONENTTOA
lXTURETHATISTHENSUBJECTEDTOIMPACT4HIS
hRINGINGPLATEvAPPROACHHASPROVIDEDTHE
BESTPRACTICABLESIMULATIONOFUNITEXPOSURE
TOSHOCK)NADDITIONVIBRATIONSHAKERSARE
USEDINSOMEAPPLICATIONSTOIMPARTATRAN
SIENTSHOCK3HOCKTESTINGISTYPICALLYNOT

4EMPERATURE

(3&&

!&

!&

PERFORMEDASAUNITWORKMANSHIPSCREEN
BUTISDEFERREDTOTHESYSTEMLEVELFORGREATER
DETECTIONOFFUNCTIONALDEFECTS3YSTEM LEVEL
SHOCKTESTSUSUALLYACTIVATETHESEPARATION
ORDEPLOYMENTSYSTEMSPROVIDINGADIRECT
SIMULATIONOFTHEMISSIONEVENT4HUSTHEY
DONOTINCLUDEANYAMPLITUDEMARGIN4EST
lXTURESAREUSEDTOSUPPORTHARDWARETHAT
HASBEENDEPLOYEDORSEPARATEDTOPREVENT
SUBSEQUENTCONTACTORDAMAGE3YSTEM LEVEL
SHOCKTESTSPROVIDEANEXCELLENTOPPORTUNITY
TOMEASURESHOCKSINCIDENTONCOMPONENTS
THROUGHOUTTHESPACEVEHICLE
!CCURATEPREDICTIONOFHIGH FREQUENCY
SHOCKLEVELSSUCHASTHOSEASSOCIATEDWITH
EXPLOSIVEORDNANCEREMAINSANELUSIVEGOAL

(3&&

&&
&&

#3&&

!&

#3&&
4IME


r
$SPTTMJOL
'BMM




"
UZQJDBM
UIFSNBM
DZ

DMJOH
PS
UIFSNBM
WBD
VVN
UFTU
QSPmMF
5IF

QSPmMF
TIPXT
UFNQFSB
UVSF
IJTUPSZ
BOE
BMXBZT

TUBSUT
BOE
FOET
BU
SPPN

UFNQFSBUVSF
)PU
TUBSUT

)4

DPME
TUBSUT
$4


GVMM
GVODUJPOBM
UFTUT
''


BOE
BCCSFWJBUFE
GVOD
UJPOBM
UFTUT
"'

BSF
QFS
GPSNFE
BU
UFNQFSBUVSF

QMBUFBVT

4HEREFOREITISIMPORTANTTHATTHESHOCKENVI
RONMENTBEASSESSEDDURINGTHEDEVELOPMENT
PHASEOFTHEPROGRAMTHROUGHBOTHANALYSIS
ANDTESTSIMULATIONS3HOCKANALYSISINCLUDES
CONSIDERATIONOFTHESOURCEAMPLITUDES
DURATIONSTRANSMISSIONPATHSPATHMATERI
ALSANDPATHDISCONTINUITIES$EVELOPMENT
TESTSEMPLOYANACCURATEREPLICAOFTHEmIGHT
STRUCTUREWITHALLSIGNIlCANTCONSTITUENTS
SIMULATED$EPLOYEDHARDWAREISFORCEDTO
PHYSICALLYSEPARATEATLEASTASMALLAMOUNT
TOPROVIDEREALISTICSHOCKTRANSMISSIONPATHS
7HENPRACTICALASHOCK PRODUCINGEVENTIS
REPEATEDSEVERALTIMESTOPERMITMEANING
FULSTATISTICALEVALUATIONOFTHERESULTING
DATA1UALIlCATIONMARGINSATTHEUNITLEVEL
ARETYPICALLYDECIBELSONAMPLITUDEAND
TWICETHENUMBEROFmIGHTACTIVATIONS!TTHE
SYSTEMLEVELITISGENERALLYIMPRACTICALTO
IMPOSEANAMPLITUDEQUALIlCATIONMARGIN
HOWEVERAMARGINOFTWOORTHREEACTIVATIONS
ISIMPOSED!EROSPACEPROVIDESEXPERTISEFOR
THEPREDICTIONOFTESTLEVELSANDTHECONlGU
RATIONOFTHEHARDWAREINTERFACESTOACHIEVE
ANEFFECTIVETEST

5IFSNBM
5FTUJOH
,AUNCHVEHICLESANDSPACECRAFTMUSTENDURE
AWIDERANGEOFTEMPERATURESASSOCIATEDWITH
LIFTOFFANDASCENTTHROUGHTHEATMOSPHERE
DIRECTIMPINGEMENTOFSOLARRADIATIONAND
TRAVELTHROUGHTHEEXTREMETEMPERATURESOF
SPACE4HETHERMALENVIRONMENTISGENERALLY
CONSIDEREDTHEMOSTSTRESSFULOPERATINGEN
VIRONMENTFORHARDWAREINTERMSOFFATIGUE
ANDITHASADIRECTBEARINGONUNITRELIABILITY
&OREXAMPLETHEUSEOFMATERIALSWITHDIF
FERINGCOEFlCIENTSOFTHERMALEXPANSION
HASRESULTEDINUNSUCCESSFULDEPLOYMENTS
OFMECHANICALASSEMBLIESANDPAYLOADS
/UTGASSINGINCREASESSIGNIlCANTLYWITH
TEMPERATUREANDTHERESULTINGCONTAMINANTS
WILLMOREREADILYADHEREANDCHEMICALLY
BONDTOCOLDERSURFACES%LECTRONICPARTSARE
ESPECIALLYSENSITIVETOTHETHERMALCONDITIONS
ANDARESUBJECTTOPROBLEMSSUCHASCRACKS
DELAMINATIONBONDDEFECTSDISCOLORATION
PERFORMANCEDRIFTCOATINGDAMAGEAND
SOLDER JOINTFAILURE
4HERMALTESTINGISUSEDTOSCREENOUT
COMPONENTSWITHPHYSICALmAWSANDDEMON
STRATETHATADEVICECANACTIVATEANDOPERATE
INEXTREMEANDCHANGINGTEMPERATURES4HE
FOURMOSTCOMMONTHERMALTESTSARETHERMAL
CYCLINGTHERMALVACUUMTESTINGTHERMAL
BALANCETESTINGANDBURN INTESTING4HERMAL
CYCLINGSUBJECTSTHETESTARTICLETOANUMBER
OFCYCLESATHOTANDCOLDTEMPERATURESINAN
AMBIENT AIRORGASEOUS NITROGENENVIRON

3HOCKRESPONSESPECTRA

MENTCONVECTIONENABLESRELATIVELYRAPID
CYCLINGBETWEENHOTANDCOLDLEVELS4HERMAL
VACUUMTESTINGDOESTHESAMETHINGBUTINA
VACUUMCHAMBERCYCLESARESLOWERBUTTHE
METHODPROVIDESTHEMOSTREALISTICSIMULA
TIONOFmIGHTCONDITIONS)NTHERMALBALANCE
TESTINGALSOCONDUCTEDINVACUUMDEDICATED
TESTPHASESTHATSIMULATEmIGHTCONDITIONSARE
USEDTOOBTAINSTEADY STATETEMPERATUREDATA
THATARETHENCOMPAREDTOMODELPREDICTIONS
4HISALLOWSVERIlCATIONOFTHETHERMALCON
TROLSUBSYSTEMANDGATHERINGOFDATAFORCOR
RELATIONWITHTHERMALANALYTICMODELS"URN
INTESTSARETYPICALLYPARTOFTHERMALCYCLE
TESTSADDITIONALTESTTIMEISALLOTTEDANDTHE
ITEMISMADETOOPERATEWHILETHETEMPERA
TUREISCYCLEDORHELDATANELEVATEDLEVEL
&ORELECTRONICUNITSTHETESTTEMPERATURE
RANGEANDTHENUMBEROFTESTCYCLESHAVETHE
GREATESTIMPACTONTESTEFFECTIVENESS/THER
IMPORTANTPARAMETERSINCLUDEDWELLTIMEAT
EXTREMETEMPERATURESWHETHERTHEUNITIS
OPERATIONALANDTHERATEOFCHANGEBETWEEN
HOTANDCOLDPLATEAUS&ORMECHANICALAS
SEMBLIESTHESESAMEPARAMETERSAREIMPOR
TANTALONGWITHSIMULATIONOFTHERMALSPATIAL
GRADIENTSANDTRANSIENTTHERMALCONDITIONS
4HERMALTESTSPECIlCATIONSAREBASEDPRI
MARILYONTESTOBJECTIVES!TTHEUNITLEVEL
THEEMPHASISISONPARTSCREENINGWHICH
ISBESTACHIEVEDTHROUGHTHERMALCYCLEAND
BURN INTESTING4EMPERATURERANGESARE
MORESEVERETHANWOULDBEENCOUNTEREDIN
mIGHTWHICHALLOWSPROBLEMSTOBEISOLATED
QUICKLY!LSOINDIVIDUALCOMPONENTSARE
EASIERTOlXTHANlNISHEDASSEMBLIES
!TTHEPAYLOADSUBSYSTEMANDSPACE
VEHICLELEVELSTHEEMPHASISSHIFTSTOWARD
PERFORMANCEVERIlCATION!THIGHERLEVELSOF



5ZQJDBM
UFTU
MFWFM
VTFE

UP
TJNVMBUF
UIF
TIPDL

FOWJSPONFOU
2VBMJm
DBUJPO
NBSHJOT
BU
UIF

VOJU
MFWFM
BSF
UZQJDBMMZ


EFDJCFMT









&REQUENCYHERTZ



-AXIMUMPREDICTEDSHOCKLEVELFORFAIRINGSEPARATION
-AXIMUMPREDICTEDSHOCKLEVELFORSTAGESEPARATION
-AXIMUMPREDICTEDSHOCKLEVELFORSPACECRAFTSEPARATION
4YPICALSHOCKTESTLEVELISASMOOTHENVELOPEPLUSD"MARGIN

ASSEMBLYINmIGHT LIKECONDITIONSEND TO

ENDPERFORMANCECAPABILITIESCANBEDEM
ONSTRATEDSUBSYSTEMSANDTHEIRINTERFACES
CANBEVERIlEDANDmIGHTWORTHINESSREQUIRE
MENTSCANBEMET/NTHEOTHERHANDATTHE
HIGHERLEVELSOFASSEMBLYITISDIFlCULTIFNOT
IMPOSSIBLE TOACHIEVEWIDETESTTEMPERATURE
RANGESSOPARTSCREENINGISLESSEFFECTIVE
!TTHEUNITSUBSYSTEMANDVEHICLELEVELS
!EROSPACETHERMALENGINEERSWORKWITHTHE
CONTRACTORINDEVELOPINGTESTPLANSTHATPROVE
THEDESIGNWORKMANSHIPANDmIGHTWORTHI
NESSOFTHETESTARTICLE4EMPERATURERANGES
ARESELECTEDTHATWILLADEQUATELYSCREENORAC
CURATELYSIMULATEMISSIONCONDITIONSANDTHE
PROPERNUMBEROFHOTANDCOLDTESTPLATEAUS
ARESPECIlEDTOADEQUATELYCYCLETHETEST
EQUIPMENT!EROSPACEWILLPROVIDEEXPERTISE
DURINGTHETESTTOPROTECTTHESPACEHARDWARE
INTHETESTENVIRONMENTRESOLVETESTISSUES
ANDCONCERNSANDINVESTIGATETESTARTICLE
DISCREPANCIES4HEREASONOFCOURSEISTHAT

IDENTIFYINGANDCORRECTINGPROBLEMSINTHER
MALTESTINGSIGNIlCANTLYINCREASESCONlDENCE
INMISSIONSUCCESS

$PODMVTJPO
3INCETHElRSTSATELLITELAUNCHINMORE
THANSPACEVEHICLESHAVEBEENLAUNCHED
THROUGHSEVEREANDSOMETIMESUNKNOWNEN
VIRONMENTS%VENWITHEXTENSIVEEXPERIENCE
ANDAWEALTHOFHISTORICALDATATOCONSULT
MISSIONPLANNERSFACEADIFlCULTTASKINEN
SURINGTHATCRITICALHARDWAREREACHESSPACE
SAFELY%VERYNEWCOMPONENTNEWPROCESS
ANDNEWTECHNOLOGYINTRODUCESUNCERTAINTIES
THATCANONLYBERESOLVEDTHROUGHRIGOROUS
ANDMETHODICALTESTING!SANINDEPENDENT
OBSERVEROFTHETESTINGPROCESS!EROSPACE
HELPSINSTILLCONlDENCETHATENVIRONMENTAL
REQUIREMENTSHAVEBEENADEQUATELYDElNED
ANDTHECORRESPONDINGTESTSHAVEBEENPROP
ERLYPLANNEDANDEXECUTEDTOGENERATEUSEFUL
ANDRELIABLERESULTS

-FGU
"
TQBDFDSBGU
JT
QMBDFE
JO
UIF
BDPVTUJD
DIBNCFS
BOE
JT
SFBEZ
GPS
UFTUJOH
"JS
IPSOT
BU
UIF
DPSOFST
PG
UIF

DIBNCFS
HFOFSBUF
B
QSFTDSJCFE
TPVOE
QSFTTVSF
JOUP
UIF
DPOmOFE
TQBDF
BOE
POUP
UIF
TQBDFDSBGU
.JDSPQIPOFT

MPDBUFE
BSPVOE
UIF
TQBDFDSBGU
BSF
VTFE
UP
NPOJUPS
BOE
DPOUSPM
UIF
QSFTTVSF
MFWFMT
.JEEMF
5IF
TVEEFO
TFQBSB
UJPO
PG
UIF
QBZMPBE
GBJSJOH
JT
VTFE
UP
FYQPTF
TQBDFDSBGU
DPNQPOFOUT
UP
UIF
TIPDL
FOWJSPONFOU
FYQFDUFE
JO

nJHIU
3JHIU
4QBDF
JOTUSVNFOU
QMBDFE
PO
BO
FMFDUSPEZOBNJDBMMZ
DPOUSPMMFE
TMJQ
UBCMF
GPS
WJCSBUJPO
UFTUJOH
5IF

DPOUSPM
BDDFMFSPNFUFST
BSF
NPVOUFE
BU
UIF
CBTF
PG
UIF
UFTU
mYUVSF
BU
B
MPDBUJPO
UIBU
SFQSFTFOUT
UIF
JOUFSGBDF
UP

UIF
MBVODI
WFIJDMF
BEBQUFS
"DDFMFSPNFUFST
NPVOUFE
PO
UIF
UFTU
TQFDJNFO
NFBTVSF
UIF
EZOBNJD
SFTQPOTFT

$SPTTMJOL
'BMM

r