Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
General difference.................................................................................................. 2
b)
Form of Government............................................................................................... 2
c)
Office of President.................................................................................................. 3
d)
Civil Services........................................................................................................ 3
General difference.................................................................................................. 4
b)
Civil service.......................................................................................................... 5
c)
Parliamentary Commissioner.................................................................................... 6
d)
CAG................................................................................................................... 7
General difference.................................................................................................. 7
b)
Office of President.................................................................................................. 8
c)
Civil service.......................................................................................................... 8
d)
Administrative courts.............................................................................................. 9
General differences............................................................................................... 10
b)
Civil service........................................................................................................ 10
India
1. New constitution (1949) originally
consisting of a preamble, 395 articles
and 8 schedules.
b) Form of Government
USA Presidential form of government
house.
4. He attends the parliamentary
sessions and has the voting right
in which he is a member.
5. He has to resign if he does not
having the confidence of the
lower house.
India
1. Elected by an electoral college consisting
of :
Elected members of parliament.
Elected members of state assemblies.
Elected members of assemblies of UT
of Delhi and puducherry.
India
1. All recruitments are based on
merit system only.
3.
4.
5.
6.
6. Restrictions on fundamental
rights such as:
They dont have any
rights to comment on
policy matters. This is
done to ensure political
neutrality.
Right to form/join
associations is
guaranteed. However the
government would
consult or negotiate only
with the recognized
ones.
India and UK
a) General difference
UK
1. Oldest democracy which is a blend of
monarchy, aristocracy and democracy.
India
1. New democracy which is a parliamentary
and republic.
India
1. See USA.
period.
3. Promotions are carried out
professionally :
Candidate is informed well in
advance of vacant posts.
Suitability is decided by
board.
Aggrieved candidates have
the right to appeal.
4. A highly comprehensive system is in
place for better employer (state) and
employee relations - whitley
counsels.
5. Rights
They have the right to
express views on non
political matters of public
importance.
There is a total ban on
political activities at higher
level. It becomes less relaxed
to the middle and lower
levels. The lower levels can
participate in all the political
activities.
Right to strike is not illegal.
However they can be
subjected to disciplinary
actions.
Right to form/join
associations and collectively
bargain is allowed.
5.Rights
c) Parliamentary Commissioner
UK
1. Limited scope. Does not include
India
1. Wider scope includes ministers, PM
and MPs.
2. He investigates matters of corruption.
d) CAG
UK
1. He is an officer of the parliament and
audits the accounts of the union.
2. Any money can be drawn by the
executive from the public exchequer
only after his approval. He is both the
comptroller and auditor.
India
1. He is a constitutional body who audits
the accounts of union as well the state.
2. He has no control over the money
drawn from the consolidated funds and
is involved only during the audit stage
when the expenditure has already
occurred. He is only auditor.
India
1. Already covered
2. No such futures.
3. Already covered.
4. Already covered.
7. NA
India
1. Already covered.
2. He has to be 35+.
India
1. Stable government.
3. Already covered.
d) Administrative courts
France
1. It is created to provide justice to
citizens on all administrative matters.
The scope is wider. The administrative
India
1. It has a narrower scope and is created
for curbing corruption.
India
1. Already covered.
2. Already covered.
3. Elected president and enjoys few powers.
He enjoys the power to choose and
appoint PM.
He appoints the ministers of course on
the advice of PM.
He can remove the ministers on the
advice of PM.
b) Civil service
Japan
1. The administrative officers called
careermen or elitos are attached to
India
1. IAS is not attached to any ministry. They
move from one to another. India believes
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
3. It is based on merit.
References
1. Public Administration M. Lakshikanth
2. Indian Polity M. Lakshmikanth
3. PRS - http://www.prsindia.org
4. Internet digging.
Personal Info:
Name: Rajith P.R.