Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Thermodynamical foundations
Conventional elastoplastic models for soils
Advanced topics: anisotropic hardening plasticity
Theory of Plasticity
Theoretical fundamentals and applications to soil mechanics
Claudio Tamagnini
Dipartimento di Ingegneria Civile e Ambientale
University of Perugia
Innsbruck 11.03.2011
Theoretische Bodenmechanik
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Outline
1
Thermodynamical foundations
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Theory of Plasticity
r = p
r = 0
r = const.
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
p = (a + 2r )/3 = c
Claudio Tamagnini
v = a + 2r
Theory of Plasticity
p = (a + 2r )/3
q = a r
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
r = c = const.
qf = M p f
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Theory of Plasticity
= F (, q, d) |{z}
= C(, q, dir d) d
rateind.
where:
O
Theory of Plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
D :=
e
+ 0
e
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
+ 0
p
e
and, rearranging:
e
!
: +
p
0
e
Claudio Tamagnini
e
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
E p := (p , )
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
+ f ()
L (, )
= E
subject to the following Kuhn-Tucker optimality conditions:
0
f () 0
f () = 0
The stationary point of L are found by setting to zero its first variation
w/r to :
L
p + f
= E
which yields:
p = f
E
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
f
q
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
p = f
E
0 ,
f () 0 ,
f () = 0
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
When no internal variables are present, the yield surface remains fixed in
stress space. The material is defined perfectly plastic.
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
p0
( ) E
This is possible only if the yield surface is convex and the plastic flow is
associative.
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
q
The quantities and q can be obtained from the hyperelastic CEs and
the flow rule:
2
f
= e
= Ce
Ce := e
e
q=
q = H
f
q
H :=
2
(cont.)
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
q
f
f
f
f
=
Ce
H
=0
q
q
which yields:
f
f
f
f
Ce
+
H
q
q
=
f
Ce
(cont.)
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
1 f
Ce
Kp
where:
Kp :=
f
f
f
f
f
f
Ce
+
H
=
Ce
+ Hp
q
q
Constitutive assumption:
Kp > 0
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Plastic modulus
The quantity:
Hp :=
f
f
H
q
q
Hp :=
Claudio Tamagnini
f
f
f
f
H
>
Ce
q
q
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Loading/Unloading conditions
The plastic multiplier cannot be negative. Therefore, from the previous
expression we distinguish 3 possible cases:
f
Ce = 0 neutral loading process, = 0
Hence:
=
1
Kp
Claudio Tamagnini
f
Ce
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
1
Kp
f
tr
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Example: 1d plasticity
= C e e
e
Claudio Tamagnini
q=
= H
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Example: 1d plasticity
Yield function:
f (, q) = || (Y + q) = 0
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Example: 1d plasticity
Flow rule and hardening law:
p =
f
= sgn()
f
=
q
Plastic multiplier:
Kp =
1
=
Kp
f
f
f e f
C
+
H
= Ce + H
q
q
f e
C
Claudio Tamagnini
Ce
hsgn() i
Ce + H
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Example: 1d plasticity
e
1
f
f e
C H
= C e e
Ce
, C =
C +H
Ce + H
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Example: 1d plasticity
= C e
1
Ce + H
Ce
Claudio Tamagnini
e
f e
C H
, C =
Ce + H
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Fundamental assumptions
Constitutive equations in rate form
A simple 1d example
Phenomenological generalization: nonassociative behavior
1
p
K
f
Ce
where:
p := f Ce g f h > 0
K
q
p := f h
H
q
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
f () = dev() dev() k 2 = 0
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
f (, n ) = c |n | tan = 0
f (1 , 3 ) = (1 3 ) 2c cos (1 + 3 ) sin = 0
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
Nonetheless, they are still among the most widely used constitutive
models in the FE analysis of practical geotechnical problems, especially in
situations where site characterization is problematic.
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
p e
v
s = 2G e e
where:
s = dev()
e e = dev(e )
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
f (p, q, , ps ) = p(p ps ) +
f
= 2p ps
p
q
M ()
f
= 2q/M 2
q
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
2
=0
f
= p 0
ps
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
p
p0
Unloading/reloading line
(URL)
v = v0 + log
p
p0
ps
;
ps
ev =
ps
ps
(cont.)
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
ps
;
ps
ev =
ps
ps
Subtracting:
pv = ( )
ps
ps
ps
pv
ps
f
=
p
ps =
(cont.)
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
Nonassociative hardening
law:
ps = hs (p, q, , ps )
Comparing with the expression
derived for ps we obtain:
hs =
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
f
ps
p
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
ps
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Perfect plasticity
Isotropic hardening plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Anisotropy in geomaterials
Almost all geomaterials are characterized to a certain extent by the
existence of some preferential orientations at the microstructural level.
Theory of Plasticity
Anisotropy in geomaterials
These preferential orientations can be due to the geological processes
which led to the formation of the deposit, or be the result of particle
rearrangements induced by the applied engineering loads.
In some cases, the existence of particular symmetries at the
microstructural level is apparent (i.e., bedding planes).
In other situations, the detection of preferential directions requires the
definition of suitable (statistical) indicators which quantify the geometry
of grains and the directional properties of their interaction.
For example, in granular materials, such preferential orientation can be
associated to the spatial distribution of intergranular contact normals,
grain shape and void shape (Oda et al. 1985).
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Anisotropy in geomaterials
As a consequence of the directional properties of the microstructure, the
phenomenological response of geomaterials may be characterized by a
more or less marked anisotropy:
Theory of Plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Theory of Plasticity
The angle is the inclination between the bedding plane and the max principal
stress direction.
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Theory of Plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
General principles
Ref.: Boehler (1987).
Consider a general CE of the form:
= F (d, )
in which:
= Cauchy stress
d = applied load (either e or p )
= structure tensor
This can represent an elastic CE, in which case d e , or a flow rule, in
which case d p .
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Q O
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Isotropy
A material is isotropic if no changes in the response occur for a given
load, upon an arbitrary transformation of the microstructure:
F (d, QQT ) = F (d, )
Q O
F (QdQT ) = QF QT
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Anisotropy: definition
A material is anisotropic if there exist a transformation of the
microstructure which affects the response to a given load:
Q O
Q S
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
General anisotropy:
S = {+1, 1}
Orthotropy:
Sorth = {+1, 1, S 1 , S 2 , S 3 }
Transverse isotropy:
Stras = {+1, 1, S 1 , S 2 , S 3 , R (0 2)}
where:
S 1 , S 2 , S 3 = reflections w.r. to the principal directions of d;
R (0 2) = rotation around the axis of anisotropy.
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Z :=
1
s + (p k) 1
0 0
0
0
0 0
0
0
1 0
0
0
C :=
(, , = const.)
0
0 0 0 2 0
0 0 0 0 2 0
0 0 0 0
0 2
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
qk ) = 0
f (, , qk ) = f(,
Claudio Tamagnini
:=
Theory of Plasticity
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
I a := a
f (, a , p0 ) = f (I a , J a , Z a , p0 )
(J a )2 := (1/2) sa sa
Z a := 6 tr (da )3 /[tr (da )2 ]3/2
sa :=
Ia a
da := dev (sa )
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity
a a = 3
Claudio Tamagnini
Theory of Plasticity