Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
My heartfelt thanks go to Werner Wolf, Katharina Bantleon, Henry Keazor, Heiner Wilharm, Ralf Bohn and Ernest Wolf Gazo for their critical discussions and helpful suggestions.
260
Pamela C. Scorzin
See for example Aronson 2005, Oddey/White 2006, Bohn/Wilharm, eds. 2009,
Howard 2002/2009, Flscher 2009, McKinney/Butterworth, eds. 2009, Brejzek/Mueller von der Hagen/Wallen 2009, Rewa 2009, Collins/Nisbet, eds. 2010 and Klanten/
Feireiss/Ehmann, eds. 2010. The term scenology was introduced by Heiner Wilharm
to differentiate the historical, theoretical and methodological approaches as well as the
emerging academic discipline from the actual practice of (meta-)scenography (see
2008: online).
261
contemporary literature on scenography strongly underlines characteristics such as the intermediate cross-modality and hybridization of
different forms and materials which outline scenographys transdisciplinary, transmedial and transgeneric character. In scenography as in
the formative tradition of installation art different (new) media and
practices blend, interact and synthesize rather than being brought into
mere opposition to, or competition or rivalry with, one another. In this
state of intense dialogue, exchange and hybridization as well as digitalization, the performance in question can also generate a particular
awareness of the characteristics of the media involved, and the latter
are thus prone to comment on their own as well as on each others
medial conditions as autonomous medial sub-systems in an illuminating way.
As a consequence, contemporary scenography acquires a characteristic feature of inherent metaization which aligns it with the metareferential turn discussed in the present volume. Indeed todays scenography generally shows a marked tendency toward self-reflection, for
example by creating and breaking dramatic illusion, and it increasingly displays an awareness of stage representation as a process rather
than a static work.
Scenography of this kind, which in addition shows a strong inclination toward mega-size, can be regarded as an excellent example of the
multi-faceted practice of the post-medium age sensu American critic
Rosalind E. Krauss. In her famous text A Voyage on the North Sea:
Art in the Age of the Post-Medium Condition (1999), Krauss expands
Clement Greenbergs canonical description of the modernist desire for
pure art forms in order to encompass the forms, methods and issues
of art today, the art of the post-medium age. Krauss argues that, while
this drive for purity of art forms still exists at the turn of 21st century,
the art forms themselves, as well as the new media technologies, have
evolved in such an accelerated way that the search for purity can no
longer follow the same tenets. The mashup rules! As a matter of fact,
mashup in its modern sense of a recent media phenomenon, a resampling of previously existing medial or artistic material, can currently
be considered the most popular source of metaization in contemporary
culture; consider, for instance, a digital media file containing text and/
or graphic, audio or video elements as well as animations, thus recombining, recoding, restructuring and modifying pre-existing digital material in order to create a derivative and hybrid new work.
262
Pamela C. Scorzin
Within the past few years the term scenography has also come to
refer to a newly emerging academic discipline which focuses on more
recent innovations in staging practices, among which metareferential
reflections on staging practices and activities themselves are a characteristic feature. Wherever scenographic description focuses on such
metareferential phenomena it transforms itself into metascenography, and in an analogous sense, the same term may also refer to the
corresponding object of description: a scenography that attains metastatus. In both cases the audience plays a decisive role. Metascenography may thus be regarded as an inherent, audience-based and usergenerated part of scenography. The term metascenography, used to
designate the aforementioned scenographic principles (cf. Scorzin
2009a: 301314), has not yet become an established term. However, it
appears to be highly relevant, since metascenography reflects, demonstrates and clarifies what scenography actually is, how it works and
functions, and where it is located and can be encountered in our
culture. Metascenography can be recognized and explicitly realized in
mise en abyme compositions, such as the act of staging a stage. A
conspicuous example of metascenography will be discussed at some
length in the following.
2. Metareference in the scenography of The Paradise Institute
In embarking on a detailed discussion of a specific example of metascenography, I would like to underline the innovative contemporary
nature of 20th- and 21st-century media landscapes with their notorious
discursiveness, the strongly theory-oriented disposition of contemporary art and its specific design practices. Before this backdrop, the
question of what metascenography actually means requires some
further elaboration. This also holds true for the question of how it generally relates to the metareferential turn, in particular when considering the developments and characteristics of the post-medial condition.
As a form of metareference, metascenography is in accordance with
Werner Wolfs definition of the concept at large:
a special, transmedial form of usually non-accidental self-reference produced by
signs or sign configurations which are (felt to be) located on a logically higher
level, a metalevel, within an artefact or performance; this self-reference, which
can extend from this artefact to the entire system of the media, forms or implies a
statement about an object-level, namely on (aspects of) the medium/system referred to. Where metareference is properly understood, an at least minimal corre-
263
sponding meta-awareness is elicited in the recipient, who thus becomes conscious of both the medial (or fictional in the sense of artificial and, sometimes in
addition, invented) status of the work under discussion and the fact that mediarelated phenomena are at issue, rather than (hetero-)references to the world outside the media. (2009: 31)
Similarly good examples for the discussion and exploration of metareferential potentials, motivations and functions in scenography are to be found
in recent media art works and installations such as Teresa Hubbard and
Alexander Birchlers Grand Paris Texas (2008), Francesco Vezzolis Trailer
for a Remake of Gore Vidals Caligula (2006), Democracy (2007) and Greed
(2008), or Thats Opera 200 Years of Italian Music (2008/2009) by German exhibition scenographer Uwe R. Brckner, Atelier Brckner/Stuttgart.
3
See www.cardiffmiller.com as well as Cardiff/Miller 2001. For a more
detailed, art-historical discussion see Scorzin 2007, 2009a and 2009b.
264
Pamela C. Scorzin
part love story, part murder mystery, and part experimental film with
delicate allusions to film directors such as Alfred Hitchcock, Michelangelo Antonioni and David Lynch. These references to film makers
greatly admired by the Canadian artists are built-in devices that can be
seen as a subtle homage to icons of the filmic medium. Hereby a given
new work is metareferentially inscribed into an acclaimed, esteemed
and eminent media tradition (see Schwanecke in this vol.).
Illustration 1: Janet Cardiff & George Bures Miller. The Paradise Institute (2001), exterior. Mixed-media installation. Running time: 13 minutes. Courtesy of the artists, Galerie Barbara Weiss/Berlin and Luhring Augustine Gallery/New York City.
265
Illustration 2: Janet Cardiff & George Bures Miller. The Paradise Institute (2001), interior. Mixed-media installation. Running time: 13 minutes. Courtesy of the artists, Galerie Barbara Weiss/Berlin and Luhring Augustine Gallery/New York City.
Towards the end of the film, the mysterious Paradise Institute resembles a fast paced movie trailer, evolving and developing in full ex4
266
Pamela C. Scorzin
The term was originally coined by Alvin Toffler in his 1980 publication The Third
Wave.
267
268
Pamela C. Scorzin
269
270
Pamela C. Scorzin
271
272
Pamela C. Scorzin
273
historization6, metaization seems to steer on a path to mere eclecticism, new formalisms, and mannerisms.
B. The eliciting of medium-awareness in the process of metaization
can moreover be regarded as an effect of the increasing differentiation, formalization and autonomy of the art system in Western culture (see Luhmann 1995) exploring and exploiting its own medial
nature, functions, qualities and potentials in comparison to other
autonomous (media) systems in modern society, thereby reflecting
its own ontological status and specific external difference to other
systems in modern society. It should be noted that ultimately all
autonomous systems tend to demonstrate and negotiate their external as well as internal differentiations; modern art, for instance,
classificatorily signals and even significantly marks its specific nature and systematically autonomous status as modern art by way of
its specific aesthetics and rhetoric. To the extent that postmodern
art and media are even increasingly considered to be autonomous
this process of differentiation through metaization is accordingly
intensified.
C. Contemporary metaization can, thirdly, be interpreted as a special
side-effect of strongly activating, involving and integrating recipients as active participants, or even as acting and performing prosumers having formed an integral component of a work of art
since around the 1950s (which can, for instance, be observed in the
development and increased production of interactive and immersive mixed-media installations; see The Art of Participation, 1950 to
Now [2008]). So metareference does not only imply the activation
of a certain cognitive frame in the participants mind, but also subtly educates, stimulates and supports his/her personal creativity in
the course of completing and manifesting the modern open work of
art (see Eco 1962/1989). It is therefore a clear marker of a tendency towards more democratic and emancipatory attitudes underlying
contemporary art with active recipients becoming immersants7,
complicit participants, users or prosumers.
In a German-speaking context, the epitome of this is Wissenschaftsgeschichte (history of science), which is in the process of turning into a flourishing academic discipline.
7
The term immersants was originally coined by the new media artist
Char Davis in the 1990s.
274
Pamela C. Scorzin
D. The metareferential turn might finally also be seen as a significant symptom and additional side-effect of the current emergence
of a new Global Art and common hyper-culture, that is, it is indicative of a post-historic, post-ethnic and post-medium state which
is characterized by remarkable practices such as the popular mashup. For are we beyond the unification, digitalization and hybridization of all creative genres (see Nth 2009) not increasingly
experiencing new (re-)combinations and syntheses of various contexts such as the recently emerging complex and multi-ambiguous
post-global hyper cultures, instead of the frequently invoked
impact of old cultures? These phenomena clearly depart from
supposedly homogeneous, national monocultures, and seem to
proceed towards a new hybrid Global Art, demonstrating in particular the interconnection and endless migrations of forms and media
across different cultures and borders. Mirroring, and reflecting on,
these tendencies is not least among the reasons that may be invoked to explain the current metareferential turn.
References
Aronson, Arnold (2005). Looking Into the Abyss: Essays on Scenography. Ann Arbor, MI: U of Michigan P.
Belting, Hans (1983/1987). The End of the History of Art? [Das Ende
der Kunstgeschichte?]. Trans. Christopher S. Wood. Chicago, IL:
U of Chicago P.
Bohn, Ralf, Heiner Wilharm, eds. (2009). Inszenierung und Ereignis:
Beitrge zur Theorie und Praxis der Szenografie. Szenografie &
Szenologie 1. Bielefeld: transcript.
Brejzek, Thea, Gesa Mueller von der Hagen, Lawrence Wallen (2009).
Szenografie. Stephan Gnzel, ed. Raumwissenschaften. Frankfurt/
M.: Suhrkamp. 370385.
Butler, Martin (2009). Please Play this Song on the Radio: Forms
and Functions of Metareference in Popular Music. W. Wolf, ed.
299316.
Caldwell, John T. (2008). Screen Practice and Conglomeration: How
Reflexivity and Conglomeration Fuel Each Other. Robert Philipp
Kolker, ed. The Oxford Handbook of Film and Media Studies.
Oxford: OUP. 327364.
275
276
Pamela C. Scorzin
277