Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Predicate Term
Subject Term
Predicate Term
Note: We should keep in mind that the quantifiers ('all', 'no', and 'some') are implied in all
categorical propositions even though they are not explicitly stated. If these quantifiers
are not explicitly used in the formulation of the proposition it is said to be in non-standard
form. The standard form for all categorical propositions is the following:
All S are P.
No S are P.
Some S are P.
Some S are not P.
If our examples above were in standard form they would look like this:
Particular Affirmative
Particular Negative
Thus, there are only four types of standard form categorical proposition possible. As a shortcut
we may tag each with a letter as follows:
A
E
I
O
F. Distribution - the quantity associated with either the subject or predicate term of a
categorical proposition
Definition: a term is 'distributed' if the proposition makes an assertion about every member of
the class denoted by the term.
1. Universal Affirmative - All S are P.
Note: in light of this distribution we might be tempted to formulate the E proposition as "All S
are not P." But this formulation is ambiguous since it could mean one of two different
things: suppose we said "All pit bulls are not mean." This could be interpreted as
1. No pit bulls are mean, or
2. Some pit bulls are not mean
Without a specific context it is impossible to determine which is the intended meaning. Thus,
even though both terms are distributed in the E claim, we always use the standard form "No s are
P."
3. Existential Fallacy - occurs when the traditional square is used in conjunction with
non-existent entities.
III. Categorical Propositions and Venn Diagrams:
The most useful device for understanding the nature of modern Categorical Propositions is the
circle diagram of John Venn. A Venn diagram is a model for some universe of discourse.
Note that there are four regions in the diagram each corresponding to some element of a
categorical proposition:
1. The region of S and only S (not P).
2. The region of S and P (both S and P).
3. The region of P and only P (not S).
4. The region of not S, and not P, and not S and P (i.e., what lies beyond both S and P (not S
and not P).
Note: a statement beginning with 'few' must be translated as a compound I/O proposition.
Note: 'only' and 'none but' at the beginning require term reversal
People shows different kinds of emotions, jealousy is the hardest one to keep. @ShitHappensDre