Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
FINAL
Version Control
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
Status
Final
Project ID
HBU/ISC/11.06.2012
Filename/Document ID
Last Saved
24 July 2012
Owner
Director
Approved by
Imad Damrah
Date Approved
24 July 2012
2 of 109
FINAL
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1
Project Introduction
Executive Summary
3.1
Macro Location
3.2
Micro Location
3.3
Site Accessibility
10
3.4
13
3.5
SWOT Analysis
16
Competitive Review
17
4.1
Laban 7
18
4.2
Dharat Laban 4
19
4.3
Laban 6
20
4.4
Laban 5
21
4.5
22
4.6
23
Development Concept
25
5.1
25
5.2
Parcel A
27
5.3
Parcel B
30
5.4
Parcel C
32
5.5
40
Financial Analysis
44
6.1
Scenario A
44
6.2
Scenario B
47
6.3
Conclusion
50
Summary Conclusion
51
52
APPENDICES
1
55
Microeconomic Analysis
67
2.1
67
2.2
Demographic overview
67
2.3
72
3
3.1
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
Residential Segment
76
Overview
76
3 of 109
FINAL
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
3.2
Characteristics
77
3.3
Residential Supply
81
3.4
Performance
82
3.5
91
3.6
95
3.7
Outlook
108
4 of 109
FINAL
PROJECT INTRODUCTION
Colliers International has been appointed by The Investor for Securities. (Client
orISC) to assess the financial viability of the development concept on a parcel of
land (the Subject Site) measuring a total of approximately 1.36 mn sqm. The
Subject Site is located in west Riyadh, at the intersection of Western Ring Road
and Makkah Road.
Based on Colliers understanding of the Clients requirements, the principal
purpose of the study is summarized as follows:
1 Investigate the market and site potential for land development (i.e. land
subdivision development options) through market research (e.g. demand,
supply and comparable/best practice case studies)
2 Determine critical success factors or key ingredients for success (including
typical plot size, road width and innovative suggestions to differentiate the
Subject Site from competing developments)
3 Test the financial viability of the land subdivision development concept on the
Subject Site
This report details Colliers market findings, site assessment and development
recommendations for the Subject Site. The report also includes financial viability
assessments on the proposed development recommendations.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
5 of 109
FINAL
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Colliers International is committed to assess the financial viability of a land
subdivision development concept for the Subject Site which measures
approximately 1.36mn sqm.
The Subject Site is located in west Riyadh at the intersection of Western Ring
Road and Makkah/Jeddah Road.
The Subject Site shows good potential for land subdivision, while varying parcel
sizes could be allocated to different land uses:
Parcel A: Land to be used primarily for residential purposes, while a large land
include:
A Semi Gated Community
A Gated Community (Residential Compound)
Large Superblock for Mixed Use Development (Retail and Residential)
Conventional Land Parcels for Commercial and Residential
In SAR
Scenario A
Total Revenue
1,599,556,891
1,613,701,538
(1,116,762,920)
(1,116,762,920)
(71,723,749)
(72,483,080)
(1,188,486,669)
(1,189,246,000)
411,070,222
424,455,538
Q9
Q11
c.20%
c.17%
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
Scenario B
6 of 109
FINAL
3.1
MACRO LOCATION
Riyadh is located in the centre of Saudi Arabia, is the capital of the country and its
largest city. The subject site is located in west Riyadh. The following exhibit shows
the location of the Subject Site within Riyadh:
Subject Sites
The Subject Site is located at the junction of Makkah Road and Western Ring
Road, two of Riyadhs major thoroughfares. The land parcel is irregularly shaped
and measures approximately 1.36 mn sqm.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
7 of 109
FINAL
MICRO LOCATION
3.2
For ease of reference, Colliers divided the Subject Site into three parcels: Parcel A
(250,922 sqm), Parcel B (200,058 sqm) and Parcel C (910,925 sqm). The Subject
Site is located in close proximity to Dhahrat Laban, Tuwaiq and Uraija Al Gharbi
Districts. The following exhibit depicts the distance between the Subject Site and
nearby thoroughfares:
Exhibit 3: Micro Location of Subject Site
Parcel A
Parcel B
Area: c. 910,925Sqm
Parcel C
Area: c. 200,058 Sqm
The Subject Site is a raw land parcel that requires minor levelling which will result
in additional excavation work. This will lead to increased infrastructure spending.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
8 of 109
FINAL
The Subject Site enjoys excellent visibility due to its presence at the junction of
Makkah Road and Western Ring Road. The site has good overall accessibility;
however, certain sections of the land are currently difficult to access due to its
significant size. This is due to the relatively undeveloped infrastructure in the
surrounding area, apart from the major thoroughfares. The following exhibit
illustrates the surrounding land use of the Subject Site:
Exhibit 4: Surrounding Land Use of the Subject Site
Diplomatic Quarters
GCC Council
Courtyard by Marriott
King Abdulaziz
Conference Centre
Yamamah Palace
Police
Station
Dhahrat Laban
Large
Palace
Wadi Hanifa
Subject Site
Tuwaiq
Uraija Al Gharbi
Residential
Hospitality
Uraija Al Awsat
Government
Other
The residential areas surrounding the Subject Site comprise primarily low to mid
income districts (e.g. Tuwaiq and Dhahrat Laban). The eastern section of the
Subject Site is within close proximity to the Diplomatic Quarter and offers high end
residential areas (including palaces). A number of palaces are also located on the
western side of Al Wadi Road, which adds increased security to the area. Other
land uses surrounding the Subject Site include:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
9 of 109
FINAL
The residential areas surrounding the Subject Site have a shortage of commercial
developments with only minor street retail presence on Al Wadi Road.
The following exhibit illustrates the Subject Site and its parcel shapes:
Exhibit 5: Parcel Shapes and Various Snapshots
Parcel A
Parcel B
Parcel C
Source:
Notes:
3.3
SITE ACCESSIBILITY
The Subject Site has good overall accessibility due to its prominent location on the
junction of Makkah Road and Western Ring Road. The three land parcels are all
corner plots with road frontages which allows for improved accessibility. However,
certain parts of the parcels are currently inaccessible due to the significant size of
the Subject Site and the undeveloped nature of the land.
The following exhibit illustrates the access points to the Subject Site:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
10 of 109
Parcel A
Parcel B
FINAL
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
B
A
Parcel C
11 of 109
Source:
FINAL
Riyadhs upcoming public transport works will further improve access to the
Subject Site through its east to west Mono Rail on King Abdullah Road and its
major Bus Route, which passes by Parcel C.
The project is divided into two phases:
Phase 1 measures 25 km and will operate between Olaya Road and Batha
Road, connecting North Ring Road to South Ring Road
The citys public transport project is expected to commence in the near term and
has an expected completion date of late 2016/early 2017. The Subject Sites
proximity to the nearest bus station will be beneficial to future users of the
envisaged development. The following exhibit illustrates the location of the Subject
Site in relation to Riyadhs planned major and minor public transportation works:
Exhibit 7: Major and Minor Public Transport Links
Proposed Metro
Major Bus Route
Peripheral Bus Route
Minor Bus Route
Subject Site
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
12 of 109
FINAL
3.4
3.4.1
The following map illustrates the aforementioned routes between the Subject Site
and the airport:
Exhibit 8: Proximity to King Khalid International Airport
Subject Site
Sources: Google Maps, 2012
Colliers Research, 2012
3.4.2
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
13 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 9: Area Surrounding the Subject Site and its Key Demand Generators
KAFD
ITCC Complex
Diplomatic Quarters
King Abdulaziz
Conference Centre
Completed
Under Construction
c.10 Km
Subject Site
Demand
Generator
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
Description
KSU - Riyadh
Techno Valley
KSU - King
Saud University
Endowment
King Abdullah
Financial District
14 of 109
FINAL
Demand
Generator
Description
Information
Technology and
Communications
Centre
Ritz Carlton
Upon completion in 2011, The Ritz Carlton became one of the most
popular hotels in Riyadh due to the hotels prestigious style and
unique decor. The hotel features 493 rooms, 3 restaurants and over
5,800 sqm of conference space. Similar to the Intercontinental Hotel,
Ritz Carlton benefits from a high number of government and foreign
embassy functions mostly due to its location. The hotel is situated
immediately across from the diplomatic quarter and the neighbouring
King Abdulaziz International Conference Centre.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
15 of 109
FINAL
3.5
SWOT ANALYSIS
Strengths
Weaknesses
Given the significant size of the land parcels, the site The sites typography comprises levelled and
could be developed into a major urban site.
unlevelled fields.
Located in low density / upcoming area, apart from the The Subject Site is located far from Riyadhs major
city centre traffic congestions.
CBDs.
Opportunities
Threats
Due to location and size of the Subject Site, potential The areas shortage of relevant activity for residential
land subdivision could offer major urban generation
developments such as schools, hospitals and retail
opportunities (releasing significant amounts of
creates challenge for the development of an attractive
commercial and residential units), which could further
residential development.
North and northwest Riyadh are becoming the prime
extend Riyadhs economic activity towards the west.
The area surrounding the Subject Site is characterised
focus of many developers and landowners, thus quick
by mostly low population density neighbourhoods
development of the site will increase future potential
which may induce demand for a potential commercial
demand opportunities.
The envisaged development should seek to increase
development.
The proximity of Wadi Hanifa and the excellent
footfall in the surrounding area as the natural (i.e.
connectivity of the Subject Site provide opportunities
population and urban) growth of the city is primarily
for suburban community developments such as
concentrated in the north.
residential compounds and semi gated communities.
Source:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
16 of 109
FINAL
COMPETITIVE REVIEW
The purpose of this section is to provide an in-depth assessment of west Riyadhs
Urban Land Development. This includes master planned communities (under
development and completed) and land subdivision (traditionally subdivided land).
2
4
3
2
3
4
Number
Masterplan Name
Masterplan 7
1,290,000
Masterplan 4
6,200,000
Masterplan No. 6
1,230,000
Masterplan No. 5
4,280,500
To further understand the nature and success factors of each of the above
mentioned masterplans, Colliers evaluated the masterplans separately through the
following case studies:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
17 of 109
FINAL
4.1
LABAN 7
Masterplan No. 7 is located in Al
Ahmadiyah District of west Riyadh. The
masterplan consists of primarily
residential developments (villas and
apartments) while a limited number of
commercial developments (mostly line
shops) are situated on the major roads.
Masterplan No. 7 is located
approximately 1.7 km south of the
Subject Site.
The following exhibit summarizes the features of Masterplan No. 7:
Exhibit 11: Masterplan Configuration
Land Subdivision Configuration
Land Size (Sqm)
c.1,290,000
Target Segment
Mid Income
developed.
61.5
793,350
No. of Superblocks
81
32,850
5,750
9,750
20
400
900
G+3
1,850
2,200
3,350
2,700
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
18 of 109
FINAL
4.2
DHARAT LABAN 4
Masterplan No. 4 is located in the Dharat
Laban District of west Riyadh and is
situated adjacently to parcels A and B of
the Subject Site. The masterplan is one of
the largest in Dharat Laban and comprise
a variety of residential and commercial
developments. The typical residential
developments within the masterplan are
villas targeting the middle and upper mid
income classes. Western Ring Road passes through the masterplan.
The following exhibit summarizes the features of Masterplan No. 4:
Exhibit 12: Masterplan Configuration
Land Subdivision Configuration
Land Size (Sqm)
6,200,000
Target Segment
Middle Income t
60
No. of Superblocks
310
3,720,000
38,800
3,200
10,250
20
600
900
N/A
1,000
1.500
2,250
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
N/A
19 of 109
FINAL
4.3
LABAN 6
Masterplan No.6 is located in Al Ahmadiyah
District of west Riyadh and is situated
adjacently to parcel C of the Subject Site.
The masterplan comprise a variety of villas
and apartments alongside commercial
developments (primarily line shops) along
30m wide roads.
The following exhibit summarizes the
features of Masterplan No. 6:
Exhibit 13: Masterplan Configuration
Land Subdivision Configuration
Land Size (Sqm)
1,230,000
Target Segment
Middle Income
62.2
No. of Superblocks
65
765,060
28,000
2,800
8,600
20
400
900
G+3
1,850
2,200
3,350
2,700
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
20 of 109
FINAL
4.4
LABAN 5
Masterplan No. 5 is located in the Dharat
Laban District of west Riyadh, and is
adjacently situated to Masterplan No. 4. The
masterplan mostly constitute of villas that
target the middle and upper mid income
classes. Al Riyadh Football Club is known as
Masterplan No. 5s unique development.
The following exhibit summarizes the features
of Masterplan No. 5:
Exhibit 14: Masterplan Configuration
Land Subdivision Configuration
Land Size (Sqm)
4,280,500
Target Segment
Upper Mid
61
No. of Superblocks
163
2,611,105
39,900
4,100
7,800
20
600
900
N/A
1,000
1.500
2,250
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
N/A
21 of 109
FINAL
4.5
Location
Accessibility
Level of Competition
Masterplan No. 7
Masterplan No. 4
Masterplan No. 6
Masterplan No. 5
Legend
Above
Average
Below
Average
Average
Masterplan No. 7
Masterplan No. 4
Masterplan No. 6
Masterplan No. 5
1,290,000
6,200,000
1,230,000
4,280,500
Target Segment
Upper Mid
Low Income
Upper Mid
Low Income
61.5
60
62.2
61
38.5
40
37.8
39
81
310
65
163
9,750
10,250
8,600
7,800
20
20
20
20
793,350
3,720,000
765,060
2,611,105
400
600
400
600
900
900
900
900
1,850
1,000
1,850
1,000
2,200
1,500
2,200
1,500
3,350
N/A
3,350
N/A
2,700
2,250
2,700
2,250
No. Blocks
Typical Size of Block (Sqm)
Typical Road Width (M)
Sellable Land (Sqm)
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
22 of 109
FINAL
Nearly 43% of the total land area is designated for civic facilities and amenities
such as roads, pedestrian walkways, mosques and public gardens.
Based on results from the research sample, plot sizes of villa residential offerings
in west Riyadh are significantly larger than those in north Riyadh and range from
400 to 600 sqm per plot.
Land prices are much lower in west Riyadh than in north Riyadh. Masterplans 4
and 5 have an average residential land price of SAR 1,000/Sqm while
Masterplan 6 and 7 show an average price of SAR 1,850/Sqm.
4.6
Demand for upper mid and high-end residential units is high in the northern and
north-western parts of Riyadh where more of the recent/upcoming masterplan
communities and land subdivision are located.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
23 of 109
FINAL
West Riyadh has seen slower growth when compared to north Riyadh. North
Riyadhs success in attracting high real estate activity is primarily due to the
good road network that links the area to central, west and east Riyadh and major
upcoming developments within the area (such as Rafal Tower, KAFD etc.)
communities is the continuous increases in land prices. Zoning policies are not
very clear and can indirectly generate land price increases; hence fewer
margins can be achieved by master-developers.
Demand momentum on housing units within master planned communities
Financial institutions and banks are reluctant to offer full financing resources to
these projects due to landowners/master-developers inflated land prices, low
equity contributions, and excessive reliance on off-plan sales.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
24 of 109
FINAL
DEVELOPMENT CONCEPT
5.1
surrounding land-uses
Consists of commercial and residential land-uses with clear
pattern
Does not comprise a district centre, and is less compact
services
Children's play grounds are conveniently located throughout
the neighbourhood
Interconnected road network designed for efficiency
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
25 of 109
FINAL
The following exhibit indicates the development concept for each of the Subject
Sites land parcels on a macro level:
Exhibit 18: Development Recommendations and Rationale
Parcel
Development Recommendation
Rationale
Parcel A
Colliers envisages this parcel to serve the retail needs of the surrounding
districts due to its excellent accessibility compared to the other parcels.
The retail component envisaged is in the form of neighbourhood box stores
which will serve the households in the surrounding area as it is an
upcoming location. These households will require a neighbourhood store in
the foreseeable future as the resident population grows. Since the land
size of Parcel A will not be able to completely cater to retail components
(land size greater than 250,000 Sqm) the remaining land can be developed
with relevant apartment block infrastructure and sold as blocks and/or
superblocks, consistent with the surrounding area.
Parcel B
Parcel C
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
26 of 109
FINAL
5.2
PARCEL A
Parcel A could serve the retail needs of the surrounding districts given its excellent
accessibility, size, and shape. Parcel A is located within close proximity to exits of
Makkah Road and Western Ring Road. The following exhibit provides a depiction
of the indicative land use strategy of Parcel A:
Exhibit 19: Indicative Land Use Strategy for Different Options
Exit/Entry Point
Exit/Entry Point
Retail Use
Area: c.60,000-80,000
The retail use of Parcel A can vary depending upon the choice of the developer but
Colliers envisages the following retail developments to have good market potential
within Parcel A:
Exhibit 20: Exemplary Retail Developments for Parcel A
Retail Use
Example
Euromarche
40,000-60,000
40,000-60,000
100,000-350,000
Centrepoint/Hyper Panda
30,000-50,000
Retail Souq
40,000-60,000
Wholesale Market
50,000-70,000
20,000-40,000
Stand-alone Showrooms
15,000-60,000
Neighbourhood Centre
Outlet Mall
Cultural Fair Grounds
Big Box Stores
Anchor stores could include names such as Centrepoint, Furniture Stores, and
Extra.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
27 of 109
FINAL
Large grocery stores could include names such as Hyper Panda, Euromarche,
Othaim, and Lulu Hypermarket.
The neighbourhood centre could offer small F&B outlets such as Baskin
Robbins, Dunkin Donuts, KFC, Mc Donalds, and Kudu.
It is recommended that the Client secure a buyer for the retail component in the
early stage of the project development. This will allow the Client to better
understand the area size requirement of the developer and whether raw land is
preferred over developed land. Given the large size of the retail component, it is
believed that raw land will be more attractive to a developer. Raw land also allows
added flexibility while subdividing the land according to the retail concept and
design.
Since the land size of Parcel A will not be able to completely cater to retail
components (land size greater than 250,000 Sqm) the remaining land can be
developed with relevant infrastructure and sold as blocks and/or superblocks. The
end product for these land parcels would be apartment blocks, which is consistent
with the land use of the surrounding area and the recommended retail use. The
following exhibit provides snapshots of apartment developments in Dhahrat Laban:
Exhibit 21: Apartment Developments in Dhahrat Laban
Villa developments on Parcel A will not be in demand given the parcels closeness
to retail developments. Given the heavy traffic and high footfall of areas with retail
developments, a mid to high density final dwelling product is more suitable for the
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
28 of 109
FINAL
parcel. The commercial component will also be limited as most of the commercial
needs of the surrounding area (immediate, and to a certain extent, west Riyadh)
would be met by the retail component. The following exhibit provides an indicative
land use strategy for Parcel A:
Exhibit 22: Indicative Land Use Strategy for Parcel A
Factor
Description
Land Size
250,922
Retail Use
70,000
180,922
37
113,981
Residential
70
79,787
Residential Product
Apartments
Target Segment
Low Income
750
No. of Plots
106
Building Height
G+2-3F
Residential and/or Commercial
30
34,194
900
Building Height
G+3F
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
29 of 109
FINAL
5.3
PARCEL B
Parcel B can be developed by taking the surrounding area into consideration. This
has been the case with Masterplan No. 4 and Masterplan No. 5 as identified in the
Competitive Review Section. The following exhibit illustrates an indicative land use
strategy for Parcel B:
Exhibit 23: Indicative Land Use Strategy for Parcel B
Source:
Residential plots in Dhahrat Laban (Masterplan No. 4 and Masterplan No. 5) are
one of the largest in Riyadh. This is due to the low cost of land in the area and its
targeted segments affordability and preferences. The area has attracted buyers
who are willing to compromise on location (instead of north and northwest Riyadh)
in exchange for larger sized residential plots. The following exhibit illustrates the
residential characteristics of Dhahrat Laban:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
30 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 25: Dhahrat Laban Residential Characteristics
Factor
Value
2,230
1,000
G+1.5F
G+2-3F
Source:
It is important for the development on Parcel B to suit the needs of the surrounding
area and its targeted segment of low to mid income households. The following
exhibit illustrates Colliers land use strategy for Parcel B:
Exhibit 26: Indicative Land Use Strategy for Parcel B
Factor
Description
Land Size
200,059
35
130,038
Residential
60
78,023
Residential Product
Villas
Target Segment
600
No. of Plots
130
Building Height
G+1.5F
Residential and/or Commercial
40
52,015
900
Building Height
G+2-3F
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
31 of 109
FINAL
5.4
PARCEL C
Due to the large land size of Parcel C and its attractive location, a mix of residential
concepts could be developed on the land. Colliers recommendations are:
1 Typical serviced plots for sale
2 Large mixed use superblock for coherent development
3 Semi gated community
4 Gated community
5.4.1
20 m
25 m
12 m
20 m
Masterplan No. 7
Typical Plot Size: 400 Sqm
North Riyadh
Typical Plot Size: 300 Sqm
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
32 of 109
FINAL
The following exhibit illustrates the development concept for the serviced plots
within Parcel C:
Exhibit 28: Typical Land Subdivision Characteristics
Factor
Surrounding Area
Subject Development
Residential
Type
Villas
Villas
Road Width
15 M
18 M
400 Sqm
400 Sqm
G+1.5F
G+1.5F
30 M
30 M
900 Sqm
600 Sqm
G+2-3F
G+2-3F
Road Width
Average Plot Size
Building Height
Sources: Colliers Research, 2012
Colliers Recommendation, 2012
Wider roads with internal green spaces could be offered by the subject
development to differentiate the development from the surrounding area. The
large plot sizes recommended for the subject development also require wider
roads to be used as parking for visitors and residents extra vehicles.
Small commercial plots may aid in absorption, while two adjacent small size plots
can be combined into a sizable commercial plot (i.e. 1,200 sqm).
5.4.2
5.4.3
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
33 of 109
FINAL
gated community is its security provisions which help to foster a greater sense of
community.
Semi-gated communities are rare in the Kingdom, with merely two such
communities in Riyadh, both of which are developed by Rafal. Blncyay was the first
semi-gated community in Riyadh, which was completed and sold out by 2010. Al
Rabia Community is the second, which is expected to be completed by the second
quarter of 2013. The following exhibit provides snapshots of Blncyah and Al Rabia:
Exhibit 29: Snapshots of Blncyah and Al Rabia Communities
Blncyah
Al Rabia
Blncyah has a limited number of large units with an average sale price between
SAR 3 mn - SAR 3.5 mn, whilst the remaining are sold at an average of SAR 1.5
mn - SAR 1.8 mn.
The more affordable units were sold during the projects shell and core phase,
while the more expensive units were sold post-completion, at largely discounted
rates.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
34 of 109
FINAL
Blncyah and Al Rabia are expected to have an average of 2 cars per unit and
their buyers have an estimated age of 41 years.
Blncyah
Source:
Al Rabia Community
Status: Under Construction
Land Area: 120,000 Sqm
No. of Units: 224
Average Plot Size: c.300 Sqm
Typical Road Width: 15 m
Al Rabia Community
Roads within the communities are wider than that of typical masterplans.
Blncyahs side roads and internal roads are 20m and 15m wide, respectively.
Whereas Al Rabia side roads and internal roads are 15m and 12 m wide,
respectively.
Both communities have one single entrance, which has 24/7 security.
Both communities have provision for civic facilities such as mosque and
community centres, while Al Rabia also offers a liner garden.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
35 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 31: Semi Gated Community Characteristics
Factor
Subject Development
Villas
Villas
Road Width
15 20 M
15 - 20 M
300 Sqm
300 Sqm
G+1.5F
G+1.5F
Type
Building Height
5.4.4
close to the major highway intersection of Makkah Road and Western Ring Road
surrounding land use comprise high end palaces which gives the area a high
level of security
frontage on Wadi Hanifa which secludes one side of the site, thereby resulting in
higher security
Residential compounds require large land areas capable of offering green spaces
and community facilities (swimming pools, banquet halls, gym, etc.). The following
exhibit lists the number of units within Riyadhs high end compounds along with
their land area and density:
Exhibit 32: Riyadh Compounds Land Area and Densities
Compound Name
Total No. of
Units
210
403,200
168
270,000
427
227,000
19
Sedar Village
250
220,800
11
Hamra Compound
404
220,000
18
Eid Compound
315
200,000
16
271
164,000
17
316
108,000
29
185
73,100
25
98
40,330
24
264
192,643
17
Average
Source: Colliers Research, 2012
Density
(Du/Ha)
Al Yamamah Village - 2
Al Wadi Compound -1
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
36 of 109
FINAL
High end compounds in Riyadh have large land areas with a high portion of space
dedicated towards greenery and community facilities. Out of the 29 facilities and
amenities within the compound sample, 13 widely used featured are considered
basic compound offerings that is necessary for the premium that is placed on
compounds over regular residential developments. The most common facilities and
amenities found in the research sample are full/Olympic size swimming pools and
recreation centres with basic lounges and facilities such as gyms and sports courts.
The least common facilities are golf courses, boutique stores, theatres and
housekeeping services.
Exhibit 33: Most Common Compound Facilities & Amenities
120%
100% 100%
100%
82%
73%
64%
45%
45%
45%
45%
45%
Bowling
Arcade Centre
Playgrounds
55%
60%
82%
73%
80%
40%
Restaurant
Supermarket
Tennis court
Basketball Court
Squash Court
Gym / Recreation
Transport Services
0%
Swimming Pool
20%
The following chart details the extra facilities and amenities found in the researched
comparable sample. These facilities are not necessary to the success of a
compound but provide the development with a competitive edge.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
37 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 34: Extra Compound Facilities & Amenities
100%
80%
60%
40%
36%
36%
27%
36% 36%
27%
27%
18%
20%
27%
18%
18%
9%
9%
18%
9%
9%
BBQ Area
Medical Clinic
Theatre
Soccer
Coffee Shop
Golf Course
Volleyball Court
Travel Agency
Boutique
Gift shop
Hairdressers / Barber
Laundry
Function Hall
Pre-School / Nursery
0%
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
38 of 109
FINAL
development of a residential compound due to its attractive location. The sale
could increase the absorption rate of Parcel C, thereby resulting in a higher return
for the overall development.
5.4.5
CONCLUSION
Parcel C can be subdivided into three major development offerings:
5 conventional/typical land subdivision
6 mixed use superblock
7 a portion of parcel C could be sold to a developer for the development of a
semi-gated community
8 a portion of parcel C could be sold to a developer for the development of a
gated community
The following exhibit illustrates the land use strategy of parcel C:
Exhibit 36: Indicative Land Use Strategy for Different Options
Colliers conducted a financial analysis on the above mentioned options and found
no major difference (i.e. gain or loss) between the recommended options and that
of typical land subdivision for the whole parcel. Nevertheless, the provision of gated
and semi-gated community will lower the financial risk of the development. The
following exhibit provides an indicative land use strategy for Parcel C:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
39 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 37: Indicative Land Use Strategy for Parcel C
Factor
Description
Land Size
910,925
40%
546,555
Commercial Area
109,311
Residential Area
437,244
Target Segment
400
No. of Plots
1,093
900
5.5
The Subject
Weighting
100%
100%
100%
100%
Total
Current Average Price (SAR/m2)
100%
100%
The likhood %
Estimated Rate
PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
100%
Site Accessibility
PROPOSED
DEVELOPMENT
(Must be 100%)
40 of 109
FINAL
1 Comparable criteria forming the basis of the sale prices are:
Proximity of Subject Site to Riyadh City Boundaries: Location is
considered one of the most important factors in assessing the comparative set
as it is a primary determinant for prospective tenants.
Proximity of Subject Site to City Centre & CBDs: Proximity to the city
residential tenants.
Proximity of Subject Site to Social/Civic Services: Proximity to restaurants,
commercial area are highly dependent on the level of footfall surrounding the
Subject Site. Active foot within the surrounding area of the site is extremely
important for commercial developments.
2 Weighting for each comparable criterion is derived from local and international
real estate pricing strategies, and differs by asset class (e.g. land, office tower
and retail mall).
3 Weighting is allocated to each assessment criteria by comparable development.
4 The subject development is given a score of 100% and is compared to each
competing developments based on the designated criteria. For example, if the
location of comparable 1 is better than that of the subject development, then the
score for comparable 1 would be less than 100%.
5 Current asking/bidding price for comparable developments.
6 The sale price of the proposed development is derived in two stages: Stage 1
involves multiplying the overall score of a comparable by its sale prices in order
to arrive at the market value of the comparable. Stage 2 (likelihood) involves
allocating a weight to the competitiveness of the subject development with the
relative comparable. The sale price is then derived by multiplying the outputs of
stage 1 and stage 2.
Colliers pricing strategy for the development concept of parcels A, B and C are
illustrated below:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
41 of 109
FINAL
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
PARCEL A & B
Exhibit 39: Residential Plots Pricing Strategy (A & B)
Weighting
No. 4
No. 5
Subject
Development
Weighting
No. 4
No. 5
Subject
Development
30%
120.0%
125.0%
100%
30%
105.0%
115.0%
100%
Location in Relation to
City Centre & CBDs
10%
120.0%
125.0%
100%
Location in Relation to
City Centre & CBDs
10%
105.0%
115.0%
100%
Site Accessibility
20%
120.0%
130.0%
100%
Site Accessibility
20%
105.0%
115.0%
100%
Location in Relation to
Social/ Civic Services
15%
110.0%
125.0%
100%
Location in Relation to
Social/ Civic Services
15%
105.0%
120.0%
100%
Surrounding
Neighborhood Profile
25%
100.0%
100.0%
100%
25%
100.0%
100.0%
100%
100.0%
113.5%
119.8%
Estimated Rate
100.0%
103.8%
112.0%
Estimated Rate
1,000
1,000
1,500
1,500
Proposed development
1,135
1,198
Proposed development
1,556
1,680
50.0%
50.0%
50.0%
50.0%
Comparable Criteria
42 of 109
Total
The likelihood %
Source: Colliers Research, 2012
1,166
Comparable Criteria
Total
The likelihood %
1,618
FINAL
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
PARCEL C
Exhibit 41: Residential Plots Pricing Strategy (C)
Comparable Criteria
Weighting
No. 6
No. 7
Subject
Development
Comparable Criteria
Weighting
No. 6
No. 7
Subject
Development
43 of 109
30%
105.0%
115.0%
100%
30%
100.0%
105.0%
100%
Location in Relation to
City Centre & CBDs
10%
105.0%
115.0%
100%
Location in Relation to
City Centre & CBDs
10%
100.0%
105.0%
100%
Site Accessibility
20%
110.0%
120.0%
100%
Site Accessibility
20%
100.0%
105.0%
100%
Location in Relation to
Social/ Civic Services
15%
100.0%
100.0%
100%
Location in Relation to
Social/ Civic Services
15%
100.0%
100.0%
100%
Surrounding
Neighborhood Profile
25%
100.0%
100.0%
100%
25%
100.0%
100.0%
100%
100.0%
104.0%
110.0%
Estimated Rate
100.0%
100.0%
103.0%
Estimated Rate
1,850
1,850
2,200
2,200
Proposed development
1,924
2,035
Proposed development
2,200
2,266
50.0%
50.0%
50.0%
50.0%
Total
The likelihood %
Source: Colliers Research, 2012
1,980
Total
The likelihood %
2,233
FINAL
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
SCENARIO A
6.1
Scenario A assumes that the Client will develop the infrastructure of parcels A, B,
and C together in year 1. Colliers believes that sellable plots within this option will
likely be sold over a project life of 13 quarters.
6.1.1
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
Q6
Q7
Q8
Q9
Q10
Q11
Q12
Q13
100%
25%
25%
25%
25%
Infrastructure Cost
6.1.2
AREA SCHEDULES
The following exhibit provides the area schedule for the entire development:
Exhibit 44: Area Schedule by Parcel
Description
Total Area (Sqm)
6.1.3
Parcel A
Parcel B
Parcel C
250,922
200,059
910,925
37
35
40
63
65
60
REVENUE ASSUMPTIONS
Colliers undertook detailed demand/supply estimation for Riyadhs serviced
residential plots. Based on the results of this analysis, Colliers proposes the
following absorption for the serviced residential plots within the subject
development:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
44 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 45: Absorption of Serviced Residential Plots by Type
No. Of Plots
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
Q6
Q7
Q8
Q9
Q10
Q11
Q12
Q13
3,951
3,979
4,007
4,035
4,063
4,092
4,120
4,149
4,178
4,207
4,237
4,266
4,296
30
31
31
14
106
106
106
106
76
45
14
3,951
3,979
4,007
4,035
4,063
4,092
4,120
4,149
4,178
4,207
4,237
4,266
4,296
30
31
31
31
130
130
130
130
100
69
38
1,021
1,028
1,035
1,042
1,050
1,057
1,064
1,072
1,079
1,087
1,095
1,102
1,110
126
127
128
129
130
130
131
132
60
1,093
1,093
1,093
1,093
967
840
713
584
454
324
193
60
Parcel A
City Demand
Expected
Absorption
Balance Plots
Parcel B
City Demand
Expected
Absorption
Balance Plots
Parcel C
City Demand
Expected
Absorption
Balance Plots
Source:
Notes:
The following exhibit illustrates the absorption rate of serviced commercial plots
within the subject development:
Exhibit 46: Absorption of Serviced Commercial Plots by Type
Type
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
Q6
Q7
Q8
Q9
Q10
Q11
Q12
Q13
Parcel A Internal
Commercial
30%
30%
30%
10%
Parcel A Retail
Area
100%
Parcel B
30%
30%
30%
10%
Parcel C
30%
30%
30%
10%
Colliers assumed an annual revenue escalation rate of 3.5% for the sale price of
serviced plots (residential and commercial).
Parcel As retail block is expected to be sold in Q8. The large size of the land will
require appropriate marketing to achieve a financially attractive sale price. Colliers
estimates the block to achieve an estimated sale price of SAR 1,360/sqm, if sold
as raw land.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
45 of 109
FINAL
Based on these assumptions and the pricing strategy detailed in the previous
section of this report, the result of Collierss financial viability assessment on the
subject development are as follows:
Exhibit 47: Project Cash Flow and IRR Calculation (Consolidated)
In SAR (Millions)
Q1
Total Cash In
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
Q6
Q7
Q8
Q9
Q10
Q11
Q12
Q13
268
271
273
278
115
112
114
115
53
(1117)
(18)
(18)
(18)
(18)
(1135)
(18)
(18)
(18)
(1135)
(18)
(18)
(18)
268
271
273
278
115
112
114
115
53
Land
Infrastructure
Payback Period
IRR
Source:
Note:
Q9
19.51%
The project is estimated to achieve an IRR of 19.51% through the sale of serviced
plots over a project life of 13 quarters. The table below shows the impact on IRR by
changes in infrastructure cost and revenue (-20% to 20% in increments of 5%).
Exhibit 48 Sensitivity Analysis
Infrastructure Cost
% Change in
Variable
Source:
-20%
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
-20%
5.22%
5.03%
4.85%
4.66%
4.48%
4.29%
4.11%
3.93%
3.74%
-15%
9.10%
8.90%
8.71%
8.52%
8.33%
8.14%
7.95%
7.76%
7.57%
-10%
12.90%
12.71%
12.51%
12.31%
12.11%
11.92%
11.72%
11.53%
11.34%
-5%
16.65%
16.45%
16.25%
16.04%
15.84%
15.64%
15.44%
15.24%
15.04%
0%
20.35%
20.14%
19.93%
19.72%
19.51%
19.31%
19.10%
18.90%
18.69%
5%
23.99%
23.77%
23.56%
23.35%
23.13%
22.92%
22.71%
22.50%
22.29%
10%
27.58%
27.36%
27.14%
26.92%
26.71%
26.49%
26.27%
26.06%
25.84%
15%
31.13%
30.91%
30.68%
30.46%
30.24%
30.01%
29.79%
29.57%
29.35%
20%
34.64%
34.41%
34.18%
33.95%
33.72%
33.50%
33.27%
33.05%
32.82%
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
46 of 109
FINAL
SCENARIO B
6.2
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
Q6
Q7
Q8
Q9
Q10
Q11
Q12
Q13
Q14
Q15
100%
Infrastructure
Cost (Parcel A)
33%
33%
33%
Infrastructure
Cost (Parcel B)
33%
33%
33%
Infrastructure
Cost (Parcel C)
30%
30%
40%
6.2.2
AREA SCHEDULES
The following exhibit provides the area schedule for the entire development (similar
to Scenario A):
Exhibit 50: Area Schedule by Parcel
Description
Total Area (Sqm)
6.2.3
Parcel A
Parcel B
Parcel C
250,922
200,059
910,925
37
35
40
63
65
60
REVENUE ASSUMPTIONS
Based on detailed demand/supply analysis, Colliers proposes the following
absorption for the serviced residential plots within the subject development:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
47 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 51: Absorption of Serviced Residential Plots
No. Of
Plots
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
Q6
Q7
Q8
Q9
Q10
Q11
Q12
Q13
Q14
Q15
3,951
3,979
4,007
4,035
4,063
4,092
4,120
4,149
4,178
4,207
4,237
4,266
4,296
4,326
4,357
30
30
31
15
106
106
106
76
46
15
3,951
3,979
4,007
4,035
4,063
4,092
4,120
4,149
4,178
4,207
4,237
4,266
4,296
4,326
4,357
30
30
31
31
130
130
130
100
69
39
1,021
1,028
1,035
1,042
1,050
1,057
1,064
1,072
1,079
1,087
1,095
1,102
1,110
1,118
1,125
128
129
130
130
131
132
133
134
46
1,093
1,093
1,093
1,093
1,093
1,093
965
837
707
577
445
313
180
46
Parcel A
City
Demand
Expected
Absorption
Balance
Plots
Parcel B
City
Demand
Expected
Absorption
Balance
Plots
Parcel C
City
Demand
Expected
Absorption
Balance
Plots
Source:
Notes:
The following exhibit illustrates the absorption rate of serviced commercial plots
within the subject development:
Exhibit 52: Absorption of Serviced Commercial Plots by Type
Type
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
Q6
Q7
Q8
Q9
Q10
Q11
Q12
Q13
Parcel A Internal
Commercial
50%
50%
Parcel A Retail
Area
100%
Parcel B
30%
30%
40%
Parcel C
30%
30%
30%
10%
Source:
Colliers assumed an annual revenue escalation rate of 3.5% for the sale price of
serviced plots (residential and commercial).
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
48 of 109
FINAL
Parcel As retail block is expected to be sold as raw land in Q6 with an estimated
sale price of SAR 1,360/sqm.
Based on these assumptions and the pricing strategy detailed in the previous
section of this report, the result of Collierss financial viability assessment on the
subject development are as follows:
Exhibit 53: Project Cash flows and IRR Calculation (Consolidated)
Q1
Total Cash In
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
Q6
Q7
Q8
Q9
Q10
Q11
Q12
Q13
Q14
Q15
102
103
180
216
187
183
136
114
115
117
119
41
(1117)
(7)
(7)
(7)
(15)
(15)
(21)
(1124)
(7)
(7)
(15)
(15)
(21)
(1124)
(7)
(7)
87
87
159
216
187
183
136
114
115
117
119
41
Land
Infrastructure
Payback Period
IRR
Source:
Note:
Q11
17.43%
The project is estimated to achieve an IRR of 17.43% through the sale of serviced
plots over a project life of 15 quarters. The table below shows the impact on IRR
changes in infrastructure cost and revenue (-20% to 20% in increments of 5%).
Exhibit 54 Sensitivity Analysis
Infrastructure Cost
% Change in
Variable
Source:
-20%
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
-20%
4.99%
4.83%
4.66%
4.50%
4.34%
4.18%
4.02%
3.86%
3.70%
-15%
8.36%
8.20%
8.03%
7.87%
7.70%
7.54%
7.38%
7.22%
7.06%
-10%
11.67%
11.50%
11.34%
11.17%
11.00%
10.84%
10.67%
10.51%
10.34%
-5%
14.92%
14.75%
14.58%
14.41%
14.24%
14.07%
13.91%
13.74%
13.57%
0%
18.11%
17.94%
17.77%
17.60%
17.43%
17.26%
17.09%
16.92%
16.75%
5%
21.26%
21.08%
20.91%
20.74%
20.56%
20.39%
20.22%
20.04%
19.87%
10%
24.36%
24.18%
24.00%
23.83%
23.65%
23.48%
23.30%
23.13%
22.95%
15%
27.42%
27.24%
27.06%
26.88%
26.70%
26.52%
26.34%
26.17%
25.99%
20%
30.43%
30.25%
30.07%
29.89%
29.71%
29.53%
29.35%
29.17%
28.99%
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
49 of 109
FINAL
CONCLUSION
6.3
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q5
Q6
Q7
Q8
Q9
Q10
Q11
Q12
Q13
Q14
Q15
Scenario A 13 Quarters
Revenue
Cost
Equity Required SAR 87 Million
Scenario B 15 Quarters
Revenue
Cost
Equity Required SAR 42 Million
Source:
The difference between the two scenarios is the amount of equity the client has
to inject during the course of the project. Scenario A would require a higher
equity contribution as the infrastructure of the parcels is developed
simultaneously until Q4 after which the project revenues are realised.
The following table provides the consolidated financial analysis conclusion for both
scenarios:
Exhibit 56: Scenario A vs. Scenario B (Consolidated)
In SAR
Scenario A
Total Revenue
1,599,556,891
1,613,701,538
(1,116,762,920)
(1,116,762,920)
(71,723,749)
(72,483,080)
(1,188,486,669)
(1,189,246,000)
411,070,222
424,455,538
Q9
Q11
19.51%
17.43%
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
Scenario B
50 of 109
FINAL
SUMMARY CONCLUSION
SITE OUTLOOK
The Subject Site is well located at the intersection of Western Ring Road and
Makkah Road.
West of the Subject Site is mostly undeveloped while the east of the site is home
to a number of the citys important demand generators. This will induce demand
for the residential and commercial components of the subject development.
The Subject Sites direct frontage and visibility on two of Riyadhs major
thoroughfares will positively affect the residential and commercial components of
the subject development.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Parcels A and B can cater to the low-mid income class while parcel C can cater
to the upper mid income.
Colliers tested the financial viability of both the semi-gated/gated and traditional
subdivision concepts on parcel C and found no difference in financial returns.
However, the gated/semi-gated concept could lead to lower development risks
and higher attractiveness for the remaining subdivided plots.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
51 of 109
FINAL
LIMITATIONS OF THIS
REPORT
This Report has been prepared in accordance with the terms of contract (the
Contract) signed between Colliers International and The Investor for Securities
Co. (the Client).
This Report is provided solely for use by the Client in accordance with the terms
of reference set out in the Contract, and should be used for this purpose only.
This Report may not be copied, reproduced or distributed (in whole or in part)
nor may its contents be divulged by the Client other than in confidence to the
Clients professional advisers (Other Recipients) for the purpose of giving the
Client advice. The Client may disclose the Report to Other Recipients for
informational purposes only, following prior written consent by Colliers
International for which the approval will not be unreasonably withheld after
receiving a Hold Harmless Letter by the intended recipients. These readers
however will not be considered users of the Report. In addition, Colliers
International will require a written acknowledgement by the requesting party of
the terms of the release of the Report.
This Report has been delivered on the basis that you shall not quote our name;
or reproduce our logo in any form or medium without our prior written consent.
You may disclose the whole or part of the report to your legal and other
professional advisers for the purposes of your seeking advice in relation to this
Report, provided that when doing so you inform them that disclosure by them
(save for their own internal purposes) is not permitted without our prior written
consent, and to the fullest extent permitted by law Colliers International accepts
no responsibility or liability to them in connection with the Report.
This Report is not suitable to be relied on by any party wishing to acquire rights
against Colliers International (other than the beneficiaries) for any purpose or in
any context. Any party other than the beneficiaries that obtains access to this
Report or a copy of it and chooses to rely on this Report (or any part of it) does
so at its own risk. To the fullest extent permitted by law, Colliers International
does not assume any responsibility and will not accept any liability in respect of
this Report to any party other than the Client.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
52 of 109
FINAL
Nothing in this report constitutes a valuation or legal advice. This Report is not a
prospectus and does not constitute or form any part of an offer or invitation to
subscribe for, underwrite or purchase securities or any of the assets, business or
undertaking described herein, nor shall it or any part of it form the basis of, or be
relied upon, in any way in connection with any contract or investment decision
relating to any securities, assets, business or undertaking. Accordingly,
interested parties are advised to carry out their own due diligence, investigations
and analysis of any information contained or referred to herein or made available
to them at any stage.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
53 of 109
FINAL
APPENDICES
Supplemental Information
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
54 of 109
FINAL
SAUDI ARABIA
MACROECONOMIC
OVERVIEW
This section of the study presents a brief yet informative macroeconomic overview
of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA or the Kingdom) with critical analysis on
its geographical significance, key economic performance indicators, and
demographics. This analysis is important as the historical trends of major
macroeconomic variables provide insights to the future performance of the
economy. We have concluded the analysis by looking at the macro economic
impacts on the residential and home financing market as a whole.
1.1.1
GEOGRAPHY
With a land area of
approximately 2.15 million
square kilometres, Saudi
Arabia is the largest country
in the Middle East. The
country occupies nearly
80% of the Arabian
Peninsula and is the 14
th
ECONOMIC SNAPSHOT
The Kingdoms economy has historically been dominated by the oil-sector which is
a major source of government revenue, contributing on average nearly 51% of the
countrys GDP over the past five years. Saudi Arabia maintains 25% of the world's
proven petroleum reserves, leading it to rank as the largest exporter of petroleum
in the world.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
55 of 109
FINAL
In recent years, the Kingdom started to place considerable emphasis on the
diversification of its revenue mix to reduce the countrys exposure to international
oil price fluctuations.
The economic growth of the Kingdom received a substantial boost in the wake of a
public spending plan worth USD 130 billion (30% of the KSAs 2010 GDP)
announced by King Abdullah bin Abdulaziz in early 2011. The plan largely
benefitted the Kingdoms lower income population and included a significant pickup in social spending which drove increases in wages and unemployment benefits,
leading to a boost in private consumption. The plan also included a sizable housing
program that is expected to stimulate the construction sector.
The countrys economic growth increased further recently due to a raise in
domestic oil production, implemented to compensate for the supply interruptions in
Libya.
1.1.3
2011(E)
2012(F)
2013(F)
2014(F)
2,162.5
2,128.5
2,274.2
2,442.6
7.0
4.5
4.9
5.1
8.2
0.5
1.7
3.6
5.9
5.8
6.2
6.4
24.8
15.4
13.9
11.6
1.2
1.2
1.4
2.2
4.5
4.0
3.0
3.0
9.2
9.2
9.3
9.4
316.7
271.2
275.8
275.2
364.4
323.1
332.8
337.5
205.0
217.4
228.7
241.2
159.4
105.7
104.1
94.3
Source:
Notes:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
56 of 109
FINAL
infrastructure and industrial projects. The Kingdoms long term strategy is to ease
the countrys dependency on oil and gas revenues.
Exhibit 58: KSAs Real GDP Performance and Forecast (SAR Billions)
1500
1000
837
872
2009
2010
975
933
1023
1126
1075
1184
500
Source:
Notes:
5%
0%
2009
2010
2011E1
2013F2
2012F2
2014F2
2015F 2
-5%
KSA Real GDP Growth Rate
Source:
Notes:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
57 of 109
FINAL
The political unrest in Libya with the consequent damage to the countrys daily
crude oil production has resulted in further growth and oil export for the KSA.
This economic advantage will likely drive GDP growth; boost investor
confidence, and increase foreign direct investments in the Kingdom.
FISCAL BALANCE
In 2009, the KSA's fiscal balance slipped into deficit (SAR 87 billion, approximately
10% of the countrys GDP) for the first time since 2004 as a result of the turbulence
in the global oil market and higher than budgeted government expenditure. Despite
the 2009 fiscal deficit, the Saudi government continued to commit to its
development of the countrys infrastructure.
Year 2010 witnessed a sharp increase in oil prices which contributed to a 45%
increase in government revenues from 2009 to 2010. This trend continued through
2011, resulting in a budget surplus of approximately SAR 331 billion. In the coming
years, government spending will primarily focus on education, healthcare and
infrastructure, thus continuing the existing trends which bode well for the real
estate and construction sectors. These stimulatory budgets ensure that
government spending will continue to play a highly supportive role in the economy.
Exhibit 60: Government Revenue and Expenditure (SAR Billions)
1600
1252
1243
1200
1105
1014 996
981
1111
10531082
1166
902
794
740
800
596
626
510
400
0
2009
2010
2011E
2012F
Government Revenues
Source:
Notes:
2013F
2014F
2015F
2016F
Government Expenditures
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
58 of 109
FINAL
infrastructure developments related to education and transportation. A large
number of existing infrastructure facilities is also being upgraded.
Exhibit 61: Gross Fixed Investment in Saudi Arabia (SAR Billions)
800
713
639
578
600
517
472
400
360
384
2009
2010
427
200
Source:
Notes:
2016F 2
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
59 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 62: SIBOR & Federal Funds Rate
6.00%
5.00%
5.22%
4.91%
4.00%
3.00%
2.99%
3.28%
2.00%
0.91%
1.00%
0.74%
0.74%
0.69%
0.36%
0.00%
2007
2008
2009
2010
0.30%
2011
SAMA, 2011
The SIBOR is relatively lower than the EIBOR (Emirates Interbank Offered Rate),
with a difference of approximately 90 bps in June 2011 (SIBOR was 0.66% and
EIBOR was 1.56%). To a certain extent, this justifies the low APR (Average
Percentage Rate) of home financing in Saudi Arabia compared with the APR of
home financing in the United Arab Emirates, standing at an average of 3.49% and
5.49% respectively. Additionally, the APR for home financing in Saudi Arabia is
comparatively lower than those found in Egypt and Turkey, standing at 3.49%,
8.70% and 4.20% respectively.
THE BANKING SECTORS CONTRIBUTION TO THE CONSTRUCTION AND
REAL ESTATE SECTOR
A preliminary estimate of the Saudi Arabian Monetary Agency (SAMA) in 2011
indicates that the banking sectors contribution of corporate and consumer loans to
the real estate and construction sectors comprise approximately 4.0% of the
countrys GDP in 2010.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
60 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 63: Banks Loans to Private sector for Buildings and Construction
7.6%
60
7.3%
7.3%
7.0%
8.0%
7.2%
7.0%
6.1%
50
6.0%
40
2007
44.74
4.0%
3.0%
23.01
14.13
2006
17.86
13.69
2005
14.91
43.43
37.85
13.65
10
31.72
20
54.37
30
55.64
5.0%
2.0%
1.0%
0.0%
2008
2009
2010
It should be noted that there is an apparent growth within the real estate consumer
loan segment. However, as compared to overall loans towards real estate, this
percentage is still very low. Based on the capitalization calculation of private sector
loan value/nominal GDP, KSA is ranked as one of the least leveraged countries in
the GCC. This situation tends to improve with the passing of the mortgage law
which is expected to remove these impediments.
DEMOGRAPHIC ANALYSIS
The KSA has the largest and fastest growing population amongst the GCC
countries. The Central Department of Statistics and Information (CDSI) estimates
the KSAs total population to reach 31.9 million by 2016, of which 22.8 million will
be Saudi nationals. The growing population, coupled with rising average income,
will continue to feed demand for infrastructure and services, particularly in energy,
water, telecom and information technology, housing, health, education, and
financial services.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
61 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 64: Saudi Arabia Population Growth and Forecast (Millions)
36
9.1
27
8.1
8.5
7.9
8.3
7.6
18.7
19.2
19.8
20.3
20.8
2009
2010
8.7
8.9
21.7
22.2
18
22.8
0
2011E 1
2012F
2013F 2
Saudi Nationals
Source:
Notes:
2014F 2
2015F
2016F 2
Non Saudis
The increasing young population is a key driver of local real estate demand and will
be a major force driving the change in KSAs average household size. The
expatriate population is also a key determinant of aggregate demand in the KSA.
However, expatriates tend to remit a substantial portion of their earnings back to
their countries of origin, putting pressure on the KSAs current account balance.
SAMA reported that expatriate workers remittance increased by 84% from 2005 to
2009, reaching SAR 4.5 billion annually. Despite their propensity to remit, the
expatriate population will continue to contribute to demand across all economic
sectors over the coming years.
Expatriate contribution to the KSA may be influenced by the recent introduction of
the Saudization program, an initiative that obliges foreign companies operating in
Saudi Arabia to employ more Saudi nationals.
INCOME AND HOUSEHOLD SIZE
As population growth is one of
the most important
determinants of demand, its
growth patterns are essential to
the future trends of housing
demand.
According to the latest available statistics, the population in Saudi Arabia has
1
increased with a CAGR of 3.04% from 2004 till 2010 . This growth, coupled with a
reduced household size, led to an increase in the number of households, which is
expected to drive demand for both housing units and home financing options.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
CDSI
62 of 109
FINAL
The following exhibit provides the estimated population of Saudi Arabia, alongside
the estimated households and household sizes that will form the basis of the
analysis in later sections of the report:
Exhibit 65: Population and No. Of Households Estimate (Kingdom wide)
2012
Population
2014
2015
2016
2017
28,811,062
29,686,918
30,589,401
31,519,318
32,477,506
33,464,822
5.85
5.80
5.75
5.70
5.65
5.60
4,924,968
5,118,434
5,319,896
5,529,705
5,748,231
5,975,861
Household Size
No. of Households
2013
Another important aspect is the household income for both Saudi and Non Saudi
residents. Keeping in view the current practices of the home financing market,
household income is a primary factor considered by banks and other financial
companies while granting a loan. This is due to the fact that household income is
currently the only guarantee available for banks (until the passage of the mortgage
law). The following exhibit depicts household income of Saudis and Non Saudis
(Kingdom wide):
Exhibit 66: Monthly Household Income (Kingdom wide)
Income (SAR/Month)
Income Distribution
Saudis
Non Saudis
13.02%
1.59%
12,000 - 15,000
9.44%
2.13%
9,000 - 12,000
15.09%
3.94%
6,000 - 9,000
26.98%
14.98%
1,501 - 6,000
34.67%
72.9%
0.8%
4.46%
HSS, 2011
Colliers, 2012
The SAR 1,501 SAR 6,000 (34.67%) and the SAR 6,000 SAR 9,000 (26.98%)
monthly income groups are dominant for both Saudis and non Saudis.
LABOUR FORCE AND EMPLOYMENT
Since 2009, the majority of the labour force in Saudi Arabia has consisted in nonSaudis, with Saudi nationals forming only 47% of the countrys labour force.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
63 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 67: KSA Labour Force by Nationality and Gender - 2009
Employed
Male
Nationality
Unemployed
Female
Male
Female
Labour Force
Saudis
3,332,628
505,340
248,162
200,385
4,286,515
Non-Saudis
3,736,810
573,214
10,380
4,082
4,324,486
Total
7,069,438
1,078,554
258,542
204,467
8,611,001
Source:
3.0
Economical
2.0
1.0
-
Legal
Social
Technological
PESTLE Score (out of 5)
Source: Colliers Analysis, 2012
The PESTLE Analysis for Saudi Arabia accounts for the following factors:
Political
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
Stable government.
64 of 109
FINAL
Political density in the region due to religious significance and oil wealth.
Strong ties with Western powers and active foreign policies focussed on
promoting regional stability.
Economics
The largest economy in the Middle East with a focus on diversifying the revenue
base of the country.
The Saudi Riyals peg to the US Dollar provides the KSA with relative monetary
stability.
Social
Large increases in salaries and benefits for Saudi citizens announced by the
government have a direct effect on consumers spending power.
Technological
Large foreign direct investments in the telecom sector provide the country with
greater connectivity and growth of social media.
The KSAs primary source of law, the Islamic Sharia, is derived from the
teachings of the Quran and Sunnah.
Royal decrees are other main sources of law but are referred to as regulations
rather than laws because they are subordinates to the Sharia.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
65 of 109
FINAL
1.1.5
The growing population implies rising demand for residential real estate within
the Kingdom.
The inflation rate was sustained over the latest fiscal year and will remain within
the same levels as per governmental estimates. These marginal fluctuations in
inflation rates are unlikely to adversely affect the residential and home financing
markets.
The improving employment rate will likely impact purchasing power positively,
and consequently create higher demand for the residential market.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
66 of 109
FINAL
MICROECONOMIC ANALYSIS
Riyadh is one of the most important administrative areas in the Kingdom of Saudi
Arabia, with a land area of approximately 1,000 sq kmequivalent to 17% of
Kingdoms total land. The city is the political and economic capital of the Kingdom,
and is home to most of the countrys government departments, embassies, banks
and major companies. Three integrated industrial estates are located in Riyadh:
Riyadh First Industrial Estates, Riyadh Second Industrial Estates and Sudair
Industrial Estates.
2.1
encompassing 15
municipalities, in addition to
the Diplomatic Quarter. The
North-Western outskirts of
Riyadh comprise the ruins
of the former Saudi capital,
Duryea. Riyadh is the
second largest province in
terms of area after the
Eastern Province.
2.2
High population growth rates
fuel demand for housing units,
which in turn raise demand for
home finance.
DEMOGRAPHIC OVERVIEW
According to demographic statistics, Riyadh had a population of 4,138,329 in 2004,
with 65% Saudis and 35% non-Saudis. Statistics released by the Central
Department of Statistics and Information (CDSI) in 2010 showed a population of
5,254,560 in Riyadh, which was expected to reach 5,467,913 by 2011. Riyadh has
one of the highest Cumulative Annual Growth Rates (CAGR) in the Kingdom
standing at 4.06% between 2004 and 2010.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
67 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 69: Riyadh City Population Growth
3,500,000
3,000,000
500,000
2,188,754
3,279,159
2,103,351
1,391,787
1,000,000
3,032,632
1,500,000
1,447,495
2,690,834
2,000,000
3,151,209
2,500,000
0
2004
2007 *(e)
Saudis
Source:
Note:
2.2.1
2010
2011 *(e)
Non Saudis
2007*(e)
Females
Males
2010
Females
Males
2011*(e)
Females
Males
Females
1,393,080
1,297,754
1,538,639
1,493,992
1,645,060
1,506,149
1,711,855
1,567,304
994,793
452,702
970,170
421,618
1,460,578
642,773
1,519,882
668,872
2,387,873
1,750,456
2,508,809
1,915,610
3,105,638
2,148,922
3,231,737
2,236,175
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
68 of 109
FINAL
2.2.2
Saudis
Males
Females
Males
Total
% of Total
Females
0-14
631,672
582,995
205,876
198,983
1,619,526
29.6%
15-34
652,202
599,113
584,689
273,218
2,109,222
38.6%
35-64
380,177
342,098
721,699
192,997
1,636,971
29.9%
47,804
43,099
7,619
3,673
102,195
1.9%
1,711,855
1,567,304
1,519,882
668,872
5,467,914
100%
65+
Total
Source:
2.2.3
Non-Saudis
IPSOS, 2009
Colliers Estimates, 2012
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
69 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 72: Riyadh Population Distribution by District, Social Grade & Households
Name
Population *(e)
% of Distribution
Social Grade
Al Andalos
41,581
0.76%
6,788
Al Worod
40,158
0.73%
6,556
Al Aqeeq
27,873
0.51%
4,550
Al Mohamdeyah
21,315
0.39%
3,479
Al Taeawen
19,861
0.36%
3,242
Ishbeleyah
17,088
0.31%
2,789
Al Rahmaneyah
16,315
0.30%
2,663
Al Nafel
15,745
0.29%
2,570
Al Nakheel
15,517
0.28%
2,533
Al Khozamah
12,959
0.24%
2,115
Al Waha
12,142
0.22%
1,982
175,837
3.22%
28,704
Al Rowdah
117,941
2.16%
19,253
Al Nahda
99,324
1.82%
16,214
Al Malaz
88,908
1.63%
14,514
Al Nadeem
85,175
1.56%
13,904
Al Rabwah
84,130
1.54%
13,733
Al Naseem
373,742
6.84%
61,010
Al Orija
212,161
3.88%
34,634
Al Swedi
170,592
3.12%
27,848
Towaeq
141,868
2.59%
23,159
Manfoha
127,519
2.33%
20,816
Al Orija Al Garbi
123,486
2.26%
20,158
Bader
110,198
2.02%
17,989
Al Khaleej
101,030
1.85%
16,492
Al Zahraa
99,981
1.83%
16,321
Al Wazarat
94,465
1.73%
15,421
Others
3,021,003
55.25%
493,154
Total
5,467,914
Source:
Notes:
892,591
IPSOS, 2009
Colliers Estimates, 2012
*(e); Estimate
A is MHI of SR16,000 and above
B is MHI of SR8,000 to SR15,999
C is MHI of lower than SR8,000
2.2.4
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
70 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 73: Household by Monthly Income
Social Classes
Income (SAR/month)
High-Income
Riyadh
11.98%
12,001-16,000
12.21%
8,001-12,000
20.58%
Lower Mid-Income
5,001-8000
18.20%
Low-Income
2,001-5000
31.80%
Low-Income
5.23%
Upper Mid-Income
Mid-Income
LABOUR FORCE
The attractive business climate brought about by sustained high oil prices has
increased the presence of expatriates in Riyadh. A number of the countrys
nationals based in other cities came to Riyadh to find work, thus increasing the
citys available manpower.
Exhibit 74: Riyadh City Available Manpower
Ratio to
Labour
Force
Year
2007*(e)
2,275,023
2,190,334
96.30%
84,689
3.70%
2011*(e)
2,311,642
2,226,112
96.30%
85,531
3.70%
Source:
Note:
Employed
NonEmployed
Ratio to
Labour
force
Labour
Force
CDSI, 2008
*(e): estimate
Statistical information from the Ministry of Economy and Planning in 2008 indicates
that Riyadh has the largest share of the total available labour force in the Kingdom,
standing at 27.6% or 2.27 million labourers. Using historical data, the CAGR of
Riyadhs labour force stands at 0.4%. This rate was used in our forecast assuming
the growth of the citys economy remains stable.
Although current statistics do not indicate a tally of blue collar and white collar
workers in the city, the Ministry of Economy and Planning has reported a growing
number of highly qualified white-collar workers in the city. These workers and
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
71 of 109
FINAL
subsequently the firms they are working for will inevitably demand better office
accommodations and facilities.
2.3
Wadi Hanifa
Heritage Land
Riyadh City
Boundaries in 1980
Riyadh City
Boundaries in 2011
City Urban
Footprint
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
72 of 109
FINAL
Areas to the West are mostly in Wadi Hanifa. Wadi Hanifa is a heritage site, on
which developments are subject to strict municipality approvals.
Considerable expansions are to take place within North, North East and North
West Riyadh, which are expected to house approximately 36.5% of Riyadhs
2
inhabitants in 2020 .
According to Ar Riyadh Development Authority (ADA), the organisation has drawn
up plans for updating the road network of Riyadh. This will be done through
rehabilitation and upgrading of road networks to meet the necessary requirements.
The expected completion date for this plan is 2016. Upon completion, these
capillaries and roads are expected to handle over one million cars per day.
Numerous roads in Riyadh will be constructed, repaired and upgraded to reduce
traffic congestion, and improve the effects of flood drainage. The following Exhibit
shows the expanded planned road network of Riyadh:
Exhibit 76: Riyadh Road Network
Many elements of the road network were implemented during the first five years of
the Eighth Development Plan at a total cost of SAR 2.6 billion through 2006. The
second five-year plan, which is currently in progress, will include the
implementation and improvement of 28 main roads between years 2007-2012. The
2nd Ring Road is a major project of this development plan which is near
2
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
73 of 109
FINAL
completion and which will greatly facilitate the expansion of the city, especially in
North, North East and North West Riyadh.
Riyadh City Metro is a planned public transport network that is aimed to ease the
traffic congestion by providing an alternative to private transport which is a
prevailing mode of transport in Riyadh. Along with a metro, the ADA has planned a
substantive network of bus routes that will also facilitate making the new public
transport of Riyadh a success. The intersection of King Abdullah Road and Olaya
Road is expected to become the major junction of Riyadh City Metro. The project
has been divided into two phases. Phase 1 which measures 25 km, will operate
between Olaya Road and Batha Road connecting the northern side of the Ring
Road to the southern side. Phase 2 measuring 14 km, will connect the East Ring
Road to the West Ring Road through King Abdullah Road. The following Exhibit
depicts the routes of the planned metro and bus networks routes in Riyadh:
Exhibit 77: Planned Metro and Bus Network Routes
Train Network
Major Bus Network
Circular Bus Network
Arterial Bus Network
Source: Riyadh Municipality
Upon completion, the Riyadh Metro will connect around 30 districts serving an
approximate 1,500 passengers per hour per track initially which then is expected to
gradually increase to 8,000 passengers per hour per track.
Certain height restrictions are imposed by the municipality along all the major
roads and thoroughfares across Riyadh. As of now, only King Fahd Road in Riyadh
has no height restrictions, while most other major roads are limited to six floors
only. It should be noted that despite height restrictions, the height of a building is
also determined by the Floor Area Ratio (FAR) of the plot, which can vary
significantly across different plots along the same road. The purpose of imposing
height restriction is to limit the height of buildings regardless of what height the
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
74 of 109
2 Floors
3 Floors
FINAL
FAR allows. The following exhibit provides height restrictions that are applicable
along major roads in Riyadh:
4 Floors
5 Floors
6 Floors
8 Floors
10 Floors
12 Floors
18 Floors
No Restrictions
2 Floors
5 Floors
10 Floors
3 Floors
6 Floors
12 Floors
4 Floors
8 Floors
18 Floors
No Restrictions
Source: Riyadh Municipality
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
75 of 109
FINAL
RESIDENTIAL SEGMENT
3.1
OVERVIEW
The strong economy in tandem with a growing population has increased consumer
confidence in the Saudi residential property market. The government is taking keen
initiatives to address the shortage in housing units , reaching one million units. The
government has increased its budget allocation for housing construction by nearly
53% over the previous plans. The Ministry of Housing has been established to
take on the responsibilities of the General Housing Authority. The stimulus
package issued by the government is especially directed towards the housing
segment, with a primary focus on building 500,000 additional housing units for
Saudi families. To reach this target, the loan limit of the Real Estate Development
Fund has been increased from SAR 300,000 to SAR 500,000. It is expected that
the continued efforts of the government, coupled with the introduction of seasoned
real estate developers, will address this shortage in the years to come.
The following exhibit provides an overview of the residential segment of KSA,
including its fundamentals and drivers:
Economic growth
Increasing
financing
facilities from specialized
institutions
such
as
REDF and the private
sector eases availability
of housing finance in the
KSA and will further
boost the demand. With
greater economic activity
and real estate financing
options, the demand for
residential sector will only
increase further in KSA
Affordability level
Availability of mortgage
finance Rising
affordability levels
Increase demand for
housing units
Gradual
shift
towards
smaller
families will lead to the decline in
average family size, which, in turn,
increases the demand for housing.
The average household size in KSA,
was over 5+ in 2000 which is
expected to become <5 by 2015
Residential
Segment
Demographic profile
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
76 of 109
FINAL
3.1.1
Others, 90,000 ,
18%
Riyadh, 115,000 ,
23%
Jizan, 30,000 , 6%
Madinah, 35,000 ,
7%
Makkah, 110,000 ,
22%
Assir, 45,000 , 9%
Eastern Province,
75,000 , 15%
Riyadh
Makkah
Eastern Province
Assir
Madinah
Jizan
Others
3.2
CHARACTERISTICS
Riyadhs residential sector has witnessed a period of sustained price growth,
driven by the fast growing demand. Currently, the most popular locations for midto high-end residential developments are in North and Northeast Riyadh. Low to
mid-end residential developments are primarily concentrated in the south and
southwest of the city. A number of master plan developments to be erected in
North West Riyadh are currently on hold.
The supply of residential units has been mainly handled by medium-size residential
developers. The role of large-scale professional developers and subject matter
expert builders is still not widely found in the city. Generally, the supply of recent
residential units by professional developers such as Dar Al Arkan, Al Arjan,
Maskan Arabia, and Rafal accounts for less than 10% of the total injected supply
over the last two years.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
77 of 109
FINAL
3.2.1
SPATIAL ANALYSIS
Residential developments in Riyadh follow distinctive patterns in the various zones
of the city. However, most new districts have a good balance of apartment units
and villas, which shows that apartments are becoming more acceptable due to
their affordability. Riyadh is divided into five zones without clearly indicated
boundaries. These zones are popular in the real estate sector and have prevailed
due to the differences they exhibit, making it easier to categorise the residential
market in Riyadh.
The following exhibit provides an indicative view of developments in the various
zones of Riyadh:
East Riyadh
Quality: Mostly mid-end
Forthcoming Supply: Above average
North Riyadh
Quality: Upper mid to high-end
Forthcoming Supply: Above Average
North
West Riyadh
Quality: Low & high-end
Forthcoming Supply: Average
East
Central Riyadh
Quality: Mix
Forthcoming Supply: Minimum
Central
Riyadh
South Riyadh
Quality: Low to mid-end
Forthcoming Supply: Average
West
South
Central Riyadh is the primary centre of activity in the city. It houses government
ministries, hospitals, residential developments (low, mid and high-end) and
commercial developments such as retail malls and offices. Residential sales
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
78 of 109
FINAL
prices are the highest in Central Riyadh towards the northwest. Forthcoming
supply is minimal as the area is mostly developed
North Riyadh is the most popular zone for the upcoming residential and
commercial developments, which is mainly due to developments like King
Abdullah Financial District, Rafal Tower, and Tamkeen Tower. These
developments and many others to come are slowly shifting Riyadhs city centre
towards the north. Developments in the north are mostly upper mid to high end.
South Riyadh is one of the most popular areas for low to mid-end residential
developments. Al Aziziyah and Ad Dar Al Bayda districts are both suitable
districts which offer a healthy mix of apartments and villas alike. A disadvantage
of south Riyadh is its distance and limited thorough fares to the city centre
(currently only King Fahd Road). It is however quite close to both Riyadh
industrial areas 1 and 2
3.2.2
MARKET CHARACTERISTICS
The following exhibit shows Riyadhs current housing characteristics from different
perspectives including the housing market by unit categories and number of bedrooms.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
79 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 82: Residential Supply Characteristics
Housing Stock Distribution Estimate (2011)
Other, 6.07%
6-Bedroom
5%
Traditional
House, 6.82%
5-Bedroom
10%
A Floor in a Villa
or Traditional
House, 16.44%
Apartment,
45.63%
2-Bedroom
26%
1-Bedroom
14%
4-Bedroom
16%
Villa, 25.04%
3-Bedroom
26%
Other
0.3%
Housed
Employees
5%
Housed
Employees
4.9%
Owner
Occupiers
83.5%
Tenants
11.3%
Source:
7-Bedroom
4%
Tenants
77%
Owner
Occupiers
17%
The majority of the citys housing stock consists of residential apartments at 46%
of the total housing units stock. Even though villas are the most preferable
accommodation type, they have fallen behind apartments at 25% due to
affordability.
The majority of the provinces villa stock is owner occupied, representing 83.5%
of the villa stock in 2007. 11.3% of these villas are leased
As of 2007, 77% of the apartment stock has been occupied by tenants based on
annual or bi-annual rental contracts, due to the fact that apartments tend to be
offered on leasehold rather than freehold. The trend is expected to change as an
increasing number of apartment units outside Central Riyadh is being offered on
freehold basis
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
80 of 109
FINAL
The apartments relatively smaller size compared to the villas commands a more
affordable pricing structure for low to mid-income users
Although Riyadhs household size is larger than that of other GCC cities, the
majority of the citys residential stock lies in the 2 and 3-bedroom category.
The most popular villa type in Riyadh province is the four and five bedroom size
villas. In rare instances however, two bedroom villas or duplex components can
also be found
Four bedroom properties are reasonably common, and form a strong sales
market. Villas with more than five bedrooms are less common, and the market
for properties of this size is smaller in volume
3.3
RESIDENTIAL SUPPLY
Considering the average household size (5.7) and preference for privacy, villas and
traditional houses are currently the most commonly chosen mode of
accommodation, accounting together for 39% of Riyadhs total residential stock
whilst the apartment submarket accounts for 36% of Riyadhs total supply,
according to the latest published government statistics.
The total number of Riyadhs housing units is currently challenging to quantify as
the most recent government statistics are dated 2004 (i.e. City Population Census
by Housing). Therefore, Colliers forecasted Riyadhs current housing supply based
on historical growth between the number of occupied houses in 2004 (based on
City Population Census by Housing) and occupied housed in 2007 (based on
Province Population Census by Housing). The following exhibits Colliers estimates
of Riyadhs current housing market.
Exhibit 83: Riyadhs Housing Supply by Unit Type
Unit Type
2004
2007 *(e)
2011 *(e)
Apartment
299,218
333,920
404,729
Villa
188,106
197,978
222,131
132,859
135,505
145,868
Traditional House
53,919
55,520
60,523
Other
50,728
50,977
53,815
726,834
773,900
887,066
Total
Source:
Note:
Due to the progressive expansion of the City, the upcoming areas in the north,
northeast and northwest are expected to house 36% of Riyadhs population by
2020 as opposed to 28% in 1996. The eastern periphery of Riyadhs urban area is
also expected to house 8.5% of Riyadhs population by 2020. The residential
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
81 of 109
FINAL
density in the central areas is expected to decline by half. The exhibit below
portrays the expected distribution of Riyadhs population among the different zones
within the urban area followed by another exhibit that depicts the characteristics of
supply:
50%
46%
45%
40%
8.5%
14%
11.5%
9%
10%
12.5%
15%
6%
7.5%
13%
20%
5.5%
10%
25%
21%
14.5%
30%
21%
35%
5%
0%
Central
Northwest
Northeast
Southeast
1996
South
West
New
Northern
Areas
New
Eastern
Areas
2020
3.4
PERFORMANCE
3.4.1
RESIDENTIAL VILLAS
The villa submarket has always been a popular choice of housing type in Saudi
Arabia and particularly in Riyadh. Considering the average size of Saudi families in
addition to cultural and traditional values, villas are by far the most preferred mode
of residences.
Many of the citys most attractive residential areas are located in North Riyadh
which is currently the focus of the majority of residential development projects
under construction. The quality of villas found in the north is generally the highest
in the city and attracts the highest rental and sales prices. Colliers has conducted
extensive research on Riyadh to gain insight into the sales prices of freehold villas
and their characteristics in the different districts. The following exhibit details the
map of researched districts followed by a table that provides a summary of the
villas in these districts:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
82 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 85: Typical Residential Villa and Researched Districts
Qurtubah
Al Munsiyah Al Yarmuk
Al Qadsiyah
Al Falah
Al Yasmin
Al Nada
Ishbiliyyah
Al Hamra
Al Tawun
Al Naseem
Dhahrat Laban
Al Mansurah
Al Uraija
Hijrat Laban
Al Aziziyah
Al Shifa
Tuwaiq
Ad Dar Al Bayda
North
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
East
83 of 109
South
West
FINAL
Average Plot
Size (Sqm)
District
Average BUA
(Sqm)
Average Sales
Price (SAR/Sqm)
Average Sales
Price (SAR
Million)
Average Land
Value (SAR/Sqm)
North Riyadh
Al Yasmin
535
606
3,518
2.13
1,700
Al Tawun
600
433
2,870
1.24
1,800
Al Falah
398
416
4,010
1.67
1,600
Al Nada
435
567
3,632
2.06
1,600
Al Hamra
950
850
3,500
2.98
2,300
Ishbiliyyah
450
480
3,170
1.52
1,600
Al Jazirah
484
536
2,470
1.32
1,400
Al Munsiyah
345
435
3,055
1.33
1,500
Al Qadsiyah
486
570
2,460
1.40
1,300
Al Yarmuk
403
546
2,991
1.63
1,400
Qurtubah
332
442
3,542
1.57
1,600
King Faisal
603
458
1,960
0.90
1,200
Al Aziziyah
433
489
2,157
1.05
1,000
Al Shifa
357
443
2,400
1.06
1,000
Ad Dar Al Bayda
375
420
2,158
0.91
1,100
Al Uraija
398
511
1,995
1.02
950
Al Nakheel
381
450
3,500
1.58
2,200
Al Tuwaiq
472
575
1,737
1.00
1,000
Dhahrat Laban
482
549
2,170
1.19
1,000
Hijrat Laban
450
502
2,100
1.05
1,000
Sample Average
477
511
2,655
1.37
1,380
East Riyadh
South Riyadh
West Riyadh
Source:
Note:
Prices are as expected to continue rising as demand grows and forthcoming supply
enters the market, especially supply that is part of the master planned
developments. Rent and sales prices of residential units located in the citys prime
residential areas remained stable due to location and high demand during the
same period.
Current occupancy levels and sales prices differ in the various districts, with
districts in North Riyadh exhibiting the highest occupancies and sales absorption
rates. This shows that developments in the north are the most sought after and
are in the final development stages offering the most necessities
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
84 of 109
FINAL
Other new researched districts (for e.g. Dhahrat Laban, Hijrat Laban) had low
occupancy rates and sales prices due to the lack of public necessities including:
Schools
Hospitals
Civic Services (Police, Fire Departments etc,)
Retail Support
The high prices in North Riyadh are not suitable for attracting low and lower mid
income households, which would find West and South Riyadh more suitable.
East Riyadh, on the other hand, primarily caters to the mid income category of
the city
Most mid scale developers build small developments with an average of 10-15
units mainly due to the lack of flexible financing options
Interviews with developers suggest that they prefer to accept full upfront
payment upon the completion of each unit. However, during the construction
phase of a project, the customer has the option of making a down payment of
around 40% 60% of the unit price. The remaining payments can be settled on
a quarterly or bi annual basis until completion of the villa or before it is handed
over to the customer
The quality of finishing is between below average and average. Some villas are
built with swimming pools which increases the sales price of the units
Central air conditioners are not typically offered by developers and kitchens are
offered unfitted which is the standard practice in the Kingdom. People typically
prefer a customized kitchen set up according to individual taste and preferences
2 Bedroom
3 Bedroom
North
30,000-35,000
35,000-40,000
50,000-60,000
Centre
40,000-50,000
45,000-60,000
60,000-70,000
East
33,000-37,000
35,000-40,000
45,000-50,000
West
N/A
35,000-45,000
50,000-65,000
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
4 Bedroom
85 of 109
FINAL
3.4.2
RESIDENTIAL APARTMENTS
Riyadhs residential apartment segment has been growing robustly in recent years.
Historically, apartments were not favoured by Saudi nationals. However, in the light
of rapid price increases in villa rental and sales prices in addition to declining
household sizes, low to middle income groups have increasingly been forced to
consider apartments due to their relative affordability.
Colliers research analysts have considered in the analysis the primary and
secondary grade apartments that are typically found in Riyadh city. Analysis has
been made on a selected number of residential districts including Dar Al Bayda,
Dhahrat Laban, Hammra, Ishbiliyyah, Qurtubah, Tuwaiq and Al Yasmeen North of
the city, especially on districts which are in close proximity to the primary CBD
areas and the north Ring Road, thus attracting the highest residential rental and
sale prices in the apartment segment.
Residential apartments located south and west of the City command the lowest
rental/sales prices in the market. These districts suffer from bad location,
mediocre connectivity to city centre and low quality of supply.
The north of the city, especially near the primary CBD areas and the north Ring
Road, attracts the highest residential rental and sale prices in the apartment
segment.
The following exhibit gives a snapshot of typical apartments in Riyadh and their
prices:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
86 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 87: Typical Residential Apartments (Riyadh)
North
East
South
Al Yasmin
West
Qurtubah
Ishbiliyyah
Al Hamra
Dhahrat Laban
Tuwaiq
District
Ad Dar Al
Bayda
Dar Al Bayda
153
2,213
338,589
Dhahrat Laban
136
2,501
340,136
Hammra
208
2,060
428,480
Ishbiliyyah
156
2,700
421,200
Qurtubah
128
2,588
331,264
Tuwaiq
138
1,964
271,032
Yasmeen
211
2,859
603,249
Average
161
2,412
390,564
Duplex apartment units are an upcoming trend in the market, in which the unit
resembles a villa rather than an apartment, and is therefore expected to continue
performing well
Most apartment buildings have between 8-12 units, and are typically low rise
structures of G + 3 floors
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
87 of 109
FINAL
increase in unit sales prices which have reached beyond the financial capabilities
of many of Riyadhs households. Although home financing companies and banks
offer financing solutions, however, many of Riyadh households are exposed to
other credit terms exceeding 30% of their monthly income, which leads to failure in
qualifying for loans from the available home financing institution. As a result, the
rental market is performing robustly, and this is further reflected in the continuous
increase in rental reviews all over Riyadhs residential districts. The following table
depicts the average rental prices for various apartments in Riyadhs key residential
zones:
Exhibit 88: Residential Apartments Rental Rates
Apartment
1 Bedroom
2 Bedroom
3 Bedroom
North
18,000-20,000
25,000-33,000
40,000-45,000
Centre
20,000-25,000
28,500-33,000
37,000-45,000
East
12,000-17,000
20,000-25,000
27,000-30,000
West
N/A
20,000-23,000
27,000-33,000
3.4.3
PRICE DETERMINANTS
Typical Villa and Apartment developments in Riyadh and the Kingdom in general
have three main components that determine the final selling price of the housing
unit. These three components are:
Land Price
Construction Cost
Developer Margins
Land Price
Land prices in Riyadh have been increasing. However, the price increase in Riyadh
was less substantial than the one observed in Jeddah. Apart from a couple of
districts in the northern and eastern parts of Riyadh, prices have increased by a
CAGR of approximately 2.5%. Major fluctuation in price was recorded in upcoming
districts in the north and east, with prices rising as much as 19% per year (e.g.
Qurtubah District).
The following exhibit provides the CAGR of residential land prices in various parts
of Riyadh over the last two years (2009-2011):
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
88 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 89: Residential Land Price (SAR/Sqm) CAGR 2009-2011
North Riyadh
Average : 1,975*
Low:
2.60%
Average:
7.79%
High:
14.0%
East Riyadh
Average :
Low:
Average:
High:
North
East
West Riyadh
Average : 1,772*
Low:
-2.60%
Average:
3.12%
High:
7.40%
Central
Riyadh
West
South
Source:
Note:
1,324*
-4.40%
5.25%
19.00%
South Riyadh
Average : 894*
Low:
-4.40%
Average:
0.92%
High:
5.80%
One of the major reasons why prices have generally been stable, unlike Jeddah, is
due to the large supply of undeveloped land available in the city. Riyadh
municipality and the ArRiyadh Development Authority have made considerable
efforts to increase land supply in order to control prices.
Construction Costs
Construction costs remain relatively stable in Riyadh and the Kingdom in general
as compared to other GCC states. The following table provides broad benchmarks
of construction costs (SAR/Sqm) according to different unity types:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
89 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 90: Indicative Construction Costs (SAR/Sqm)
Development
From
To
Villa
Low End
1,000
1,500
Mid End
1,500
2,000
High End
2,000
3,000
Low Rise
2,600
3,600
Medium Rise
3,200
4,800
High Rise
4,800
6,100
Apartment
Construction costs provided in the table above are absolute averages that should
be taken only as indicative values. Furthermore, they are limited to finishing only
and do not constitute other costs such as architectural design fees, furniture (if
furnished) etc. Costs vary per type of development and location in the city.
The land cost of typical Villa developments in Jeddah ranges from 35% to 45% of
total sales price, leaving room for construction costs and developer margins.
Recent hikes in land prices however, have increased this ratio to as much as 60%,
with the average being approximately close to 50%. The following exhibit provides
typical average sales prices of villa units and lands in different districts in Riyadh:
Exhibit 91: Sales Prices and Land Price Comparison
Average Sales
Price (SAR/Sqm)
Average
BUA/Unit (sqm)
Sales Price
(SAR/Unit)
Land Price
(SAR/Sqm)
Eshbelya
3,170
480
1,521,600
1,183
Al Yarmook
2,991
546
1,633,086
1,083
Qortuba
3,542
442
1,565,564
1,242
Al Hamra
3,500
588
2,058,000
1,317
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
90 of 109
FINAL
affected by land prices , which results in declining yield trends for villas. According
to the database of one of the research companies and to Colliers analysis, yields
for typical villa developments within various regions of Riyadh dropped marginally
from 5.38 % to 5.09% during 2008 to 2011, which is mainly due to land prices.
Similarly, the yields for apartment developments showed a consistent trend during
the same period, where yields dropped slightly from 7.4% to 7.05% between 2008
and 2010. As discussed with market participants, the apartment market is more
stable than the villa market.
Going forward, the yields for both villas and apartments are expected to improve
provided land price correction takes place in the near future.
3.5
3.5.1
OVERVIEW
Between 2004 and 2010, Riyadh has had one of the fastest growing populations
among the major GCC cities with a CAGR of 4.06%. Demand on housing units has
seen sustainable growth as a result.
3.5.2
SUPPLY FORECASTS
The total number of Riyadhs housing units is currently challenging to quantify as
the most recent government statistics are dated 2004. The majority of residential
construction activities are private, individually financed, and managed by mid scale
developers, which makes the existing and upcoming supply impossible to
calculate.
The following exhibit portrays Riyadhs estimated supply projections for the next 10
years:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
91 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 92: Supply Projections
40,000
35,000
30,000
36,195
35,106
34,051
33,027
32,034
30,137
29,230
28,352
10,000
27,499
15,000
29,978
20,000
31,071
25,000
5,000
0
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Supply
Source: Colliers Estimates, 2012
3.5.3
DEMAND ANALYSIS
Demand analysis is based on available information, however, due to the absence
of available and up-to-date statistics, Colliers has estimated potential demand
based on historical growth rates. A number of indicators on the residential demand
supply balance in Riyadh show that sales prices along with land prices are on the
rise and yields are compressing amongst the more sophisticated investors.
Population growth is high and sustained, and average household sizes have risen.
These indicators point to a growing supply gap in Riyadhs residential sector.
Colliers modelled the future residential unit demand in Riyadh based on a number
of key assumptions. Population growth in the city is estimated at a CAGR of 2.5%,
and for the purposes of our model, this growth rate is assumed to continue.
The most recent available census data indicates that the average household size
has reached 6.13, while the total number of households is estimated to be around
892,592. This change in population dynamics was taken into account in the
calculation of Riyadhs housing demand.
MARKET-WIDE DEMAND ANALYSIS
Colliers identified three major sources of demand:
Natural demand stemming from population growth
Replacement demand, which is assumed at 2% per year
Declining household size
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
92 of 109
FINAL
Even though Riyadhs average household size increased from 5.71 in 2004 to 6.13
in 2010, Colliers still assumes that the household size of Riyadh will decrease in
the future. This is primarily because the majority of Riyadhs population is young
and is expects to look for housing upon marriage. The average household size is
likely to decline in the future judging from the pace at which Riyadh is urbanising.
This is consistent with trends that cities undergo when going through urbanisation.
The following exhibit provides a 10 year estimate of demand on housing
categorized by income classes:
300
6.25
250
5.85
5.65
68
69
66
67
64
65
62
63
60
62
59
60
57
58
56
57
54
55
50
56
57
100
Household Size
219
209
213
203
207
198
201
192
196
187
190
182
185
177
180
172
175
167
150
181
173
204
195
200
6.05
63
64
Hundreds
5.45
5.25
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
Demand By High-Income
Demand by Low-Income
Household Size
2018
2019
2020
2021
Demand by Mid-Income
An analysis of these indicators places the average demand for housing units at
over 50,000 household units annually for the next 10 years.
3.5.4
MARKET GAP
Riyadh has seen considerable rises in population, which has created a shortage in
the citys housing units. This shortage is most pronounced among the low and mid
income categories of the population, and is prevalent in all major cities in the KSA
due to relatively lower rate of increase in supply compared to demand. These
consequences are caused by the following:
Unreasonable increases in land prices due to land trading
Relative lack of experience of developers
High rate of increase in population (a CAGR of 4%)
The following exhibit depicts the annual net demand, annual net supply and the
market gap in Riyadhs housing units over the next 10 years period:
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
93 of 109
FINAL
Hundreds
Exhibit 94: Market Demand, Supply and Gap per Year for Riyadh
600
25,000
500
20,000
400
15,000
300
10,000
200
467
275
451
284
464
292
477
301
491
311
505
320
519
330
534
341
549
351
565
362
5,000
527
300
100
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
Market Gap
3.5.5
AFFORDABILITY ANALYSIS
Colliers has estimated the affordability of different units according to income levels
and prices prevailing in the city. The following characteristics of the market have
helped us formulate mortgage affordability according to income levels.
As the BUA of the unit increases, the sales price per sq m decreases. There is
no clear trend as to how much the sales price decreases as other factors such
as location, quality etc. play an important role. For the purpose of this analysis,
Colliers assumes that sales prices remain constant for both villa and apartment
developments, so that affordability can be gauged. This rate is assumed at SAR
2,800/sq m for villas and SAR 2,400/sq m for apartment developments.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
94 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 95: Affordability Analysis
Unit Type
BUA
(Sqm)
Apartment
125
Apartment
Avg. Sales
Price
(SAR/Sqm)
Unit Price*
Down
Payment*
Required Loan
Amount*
Monthly
Installment*
Monthly
Income*
Population
Affordability
2,400
300,000
60,000
240,000
1,454
4,155
94.77%
150
2,400
360,000
72,000
288,000
1,745
4,986
94.77%
Apartment
175
2,400
420,000
84,000
336,000
2,036
5,817
62.97%
Apartment
200
2,400
480,000
96,000
384,000
2,327
6,648
44.77%
Apartment
225
2,400
540,000
108,000
432,000
2,618
7,480
44.77%
Apartment
250
2,400
600,000
120,000
480,000
2,909
8,311
44.77%
Apartment
275
2,400
660,000
132,000
528,000
3,200
9,142
44.77%
Villa
300
2,800
840,000
168,000
672,000
4,072
11,635
44.77%
Villa
325
2,800
910,000
182,000
728,000
4,412
12,604
24.19%
Villa
350
2,800
980,000
196,000
784,000
4,751
13,574
24.19%
Villa
375
2,800
1,050,000
210,000
840,000
5,090
14,544
24.19%
Villa
400
2,800
1,120,000
224,000
896,000
5,430
15,513
11.98%
Villa
450
2,800
1,260,000
252,000
1,008,000
6,108
17,452
11.98%
3.6
3.6.1
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
95 of 109
FINAL
AJMAKAN
Exhibit 96: Ajmakan Snapshot Overview
Master Developer
1.84 Mn
Location
Al Khozama District
# of Units
500 Residential
700 2000 Sqm
6,900 7,100
9,000 Mn
Status
Not Completed
LIMITLESS
The company which is a master development arm of Dubai World came to Saudi
Arabia as a silver sponsor of RestatexThe Riyadh Exhibition for Real Estate and
Architectural Development- in 2008 and is undertaking a project located north of
Riyadh.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
96 of 109
FINAL
AL WASL PROJECT
Exhibit 97: Al Wasl Project Snapshot Overview
Masterplan ID
Al Wasl Project
Master Developer
Limitless
14 Mn
Location
Al Malaga District
# of Units
55,000 Residential
240-1,700 Sqm
45,000 Mn
Status
Not completed
DAR AL ARKAN
One of the largest Saudi large-scale developers is Dar Al-Arkan. The focus of Dar
Al-Arkan is not on the high-end, luxury projects that so many large-scale
developers are building, but on more reasonably priced housing projects targeting
middle-income bracket Saudi families.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
97 of 109
FINAL
SHAMS AL RIYADH
Exhibit 98: Shams Al Riyadh Snapshot Overview
Masterplan ID
Shams Al Riyadh
Master Developer
Dar Al Arkan
5 Mn
Location
Salboukh Road
# of Units
3,189
400-1,500
6,000 Mn
Status
Not Completed
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
98 of 109
FINAL
AL QASR PROJECT
Exhibit 99: Al Qasr Project Snapshot Overview
Masterplan ID
Al Qasr Project
Master Developer
Dar Al Arkan
814,000
Location
Al-Swaiyadi District
254 Villa
1,479 Apartment
# of Units
AVG. Unit Size
300-800 Sqm
2,000 mn
Status
Completed
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
99 of 109
FINAL
The developers main target segment was Working Class Saudis falling in the
mid income category. Now, the target segment has changed to comprise both
mid income Saudis and mid income expatriates. In hindsight, it can be seen that
the location was a major flaw since Al Suwaidi, situated in South Riyadh, is not a
favoured location for the upcoming mid income class of Saudis.
Potential buyers prefer the upcoming areas in the northern and eastern parts of
the city, which are much better in terms of
Infrastructure including the presence of schools, hospitals and other civic
The unit mix of the development was not in line with local preferences, which are
targeted towards villas rather than apartments. It should be noted that villas have
sold much more quickly than apartments have in this location. The apartments at
Al Qasr, set up in a community setting, are less preferable than standalone
apartments in non community settings in areas located in the northern and
eastern parts of the city. Although community settings are the upcoming trend
and much more preferred in the market than stand alone developments, the
location factor of Al Qasr has overcome the community element and has not
helped the development in securing quicker absorption.
AL ARGAN
Al Argan began operations in 2006 owned by more than one shareholder. The
companys strategy is to develop the shareholders land properties. One of their
major developments is Manazel Qurtoba.
The average return on investment is about 21% through projects with a life span of
14 months. The companys shareholders are land banks, but they are also ready to
invest in developing potential lands that are not owned by the company. Al Argan
developments are financed through equity and debt. Financing sources are AR
Riyadh Bank, Dar Al Tamleek and Amlak at an average rate of 4.5%
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
100 of 109
FINAL
MANAZEL QURTOBA
The project is located in the north east of Riyadh city within Cordoba district. It is
situated over a land area of
360,000 sq m offering a total
number of 1,400 residential
units which include 1000
apartments and 400 villas. Only
phase 1 of the project has been
completed, delivering 400
residential units.
The average price range for
villas with average BUA of 400 650 sq m stands at SR 1.1 mn SR 2 mn, while the price range for duplex units
with BUA ranging from 237.5-240 sq m stood at SR 750,000 SR 850,000.
The project is an integrated housing component, delivering all the necessary civil
services such as electricity, sanitation, internal streets, mosques, schools,
restaurants and malls which position it as so much more than just a housing
project.
Current Status: The 400 units of Phase 1 of the project have been sold out are
expected to be completed in Q1 2012. The development is currently undergoing
construction for c.1,000 apartment units and is expected to deliver them by 2014.
3.6.5
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
101 of 109
FINAL
BLNCYAH
Exhibit 100: Blncyah Snapshot Overview
Masterplan ID
Blncyah
Master Developer
Rafal
Land Area (m )
85,956
Location
# of Units
144 Villas
321 693
N/A
Status
Land Area (m )
# of Units
Project ID
120,000
238 Villas and
Apartment not determined yet
285 Sqm for Duplex on 238 Sqm Plot Area
500 Sqm for detached on 400 Sqm Plot Area
Status
Under Construction
The second gated community by Rafal is located along Salboukh Highway close to
the new Addereyyah. The project comprises villas and apartments. The project is
specifically targeting the middle income segment.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
102 of 109
FINAL
Exhibit 102: Al Rabia Residential Community
The land area of the project is of about 120,000 sq m with a total BUA of
115,000 sq m comprising only two types of villas (i.e. duplexes and detached
units), and no further details are available as of current on the mix of apartments
and sizes.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
103 of 109
FINAL
DURRAT AL RIYADH PROJECT
Exhibit 103: Durrat Al Riyadh Snapshot Overview
Masterplan ID
Durrat Al Riyadh
Master Developer
Dallah Al Barakah
3.2 mn
Location
Al Qaseem Road
# of Units
843
590-2,500 Sqm
3,000 mn
Status
Not Completed
Durrat Al Riyadh, located on Al Qaseem Road, will be developed over the course
of four phases and will provide a total of 843 housing units. It covers an area of 3.2
million sq m, and the first phase includes 150 medium-sized, high-income villas
named Kadi Villas. Kadi Villas are four-bedroom villas with an average plot size of
1,175 sq m and average unit size of 590 sq m.
The average selling price of the villas is at SAR 2,300,000 to SAR 2,700,000. A
maintenance programme is also offered for a period of 8 years at an additional cost
of SR 104,340. The total land area of each villa is between 950-1400 sq m. The
BUA for each villa is 590 sq m. Phase 1 will also include community support retail,
a destination shopping mall, a hypermarket and a 5-star resort hotel. Available
information indicates that 70% of the project will be landscaped.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
104 of 109
FINAL
Phase 1 includes 843 villa plots, each of which will sit upon a raised mound
designed to ensure privacy for residents. The second set of villas will be Emerald
Villas, which are 35 villas of Spanish architectural design. The BUA for each villa is
666 sq m and the land area is between 1200-1600 sq m. The villas have three
floors, the ground floor area is of 364.5 sq m, the first floor area is of 245.72 sq m
and the upper floor area is of 42.91 sq m. Based on Colliers research, we believe
selling prices for these villas start at SAR 3,300,000. Finally, the last set of villas is
the Mound Rubies Villas, in which purchasers will be able either to develop their
own villa, according to certain planning guidelines, or to have the villa built from a
range of five design options provided by the master developer. They can choose
from Spanish, Malaysian, Najdi, Andalusia or Modern design. The land area per
villa is 950-2,500 sq m and the BUA is 1,017-2,500 sq m. Plot prices will depend
on size and location of the property although price ranges have not yet been
determined. The entire area will sit within a walled community with 24-hour
security.
Dallah Al Baraka report that they are in advanced negotiations with Amlak Finance
to provide mortgage lending on the villa plots in anticipation of legal changes in this
area.
Exhibit 104: Real Estate Sector Division in Durrat Al Riyadh
Sector
Area (sq m)
Residential
1,008,534
31.8%
Commercial/Offices
110,541
3.5%
Hotel
158,400
5%
Mosques
520.48
1.6%
Schools
675.41
2.1%
Other services
272.01
0.9%
1,205,822
38%
544,962
17.2%
3,175,049
100%
Open areas
Road & pathways
Total
Source: Dallah Al Baraka
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
Ratio
105 of 109
FINAL
The above table summarizes the arrangement of sectors present on this land. The
communitys retail element has been allocated a total land area of 26,297 sq m split
between several small plots. Additionally, two larger plots of 35,222 sq m and
49,807 sq m have been reserved for retail uses. Dallah Al Baraka hopes to find
sub-developers to build and operate retail facilities on both plots.
The final element of Phase 1 will be a hotel resort. It is planned to offer 160 rooms
and 54 chalet suites. Negotiations are reportedly underway with Rosewood to
operate the property, although it has not yet received a hotel license from the
municipality as yet. The hotel will cover an area of 158,400 sq m.
There will also be four (girl/boy) elementary schools, two (girl/boy) middle schools
and two (girl/boy) secondary schools. The total schools land area is of 67,000 sq
m, which forms 2.5% the total development area. Each school will acquire an area
of 8,400 sq m.
According to plans, eight mosques will require an average land area of 52,000 sq
m, which forms 1.64% of the total area. For each mosque, the population density
will be 1000 pax/mosque. Therefore, the land area of each mosque is of
approximately 6,500 sq m.
This whole project is expected to accommodate 6,800 persons, which equates to
22 pax/hectare or 0.0022 pax/ sq m.
Current Status: The project is undergoing slow construction activity; nevertheless
it has secured buyers for 252 Villas, of which 208 have already been delivered. It is
also reported that approximately 80% of the land parcels have been sold to
individuals who can either hire the developer to build their units, or choose to sub
contract the development. This option remains feasible for buyers who are
currently not in a hurry to secure a unit, but nevertheless want it for future use.
3.6.7
THABAT
Thabat is a joint collaboration of Talaat Mostafa Holding Group in Egypt and Al
Oula Company for Real Estate Development in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. It is
an entity that aims to develop residential and commercial communities across the
Kingdom.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
106 of 109
FINAL
NASSMAT AL RIYADH
Exhibit 105: Nassmat Ar Riyadh Snapshot Overview
Masterplan ID
Nassmat Ar Riyadh
Master Developer
Thabat
3 mn
Location
North Eastern
# of Units
4143
130-480 (Apt)
520-707 (Villa)
6,000 mn
Status
Cancelled
The strategy of sell-build has been relatively not successful in building the
required demand momentum by individuals and/or bulk purchasers as observed
in Nassamat Ar Riyadh development. In order to build investor confidence in the
projects vision, building the required infrastructure is essential to the success of
any master plan development.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
107 of 109
FINAL
Building critical mass in early phases of any master plan is crucial to the success
of the development. Thus the Master developer must take the initiative to selfstart the development before expecting external investors to come in and
support the project life cycle.
South Riyadh is not favoured for mid to high income housing types, as exhibited
by the Al Qasr Developments disappointing performance. Upcoming areas in
the North, Northeast and Northwest are more preferable.
3.7
OUTLOOK
The outlook for Riyadhs residential market is strong with demand continuing to
outstrip supply, thus resulting in a market-wide gap of over 20,000 housing units
per annum. A major portion of this gap lies in the low- to mid-income housing
category which allows the future development of middle to large scale projects
targeted towards this income segment.
This gap is expected to further widen as the population increases and household
sizes continue to decline. The availability of mortgage financing schemes is also
expected to increase demand for residential units. This translates into future
opportunity for the mid scale developers in Riyadh.
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
Financial Feasibility Report
108 of 109
CONTACT DETAILS
Tel: +966 (1) 217 9997
Fax: +966 (1) 2174090
Idamrah@colliers-me.com
Colliers International
Office 603, Al Mas Tower
King Fahad Road
P.O. Box 5678
Riyadh 11432
Saudi Arabia
www.colliers-me.com