Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abdalla
October 2009
Contact
Author
Notify Me
of New Work
1. INTRODUCTION
Summary:
The paper concerns with formulae and calculations
of a selected group of Key Performance Indicators
(KPIs) for the main electricity transmission system in
Oman. These include the following service quality,
reliability, security, and financial indicators [1]:
System Average Interruption Frequency Index
(SAIFI)
System Average Interruption Duration Index
(SAID)
Energy Not Supplied (ENS)
Average Interruption Time (AIT)
Overhead Lines Maintenance Cost Index
(OHLMCI)
Substation Maintenance Cost Index (SSMCI)
Results of the main transmission grid in Oman, over
the last 3 years, are presented. The results are useful in
indicating trends of the KPIs and determination of
future targets to improve transmission system
performance.
The goal of presenting the paper at the GCC 09 is to
open a discussion among transmission utilities in the
Gulf region for the possibility of introducing common
KPIs to evaluate system performance. This could
provide an excellent opportunity to establish acceptable
benchmarks of the proposed KPIs
Al Batinah North
SIA-1
Shinas
2.2km
SRC
800mm2 XLPE
CABLE
UAE
Legend
220kv Grid Station
220kv Double Circuit
220kv Double Circuit Cable
Liwa
km
Y
EW
2500mm2
XLPE CABLE
x2
Aluminium
28 km
Power Station
YEW x 2
12
km
1k
37km
40
Saham
YE
Al
km
AR
x2
CU
5
22
54
YE
A
A
A
km
Ba
RIA
Bureimi
Khaburah
x2
t in
ah
So
u th
Barka
x2
Muladah
C
YEW x 2
km
25
YE
9k
Filaj
24
15km
2
x
km
10km
YEW x 2
Rusail
Mabailah
Rustaq
28 km
240 ZTACIR
Bawsher
YEW
x2
59 km
YEW x 2
x2
AC
AA
km
5
22
54
Al-Dakhiliah
Ibri
8 km YEW x 1
8.2km
Wadi
Adai
YEW x 2
RIA
46 km
YE
3
YE 5 km
W
x2
U
RC
AlFalaj
MSQ
Wadi
Kabir
km
Alhayl
Mawalih
m
YEW x 2
Y
EW
52
AA
43
5A
Ghoubrah
CS
7 km
22
0A
8 km
Barka
Main
x2
7 km YEW x 2
RIA
x2
Seeb Main
11km
IR
Dank
ARCU
x2
8 km
64 km
AC
0 ZT
YE W
ARCURIA
x2
43km
12 km
4 km 240 ZTACIR
MIS
24
km
43
Ad Dhahirah
Al Dhahirah
Oman Gulf
x2
x2
30
YE
km
SIS
Wadi
Al Jizzi
33 km
ELM x1
Bureimi
13km
Sohar
24
YE
33 km
ELM x1
Mhadah
(Alwasit)
1 km
x2
0.5km
41 km
km
RIA
ARCURIA x
2
47
CU
YEW x 2
28 km
Auha
3 km
3 km
Smelter
YEW x 2
AR
SPS
2500mm2 XLPE
CABLE
20 km
x2
Jahloot
Sumail
KSA
61
k
120k
x2
YE
W
Muscat
Bahla
YEW
x2
Al-Sharqiyah
3
YE 2k m
W
x2
Izki
Nizwa
x2
Y EW
33 km
W
YE
Mudhirib
Mudaybi
m
3k
EL
M
Adam
Sur
YEW x 2
YE
x2
51
km
Alkamil
k
73
YEW
x2
W
YE
Nahada
PDO
OMIFCO
km
60km
x
YEW
Al Wusta
63
67
EW
Y
G
47km
km
km
x1
20
Manah
km
55
JBB Ali
A.
B.
Financial Performance
2008
31,602
8,836
299,369
5.95%
C. System Availability
Table (III) shows the transmission system
availability during 2006, 2007 and 2008. These include
both summer period availability and annual availability.
Table (III): System availability index.
Item
2006
2007
2008
Summer
98.49% 95.96% 98.75%
Availability
Annual
98.23% 95.99% 98.49%
Availability
The system availability is calculated in terms of
the summation the availabilities of individual circuits of
the transmission grid expressed as a percentage of the
total number of circuits. A circuit is defined as an
overhead line, cable, transformer or any combination of
these equipment items controlled by one or more circuit
breakers. The formula for calculating this availability
indicator is given as follows:
B.
Total unavailability includes planned and
unplanned outages. It is also calculated in OETC on
monthly and yearly bases.
8760 60 ENS
Annual Electricit y Demand (MWh)
D. Transmission Losses
This KPI gives indirect indication of the
transmission grid efficiency. Transmission losses can
be calculated as the difference between the total
electrical energy received from the generating plants
and the total energy supplied to all transmission
customers. It is usual to express losses as a percentage
value rather than absolute value. The losses are
measured over a definite period (e.g. one year or one
month). The total energy received is the sum of
energies measured at the connection points with
Notes:
SAIFI is normally calculated over one year. If it
is required for other periods, its name and
equation should be modified accordingly.
SAIFI can be calculated for each voltage level.
A customer of a transmission grid is considered
to be each company that has a connection
agreement with the grid.
D.
SSMCI =
5. RESULTS
The following results summarize the recommended
KPIs calculated for the transmission system in Oman
during the last three years 2006-2008 [11]. Table (IV)
shows the energy not supplied ENS and the average
interruption time AIT key performance indicators.
One Year
Number of Customers
2006
2007
2008
1995
2028
2080
96.91
93.66
79.00
OHTLMCI =
MWh/year
1500
1000
ENS
500
F.
Substation
(SSMCI)
Maintenance
Cost
Index
0
2006
2007
2008
Years
100
80
AIT
60
(min/year) 40
20
0
AIT
2006
2007
2008
Years
2008
19.32
16.98
0.8
OHTLMCI
SSMCI
2006
2007
2008
Years
0.6
SAIFI 0.4
0.2
CAIDI =
SAIDI
SAIFI
40
SAIDI
30
20
10
0
2006
2007
2008
Years
8. REFERENCES
I.
7. CONCLUSIONS
The paper has described a number of key
performance indicators for electricity transmission
system. These include a group of six KPIs
recommended by the CIGRE Study Committee C2 and
JWG B3/C2-14 Task Force 02 and results of the
application to Oman electricity transmission system. A
group of three additional selected KPIs have been also
proposed. The two groups cover important practical
performances of electricity transmission systems. These
include availability, reliability, quality and maintenance
cost indicators. The KPIs can be used to measure the
system performance compared to benchmarks and to
illustrate the trends in these indicators. Thus, companies
can set targets and take corrective actions, if necessary,
to improve system performance.
These KPIs may provide a useful tool for
evaluating the operational performance of transmission
systems in the Gulf region. The GCC CIGRE is
encouraged to establish a task force committee from the
countries in the region to further study the possibility of
using these KPIs. Precise definitions, methods of