Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
The University of Chicago Press and Astronomical Society of the Pacific are collaborating with JSTOR to
digitize, preserve and extend access to Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific.
http://www.jstor.org
ABSTRACT. Stunted outbursts have been reported in old novae and nova-like cataclysmic variables by
Honeycutt, Robertson, and Turner. These 0.41 mag outbursts were concluded to be either mass transfer events
or disk outbursts similar to dwarf nova eruptions, but seen under unusual conditions. Honeycutt, Robertson, and
Turner did not have enough evidence to favor either of these possibilities. This paper uses additional long-term
photometry and analysis to argue that the similarities of these stunted outbursts to dwarf nova eruptions are now
so numerous that the dwarf nova outburst choice is strongly favored. The similarities discussed here include the
range of outburst spacings, the coherence and stability of the outbursts, and the presence of isolated outburst/
dip pairs. As part of this discussion we note the presence of unexpectedly stable clocks over 9 years for the
repetition interval of dwarf nova outbursts in SY Cnc and of stunted outbursts in FY Per.
1. INTRODUCTION
Cataclysmic variables (CVs) typically consist of a red dwarf/
white dwarf pair in which the red dwarf is losing gas to the
white dwarf via Roche lobe overflow (Warner 1995a). The
accretion luminosity usually dominates in the visual part of the
spectrum, making CVs important laboratories for the physics
of stellar accretion. Dwarf novae (DNs) are a subclass of CVs
in which an accretion disk surrounding the white dwarf undergoes regular eruptions due to a thermal instability in the
disk (Cannizzo 1993). This instability occurs only in a restricted
range of disk temperatures (and hence in a restricted range of
from the red dwarf) over which partially
mass transfer rates M
ionized hydrogen controls the thermal structure of the disk. At
, hydrogen
the higher disk temperatures provided by a larger M
is nearly fully ionized in the relevant portions of the disk, and
accretion takes place under steady state conditions without DN
outbursts. Therefore we do not expect DN behavior in systems
1M
crit.
with M
1M
Systems with M
crit are identified observationally as
nova-like CVs (NLCVs). (Most classical novae observed decades after the nova outburst are similar spectroscopically and
photometrically to NLCVs, and we will make no distinction
between the two types in this paper.) As expected, NLCVs are
found to be brighter on average (by 3 mag) than DN-type
CVs at the same orbital period (Warner 1995a).
In a decade-long monitoring program of about 70 NLCVs,
Honeycutt, Robertson & Turner (1998, hereafter HRT98) reported that a significant fraction displayed stunted outbursts.
These 0.41.0 mag events have spacings and widths characteristic of DN outbursts but are of much smaller amplitude.
Several candidate explanations for stunted outbursts were ex-
burst widths are 320 days. At low M the outbursts are spaced
approaches
at intervals of many times their mean width. As M
Mcrit, the spacing decreases until the duty cycle becomes 100%
(Lin, Papaloizou, & Faulkner 1985). At this stage the outbursts
473
474 HONEYCUTT
Fig. 2.Periodograms over the period interval 5100 days for seven old
novae and NLCVs, plus three dwarf novae. The input data in each case are
9.5 year light curves from RoboScope. Before producing these periodograms,
eclipse points were removed from the light curves of SW Sex, BH Lyn, and
RW Tri, and the low states were removed from FY Per.
Fig. 3.RoboScope light curve of the NLCV FY Per from 1990 November
to 1999 November showing large faintward excursions as well as oscillations
in the high state with an amplitude of 0.7 mag and a typical period of 32 days.
476 HONEYCUTT
Fig. 9.The 9 year FY Per light curve of Fig. 3, for data brighter than
V p 13, is folded on the periodogram peak at 32.45 days and shown as small
dots. For clarity the data are repeated to make 1.5 cycles. The large filled
circles with error bars are data averaged in phase bins 0.05 phase units wide.
The error bars are the standard deviations of the mean.
Fig. 10.The 9.5 year light curve of the Z Camtype dwarf nova SY Cnc,
folded on its periodogram peak in Fig. 2 of 26.50 days. Points with error bars
are averages as in Fig. 9.
478 HONEYCUTT
Fig. 13.Isolated outburst/dip pairs in the Z Cam star AH Her (1995 February1995 June). Points closer than 5 days are connected by straight lines.
with the extra light in NLCVs that makes them more luminous
than DNs. Another way of looking at this relationship is that the
total energy of a typical stunted outburst is about the same as
the total energy of dwarf nova eruption, because the smaller
amplitude (in mag) stunted outbursts are seen against a brighter
source. This is a firm similarity between stunted outbursts and
DN outbursts and holds regardless of the validity of any hypotheses regarding the existence and nature of extra light.
The widths of the parent distributions in the bottom three
panels of Figure 15 are less than the DN distribution width by
about a factor of 2. This could reasonably be taken as an
important evidence against the idea of extra light being responsible for stunted outbursts. However, the distribution of
the amplitudes of stunted outbursts could be made more narrow
by some combination of the following effects: (1) The distribution of amplitudes of DN eruptions is from well-sampled
data, usually dozens of visual observers. However, the distribution of amplitudes of stunted outbursts is from more poorly
sampled RoboScope data, where the peak of the outburst is
sometimes missed. (2) Low-amplitude stunted outbursts could
be missed entirely in the RoboScope data, narrowing the apparent distribution. (3) Z Cam systems broaden the DN distribution because their amplitudes are systematically smaller
than those in U Gem systems. However, Z Cam systems are
brighter than U Gem systems at the same orbital period. Being
brighter, a Z Cam system could compete more effectively
against a constant background source, so their amplitudes
would not be attenuated as effectively. This effect could also
narrow the amplitude distribution of the stunted outbursts
compared to DNs.
480 HONEYCUTT
TABLE 1
Stunted Outbursts Observed, 19912000
Typea
(2)
Star
(1)
UU Aqr . . . . . . . .
CP Lac . . . . . . . . .
Q Cyg . . . . . . . . . .
RW Sex . . . . . . . .
X Ser . . . . . . . . . . .
HR Lyr . . . . . . . . .
FY Per . . . . . . . . .
DI Lac . . . . . . . . . .
V841 Oph . . . . . .
GI Mon . . . . . . . . .
RW Tri . . . . . . . . .
a
NL
N
N
N
NL
N
NL
N
N
N
NL
No. of Outbursts
(3)
Mean
Amplitude
(mag)
(4)
6
6
5
11
3
6
130
6
7
6
10
0.6
0.6
1.0
0.6
0.6
0.7
0.7
0.4
0.5
0.9
0.5
Typical Spacing
(days)
(5)
75:
200:
200:
50:
300:
Period
(days)
(6)
Mean FWHM
(days)
(7)
60
35
100
28
22
32
60
25
5
6
24
13
20:
most NLCVs do not have stunted outbursts. However, as dis for the
cussed in HRT98, the meager literature estimates of M
NLCV RoboScope program stars do not support the idea that
those NLCVs having stunted outbursts are systematically the
portion of the NLCV population. Perhaps this situation
lower M
is due to the hypothesized background source varying in
strength from system to system so as to obscure any dependence
; that is, the strength
of the presence of stunted outbursts on M
.
of the background source seems to be uncorrelated with M
Several possibilities for the nature of this background source
were briefly discussed in HRT98. We emphasize here a point
briefly mentioned in HRT98. Judging from extensive RoboScope data, there is no correlation of the system brightness
with the appearance of stunted outbursts, either within a given
system or from system to system. This would appear to rule
out accretion luminosity as the source of the background light.
If the extra light is derived from accretion energy, then a system
falls to make the disk unstable to
should become fainter as M
the thermal instability. This appears to argue against an irradiated, truncated disk (Warner 1995b; Leach et al. 1999) in a
system being somehow responsible for the stunted outhigh-M
burst phenomena. Such a configuration would leave the inner
disk in an ionized, high-viscosity state, which would respond
. Casting an initial wide net, this leaves
quickly to changes in M
as possibilities for the postulated background light rotational
energy, magnetic energy, radiation from a hot white dwarf, or
hydrogen burning on the white dwarf.
An intriguing possibility for the background source is nuclear
burning on the white dwarf, for which some qualitative com values
ments can be made. It seems very unlikely that NLCV M
are high enough to allow nuclear burning over a significant
portion of the area of the white dwarf. Rather, the nuclear
burning, if present, probably takes place at the base of magnetic
accretion column(s). The NLCV systems discussed here are
certainly not polars with B 10 7 G, but may nevertheless have
magnetic fields in the range 105107 G without producing con-
REFERENCES
Cannizzo, J. K. 1993, in Accretion Disks in Compact Stellar Systems,
ed. J. C. Wheeler (Singapore: World Scientific), 6
Di Stefano, R., & Nelson, L. A. 1996, in Supersoft X-Ray Sources,
ed. J. Greiner (Lecture Notes in Physics 472; Berlin: Springer), 3
Downes, R., Hoard, D. W., Szkody, P., & Wachter, S. 1995, AJ, 110,
1824
Gansicke, B. T., Sion, E. M., Beuermann, K., Fabian, D., Cheng,
F. H., & Krautter, J. 1999, A&A, 347, 178
Gansicke, B. T., van Teeseling, A., Beuermann, K., & Reinsch, K.
2000, NewA Rev., 44, 143
Greiner, J., Tovmassian, G. H., Di Stefano, R., Prestwich, A.,
Gonzalez-Riestra, R., Szentasko, L., & Chavarra, C. 1999, A&A,
343, 183
Hoard, D. W., Szkody, P., Honeycutt, R. K., Robertson, J., Desai, V.,
& Hillwig, T. 2000, PASP, 112, 1595
Honeycutt, R. K. 1992, PASP, 104, 435
Honeycutt, R. K., Robertson, J. W., & Turner, G. W. 1998, AJ, 115,
2527 (HRT98)
Honeycutt, R. K., Robertson, J. W., Turner, G. W., & Henden, A. A.
1998a, ApJ, 495, 933
Honeycutt, R. K., Robertson, J. W., Turner, G. W., & Mattei, J. A.
1998b, PASP, 110, 676
Honeycutt, R. K., Robertson, J. W., Turner, G. W., & Vesper, D. N.
1994, in ASP Conf. Ser. 56, Interacting Binary Stars, ed. A. W.
Shafter (San Francisco: ASP), 277