Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
This paper reviews most of the research done in the field of tensile buckling characteristics pertaining to aerospace structural
elements with special attention to local buckling and parametric excitation due to periodic loading on plate and shell elements.
The concepts of buckling in aerospace structures appear as the result of the application of a global compressive applied load
or shear load. A less usual situation is the case, in which a global tensile stress creates buckling instability and the formation
of complex spatial buckling pattern. In contrast to the case of a pure compression or shear load, here the applied macroscopic
load has no compressive component and is thus globally stabilizing. The instability stems from a local compressive stress
induced by the presence of a defect, such as a crack or a hole, due to partial or non-uniform applied load at the far end. This is
referred to as tensile buckling. This paper discusses all aspects of tensile buckling, theoretical and experimental. Its far reaching
applications causing local instability in aerospace structural components are discussed. The important effects on dynamic
stability behaviour under locally induced periodic compression have been identified and influences of various parameters
are discussed. Experimental results on simple and combination resonance characteristics on plate structures due to tensile
buckling effects are elaborated.
Key words: Parametric instability, Vibration, Curved panels, Nonlinear behaviour, Tensile buckling
1. Introduction
** Graduate student
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 1
2011-04-12 7:25:59
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1. Combination of tension-compression zone (a) non-uniform
edge load, (b) presence of hole.
DOI:10.5139/IJASS.2011.12.1.1
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 2
2011-04-12 7:25:59
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 3
http://ijass.org
2011-04-12 7:25:59
(2)
Fig. 3. Description of the problem: (a) partial edge loading at one end (b) partial edge loading at the centre (c) partial edge loading at both ends (d)
concentrated edge loading.
DOI:10.5139/IJASS.2011.12.1.1
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 4
2011-04-12 7:26:00
(9)
(4)
where x and y are the rotations of the mid-surface. Also
u, v, w
and u, v, w are the displacement components in the x,
y, z directions at any section and at mid-surface respectively.
The constitutive relationships for the shell are given by
(10)
(5)
where and are termed as static and dyamic load factors
respectively. Using Eqs. (3-5) the equation of motion is
obtained as:
where
(11)
(6)
(12)
Putting this in Eq. (6) and if only first term of the series is
t
t
and cos
,
considered, equating coefficients of sin
2
2
( )
( )
(13)
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 5
http://ijass.org
2011-04-12 7:26:00
(22)
Vibration problem: Assuming that the panel with applied
load vibrates harmonically with angular frequency,
(23)
(16)
(18)
(19)
Geometric stiffness matrix
(20)
Consistent mass matrix
(21)
The overall matrices, [Ke], [Kg] and [M] are obtained by
assembling the corresponding element matrices.
The panels of various geometries can be considered
as follows: spherical (Ry/Rx=1), cylindrical (Ry/Rx=0) and
hyperbolic paraboloid (Ry/Rx=1). With ratios a/Rx and b/Ry
as (0.2, 0.2), (0.0, 0.2) and (-0.2, 0.2) respectively for shallow
panel, b/h=100 for thin shell analysis.
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 6
DOI:10.5139/IJASS.2011.12.1.1
(24)
where, terminologies are explained in Udar and Datta
(2007).
When the frequency of the excitation is close to the sum
or the difference of two natural frequencies of the system, a
combination resonance of the summed type or the difference
2011-04-12 7:26:01
(25)
where is obtained from the solution of a quadratic
equation
(26)
The constant coefficients A, B and C lained in Udar and
Datta (2007).
The two roots of Eq. (26) correspond to two boundaries of
the DIR. The case m=n gives the simple resonance zone and
the case mn gives the combination resonance zone of the
summed or difference type as explained by Choo and Kim
(2000). The critical dynamic load factor, *, corresponds to
the value of for which the expression B24AC=0. For values
of below *, Eq. (26) gives complex roots, which means
dynamic instability cannot occur.
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 7
http://ijass.org
2011-04-12 7:26:01
resonance phenomenon.
Ravi Kumar et al. (2003c) studied the tensile buckling,
vibration and dynamic stability behaviour of multilaminated
curved panels subjected to uniaxial in-plane point and
patch tensile edge loadings. The results in general show
that the introduction of curvature improves the instability
behaviour of the panels. The tensile buckling value for angleply laminates is less than cross-ply laminates because of the
effect of coupling in angle-ply panels.
Effect of aspect ratio and boundary conditions on the
tensile buckling and vibration behaviour of curved panels
was studied Ravi Kumar et al. (2004b, 2006). The results show
that the tensile buckling characteristics are significantly
influenced by the aspect ratio and boundary conditions,
because of extensive non-uniform stress field developed.
Udar and Datta (2007) studied the dynamic analysis of
parametrically excited composite curved panels under nonuniform edge loading. It was observed that the combination
resonance zones of sum type contributes a considerable
amount of instability region and the effects of damping are
destabilizing for higher values of dynamic load factor.
Ravi Kumar et al. (2003b, 2005) has studied the dynamic
instability behaviour of laminated composite plates
subjected to partially distributed non-conservative follower
forces. The in-plane stress distribution is a combination of
tensile and compression zones. In certain domain, when the
tensile zone dominates, it gives rise to stiffening effect. On
the other hand, domination of compressive zone leads to destiffening behaviour. Their effects on divergence and flutter
characteristics are discussed.
DOI:10.5139/IJASS.2011.12.1.1
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 8
3.1 Conclusions
The results from the study of tensile buckling, vibration and
dynamic stability behaviour of curved panels subjected to
non-uniform in-plane stress distribution can be summarised
as follows:
1) The value of tensile buckling load depends on the
strength and area of compressive zones. It is the lowest
under concentrated loading, increases significantly as the
width of loading increases, and approaches infinity as the
load approaches the full load over the edges.
2) Tensile buckling load, generally, increases with the
increase of the curvature of the panel. However, the buckling
behaviour for certain curved panels is similar to that of flat
panels, depending on the edge conditions and aspect ratio
of the panel.
3) The vibration behaviour due to tensile edge loading
shows that for small bandwidths of loading, the natural
frequency initially rises with the load, but begins to fall
beyond certain value of load. The frequencies reduce to
2011-04-12 7:26:01
4.1 Conclusions
The results from a study of the static anti dynamic analysis
of plates with internal opening subjected to uniaxial uniform
periodic loading, compressive or tensile can be summarized
as follows:
1) The fundamental frequency of the plate is affected
by the size and shape of the cutout. Natural frequencies
decrease as the compressive load increases and frequency
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 9
http://ijass.org
2011-04-12 7:26:01
5. Experimental Program
5.1 An experimental study of the static and dynamic
behaviour of a tensioned sheet with a rectangular opening
Datta (1976) performed an experimental study of the
buckling and vibration behaviour of a thin sheet with
rectangular hole in a tensile field. Few salient features of the
experiment are presented here.
The choice of specimen with its geometry and the hole
dimensions is such that it corresponds to an infinite sheet.
This eliminates boundary effects. A typical specimen is
DOI:10.5139/IJASS.2011.12.1.1
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 10
10
2011-04-12 7:26:01
5.2 E
xperiments on parametric vibration response of
plates under tensile loading
Experiments on parametric instability behaviour of
structural elements are very few in the literature because
of the complexities involved. Somerset and Evan-Iwanoski
(1966) and Evan-Iwanoski (1976) have demonstrated some
experimental works on rectangular plates. Ostiguy et al. (1993)
have studied the occurrence of simultaneous resonances in
parametrically excited rectangular plates under compressive
loads. As mentioned earlier, Carlson (1974) and Datta
(1978) presented some experimental results on tensioned
sheet with crack-like opening and slot respectively. A very
comprehensive and controlled experiment work by Deolasi
and Datta (1997a) on parametric resonance of plates under
tensile loading is briefly presented here.
In this work, parametric instability characteristics of
rectangular plates with nearly concentrated eccentric periodic
tensile loading at various locations on the two opposite edges
are studied. Test specimens are shown in Fig. 8.
The test facility, shown in Fig. 6, applying a dynamic load
P(t)=P0+P1 sint, is used. A piezoelectric accelerometer
located on the plate measures the plate response. A schematic
diagram for the measurement of vibration response is shown
in Fig. 9.
The details of the measurement procedure and experimental
techniques are described in Deolasi and Datta (1997a). The
measurement method involves the determination of the lower
5.1.1 Conclusions
The local buckling phenomena of the free edge of the
opening are seen to be dependent on cut-out parameters
like aspect ratio, ratio of cut-out width to plate width, sheet
thickness, cut-out corner radius and edge supports. It is
observed that critical buckling load decreases as the length
of the slot is increased and the critical load increases as the
end radius is increased.
The vibration experiments indicate the frequency versus
applied tension behaviour is markedly affected by the hole
shape. For narrow hole, the plot of frequency versus applied
tension shows a well-defined minimum, corresponding to
the local buckling of the free edge of the hole. For wide hole,
the plots of frequency versus applied tension show kinks,
corresponding to the buckling load. The pre-buckling, onset
of buckling and post buckling phenomenon of the free edge
of the opening are clearly demonstrated.
The stress distribution in rectangular slotted plates under
11
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 11
http://ijass.org
2011-04-12 7:26:02
6. Concluding Remarks
This paper has surveyed the tension buckling behaviour
of aerospace structural elements such as plates and curved
panels. Apart from local static buckling phenomenon,
emphasis is on the DIRs due to periodic parametric excitation
loading. Interesting problems related to flat and curved panels
subjected to eccentric patch loading have been extensively
studied, showing undulations due to load buckling effects.
Plates and curved panels having discontinuities such as
damage, narrow slit and different openings cannot be
avoided in aerospace structure. The present review paper has
discussed the local instability problems due to the presence of
opening in a highly non-uniform stress zone. The occurrence
of flutter due to non-uniform tensile follower edge loading is
an important phenomenon and is discussed.
Dynamic instability phenomenon which are mostly
studied as global effects, have shown to have significant
influence on locally induced tension buckling environment.
On the experimental side, nicely controlled experiments have
demonstrated local buckling phenomenon and its influence
on vibration behaviour and parametric instability through
developments of simple and combination resonance zones.
Fig. 10. Parametric resonance zones for a plate with tensile load at
corner. (a) Simple resonance zones. (b) Combination resonance zones.
DOI:10.5139/IJASS.2011.12.1.1
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 12
12
2011-04-12 7:26:02
Acknowledgements
The first author greatly thanks Prof. Robert L. Carlson,
Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA, USA. for
introducing him to the problem of Tension Buckling and
Prof. Y. Sugiyama, Osaka Prefecture University, Japan for
having introduced him to the fascinating subject of Dynamic
Stability.
References
Backer, G. C. (1972). Static and Dynamic Behaviour of
Tensioned Doubly Connected Plates. PhD Thesis, Georgia
Institute of Technology.
Bert, C. W. and Birman, V. (1988). Parametric instability of
thick, orthotropic, circular cylindrical shells. Acta Mechanica,
71, 61-76.
Bolotin, V. V. (1964). The Dynamic Stability of Elastic
Systems. San Francisco, CA: Holden-Day.
Brock, J. E., Costello, R. G., and Pellet, D. A. (1968). Buckling
of a tensioned panel containing circular hole. AIAA Journal,
6, 2012-2014.
Carlson, R. L. (1974). An experimental study of the
parametric excitation of a tensioned sheet with a cracklike
opening - Results of experimental studies indicate that both
principal and secondary regions of instability are developed.
Experimental Mechanics, 14, 452-458.
Carlson, R. L., Zielsdorff, G. F., and Harrison, J. C. (1970).
Buckling in thin cracked sheets. Proceedings of the Air Force
Conference on Fatigue and Fracture of Aircraft Structures and
Materials, Miami Beach, FL. pp. 193-205.
Cherepanov, G. P. (1963). On the buckling under tension
of a membrane containing holes. Journal of Applied
Mathematics and Mechanics, 27, 405-420.
Choo, Y. S. and Kim, J. H. (2000). Dynamic stability of
rectangular plates subjected to pulsating follower forces.
AIAA Journal, 38, 353-361.
Clarkson, B. L. (1965). The propagation of fatigue cracks
in a tensioned plate subjected to acoustic loads. In W. J.
Trapp and D. M. Forney, eds. Acoustical Fatigue in Aerospace
Structures. Syracuse, NY: N. Y. Syracuse University Press. p.
361.
Datta, P. K. (1976). An experimental study of the static and
dynamic behaviour of a tensioned sheet with a rectangular
opening. Aeronautical Quarterly, 27, 257-262.
Datta, P. K. (1978). An investigation of the buckling
13
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 13
http://ijass.org
2011-04-12 7:26:02
DOI:10.5139/IJASS.2011.12.1.1
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 14
14
2011-04-12 7:26:02
15
(001-015)10-IJASS.indd 15
http://ijass.org
2011-04-12 7:26:02