Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
I.
INTRODUCTION
IN ironmaking
B. Importance of Drying
The feed mixture to a sintering operation contains both
constitutive water (water chemically bound to the solids)
and free water. Constitutive water comes mainly from
ores and exists in low concentrations; its removal occurs
by dehydration reactions. Free water comes from ores,
fluxes, and mainly from water added to aid the pelletizing process. It represents 6 to 12 wt pct of the feed mixture for iron ore, and 4 to 6 wt pet for zinc ore. Free
water removal is an important step in the sintering operation because of the high thermal energy consumption
required for drying (up to 25 pet of the requirements for
iron ore sintering) and the reduced permeability of the
overmoistened (i.e., with excess water, after condensation) zone, which obstructs gas flow.
As shown in Figure 2, when the hot gases leave the
reaction zone and enter the moist zone, they dry the solids and become loaded with water vapor. But, as will
be shown, when these now very moist gases come in
contact with the colder charge in the deep layers of the
bed, water condenses on the solids. Therefore, the term
"moisture transfer" will be used to include both drying
and condensation.
C. Previous Descriptions
In the past, moisture transfer has been described in a
rather simplified manner in various mathematical models
of the sintering process. For drying, the simplest approach considers that it takes place entirely at a fixed
temperature of 100 ~
Other authors introduce a twostage drying model: first, drying occurs at a constant rate
and, after, at a rate that decreases linearly with the moisture content, t4-9] Yoshinaga and Kubo [1~ mention a threestage drying process but give a single equation where
the drying rate decreases continuously with decreasing
moisture content. Except for Cumming e t a l . , [11] w h o used
semiempirical results obtained for hematite p e l l e t s , [12] the
specific transport properties of the materials have not been
taken into account. Condensation has either been ignored [3-7,1~ or assumed to occur after the gas has become
bulk-saturated (when the dew-point temperature is equal
to the gas temperature), with the gas remaining saturated
during condensation. [L2] Toda and Kato ES] and Kasai
et al.[9] consider a condensation rate that depends on the
difference between the gas humidity and the saturation
humidity and an arbitrary constant. In the work of
Cumming et al.,tH] it is assumed that condensation occurs when the gas is saturated at a temperature midway
between that of the solids and the gases.
Few papers are specifically concerned with the study
of moisture transfer during the sintering operation. Korotic
and Puzanov E~3]first explained the mechanism of the formation of an overmoistened zone. Wajima et al. ~4] studied the influence of the amount of condensed water on
the permeability of the bed, both experimentally and using
VOLUME 21B, FEBRUARY 1990--37
II. E X P E R I M E N T A L S T U D Y
OF DRYING OF ORE PELLETS
Ores
Ftuxes
Ignition
Water
..
sinter
llll
11111
tAIAt&l&l/ l? /
G~ : 02" N2" C02" CO" H20" etc'
Roughing 1
oo,,no
Screening
Undersized Slnterto
slnter blostfurnece
Fig. 1 -
D. Outline
In order to optimize the iron ore sintering and zinc ore
sinter-roasting processes, a mathematical model of the
operation has been developed. The model, described in
p r e v i o u s a r t i c l e s , [16'17,18] permits calculation of the timedependent temperatures and compositions of the solids
and gases throughout the bed. In the present paper, the
study of moisture transfer during the strand sintering
process is fully discussed, giving particular attention to
describing, from a macroscopic viewpoint, the moisture
transfer phenomena during the drying of a packed bed
by hot gases, and from a microscopic viewpoint, the
moisture transport properties of the drying materials.
The mechanisms for moisture transfer in a packed bed,
including recondensation of water in the deep layers, are
described and explained. The model proposed is also applicable to other processes in which similar drying occurs. The model is validated by comparing its results
with measurements taken during predrying experiments
on a pilot pot.
The moisture transport properties of the drying materials have been studied experimentally to characterize
the behavior of iron and zinc ore pellets.
Gos
Temperoture of solids
$ ~ (]iF
or ~
The experimental work was carried out by thermogravimetry. The moistened pellets were placed in a wiremesh basket and then dried in a furnace by a forced flow
of hot gas. The weight loss was continuously recorded.
The operating conditions are given in Table I. When a
sample stopped losing weight, it was weighed, placed in
an oven at 150 ~ for several hours, and then weighed
again to determine its dry mass. Curves showing drying
rate vs moisture content are calculated from the weight
loss vs time information. Examples of these curves are
given in Figure 3.
B. Interpretation
These experiments clearly show that the drying process is divided into two characteristic periods, one at a
constant drying rate and one at a continuously decreasing
rate. This behavior, typical of porous materials, can be
explained as follows.
1. First period--constant drying rate
During this period, heat from the gases is fully utilized
to evaporate water on the surface of the solids. The system is in a state of dynamic equilibrium. The surface
temperature remains constant (i.e., at the wet-bulb temperature, Tw), and the surface is saturated with water.
The drying rate during this period can be calculated from
external heat or mass transfer balances.
2. Second period--decreasing drying rate
When the moisture content of the solids decreases, the
internal transport of water to the surface is not fast enough
to maintain saturation on the entire surface. The moisture content at this point is called the "critical moisture
content," Wcr. The drying rate begins to decrease, as the
internal resistance to moisture transfer becomes significant. Various shapes of the ends of the drying curves are
observed, depending on the material being dried.
The critical moisture content was found to be different
for iron ore (-~5 pct) than for zinc ore ( > 1 0 pct). For
iron ore pellets, several authors t4'6,81 have used a value
of 2 pct, without stating the origin of this value. I f the
Table I. Operating Conditions
for Thermogravimetry Experiments
:lntered zone
Reocti0n zone
t.)
t4-J
t,~
Dried
zone
Moist
zone
Gas mixture
Gas temperature
Superficial
velocity
Initial mass
Harmonic
diameter
Initial moisture
content
dry air
22 ~ to 100 ~
dry air
30 ~ to 90 ~
7 cm. s -~
about 1 g
2.8 mm
5.0 mm
up to 12 pct
up to 12 pct
METALLURGICAL TRANSACTIONS B
0.8
Tg = 59"C
c r i t i c a l moisture
Tg = 99%
content locus
'~ 0.6
X
x
XiX
I
x
x
falling
':~ 0.2
Rr = R/RM
rate
drying
constant rate
d ryi ng
/
l
e-
x
x
0.4
O~
O 00
00o
content is zero)
O0 o
R~ = R/Rtr
2
10
Wr = (W-
(a)
g0*C]
Tg
0.8
+
constant
rat~
/
d ~ i ng
~groscopic + [ nonhygroscopic
/
behavior
behavior
~ m s s ~ s ~ m ~
+I /
r
~s
~0.6
v
2.?'"
0.4
e-
transition m i s t u r e
content locus
0,2
R = RM" P(Wr)
+
s
Weq)]/(Wtr- Weq)
These two different normalizations were based on physical considerations. In the case of zinc ore, the transition
point is the experimental characteristic point, whereas
for iron ore, the critical point is obviously the reference
to be considered.
In each case, a single curve was obtained, which is
characteristic of the drying of iron ore pellets (Figure 4(a))
and of zinc ore pellets (Figure 4(b)). The drying rate at
any instant is calculated from the known maximum drying
rate, Ru (see Section I I I - B ) , and the equation of the
characteristic drying curve, P(Wr), obtained by polynomial regression. In the case of iron ore, the drying rate
i s given by
Tg = 70~
_
!
12
[la]
10
[lbl
12
Since, in the case of zinc ore, R,~ is not known analytically, we use
(b)
Fig. 3 - - E x p e r i m e n t a l drying rate
pellets and (b) zinc ore pellets.
vs
R = f . Ru" P(W~)
moisture content: (a) iron ore
P(Wr) = - 0 . 0 5 6 0 3 + 3 . 2 1 5 5 W r - 3.9223W 2
+ 2.2488W~ - 0.4914W 4
critical moisture contents are compared to the usual initial moisture contents for the sintering process (5 to 12 pct
for iron ore and 4 to 5 pct for zinc ore), it is concluded
that the drying of iron ore pellets during the sintering
operation occurs in two periods (at constant and at decreasing rate), whereas for zinc ore sinter-roasting, the
decreasing rate drying commences directly.
In addition, the shape of the drying curves is different.
In the case of iron ore (Figure 3(a)), during the second
period, the curve is concave downward. This is characteristic of hygroscopic behavior. The final (equilib-"
rium) moisture content, Weq, is close to zero. In the case
of zinc ore (Figure 3(b)), a period is observed during
which the curve is concave upward, characterizing nonhygroscopic behavior. Later, below a transition moisture
content, Wt, hygroscopic behavior appears. Such features can also be found during the drying of other materials, such as wood, for example, t~9] In the case of zinc
ore, the equilibrium moisture content is about 1 pet.
METALLURGICAL TRANSACTIONS B
[2a]
[2b]
A. General Equations
As noted earlier, the present model of moisture transfer during the sintering operation is part of a comprehensive model that simulates the entire sintering
process. [16JTA8l The equations used to describe heat and
mass transfer in the moist zone are as follows (see
Nomenclature for symbols):
Thermal balance of the gases:
0
upgCpg Ox Tg
[3]
1.2
x
"
e2 ~"
O
=~j~
0.8
I~l
k..
cn n K
.~ ~'~
~m 111
I}1~0
~
0"
I
I
I
,
I
constant r a t e
drying
x~ 0./I ~ J e
falling r a t e i
It:
~ ~
0.5
1.5
Reduced m o i s t u r e c o n t e n t
2.5
(g/Wcr)
ag = 6(1 - e)/de
(a)
1.4
pv,,(Ts)=exp
Iinonhygroscopic
I
i
i
i
~1.2
.
~ o.~
ox
~0.6
a~
[8]
k.
[7]
behavior
25.541-
5211~
T~ /
[9]
[]
[]
[]
0
The term PH:o is the vapor pressure in the bulk gas, and
k is the mass transfer coefficient, as defined by Krischer. I22~
o~ oQ_S'W--~
~t~R
hTg
k =
[10]
hygroscopic
3.155P~(1-
behavior
oXt3 ? ~
0.24Xm)(1 + ~ ) ( 1 - - X m )
~0J4
0.2
Oil
0.2
Odt
0,6
0.8
Reduced m o i s t u r e c o n t e n t
1.2
1,g
([ W-WeoI/[ gtr-Weq] )
(b)
Fig. 4--Characteristic drying curve: (a) iron ore pellets and (b) zinc
ore pellets (the various markers represent runs carried out under different experimental conditions).
Ts) - MH2O r a 2 o L ~ ( T ~ )
[4]
OX U C H 2 0 :
- - e Ot C H 2 0 + rH~o
[5]
--MH20
rH20
[6]
The term Xm is the logarithmic mean of the molar fraction of vapor in the bulk gas and at the saturated surface.
The value of rR is used to determine the regime of
moisture transfer (drying or condensing) and, hence, the
appropriate form of the equations.
If rR < 0, there is condensation, and rHz0 = rR.
If rR -- 0, there is drying, and rn2o depends on the
case considered. For iron ore, if W -> Wet, "equilibrated"
(first-period) drying takes place, and rn2o = rR. If W <
Wcr, decreasing rate drying occurs, and rn2o is calculated
from the characteristic drying curve using Eq. [1]. For
zinc ore, drying always occurs at decreasing rate, and
rnzo is calculated from the characteristic drying curve using
Eq. [2].
The value of rM in Eqs. [1] and [2] can be determined
from the mass transfer relationship (rM = rR(Tw)) or from
the thermal balance of the solids, since during the first
period, drying takes place at a rate such that the temperature of the solids remains constant and equal to T~.
This thermal balance is written
agh(Tg - Tw)
=
MH2orMLv(Tw)
(heat brought by gases)
(heat for evaporation)
[111
rM
agh
(Tg
Tw)
I12]
MrhoLv(Tw)
auk
ag h
(Tg - Tw) =
(Pv+a,(Tw)- Pn2o)
MH2oLv(Tw)
-~g
[ 13]
1. Principle
Hot air leaving a Cowper stove passes through the
charge and dries it. Thermocouples are used to measure
the temperatures of the solids and of the inlet and outlet
gas. Gas flow rate and pressure drop are controlled. In
order to determine the moisture content of the outlet gas,
the pot has been fitted with a hygrometric measurement
apparatus that includes a gas collector in the exhaust pipe
and a LiC1 hygrometer to measure the dew point. However, this measurement is affected by condensation of
iron ore
2. Results
From these experiments, we have determined the variation in time of the temperature of the solids at various
positions and the temperature and moisture content of
the outlet gas.
B. Comparison of Computed and Measured Results
Using the model based on the equations already described, predrying experiments on the pilot pot have been
successfully simulated. The results of these simulations
are presented below. The discussion and interpretation
of the shape of the curves are given later in Section V.
Figure 5 shows the comparison between the computed
Ts(t) curves and those measured by seven thermocouples
placed in the charge for experiment A (Table II). Very
good agreement between predictions and measurements
is noted. At a given depth, the evolution of the temperature curve shows several stages:
(1) a short plateau at the initial temperature (25 ~
(2) a small and rapid rise;
(3) a plateau with temperatures between 55 ~ (at the
beginning) and 45 ~ (at the end); for a usual complete
sintering experiment, these temperatures would be slightly
greater; and
(4) an increase in temperature up to the temperature of
the drying gas.
All of these stages are reproduced by the calculations,
and, particular!y, the length of the plateau is well represented for all depths. A few experimental points at high
temperatures deviate from the simulation results, but since
these points indicate temperatures greater than those of
the drying gas, it is concluded that the discrepancies are
caused by irregularities in the measurements.
Figure 6 shows the comparison between the dew-point
temperature of the outlet gases measured by the hygrometer and computed by the model for the same experiment. Measurement of the dew point is a method of
500
l~Ol ~
400
.,
:,
iron ore
zinc ore
iron ore
iron ore
METALLURGICAL
TRANSACTIONS
~ 200
I
,.,
t
+
~
i
100
+]
0
x+
~.
400
I.
i'.
i
/
..+
I"
i~
o f-a-':7~:~
mI
- - -.- _
/.
,'o
+o~
~ ~ ~--~-.2"~-~'~-
lii
~ o o
--+ 0*__o*
....
.."
300
~ /--~.q~-~.~
i
/
]^
*+
,.i
,,
,'
i o~
<
,'+
~
;
./ - "
,'
:::::
.....
- -Is c|
--2+era
, ]
+/
- - - 77 cm
.A?_+;_2' ....... J
800
r. II
11 ~
+,
+'
1200
I
I
+~+,
1600
2000
Time (s)
Fig. 5
Comparison of experimental and computed solid temperature vs time during predrying experiment A (iron ore).
V O L U M E 21B, F E B R U A R Y 1 9 9 0 - - 4 1
6O
,,
30
.......
10 ~
L
0
Measueed,
~-
Computed
3b0
9b0
1 00
1 00
is00
Time (s)
Fig. 6--Comparison of experimental and computed dew-point temperature of the outlet gas during predrying experiment A (iron ore).
DISCUSSION
Temperature (*C)
02550
200 - .
.
GAS
Falling
79 8.
It
Drying r o t e rH90
(mol.m_3,s_l) L
0
IO0
-50
soLids T
D r i e d zone
rate drying
"Constant"rate
Solid moisture
content W (Z)
drying
'-I
tl
(,D " - I
Overmoistened
subzone
II
.-I
C
b,,--,.
II
O.
"4
Condensation subzone
e - - - Raw subzone
GAS
<
X
60
-r
50
,"
,'"
/ .". . . . . . . . .
a~ 40
f,,,.
ii
""-
~rL---
N
"-----:---
i / i / /
4. Raw subzone
The raw subzone consists of that portion of the charge
where moisture transfer has not yet commenced. It extends from point (e) to the bottom of the bed.
P 30
~ 20
--Tglgas)
/ . . . . Td(dew-point)
10
-*---:-Td (t-220)
120
240
360
480
600
Time (s)
Fig. 8--Experimental temperature and dew-point temperature of the
outlet gas during predrying experiment B (iron ore).
METALLURGICAL TRANSACTIONS B
20
~0
60
BO
t~O
20
60
80
100
120
220
2~.o
_a?-,-
200 9
180
~.J 180
16o
'C
160
1~0
\
120
lt~O
,00
--
<"
-
__
6
~'0
-_
.20%
16cm
18cm
wet-bulb temperature ( % )
relative humidity (%)
5 nm between each point
.....
.....
t00%
cm
r
]
.t-bulb ts
y -6.5cm
(~
e
humidity (%)
5 m between each point
1~)0
0
120
0
100
o
~
40
32cm
32cm
ta
9
60%
...-,)
,1,o.
20
.?
6o
~ 1 ~ "1_
,~J c l l & - c t
\/
20~
~ 7 o ,
\~
6o
~O
lO~
[0~
120
80
~o
200
220
[] 2cm
o ~
0
0%
80
~0
~"6"0~
~5c|
o'- 10cm
0 0
B'
16cm
9t,
m. 60
O R B - 12cm
~os
[]
,,/,'0 0
7.5cm 0
9
~
Cl -I.5 cm
8O
ae
o a~176
o
a,O-6cm
0
0
o 0
0
'5
"~ - 20
4o
- 60
32cm
O0 0
O0
O0
20
30
t~O
50
0 0 0 0 0 0 O0
60
70
80
gO
100 110
120 130
OoDoODO0
10
20
(a)
diagrams
30
40
50
60
?0
80
90
(b)
d r y i n g rate d u r i n g a p r e d r y i n g e x p e r i m e n t :
'-6,5cm
Fig. 9 - - M o l l i e r
32cml2~1
- 20
10
( a ) i r o n o r e ( c a s e A ) a n d (b) z i n c o r e ( c a s e
C).
500
w i t h condensation
oG
q00
300
without
condensation
200
o
u~ I00
2;0
4;0
8b0
6;0
looo
Time ( s )
2. Influence of condensation
Figure 11 shows the influence of considering condensation (case C, zinc ore). It is seen that if condensation
is neglected, the initial rise in temperature is poorly described, and the total duration of drying is overly reduced. This comparison shows as well the harmful
influence of condensation on the rate of water removal
and, consequently, on the productivity of the sintering
operation. Similar results are obtained for the case of
iron ore.
Fig. 11 - - Comparison of the computed solid temperature v s time during a predrying experiment with condensation (case C, zinc ore) and
without considering condensation.
maps of the moisture content of the solids during a normal operation (case D) and during an operation with a
preheated charge (60 ~ case E) are presented. The abscissa represents time (equivalent to distance along the
grate), and the ordinate the height in the bed. The dotted
line indicates the boundaries of the overmoistened zone.
The considerable decrease of the extent of this zone after
preheating should be noticed, as well as the appreciable
decrease of m a x i m u m attained moisture contents.
VI.
CONCLUSIONS
d:Ying'r~
,.
u
c
firstp e r i o d
only
MO~it
,i.it
lL,oora,e~
c~
ratedrying
solid
2880
//
~= 300
cm
20o
,~NV.O%
~a
~
. drying
con~ensat ion~
~7 %, over--
Dried zone
front
~<"~
~.~
~ , ~ : c - - T a. t t l n g.
~'~
rate drying
m o i s t e n e d zonee .l'zml
m~176
l i m ~ . ~ " c o n s t a n t ,,
....
Time (s)
(a) Initial
~N
% Z ~ ~
40
C, 400
0r,e0z0ne
over.oistened
con--,
500
two p e r i o d s
84
300
660
9do
1260
I;oo 18oo
Time (s)
Fig. 10--Comparison of the computed solid temperature v s time during a predrying experiment when drying occurs in first period only
and in two periods (case A, iron ore).
METALLURGICAL TRANSACTIONS B
40
(b) I n i t i a l
Moist z o n e ~
Time (s)
solid
,, r a t e
drying
2880
moisture content has been determined, and the characteristic drying curve has been given. Drying of zinc ore
pellets always takes place with a decreasing rate, because the critical moisture content is higher than the usual
moisture contents for the sintering practice. The characteristic drying curve has also been given. In the sintering process, gases leaving the drying zone are highly
loaded with water, and during the early stages of the
operation, this water condenses in colder layers. Passage
of the condensation front leaves behind an overmoistened (+1 to 2 pct water), inert (without heat or
moisture transfer), heated (typically 55 ~
and low
permeability zone, which remains until the drying front
arrives.
An accurate description of these phenomena using a
mathematical model has allowed us to successfully simulate predrying experiments on a pilot pot and to calculate all of the variables relative to moisture transfer.
The necessity of describing both the two periods of drying
and the condensation period has been shown and the influence of changing operating conditions, such as preheating the charge to reduce condensation, has been
studied. It is believed that this approach can be directly
adapted to other processes where a hot gas passes through
a moist packed bed.
NOMENCLATURE
ag
Cn2o
pg
de
f
h
k
Lv
MH2O
PH20
Pvsat
P
P(W~)
FH20
rM,RM
rR
R
R
Rr
gtr
t
Td
r~
T~
Tw
u
w.
~q
W,r
x
x~
E
4,
Pa
Pg
~'12O
(-)
(-)
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This study has been performed with the scientific and
financial support of IRSID, which is interested in modeling the iron ore sintering process, and MINEMET
RECHERCHE, which is interested in modeling the
zinc ore sinter-roasting process. At IRSID, we thank
Drs. E. Marli~re, C. Dulcy, J.M. Steiler, and P. Riboud
for their collaboration and for allowing us to have pilot
pot experiments at our disposal. Since 1984, the iron ore
sintering study has been part of the Groupement
Scientifique "Fonte de haute puret6," jointly financed by
IRSID and CNRS. At MINEMET RECHERCHE, we
thank Drs. G.Sanchez and S. Jorget for their collaboration. In addition, we wish to thank Dr. B. Lally, who
kindly assisted with the English translation of this paper.
REFERENCES
1. I.R. Dash and E. Rose: Ironmaking and Steelmaking, 1978,
vol. 5 (1), pp. 25-31.
2. M.J. Cumming, G.W. Barton, and R.J. Batterham: in Proc. 4th
Biennial Conf. Simulation Society Australia, Brisbane, 1980,
pp. 108-19.
3. G.W. Healy: J. Met., 1981, vot. 33 (I), pp. 30-37.
4. I. Muchi andJ. Higuchi: Trans. lronSteellnst. Jpn., 1972, vol. 12,
pp. 54-63.
5. T. Tukamoto, S. Shimada, T. Taguchi, and J. Higuchi: Tetsuto-Hagan(, 1970, vol. 56 (6), pp. 661-70.
6. R.W. Young: lronmaking and Steelmaking, 1977, vol. 4 (6),
pp. 321-28.
7. S. Nigo, K. Kimura, M. Ichimiya, S. Yasumoto, K. Nakashima,
and T. Kasahara: Tetsu-to-Hagand,
1982, vol. 68 (2182),
pp. 118-25.
8. H. Toda and K. Kato: Trans. Iron Steellnst. Jpn., 1984, vol. 24,
pp. 178-86.
9. E. Kasai, J. Yagi, and Y. Omori: in Proc. 43rdlronmaking Conf.,
ISS-AIME, Warrendale, PA, 1984, pp. 241-49.
10. M. Yoshinaga and T. Kubo: Sumitomo Search, 1978, vol. 20 (11),
pp. 1-14.
11. M.J. Cumming, W.J. Rankin, J.R. Siemon, J.A. Thurlby, G.J.
Thornton, E.A. Kowalczyk, and R.J. Batterham: in Proc. 4th
Int. Symp. Agglomeration, AIME, Warrendale, PA, 1985,
pp. 763-76.
12. J.A. Thurlby and R.J. Batterham: Trans. Inst. Min. Metall., 1980,
sect. C, vol. 89, pp. C125-31.
13. V.I. Korotic and V.P. Puzanov: Izv. Vyssh. Uchebn. Zaved. Chem.
Metall., 1984, vol. 10, pp. 28-33.
14. M. Wajima, Y. Hosotani, J. Shibata, H. Soma, and K. Tashiro:
Tetsu-to-Hagan~, 1982, vol. 68 (1719), pp. 45-53.
15. W.J. Rankin and P.W. Roller: Trans. Iron Steellnst. Jpn., 1987,
vol. 27, pp. 190-96.
16. F. Patisson, D. Ablitzer, C. Dulcy, E. Marli~re, and J.M. Steiler:
in Proc. 5th Int. Iron Steel Congress, ISS-AIME, Warrendale,
PA, 1986, vol. 6, pp. 511-14.
METALLURGICAL TRANSACTIONS B
METALLURGICAL TRANSACTIONS B