Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 287

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 1 of 222

t.
J

'
:
l
.
l
l-

M ONTGOM ERY v.ETREPPID,DEPT 0F DEFENSE


Case No.CV-N-06-056
SEALED TILANSCRIPT OF HEARJN G OX
PRELIM INARY IN JtJNCTION DATED 2-7-2006

(VOLUM E lOF I1),IN 2NDJ'UDICJM DISTRICT COURT


OF N EV A DA, COUNTY OF W A SHOE,

CASENO.CV06-00114,DEPT.9

b'

-- ... ... ..... ..

............... -...-

i
j
j
j
1
((
.

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 2 of 222

*-*11

.--- ----

- --

- .- -

- -

.- ..-

'

;@
!6.
a
;.
f
'(
.
;r.
-co,s
p-j ?.,o:j
yjy
3

-.

'.

i '. . ..'

e :
c?1J
z5j 4

-:-.
u
!'k

-. - .

& :tr
I.%

== J42

5ra.

7 r=is

7
g

- - ?;z.J

rs .

SEC()ND JUDTClA, D!S,PRIC% COUR1, (.)E, st,jjs svp,,yy, oy, uuvsops


tN P

XN() F()R 'l'HE C0UH'


l.Y OF WASi
4OEl

I
3EE-OREL l'i4F2 HoNtlrtal3t,- RO B EIRT lt. PIqR R Y , U TS T R ILC
T klu uc E
-

o(.
)0-

ET RE PP ID T EC H NO IuC)G Th.u S . L -L .C . . (1
N e va d a L im it e d Lia iai 1. ity C o m pa n '
t',

10
Pla intiff ,
11

No . CV 06-O0114
VS .

12
'

t
'

'

E ep t . No . 9

D E NN I S MO 1
$1T G O M E 1)Y , a n i.n d i v id ua 1;
T HE M ON T G O M 1!R Y 113AM (L Y 14il(JST ;
D ENN 1E; MON T (5OM ElILY 4n d BR ElN DA
MONTGOME RY , a s 1 ru 25t ee s fo r 'FP.FS
M O N T GO M ER Y FA M 1 !lY 'rR 7 ST , a n d
DO E S l th ro ug h .,?0 ,
.

l3

14

.
.

15

'

16

I)e fi?n.
Ja n ts .
.

/
17

18

S E A L E D

19
20

VOLUME I of 11
T RANSCR IPT CF PROCZEDINGS
HEAR ING - PRRLIM INARY INJUNC TION

21

Tuesday , February 7, 2006

22

RENO , N EVA LIA

23
.q .

f.

'

k.'..
.

21

.
.

. .

. (jr) (j

..

W c'U
G .#2 ,
O :11
'-* ay.
t!
. N

.,

e 2ll:

R
=
>
-

' t.

Reported By :

LIZA CHAPEN , RMR, NV CCR #93

California CSR #2065


L IZA C HA PE'
,N , CCR , RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 3 of 222


'

..,.e'y

x-...

l
l

S g) P I!
1 A R A )1 C! El S

2
3

l''t-)r t)h (a 15
71a in t i f f :

HA L R , LA lE ; PF E K , L)F,N li1s O N & HO WA R D

BY :
5

J'
1'E PH EN J . PZ FuK , RS QU 1R E

- -a nd - J E R RY M . S N Y DER , E SQ U 1 RE
5 4 4 'L K Le t z ke i,a ne , ETe C:on d Enlo o r
!1e no . N t
av a d a 8 9 5 11
.

P IL l,S13(JR Y W 1N T H RO P 3$H A W P1T T M A H

13Y :
9

D A k;i 1
3 A . JA KO P 1H , F S QU 1R E

;?4 7 5 i!a n o ve r J!t 17ee t


P a lo th1 1Ech, C a l i.fo rn ia 94 30 4 - 1 1 14

10
11

F'o r t h e De fen(1a n t s :

12

LA W O F'1
?I(-E'
,S C)F L OG A R & P(JL V ER r A P C

BY :
l3
14

ikO MAL D J . LOGA R , ElSQ U 1R E

- - a nd -ER fC A . PU L V E R , E S Q U IR E
2 2 5 S;. lbr'1 in(gt o n A v en u e , E;u it e A
ILe no , N e v ad a 8 9 50 l
.

15
16
17
l8

FL YN N & S rg1)L LM A N
M 1C i1A EL J . F LY NN , E SQ U IR E
- a rtd - P /1IL 'gP H . .ST JL LMAN y E SQ U IR E
2 2 4 B i ql
rtingham D ri ve , S u ite 1A 4
C a rd i ff , C a l i fo rn i.a 9 20 0 7

RY :

19
20

21
22

23
$

24

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

;?

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 4 of 222


-.e
xv
3

2
3

V IJ D .j'
rX
-

IjJ-T.FR6;ShlS FOR T H K PluJLh141E''

PYG Z

SL OA N V ENA B L E S
D ir e ct E)x a rftin a t io ri L)y Ja ko p in
C ro s s- f:x a m i na t io I
R b b' F 1yn n
Re d i re c t R x am in a 12io n iay Ja ko p i;4
Re c r os s -E x aInn a t.i()n i7.y F ).y nn

21
53
1 37
1 54

6
'

ZE HA NG S UN
D ir e ct Ex am i na t orl L)y J a ko p in
C ro s s- R xa m ina t i o (R b j' 1?1y nn

'

17 4
19 2

8
9
10
11

K EN DA L L RO M A N
D.
i.re c t E x am in a t i :7rl k)y J a ko p in
V o 1 r D ir e Ex am i n at)i c)n t)y F ly n n
C2on t inu ed L)i re c t F,x :4m L11a ti o:1 L)y J a ko p in
C ro s s -E x am in a t i o r
R b y F 1yn n
Re d ire c t E x am i n a t:i.o ri b y Ja ko p j n
Rec ross Fxam inat ion hy Flynn

203
212
211
218
222
223

WARREN TREPP
Direct Exam inat ion by Jakop in

22 6

l2
-

13
14
15
16
17

18
19

20
21
22

23

24

LIZA CHAPEN , CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 5 of 222


....

1
(

''... .

!?
- u-..
!i-l--M..- -T -J- -

MCSIGNATION

MFRFRO ADMITTED

Exhibit 1

70

--

Ex h ib i t 2

230

235

Exh ibit 3

2 38

240

Exh ibit 4

245

217

Exh ibit 5

247

248

Exhib it 6

253

254

Exhib it 7

2 54

256

10
11
12
13
14

15
16

17
18

19
20
21
22

23

24

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 6 of 222


...e.

.-...

REN O , N KVA DA , i13u e F.


5C1a y , 'eb rt2a ry 7 : 2 0 0 6 , 9 :0 1 A .M .

- oOo -'

@$

1'H E C()U R'


1':

G o od nlo rn in g .

Plea s(? i)e seated .

A l 1. r.L(
Jh t .

W e 're .
Ln se s s i on f o r

C V 0 6 - 00 1 14 .

Pre lim i.nary InjuIRc1.ion .

l0

nO:01

W e '17e he r e fo r cp h ea ri n g o n a

W o u 1 c1 c o un s e l s ta t e y o u r a pp e a ra n c e s fo r

t he co u rt re p o r t:(7r .

0::04

11

M R . PlrE'
.K :

G oo d m (3rn i.n g r y ou r H on o r .

12

S te p h e n E'ee k o n L)e h a lf o f th e P la in t i ff ,

'

13

e'
Pre p p i d T e c hn o lo g i
.E,s .

14

A 1 so w i 1r.l
't m e t hi s mo rn in g , an d yo u si gne d

15

t he o rde r on th e p r t) h ac v ic e , is Da v id Ja kop i n ,

16

c o -c o u n s e 1 ; D o u g E'r 5,e , l
na na g e r o f e T re pp id ; a n d

17

Wa r re n T r epp , a 1.
so rrtan age r a n d ch i e f exe cu h ive

18

o f f 1ce r o f e'
P re pp id .

19

T H E CO U R T :

A 1 1 r ig h t .

20

MR . LOGAR :

You r Hon or r i f i t p lea s e the

t,

Thank you .

21

C o u rt , I 'm Ro n a ld L o ga r rep r e s ent ing t h e De fe nda n t .

22

a lo n g w it h M r . E r5c Pu 1v e r i n m y o f f ic e .

23
24

1 w o u ld li.ke to i n t ro du c e t o y o u a M ic h ae 1
J . Flynn .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

00:o4

(775) 323-5492

o0:04

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 7 of 222


*.- #

' M R . FluY H N :

M R . LO GA R :

pro hac vice has been made .

T h e ap p l Lc a t io n f o r ad m ia s io n to

T h e M a ss ac h u se t ts Ba r ha s s en t a

00:05

Certificate of Gocd Standing to the State Bar of

Hevada .

a pp ro v a l .

The State Bar of Nevada has issued its

lt wa s over-nighted yeste rda y to my

10

office .

It sho uld be received by Federal Exp ress

11

about 10 :00 or 10 :30 th is m orn ing: h avinq complied

12

with the Supreme Court rule as to adm ission , and we

13

a s k t ha t M r . F'A y n 11 be pe rmi 1.te d t o a p (7e a r in th is

14

m a t te r o n b eh a 2 f ()f t he De f en d Esn t .

15

M R . PE L'K :

Y o u r I1on 0 r , 1 w o u l d h av e no

l6

objection basecl o11 t14at reJ)resentation that it is

17

b e i ng o v e r - n i g h te d an d s h ou ld b e h e re t o d ay .

18

accep t Mr . Logar 's repre sentation as an o fficer of

19

this court .

20

So 1 certainly -- although I 've not seen

the p ro hac v ice application , l expect the Bar to do

22

their job .

21

TH E COIJRT :

A l1 right .

On th at basis ,

that will be fine. We'1l allow that.

L1ZA CiIAPFIN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

ao:os

Qo:0s

21

23

M r . F'Ly n n is a m em b e r o f the

M as sa c h u se tt s B a r.

G o od Ino rn in (
g y y(7u r ilo n o r .

.. .

oo:os

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 8 of 222


.
,..

....,

1.

M r . PlRilir) S tillman .

good stancikng o f P()th Lhe Massachustts and the State

B a r o f C a l f o rn i a .

Mr . St ktlman is a member in

He has mcde application to the State Bar

o f Hev ada fo r admission and app rova l p ro hac vice .

His Cer tificate of Good Standing w as sen t to the

State Bar 's office in Las Vegas yeste rday b y the

State of California .

10

It 's expected that the State Rar o f

11

Massachusetts wi . l send the Certificate of Good

12

Stand ing to the Las Veqas office tod ay , and then the

13

Las Vegas office will issue its approval and we

14

expect that w ithsn the n ext tw o days .

15

An(
-1 t he IA 1 'd 1. i ke to in t rod u ce

M R . L ('
)CJh R :

The de lay on Mr . St i llman is due to the

16

fa c t t h at M r . Stlllman p rov ided with his app lication

17

t o t h e St a te B a r r ec e nt adm i s s ion b e f o re a F e d er a l

18

Court in the State of California ; however

19

was b eyond 30 days ' tme o f issuance from the date of

20

app lication , the S tahe Bar sa id they needed something

21

more current , so that is the --

22

MR . PFEK :

00:06

00:06

since it

Your Honor, absent the app roval

23

by th e State Har , E would object to his admission

24

until the State Bar has at least had its opportunity

LIZA CHAPEN , CCR, RMR

00:06

(775) 323-5192

:c:qn

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 9 of 222


%..e
.- s
8
1

2
3

E wou 1ct ()L)ject unLil thaL process has been


a pp ro v ed .

MR . S'
T JL J=MAN ;

'filF, C '
3 t.
IR'?:

No .

M R . 1,'
3(;A 11:

W e 1 1 , y o u know , yo u in d ic a t e d

Y ou r ilo no r , m a y 1?
M !:. L o C
Ja E .

co:G?

to u s , yo u r H on o r , w he n w e ha d o u r me e t in (
g 1 a s t w ee k

t h a t y o u h a v e 13a :i s(lme d i.ff ic u ).ty w it h t h e

r ep r e se n t a t io r4s :)1 (7c)un se 1 j.n t he p a s t .

10

1 do n 't know how t o re spo nd to th a t

o t he r

11

than the fact that Lf there was any ind ication by way

12

o f either M r . Elynn o r Mr . Stillman that there wa s a

13

p rob lem , the app lcation would not have even been

14

filed , no r w ould : have considered the assoc iation .

15

1 ma ke the representation to the Court in

16

good faith and a sk that Mr . St illman b e allowed to

17

participate subjact to approval and an order signed

18

b y th ks C ou rt thts w ee k .

19

t.o ve t an d re ce ivE', .
i.t yo u kli1 1.r a nd t he n ap p rov e .

M R . PEEK :

oo:07

oo:ca

Your Honor , if this were a

20

situation where there weren tt alread y ab le counsel --

21

I count four at coun sel table right now -- to

22

rep re sent M r . M ontgomery and the Montgomery Trust , I

23

probably would not have that objection, and I also

24

knowr respectfulky to Mr. Logar, whose

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:08

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 10 of 222


..,

rep resenta tions E accept, buL he do es not speak fo r

t he St a te B a r .

29o u n 1ni L the FJta te B a r h a s sp o ke n , I 1:h n k

Lhat frty ob ject ion 1arder SC'R Rt.h1e 12 is we11 taken and

shou lcl b e hono re (1.

DD:8

T H E C (3U RT :

We 1. l , th e ru 1e , i f I re c a 11

it , S C R 42 , sa ys t 14ftt unt i1 app rova 1 and the o rder i s

s ig ned , t.h a t L h e o t4t:-o f-s t a te c ou n s e 1 sh a l l n o t be

a 1l ow e d t o a c t iv (a1 y p a rt i c ip a Le .

10

1 thiIRk w ith this objection, 1 'm L)ound by

11

th e r u le s o l c a 14n ()t. -- 1 w j 1l a 1 1.ow th e f i r st

12

g en t lem a n t o p a rt i(Jp at e , b u t 1 c an n o t. - -

00:09

13

M R . L()G A R :

I u n de rs t a nd , y ou r H o n o r .

14

T H E O ()U R 1':

T f it w e re n 't f o r t he ru le , I

l5

wo u 1d .

00:o9

16

M R . L()G 1$R :

1 14nd e rs t a nd .

17

T H E C()U R7':

Bu t o n e o f t h e th inq s I 1m

18

fin d in g o u t t h e ko n (
;e r 1 ':(t u p h e re is th e re a re a 1o t

19

of things that jlzdges thin k the y can do that., if you

20

re a d th e ru le , th e y c a n 't , a nd th is i s o n e o f t hem .

21
22
23

....-

24

1 t h i11k th e ru 1 e s a y s ''s h a 1 l n o t. '' an d


s o -M R . LOGAR :

W e 1 l , t ha t i s ''p a rt ic ip at e z''

but I b elieve that bt 's p erm issible , M r . Stillm an can

LIZA CHA PEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

oo :o9

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 11 of 222


.u..
'--.r
1()
.

> -

l
$

..

. ..

- .-

co n fe r w t h u s .

rl'H K '
.-()U P.'
1':

problem w ith thitl .

a b l e t o ta l k t o h i m .

O h , su re .

1 d o n 't. se e a

! don 't see a prob lem with being

1 th ink tha t the ru le ta lks about

pa rticipate in settlement con fe rence s and various

other thing s, b ut. 1 cion 't see -- I d on t see that

the re w ould be any reason why you co uldn 't confer

w i t h h im .

10
11

MR. PEEK: And 1 have no objection to him

TH E C()URT :

13

MR . PEEK:

15

Righ t .

It's just a matter of

partic tpating .

THE t'
-'CIUFT :

Well, I 'm hop eful that we lre

16

not go ing to have , you know , ev ery time there 's a

17

a r g um e n t , th a t e ve ry law ye r o n e ac h s id e i s g o in g to

18

sp ea k, anyway ; f 'd like to try Lo keep it a little

19

b it m ore o rganized than that .

20

21
22

So I thin k thak we bre going to have som e

con ferencing on :,0 th sides .


M R . PEEK :

Your Honor , with that in m ind ,

23

1 1m m ind ful of that rule and ge nerally what I have

21

seen is that if 1 ,m presenting a witness r I pm the one

'

00:09

s it ting be fore the Bar either, your Hono r.

12

14

09:99

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

norlo

0o:1a

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 12 of 222


.,... .
- ,.
)1
k

maki-ng the 0bjec 1)i)n; if M r . Jakop in is p resenLi-nc.l

the witness, he's the one maktng the objection .

1 a s s um e t h a t th a t w l l b e th e p r o ced u r a l

order of this Cour t. today , that whoever is presenting

that w itness or cross-exam in ing will be the one

making the objections.

'
l'HE COURT :

Yes, 1 fd li ke to

try to do that just for the purpose of order and

o rgan ization .

10

A gain , you know , i 'm in terested m ostly in

11

find ing out what the truth bs here and so that 5s the

12

first qoal ; procedu ra l propr ietary is th e second one .

13
14

somebody needs to sa y som ethinq and it 's not

15

something that we fre doing a l1 day long , that fs fine .

17

r ea d y t o p ro c ee d ?

MR . PEEK :

W e are ready to p roceed r your

Honor .

20

THE COURT :

A ll right .

21

MR . FLYNN :

Good morning , your Honor .

22

Than k yo u for granting m y adm ission .

23

Befo re w e proceed , 1 need to add ress the

24

00:11

So w izh that in m ind r M r . Pee k, are you

18
19

o:lo

So , you know , if something come s up that

16

1.

A 11 light .

00:::

eu:11

Cou rt about an u rgent and immediate p ro cedural

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 13 of 222


-.
.
,d)
.-..-y
rk;4!
.
.

1
t

T H R C.()U R1':

Tb11 r i.q h t).

M R . FiuY Ht4 :

A ;1d 1 '::t g o in (; t o b e 1 i.m ite d a s

. .

t o how m u c h 1 c an fle s h o u t t)o the C ou rt b eca us e o f

the na ture o f w hitt 1 'm go tng to desc rib e to the

C ou rt .

Let me preface my remarks by saying that

what we lre invo lved in here is of the highest , most

secretive , m o st urgent, m ost imm edia te cla ssifed

10

security info rm ation r that I th in k, afte r the Court

11

gets an idea wh at. it is, will agree w ith m e , that can

12

be possib ly imagined by this Oourt .

13

00:11

00:12

S o a t t h e o u t s et , w e 're d e a l tng w th th e

14

fact that who has a security clea rance in the

15

courtroom and who does n ots because everyth ing 1'm

16

go ing to describe pe rsphe raliy involves th is secret

17

i n fo rm a t io n w h i ch g o e s t o t h e h e a rt , t h e c o re i ssu e s

18

o f wha t th is Cou rt ha s to decide , includ ing the core

19

issue of what prop rietary inform ation is involv ed and

20

who owns it .

21

p r ob 1 eIa w . th re C
ga r d t)() h 0w w (? p ro (
7e ed .

oo:w

The dichotom y existent with in eTreppid

22

T echnolog ies : between the o riginal deal that w as made

23

u nder the Contribution A greement , wh ich I understand

24

the Court ha s seen , for data compression technology

LIZA CHAPZN , CCR, RMR

00:12

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 14 of 222


..

M R . P CFK :

M R . F LY I1II:

M R . P ZFK :

Your Honor, I -T h e it
ssu e s --

1 app reciate counsel 's

eloquence , bu t t hjs is not a filibuster .

a motion to be Inacle , Inake a l


notion .

1;

ha s been m erqed into b y the Pla intiff .

lf there 's

r e ad y to p ro c ee d on m y m o ti on .

lf th ele 's a motion to be made , as opp osed

10

to the sup erlativi.s and the filibu ster, 1 'd like to

11

hear the m otion so that we can add ress if hhere is a

12

motion of urgency to be made , but otherwise I 'd l ike

13

to p roceed w ith my case .

14
this .

16

from Mr . M ontgom ery and 1 don 't want one more delay .

18
19

00:13

The C ou rt to ld u s we only have today to do

15

17

00:13

You a sked if I was ready to p roceed ; I 'm

('

....,

W e have already had over tw o weeks o f dela y

on:1a

So I wcuatcl a pp re c ka t e , y ou r Ho n o r , t h i s i s

m y case , I 'd like to proceed with my ca se .


THE C DURT :

A 1l right .

I believ e he 's

20

prefacin g what he 's saying as a p re face to som e kind

21

of a requ est or mo tion .

22

MR . FLYNN :

That 's correct , your Honor .

23

If the Court will indulge m e --

24

T H E C O I)Rr2:

1 w i1 1 .

LIZA CHAPEH, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:13

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 15 of 222


q
...
x:1..
.
(
k.z
l
r

M R . FL b'N N :

-- f()r f iv e m i.n u te s .

'?H E C C)11R'r:

1 w i1 1 .

M R . F L h')
1H :

T he d j.ch o to m y t h at e x is t s in

eTrepp icl #3et.ween 12#1e technoLogy that wa s th e sub1ect

o f t he C o n t2r ib l.lt if)n t


'
.
Lq re em en t a nd t.h e mo st c la s s if e d

in f o rm a ti.o n re 1.a t in (q to th e t ecrh n o lo g y th a t 's a t th e

co r e o f t h is c a s e i.s t he p rob l6)m .

De c em b e r 1 9t h , J
?()1
32 , J.n ()p e n co u rt , a s 1 o ng a s t 1ne

10

court is sealed and perhap s no one else other than

11

the deputy sherj f f, the clerk, and the court

12

repo rte r.

13

courtroom is sealed even during that p ha se .

00:14

1 th n k we 're safe there as long as the

Once we reach 2002, 1 th ink the C ou rt is

15

going ho have to cond uct some Lype of a procedure ,

16

and I 've been thinking all night what you could do ,

17

and the on ly thinq I can come up w ith , because of the

18

natu re o f this inform ation , is for you alone to take

19

Mr . Trepp and M r . Mon tgom ery into chamb ers with a

20

sworn con fidentia lity oath by your Honor , unde r oath ,

21

and hav e them basica lly explain what is involved .

22

oo:14

We cro u Ld p roce ed , (
E be 1 i.eve , up t o

14

G o ah e ad .

I th ink the Court will then see that it is

23

abso lutely im possib ke , given the nat ional securit y

24

interests involved, right now, this minutey today,

LIZA CHAPEN , CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:14

00:14

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 16 of 222


..
''I
.
-..Y)

'- ,

!.%

fo r t h e C o u rt t o e ve n is s ue an y ty p e o f an o rde r o r

findings , given thc! natu re o f the issue s Vnvolved ,

becau se 1 wou ld sublrit to the Cou rt that the national

security interests p reempt Judicial intervention in

this Co urt , and that 's a strong s tatem ent .

1 bel Eeve that the entire proceed ing s have

to ultimate ly go over to the Fede ral Court, be sealed

in the Federal Court, and even then how they are

going to be ab le to p roceed is fran kly a m ystery to

10

11

me , your Honor .

00:15

So here 's what 1 - - he re is w hat the

12

de fense re comm ends :

13

Decemb er '02 .

14

to the Cou rt w hich w ill basical ly outline th e

15

impending p rob lems .

16

Let the Pla intiff go fo rward to

I 've got a ch ronology that 1 can qive

00:16

Once we reach December '02

we 're going

17

i nt o t h e h ea r t o g c la s si f ied m a te r ia l .

At that

18

point : I don lt know how we can p roceed except fo r the

19

Court to t ake M r . Trepp and M r . Montgomery into

20

chamb ers and inquire into the natu re o f the m aterial .

21

THE COURT :

Well, let 's see how it goes .

22

My thought , and again, I 1m p robably the

23

least educated individual in the court room as far as

24

what this involves, but my thought is that we lre not

t.

O0:1b

LIZA CHAPEN, CCRZ RMR

(775) 323-5492

oo:t6

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 17 of 222


.,..

..1. )
.

16

h e r e n e c e s sa r i 1v tc) t a 1 k a b ()1.
1t t he c o n te n t o f

whatev er ''itu is, but the ownership and the right to

possess ion o f ''2t ,'' and so 2. t would seem to m e , and I

don 't know Lh is yet, but it would seem to m e that we

c a n ta l k a ho u t a 1 1 o f th o se is su e s a n d p e r h ap s m a ke a

determ inat ion on those issues w ithout even ta lking

about wha h the contents of ''it'' are, and if I 'm

w rong , then you can explain that to m e, and i f I

agree with yo u, then 1 agree w ith you .

10
11

12

So Y 'd like to go a head and give it a

oa:16

00:16

sho t .

Secondly , I w ould like to have some

13

reference to some case law , a s ta t u t o r y law , s om e

14

other author it g that says that -- that , o n e ,

15

ident ifies th is a s classified ; two , t e l l s u s w h a t

16

level o f class ificat ion tha t it has ; Lh ree , by whom ;

17

an d t he n som e k in d o f st at u t o r y c a se Y aw o r o t h e r

18

docum entation that wou ld tell us that it was not

19

proper for me to proceed , fo r us to p ro ceed in this

20

court , and if 1 'm persuaded that that 's right , t he n

21

certain ly 1 11 1 fo klow the ru les .

22

(
'

. .I

I 'm surp rised I hav en 't hea rd from the

23

federal governm ent y if they have such a conce rn , but

24

maybe you can add

ress that .

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:17

onttn

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 18 of 222


...-A

'.- .

l
t

M R . FLYNH :

secretive , and so compartmenta lzed w ithin the

fed e r a k go v e rn m tan l , th at th e re a r e v e ry f ew

ind ividuals w ith in the fede ral governm ent that have

a c c e ss to it .

n0:18

I w ill tell the Cou rt in open court what

is involved , invo qved daily br iefings to President

Bush ove r the la st two yea rs t da ily b riefkng s .

A nd w ith regard to your Honor 's other

10

p oint covering the ''ih'' w ithout gett ing in to the

11

content, the ''i t'' is the conte nt .

12

THE COUFT :

We '11 see .

13

MR . LOGAR :

Your Honor r we would like to

14

invoke the rulo as; 1:0 exclusion of witn esses for

15

sealing and everything we can do to p rotect the

16

integ rity o f these proceed inqs .

17

18

T H E C O URT :

M R . PEEK :
Hon or .

00:18

I d o n 't kn ow t he

He 's a w itness of ours , you r

He w ill shep out .

21

TH E COURT :

22

MR . PEEK :

23

THE COURT :

24

A l1 r iq h t .

o0:la

gentlem an se ated in the fron t row bac k the re .

19
20

IJ

Th ts in fo rm atio n is so

i.-

eo:18

A1l right .
1 don 't know who the other -And the other gentleman is my

1aw clerk. He will observe the order that I will

L1qZA CHA PEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 19 of 222


.,
!
.,..
..,
l8
1

m a ke h er e w i-t lQ !'e qcircl to co n fi(1e rAt ia l it y .

MR . PEEK ;

expe rt who wil l com e in, and 1 would like him , of

course , to sit in .

5
6

i think it 's approp riate to have an expert

MR . E'LYHN :

Your Honor, 1 thin k Mr . Frye ,

unless he 's the firsl. w itness, should be removed from

the court room .

10

MR . PEEK :

Your Honor, he 's a client .

11

H e 's a p r iv a t e c l ie n t .

12

compan y .

13

THE COUHT :

14

MR . PEF.K :

He can sta y .
Your Hono r, respectfully to

w hat coun sel had said earlier r I ta ke th at also to b e

16

that they wou ld at ke ast offer a st kpu kation that the

17

p ro c e e d in g s c o n clu ct e d h e re tod a y s th e a ff id a v it s th a t

18

h ave been previou sly subm itted under seal, and the

19

t ranscript of these proceed ing s m ay remain

20

confidential , and may be sealed by th is Court on ly to

21

be op ened upo n motion --

22

T HE CODRT :

23

M R . PEEK :

00:19

He 's a m em b e r m a na g e r o f th e

15

24

oa:19

Lo at least s it in on rebuttal, if necessary .

Your ilonor , we will have an

W ell --- and that nothing other than

t hat which is stated here today can go any farther,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

cQ:19

00:19

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 20 of 222


.....

w /..

19

1.

a nd I s a y hh a t '-- a IAd 1 'I


rt c u ri o us to h ea r co u n s e 1. 's

a rq um e n t , w h e n w e c e r ta i n ly , l a st W ed n e sd a y , he a r d

m uch ab outo

tech no logy to be c
ah le to sell my technolog yy'' and

if -- we bad , as ycu recall, mu ch ado about w hat the

ab ility w as to discuss w ith others , so 1 111 take that

as a st ipu lat i6n and 1 'd ask the Cou rt to ente r that

kind o f an ord er .

'11 neecj ho be ab le to talk ab out my

T dR COURT :

the record rig ht now and I will enter that orde r and

11

it is entered Lrt tte record .

12

Does that conta in , ror the moment v a l1 o f

13

the issues tha t you wanted to address w ith regard to

14

con fidentiatity?
A nd I would ask that , in add ition , that

16

you prep are some Uyp e of a stipu Lation that m eets the

17

conce rns you a rticulated a m inute ago , fi r st p r e sen t

18

it to the oth er sider present it to me , and then 1 '11

19

review it , and part icu larly, if you have re fe rence to

20

any statutory autho rity or anything else , p ut that in

21

the stipu lation and o rder , and 1 :11 take a loo k at it

22

and sig n it , mo re like ly than not , part icularly if

23

a11 sides -- if both side s approve .

24

MR . F'LYNN :

00:2n

We kk , T 'm happy to do th at on

10

15

We 're happy to do it , your

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:20

00:20

00:20

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 21 of 222


u.#.q
:
'w z'
.j
20
f
-

'

.-

.-

. - -

. - -

Ho n o r .

We w il l prepa re the stipu lation .

The

prob lem w ill beconzeo as you r Honor w ill hope fully be

able to lea rn during these p roceed ings , that even the

attorneys cannot be given access to this inform ation .

THE C.OURT :

Do you ha ve acces s to it?

MR . FLYNN :

1 hav e lim ited accessz enough

T H R C-G U RT :

Do yo u ha v e - -

10

M R . FLYNN :

Do I have com plete access?

12
13
14
15
16

THE OOURT :

Do you have a se cur ity

clearance o f anv knd?


M R . FL YNN :

Ho , and neither does -- do the

gent lemen on the othe r side o f the aisle .


M R . PE HK :

18

the material because the source code has been deleted

19

from our file and ta ken from our prem ise s .


THE COURT :

A11 righh .

Well, you know z I

21

don 't have enough information right yet to know -- to

22

m ake an in te lligent --

24

MR . PEEK :

:0:21

And , y our Honor , T don 't have

ac c e s s to t h e m a t e ri a l a nd I h a v e n o t h ad a c c e ss to

23

oa:21

Absolutely not .

17

20

u0:2l

to conduct the proceed ings .

11

1 will rev iew the st ipulation ,

your Honor --

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

0Q:M

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 22 of 222


....,

...v)
'

T i4E (-O !l1?T :

MR . PEKH ;

-- and ma ke su re that it bsn 't

too overly broaci, Lqecause w hat f'm hea ring he re

today, 1 think, maybe too ove rly broad .

THE COUPT :

MR . PEF'
,K :

21

A l1 1:Lg h t .

We ll, w e 'll see .

09:22

W jth that in m ind, your Hono r,

Mr . Ja kop in w ilq be presenting the first w itness .

THE CO UHT :

A 1 l rtght .

Let 's go .

(The w itness was swo rn .)

10

THE COURT :

Plea se take the witness stand .

11

A s a p relim inary matter, fo r the reco rd r

12

not on ly are the part ies and counsel but court staffz

13

as we llz and 1 in czude m yself in this, are instructed

14

that anythng th at 's sa jd o r done here in this

15

cou rtroom tod ay , pend ing the subm ission and approval

16

of an order r is confidential and w ill not be

17

discussed with th ird parties o utside o f the

18

cou rtroom y ex cept to the extent that it needs to be

19

d iscussed w ith w itnesses and experts with regard

20

specifically to the pursuit of the p roceedinq s in

21

this particu lar case .

22

Go ahead .

23

M R . JA KOPIN :

24

(Discussion off the record .)

Did you swear the witne ss?

LIZA CHA PF'


,N , CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:22

00:22

00:23

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 23 of 222


'
...+.)

22

l
.w .,.'

.-

S LO A N V ElN A F$laEE;;

c a 1 led a s a w j-t ne s:5, h a v i11q t)ee n f.


i.r s t d u ly sw o rn ,

t.e s t i fi ed a s f'o 1 lows :

D IR KC T KXAM IN AT 1ON

B Y M R . JA KO P 1N :

Q.

Y o u r n ame , p 1 ea se .

A.

S 1o aIt %'e IRa b le s .

Q.

Wh e re do you r e si de ?

10

A.

1n t91e V ir g i n ia (2it y H iq h 1 an d s .

11
12

T H El R E PG RT ElR :

15

T H EI lI'1.N E S S :

Fir st nam e r S- 1-o -a - n ; 1 a sL

n am e - -

MR . IaOGA R :

Your Ho no r , 1 'm so r r y .

16

hav ing di f fi c u 1t)y h e a ri nq tle w it ne s s .

17

t he m i c rophon e , p le a s e .

1 'm

T H E CO URT :

19

W h y cto n 't; yo u t ry t o sp e a k up a n d t ry to

21
22
23
24

00:2a

C ou ld he use

18

20

W o 141 d yo u sp e l1 you r n ame

fo r m e , p 1e a s e .

13
14

nn:2a

H o p e fu 1 1 y i t w o r k s .

u se the m icroph one .

no:za

W e h a d s om e d i ff ic u lt y w i th i.t 1a s t w e e k ;
.

i s i t wo r kin g n o w ?
T H E E$A IL 1(F F :

(Es th e b u t to n b e 1 o w yo u o n
.

the le ft-hand sde , on the gro und , is it on ?

LIZA CIIAPEI.
I, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Is it

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 24 of 222

t
r,. v )
,'
1
(

-.

'...'
p

T H El (-O tllk'l':

T H E BA 1J-.1 F F :

T H E: C O tlFkT :

T H E W 1T N E)SS :

C a IA y :)u he a r frte ?

T H E i3A 1.f-.fP'F :

lo w , t r y i-t .

T H F CO LJRT :

T H E 1h1173N E S S :

La sl name r V-e-n-a-b-l-e-s .

Yes .

T he IAr i t s h o u ld b e w o r k ing .

O ka y .

T h er e w e (
7o .
Ho q ab o ut n ow ?

T HE C-Ot)R77: A ll rLght . Mr . Venab1es , ju st


t.r y t o sp e a k up a ) it.t le b i t , to o .

12

T H E W I13N ElS S :

A 1 1 r i gh t .

13

THE I3A IL IiMF:

You have a v olume control,

THE COURT :

16

THE W ITNFSS :

17

T H E CO U R T :

Ye ah , I t h in k t h at ls b a t te r .

18

MR . LOGAR :

T hat 's better .

19

MR . PEEK :

20

THE COURT :

22
23
24

o():24

your Hono r, right up by your ow n spe aker .

15

21

00:23

'

11

14

23

1 i t up ?

10

.- --- .-

A 11 righh .

H ow is that?

How ab out now?

Thank you , you r Honor .

O kay .

00:24

BY MR . JA KO PIN :

Q.

Can you desc ribe your edu cational

bac kground since h igh school?


A.

00:24

Since high school, I wen t to UC Berkeley

LIZA CHA PEN , CCR , RMR

(775 ) 323-5492

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 25 of 222


A.-#'

N-

jx-)j
z-oscjcw .C),.
'
/.
js'
-V.(Lowcl- A7p'trt/ol
o-()c',/&/
.

kaxws (

n zua

x.
.

-) )

4
.
y.
.

..

1d.p-mx-'vc-cyj-, (
3
)/

t
-izAq '
my 9
'-'

,
vxs

--T,-xx.-sLlc.-

.... .

f-

o(

7/.2.o

(b

//

(
/''> .
7%
h
,

. / () rA

'*

/ j . 'oos.j.1-rA flCZGYy,
C S()'
: , .4.4..4t'
pu. ,
,

/i

-?

-g (
y
)yd.t-- '.,
(bG-'.
,
/
g
:
yzy
'
)

.
/
'
k
/
f
t
j
j
/
,
v
'
(
;
'
;
.z
2.w'y
1
.

-,

C %.z-,

;'(- -.
-a

. .-,
-.,

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 26 of 222 24


1

briefly , or for three years ; then


r

''

d esign school , learned 3D m odeling a nd c omputer

programm inq ; artd s ince then , I 've bee n self-taught in

computer p rog ramm ing .

M R . JAKOPIN :

You r Honor , ou r exp ert is

outside and the bailiff is not pe

in .

8
9

into the court room and attend th


THE COURT :

and any exp ert for the other sid

12

one .

13

MR .

14

p resent tim e w your Honor .

15

FLYNN :

We object

I f11 a llow him r

e , to o , if you fve got

We have no expe rt at the

Under the documents that

n0:2s

dep artment of th

e U .S . Gov ernment

18

involved in this case , they would be p re cLuded from

19

confiding anyt hng to any exp e rt .

20

T HE COURT :

W elk
,

I 've got to see the

21

documents .

22

d o, I 'm going to p erm it him t o be here .

23

24

oo:zs

M r . Trepp and Mr . Montgom ery sLgned w ith the

17

rm it ting him to come

e p roceedings?

A 11 ri
ght .

11

16

:::24

Can we have perm issi


on to have h im come

10

f we nt to graphic

I 've got to see some authority .

MR.

FLYNN :

Unless I

No r has he been disc losed t

us , your Honor .

LIZA CHA PEN: CCR , RMR

00:25

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 27 of 222

?o r )
,

1
d

- - - -

--

:- )

2b

1 'l
'
rt l
:
Jti 1 1 g o in g to p e rm i t h im r
.

ab s en t b e t ng p t
:0v i-cled w i t/1 th o se d o c um e n ts a n d

m a te r i a 1 .

M R - F1.YN N :

Y o u r' 5!on o r w i 11 n o t e m y

object.1on .

nO:2s

T FlE t!O IJRT :

G o a IRe tct.

MR . .7JhK()P1N :

13Y M R . JA KO P IN :

10

Q.

A l k rig h t .

1 L 's no t.e d .
'

T h a n k y ou , you r H o n o r .

C a n yo u d e s c r ib e yo u r em p 1o ym en t f ro m th e

11

time you finished schooling up un ti ) eT repp id ,

12

b rie fly .

13

A.

00:2s

l w orkecl most recently before eT repp id fo r

11

abouh ten years in the video gam e industry ma king

15

computer qam es from the PC platform .

16

was a 3-D modeler and then later on as a programmer .

17

T 11F: (OC)(1RT :

.-

lnitially , I

00:26

My most recent job before coming to

18

eTrepp id r 1 wa s a lead p rogrammer on the last couple

19

o f v ideo game s m ade for electronic ca rds .

20

Q.

And you began working at eTreppid when?

21

A.

In Decemb er of '99 .

22

Q.

A nd were you one o f the first emp loyees?

23

A.

Th at 's correct .

24

Q.

W ho was w orking there at the time you

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

no:26

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 28 of 222


)..,,
..)
:.
h..-r
26
l
!

s 12a r te d ?
A.

De rl:1i s 2.
1o n tCJo(rte ry ; iiF; so n r B r i.a n

M on t go m e ry ; a r'i t he y ha d t h ree co n t 1'a c t o r ind ia n

n at i on a 1.s Uh a tz ztre no 1on (Je r tile re .

5
6

7
8
9

Q.

A n d wh e n you L)e (
gan , w h a t p o s it io n d id y o u

h av e w it h th e .
:romp an y ?
A.

1 w a :; jn i t.ia 1 ly h i.r ed t o b e a d i re ct o r o f

g am e de ve lopme nt).

11

that I develop E?tl on my own with me and sub licensed it

12

to eT reppid an :y continued further development o n it

13

for a gam e tha l: we wou id someday release from th e

14

company .

16
17

Q.

1) b ro ug h t m '
g v ide o ga me te ch n o lo g )fr

So when you worked at eTrepp id , then what

00:26

00:27

did you do?


A.

G r a d u a ll y t oo k o n m o re t a s k s s b e g an d o in g

18

a11 the IT wor k for the company, a11 the e-mail , the

19

W EBSERV ER , al1 the ne twork infrastructure , g radually

20

too k on al1 the hardware p urch asing v a1l the ha rdwa re

21

development .

22

u::26

ye a r t ha t I w o i:')2ecl t)h e re .

10

15

The y' were just bri.ef1.y t.h ere the first.

M os t: recently, in the p ast two years, I 've

23

taken on the role of our fac il ity security office r.

24

I maintain al1 of the security c tearances and the

LIZA C1.IAPi''
UN , CCRr RMR

(775) 323-5492

:::27

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 29 of 222

r.'
-.)
l

Q.

electronic inform at ion, correct?


A.

Tha t:'s riqht .

Q.

Cou kd you describe some o f the d ifferen h

types of info rlnaton that is stored ah the company

prem ises?

A.

We have , first o f atl, the sou rce code ,

10

files that is compled into an actual runab le

11

program ; a1l o g the too ls that we use to develop the

12

source code , wh icb is usually th krd -party software ,

13

Microsoft deve Loped prog ram s; a lso a11 the other

14

th ird -party softw are that we use , the operat ing

15

system s, other tocls fo r developing .

sample files that we use to run our code on ; images ,

18

m ovies , bit m ap s , all kinds o f file s .

19

Q.

classified files , and there 's ohhe r file s that are

21

not?

24

00:28

A re there certa in f iles that are

20

23

oa:za

So a l1 that stuff is stored , as well as

17

22

0:.27

which is a -- basically , sou rce cord is a 1ot of text

16

You wolk with a 1ot o f different kind o f

27

fac i 1.it y s e cu r it.y c )e a r an ce s a nd p ro c ed u re s .

2
3

!.v

A.

That 's correct , based on where the con tent

cam e from and who we received it from .

Usually, a source code isn 't classified .

L1ZA CHAPENt CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:28

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 30 of 222


7. -.)
f->.-y
.
28
)
.
1
(

so u r ce c o d e s f b tlt tln(? b it m arn i.ma g e s o r fr am e s o f

p.
i.c t u re s ilav e b ()e n c 1a ss if i.ed .

Q.

c e r ta in o n e s ?

oo:29

A.

T h a t 's co r rec t .

Q.

Wh e n y c)u sa y t he eT rep p i d s o u rc e co d e ,

9
10

w h at a re y ou r e fe z'r.t:1g to ?
A.

T h e Elc tu a 1 C ++ fi le s th a t a r e u s e d to b e

comp i.1ed 5.nt o t #1e so ft.wa r e we deve 1op .

11

Q.

A nd w h c) w r te s t #1at sour ce c o de ?

12

A.

V a r i o u s; (3ro g rafrkm e r s in t h e b u i1d in (


g.

13

Q.

H a v e yc)u w r1.tt en some o f th a t so u rce c ode '?

14

A.

N o t 13o 1' a w h i 1e .

15

The last stuff I wo rked o n was about 2002 .

16

1 worked on a player that we developed for a project

17

w ith Inte l .

18
19

21
22
23

24

oa:29

:0:29

I 'v e also worked on the game engine over


the years that we developed .

20

That would not be a 11 images, but just

we haven 't had any c lassified

'

So far

O the r than that, I haven 't .

Q.

A re you responsible for b acking up any

inform ation at the company?


A.

I bac k up al1 of ou r serv ers that run a 1l

of our infrastructure, our e-mail, our web sites, but

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Qo:29

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 31 of 222

j
...-y)
!

1 d o n 't d o a n y C)f t h e so u rc c) c 0d e b a c kup ; t h a t w a s

a 11 M r . Mont(
gom (?rj:'54 job .

Q.

A nd hob
n' lo n() h av e y (3u b ee n d o in g t 14a t ?

A.

P re Lt. y rnu(:h fr(?m t h e 17eg in n in g ; t he pa st

00:30

Q.

A nd why do you bac k up tha t info rmation?

A.

Hardwa re always faiis .

You 've g oL to have

a ba ckup so you can recover from it .

I haven 'h iost a file since we 've been in

10

existence .

11

overheating or what have you , n'echan ical fa ilure r so

12

bf you don 't have bac kups , you won 't be ab le to

13

recove r from it .

14

Q.

Ha rdw are a lways tends to fail from

company bac ked up its source co de fo r the sam e

16

rea son ?

17

A.

Right .

18

Q.

Up untjl recently , had the company ever

oo:3a

lost a ny o f the source code ?

20

A.

Not to my know ledge .

21

Q.

Is the re anyone othe r hhan M r . M ontomery

22

00:30

Now , is it you r unde rstanding hhat the

15

19

29

s i)( y e a r s .

('
..
p

0o:a0

tha t was resp on sib le for backinq up the sou rce code?

23

A.

No.

24

Q.

For how long had he been responsible for

L IZA CHAPEN , CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 32 of 222


r...,
.,.
) - - .$
''.
-!
30
z.

1
t

backing up the so urce codo ?

A.

F roln the be (
7n n i ng .

Q.

W a s le a 1s o r e sp on s Lb 1e fo r m a in t a in incl

th e so u rce c o de ?

A.

A s fa r a s 1 kn o w , t IRa t wa s i
4is job .

Q.

H ow hra s i t ma i.n ta in e d '?

A.

We hav.
2 a st ru c t ure . a f i le s y s tem

s tr u c tu re o n o I.1r. se rv e r w he r e w e ke p t it f a nd it

st o r e d v a r ou s m e th od s u n de rn ea th Lh e - - o u r fo l d er

10

stru ctu re .

11

aoi3l

We have our cucrent pcojects. Each

12

project had a sub fozder.

13

of -- a11 the proq rammers in the buildinq have

14

locations where only they can acce ss and store ther

15

projects.

We also have a subsystem

o:;l

16

So al1 this file structure is a11 stored

17

on one of ou r servers that Mr . M o n tg om e r y b a c k ed up

18

to another set of m achines in ou r sep arate lo cation .

19

20

Q.

Wa s the re a name for that serv er that yo u

were just talking about?

21

A.

22

SRC , S-E-R-V -E-R .

23

Q.

ao:31

We call it the sou rce server , abbreviated

W ho had access to th e source code that was

f'

21

90:3l

on tha t SRC SERVER'


?

LIZA CHAPEH, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 33 of 222

T
x
.

1
t

A.

.-

--

f )
'.

. ..

W e lna V e d if fe re !At le ve 1s o f a c ce s s -

been ko cked that'


.
on ky have -- i be lieve , five or skx

p eople had the key to .

The physicat access , it 's in a room that 's

Log-on access , only M r . Montgome ry and L

Netwo rk access , va rious p rogramm ers in the

bu ild ing had ciifferent file -share lev el permissions

to the fo lders, but none of them had a fu ll access --

10

full pe rm issicns to the file levels under network

11

sharing ; they h ad modified , which means they can add

12

but they can 't de Lete .

13
14

0a:32

Fu ll access leve l was only fo r


M r . M o n t go m e ry an d m e ,

15

Q.

And hcw was that put into p lace ?

16

A.

We had an Eff, what we call ou r eTreppid

17

adm kn ist rator accoun t , wh ieh on vy M r . Montgom ery and

18

I had the passw ord for .

19

00:32

Only w ith that u ser account that you could

20

get on and log on and change these pe rm issions ;

21

otherwise , you have to go through the networking and

22

you 're subject to all the permissions that we 've set

23

up .

24

00:32

had the password to it .

.-

Q.

W as there a server othe r than the

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

cc132

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 34 of 222

.
,..,)
1
p

32

E;RC SE RV EIR th a t yo u w e re re fe rr ing to ?


A.

W e ha d a n o th e r se rv e r, a c o u p l e -- w e l lf

w e h a v e s e v e ra 1 s er ve r s in th e b u i ld i ng ; no t a 1 l of

them u s e o u r s otzrc:e crod e .

t ha t r u n th e iIRfr as t.r uc t ur e of o u c n e tw o r k .

F,-m dhi L se r ve r s

sf
arv e r s

We have another server for sto ring a1l the

th ird-party tools that we do , and anothe r server that

1 had recently set up , in the past four months, tha t

w as used for a backup to tho SRCSFRVFR .

10
11
12
13

14
15

16
17

18
19
20

f
r'-1

Q.

Did all of these se rvers get accessed w ith

aa:33

:0:33

the eT reppid administrator password?


A.

A1l the servers are only logged on w ith

the eT reppid administrator account , that 's right .

Q.

And jt was only the two of you that had

a c ce s s t o a 11 o 17 th o s e ?

A.

That 's right .

oo:aa

Not even Mr . Trepp knew the

p a s sw o rd t o t h e a dm i n i st ra t o r a cc o u nt .

Q.

About how large were the total eTreppid

source cod e files?


A.

W ell, from my recollec tion of do ing a

21

b ackup som e tim e back , and also l d id another backup

22

in the m iddle of December, it was about 200 gigab ytes

23

on the SRC SERVER tha t was copied over to my other

24

backup server which I call an ISASERVER .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

on:33

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 35 of 222

X
l
!

Q.

--

- ..-

''

'='
2.

3?

And how la rge is the memo ry capacity o f

t he ISA S FR V ER ?

A.

We llr tho actu al m emory i.s separate from

the hard drive space .

have about one Lo two gigab ytes o f memory , but that 's

just random access memory.

There 's -- a1 1 o f our servers

The hard drive space on the SRCSERV ER is

about -- just shy of three terabytes. My ISASERVER

is just over fouz terabytes, but we weren't ussng

10

anywhe re near the capacity on e ith er one o f those .

11

Q.

that had been used for backtng up th e eT repp id source

13

code?
A.

in our wa reho use axea that had , ea ch of them ,

16

attached storag e box , what w e call RA ID sto rage box .

17

E ac h o f t ho s e s to r ed ab o u t 1 .7 , 1 . 8 t e ra b y t e s .

19

0::34

T hose are used to back up wha t was on


SRCSERV ER .

20
21

aoLiq

1 bu Llt tw o wo rk station s that we kep t out

15

18

oa:34

You had mentioned some other wo rk stat ions

12

14

- --

Those backup s were made b y Mr . M ontgom ery


on a regular basis .

22

Q.

A s o fr say, around Decemb er 2 1st , 2005 --

23

A.

Uh-huh .

24

Q.

-- what wa s your understanding of where

LIZA CHAPENr CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

oo:ab

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 36 of 222

w.

34

c omp le te c op ie s o 1' t h e so u rc e c o (:1e ex is 1ued a t

eT repp id?

A.

A s Fc
ar as I know , there was the comp lete

original copy on the SRCSERVER , as well as copies on

each o f these two work sta tions tn ou r w arehouse .

6
7

had cop ie s of a ll the hard drkve s o f alY the

p rogrammers in the building .


Thoset were cop Le s m ade by M r . Mon tgomery

10

on a fairly regu lar basis .

11

pretty often , mu ltip le tkme s a week over the past

12

s e v e ra l y e a r s .

13
14
15
16
17

Q.

1 had se en him doing it

o0:3s

You had Aent ioned an IGASERV ER ; was tt

also sto red there ?


A.

Up unt l December 2 1st ,

that was just n

eQ:a6

testing .
On De c tam be r 2 1 st , I m a d e a c o p y o f

18

eve rything on SRCSERVER .

19

December 22nd for the holidays , I went ou t of the

20

countryz and I sta rted copies , part o f them comp leted

21

b efore I left on the 2 1st .

22

on:3s

The work stations in the warehouse also

(x.
x

I was go ing on a trip on

I was there until about 1 1:00 o 'clock on

23

the night of the 21st finish ing up th e copie s , and

24

w hen I left some o f them we re still going .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:36

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 37 of 222

(x
1
$

that they had completed , so ( had backed up

eve ryth inq frorn SRCSF,RVKR over to th is TSASKRVZR .

Q.

fin ished ?

A.

10

11

A nd did your 1og te ll, say, w hen that


00:36

Some o f them fin fshed the n ight of the

21st; som e finishod the next day, the 22nd .

' 35

Bu t ny 1oq files , when I got back, showed

(m

A1 l Lhe 1()g fj le55 a ren 't there anymore;

th ere 's o nly a couple left .

Some of them were

deleted .

00:a6

Q.

Do you have any reason to th in k that if it

12

d id n lt occur the wa y you had p rogramm ed it to , that

13

it wouldn 't have been comp lete ly backed up ?

14

MR. FLYNN: Objection, your Honor.

15

THR COURT: What 's Lhe objection?

16

M R . EPLYNN :

None of this testim ony -- the

17

entire co urse of the testimony so far has been

18

utterly lacking in foundation .

19

T HE CO URT :

W ell, 1 thin k there --

20

MR . FLYNN :

I 'd move to strike a l1 o f the

21

test im on y , but l 'm trying to cut through it , so I

22

don 't want to keep objecting because I believe I've

23

got a w ay to cut through and across --

24

TH E CO URT :

00:37

A 11 right .

Tu(
EZA Ci1APHN, C(
7Rr RMR

Well - -

(775) 323-5492

00:37

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 38 of 222


'

t--)
1
l

M R . 1'L Y H H :

- - b 11t n (3n e (7f t h i s h a s a n y

T H R (2O tlHT :

A 1 1 r i(
ght .

U n L i l I 1e a rn a

li.t tl '
a b it Irto re a b o u t th e b a c kg ro u nd , i t 's ha rd fo r

m e to ev a lua t e th :1t .

oo:37

M R . IrL Y N 19:

TH E C-OLlRT : T here 's not. a jury lqe re r so

36

fo un d .
at io n .

1 und e rs ta n d th a t'
..

I 'm (
gd
3ing t.o a t1ow t he t e st imon y .

G o a11e ad r s i-r .

10

T H E W 18AN E S S :

Wh a t w a s t h e qu e s t i on ?

11

M R . kJA KO P YN :

i t h in k you fi.n is h ed .

12

I think it wa s ju st an ob jection afhe r the

13

T ilE (2O :1RT :

A 11 r ig h t .

Fo r t he r e c o r d ,

l5

the o'
.
ojec t.ion is c)verru1ed .

16

fou nd'
at io n t o wh a h u 1t j.m at e ly w e fre g o i n (
g to g e t to .

l7

18

S e em s t o b e

1 think t.his is

on:37

a t a n y r a t e , a s 1. e a s t. a s o f

now .

19

Go ahead .

20

BY MR . JAKO PIN :

21

Q.

:o:3a

Could you describe how the programmers

22

have th eir wo rk stations configured and how they

23

relate to the SRCSERVER ?

24

oo:3-/

co n c1 .2s io n .

l4

tl
''

A.

The prog rammers have a ha rd drive on their

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR , RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 39 of 222

(.
%

-.- -

- .- ..- .-

(''.T'
.

37

ma c 14i ne o u t s id e c.f the i r re qu 1 a r o p e r at ing s y s Le m

ha rd d rjve tha t 's kept on there .

Current Source was tor the projects Lhey 're currently

wo r k o n .

Their folder ca lled

Th at Current Source folder conta ins their

working in progress and the projects that they 're

cu rrently proq ramm ing on .

by Dennis over t:o the two work stations we keep in

our wa rehou se fo r bac king those up .

10

Q.

11

stations?

12

A.

13
p urposes .

15

Q.

17

Those folders a'


re copied

And c1o the programm ers have personal work

ooraa

Eve ry programm er has at least one .

Whac 's the operating system on the work

00:38

sta tions that they have?


A.

18

W ind ows XP , on the majo rity .


There 's a few that have W indow s 2000 for

19

testing , and then they were p rog ramm ing with some

20

older code th at wou ldn 't compi le on w indow s X P .

21

00:3:

Som e of them have two for te st ing

14

16

Q.

Directing your attention to the last day

22

that you w ere at the office be fore you went on you r

23

vacation .

24

A.

Uh -huh .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

oo:aa

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 40 of 222

*...t)

('-.?f'

448)

Q.

C a 11 y o u d e sc r ib e wh at h ap p en e d th a t d ay ?

A.

( c am e i n tha t d ay .

3
4

A t tlte L7e (
g tnn in(J o f t.h e d a y , 1 c a 1.1e d a s L
.

w a s c o m j.n g in f:)r som e re a so n , 1 fo rg e t w h a t i.t was .

1 c a 1l ed Den n is an (2i h e a s k ed m e i f I 'd

g o t te n a 1l m y (7re y'a r a t ion rea d '


g fo r m y t r i p a n d 1

sa id no , and h e said !
' ''We11 r stay home and do your

pac king or w hatever ,'' and I to ld h im I w as almo st to

the office anyway , so I w as com ing in .

get the IGASERVER fin ished sett ing -- setting up and

11

do ing the backups .

do ing the backup s of SRCSERVER and also our

14

DE V S E R VE R .

So I came in and 1 got m y stuff arranged

16

in m y office ancl 1 went out to Lhe wa rehouse , a n d

17

th at 's when I not iced that the w ork -- one o f the

18

wo rk stations that had the RA ID box attached to it

19

was gone y and I asked Denn is where it wa s .

20

21
22
23

24

cq:39

W e had talked abouh setting the 15A up fo r

13

15

00:39

I wanted to

10

12

T his was one o f the one s that he u sed for

b ac king up the SRCSERVER .


And he said he 'd taken it hom e , and he
didn 't te ll me why .

And so then the rest o f th e day I spent

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

oo:ag

00:40

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 41 of 222

hY
1
(

And the next mo rn ing , I le ft on m y trip to

Budapest .

Q.

You we re gone untl when?

A.

I qot. bac k the late n Lght. o f the 2nd ,

Q.

And cti you at some point go bac k to the

o ffice?

MR . LOGA R :

10

I 'm so rry .

11

Could you speak up , please .


00:40

HY MR . JAKO PIN :

12

Q.

At some po int did you go b ack to the

14

A.

The mo rn ing o f the 3rd , I came to work.

15

Q.

What d id you discover then ?

16

A.

When 1 got into the o ffice , I no ticed

13

office?

17

that -- m y o ff Lce is situated right next to our

18

server room with the door so 1 can see th rough to m y

19

servers, and I noticed that somebody had been doing

20

som eth ing on our SRCSERVER .

21

cn:4o

January 2nd .

7
8

99

se t t in g u p t h e 1S.
AS F RV E R a n d rlJn IRin (; t IAe b a c ku p s .

l 'Y

00:40

A nd so I went over and looked at it and

22

there was a comm and prompt window up do ing som ething

23

wh ich I didn 't know what it wa s, and Dennis cam e in

24

at that p oint and 1 a sked him what h e was doing and

L1ZA CHAPE1.1, CCRr RMR

n0:4o

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 42 of 222

C.
I

(=--e
).

4o

h e s a id h e w a s d ()i!1C
J som e c 1.ea n - u p w f)r k , g e t ti ng ri d

o f o ld s t u f f w e (1(jrR't nt?e (1 a n ymo re .

S;o th q,11 I b e 1ie v e o n e o f o u r e mp lo ye e s ,

Jim Baude r , came L!) a t tha t po nt and st a rted talki ng

t.o m e 1 i ke h e u su a 1 1y d oe s ea c h mo rn 1 ng , a nd Den n is

1e f t .

So then I started going over the SRCSERVER

and noticed that m ost of ou r sub fo lde rs on that -- on

our source RATD box had been all deleted out .

10

Q.

What d kci you do then ?

11

A.

T w e nt t o q o t oo k on m y b ac kup se r v er ,

ISA SERVER .

13

and keyboard , so just do a command to switch over

14

to the next com puter, and that ma ch ine wa s totally

15

loc ked up .

16

resp onding at a Ll .

The y 're al1 attached to the same monitor

1) c ou )drt't Lo q o rt to it .

T.t. w a sn 't

cc:4t

S o t he n I w en t b a c k to m y de s k a nd tr ie d

18

to loo k at that mach ine through the netw ork and I

19

could see the ISA box was respond ing , that ISA 'S RA ID

20

was resp onding through the netw ork and it a lso had

21

been com p letely deleted out .

22

Q.

Did you ask M r . M ontgom ery about this?

23

A.

R ight away -- 1 th in k 1 talked to some

24

00:4l

no:41

12

17

other peop le
r

asked what happened w hile I was gone ,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5192

oo:4a

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 43 of 222

...,j
/r

(
z
-..
' '
zy
.
.

and hhey said strange stu ff had been go ing on .

h a d b e e n g ra d u .
it11 k' )e tng d e le t ed .

The n

Stuff

l w e n t o ut t o t h e w a reh o u se to a s k

h im a b o ut it a nd ( a s ked h int w he re th e b a c ku p w a s a n d

h e said he wa s br ingjng that -- the b ackup work

stat ion w jth the RAID box from our warehouse , that he

w as bringing it back , he wa s done w ith it or

something like that .

9
G RCSERVEB .

11

something to that effect .

He sad he d idn 't: do an ything or

12

Q.

Wha t happened the rest o f that wee k?

13

A.

l was; going over the m achines, assessing

14

w hat the damages weue while 1 was gone .

15

to get 1SA bac k up, realized that one -- som ething

16

had happened to it .

00:42

I was tryinq
o0:4a

rt h ad b e e n w o r k j. n g in m y o f fi ce f o r a

18

good three m onths before 1 put it into its permanent

19

location , so I figured something was -- som ething had

20

hap pened to it wh l
ile i was gone , e ither m alfunct ion

21

or sabotage .

22

00:12

Bu t he neve r told me what happened on the

10

17

zgg

A lso , 1 sharted asking a 11 the p eop le in

23

the bu ild ing what had been going on , and they told m e

24

that Dennis had deleted a11 the code off their

LTZA CIIAPEINr CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:43

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 44 of 222

.,

m achines while g was gone , and that he was

gradua lly -- just qiving them libtle bits and pieces

to work on .

4
5

strike .

Hea rsay : speculation

lacks foundation .

He's just guessing .

T HE CO URT :

it is hearsay ; 1 wjll sustain tt .

10

42

MR. FLYNN : Objectiony your Honor; move to

9
Hono r .

12

of the m atter ?

13

it .

14

It's just foundational, your

It 's not --

THR COURT :

00:13

It 's not o ffered for the truth

1 th jnk it is .

T HE W F fNESS :

Cm going to sustain

That w as a short wee k , s o

15

that wa s abo ut a11 that happened that week , I

16

believe .

17

00:d3

1 think as to hearsay , it 's - -

MR . JAKOPIN :

11

on:4a

W e w e re a ls o p rep a r in g -- w e h ad a . fo r

18

our fac ilities secu rlty clearance , we h ad our

19

inspect ion schedu led for -- 1 believe the 9th .

20

('%g,

We had our rep resentative fo r the De fense

21

Security Serv ice com ing on the 9th , s o 1 w a s

22

prepa ring our facility security docum en ts for that

23

visit .

24

BY MR . JAKOPIN :

LIZA CHA PFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:44

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 45 of 222

....)
1.
1

Q.

4a

W h a t: h .tr)p e ne d t h () w e e k , 1 g ue s s , b eg i.n n in g

January 9th ?

A.

W el L, on the 8th , which is a Sunday z

Mr . T repp called me at home and a sked me if an yth ing

un u s ua l h a d b e en hap p e n in q , an d I t o ld h im th a t w h e n

1 got bac k from my t rip Lhat a ll the code on our

SRCSERV ER had been deleted off.

So he asked me to come in ea rly the next

day to ta lk ab out it, and asked M r . Montgom ery whah

10

was going on .

11

00:44

12

o n ly t he r e fo r '
ti /:e a n h o ur or tw o a n d h e le f t a nd

13

never c am e b ac k for the re st o f Lhe day .


So that day we started loo kinq around the

15

bu ilding to see what e lse was m issing , and we had

16

basica lly everyone in the building going through

17

st u f f .

18
19

20

on:45

He sa id he wa s coming b ack but he never


came -- M r . Montgomery never cam e back .

So we spent m ost of the night -- 1 was

21

also gett ing ready for m y visits on the 10th .

22

Jay Dixon from the Defense Security Service there

23

first th in g in the m orning .

24

00:44

When 1 got in that day, Mr . Montgom ery was

14

(w)

I had

And also when I got there that morning --

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

oo:4s

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 46 of 222

T mg
(

(
'.
rp

44

I c a 1 1ed be f o r (? 1 c an1e to t 91() 0 f fi.ce , a n d De n n is sa .


i.d

he w a s g o j.ng t o b 6. 1:he re wh (?n t g o t t he r e .

(E a s 4:e d if he w a s g o in g to b e tn th a t. da y .
He sa id , ''1 l 1 L)e the re whe rl y o u qe t. t he re .''

W h e n I (Jo t t h e re , h e w a s o u t in th e

warehou se with Mr . Trepp and a friend of M r . T repp 's ,

ye l li ng a t h im , o b sc e n it ie s , g o i ng th ro u g h th e

warehou se out the back door , and he got in his Lruc k

a nd d ro v e aw a y .

10

W e spent the re st o f that day m eeting with

11

Jay Dixon, explaininq to hm that we had major chaos

12

going on and personne l prob kem s, and he basically

13

to ld us that w e 've got to go t hrough a bunch of

14

p rocedu re s fo r -- we also -- p rocedures fo r

15

determ ining wh at happened .

16

p o ss ib le t ha t De n n i s Mo n t go m e r y h ad t a ke n o r sho w n

18

som e of our c lassified m ate rial to foreign nationals ,

19

so I started that nvestigation on w hat happened w ith

20

that situat ion .

MR . FLYNN:

0::46

Your Honor, objection; move to

strike , specu lation .

23

24

oo:qs

00:46

17

22

ou:4s

We also determ ined that possib le -- it was

21

--

--

A nd can we have the identity of the peop le

present?

He keeps saying ''we .''

LIZA CIIAPFulh
l, CCRr RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 47 of 222


-

1
(

.-

(
r'
N A

45

T h e reh's b ee n n o 1o u IAd a t io n as t o w lno W a s

presenh on -- in an y of these conve rsations o r

c i rc um st a nc e s , an d th e la s t p a rt o f t h e te st im on y w a s

just rank hearsay and speculation and lacks -- lacked

foundation .

03:46

TH E COURT :

W ell , 1 thin k he 's simp ly

rec iting even ts that took p lace to show what h is

conduct and state o f m ind were a t th e t ime .

going to overrule the objection.

10
11

13

THE W ITNESS :

15

T HE WITNESS :

Do you want me to

Yeah .
A 1 L the emp loyees in the

W e w er e -- l 'd s ay J e s s ie A n d e rs on , J im

Bauder .
I can list a11 the peop le that wo rked for

20

the com pan y .

21

through the hard d riv es in our wa rehouse , going over

22

v ideo -- ou r -- w e went to check our surveillance ,

23

M r . Trepp and m yself d id that , chec k ou r surveillance

24

00:47

b uilding, as a group .

17

19

The ''we''?

say it?
THE COURT :

18

00:47

identify w ho the ''w e'' is .

14

16

I 'm

lt wou ld be appropriate , how ever , to

12

(
'

(%u'K-J'

lt was -- the whole com pany was going

video cam eras, which had al1 been deleted .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCRZ RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:47

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 48 of 222

(-.-)
l

W e nc)t ic ed th a t o n t.he 1.0 t h , a s w e 11 .

I can 't rem ember al ) the -- Patty G ray

w a sn 't th e re t h a t d a y , o r m a yb e -- no , s h e w a sn 't .

Len G lcgaue r .

Eve rybody in the bu ild ing b esides Patty

G ray and Denn is Mcntgomery were there , a l1 the

emp loyees , wh ich I 'm su re they can give you a list

of .

10

THE COURT :

A l1 rig ht .

A re those names

you 've given us the ones you reca ll right now?


THE W ITNF,SS :

12

T H E C OU R T :

13

BY MR . JAKOPLN :

14

Q.

A.

A 1 1 r ig h t .

G o ah e a d .

Did you have any discussions w ith


n0:4:

O the r than he as ked m e -- I didn 't ca ll

17

h im o ve r th e w e e ke nd t o g o t ra p sh o o t i ng l i ke w e

18

usually do .

19

trip .

I said 1 just wanted to relax after the

That was about it .

20

Q.

Anything else that d ay ?

21

A.

The 9th , no .

22

23
24

00:47

Uh-huh .

Mr . Montgom ery on Monday the 9th ?

16

00:47

They we re a11 p resent .

11

15

46

1-

The 10th, we d id .

Q.

What happ ened on the 10th , in term s o f

conversations?

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR r RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:4*

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 49 of 222

(Ni
gy r
l
!

A.

4.g

T he 10 trh w a s t h e mo 1'n ing w IRe n L h e ch a o s i n

th e w a re h o u s e t3e tw e en h im and M r . T re p p w a s g o in (
J on .

L a t(nr f)n , L c a llect -'- M r . 'Pre pp a s k ed me

to c a l1 14iIn t o coIne h ac k to thC? o f fi c e to t a 1 k t o u s .

and De n n 1 s c alzr(.
t b,
uc k a nd h e wen t .
i.n t c) D e nn i s ' - -

Wa r re n 's o 2'f icfa a rd the y ta 1 ked p r iva t e ly .

7
8

I a s ked h im w htat. b
aa s g o .
i.n g on y a nd h e s a id t h at

Warren was try ing to screw him out of money for

10

years , he hadn 't been paying h im prope rly fo r h is

11

sou rce co de , ancl he said --

have, our'' -- ''tlhis classified project that was of

14

extreme impo rtance?''

15

And he said that if the com pany wanted it ,

19

A n d th en h e le ft an d h e n e v e r c a m e b a c k to

the b uilding since .

Q.

You had m ent ioned be fore that th e company

20

had a sec urity system with cam eras .

21

Coultl you describe that?

22

00:49

they had to g ive him bjg money .

17

18

00:49

1 said, ''What about this latest project we

13

16

00:4a

A nd t he n De nn i s came o v e r t:o ray o f fi c e a nd

12

(T

.- <

A.

W e dve got abou t 16 cameras in ou r

23

build ing , and last summer we in stalled -- w e

24

orig inally had maybe 12 .

We in stalled different

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

00:49

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 50 of 222

>ge
x . ./

.--

(
p
k 1- .

4yy

. ...

cam e ras o n th e roof and we ran a 11 the feed s for

these cam eras out to ou r warehouse a rea , the area

whe re Dennis usua Lly works , antj we set up 16 work

sta tions, one work statio n for each came ra y and they

d ig itally recorded all the footage com tng o ff of

t he s e ca m e r a s .

Denn bs maintained it; I d idn ft .

m y only invo lvem ent wa s o riginal fy setting up the

hardware .

After thaty he ma intained a1l the actual

10

record ing and ma intenance o f these machine s .

11

h is son .

13

11

He and

oa:so

I don 't know , Jessie might h ave had som e


involvem ent .

Q.

I don 't know .

And you had m ent toned that you and

1$

Mr . Trepp had gone and looked at what w as sto red on

16

that video system?

17

O0:sn

I had --

12

.- -.-..-

A.

00:50

A b o u t n o on on th e 1 0t h , w e w e n t a n d l o o ke d

18

on the -- a11 o f those hard d rives fo r those

19

rec ording machine s had been cieaned o ff .

20

modifiecl date on the folders for reco rd inq was the --

21

between 8 :00 and 9:00 in th e m orning on the 9th , so

22

for that -- for those m od ified dates , it m eans th at

23

tho se fo lders -- the last t im e someth ing wa s on those

24

folders was betw een 8 :00 and 9 :00 a .m . in th e morning

LIZA CHAE'EN , CCR r RMR

The last

(775) 323-5492

0O:sn

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 51 of 222


' Ax<
y. '

tr
)
l
4
,

z)j)

o f Ja n ua r y 9t h .

A ft i
ar th a t , it h a d h ee n d e le t ed o f f .

Q.

Does e7'reppid have an a la rm system ?

A.

Yes , wt do y ma intained by ATD .

Q.

Cou Ld you describe that?

A.

We rve on ly got -- I believe there was five

codes fo r the aia rm prio r to Lhe -- prio r to this

incident .

9
10

Patty ha one , and 1 believe Jessie Anderson and J im

11

Bauder shared one ; and only th ose people could tu rn

12

off the alarm to come in the b uilding at any time

13

they wan ted Lo .

15

ooisl

Barjinder Ba1 probably had one; 1fm not


s u re .

aotsl

16

1 hacl an o1d list o f who had what ala rm

17

codes from 2002, so I don 't know w hat the -- when we

18

m oved in lo the b uild ing, f don 't know what had

19

been -- changes m ade since then .

20

Q.

21

alarm on and off?

22

oO:s1

Dennis had one , Warren had one, I had one :

14

j-wqyr

A.

Can y ou tell by those codes who turned the

Each user, from m y file , which is the

23

Nov ember of 2002 , that I got from Dennis, it had user

24

numbers Eor each code .

LIZA CHAPRN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

oo:sl

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 52 of 222

)....
J
1

j,()

Go , gor examp ze , I thin k I wa s User

N o . 12 , De n n is w a 55 U se r N o . l3 , a nd t he A T D A l a rm

lo(gs wh ic h we rfac i)ive d s how s wh a L u s e r n umb e r c afne in

and w hat hours f which one set the a la rm , which one

t u rn e d th e a la rm o f f .

6
7

8
9

10

Q.

oo:sz

Cou ld you te ll -- is a report generated of

th o s e c o d e s ?

A.

Right .

AT D keeps tho se and we geL them by

request .

Q.

Did ycu request a rep ort for who was in

11

and out of the bu ilding on the w eekend o f J anuary 7th

12

an d 8 th ?

13

A.

Yes , w e did .

checked -- we reset th e ala rm codes on the bu ild ing

15

on the 10th .

16

and we added new codes for just a smaller group of

17

p e op le , a n d w e a l so g o t t h e lo g a nd 5% sh o w e d t h e 7 t h

18

and the 8th weekend , User No . 13, wh ich is Dennis , is

19

the only one that cam e in the bu ilding .

Q.

21
22
23
24

We had AT D come out and reset the codes

Let me ask you a few quest ions .


You had ta lked about e-ma ils .

Were there

any e-m ails th at we re deleted at the com pan y?


A.

00:52

I requested it when 1

14

20

('

'7'

W ell , I do n 't know about everybody r but I

know in pa rticu La r 1 ran recovery so ftware on a

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

o0:s2

oo:sa

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 53 of 222


.

(wy'
e

jj1

1o t. - - wda ra n re c(nve ry so f tkia re s ta r t inci o n t he 10 th

to try to recover deleted file s on eve rybody 's

machines .

A n d a 1 1 t he p ro g ram m e r s f w o r k s t a t io n s h a d

a wipe a ad delete prog ram , which is a prog ram used to

wipe off sp ace on the hard clrive .

them to Xecla ssify' hard d rives .

every sp ace on the hard drives .

T he m ilitary uses

It w ipes zeroes

10

run -- h ad this w ipe and delete program run on al1 of

11

them , so nothing was able to be recov ered from any o f

12

t h o se .

station and they had wipe and de lete run on there but

15

it hadn 't wiped and deleted a11 the area s .

16

The recycle bin are a hadn 't been wiped .

17

It h ad b e e n em p t ied b u t n o t w i pe d , an d I r e c ov e re d

18

nine e-m ail files from that that had b een de leted on

19

o r b efore December 11th and 12th .

21
22

oo:ba

But q ran it on Denn is ' personal work

14

20

ao:53

So .
/1 1 o f t he p ro q r am m e r s ' m a c h ine s h a d

13

1.

( g'

Q.

Did any of the other emp lo yee s complain

about the ir e-m ail files that had be en d eleted?


A.

I had one p rogramm er, Krishn a Tangira la,

23

comp lain that when I w as gone , Dennis took h is hard

24

drive away and gave it back to him with just a clean

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

on:53

oo:s4

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 54 of 222

(
y
kt

-. .

1
4

..-

.-.-

jX 'gr

--

j5y)

slate harti dr.


i.v,, just: the ope rati-ng system .

And ) asked Dennis about that .

Th is is

th e we e k o f t h e 3 zd t o t he 6t h .

he said th at Krishna 's mach ine had crashed and died .

I a s ked De n n is a nd

A n d 1' c
as ke d K r j.sh n a an d h e s a id th at

wasn ': true.

too k his hard drive .

MR . FLYNN: Objection; hearsay .

THE COURT :

MR . FLYNN: Objection, hearsay.

11

THE COUHT :

12

A sk another questio n .

13

MR . JAKO PIN :

16

Sustained .

10

15

:Q:b4

The computer was working fine; he just

14

Fine , your Hono r .

BY M R . JAKOPIN :

Q.

O the c than Krishna , d id any o ther

Object ion ; he arsay .

18

T HE COURT :

1 'm not sure 1 'm go ing to

19

sustain that .

20

o f m ind and what they did afterwards than it doe s the

21

truth o f the matte r .

24

oo:ss

employees comp lain about e -m ails hav ing been deleted ?

M R . FLYNN :

23

o0:s4

It 's su stasned .

17

22

('

I thin k th is g oe s m ore to th eir state

1 111 consider it on ly for the former as


opposed to th e latter .

Go ahead .

LIZA CHAPJSN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

oo:ss

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 55 of 222

(z.,r,.
1

- -

t sz-

B Y M R . JA KO P IN :

Q.

Answer the quest ion .

A.

They d cln 't de lete

I d on 't believe the y

com plained about f'-nlails be ing deleted ; they

complained about sou rce code on their m ach ines beinq

deleted .

7
8
9

Q.

A.

Did you do any recove ry fo r e-m ails of

E-m ails, no .
1 only -- we t ried recovery of a 11 files

11

deleted, not just e-mails. We tried to recover

12

anyth ing deleted .

13
14

e-ma ils; we were tryjng to figure out what was

15

deleted .

00:56

We d idn 't know what was de leted overall :

17

so w e w e r e t r y in g t o re c ov e r t o d e te rm in e w ha t w a s

18

deleted .

19

MR . JA KOPIN :

20

THE CO URT :

That ls al1 1 have .

Cro ss?

O0:s6

21
22

24

oo:ss

So we weren 't just narrow ing in on

16

00:55

anyone othe r than Mr . Montgom e ry 's e -m ails ?

10

23

5a

CROSS EXAM INATION


BY MR . FLYNN :

Q.

You testified about a conversation that

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 56 of 222

)
1
t

54

yo u ha d w it h M lT. 1
',
1o nt g om e r y ab o u t b i g m o n e y ?

A.

Right .

Q.

And l3e lieve you said that Mr . Montqome ry

said that unless the gove rnment qave h im b ig m oney --

some thing ; is tlla t correct?

eo:56

A.

No .

Q.

No ?

A.

He d idn t mention the government .

Q.

Was it un less Mr . T repp gave him b ig

10

money ?

00:56

11

A.

M r . Trepp was the words he used .

12

Q.

And that conversation took p lace on

13

January 10th?

14

A.

That 's riqht .

15

Q.

Now , let 's go b ac k to the begin ninq of

16

your employm ent .

In m y offiee .

17

I 'v e n o ti c e d i n y ou r De c la r a t io n a n d yo u r

18

test imony he re , you keep us ing the singula r eTrepp id

19

sou rce code .

20

21

f 7-

A re you aware o f that?

A.

00:57

1 ca Ll it the co llective .

It 's m ultip le

22

projects, multiple source code files, so eTreppid

23

source cod e is probably m ore than a hund red different

24

projects, thousands of files.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

00:56

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 57 of 222


-..e

1
1

Q.

th a t j.n yo u r De c)1.a ra t io n

e T re p p id s o u r ca c cd e .

s:

Now , so you ag ree w ith me# though ,

y ou u se d t.h e E;in (
JL1ia r

In you c testim ony here , you fve been us ing


the e T re pp id s(3u rc e cod e i n t h e s i n(gu 1a r .

6
A.

R ight .

Q.

But wh nt you really m eant was

collectively ?

10

A.

11
12

R ig h t .

oc:sv

MR. JAKOPIN: Objection; argumentative.


BY M R . FLY N N :

13

Q.

ts that correct?

14

r HR COURT :

15

lt 's not a statem ent .

Ho , T th in k it 's a question .
n0:sJ

16

G o ahead , answer it .

17

T H E W IT N E SS :

18

Q.

23

24

N ow , let 's talk about what co llect ive ly

means .

n0:s7

21
22

T h at 's c o r r e ct

BY MR . FLYNH :

19
20

oo:57

You ag ree w ith that ?

O kay .

jg'

When you first started wor king at


eTrepp id , describe actually what you were doing .
A.

1 was programm ing the gam e engine that I

had develop ed previous to work tng fo r eTreppid ,

LIZA CHAPEN r CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 58 of 222

f
'M -/
1
1

'.

b6
.

c on L.
inu i ncg d e ve 1.o p j.ng o :1 j-t .

Denn is and W arren wanted me to possib ly

ma ke it into a Henny Rogers video gamez The G ambker .

We exp Lo red that route .

We exp lored many diffe rent routes , but

programming it .

Q.

How long did you work on that ?

A.

C o up Le o f y ea r s .

Q.

How many files would you est im ate you

10

created ?

C ompute r files?

A.

C o u p Le t ho u sa n d .

12

Q.

How lnany computer lbraries would you

14

e stimate you --

A.

15

1 1/1 tncluding the lib ra rie s.


When you compile source eode /
' it generates

16

libraries a s ntc rmediate files .

17

those as final fjles, but l 'm includ ing those files ,

18

as well .

19
20
21

22

23
24

Qo:sa

0O:b8

11

13

j
'

('&

Q.

You can a lso u se

So cart you characterize any of the se files

co llective ly as libraries?
A.

O r no?

Lib raries are part o f a source code .

They fre pre- -- they fre inte rm ed iate comp iled file .

Q.

0o:b8

How m any so urce cod es were there fo r th is

video qame techno logy ?

LIZA C!HAPEFI: CCRr RMR

(775) 323-5492

0o:s8

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 59 of 222


(
,.....
(
'
qs-2
.

1
i

A.

The actual C++ fizes is what you 're

referr ing Lo ?

Q.

Kxp lain to the Cour l


- what a C ++ file is .

A.

T ha t 's the actua) - - wh en you 're

p rogramm ing, you can prog ram in va rious langu ages .

p rog rammed in C.4+ .

T h e y 're b a s ic a l ly t e x t f i le s .

read them with just a regular notepad, even, and

the se comp ile to generate librar ies as interm ed iate ,


and fknally as an e xecutab le .

11

00:59

So I -- you create the text -- these

12

va rious text -- Cd+ text fi Les, and I w ould say there

13

we re several hundred ; maybe 800 in the game engine .

14
15

Q.

Eight hundred source codes just for the

video technology hhat you worked for two years on ?

16

A.

Correct .

17

Q.

And that takes u s up to 200 1?

18

A.

Into 2002 .

19

Q.

And the --

20

A.

I m ean, I still work on -- I 'm shi ll

21

working on it regularly with one of ou r programmers :

22

M ich ae l Svatek .

23
24

0::59

Y ou ca n

10

.''r .

Q. Were there any other projects you worked


on betw een the inception of your emp loyment and

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

:0:s9

00:59

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 60 of 222

('-w.
)'
f

throughout the tioe you were workinq on the v ideo

game project?

A.

Theater System .

Q.

for that?

A.

10
11

:j

T he plqhyer that we used for the lntel Home

And Low many source codes d id you create

T here was not as many as the game engine ,

but a coup le hundred .

Q.

How many lines o f code were involved --

Thousands .

13

Q.

Tens 01.
2 thousa nds ?

14

A.

Ten s of thousands .

15

Q.

But you 're not calling those source cod es?

A.

That is C++ coding .

18

Q.

So there were tens of thousands of sou rce

21
22

23
24

u1:o0

Because that 's not C++ coding?

17

20

nn no

are involved in the video game technolog y?


A.

19

n!:no

1 can 't recall w ith tha t .

12

16

',

(.
7.

codes just for the video game technology?


A.

Yo u wouldn 't call th at sourc e code .


Sou rce code re fers to the ac tual code to

m ake up a program .

Q. Okay. And on this second project you were


wor king on, how many l ines of code did you create

LIZA CHAPEN : CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

on oo

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 61 of 222

e..)
1

A.

I d on 't recall .

1 wtlskeci on it w jth a coup le of other


programm ers .

Q.

Dur ing this period of time , did you wo rk

on any other addlional projects other than those

tw o ?

A.

Program -w ise r no .

Q.

So dur lng this two-year pe riod ,

10

col lective ly , hcw m any source codes d id you create

11

for eTrepp id Technology?

12

A.

Just add up the ones we just talked about .

13

Q.

So L,ow m any?

14

A.

Lines o f code or files or what are you

15

01:01

01:01

Rough ky ?

as king?

01:01

16

Q.

Wel L, let 's deal with line s of code .

17

A.

A c od e is n 't l i ke s om e l i t t le s im p le ca rd

18

or something. it's not just one little bit of

19

numb er .

20

ca ll -- source code is what m akes up a p rogram

21

i
,

59

d u r i n q t h a t tw (n- yt?a r p e r iod th c)t w e 're t a 1 k ing a b ou t ?

('-v
-j

You would n 't ca ll that a cod e .

You would
.

Go to m ake up y like , sayr fo r example r

22

W indows M ed ia Playe r, they have thousands -- 1O , 20,

23

40,0007 who knows how many .

24

collectively the source code that ma kes Windows M edia

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

You would call that

(775) 323-5492

01:01

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 62 of 222


,

tM-.h

$.

P la y e r .

Q.

o f c o d es ?

A.

L inils; of code is mo re accurate .

Q.

And co llectivelyz to acces s those tens of

B u t th e re a re , in f,Ac t . t e n s o f th ou s a nd s
L j n.
E)s :?f (rod e ?

t h ou s a nd s o f l in e s o f c od e , h ow m u c h so u r c e c od i n g

wou ld you need?

A.

Your que stion doesn 't ma ke m uch sense .

Q.

Does it a 1l end up in an executable file?

10

A.

lt al1 ends up in one file .

11

12

01:02

help er files , if you want to b e simp le ab out it .


DLLS are like -- you would say W indows

14

Med ia Playe r ha s one executab le and m aybe 10 , 20

15

add itiona l files to m ake it run .

16

Q.

A l1 right .

01:02

How m any lines of code a re

17

i nv o l v ed i n t ho se tw o ty p e s o f fi l e s ?

18

file or the executable?

19

A.

20

thousand .

21
22

23

24

O1:a2

O r possib ly auxilia ry DLL files , which are

13

jj(;

T he h e lp e r

Tens of thousand s; 50,000 , m aybe a hund red


01:03

For like the W indows Operating System ,


it 's m illions of line s o f code .

Q.

So if we we re dealing w ith som ething you

want to call source code to access that --

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 63 of 222

)...h

t--77.

(;).

A.

U h -tllh .

Q.

-- how many actual kines o f code would we

b e dea ling with in that source code?

4
5

A.

For krhat, like the p layer 1 made for

lntel?

01:03

Q.

Yeah .

A.

That one had thou sand s of lines .

The game engine thah 'sr you know -- lines

in there , 1 b e l.aev e there 's 50 ,000 , prob ab ly , in al1

10

the various p arts .

11

01:03

Q.

A nd whatt would you call those?

13

A.

There ts no codes, plu ral ; it 's code ,

14

singular .

15

Q.

12

16

Source

codes?

But Lt involv es tens of thousands of lines

o f code?

17

A.

L in e s o 1: c od e i s th e a c tu a l t e rm .

18

Q.

Okay .

20

A.

Which technology?

21

Q.

This technology for the v ideo game ?

22

A.

We have that .

19

23

Now, where is that technology

toda y?
01:03

That hasn 't been deleted .

It 's kept on m y m ach ine ; m y programmer ,

t'
1,

24

:1:03

Michael Svatek rs , mach ine ; and also we have that

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 64 of 222


.

q
'-.h
'

l
,

(..
u
'

'

6z

T ha t w a sn 't d e le ted .

Q.

So when you we re g ivinq your te stimony on

direct , when you sa id a11 the se source code s --

e'
rrepp id source code was de leted --

A.

Uh-huh .

Q.

-- you weren 't re ferring to two years o f

work and tens of thousands o f lines o f code , pe rhap s

million s?

10

A.

11

Dennis ha s never had any invo lvement in

Q.

You were not referring, even though you

11

used the s ingu lar f you we re not referr ing to those

15

ten s of thousands o f line s of code on the v ideo game

16

technology , w ere you?

17

A.

No .

18

Q.

And that is eTreppid source code , isn 't

20

A.

That 's som e of the eTrepp id sou rce code .

21

Q.

But you didn 't m ake that d istinct ion , did

23

A.

We 've got r I would say --

24

Q.

Please. Again, you didn 't make that

22

01:04

Please , p lease , M r . V enab les .

13

19

01:04

do ing the game eng ine .

12

s t i.1 1 o n o u r S 11C SF,J?V E R .

'

ol:a4

it ?

you ?

LIZA CHAPRN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:04

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 65 of 222

r
t
.'w'.''
j
1
f

A.

-- one pe lcent o i the eTrepp id source code

i s t h e g a m e e n g in e .

Q.

Th ank you .

S o L f7 th e re a re t en s o f th o u s an d s a nd th a t

represents one percent , then the eTrepp id source code

involves m illions and m illions of lines of code , does

it not ?

A.

We don 't have tha t much .

is m ore complex than a 1ot of the other eT repp id

11

stu ff .

13

1 would say in the hundreds o f thousands .

Q.

A re you able to d raw on the b lackb oard an

outline o f th e networ k stru chu re , the in frastructure

15

at eTrepp id T echnologies?

16

A.

IV

.Q.

18

A.

01:05

Yes .
How the computer ne twork was set up?

Yes .
MR . FLYNN :

W ith the C ourt 's pe rm ission,

20

could we m ove the b lackboard pe rhap s over here so the

21

Court could see it?

22

THE COU RT :

Yes .

23

MR . FLYNN :

And hav e the w itness --

24

01:05

14

19

n1:as

T he game enqine

10

12

)'

63

distinct ion ?

2
3

(%.g

BY M R . FLYNN :

LIZA CHAPRN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

n1:ob

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 66 of 222

(r...j
1
(

Q.

64

Be fo ,7e w e do tha t:, d id yo 12 h a v e , in yo u r


.

hom e, a pe rsona l connection to a L1 of the servers at

eT tepp id Techno lo gy?

A.

p rivate networ k.

I hacl a d jal-up VPN at my house , v i rtu a l


0l:oG

T hat lets me connect to the office through

an encrypted hunnel so the passwords o r anything else

cou ldn 't be sp ied on over the (nte rnet , and 1 had seL

up that VPN in September of th ks p ast year so I can

10

mon itor our ma gLl server on our WEBSERVER .

11

Q.

Why d id you set that up ?

12

A.

So

13

E can monitor our ma il servers and our

Occasionally , our netwo rks would go down

15

and I w an ted ho m a ke sure that -- Dennis w anted to

16

ma ke su re -- I w anted to m ake sure that they w eren 't

17

g o in g - - t h ey w e r e n 't dy i n g o n u s g a nd I c a n w a tc h

18

them from my hou se .

19
20

house .

on o6

Q.

Did anyone else have that capability?

22

A.

No .

24

oz:o6

That could only b e connected to from my

21

23

01:06

WEBSERVER and ou r network status .

14

Patty G ray wanted it set up for her house

in Phoenix, but wzj hadn't set that up yet .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 67 of 222

)--j
1
t

Q.

(;s

And so you -- what would you call it ,

v irhua t p rivat a network?

A.

T h a t 's r ig h t .

Q.

Can you tell the Court w hether you d id

this because a rte r a ce rta in date and tim e there

seemed -- there began a period whe re there were tens

of hhousands o f efforts to intrude into the eTreppid

software?

A.

contract was made public by som e sort o f press

11

release by som ebody in the military r ou r n e tw o r k w a s

12

constantly under attack .


So w e beefed up ou r router system .

0nn7

I got

14

a m uch stronger C tsco rou ter , and l ran -- sta rted

15

running in tru sion detection software to see who was

16

try ing to get into ou r networ k from the outside .

17

18

Q.

01:07

Now y man y hits after the first -- can we

call it a m ilitary contract?

19

A.

Rkght .

20

Q.

A fte r the first m ilitary cont ract w as made

21

pub lic, a s you put it, how m any hits began to ap pear

22

per day?

23
24

a1:ov

A ftez , I believe , our first m ilitary

10

13

4
'
;

('.
y

A.
fo

We w ere getting thousand s a day g prob ab ly

ur or five th ousand .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:08

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 68 of 222

;
'=..;

(x..;,?

1
t

t he re w e re a lo t ; 4- to 5 ,0 00 ra n g e .

I kfaep a lo .

inputs .

Q.

were you gett ing?

9
10

1 have a 1og o f a11 the

It 's been record jng s nce that period .

A.

A nd p rio r to that , how m any h its per day

01:08

Plior to the m ilitary contract?

W e host variou s web s ites ,

so includin q

tho se , probably a couple hundred , maybe 500 a day .

Q.

So it went from 500 a day to 4- to

5 ,000 --

ol:aa

11

A,

T housand .

12

Q.

-- or mo re per day?

13

A.

Right .

14

Q.

Now , the first m ilita ry contract : just in

15

as few wo rds as possible to give a desc ription o f it

16

for the C ou rt , how would you characterize it , just in

17

te rm s o f s om e t y p e o f a d e sc r ip t io n ?

18

A.

19

contract .

20

Q.

Warren and Dennis --

In fact , you never had access to any of

the source codes o r any of the governm ent contracts

22

did you ?

24

A.

n1:oa

I don 't have a l1 the d etails about our

21

23

1t '.
l; tap i?red o f f s in cia, bu t. in i t ia 1 1-y

(:
;(;

I d on 't actually -- 1 know what program s

we delivered to them

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:09
,

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 69 of 222

Q.

A l l 1-j.(
gh t..

A.

1 was invo lved in --

Q.

You neve r had ac cess to any of them?

(Discussion o ff the record .)

T H E C O U RT :

M R . l3EF,K :

his answer be fore --

T H E CC U R T :

Q.

11

Y e s , y e s , ye s .

W hat 's the answe r to my question?


T H E CG UR T :

L e t h im f in i sh t h e l a st

THE WITNESS :

11

THE COURT :

Which part?

Do you rem ember the question?

BY MR . FLYNN :

Q.

01:09

Did you ev er have access to any of the

17

l in e s o f c od e d on e b y M r . M o n t go m e ry o n th e s ec re t

18

government projects?

19

20

A.

01:09

The actual code to generate those


executab les , I haven 't seen an y of that .

23
24

1 know what executable s we de liv ered .

was involv ed w ith the delive ry .

21
22

01:09

answe r.

16

f
'

Will he he allowed to finish

13

15

nl:09

BY MR . FLYHN :

10

12

O n e a t a Lim e .

Q.

Yo u were never given acces s to them , were

you?

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 70 of 222


(
h'
-h
,
'

'

'

- .- - -

.- -

- =

'
r'

A.

R i.g h t -

Q.

N ow , can we use the term , fo r the first

m ilitary contract , facia l recognihio n?


A.

I don 't even know if that was it .


1 be tieve the first contract was more with

the Predator .

pub licly known th Lrlg .

8
9

Q.

So you d on 't even know wh ich one actually

came first ?
A.

H uh -uh .

11

Q.

Is l t fair --

12

I hav e a --

01:10

Go ahead .

A.

I have an actua l -- for pa rt of ou r

14

fac ilit y, m iljtary fac ilit y, l 've got copies of

15

the -- what 's ca qled DD Fo rm 254 f wh ich is the

16

m ilitary cont ract gorm .

17

18
19

cn zo

I h a v e t h e eo p i e s c)f th e o r ig in a l o n e o f

that , and th e first one c ame from the A ir Force .


Q.

S o you were g iven -- because of the actual

20

fo rm in the cont ract, you were given som e knowledge

21

by someone at eTreppid about what the end result was

22

of what M r . Montgomery wa s doing ; is that a fair

23

character izat ion?

24

on lo

That ts the public -- pub lic --

10

13

(jjj

X-.

. .

Ju st overall , general , what it w as ab out .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:10

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 71 of 222


a.,h
(;,y
I.
.

1
1

D.

B u t y o u w ou l d n ev e r - .- no 0 ne e v e r to 1(El
.

you sp ec i f Lc a 1 1.y 'ah a t h e w a s do i (Ag ?

A.

No .

Q.

A 11 riqht .

outline o f the ne tworking infrastructure at

eTreppid --

7
8

10

THE C'OURT :

Ts there something for him to

T HE CLERK :

I be lieaze there 's ch alk up

the re .

01:11

11

T HE CO URT :

O kay .

12

T HE CLERK :

Would they like to u se the

13

16

17
18
19

A 11 right .

paper or the chalkboard?

14
15

01:11

write w ith ?

(
.

If we cou ld have you c reate an

THE COURT :

t pre fer the paper , if we 've

got some .

01:11
M R . FLYNN :

The pape r may be better for

your Honor, if you couYd just makntain custody of it .


THE COURT :

I dm going to m aintain custody

o f it a fter it s filled out .

20

And we 'll mar k it --

an zz

21

M R . FLYNN :

Thank you , yor Honor .

22

T HE COURT ;

-- as Exhibit 1 .

23

Did you hear that , Greg?

24

THE CLERK :

Yes .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492 '=

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 72 of 222

I)
'

. --

7:
.-

(Exhibit 1 was marked for dentification .)

THE W ITNESS :

4
5

What exactly do you want m e

to dkaqram ?
Hetwo rk structure is pretty open ; we don 'h
h a ve a 1o t o f d tv js io n s .

01:12

(Discussion o ff the record .)

THE W ITNESS :

Ou r netwo rk struc tu re is

fairly open .

sub-networ ks on our netw ork .

10

We clon 't have any subd ivisions or

W e have our m ain Internet , sa y, com ing --

11

say this is the Tnternet com ing into ou r ma in router,

22

which is C isco router .

13

of fire w all instruction s w hich prevents w hat can

14

com e into the netwo zk .

15
16
17

0::12

In that route r, I have a list

I basically 1et eve rything go out ; hhere 's

n1:12

no re striction on that .
A f t e r t h at , I h av e a s e r ie s o f sw itc h es

18

set up in a rack that al1 of the comp uters in the

19

bu ildings are set up to .

20

another interm ediate router be fore this , wh ich does

21

our NA T , wh ich is Network A dd ress Trans lation .

22

('7/

--

'

I actua lly go thtough

So everybody on the Intel network is on a

23

priv ate IP seqment, so these m achine s c an 't even be

24

seen from the Internet except through one IP

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:13

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 73 of 222

(..-)
1

to tell you what it is , but t 's one private IP

everybody 's in the bu ild ing r looks like , o u t o n th e

n etw o r k , o n t h e In te r ne t .

sitez everybody in the build kng looks like just one

IP.

So if you 're busy in a web

building are p lug ged into this .

server s and a11 the wo rk stations thah a11 the

That includes our

p rogramm ers use .

11

on la

I had one other segmen t o f network set up

12

out in the w arehouse .

13

Denn is u sed regularly for do ing som e o f h is

14

classified pro jects.

15

These a re the machines that

Th ose were going th rou gh anothe r m achine .

16

That m a chine was the gatew ay to th is network .

17

w e r en 't a n y re s t r kct io n c o n t ro l s ; th ks t r af f i c w as

18

two-way .
We were go ing to put another route r he re

20

in p lace o f th is comp uter because this compute r was

21

not ver y rel iab le .

22

24

That s the basic st ructure .


BY MR . FLYNN :

Q.

What would we call this?

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:13

There

19

23

01:13

T hen, every -- a11 the m achines in the

10

.yy

T his one IP is set up -- 1 don 't even need

tq
..yj

01:14

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 74 of 222

f Ah

t-7

1
t

2
3

Y o u sa .
Lcl it 's in t hi? kla re ho u se ?

T h is s e t

o f ma ch in e s t h (
:,t 'po u s a id De n n 1s w a s '
ao r k ing w it h ?
A.

De n rli s c a 11e d the ra 12h63 c lu st e r .

T h e y w e re

a (
Jro up o f W inc1ow :5 )(P w o r k s ta 1:ic)n s s et up i n - - a t

va r .
i.o u s t im e s f w e l-la d d i f f'e re n t am ou n t s .

in each rack .

cab inet .

10
11

Q.

Each one of the se w ou ld be a rac k

A nd whe re was Dennis actua lly wo rking in

connection w ith the clu ster?


A.

o f d iv ided in two p arts .

13

offices .

17

18
19
20

21
22
23
24

The fronh section is

This back sect ion here is w arehouse .

14

16

01:14

Th is w as up in our -- our building is kind

12

15

:1:14

T here 's about five of these work stations

j
'

72

az

..

Denn js had set up a ser ies of tab les out


he re that he wo rked on .

Q.

O kay .

He was regularly out here .

1:14

A nd where did you w ork ,

M r . Ve n ab l e s ?

A.

Our serv er room was up in th is area and my

o ffice is right next to it .


So our servers were here and I was here .

Q. Okay . Could you just put the initials DM


down there .
And wh o w orked in these work stations over
here in the warehou se , near Dennis?

LIZA CFIAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5192

o1:z4

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 75 of 222

r'
-)
1
'
'

A.

Ju s t. Ee J1n i.s .
W a 1'r e rl ()c CJa s io na 11 y w a s o ttt t h e re w o r ki ng

w it h h im .

Q.

A nd n o ()n e e 1 se '?

A.

R ig h t .

Q.

D ici y o u ev e r (
;o o u t th e re a nd w o r k on a n y

8
9

Ol:Lb

o f t ho se w o r k s ta t io n s ?

A.

Troubleshooting , helping him clone them to

m ake more of them .

10

Q.

Bu t actually creat ing line s of code --

11

A.

No .

12

Q.

-- d id you ever do that ?

13

A.

Neve r .

14

Q.

The answer was neve rr correct ?

15

A.

Righ t .

MR . FLYNN :

17

Y ou ca n r e su m e t h e s ta n d , p l e a se .

18

THE COURT :

22

Than k you , sir .

A re there going to b e any

additions to th is draw in g?

20
21

ol:ls

01:15

16

19

73

M R . FLYNN :

I believe so .

THE COURT :

A ll right .

M r . Montgomery

w ill be - -

23

there y then , untjl we --

24

BY MR . FL YN N :

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

We fll leave it up

(775) 323-5492

o1:ls

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 76 of 222


-

Q.

Where were the programmers achua lly

tha t the p rogrammers --

A.

R i g ht .

Q.

-- were actually wo rk ing ?

A.

Th at section there Lhat 1 have that Lop

01:16

diagram o n is actually a two-s to ry a rea .

warehouse is a k1 sngle-story .

11

12
13

The

So some of them were on the seeond floor

Q.

So , for exam ple , on the v deo game , was

th at d ata com p ressson-type technolo gy?

A.

No, just 3-D rendering.

15

Q.

So e'
rreppid Technolo gies was doing

16

software technology other than just data compression,

17

c o r re c t ?

A.

19
20

23

24

01:16

Co rrect .
MR . PEEK :

Counse l, I can 't see the

w itness .

01:16

21

22

0n t6

some we re on th e Jrirst floor .

14

18

/4

I believe -- are these the work stat ion

10

f-''7

working ?

3
4

T han k you .

B Y M R . FLYNN :

Q.

A nd who w as in charge o f these prog rammers

working over heue?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

'

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 77 of 222

1
/
z'7

(
.
''-SZ

.'

1
2

A.

Gentqra Lly Denn is wats in cha rge o f a 11 the

prog ramm ers in th e bu ilding .

3
4

y:

Q.

A nd who were -- can you give the identity

o f those p rogramm ers for the Court?

A.

Upsla i rs area or the downstairs area?

Q.

Upsta i rs first .

A.

Upslrairs, we had Aarjinder Bal.

I oI4ly remembe r hjs first nam e , Ka rthik.

T h is i s c u r re n t ; w e dv e h a d p e op le com e a nd

10

g o ove r the yeazs .

11

Venkat a Ka lluri .

12

Lal i.th Tenneti .

13

Q.

14

15

01:16

lf t could just stop you there .


Mr . Ba ls and M r . Ka llur i are the same

people that have subm itted Dec larations in this case ?

16

A.

Co rrect .

17

Q.

But they never wo rked with Dennis down in

18

th is o ther a rea you 've got dow n be low , either , did

19

they?

20
21

22

91:16

A.

Th ey were occasionally down there .

do n rt know for what .

The upper a rea had g lass w ind ows so we

23

could see who went down to that area , an d I observed

24

just about everybody in the building down there with

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:17

01:17

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 78 of 222

).-)
1

y(y

De n n is a t o ne t im e o r an o th e r .

Q.

cr e a ti o n ?

A.

Fo r /1hat project'?

Q-

T o y 0 u 17 kno w l ed g e ?

A.

I have no idea wh at they d id for him .

Q.

O kay .

B u t th 6)y 14e v e r d id a n y so u rc e c od e

ol:17

: nd would you cont inue with the

identity o f the programm ers, p lease .

A.

10

that one .

Just programmers, Michael Sv atek ; you got


01:17

11

Jessie Anderson .

12

I believe that 's a1l hhe p rogramme rs

13

upsta krs .

14

p ro g r amm e r s .

15

Q.

The re 's other people , b ut those are the

All right .

Now , so you tv e done -- during

16

those first two years , did you do any work that we

17

w ou ld c a l l d at a cem p re ss io n - t yp e w o r k?

18

A.

No .

19

Q.

Do you know of anyone who did?

20

A.

Ven kata d id .

21

Q.

A nyone e tse?

22

A.

I 'm su re others .

23

nl:la

I know h im for su re ; I rv e seen the

24

prog ram s he 's worked on .


.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

01:17

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 79 of 222

?-)
1
j

Q.

.1-1

Dur in tho se first two years , what

p e rc e n ta r
ge o f Lh e c;om p an y w o r k , i f yo u kno w , wa s da ta

co mp re s s i()n - t yp e w o rk ?

4
5

A.

1n i t ia 1 J.y,
.

I L)e 1ieve that was the rt


ajority

o f w ha t. w e we re clo ng .

Q.

:&:1e

Have you ever seen any of the books or

records o f the com pany ?

A.

No .

Q.

Have you ev er seen any of the agreements

10

between Mr . --

11

A.

12

of:la

No .
We lt, a s far as record s , 1 h ave th e

13

majority stockholder list as part of our facility

14

security .

15

Q.

In you r office?

16

A.

Yes .

17

Q.

De scribe those records, p lease .

18

A. They show who the majority shareholders

19

20

r'-h

I have that info rmation .

n1:18

a re .

For ge thing you r facility se curity

21

c learance , you need to know if the com pany ha s any

22

foreign inte rest in the com pan y so that we could

23

have -- foreign interest or influence , so the records

24

show -- 1 be lieve it 's Friendly C ap ital Partners ,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

n1:18

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 80 of 222

V--'
)
1

Q.

That 's M r . Trepp , a lso, correct?

A.

M r . T re p p re p re s en t :T D e nn i s a n d B re nd a

M on t gom e ry , a n d 1 b e l ie v e o ne ot h e r s ha r e - - th e r e 's

three shareholders on this as the majority

s h a r eh o ld e r s .

Q.

Is W ayne Primm one of tho se ?

A.

He 's not on the list .

Q.

Is Randy Ha lloway on that list?

10

A.

The list has M r . Trepp personally ,

11

Mr . T repp representing Friend ly Capital, and Dennis

12

and B renda Monlrgom ery .

14
15

Q.

Is M ichael M ilken in an y of the records as

17

T e c h n o lo g ie s - -

18

A.

Not that I know o f.

19

Q.

-- that you have p ossession of?

20

A.

N ot that 1 have, no .

21

Q.

A re you awa re that M r . T repp has stated

24

ol:la

majority shareholders list.

be ing shown as a shareho lder o f eT reppid

23

01:19

Those are the three ma in entities on the

16

22

78

a nd - -

13

fN)

o1:la

that he is a sha reholde r of eT reppid Techno logy?


A.

Yes .

That Mr . Trepp is ?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

ol:tg

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 81 of 222


7.
. -6
.

1.

Q.

'
i'h a t M r . M i-lke n i s .

A.

O h , i do n 't kno w ab (3u t: th a t:.

Q.

A r e y'o u a wa re o f w h (n M r - M i 1 ke n i s ?

A.

Ye s .

Q.

In fa ct , h e 's - - ha ve you e v e r

parhicipated in any discussions with M r . T repp about

M ichael M i tken 's knvolvement o f eT reppid Technology

and bein g a co nv icted felon ?

MR . FLYNN :

If 1 can finish z your Honor .

11

THE COIJRT :

Yeah , 1et him finish the

12

question.

13

until 1 hear it .

14

BY M R . FL Y N N :

16

Q.

In being a conv icted felon , and that fact

01:20

o1:zo

in te rtering witb the governmen t milihary contracts?

THE GOIJRT : Wait.

18

Sit down, Counsel, just for a minute .

19

A 11 right .

20

THE WITNESS :

Hold on just a second .

He 's never ta lked to m e

ab out M r . M ilken .

22

MR . PEEK :

23

T HE COIJRT :

24

O1t20

I don't know if it's objectionable or not

17

21

79

MR. JAKOPIN : Objection, your Honor.

10

15

47

Mr . Venab kes , p lea se .


N ow , go ahead and a sk the

question so I can --

LIZA CIIAPFN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:20

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 82 of 222


>-..

ap

B Y M R . FL Y NN :

Q.

Have you ever had any d iscussion with

Mr . T repp ab oui M r. Milken being a shareho lder o f

eTrepp id '
rechno logy, and that ract, because he is a

conv icted felon a t the Drexel -- d uring the Drexe l

days --

M R . PE KK :

conduct .

H Y M R . FL Y N N :

10

There 's no question --

Q.

-- o 1' interfering w ith a government -THE COURT :

12

M R . PE KK :

13

THE COURT :

16

THE COURT :

19
20

21
22

W aih a m inute .

Your co-counse l is handling

this witness -M R . PEEK :

18

Wait, w ait .

01:20

Yo u r H o no r , t he r e 's o n ly - -

15

17

o1:2a

Your Hono r, th is is outrageous

11

14

;zw ,,

O kay .

01:20

-- so a llow him to dea l w ith

t h is i s su e .

MR. JAKOPIN : Objection, your Honor.

He

answered the que stion no .


THE W ITN ESS :

He 's never ta lked to me

about M r . Milken ; never .


T HE COURT :

Well , I - - th is is

23

cro ss-exam inat ion .

I don lt know whethe r there 's any

24

relevance at a11 to this issue about the fe lony

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

on al

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 83 of 222

,--A
1

r'l

a1

c on v ic t i on .

I 'm p e rsona lly very wel l aware who

M r . M lken is, i know what his bac kqround is y and if

we had a jury here, 1'd be a little more worried

about it, but we don 't have a jury.

01:21

i 'm go ing to try to sort out what I thin k

has som ething to do w ith this case , what doesn 't f so

I'm going to go ahead and 1et you go with that just a

little b it , but I do want you Lo tie it in on a -- on

10

relevance ground s.

11
12

0i:21

Mayb e it has to do w ith security


clearances .

13

MR . FLYNN :

lt does, your Honor , and when

14

M r . Montgome ry testifie s, we 'll go into it .

15

BY MR . FLYNN :

16

Q.

91:21

In the boo ks and records that you have, as

17

I u n d e rs t an d y o u r t e s t im o n y , yo u o n l y sh ow t h r ee

18

sha reholders?

19
20

21

A. Three majority; that 's a11 we require for


our fa cility c learance .

01:21

T he gove rnment doesn 't care about any

22

m inority shareho lde rs , any lowe r than -- I forget the

23

num ber ; I think it 's four percent .

'

24

Anything lower than that, they don 't care

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 84 of 222

y'-.
X)
1

j'y

''

Q.

Did yo u eve r have any conv ersations with

anyone from the government about the identity of any

of Lhe shareho Lde rs o f eT repp id Technology?

A.

Thev just wanted to know who the majority

Q.

A nd yo u gave them - -

A.

Basiad on tha t, hhey granted us ou r

10
11

12

facilsty clearanc e .

Q.

O kay .

Explain to the Cou rt what a

A.

FaczLlity clearance is what we get as a

collect ive after the ke y people in our company got

14

their personal clea ran ces .

T he ke y peop le that we 've subm itted were

16

Denn is Montgomery , Warren Trepp v and myself as our

17

fa c i l it y s e c u r it y o f fi c e r .

18

01:22

fac ility clearance is .

13

15

01:22

o n e s w e re .

gyg

a bo u t .

t
'

01:22

A fter u s three got our clearances, they

19

reviewed w ho the sha reholder s were, and a fter that ,

20

what cont ract we had w ith the gove rnm ent -- you

21

have -- to get a clearance : you have to have a

22

cont ract that spec ifie s comp liance , and afte r that

23

they gran ted u s ou r facility clearance , meaning we

24

can handle cla ssified material after a further

L IZA CHAPENy CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:22

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 85 of 222

1--.
1
'

Q.

A.

We weren 't given that fina l pe rm ission

yet .

inspection to kn spect our storage conta iners, our

sa fe s .

9
10

It said tha t w e could but we needed furhher

Q.

been giv en a final security clearance to store


classified m aterial ; is that co rre ct ?
A.

C orrect .

12

Q.

A nd your explanation of the reason why is

14

A.

The rules state that DSS , De fense Security

Serv ice , is in charge of granting th at fina l storage

16

c learance .

17

e x it p r o ce d u r e s to r t h e b u i kd in g , o u r a la rm c o d e

18

stu ff, and also what storaqe containers we fre using

19

and how w e m aintain the proced ures fo r ente ring and

20

takinq out classified m ateria l, wh ich w as part of

21

that review on December 10th , that Jay Dixon came to

22

start -- initiate .

24

:t:23

what aga in , M r . Venab les?

15

23

01;2a

So as of today 's date, eT repp id has never

11

13

Did that c learance (pive eT repp kd the rght

to store any c lassified m aterial ?

83
.

inspech ion to see what storage capab ilities we had .

2
3

y'-$

Q.

01:23

Th ey come and inspe ct wha t our ent ry and

A1l right .

Let 's go back to -- let 's go

back to the var iou s technologie s that you were

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:23

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 86 of 222

!r->
'

'

inv olved in , and 'L gu ess We 're up to some tim e in

200 1, and we 've got: the video gam e technology,

correct ?

A.

Correc t.

Q.

A nd the other technology -- what did we

A.

11
12

T forget the name of iL .

Q.

15

it was a med ia

And what time in 2001 d oe s that take us

to?

0t:24
A.

That was up unt l 2002 be fo re we moved to

our current bu iYd ing .

13
14

We movecl to our current bu ilding in August


of 2002 .

Q.

O kay .

And whah d id you work on a fter

16

these other technolog ies that you men tioned for

17

eTreppid Technology?

18

A.

infrastructu re whatsoever .

20

that up , working with contractors to w ire our

21

bullding , se tting up al1 the n etw or k stuff .

22

24

01:24

The b uild ing we mov ed into had no network

19

23

cl:24

player fo r the lntel Hom e Thea te r Gystem .

9
10

'

call that , Mr . Venable s?

'

a4

6k

r'-h'

1 wo rked on setting a11


o1:2b

W e had nothing in that bu ild ing , so I


wo rked on that .

Q.

Fo r how long?

LTZA CLlA PEN, CCRz RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 87 of 222

)G.,h
1
!

A.

It too k about a yea r to get it to whe re it

is now .

Q.

So dur Lng that year , clid you ha ve anything

to do w ith creating source codkng for any codes for

eTreppid Technology?

6
7

A.

o1:2s

On a regular basis, 1 dea lt w ihh M ichael

and wh a t h e w a s d(7ing , b u t o t h e r th a n t h a t , no .

Q.

M ic #1a e 1 '
aho ?

A.

M icla e 1 Sva t e k . wo r k ing o n the game

10

11
12
13
14

ertg ine .

:l:2s

Q.

So other than tha tr for another whole

yea r -- we lre now up to when in 2002 , would you say?


A.

We rre into 2003 by the t ime we finalize

our full networ k se tup .

15

Beg inning in 2003 , I was involved w ith

16

d oing a 11 the purchasing and designing of the

17

h ar dw a r e t h at L e 's g o t o u t th e re o n t h at r a c k - -

18

system of rac ks .

19

Q.

20

('

pb

1:2b

So , again , no involvement with regard to

creating source coding for eTreppid T echnolog ies?

21

A.

No.

22

Q.

Is there an y time up to the pre sent , since

23

your invo lvem ent in the video game s, where you 've

24

b een invo lved in creating source code for eTrepp id

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR , RMR

(775) 323-5192

91:25

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 88 of 222

7
1

a6

T e c h n ol o g y ?

A.

N o t s inc 6) th e n f no -

Q.

Do you h ave any know ledge as to what

percentage of the eT repp d business invo lved data

comp ress ion techn olog y up unti t December o f 2002?

A.

m o n e y ca m e fr om .

Q.

So you have no know ledge of even what was

paid for any of the projects eTreppid was working on?


A.

No .

11

Q.

Do you have any know ledge of how m any

13

01:26

projects eTreppid was doinq?


A.

14

To tal. number, no .
I thin k Patty Gray, Dennis and W arren were

15

probably one the on ly one s -- the only three that

16

know al1 that .

17
18

Q.

Let 's call one technology dat a

You apparently never worked on any source


coding for data com pression ?

:1:26

21

A.

That 's correct .

22

Q.

We 'l1 call the other one vide o com pression

23

24

01:26

comp ression .

19
20

c1:26

I hav e no idea where the b reakdown of

10

12

j'

-7

technology .

Is that basically the game?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

The video

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 89 of 222

h
1

A.

No .

V ideo comp resson is for p laying b aek

video, such as a IIVD or just a video file itself,

like , for exam p ie y compre ssnq a DV D m ov ie to fit

onto a CD .

Q.

01:24

So you have no knowledge a s to how much

sou rce cod ing was d one by eTreppid for video

compre ssion tec bnology; ks tha t correct?

10

8-1

game ?

A.

I 've seen the variou s p rogrammers and what

projects they 're working on and --

11

Q.

Do you --

12

A.

-- l 've dealt w ith that video compression

13

14
15

Q.

Do you know what pe rcentage of the company

business that Lnvolved?

01:27

A.

No iclea .

17

Q.

Do you know what percentage of the company

revenues that inv olved?

19

A.

1 have no idea .

20

Q.

But aga in

21

you never created any source

coding yourse lf for that?

22

A.

No.

23

Q.

Did you ever have an y access directly

24

01:27

for the Intel Media Player .

16

18

('

where you loo ked at the sou ree coding for v ideo

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:27

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 90 of 222

)
1
'
'

8i'

comp ress ion techno logy?

A.

I h,
itci w o r ke d w i.th on e o f the p rog r amme r s

on the stream ing o f ou r v ideo com pressed videor

Lalith Tennetir so T've seen some of Lhe projects he

W o r ke d o n .

6
7

01:28

And a lso with one o f the p rior employees ,


Am it .

1 forget Am it 's last name .

l 've se en some of the stu ffy he lping them

10

11

'
-5

hrouble shoot , comp iling stu ff .

Q.

:1:28

Do you know how many Lines o f sou rce

12

coding there are at eTreppid fo r the video

13

compression technoloqy?

14

A.

1 have no idea .

15

Q.

Do you know how many lines o f source

16

coding the re are at eTrepp id for the data compression

17

te c hn o io g y ?

18

A.

No .

19

Q.

When you gave a11 this direct te stimony

20

and you we re doing th is search w ith a11 of the other

21

employee s, as you put it , did you go b ack and loo k

22

for source coding for data compression or v ideo

23

comp re ssion techn ology?

24

A.

we loo ked for all deleted files .

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:28

01:28

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 91 of 222

)
1
(

Q.

A.

Q.

A.

Q.

So you could -- as you s1t here Loday ,

BY MR . FLYNN :

Q.

-- for data compression techn oloqy in the

15

computers at e'
r repp id that you haven 't even chec ked

16

yet ; is that correct ?

MR . JA KO PIN :

THE COURT :

23

24

Ob jecton ; using ''aource

1 'm not sure I understand the

objection .

21
22

01:29

code s'l is imp rop er , foundation .

19

20

:z:29

MR. JAKOPIN : Objection.

17

t '

T don 't know what fjles we 've recovered .

there cou ld be tens of thousand s o f source eod es --

14

18

01:28

deleted files ; we have n 't gone through them all.

12
13

1s the )'e an y dat a comp re ss i o n t e chn o logy

We 're st ill in the p roeess o f recov ering

10
11

Y ou c art'11 d o a s e a rc h fo r (1e 1e t ed fi le s b y

so u rc e c o d i ng 84t e T .
re pp id t.o d a y # if y(3u kn o w ?

Did you loo k for any sou rce cod ing fo r

w h a t ki.nd o f t ec h fko.Log y it i s .

5
6

89

da t a c o mp res s .
i.o n t e(7#1no 1o (
gy ?

3
4

-)

01:29
THE W ITNESS :

He keeps using the term

wrong .

THE COURT :

A 11 right .

Rephrase your

question and then we'll go from there.

LIZA CHAPENr CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 92 of 222

'
*-')
-

-7
X

. -

90

B Y M R . FL Y NN :

Q.

In the computers , as you s it here todayz

at eTreppid Techno loqy, is there source coding fo r

data compression technology ?

A.

I have no idea what we 've recove red .

Q.

You don 'b know ?

A.

It cou kcl be .

8
9

W e haven 't gone thro ugh it all .

actua lly -- working w ihh 1aw enfo rcem ent o fficials,


they don 't want u s to tamper w ith any more of the

11

evidence o f trying to recover this .

Q.

haven 't go ne through it all, there could b e tens of

14

thousands of source codes for data comp ression

15

techno logy alone on the eTrepp id computers; is that

16

correct ?
A.

MR. JAKOPIN: Objection; confusing.

19

THE W ITNESS :

on ao
THE CCURT :

22

THE W ITN FSS :

24

That doesn bt really make

sense --

21

23

01:30

T h a t d o e sn 't r e a ll y m a ke s e ns e .

18

20

01:30

So as you sit here today , since you

13

17

01:z9

We 've

10

12

1
.
k

We ll , 1 fm not sure --

-- wha t you fre saying , but

maybe you can c larify it .


THE COURT :

Ho ld on .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

Stop .

Stop .

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 93 of 222

....

91

I 'm 11O L S L1r O t ha t i h lV e t he u IRd C)C S12ilI


Rd i nV

yet to make a dete rmination as to whe the r or not it 's

confusing.

that 1 would sustain , anyway .

l'm not sure that that's an objection

So i'
.'m qoinq to allow th is testimony for

w hatever it 's wo rth so it he lp s m e get educated about

what the ssues irz th is case a re .

8
9

betw een sou rce code , singular, source code, p lural,

10

and w hethe r we tre talking abou t line s o f source code

11

and lines o f d ata codes

12

codes , but I want to learn a little bit more about

13

this, and so allow ing m e to listen to th is helps me

14

to do that .

So i f you 'd indulge me a litt le b it,


p lea se , 1 'd like to hear a little m ore about this .

17

B Y M R . FL Y NN :

Q.

are , I think as you put it , hund reds of source codes

20

for th e video g ame techno logy that you wo rked on that

21

are still at eTrepp id ; is that correct?


A.

01:31

M r . Venab les , we bve establ ished that there

19

22

on al

as opposed to separate

16

18

e1:3o

1 Im beginn ing to see tha t the re 's an issue

15

'
;

w$

We 've recovered hundred s of files that

23

were de leted .

What the conten ts of those files or

24

what -- if the re j
I:5 actually any cod es , we know that

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

n1:31

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 94 of 222


&$
l

some file s have zero contents because they were wiped

c le a n .

S o th e re 's a fi le n am e bu t ze ro c od e is

within th at fi ke .

Q.

We lre just talking about the video qame

A.

The video gam e?

Q.

Yeah, just the video game .

A.

W e haven 't --

10

Q.

Are there hundreds of source codes just on

11

the video gam e, as you testified befo re , that are

12

st ill on the eT repp id --

14

A.

That ss like saying there 's hundreds o f

What you 're saying doesn 't m ake any sense

01:32

in any wa y .

17

THE COURT : Well, hold on just a second .

18

THE W ITNESS :

19

THE COURT :

20

THE W ITNESS :

21

THE CO URT :

22

T HE W ITNESS :

23

THE COURT :

:4

01:31

tom atoes in the v ideo game .

15
16

01:31

now .

13

92

We have a11 --

Stop .
-- the video --

01:32

Stop .

-- game file s .

When 1 say ho ld on , I m ean

stop .
-

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

'

(775) 323-5492

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 95 of 222


93

You gs
pt a
iuli?

..-.--.-.--

T H E W 1't'N K SS :

O ka y .

T H El C!OIJ3)T :

- --- ..-

A 1 1 ri(g)t .

. ...--

b0th of you to do is to try to allow the other one to

finish .

Th is is not like norm al conversat ion .

to get dow n w hat ls being sad , and I know tha t ih 's

not an easy th tng to do if you lre not used to it .

So , p lease , if he 's asking a question , let

10

h im finish it .

11

finish it .

12

If he 's ma king an answer , let him

just want to try to deal with this issue right now .


So gc) ahead , please .

15

MR . FLYNN :

17

Thank you , you r Honor .

Q.

M r . Venables , let 's try it this way .


You say you have found de leted files o f

source code ; is that correct ?

20

A.

Co rrect .

21

Q.

Have you found de lete d files o f source

22
23

o1;a2

code on you r v ideo gam e technology ?


A.

1 said in the begin ning , those files were

'

24

01:32

BY MR . FLYNN :

18

19

01:32

A nd : 'm so rry for the interruption r but 1

14

16

Q::32

W e 've Jot a court reporte r he re that 's goL

13

----- -.
-

W h at. I w o u 1d 1 i-k e

j.

neve r deleted .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 96 of 222


,.-

1
(

Q.

Have you found deleted fi les o f source


code on data comp re ssion technology ?

A.

I have found de leted folders fo r a program

called ET Adaptive , wh ich 1 be l.ieve is the data

comp ression prog ram .

Q.

What make s you be lieve that?

A.

Because I asked the p rogr ammer, V en ka , who

9
10

com pression .
Q.

A nd when you say you found dele ted filesz

you found files -- you saw som ething that showed you

13

that th e file s were once there and now they pre not

14

the re?

O r did you recover them ?


A.

16

Some zocations, we d idn 't recover them .

r e co v e r ed fi l e n am e s b u t ze ro c on t e n t s in th e fi Ye s .

18

On the server , I 've recov ered the folders

20

01:33

L ike the p rogramm ers l ma ch ines , they

17

/9

01:33

12

15

01:33

was wo rking on it what it 's used for and he sa id data

11

j
'

:4

Tha rlk yo u .

2
3

and aome of the files but not all of the files.


Q.

O kay .

On video com pre ssion technology

21

software, have you found any files at eT repp id -- on

22

eTrepp id com pute rs that were never deleted ?

23

A.

No.

24

nave you looked?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:34

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 97 of 222


--';
'w
95
'
. .- -

1
f

A.

m ach ine in the bu tlding .

Q.

For v ideo compression?

A.

Ry lideo comp ression, 1 assume that you 're

talking about the video Codec that we use .

The re 's various names for it .

o f them , b ut w e haven 't found any o f those on

anybody 's work stations o r the serve r .

t don 't rem ember a1l

Q.

Have you made any e ffort to rec over those

12

A.

Ye s, I have .

13

Q.

What did you do?

14

A.

From the SRCSERV KR , we 're running the

p rog ram m ade b y Execut iv e Software c alled Emergency

16

Und elete .

17

Q.

And have you recovered any o f them ?

18

A.

l 've got some folders w ith th e nam es of

It 's made for recovering deleted file s .

We h aven 't gone th rouqh a11 o f them yet .

21

It 's st ill run ning .

22

piece th ese p ieces together .

24

H :3s

th e v ideo Codec s .

20

23

01:34

files?

15

19

ETVC is one

o f them .

10

ERV P is anothe r one .

:1:34

11

We loo ked on every

'

W e ''ze looked a11 over .

Q.

It ta kes wee ks and wee ks to

That 's how I understand it .

How many files have you recovered to date

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:35

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 98 of 222


'

.. .

and how long -- how m any fi le s have you recovered to

date on the video compression technology?

3
4

96

1 just have a total

num ber o f gigab ytes that l 've recovered .

What is that?

A.

About 40 to 50 giqabytes have b een

t have no idea.

Q.

'

A.

'

.
w..

01:35

r e co v e re d .

Q.

How long has that recove ry p rogram been

running?

10

A.

Sin ce January 12th .

01:as

11

Q.

A nd how long w ill it -- it will take weeks

12

longer to cont inue ho run it to recov er files; is

13

th a t co r r e ct ?

14

A.

By Lhe current rate , p robably .

15

Q.

Okay . A nd is that technology, the

16

recovery technoiogy going to enab le you to recover

17

al1 o f the sou rce codes on the video comp ression

18

te chnology ?

19

A.

I have no idea .

20

Q.

You don 't know ?

21

A.

No .

22

Q.

How m any source cod es, what you describe

ozta6

23

as sou rce codes have you recovered to date on the

24

video compression technology?

LIZA CfG PEN, CCR, RMR

01:a6

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 99 of 222


.1.
,.J
'%q,
..r
()/
.---- ----------

A.

I just have the recovered folders and


Cilesr and nobod y has access to t r igh t now .

n o t ev e n p lu g g e d in t o o u r ne tw o r k .

Q.

Why no t?

A.

W e d on 't w an t to c o r rup t a n y th i ng .

It 's

01:36
We

want to p reserve the state that it was in at the

poin t o f d elet ion .

Q.

10

Just yes or no .
Did you ev er have a conv ersation w ith

11

Mr . Trepp instruc ting you to go into Mr . Montgomery fs

12

work station and try to recover classified

13

info rmation o r classified source cod es?

14

A.

He a sked m e to recover w hat files I could

find , in p art icular the e-m ail files which I d id

16

recove r .

17

Q.

What d id you do to try to recov er?

18

A.

I ran the sam e program I already talked

20
21

:1:36

15

19

I have no idea .

--

01:37

about , Fme rgency Undelete .

Q.

And just yes or no.

0z:37

Did yo u ev er have a conve rsation with

22

M r . M ontgom ery about a certain gove rnm ental agency

23

requiring intrusion d evices on a11 o f the equipment

24

Mr. Montgomery was working on?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 100 of 222


..,.
,

A.

N ev e r .

Q.

Do you know what an intrusion device is?

A.

Yes .

Q.

What is an intrusion device?

A.

lt de tects i f someb ody is try ing to get

into the th ing , and i. t w ill usua Lly 1og it ; try to

bloc k it and log it .

Q.

know ledge o f whatever governmental interact ion


M r . M ontgome ry had to estab lish tntrusion dev ices

11

that would sel f-destru ct any in formation on

12

M r . Montgomery fs equipment?

14

A.

(.

01:38

I have no know ledge o f any of h ks

inte ractions .

15

I know what 's on a1l the machine s in the

16

building .

17

Q.

18

01:37

Does -- so as I unde rst and it f you have no

10

13

j)(y

l 've got orte on ou r C ksco route r .

-..-.,

on aa

Do you know whether or not there is an

intrusion dev ce on M r . Montgome ry 's wo rkp lace --

19

A.

No, there 's no such --

20

Q.

-- computers, that if anyon e tries to

21

access without c erta in codes , self-de structs al1 the

22

material in the computers?

23

A.

There 's no such thing .

24

Q.

To you r knowledge ?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

n1:38

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 101 of 222


.-x-99
1

A.

'
l'o m y' krlo w 1e d q e a nd o11h e r s in t h e b u i ld in g

that l 'v e con sulted :

Tenneti .

4
5

Q.

Did eT repp id do aud io compression


technolog y?
A.

Yes .

Q.

Do you have any know ledge o f w hat

10

percentage o f the busine ss w as aud io com pression

11

techno logy ?

12

A.

1 have no idea .

13

Q.

And 1 La ke it you don lt know what kind of

A.

No .

16

Q.

Did you ev er do work on aud io compression

01:39

te ch n o lo g y ?

18

A.

No.

19

Q.

In the last several weeks, have you made

20

an effort to exam ine the com puters of eTrepp id to

21

determ ine whether any aud io com pression techn ology

22

software file s are presen t or not present ?

23
24

nliag

revenue the audio comp ression technology generated?

15

17

01:38

14

'

Let 's La lk about audio com pression

technology .

6
7

Jessie Ande rson , Lalith

A.

We 've loo ked fo r what we call ETA C ,

eTrepp id Aud io Codec or com pression

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

and none of our

(775) 323-5492

ol:3a

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 102 of 222


.... .
..- .
10()
yI

prog ramm ers ' work stations, none o f the machines out

in the wa rehouse have it .

1 be lieve I've recovered a folder o r two

from SRCSERVER , but 1 don t know w hat the contents

a re .

6
7

Q.

A.

It doesn 't loo k for any particu lar kind of

Q.

been recovered r if you knowr in audio comp ression

14

technology software?

15

17
18

So h as any -- have any source code files

13

16

01:4a

file; it just looks for any deleted files.

12

W e 're zecovering any and a11 files that we

can find on SRCSERV RR that have been deleted .

10

11

A re you running any recovery technology

for any aud io com pression software ?

8
9

01:39

A.

The re ls a couple of folders that are fo r

Q.

O kay .

01:40

ETAC .
And that 's currently o n the

compan y 's p rem ises?

19

A.

Yes .

20

Q.

Now, Irm just going to use three different

21

descriptive terms and 1111 just ask you some

22

yes-o r-no qu estions .

O kay?

23

A.

O kay .

24

ob ject track.
i.nq .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

ol:4n

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 103 of 222


-.. .)
'%.. .
10 1.

.-

.-

DO you know, ye s or no , whether eT reppid

Techno logie s has ang government contracts with regard

to object tracking?

A.

Yes .

Q.

Have you ever done any computer

A.

No .

Q.

Have you ever had access to any of the

source codes for object tracking'


?

10

A.

No .

11

Q.

Wh o at eTreppid has had access to the

12
13

01:41

programmng on object tracking?

01:41

source codes for object tracking?


A.

A person l mentioned beforey Krishna.

14

- -

Zehang Sun is working on it w ith a team o f

15

peop le downsta krs, in our down stars a rea which 1

16

haven 't m ent ion ed yet .

17

d ow n t h e r e .

18

majority of them are working on that stuff.

01:41

We have anothe r ten peop le

A l1 o f th em - - no t a Y l o f t h em , b u t a

19

Q.

Under Mr . Montgom ery 's superv ision?

20

A.

Yes .

21

Q.

A nd is it true to say that each o f these

n1:4l

22

indiv iduals has on ly h ad bit s and p ie ces , and only

23

M r . M ontgom ery has the full p icture of what 's being

24

worked on?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 104 of 222


1
'-. ,
..1O2

A.

I hav e no idea how he de legated .

Q.

That's a11 classified; is Lhat correct?

A.

How he delegates isn dt c la ssified ; only

the cla ssified m a te rial .

Q.

The wo rk heing done i:; a11 c lassified?

A.

They can work on a1 L kind s o f p rogram , but

the classified materia l which we rece ive ftom the

qove rnm ent agency is c lassified .

So they can program on wh atever the y want ,

10

but they can 't h andle -- they can 't see classified

11

mater ial because none o f them have clearances .

12

Q.

On ly M r. Montgomery?

13

A.

Correct .

14
15

clearances in the bu ilding .

So to you r knowledge , were they doing line

18

A.

Yes, they were .

19

Q.

Bit s and piece s?

20

A.

They were w orking on whatever ; I have no

22
23

01:42

Q.

21

24

01:42

W el l, w e have -- six peop le have

16
17

01:42

co d i n g ?

idea what they we re doing exactly .

Q.

On ave rage , how m any codes can a

programmer d o a day?

How many line codes could a programmer do

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

0z:42

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 105 of 222

-.-2

2
3

A. 1 have no idea what the -- a 1ot of it is


edihing pre-ex st ing lines r not generating new lines .

So ( wauld say the ma jority of the days


are spent on twea king and m odifying existing lines.

Q.

10
11

To you r knowledge, did eT repp id Technology


have any cla ss ified governm ent contracts w ith regard
to p attern re cogn it ion technology?
A.

01:4a

We only have one classified con tract , to

my know led ge , and that 's -- that 's in our file on

13

record .

15

Q.

so you don 't even - - do you know what

patte rn recogn ttion technology is ?

Yes or no?

16

A.

Ye s .

17

Q.

A nd to your know ledge , you don 't even --

18

you hav e no awareness, as you sit he re today, of what

19

eTrepp id was doing on pattern recognition ?

20

A.

I have bits and pieces of what I lve seen

21

going on in th e building, b ut I don 't have the full

22

p icture .

23

1 fm qo ing to use another descriptive term ,

12

14

24

91:43

and 1'11 just ask for yes or no.

8
9

1()a

per day?

4
5

..-

Q.

Do you have any idea how many source codes

have ever exiyted on pattern recognition technology?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

on xa

01:44

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 106 of 222


.... j
..101
/
m -

No , I lave no idea .

Q.

Do you have any idea w here any o f those

s o u r ce c od e s co u ld e ve r b e fo u nd a n yw he r e ?

A.

We1 G

f we go by what Dennis told me, a11

the source code is on SRCSERVER .

contents o f the SRCSERVER were by file , number o f

files, and total file size .

8
9
10

Q.

12

13

1 know what the

So this is just based on what

A.

R ight .

01:44

If he sa id it 's not there , if he 's saying


it 's not the re , then I would have no idea .

Q.

Have you ever seen any of the contracts

14

M r . Trepp and Mr . Mo ntgomery s igned w ith a ce rta in

15

governmental aqency with regard to either object

16

trac king or p atte rn recognition techno logy?

17

18

19
20

01:44

M r . M ontgome ry to Ld you?

11

..

A.

(
1

.- -

- -

A.

01:44

If you 're talking about sp ec ial access

program stuff, no , I don 't hav e an y knowledge of it .

Q.

So you h av e no know ledge of the term s of

any of those contracts?

01:4s

21

A.

No.

22

Q.

And with regard to M r . M ontgomery 's

23

sup erv ision techn iques of the peop le working under

24

himy the programmers , you have no kn owledge o f what

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 107 of 222


1
..,.,
xxr.
1()5
y

('

he was allowed to share and what he wa s not al lowed

to share in o rder to get the work done ; is that

correct?

A.

I have no idea .

Q.

1'm going to use another term, and just

answer y es o r no z please .

7
8
9
10

11
12

Hav e you

ever heard th at term at eTrilppid Tech nolog ies?


A.

Y es .

T 've seen the work in progress being

done by the p eople downstairs .

Q.

01:4s

Have you eve r seen the source codes for

facial rec ogn ition techno loqy?

A.

No , I h aven 't .

14

Q.

Who wa s the individual at eT repp id that

16
17

was do ing th e wor k on facial recognit ion technology?

A.

Zehang Sun 's team .

p e op le w o r ki n g u n d e rn e at h h im .

Q.

Under the supervision of Mr. Montgomery?

19

A.

R ight .

20

Q.

A nd have yo u, in any recovery p rogram

21

you 've been implem enting , m ade an effort to recover

22

any sou rce codes for facial recognit ion technology ?

24

:1:46

He has a team o f

18

23

'

Fac La l recogn ition tech no lg y .

13

15

onds

A.

A s 1 said , we 're not looking for any -- we

cantt look by any particular technology, just by

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

01:46

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 108 of 222


.ww.)

Q.

M r . Montgomery 's compute rs , som e of which are, in

fact z a certa in governmental ag ency 's comp uters ; is

that co rrect?
M R . PEEK :

91:46
Counsel , 1 can 't see the

Witness .

THE W ITNESS ;

None o f those m achines out

the re hav e been certified for (rlassified mate rial , if

10

tha t s what you 're asking .

11

BY M R . FL YNN :

12
13

Q.

01:46

A s you sit here today , are you aware that

a certa in qov ernme ntal agency b rought kn computers?

14

A.

Yes .

15

Q.

Have you attempted to access those

16

01:47

computers?

17

A.

Th e y to o k th o se com p u t er s b a c k a w ay .

18

Q.

When did they do that?

19

A.

L ast year sometim e , 1 believe .

20

So you just went on a11 of

('

106

file , d eleted fili


a.

'..-:

La s t

spring .

:::47

21

Q.

A nd they took the source codes w ith them ?

22

A.

I don 't believe so .

23

hardware .

24

Q.

They just took

W ere the source code s on the hardware?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 109 of 222


.s,
.w

A.

M r . Morttgom ery had me make a p rogram that

would delete a1L the hard drives in al1 the computers

w e g av e b a c k t o th em .

Q.

So it 's your testim ony today that all

those source codes at eT repp id were taken b y the

go v e rn m e n t ?

A.

one was called .

w iping a11 those hard drives .

10

Q.

12

13

No .

It 's a DO D ce rtified program for

THE COURT :

Is this a good time to take a

llttle break?
M R . FLY N N :

S u re .

15

THE: COURT :

W e fve b een going not quit e tw o

17

M R . FL YN N :

J us t on e qu e s t i on z y o u r H on o r ?

18

THE COURT :

Sure .

19

20

Go ahead .

BY MR . FLYNN :

Q.

So to you r kn owledge, what is left at

eTreppid w ith regard to the source codes fo r that

22

technology that was w ip ed out?

24

01:48

hours .

21

23

01:47

So what was le ft?

14

16

01:47

We ran A ctive Kill, I be lieve Lhat

Those were a11 given bac k clean slate .

11

1.()y

2
4

A.

I hav e no idea what source code was used

for that project.

LIZA CHAPENZ CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

n1:4a

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 110 of 222


ee .)
...
10()

/'

M R . FLY N N :

T h a n k y ou , y o u r H o no r .

T HE COURT :

A 11 right .

until -- le t 's m ake it five a fter 11 :00 .

(Re cess taken .)

T H E CO U BT :

P le a se b e s ea t ed .

M R . FLYNN :

Thank you, your Honor .

T HE COUPT :

Oh , by th way , before you

1 '11 file that in w ith the c lerk .

10
11

And then when you conform Lhe eop ies , give

M R . FLYNN :

THE COURT :

15

Go ahead .

17

18
19

It 's n ice

Doesn lt hurt .
02:07

BY M R . FLYNN :
Q.

Mr . V enab les

how m any hard d rives are

there at eTrep pid T echnology?


A.

I don 't know .

1 -- since I purcha sed them

20

all , I shou ld know an accurate numbe r, b ut we lve

21

bought m an y, m any hund red s .

22
23

T hank, your Honor .

to b e lega l for a change .

14

16

24

02:06

them the copies , tloo , please .

12
13

92:06

sharty I d o have an order permit tinq you to pract ice .

Le t 's be in recess

I w ould say , total , we p robab ly have about


a thousand , bu t no more than 2000 .

fa .

H a z.d drlve s ?

LIZA CHAPEINr CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

:2::7

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 111 of 222


s...
...
1o9

('

A.

Y e ah .

Q.

How many files are on those hard drives?

A.

W e fv e go t - -

Q.

You r best estimate?

A.

We bve got p lenty that only have a couple

o f file s in them in our file cab inets in the

warehou se .

8
9

Q.
O r can you ?
A.

1 can 't estimate .

11

Q.

How m any computers do you have at eTreppid

13

Technology ?
A.

On m y netw ork , 1 have less than a hundred z

b ut we pve go t pzenty of other ones that are not in

15

use or --

16

02:07

14

17

02:07

Col le ctive ly / how many wou ld you e stimate?

10

12
t

C o r re ct .

02:08

Sayy total , 200 or less computers .

Q.

If 1 suqgested to you there were over

18

150 m illion files on eTreppid Technology com puters,

19

wou ld you d isagree?

20

A.

No .

21

Q.

But you don 't know ?

22

A.

I wou ld say --

23

Q.

Y ou can 't give u s you r b est estim ate?

24

A.

Since T 've seen a 1ot o f the files we 've

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

n2:0a

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 112 of 222


hag-'

(
'

1J.(j

been going ove r the l.ast couple of weeks on most o f

these hard drives in the warehouse and what have you,

a lo t of them have ind ivi.dua l fram es of video , so a

s ing le frame for every second, or less than 30 frames

a se cond they we re recorded at, so you r number of a

million or more would be accurate becau se it conta ins

a 1o t of these v jdeo frames .

Q.

Well r L50 m illion?

A.

Right .

10

Q.

How m any of the 150 m illion have you

11

c h e c ke d t o d a t e ?

12

A.

02::8

In the past two wee ks, sin ce the 10th ,

I've looked at just about every hard drive in the

14

building .

15

Q.

17

How m any files have you chec ked to date,

A.

1 h a v e n 't op en e d ev e ry s i n g le fi le .

I #d

say I 'd op en a folder and it has like a thousand

19

frames of somethingr Ifl1 just look at the first one

20

and then go to som ething else .

Q.

02:09

So o f the 150 million filesw can you tell

22

the Court today how m any are still on the eT repp id

23

comp uters that have never been de leted ?

24

02:09

o f the 150 m ill ion?

18

21

oz:oa

That 's --

13

16

w'

I 'd say about 80 percent a re not source

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 113 of 222

y.,.x
)
1

code and those aren 't de leted .

Q.

Now, perhap s it was an ove rsiqht of m ine,

but as T u nderstand it , there is a fa irly significant

little structure zgh t there on eT repp id prem ises : is

there not?

A.

10
11

o2:n9
In Lhe downstairs -- center of the

downsta irs a rea, our little private room ?

Q.

Yes .
Could you -- would gou indulge me and put

it whe re you thin k it should go , the pr ivate room ?


A.

the bu ilding here ; it 's abou t located c enter

13

downstairs .

14

Q.

Have you ever been in the p rivate room ?

15

A.

Yes .

16

Q.

How m any t im es?

17

A.

In t h e p a st t w o w ee k s , I 'v e s pe n t a lo t o f

19
20

02:10

time th ere .
Q.

Before the p ast two w ee ks , h ow m any time s

w ere yo u in the p rivate room ?

02:10

21

A.

V ery little .

22

Q.

W ho had access to the p rivate room at

23

eTreppid?

24

02:10

Tt 's underneath -- say this is the rest of

12

18

11l

'
x- ;

Warren and Dennis and Patty and some

LIZA CHAPIEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 114 of 222


..,
.x
1

Q. Just ii you can give me a number, how many

of those outside government peop Le that had access Lo

the priv at e room have you ever dea lh with?

A.

1 d ealt with two o f them a 1ot recently ,

O th er than that, wM had some with the

specia l access program .

requ la rly .

10

1 dea lh with a1l of them

I hacl to know who they were com ing and

11

going out of the buildng . They can 't just get to

12

that room without com ing through our -- one of our

13

outside doors.

14
15

Q.

These government people you 've dealt w ith

A.

No .

18

Q.

Who at eTreppid do you know contacted

A.

Jay Dixon actually is the guy w ith DSL .

21
22
23

24

02:11

Did you ?

17

20

02:11

in the last two wee ks , who contacted them ?

16

19

:2:10

and I 've dealt with them in the past .

11.2

o u t s id e g c)ve r n me n t. p (aop 1.e .

..
v

them ?

b rought him in there .


But out side that , there are governm ent
people that Wa rren contacted .

Q. Who --

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

n2:11

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 115 of 222


),..'
.)
w .
113

S t r i ke tha t .

You (3e)'sona11y contacted Jay Dixon?

A.

basis since he 's our rep resentat ive with our facility

clearance .

Q.

W hat is in the p rivate room?

A.

A couple of tables , a coup le of computers,

and a coup le o f secure conta iners; safes .

9
10

Q.

A.

12
13

The -- one of them wa sn 't even plugged in .

was on it .

Q.

What was on it?

Just in term s of a

genera l d escription ?

16

A.

02:12

Basically just operating system and

17

M ic ro so ft O f f ic e a nd a cc e ss t o t he In te r ne t ; n o th in g

18

else .

19
20

21

02:12

The other one was running and I saw what

14
15

A nd have you made an effort in the last

several wee ks to access those comp uters ?

11

Q.

O kay .

Did you ma ke any effort to access

any o f th e files on e ither o f these two computers?

A.

22

n2:l1

W ezl, it wa s -- we 're on a regular contact

No .

I just saw what was on them .

I conne cted one o f them to th e Internet .

23

Q.

Did you b ring Mr . Dixon into that room ?

24

A. He requested to go there to see where our

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:12

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 116 of 222


......

containers were .

Q.

....y

114

Now, I believe you had previously

testified that these computtqrs dow n here be long to

eTrepp id ?

A.

I 'm awa re hh at some o f them w ere paid fo r

by variou s government agencies; I don 't know which

one s belong to us / wh i.ch ohe s don 't .

Q.

that these belong to eT reppid?


A.

1 don lt b elieve 1 said that .

11

Q.

Okay .

02:13

How many com puters are there in

12

th is ban k here next to Mr . M ontgom ery 's w ork station ?

13

A . Currently, there 's like 30 or less.

14

Q.

16

A nd do you have any knowledge of who owns

tho se 30 or less compute rs?


A.

17

18

02:13

There 's two banks, actually .


M R . PE E K :

Co u n se l , I c a n t se e th e

w itness .

19

THE W ITNESS :

20

The one ban k I 'm describing there is the

There 's tw o banks .

21

o ne that Dennis wor ked on regu larly .

22

bank that's just along the same wall that had a11 our

23

security cam eras hooked -- connected to it .

24

02:13

Just -- d id you testify befo re the break

10

15

'

They 're the same kind of

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

- -

The re 's another

s am e ex a ct

(775) 323-5492

n2:l3

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 117 of 222

yev
e')
j
'

c om p u t er , sam e e x ac t c ab in e ts .

BY M R . F L YN N :

3
4

Q.

The question agajn ts, who ow ns hh ose

A.

1 have no idea .

I know 1 pu rchased al L of them and

eT repp id pa id for a11 of them .

Were paid for through outside contraets .

know .

11
12

Q.

I don 't

Do you know whether there are any source

A.

02:14

The surveillance compute rs don 't have

13

anything , and -- don 't have anything excep t for v ideo

14

record ing softwaze , which is outside third-party .


This bank of com puters has noth ing on them

16

anymore .

17

a nd t h e re 's n o th in g on a ny o f th em .

02:14

Warren and I went and looked o n each one

18

Q.

Who --

19

A.

Just operat ing system .

20

Q.

Who else was in the room when you tried to

21

I don 't know if they

code s in tho se corap uters?

15

(.

:2:13

10

j.1jj

compuhers?

-g-

look on th ose computers?

22

A.

Just Wa rren and me .

23

Q.

Ancl you found nothing?

24

A.

Tha t ,:5 co r re c t .

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:14

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 118 of 222


.. .

.w

)' )
1

Q.

A.

We just logqed on and looked ho see what

was on the drives and there was nothing; just

operating system .

Q.

10

A.

A nd every sinqle fi le on a 1l 30 computers

We do a regular partition o f drive space r

so the sp ace where data s kept , the ''E'' partit kon

had nothing on it ; ze ro files .

11

12

02:14

had nothing?

8
9

Q.

02:1s

Now , this 80 percent of the files , the

150 million files hhat are sti Ll at er


rreppid.

13

A.

U h -huh .

14

Q.

How many of those have source codes?

15

A.

None o f them .

Q.

I be Lieve you te stified that the g am e

16

17

&1(;

What d id you do to t ry to access any of

They /re al1 samp le test

engines fo r your v ideo prog ram , there were about a

19

hund red source code files still at eTrepp id , co r r ec t ?


A.

21
22

23

24

02:15

files .

18

20

the source codes jn those computers?

On M ichael 's m achine .

oz:zs

The se aren 't any o f th e other drives I 've


loo ked throughout the building .

Q.

Now , I understand that , but ove rall in th e

computers, there's about a hundred source codes just

LIZA CIIAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 119 of 222


1.-.
.
-;
117
1

fo r the video gam es that are sti kl the re?

2
3

A . Tw o har'cl drives : M '


g lnachi.ne and Michae1 's
m a c h in e .

Q.

And --

A.

I be l.ieve there m igh h b e a coup le in the

SRCSERVER shill .

Q.

A copy on the SRCSERVER ?

A.

C o r re c t .

Q.

Le t m e show you you r Decla ration

under the penalties of perjury . It was filed in this

11

case .
MR . FLYNN :

Honor, there 's no date on it , it 's b lan k, but there ls

14

a signature, but it fs among th e documents that we re

15

filed to support the TRO .

17

02:z6

THE COURT :

A 11 right .

MR . FLYNN :

You 've got it , your Honor?

Go ahead .

I 've

got it .

18
19

o2:z6

On the copy I have, your

13

16

s igned

10

12

n2:1s

BY MR . FLYNN :

20

Q.

Did you prep are this Declaration?

21

A.

Ye s .

22

Q.

Did you , you rself, persona lly type it up ?

23

A.

No .

24

Q. Did you prepare it in conjunction with

LIZA CfG PEIN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:16

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 120 of 222

)
.....x;
.

A . Yes.

Q.

w
ux..
tl
-

11i
)

..

Now , you say in paraqraph 11, page three ,

bottom of the p age .

''Fr tlm t h i.s ch ec k '' - -

Th i s wa s a f te r yo u re t:u rned f rom va cat ion .

02:17

Yo u ca n re a d a 1o ng w it h me .

'

A.

O ka y .

Q.

''F'rtlm th i s che c k , I det e rmine d tha t a l 1 o f


-

10

the eT repp i d s()u r c e code st o r ed o n e ach o f th e s e

11

se rver s h a d b e ()n d e le ted .''

12

A.

Rigt1t .

13

Q.

Is that truth ful?

14

A.

It ds a little bit of an overstatem ent

15

since the gam e engine , khere 's a copy o f the game

16

engine probab ly still there .

17

18
19
20

Q.

22

02:17

n2:17

And how much -- how many o f the files have

you no t even chec ked yet ?


A.

Th e rest of the folders were completely

deleted .

02:17

21

c ou n s e l fo r eT re pp d ?

If I cou ld exp lain the w ay the structure


of the ha rd driv e is .

23

Q.

Su re .

24

A. We have four main folders on that

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 121 of 222


'

f'

SRCSERVER .

the source code, except for the game engine, was

stored .

1'9

The one called KT Latest was where all o f

The game engine, Michae l and 1 kept as a

separate bac kup .

he and 1, it was only he and I hhat kep t backups of

it r and Denn is wa s aqreable w tth this .

8
9
10

12

13

We ddn ft -- slkn ce it only involved

unde r this ET Latest fo lder and ET Developm ent


folde r .

o2:la
Those fclders were de Leted , comp letely

dele hed out ; noth ing ex isted underneath tho se .

Q. But since you were never given prior

14

access, as for the source codes for object tracking,

15

patte rn recogn ition, and face recognit ion , you

16

wouldn 't even know what source codes to look for,

17

w o u ld y o u ?

18

A.

I don 't know if they we re ev er there .

19

wouldn 't know .

20

were called .

21

02:18

I don 't know what the actual p rog ram s

o2:1a

There 's a couple hundred dif feren t

22

projects underneath that, that were underneath that

23

ET Latest fo lder .

24

oz:ta

A 11 the rest of the source code w as kept

11

Q. So, again, you don't know whether they

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 122 of 222


I

1
f

were ever there , correct?


Co rrect .

Q.

You clon 't know whether the government took

them , correct ?

A.

Co rrect .

Q.

And if they were ever hhere, you have no

02:19

knowledge of how they everz ah some point, were not

there ?

10

11

A.

Well: Jf they were never the re z 1 have no

idea i f they disappeared , co rrect .

Q.

12

If the assumption is at some point they


were there , w ithout. using the word d eleted, yo u have

14

no know ledge o f how , at some po int , they were there

15

and then no t there?

17

18

A.

02:19

I could only tell you what was there based

o n w ha t l .m re c ov e r in g .

Q.

And you were never given access --

19

Strike that .

20

You never h ad a conv ersation w ith

21

M r. Mon tgom ery about the methodology of the intru sion

22

d etection device s that the government w anted to p ut

23

on these computers and these comp uters, did you?

24

o2:t9

R ight .

13

16

4.
*
'

120

A.

No.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:19

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 123 of 222


'
w.4
1

MR . FLYNN :

A nd for Lhe record , when 1

said these computers, I was referring to the 30 or so

c om p u t e rs ne x t to M r . M o n tg om e ry 's w o r k st a t i on a nd

t he tw o comp uters in the so-called private area .

T HE CO UHT :

Tn Exhib it 1?

M R . FLYNN :

On Exhibit 1.

Than k you , your Honor .

Q.

Who we re the p rogramm ers downstairs that

10

you re ferred to ?

11

A.

You wa nt the list by nam e?

12

Q.

Yes .

13

A.

Krishna Tangirala that 1 mentioned before.

oa:2o

''C h :J'' --

l5

Q.

A r e h is f i 1e s m i s si ng ?

16

A.

Yes .

17

h a r d d r i ve w h en I c am e b a c k f rom m y t r ip .

Q.

And the next one?

19

A.

Chucai Huang .

20

Q.

A re h is files m issing ?

21

A.

He s wo rking on som eth ing that I don 't

even kn ow what it is , so I cou ldn 't tell you .

23

Some other peop le checked his machine ; I

'
.

24

()2:20

His hard drive had a comp letely new

18

22

02:2:

BY MR . FLYNN :

14

12l

s
>n..y
')
.

didn't.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:20

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 124 of 222

( N)

(
' )

l22

t'

Q.

individual's ftles are missing or not?

A.

No, I can 't say for s ure .

Q.

W ho is the next p rog ramme r?

A.

Such ita Samant .

Q.

A re his files missinq ?

A.

Tha t fs a lady .

8
9

me , as we ll .

10

Q.

So you don 't know?

11

A.

I don lt know .

13
14
15

16
17

02:21

She has reported to somebody else besides

12

But yo u don 't know whe ther th is

02:21

Then - -

Q.

When you say ''al1'' in youz Declaration,

were you referring to the ir file s, too?


A.

I was talking about the two servers I had

02:21

under m y contro L.
Q.

And f o f cou rse f you neve r had under your

18

con trol th e 30 or so computers next to

19

Mr . Montg om ery 's wo rk station on Exh ib it 1 and the

20

private a rea ; is that correct?

02:21

21

A.

Correct .

22

Q.

And who is the next ind ividual?

23

A.

Zehang Sun .

24

Q.

We re his files m issing ?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 125 of 222

()
(

A.

He had his hard d rive taken away from him .

Q.

By who?

A.

He sa id by Dennis .

Q.

So right now , th ts individual has no hard

d r iv e ?

02:22

A.

He had h is wo rk-in-progress hard drive

removed - - the removable drive taken out .

operating system drive is in the re .

Q.

Were there any files on that?

10

A.

No .

11

Q.

Who is the nex t individua l?

12

A.

N o t th a t 1 kn ow o f .

13
14

His

02:22

No h th a t I kno w o f .

The next one in the room is -- I on ly


rem ember h is first name , Yong Mian .

15

Q.

Were any of his files missing ?

16

A.

I don 't kn ow .

17

I only ta lked to mayb e three of th em .

19

them were spo ken to m y Jessie and Patty .

T he rest of

20

Q.

How m any p eople are there downstairs?

21

A.

There a re three more, in add it ion to the

23
24

02:22

I d id n 't - - h a l f o f t he p e op l e d ow n st a ir s ,

18

22

123

/1

ones I 've mentioned .

Q.

so since you rve never spo ke to them , you

don 't know whether any o f their files are m issing,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:22

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 126 of 222

()
.1

Vh

A.

I o n 1y

know what I was told by the others

who checked their computers .

A.

Right .

Q.

You ment ioned som ething about a 1aw

10

13

02:22

enfo rcem ent person com inq to eTreppid ?


A.

N o, I said !aw en forcement told m e not to

run the machine s anymore , some o f the machines that 1


was runn ing recove ry on .

11

12

124

e ither?

You don 't persona llg know?

a' )

Q.

:'
1.
.

j
'

- -

p2;2a

Th ey never cam e to the bu ild ing .

Q.

So you had a telephone conversation w ith

this p erson ?

14

A.

15

bu ild ing .

16

Q.

T went to go meet h im outs ide the

92:23

Who is this 1aw en forcemen t person ?

17

T H E W IT N E SS :

18

MR . PEEK :

Am I supp o s ed t o s a y ?

Your Honor, the law enforcem ent

19

individ ual s h ave asked us not to identify that there

20

is ongoing investigat ion , so he 's a little reluctant

21

to say that .

22

THE COURT :

23

MR . PEEK :

24

Well , you know --

So 1 know th is is sealed , so --

bu t the y a re co n c:e rne d .

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:23

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 127 of 222


'

I1
1

f
'

Wel l, 1 think th at -- I mean ,

one o f the things that 1 was going to add ress here

be fore we too k ou r noon recess is th is w hole issue o f

classified in formahion, what leve l of classification

we 're talking abo ut, and fran kky, M r. Flynn , 1

thought I hea rd you say, and 1 m ade a note o f it,

that there 's goihg to be a ce rta in point at wh ich we

need to have this p rivate meeting , after wh ich th is

w ho le matter is going to or m ay go to Federal Court .

10

M R . FLYNN :

Yes, your Hono r .

11

THE COURT :

Am I m i sta ken about that?

12

MR . PEEK :

13

:2:24

,
,
don t thin k it s going to go to Federal Court .

THE COURT :

I know e but 1et me hear --

15

MR . FLYNN :

No , you r Ho no r, you rre not

16

m istaken and , ye s, your Honor y we are go ing to reach

17

th a t p o in t .

02:24

l 've now lea rned from th is w itness that he

19

doesn 't even know five percent enough of what we 're

20

talking ab out to test ify about it , and the only one ,

21

probably, is Mr . Montgomery .

22

Mr . T repp apparen tly do esn 't know , either .

23

So at some point , M r . T repp is going to

24

n2:23

Well , that 's what he sa id ; I

14

18

THE COURT :

Y25

have to be -- M r . Montgomery is go ing to h ave to be

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:24

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 128 of 222


$- p '

( X

kv )

126

on the witness stand and he 's go ing ho have to go at

least to December '02 -- and 1'11 give you a copy of

th is ch ronology - . and we 're going to reach that

point a t that tim e because l was wondering if,

franklyz if this ind ividual knew enough --

T H E C O U RT :

W e l l , I gu e s s - -

M R . UL YN N :

-- a n d h e d o e s n 't .

THR COUPT :

Well, 1 gue ss there 's --

Let me fin ish th is conve rsation here .

10

What I 1m looking at is a coup le o f things .

11

Oner I 've certainly enjoyed your company,

12

gentlemen, very much, and 1 enjoy the issues; it's

13

kind o f an interesting case , but if th is ca se is

14

going to go somewhere else, then I d on 't w ant to sit

15

here and go through a half a d ay or a day of

16

testim ony about things that , you know , I 'm not go ing

17

t o b e a b l e t o u lt m at e ly d e c id e .

18

92:24

02:24

n2:2s

Secondly, i f there are th ings that are

19

classified or potent ially classified , 1 don 't have

20

enough understanding about those to m ake an y kind of

21

ruling whatsoever on it .

22

,
-

Th irdly , I would assume , and I d on 't know

23

this , but I would a ssum e that if the federa l

24

government had a concern, the federal government

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

o2:2s

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 129 of 222

t )

would be here , or the U .S . Attorney 's o ffice would be

here

federal gove rnm ent or agency d irecting m e w ith rega rd

to how far this p zoce ss cou ld qo .

5
6

or we would have a court order from some

Unt il 1 get that , then any que st ion that 's

MR . PEEK : Your Honor, this was just


re lated to 1aw enforcem ent issues ; th is wasn 't

related to the Department o f Defense .

THE COURT :

Well, I -- whatev er it is,

o2:z6

11

unt il som ebody cites m e to a statute or until

12

som ebod y gives me a cou rt order tha h says this stuff

13

can 't b e discu ssed , then wh en a quest kon is asked ,

14

T lm go ing to o rder it to be an swered .

15
16

MR . PEEK :

We 're happy to 1e t h im answer,

T H E C O U RT :

So - -

18

MR. PEEK: I just was --

19

T HE COURT :

But b ac k to m y -- m y question

20

is, is there someone at the Depa rtment o f Defense or

21

the other federal agency w ith whom I should have a

22

discussion ab out what shou ld go forward in this case ?


A nd if so, I would ask you to have that

'

24

02:26

you r Ho nor .

17

23

02:2s

as ked is go ing t.o be answered , so --

10

127

individual contact me or to do something, because T'm


.

L1ZA CIIAPEN , CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

:2:26

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 130 of 222

--.
.

1:y

---<x .m-

not go ing to have secret meetings and continue the

ca se and do a1l this other stu ff unless I have a

b asis to do that .

lf 1 do , be happy to do it , but I don rt .

M R . PE E K :

Y ou r H o n o r , m a y 1 b e he a r d o n

T HE CO U RT :

MR . PFEK :

Y e ah , ye a h .

-- I think what 's happen ing is

that you 're be inq given half o f the sto ry .

10

Th e source code is a code that was b eing

11

asked b y the governm ent unde r contrach of eTreppid to

12

develop that woulcl do certain thinqs, patte rn

13

recognitionz anomay detection, those kinds of -- it

14

would perform those funct ion s in an executable

15

format .

02:27

02:27

16

The Department o f Defense provided to

17

e T re p p id c e r t a in c la s s if ied m a t e r ia l - - an d I

18

m ent ioned th is to you the other da y -- in the form of

19

video , and yo u m ight can im agine w hat th at is -- to

20

try to se e if the source -- if the code could

21

actually operate and m ake p attern recogn ition and

22

anomaly detection and facial recognition and object

23

detection .

24

o2:2G

this b ecause --

.w.
1
---

n.....

But the source code itself is not

LIZA CHAPEH, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

:2:27

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 131 of 222

)
1

It is not a classified piece of --

WelL, it's not classified tn any way.

It's just the knfarmation qjven to eTreppid that was

classified on wh ich the source code would ope rate .

c lassified .

Now , some of those videos, there 's a

concern about w he re they a re .

the Department of Defen se r has b een investigating

eTrepp id to find out what ha s happ ened to them , but

you 're b eing sort of given this im pression that there

So the OSI, as part o f

10

is something o ut here that in the national se curity

11

intere st tha t we shouldn 't be ta lking ab out : and

12

that 's not t he case .

13

:2:27

02:28

If jt were the case, you would have heard

14

from the fed eral government r you wou ld have heard

15

from the United States District Court, you wou ld have

16

even seen a m otion to stay this proceeding .

17

a d d re s s t h a t i n a n ab st en t i o n i s su e a s t o w h e th e r

18

they w ere or were not .

We wou ld

19

So I on ly raised the po int ab out Sloan s

20

test im ony , M r . Ven able 's testimony , because the 1aw

21

enforcement had asked not to disclose that there w as

22

the subject of an onqoing criminal investigation .

23

That 's the only reason I b rought it up .

24

THE COURT: A1l right

LIZA CHAPENP CCR: RMR

n2!2a

We ll , th is record

(775) 323-5492

02:28

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 132 of 222

))
1
l

is sealed .
He re is m y position .

I feel li ke I 'm --

you know , 1 'm no t reatly out in the ligh t in terms of

what -- you know , what exactly it is you lre saying .

1 fee l like I 'm in the da rk on that , and until 1 have

some solid statuto ry authorty o r som ething from the

government or contact from the federa l government,

then I'm just going to go ahead and proceed because I

don 't have a basis not to proceed .


MR . FLYNN :

I understand f you r Honory and

11

with a11 due respect to Mr . Pee k, if 1 only qave you

12

half the story , wh sch adm ittedly I 've ev en given you

13

less , because there isy a s I said , a dicho tom y

14

betw een the d ata com pression technology that these

15

folks made a dea l c)n and a11 this government stuff .

16

That fs the bottom line to the proceeding

17

18

(
'

t
-..
---

10

----

02:29

02:29

b ef o re y o u .

Now , in a11 th is governm en t m ate riak, the

19

way , a s T understand it , on th is level , the

20

government works , the ind iv idu als involv ed , w ho have

21

been at eTreppid Techno logies , would never contact

22

any U .S . A ttorney and go into any cou rt to d isclose

23

anyth ing or see k any order .

24

02:29

THE COURT :

Well , they ,re out of luck,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(7V5) 323-5492

02:29

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 133 of 222


$

hhen , 1 guess , if they -- 1 mean, if there 's som e

statutory authority that we're not supposed Lo

proceed with this thing , then f need to see it .

If they don 't want m e to p ro ceed w ith

this , Lhen they need to tel me that .

secreh that they can 't tell me that, then we fre just

go i ng t o g o a h e ad .

MR . PEKK :

Honor .

THE COURT :

11

M R . PEEK :

We ll --

:2:30

-- as we go through the

one w itne ss into it , it is a kmost noon -THE CO UPT :

16

MR . PEEK :

Right .

02:39

-- and I wou ld as k that we

17

p ro c ee d e xp e d i t iou sl y b e c au se y o u to l d u s w e o n l y h a d

18

today .

19

m erits .

Th is is not a m in i-trial or tria l on the

20

THE COURT :

21

I m ean , here is m y prob lem and I hope you

24

T understand .

can understand and apprec iate that .

23

We w ant you to p roceed , your

We have just started our case, we are only

15

22

02:30

process .

13
14

lf it 's so

We 'll tell you what the source cod e is --

10

12
/

It 's like a lawyer stands up and says , ''I

object

''

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:3:

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 134 of 222

)
('

An d s o , ''What 's yo u r 13a si.s ? ''

''We 11, 1'm not going to tell you what the

'

basis is, but E oklject to ths evidence.''

M R . FLYNN :

That is the pa radox .

THE COURT :

Can you --

MR . FL YNN :

Tha t is the pa radox the Court

02:31

is confro nted w ith , and 1 w jll say th is is where we

end up -- here 's where we end up .

The re is no source code except in

10

Mr . Montgomery 's head .

11

by contract .

12

had to be that wa y .

13
14

15

It has a lw ay s been that way

You will hear his test im ony .

02:31

lt always

THE COURT:

I've read that.

I've read

MR . FLYNN :

The re is no source code that

that .

16

could be made to de live r to an yone , practically,

17

p ra gm a ti c a ll y , le ga l ly o r o t h e r w is e .

18

. -

02:31

Th e bottom line for the Cou rt is whether

19

the source cod e that 's in M r . Montgom ery ls head ,

20

which is what we 're fight ing about , b ecause of the

21

conv ersat ions that M r . Montgom e ry and M r . Trepp had

22

financia lly in the fa ll o f 2005 , involving hund red s

23

of millio ns of do llars, is the reason for -- that 's

24

the reason we're in


.

court today .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:31

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 135 of 222

.
t'..
)
(

(
h.

r.
>j

'33

T hat code r if you want to ca ll iL, that 's

in Mr. Montqomery 's head, has nothing to do with the

deal that: was m ade between these people for data

compre ssio n technoiogy, which is al1 over the

co n t r ac t s .

02:32

THF COURT :

1 read that , too .

MR . FLYNN :

So where we 're go ing to end up

when M r . M ontqome ry teshifies, and 1 911 giv e the

judge -- your Honor a heads up -- is there are

10

thousands of lines of code involving this classified

11

technology , notw th standing what M r . Peek says, that

12

extrem ely few indiv iduals in the gov ernm ent even know

13

abou t .

92:32

14

Mr . Montgomery and Mr . Trepp have signed

15

docum ents that they would neve r disclose it to

16

anyone .

17

18
19

T h a t 's w he re w e 're q o in g t o e nd up , y ou r

Bono r .
The on ly way the Cou rt can understand the

20

ram ification s o f this technology is for

21

M r . Montgome ry to tell you r mu ch of which M r . Trepp

22

doesn 't ev en know , how it was used , what the results

23

of that were over the last sev eral years .

24

02:32

THE'
, COURT: And you're saying he cannot

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:32

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 136 of 222


Mxp>

6)
f

te ll m e that ?

MR

FLYNN :

that .
W hy

M R . nLYNN :

And 1 bel ieve the only th ing

that I can com e up w ith is tha t he and Mr . Trepp

could go into chamb ers , and Mr . T repp could v erify

what M r . Montqom ery will tell you .

way o f -M R . Peek :

THE COUHT :

13

M R . P E EH :

14

T HE CO UHT :

16

I have no othe r

Your Honor , we 're going to do

02:33

You have a -W e 're go i ng t o - Well , we 're goin g to d o it

where 1 say -M R . PEEK :

:2:33
1 unde rstand that , you r Honor :

17

b ut I would like to have it done in op en court , as

18

opposed to just send two individuals into your

19

chambe rs to d iscu ss --

20

02:33

this in op en court .

12

15

134

Abso Lutely cannot tell you

T H E C O UP T :

11

- -<rN'

10

1'

-.-

THE COURT :

Well , we 're not going to even

21

do that if I don tt have some statutory basis for h is

22

saying he can 't or won 't d isclose it .

23

G ive me that , and 1 '11 say fine .

24

MR. PEEK: Andr your Honor, what I find

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

o2:3a

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 137 of 222


'

(
'
*
x-) -.
.
-.
-(

interesting to this filib us ter is that we know that

there were 200 gigabytes de leted o ff o f the

SRCSEPVER , o ff the IGASERVER , and out o f the RA TD

box , and he 's saying , #'Wel1, thaL doesn 't'' -- ''That 's

meaningless .

:2:34

it wa s thah he did de lete .

inference , if you will , he 's trying to put ouL

there -- imp lication , if yo u will -- that there was

We have this sort of

10

som eth ing put on a p rogram that autom atica lly

11

deleted , and we 'll hear from that later , but --

THE OOURT :

I 'm getting that part .

:2:34

1 'm

13

just -- 1 just have a concern about this scurity

14

issue , th at we dre going to get to a point w here

15

there 's going to be evidence or inform at ion that 's

16

critica l to e ither side , and one side o r the other is

17

go in g t o s a y , ''I Im so r ry , I c a n t t e l l yo u ab out

18

that .''

19

MR . PEEK :

20

THE COURT :

21

MR . PEEK :

22

Tlaat fs not a source code .''

But you never hear him say or expla in wh at

12

('

1g$

g
'

j
.-

o2:a4

Well --

A l1 I 'm sayin g is when that --- then they fail on their

burden .

23

THE COURT :

A l1 I 'm saying --

24

We lly who ha s the burden ?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:34

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 138 of 222

<

136

... .

po int , and I 'm trying to give both sides a heads up ,

what I 'm saying to you, Mr . Flynn, is if we get to

thah po int a nd you or you r clie nt tell m e that you

cannot disclo se hhat , without some citat ion to some

authority fo r Lhat purpose , 1 'm going to orde r it to

b e disc lo sed .

9
10

order -- I m go ing to issue a show cause order with


regard to contempt .

o2:3s

A nd 1 111 do the same on the other side .

12

I don 't want to do that .

1 want to do the

13

rig ht thing .

14

thing is and give m e c ita tion to some authority .

But you need to te ll me what the right

15

That 's a1l I 'm saying .

16

MR . FLYNN :

02:35

1 understand, your Honor, and

17

T 'm co n v in ce d a t t h i s p o i nt th a t t h e C o u r t w a n t s to

18

do the right thing and --

19

THE COURT :

20

Huge sa lary that 1 --

21

MR . FLYNN :

That 's what I get paid for .


02:35

And I don 't know whether they

intend to call M r . Montgome ry .

23

24

02:34

If it 's not disc osed , I 1m going to

11

22

(
R
V

A 1l i 'm saying is that if we get to th at

('

I thin k a 1ot will b ecome clear when we

call him,

and you 'll see wh en we reach a certain end

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 139 of 222

%-e.
)
l

forw ard with it and then we 'll see where we go w ith

it .

I do have a Judges ' meeting at noon so 1

need to recess just a couple minutes early and 1'11

be back at 1:30f so just for planning purposes .

BY M R . FLYNN :

Q.

For two years , acco rd ing to your

11

test im ony, you worked on about one percent of

12

eTrepp id source code ?

13

A.

Correct..

14

Q.

And th en a fter that , you were bas ically

do in g adm inist rative, orqanizing dut ies ?

16

A.

Purchasing , p rep aring stu ff the re , right .

17

Q.

So in a11 the years --

18
A.

Co rrect .

20

Q.

You worked on one p ercent of the source

A.

I can 't te ll you what p ercentage of a11

22
23

24

02:36

o2:a6

You dve been there six years , is it?

19

21

n2:3s

Go ahead , Mr . Flynn .

10

15

jgg

THE COURT: A11 right. Well, let's go

---(x
r

point , it will become obv ious .

-----.

code ?

the stuff .

I just told you the two projects I've


= '

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:36

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 140 of 222

()
1

w o rk ed o n .

Q.

And whatever the Denn ks Mo ntgom ery sou rce

code is on these government con tracts , you don 't know

a ny t h i ng ab o u t t '
?

MR . PE EK :

Counse l, could you p lease .

T h a n k yo u .

THE W ITN PSS :

1 don 't know about the code ;

1 just know about the hardware that was used for the

projects.

10

M R . FLYNN :

Than k you , sir .

11

THE COURT :

Are you finished?

12

MR . FLYNN :

Yes, s ir .

13

THE COUBT : Al1 right.

14

02:37

Th an k you .

Do you have any

redirect?

15
16

02:36

MR . JAKO PIN :

Yes, a little b it , your

02:37

Honor .

17

18
19

20

REDIRECT EXA M INATION


BY MR . JAKOPIN :

Q.

W e 've heard a 1o t about the source code ,

21

and so that we can m ake -- get som e c larity to that ,

22

Windows is an application -- o r W ord is an

23

application , it 's a typing app lication , correct?

24

A. correct.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:37

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 141 of 222

(x
)B*
w.- ,

>. -

Q.

relates to that ?

A.

How w ou ld you exp lain the source code that

Microso ft hired probably severa l hundred r

m ayb e thousands to develop the ir O ffice ap plications,

and they w rite al 1 the actual text files that are

eventually com piled to make th is one executable

called Wo rd .EXE, and th at runs and it 's got who know s

how m any lines of code in it .

thousand, maybe a million just for Word because it ls

11

a ve ry , v ery -- what we call fat app lication , ve r y

12

featu re-rich .

13

Q.

referred to as the source code , then , fo r this Word

15

applicat ion ?

:2:38

16

A.

Co rrect .

17

Q.

So you 'll have source code that is fo r an

18

app licatio n that w ill have a whole 1o t of lines o f

19

code that a11 together form the source code for that

20

application ?

23

24

A.

oz:aa

C orrect , that are comp iled and that

creates th e applicat ion .

Q.

02:37

A nd are a l1 those lines o f code together

14

22

oz:ap

I heard th at it 's seve ral hundred

10

21

. 1ar)

O ka y .

For each o f the d if ferent

applications that exist at eTreppid , there 's then

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 142 of 222


.

j
..,.,..;
1
(

,,
f
..;

14()

sou rce code tha t corresponds to that , correc t?

A.

T h a t 's r iq h t .

Q.

Now , are there d ifferent app licahions that

4
5
6

share source codes among them?


A.

Seve ra L of those app licat ion s used video

02:38

comp ression Codecs .

For exampley they hard-coded the v ideo

comp re ssion Codec into the player so thah w e cou ld

ship this p laye r to some o f our c lients tha t wou ld

10

just be a stand-atone and it only played our type of

11

media file , our type of video .

12

So , in that case, that Codec, that video

13

comp re ssor and the p laye r had the sam e code in each

14

of those two deals .

oz:aa

f'

15

Q.

So you can com bine together d iffe rent

16

lines o f source code , or the same lines o f source

17

co d e fo r d if f e r e nt ap p l i ca t io n s ?

18

A.

T hat ts right .

19

Q.

Now , we 've also hea rd about clas sified

20

information .

21

02:39

Do you have an unde rstanding o f what 's

22

d ifferent betw een classified in formation an d source

23

code --

p
'

24

A.

Ye s .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

02:39

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 143 of 222

)
l
(

2
3

-- as Lt was u sed at eT reppid ?


And what was that?

A.

A s ER facility secur ty officer, 1 'm

required to take courses from the governm ent that

trains me on what 's classified , how the classified

m ateria l is handled , who can handle the class ified

mate rial , how ho destroy 5t, a 11 the thing s that are

invo lved with classified material , how it 's defined ,

eve rything , and I 've taken the se cou rses and gotten

11
12

cert ificates for th em .

Q.

No.

14

Q.

O kay .

17

o2:ag

sou rce codes be ing classified?


A.

16

Are you aw are of the different

app lication s that are being wo rked on at eTreppid?


A.

I know a lot o f the diffe rent ones .

p r o b ab l y d o n 't kno w a 1 l o f t h em .

Q.

W hat are th e one s that you 're aware o f?

19

A.

I mentioned the one be fore y the Ad aptive

21
22
23

24

92:39

18

20

n2:3a

A re you aware of any o f the eTrepp id

13

15

--:7

10

Q.

.-

Program which we lve had pretty m uch from the start .


The data comp ressor y th e v ideo Codec
p rogram s, the audio Codec p rogram s .
Codec is a wo rd for a comp ressor ,

decompressor

L'
.'
.ZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:40

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 144 of 222

(..,
,
.
j

. -

- -

k;7-

14(
2

O ur stream ing programs , ou r v oice-ove r IP

'

programs .

3
4

app l icat i ()n s .

Q.

p r og r am s ?

A.

I do rl1t. kn ow w h ic h p rog ram s do t ha t .

Q.

A l1 r.
i.gh t .

A.

1 c o u 1dn 't g iv e yo u a n ame o f a p ro g ram

10

11

We 've go t h un d re d s o f d if fe re n t

t ha t d id 1)h a t .

Q.

A re yo u -- do yol hav e an unde r st a nding o f

where the sou rce code for a l 1 of the di f fe rent so urce

13

code programs was stored?

15

MR. FLYNN :

Strike -- objection, your

Honor , to th e wo rd ''a ll''; lacks foundation .

16

THE COURT :

17

more -- better than just ''all ''

18

BY M R . JA i(O P IN :

19

Q.

20

Let m e a sk it a different way .


Do you have an understand ing of where the

source code that diffe rent prog ramm ers w rote got

22

stored ?

24

A.

02:40

Define them a little bit

21

23

:2:4:

o2:4o

12

14

A ce y o u a w a r e o f pa tt e rn r e c og n i t io n

A 11 -- they stored a 11 of the ir stuff on

the SRCSERVER

They had local cop ie s on the ir work

LTZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:41

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 145 of 222

stat ions and they had -- when they had something that

was a worl:ing order on a version-by-version basis, it

m ig h t b e ro t e v 6)ry d a y , b u t e v e ry c ou p 1e o f d a ys o r

every weelo

SRC SE RVER .

Q.

they would p ut tha t good bu ild up on


92:41

And so a11 of the sou rce cod e that each of

the d ifferent programm ers worked o n ultimately got

sto red on th e SRCSERVER?

A.

10

Right .
A nd each one of the p rogramm ers could g ive

11

better details of which prog ram s they worked on and

12

which fo lders Lhey p ut them on SRCSERVER .

13
14

15
16
17

one p erson w as doing .

Q.

A re you aware o f eTrepp id hav ing backup

A.

I 'v e b ee n to ld ov e r t he y e a r s t h a t Den n i s

19

maybe there w as CDs in the b eginning -- but gave them

20

to Wa rren to p ut in a safe somewhere outsid e the

21

build ing .

24

02:42

C Ds of sou rce code?

had , on a regular basis, m ad e DVDS and hard drive s --

23

02:41

1 w asn 't awa re o f w hat every particular

18

22

14(
3

a.

M R . FLYNN :
foundation .

MR

M ove to strike ; lacks

''I was aware .''


.

JA KO PI N :

From what?

Your Honor --

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:42

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 146 of 222

rj
!

THE COURT:

1 'm no t sure w ha t the question was .

that he was awa re .


I t h i n k y o u n ee d t o d et e rm in e e x a c t ly h ow

he was aw are ancl then i '11 decide whether to strike

it or not .

BY MR . JAIIOPIN :

Q.

11

CDs?

02:42

A.

Denn s told me that he was ma king them .


THE COURT :

13

MR . JA KO PIN :

15
16
17

02:42

How were you awa re that there we re those

12

14

Motion is denied .
Th ank you .

B Y M R . JA X O PIN :

Q.

Did you eve r have an opp ortunity to loo k

02:42

at tho se C Ds?
A.

18

thin k you asked h im did he know , and his answ er w as

10

Hold on just a minute.

t
'

U p u nt il re c e n t l y s n o , a nd t he n - -

Do you want m e to continue?

19

Q.

Ye s .

20

A.

I fo rget what -- T believe Lhe 10th or the

21

11th of J anua ry, W arren b rought me everyth ing he said

22

he had in the safe and had m e look at it to see what

23

it contained , and it was four hard drives and a stack

24

of Dvos and cos m fxed .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:4a

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 147 of 222


(,'..

Q.

Did you check tho se ?

A.

I went ove r them .

14 5

Th ree o f the hard d rives we re supposed to

be a RA ID group , created with a Window s Dynamic

Driver RA rD ; one of the drives was b lan k ; and the

othe r two were part of a Dynam ic RA IB group but it

was missing the third drive .

8
9

A dapt ive Prog ram from 2001.

10

Another CD had files on it that were

11

passwo rd p ro te ctecl and the password wasn 't what

12

Dennis had g iv en Warren .

13

None of it had cu rrenh stu ff .

n2:13

T he m o st

14

recent fi Les on the -- a ll of the co llective C Ds and

15

the hard drive s, 1 couldn 't even read , but the CDs

16

was 2001, 1 b elieve ; m aybe January 2002 .

17

Q.

Yo u had mentioned an Ad ap tkve Prog ram ?

18

A.

ET Adaptive r the data com pre ssor p rog ram .

19

Q.

Uh -huh .

20

A.

It h ad --

02:44

Wa s there -02:44

Wh at 's tha t?

22

Q.

Go ahead .

23

A.

lt had the code for that but not the

24

:2:13

The -- one of the DVDS h ad code fo r the

21

.
'v j
--(z.

.-

(
'

compzete code

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 148 of 222

..e

It had imb edded anobhe r program inside

th at was comp iked with in tt so it did n 't have the

com plete code .

th ks litt.
'e embedded p rogram ins tde o f it w as .

Q.

Was there any source code on the CDs and

o th e r m e d ia th a t y o u w e re g iv en , oth er than th is

Adap tive Prog ram ?

A.

11

Q.

You mentioned binaries .

Cou ld you expla in

ho the Court what a binary is?


A.

Binary is what source code

just call a11 executables binaries

16

-- we general ly
02:45

They can be an executab le o r a DLL file .

17

They lre the fina l p rodu ct after com pilinq .

18

c reate you r b inary file .

19
20

Q.

Y ou

Ts the binary fjle created from the source

code ?

02:45

21

A.

C o rr e ct .

22

Q.

How is that done?

23

A.

Through a compiler such a s -- there 's

24

c2:44

code on an y of those d rives was for the Adap tives .

14

15

But other than that , that wa s the onky

12

13

02:44

The re we re only the b inarke s , the se

executab le's for v kdeo comp re ssion and a m ed ia play e r

10

W e don t know what th e code was for

146

('

(w )

command line one s .

The one we use in the bu ilding is

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 149 of 222

f
.

the Visua q Studo Product that M crosoft ma kes .

Q.

And how does it operate?

A.

lt goes and run s th rough and compile s each

C ++ file , creates in termed iate libraries .

F rom th o se , it comp tle s them toqether and

creates the final executable or DLL and converts it

a11 to what we ca Ll the binary .

8
9
10

It ps basically just ones and zeroes


Q.

O kay .

w ill be many lines of code , co r re c t ?


A.

C o r re c 1).

12

Q.

And there w ill be p()tentia l1y many

l3

d i f fe ren t so u r ce c od e fi le s t ha t a re d i re c t e d t o a

14

single app zication ?


A.

C o r ze c t .

16

Q.

Doe s the compile r act upon a11 o f those

02:46

17

source code fi zes , each o f w hich have line s in it, in

18

a sequence to then create a sing le executab le file?

21

o2:4s

15

20

oz:ls

So with in a sou rce code file , t he re

l1

19

A.

Exact ly .

It goe s through each o f the

files in the project .

02:46

You create a project in our developer

22

environm enL .

It goe s through each o f those y c r e at e s

23

an inte rmediate 1ib file , library file , and then

24

combines al1 those together into your final

'

147

'

j-e)

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 150 of 222

.
a,
...
1

f'

148

executable , and it does it in a sequenttal fash ion .

2
3

Q.

So that you end up with a single program

thah can be executed by the com puter ?

A.

Correct .

N ow , you m ight need interm ed iate steps .

L ike, for examp le , our video compressor , it can 't do

anything by it sell .

something else wo uld need to , like a m edia player

wou ld need thak file to be able to p lay bac k our

10

T ha t 's - -

v ideo .

11
12

It 's a DLL lib rary .

02:46

02:46

Q.

You referred to a DLL library .

A-

Dynam ic Lin k L ibrary .

W h a t 's

that?

'

13
14

15

d ifferent p art s o f the ope rat ing syst em and software

16

that 's ru n on the ope rak ing system , so that to play

17

back, for exam p le r M P3 audio , you wou ld have a DLL

18

that handles M P 3 a ud io files , and we created DLL

19

files for vid eo and for aud io .

20
21
22

('

That 's w hat Windows use s to modulize

Q.

You 'll have a DLL that wil l lkn k to get

different kind s o f files to th e prog ram ?


A.

For examp le , you try to p lay bac k eT reppid

23

A udio, there wou ld b e a -- that , fo r examp le, isn 't

24

exactly the DLL , but it Is similar and it w ould allow


=

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

:2:44

:2:47

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 151 of 222


.

fx*-zmj
..

(
t'N

-- -

14j)

..

yo u t o p 1(,y b a (7k t.he au d io .

Q-

O kay .

A.

We wou ldn 'h create an e xecutable for ET

A udio ; we did hav e our own players .

Q.

Gett ing back to source code r could you

describ e #lhe mannec n which various programmers

would storce source code onto the SRC SERV ER?

8
9

A.

ET Latest is where they we re supp osed to

We a lso had a fo lder in there called ET

11

Programmers , underneath which had a subfolder for

12

each p rog.rammer that we assigned .

13

they each -- that fo lder, fo r exam ple , for Venkata ,

15

only V en kata can get into that fo lder .

16

other u sers on the netwo rk could .

17

None of the

02:48

V e n ka t a h a d w h a t w e c a l l m od i fie d

18

p erm issions .

He cou ld add files , change file s, but

19

h e can never dele te .

20

de lete .

Only the adm in istrator could

02:48
And th ere was a sub folder for each of the

22

p rogramm ers w ith tho se pe rm issions a ssigned , and they

23

w ould put the ir w or k in p rogre ss und er those and do

24

the ir own da ily or w ee kly b ackup s under there .

i'
S..

02:48

Denn is and I assigned perm issions that

14

21

02:47

put their latest b uilds .

10

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 152 of 222

t-....
'
;
1

Q.

A.

O kay .

A 1l of the proqramm ers excep t for Michael,

Jessie and Jim , w hch is not a programme r; al1 the

re st w e re d e le t e d .

02:48

Jessie , Michae l and Jim 's folde rs w ere


still the re .

Q.

What was in M ichael 's folder ?

A.

The game eng ine code .

10

Q.

What wa s; in Jim 's folder?

11

A.

A 11 the 3-D models he m ade for the game

12

And Jessie 's had all the web site stu ff he

developed ; no C+4 code, just Java and HTML stuff.

15
16

Q.

Jav a and HTML are differen t p rogramming

02:49

languages r corre ct ?

17

A.

T h e y dre w eb s it e p ro g ram m i n g la n g u a ge s .

18

Q.

And that 's different from the C++

19

:2:49

engin e .

13

14

1qj()

And were a11 o f tho se files deleted

programm ing lang uage?

20

;7r
..

from the SRC SERV ER?

A.

They don 't ma ke executab les or p rogram s

21

that are run; they just generate code to display web

22

pages .

23

MR . JAKO PIN :

I don 't have anyth ing else .

24

Did your Honor have any questions of the

LIZA CHA PEN , CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:49

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 153 of 222


x

(... )
(

151

witness as it relates to just having your

understand ing be clear as it re late s to sou rce code

or files?
T H E C O tJRT :

Y e ah , 1 do hav e a p retty

bas ic -- pretty b asic que st on that re ally hasn 't

been, at lea st , laid out well enough for me to rea lky

understand it .

8
9

I 'm not exactly sure -- wh en you sa

sou rce cod e, I 'm not sure what you m ean by that

: so

if you could explain it to m e in laym an 's te rms so

11

that --

12

THE W ITNESS :

13

THE COURT :

oz:so

Okay .

Is it li ke a key tha t a l low s

y ou acce ss to n formation --

15

TH E WITNESS :

16

THE COURT :

17

:2 :43

y a

10

14

No

02:s0

-- or is it the in formati

on

itself?

18

('
-j

THE W ITNESS :

It 's som eth ing you co uld

19

read l You could open one -- say , fo r examp le , for

20

the v ideo C odec , it would be arranged -- the project

21

wou ld b e a rranged , so this w ould m ake a DLL file to

22

1et you play th is video .

23

header files and then there wou ld be a bun ch o f ''C ''

24

files.

Th ere wou ld be a bunch of

LIA CHA PEN , CCRZ RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:50

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 154 of 222

t....c
1

text that you coulcl read . There would be like

function -- p lay function , for examp le , and it would

say wha t the variab les for tha t funct ion is .

Then , there would b e a cor responding C++

file that would actua lly have the bu1 k o f that

function .

wou ld have some stuff ins ide , fo r example , a ''fo r ''

loop , it wou ld be -- say , ''For th is number o f th ings ,

10

th is num ber o f ite rations , do th is calculat ion and go

11

around .''

o2;so

A nd you can actually -- an ybody could read

13

this stuff

14

it ls in plain Engzish language .

15

nz:so

Tt woulcl say ''p lay funct ion y '' and then it

12

gk!(j;4
!

The header files just have definitions and

('

'
am.pfj

They m ight not know wh at it 's doing , but

TH E COURT :

Bu h w hat I1m a sking , Vs the

16

source code the dev ice that you use to get access to

17

what you just described ?

18

THE W ITNESS :

19

T HE COURT :

20

THE W ITNESS :

c2cs1

Uh-huh .

It is?
You could - - no .

The sou rce

21

code -- we co llective ly call a 11 of this language

22

that 1 'm desc ribing the source code .

23

THE COURT :

It 's the content ?

24

THE WITNESS: You can look at it with a

LIEZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02:51

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 155 of 222

(..,;
1

T HE (>
-()tlRT : A 11 ri.ght .

T HE W ITN ESS :

TH E COUFT :

THE W ITNESS :

THE COUFT :

A l1 riqht .

02:51

-- and com pile them .

A11 riqh t .

Now , out o f

cu rio sity , do you bave a security ctea rance?

TH E W ITN ESS :

Yes, 1 have top secre t .

10

THE CO UPT :

11

Do you know what c learance M r . Montqomery

12

13

Top secret .

02:51

has?

THE W I1'HESG :

He ha s top sec ret w ith a

14

specia l compa rtm ent r SC I special compa rtm ent .

15

forget what it stands for .

16

We use a sp ec ia l ed itor to

look at them --

153

Word docurAent or Notepad .

/
.

('.
-

THE CO UHT :

That rs the h ighest level .

W ith regard to th e

17

c onversation that you indicated that you had on

18

January loth -- actually , 1 first th ought it Was on

19

J anuary 11th , but it appears that it w as clarified to

20

have b een on January 10th -- w ith M r . Montgomery

21

where he said to you that Mr . T repp w as going to have

22

to pay big money o r big bucks for ''it .''

23

What wa s the ''it'e?

24

it this waky: Dd Mr

02:51

D kd M r .

- -

ket m e ask

M ontgome ry in that conve rsation

L'
.
EZA CHAPEN , CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

n2:s2

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 156 of 222

...v x.)
.

i
.

(.

--

154

describ e 'lhe ''it'' or was his stateme nt simp ly he ha s

t o pa y b i.fJ b u c k s fo r - -

T H E W IT N ES S :

No , he de s c r ibe d wha t ''it ''

was .

T H E CO (JRT :

THE WITNESS :

W ha t w a s b'it ''?

02:52

This w as th e top -- ou r mo st

recent contrac t, potential contract .

detect ion and sate zlite images, other imaqes for the

governmen t.

10

THE CO URT :

A 11 right .

It 's anoma ly

W e ll , what I 'm

11

ta lking about -- w e 're ta lking ab out source code fo r

12

tha t ?

13
14
15

THE W ITNRSS :
use to d etect it .
THE COIJRT :

A 1l right .

A nd a re those --

is that a tangib le thing or is that info rmation

17

t ha t 's c o nt a in ed i n h i s h ea d ?

18

O r do you know .

19

THE W ITNESS :

20

how he did it .

21

it w ith him .

23

24

02:52

lt 's for the methods they

16

22

Well, 1 don dt know exactly

1 know various people that wo rked on

THE'
, COURT :

:2:52

A 11 right .

W ell y I m ay have

som e furthe r quest ions, but I don 't --

Just give me a second; T thought I had one

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

o2:5a

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 157 of 222

(<w.)
1
t

No ,

l cltan 't h av e an yt h in g fu r t h e r r ig h t

n ow .

M r . F1 ;nIA?

MR . FLYN N :

1yj5

more .

2
3

1w'
b
z-

..- - ---

I-lope fu l ly i t w i 1 1 be

02:s3

r e 1a t iv e 1 5( s h o r1:, k'o u r Ho n o r .

'

.7

R E:C R OS S EXAM IN AT 1O N

BY MR . FL'fNN :

10

Q.

M r . Ve nab le s , the st a c k o f C D s w h i ch you

11

sa id w a s w it h fou )7 h a rd d r ive s : a n d t ha t w a s , qu o te ,

12

''Eve ryth ilRg i n the sa fe ''?

13

A.

C orrect .

14

Q.

ls that r in fact , accurate , that the fou r

15

hard drive s in the stack o f C Ds w as everyth ing in the

16

safe?

17

A.

I d o n 't kn ow .

they we ren 't in a sa fe on your p rem ises ; they were

19

brough t from a post office box or a bank vault

20

som ewhe re .

22

Q.

1 have no idea .

02:54

Whe re d id you get the term inology,

''Every th iqg in the sa fe''?

23

A.

From Warren .

From M r . Trepp .

24

Q.

W as it the downstai rs safe or the upstairs

/'

02:54

l d i dn 't t a ke t h em f rom - -

18

21

:2:53

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 158 of 222


-..

(
1

2
3

A.

bank vau kt or somep kace out skde the bu kkdin

Q.

A.

building .

Q.

12
13

I have no idea what he has outside th e


I know what w e have in our building .

Have you ever seen the contents o f an y

sa fe be lon ging to Mr . Trepp ?


A.

The one that we have in o ur secret room :

Q.

The secret room being what we de sc ribed on

Exh ibit 1 as the p r ivacy room that 's


A.

R ight .

15

Q.

-- right there, r ight ?

18

n2:s4

he opened for me and Jay Dixon .

16

- -

02;s5

And what did you see?


A.

S p a r e c op ie s o f ke y s a n d v a r i ou s m in i DV

tapes that w e 'd rece ived from the m ilita

19

n2:s4

14

17

g.

How ma ny safes , to your know ledge , d id

11

156

No safe in our build ing ; it was at the

M r . T repp have ?

10

(v)
.
m

safe?

ry .

That wa s it .

20

Q.

How many drawers did you look in?

21

A.

The two -- there 's two saf e containers in

22

that room .

Each has two d rawers .

23

only -- as far as I know : the only comb inat ion to

24

one. Re opened it, showed b 0th m yself and Jay Dixon

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR , RMR

oz:ss

Wa rren had the

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 159 of 222


.-.. .

'
-

Q.

in b0th sa fe s?

A.

No .

Q.

''He '' b eing ?

A.

Wa r ren .

Q.

And what was in that safe again, just

A.

That was just mini DV tapes, no hard

10

1 just described the one he opened .


o2:ss

so --

drives, and th e spare keys to the bu ilding .

o2:5s

11

Q.

And what was in the oth er safe?

12

A.

The othe r safe had -- 1 forget the number ;

13

we have a 1og fkle of it -- of hard drives that Patty

14

had placecl in the re that som e o f were classified ,

15

som e are not , and also a bunch o f m kn i DV tapes ;

16

prob ably 20 .

17

Q.

of these safe s pr tor to th is t im e whe re you saw them

19

in --

20

A.

No .

21

Q.

And , again , it was in January o f 2006 th at

23

24

czts6

Had you ever seen the contents of either

18

22

So have you describ ed , in total , what was

1sy

.-

A nd t h e o the r sa fe , Pa t ty o p en e d f o r u s .

2
3

oa:s6

you saw these ?


A.

In the last two weeks when Jay Dixon from

DSS had me check L)0th of them.


'

- -

.. -.- ..-. -..... - .- - .- - - -- -- -- .-- - .-

- -. ..

.- - -

- ..

. ..- - - - - - - .. .- -

- -- - - . - - . -

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

- .-..- - - - -- .

- - -. - .

(775) 323-5492

. --

-.-. - .-

--

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 160 of 222

(
1--)
(

Q.

Did you see an inventory ?

A.

Yes .

Q.

ln which safe did you see the inventory?

A.

In the sa fe th at Patty op ened .

Q.

Where is the inventory now ?

A.

There 's a copy in th e safe and 1 have a

1gg

Patty had made an inventory .

Q.

Do you have it w ith you?

A.

No .

10

Q.

What was on the inventory ?

11

A.

A l1 th e m ini DV tape s and hard d rive s that

12

Patty sa icl w ere in the hard drive at on e time or

13

another.

15

02:56

The re 's some o f them listed as m issing

right now .

czts;

16

Q.

Wa s the re an inventory of the other safe?

17

A.

No .

18

Q.

Who created the inventory, if you know?

19

A.

Patty to ld me she d id .

20

Q.

When d id she c reate the inventory?

21

A.

I have no idea .

22

Q.

A 11 right .

23

A.

If -- sh e had updated it recently; that fs

24

92:s6

copy in m v of fice .

14

(vj
'

a1l I know.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

02::7

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 161 of 222

:.,..j
1

Q.

1!;9

Tha t was go ing to be my next --

--

How many d ifferent ed ition s of an

inventory in the -

you aw are of a s you test ify today ?

A.

Q.

A nd how m any editions had it gone th rough

you have ao knowleclge of; is thah correct ?

A.

Wh at 's that again?

10

Q.

How many editions o f -- how m any t im es

11

that inve ntory that you saw had been changed in the

12

past --

13

I don 't know .

14

Q.

-- you have no know ledge o f?

15

A.

No .

16

Q.

Patty Gray may have som e know ledge ; is

18

t ha t c o r re c t ?

A.

I saW the current one and I added stuff

that was in Warren 's sa fe to it , so I 'm -- the copy

20

that 's in th ere has only been edited by m e sin ce I

21

first opened it .

22

Q.

24

o2:s7

o2:s7

19

23
1
'

02:57

17

There 's just one copy in there .


1 h ad to provide that to DSS .

7
8

call it the Patty Gray sa fe are

A nd you could have your o ffice , ov er the

brea k, fax that inventory to you ?

MR . JAKCIPIN : Objection, your Honor.


.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

o2:s7

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 162 of 222

v'j
(

T HE W ITNKSS :

They don 't have access .

MR. JAKOPIN:

The inventory is beyond the

scope o f redirect .

MR . FLYNH :

It 's go t to do w ith the sa fe .

THE COUHT :

1 'm interested in the truth ,

9
10

11
12

Go ahe ad .
BY M R . FLYNN :

Q.

You 're the only one that has got the

combination?

A.

o2ts8

DSS has instructed me to change the

combination and not to give it to anybody .

13

Q.

zncluding Mr . Trepp ?

14

A.

Includ ing M r . Trepp .

15

Q.

Tnclud ing M r . Gray?

16

A.

Patty .

17

Q.

I mean M iss Gray?

18

A.

Correc t .

19

Q.

Correc t?

20

A.

That 's right .

21

Q.

Wa s th e inventory c reated on her computer?

22

A.

I have no idea .

23

24

o2;ba

not necessarily the scope o f redire ct .

'

l 've given som e lat itude , but --

('

160

w)'

02:5a

02:5:

Probab ly .

Q.

So the various ed it ion s of the invento ry

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 163 of 222

(...'j
1

A.

Co r rC?c t .

Q.

Now , w tln regard to the CDs, the stack ,

what 's your best: estim ate of how m an y we re in the

s t ac k ?

o2:sa

A.

Less than ten .

Q.

And do you know what safe they cam e from ,

personally ?

A.

No.

10

Q.

M r . Trepp handed them to you and sa id y

11

T don 't know whe re they came from .

''Th is is eve rythin g in the safe .

12

Is tha t your testim ong?

A.

That's rkght.

14

Q.

But you don 't know what sa fe ?

15

A.

He said that they w ere in a bank vault or

Q.

And wh ere are those CDs today?

18

A.

In m y office .

19

Q.

So you could b ring those to court also ?

20

A.

Correct .

21

MR . PEEK ;

o2:s9
Your Honor , 1 1m going to

object.

23

24

02::9

a P .O . Box somewhere ; I forg et wh ich .

17

22

02:sa

''

13

16

161

may still be pre sent o n her hard d rive ?

(
-v'
)

We 're n ot going to engage in d iscov ery

right now

we m ade th is request a long t ime ago o f

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 164 of 222

cou nsel and they didn lt want -- they did n 't w ant to

engage in any exchange of discovery last week when we

ta lked abou h it, and we 're here now in a Preliminary

Injunction and 1 think to be asking to produce

documents over the lunch hou r is un reaso nab le at this

time .

truth , and I unde rstand the search , but , yo u know,

I 'm not inclined to tu rn ove r anyth ing to

10

Mr . Montgomery r igh t now without having the

11

opportun ity to ce rta inly cop y it b efore we do thatr

12

make an inv entory of it , and 1 th in k to a sk to do

13

that in th e n oon hour and t ry to do that an d h ave

14

som e idea of what 's on it between now and the close

15

of bu siness today when we clo se this test imony is

16

unrea sonab le Lo as k.
M R . FL Y N N :

oaloo

o3:no

Tb e q u e s t Lo n w a s o n l y w he t h er

18

he could do it , your Honor .

19

righ t now .

That 's where we are

20

M R . PEEK :

21

THE CO URT :

That 's what I --

22

M R . FLYNN :

I haven 't asked --

23

THE COURT :

That 's what I though t the

24

o2:s9

I unde rstand this is a sea rch for the

17

162

(
r-7

W ell, I know where h e ls go ing .

question was and --

L.EZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

03:00

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 165 of 222


.-

r,.
'v1
.-

M R . PE RK :

- -

y6a

% .-

T he n , I d o n 't kn ow w ha t t h e

relevance of that is.

T H F C O U RT :

Go aheud and ask the question and we 'll

We l l r 1 d o .

see where we go w ith it .

B Y M R . FL X N N :

Q.

8
9

11

o3:0a

Mr . V enables, one o f the CDs --

1 want to remind you we just have a few


m inutes .

10

O ne o f the ODs you sa id had data

A.

Correc t .

13

Q.

Wh en you spoke to M r .

- -

14

Strike that .

15

Did you see any o f them --

16

Str i. ke t ha t .

17

W a s t h e C D it s e l f , t h e ac t u a l d is k , in sid e

03:01

a little container?

19

A.

Plast ic sleeve y yeah .

20

Q.

Did it have any m arking s on tt ?

21

A.

I be lieve it had the d ate , whichever that

22

oa:oo

comp ressic n technology on it?

12

18

('

was ; I can 't rem ember .

23

Q.

W hat wa s the date ?

24

A.

I can t remember what it was

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5192

:3::1

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 166 of 222

(*'*')
1
i'

Did you see any marking on the data

compression CD of the type , ''c D No . 1''?


A.

1 can lt recall .

Q.

As you sit here today, have you ever seen

the Contr tbut ion A greement between M r . T repp and

Mr . Montgomery?

A.

No .

Q.

A s you sit here today , are you awa re if

10

data comp ression technology on CD No . 1?

A.

1 d on 't know what their ag reement is .

12

Q.

Do you have any know ledge , h av ing looked

13

at wha tever this C D is th at you looked at that had

14

data c omp ression technology , whether that corre late s

15

in any wa g to the C D that 's described in the

16

Contribut ion A greem ent?

18
19

A.

03:01

03:02

T h e on l y t h in g I k n ow i s w h a t I fo u nd o n

the CD .
Q.

Did Mr . Trepp ever te ll you that , ''Oh T

20

yeah , tha t's the d ata compre ssion technology CD that

21

is the ba sis for forming the company ''?

22

A.

No .

23

Q.

You , yourself, never wo rked on data

24

03:01

that Cont ribution A greement exc luded -- only gives

11

17

f
'

164

Q.

1%Y

He didn 't say that .

comp ressian te chnology at eT repp id , d id you ?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

03:02

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 167 of 222

v...7

(.'y..

'

A.

No .

Q.

S o b'lh e rk yo u 1.o o ke d a t th a t C i3 - -

Str.
i.ke th a t .

H ow m a ly f i.le s w e re o n th a t C D ?

A.

A c o up 1.e o f h u n d re d .

Q.

An d yo tz don 't re ca l 1 th e d a te ?

-/

A.

No .

03:02

I12 w a s e it h e r 1a te 2 0 0 1 o r e a r ly

2 00 2 ; I c an 't r emem be r .

Q.

And a s 1 unde r st and you r t e s t imon y r s ome

10

o f t he con te n t.s o f the C D , in pa rt , we re pa s swtnrd

11

prot ec t.ed s o you co u 1dn 't acce ss t hem ?

12

A.

13

Q. But ot14er components of that CD, thfa CD on

14
15

Thal:'s r igh t .

A.

The re we re separate C Ds .

w i t h a te x t f i le th a t sa i d , ''W a r re n k n ow s th e

18

passwo rd .''

19

The othe r C D had th is A dapt ive Program --

20

source code for the A daptive Program wh ich wasn 't

21

com plete; it wa s m issing stuff .

23

24

oa:n3

O ne CD only had password p rotected biles

17

22

03::3

data c ompression , were not passwo rd p rotected?

16

16
.
s

Q.

A 11 right .

The one where W arren knows the

password, did you ask h im if h e knew t he pa ssword?

He said h e did , and we tried it and it

LEZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

03:03

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 168 of 222

(
.y
1

d idn 't work .

Q. What was the password that he gave you?

A.

I don 't remember .

Q.

Was there anyth ing in hhe sa fe that wou ld

indicate what the password was?


A.

10

A ny document?

Wa rren 's safes didn 't have any pap er

Pat tly es safe had copies of our contract

from the r ilitary and the m ater ia l log .

Q.

Now , over the -- a1l the years tha t

11

eTrepp id had been in business since 1998 , do you know

12

how many M r . -- how m any passwords fo r files

13

Mr. Trepp ha(:i .n hi.s head?

14

A.

I have no idea what p assword s he had .

15

Q.

Do you know whether h e m a knta ined a

16

separate inv entory of passwords fo r the m illion s of

17

f i le s t h a t w e r e i n e T r ep p id c om p u t e r s ?

18
19

03::3

documents in it, only m in i DV tape s .

y(;(;

=r
'
.
g>

A.

03:04

03:04

I 'v e seen h im acces s his locked drawer in

h is office that had a pape r with the passwords on it .

20

Q.

Than k y ou .

03:04

21

A.

I 've nev er seen it .

22

Q.

Did you ever look at M r . Trepp 's computer

23

to see w hethe r he ma intained p asswords on his

24

computer?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 169 of 222

jw-.x)

A.

No .

Q.

So how -- tn the docum ent that you saw ,

A.

I d tcln 't see the document .

Q.

W hat did you --

A . I just saw him checking for passwords or

Q.

So as you sit here Loday y you have no

know ledge whetlner he , giv ing him the benefit of the

10

doub t, m ade a m ista ke in giving you t he p asswo rd for

11

th is d ata comp re ssion technology C D?

12

A.

03:05

I be lbave that password for tha t one was

13

the name of his mother . 1 think that 's what he told

14

me.

Som eth ing like that .

Someth ing he would know .

15

Q.

How abou t the nam e of h is w kfe , J a le ?

16

A.

I ha ve no idea .

17

H e h ad p le n ty , 1 'm su re .

18

THE CO URT :

It 's time .

19

MR . FLYNN ;

Thank you , your Honor .

20

THE COURT :

We rll --

21

M R . PEEK :

22

03:04

som ething one t im e .

8
9

y(;.
/

how many cliffe Eetn t p asswords we re on it?

(.
'
.
n

oa:os

Your Honor , m ay th is witness be

excused?

23

THE COURT :

I don 't know .

24

Are you inkshed with this witness?

LZZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

03:05

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 170 of 222

y..q:)

'
l

M R . F IuYN N :

N o r 1 'm no t , Y o u r H on c)r .

THE COURT :

A 1l r iqht .

M R . PRRK :

4
5
6

7
8
9

10
11
12

(
'

13

16a

Then , not .

You r llonor, are we go ing to

have more t im e than today ?


THE COURT :

No , 1 don 't have planned -- 1

1 'm interested in a coup le of im portant


pieces o f in formation to me .
I 'm interested in what ''it'' is , whether

''it'' is a tangible thing .

o3:os

I 'm inte cested in know ing whether o r not


''it'' was developecl while he was wo rking for eT reppid .

And I 'm knte rested j.n knowin g whether or


not the aqreement that was entered would have

15

excluded that technology o r the b asis for that

16

techno logy .

I haven t heard mu ch e laborat ion on that and , to me ,

19

those a re the kind s of simp le thin gs that I m ay need

20

to dec ide in m aking a decision ab out whether or not

21

you get yeur injunction or you don 't get your

22

injunction .

24

03:06

I 'v e se e n t h e a rg um en t s in t h e b r ie f s , b u t

18

23

03:05

hadn 't p lanned any more t im e than tod ay .

14

17

(.
-s.
rJI

MR . PEEK :

And we lre trying to do that ,

your Honoz.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

03:06

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 171 of 222


.

b'
7
..

1
f

i
!

y(;,

What Mr. Venables was just talking about

here today p rim ariiy w as -- it was on a SRCSKRVER, it

w a s d e le t e!d o f (' o f t he SRC S F,RV ER

who w ill connect up what went on to that SRCSERVER,

but we spent just three hours with Mr. Venables on

what was zea lly a very discrete a rea o f inqu iry abou t

the fact that it was there and it was deleted .

T HE CO URT :

M R . PEEK :

10

THE COIJRT :

11

M R . PEKK :

12

THE COURT :

t h e re a r e o t he rs

A 11 right .

Mr . Trepp will be te stifying .


Here ls whah f --

03:07

Mr . Frye will be te stifyinq .


-- need to understandz and it

prob ab ly w'ill ref Lect my ignorance w ith regard to

14

this subject, but what is the ''it'' that you want

15

back?

o3:ov
In other words , if I we re to w rite an

17

o rd e r t od ay a n d s a i d

18

g ive 'it ' back '' w hat is ''it'' and wh at w ould ''it''

19

loo k like if ''it'' was sitting in front o f me?

20

93:06

But --

13

16

r.s,

. -

''o ka y

M r . M on tg om e r y h a s t o

MR . PEEK : It would look just exactly the

21

way Slo an testified it was, your Honor , w hich is

22

lines o f code .

23

THE COURT :

On a p iece of paper ?

24

MR . PEEK : No, no.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

03:07

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 172 of 222

I-'-)
(

THE COURT :

MR. PEEK: On disk.

Actually , it 's an e lectron ic file , so it

4
5

T H E C O U RT :

MR . PE KK :

On a d isk?

O ka y .

03:07

lt cou ld be on a hard drive , it

ould be on a C D RAM , could be on a numb er of ways to

sto re the info rm ation .


T HE COURT :

10

M R . PERK :

A l1 r ight .
But it would be -- as he sa id ,

11

it 's sou rce code w ith in which are wr itten m any , many

12

lines of code which he ll that code how to operate ,

13

how to perform its functionality

Now , we 'll get into a little bit --

15

THE COURT :

M R . P EE K :

18

THE COURT :

20

Wou ld that inc lude all the

03:08

cod es?

17

19

03:07

14

16

170

wou ld be e ithe c on a d is k --

(
*-)

Y e s r i t 's a L l t he c o d es .

For the video , the aud io ,

the -M R . PEEK :

Yesy because a11 o f those We re

21

th e p rope zty of e'Preppid , and a11 o f that was , as h e

22

said, deleted off the file s .

23

THE COURT :

21

MR

PEEK :

Well , we 'll -A nd 1 know th at he 's talked

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

03:na

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 173 of 222

-.
1

THE COURT :

MR . PEE.
'K :

A 11 r tght .

Well , we lll see

Where we go with th is .

I just have got that meeting .

if wefve

got to run a little lahe tonig ht , i '11 talk to my

10

staf f about what the ir schedule is , if we can

11

accomm odate --

12

oxtoa

THE COURT :

8
9

It wa s d eleted off o f the

servers .

6
7

1'm sorry for interrupting

you .

4
5

1y1

about --

2
3

t
z%

13

M R . PEEK :

THE COURT :

15

M R . PEEK :

We ll , that 's -Just exac tLy w hat you rre

ta lking about .

17

18

I w ant to get to the m erits ,

you r Hono r .

14

16

THE COURT :

- - k in d o f w h a t m y c o n ce r n

Was .

19

We '11 be in rece ss until about 1 :30 .

20

(Noon recess.)

21

--00 0--

22
23
'

( .

natoa

24

LZZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

G3:GB

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 174 of 222

(....)
1

(.
.
--..
r

y-jz

RENO , NEVA DA ; Tuesday, February 7 , 200 6; 1 :30 P .M .

--000--

3
4

THE COUR'
T:

said you had some more quest ions?

MR . FLYNN :

04:3t

Your Honor, in the interest of

time, we'd like to reserve on Mr. Venables subject to

recall .

10

M r . F 1 yn n , y ou

!
/

A1l r.
i.g11t .

THE COURT :

A11 right .

Ca ll you r next

w itness .

04:a1

11

You can step down , sir .

12

MR . PEEK :

13

subject to recall?

Your Honor, m ay he be excused ,

May he be allowed to leave?

14

THE COURT :

15

MR . PEEK :

Yes .
Because ; know that he

16

doesn 't -- ob vious ly because he w ants to recall him ,

17

h e w a n t s h im o u t (af t h e c o u r t ro om .

18

So may he be allow ed to leave?

19

TH E COURT :

20

MR . PEEK :

21

(Witness excused .)

22

(Discussion off the record a

23

MR . PEEK :

24

04:31

Yes .
Thank yo u .

04:31

Actually , Mr . Ste iner w ent to

get him so he 'l1 walk in with Mr. Steiner, so -- I

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 175 of 222


)
,-)
l

THE BACLIFF: There's nobody out there


now .

MR . PEEK :

S o r r y , yo u r H o no r .

THE CO URT :

M R . PRKK :

THE COURT :

lt rs okay .

MR . FLYNN :

Your Honor r wh ile they re

He was right there .


04:32

That 's a11 rig ht .


I thought he was righ t there .

10

looking , w e tr ied to get you some cases on the

11

gove rnm ental p riv Llege secrecy , m ilitary secrecy

12

privizege , and 1 think they were given to your

13

secreta ry as you we re walking outo

11

going to grab th en and get them up to you .


THE CO URT :

16

(The w itness was sworn . )

17

T H E C O U RT :

A 11 right .

04:32

A 1 1 r ig h t .

P le a s e t a ke t he

w itness stand over there .

19

The re 's some wate r the re --

20

T HE W ITNESS :

21

THE COURT :

22
23

24

04:32

so M r . Pulver is

15

18

173

hope .

2
3

(''n

Than k you .

04:a3

-- if you w ant to have a

little bit .
M ake sure wh en you lre testi fying that you

speak up so that everybody can hear you

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 176 of 222


..--.
w

,,-

')

')

T HE W 1'
JN E,
'SE;:

THE COURT :

174

O k ay .

And try not to speak at the

same time as the taw yer .

T H R W IT N E SS :

Okay .

MR . PEEK :

THE COURT :

MR

MR . FLYNN :

May 1 approach the bench?

THE COURT :

Yes .

Your Honor , may I move this ?

PEEK :

04:a3

Oh , certainly .
Than k yo u .

10

Thank you .

11

M R . FL YN N :

n4:3a

Y o u 're w e lc om e .

12
t

13

Z EHAN G S UN ,

11

called as a w itness , hav ing been first duly sworn ,

15

testified as follow s :

16
17

D IR E CT E XA M IN A T IO N

18

BY M R . JA KOPIN :

19

Q.

Wou ld you tell th e Court your nam e?

20

A.

Oh , my n ame is Zehang Sun .

21

Q.

A nd where do you currently w ork?

22

A.

eT reppid Technology .

23

Q.

A nd what 's your p osition ?

24

1 'm the v kce pre sident of en gineering .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:a3

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 177 of 222


1
.

1
(

2
3
4

Q.

-)

was the first school that you went to?


A.

Actually , before the ye ar 2004 , m ost of

the tim e 2 was in schoo t.

THE COURT :

THE W ITNESS :

C a n yo u sp e l l hh a t ?

10

T H E R E P O RT E R :

11

THE W ITNESS :

15

Northern , N -o-r-t-h-e-r-n .
Ho rth e r n .

G-l-a-o-g-o -n-g , Un sversity .

And then my major was telecommunications


and in form ation theory .
A fte r that , 1 went to hhe graduate school

of the same university and my ma jor was digital

17

si g n a l p ro c e s s in g , a nd th a t w a s -- 1 g ra d u at e - - go t

18

m y fir st Master of Engineering from that university

19

in year 1997 .
A fter that , I received a fellow ship from

21

Universit y' in Singapore .

22

sorry, Naryang Technology Core Un iversity .

23

24

:4:34

Northern Giaogong ,

16

20

04:34

undergraduate in un iversity in China called --

14

From yea r 1990 to 1994, I was

(Discussion off the record .)

13

l7b

..

12

O nce you gradua ted lrom h igh school, wha t

5
6

.
-

The nam e of university is ,

N anyang , N-a-n-y-a-n-g , Technology Core

Univ er sity .

L.
1ZA CHAPEN, CCR r RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:34

o4:a5

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 178 of 222

P
A)
k-''
'w..m

r
'
Mt
'
l

176
.

And J spend there about two years and go t

my se cond Maste r 's Degree that was three-dimen sional

ima g e p ro c:e s s i (Rg a nd c om p u te r v i. s i-on .


I n y e a r 20 0 0 , I r e ce ive a n o th e r fu 1 l

a s si s ta nc e's h ip f rom U n ive r s it y o f N evad a - Re n o h e re ,

and that 's why I went to the graduate scho ol here ;

sp ent another fou r years .

9
10

I got my Ph . D . deg ree .

12

13

My degree w as in

BY MR . JA KO PIN :

:4:36

Q.

Did you write a dissertation fo r your

A.

Ye s .

Ph .D .?

M y dissertation was about feature

14

subset selection for vehicle detection .

15

grant -- that was a project supported by Ford Motor

16

C om pany 's Scient ific Research Lab .

That was a

17

T n ye ar 2 0 01 , I q ot a n int e r n sh ip f rom

18

Ford M otor Com pany and I spent three m onth the re .

19

m y work had great potential and that 's why he g ive m y

21

advisor, Professor George Bebbis (phonetic), U NR , a

22

grant to f arther support m y work .

24

:4::6

A fter three m onth , m y boss in Ford think

20

23

04;3s

com pute r science and enqineering .

11

t.'

'

M y work was v ehicle -- for the vehicle


detection and c kass ification .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:36

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 179 of 222

i)
1
f

Q.

you used the wo rd feature .


Can yo u tell the Court wha t you mean by
the word feature ?

A.

Fe ature is a rather abstract -- it 's a

concept.

in the w ozk o f pa ttern recogn ition and image

processing .

For example -- I th tn k we can m aybe have

10

an example here - - if we try to d ishinguish between

11

human and , let 's say, an an im al, the feature cou ld be

12

the face , the leg , the head ; th at cou ld b e a feature .

13

Q.

talking akout fea tures o f the vehicle s?


A.

Ye s .

16

Q.

Co rrect?

17

A.

Ye s

18

:4:37

And that --

19

Q.

Go ah ead .

20

A.

A nd m y d issertation wa s about automat ic

21

feature subse t selection , and basical ly my w ork on

22

that produ ct for th ree year .

21

n4:a7

And so you were , in you r dissertation ,

15

23

:4:37

How we direct the ob ject is a terminology

14

(
'
%

177

You talked about vehic le detect io n, and

3
4

6)

A fter that , m y wo rk wa s inv ited into

fourth generation Sm art Car . There wa s auto show in

LIZA CHAPEN, CCRZ RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:37

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 180 of 222


-,- .
.

(J

,7v ,

. .)

y.ya

2002 in Ch icago and m y wor k was there .

Q.

And w hat d id that work do?

A.

Th at work ks detect vehkcle s and the -- in

front o f the -- in front of veh icle was my softw are

running .

Q.

04:38

And what was that -- you say software

running ; could you exp lain to the Court how thah

software ran ?

A.

That sofkwa re is a -- the software --

10

software is just a sequence of instructions and

11

that -- and the interface betw een hum an and the

12

machin e, :nd we can do some cod ing , use a software:

13

and after the cod ing is done , the m achine convert

14

that into m ach fne language , which first step going to

15

b e the assembly language .

16

o4:3a

17

th e y c a n c o n v e r t t h at to m ac h in e c o d e b e c au se th e re 's

18

no way hum an can read mach ine code , but m achine can

19

read m ach ine cod e .

21

That 's basically -- m ach in e -- how the


mach ine running is based on tha t m achine code .

22
23

24

04:38

A fte r they get so many languages , further

20

The code is just bunch of numbers, like


83, 100, tho se kind o f things .

The c ocle that you refer red to that is the

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:39

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 181 of 222

)
1

A.

Yes .

Q.

Is tha t called source code ?

A.

Yes .

Q.

And co uld you expla in what that is?

A.

Source code is just a, once again,

Sou rce code is a bunch of sm alle r

fun ctionaiities, you know , m ake su re -- each smaller

10

funct ion doesn 't m ake any sense , but the source code

11

is l ike com bination of those kind of sm alle r

12

function s .

13

to serve a purpose .

15

write the source code .

Q.

That s basica lly why people

o4:4n

And so would each of the comb ination of

17

functions have a num be r of different lines of source

18

code --

19

A.

Ye s .

20

Q.

-- that are asso ciated with it ?

21

A.

Yes .

22

Q.

And then those different functions

23
24

04:39

Th e comb ination of hu o se :unc qyons going

14

16

04:39

inte rface between hum an and m ach ine .

179

human readab le code?

,
$

'
-)

together provide the overall function of the program ?


A

ves

that 's correct .

L FZA CiIAPEN: CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

:4:40

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 182 of 222


..-.

;%.-:

()
(

Q.

N ow , you 've worked at eTreppid since when?

A.

1 o f t'ic i a2ly jo i-ned the company lst


-

January 2004 .

Be foze that f l work on Lhe consu ltant for

abou t m aykhe th re e wee ks ?

04:40

Y e ah , t h ree we e ks .

Q.

A nd what was your posit ion?

A.

V ice p resident of engineering .

Q.

And have you he ld that po sition

10

cont inu ou sly while you tve b een at eT reppid?

11

A.

Yes .

12

Q.

And what have you r re sponsib ilities been?

13

A.

1 thnk my job falls into two different

14

16

04:40

categor ies .

15

The first category is like a -- m y boss

04:41

gave m e some work to do .

17

And the second ca tegory y l t h in k y t h e

18

eTrepp id m igh t want this kind of wor k, and these two

19

kind of wo rk s .

20

the w ork, my boss 1et me to do first time is evaluate

21

feasib ility , whether or not we can handle that .

22

180

( 'i

I hand le tha t d ifferently , and for

Som et ime the requ irement from the

23

governm en t - - from the cust omer is not v ery realistic

24

and,

fo r examp le , you know , they -- som etim es they

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:41

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 183 of 222

r)
.. ---

( '!

('

say, ''Oka '


g, can you detect a person ?''

in thah im age may be only five-by - five p ixels big .

4
5
6

we cannot do this; this is the reason .

and th is

If we thin k the product is feasible r

ho a nalyze the p roduch further .

13

w e r e

The second step is going

Most tim e , I 'm going 1:o come up w ith a

For example , if the object -- if the goal


is ''A ,'' then I need to figure out

you know, how to

do ''A .'' W hat we n eed to do , m aybe , we need to get

15

''B '' a nd ''C '' do wn f i rs t

T HE COURT :

04:42

Excuse me .

17

a l i t t le b it ?

18

trouble keep ing up with you .

Can you slow down

I t h in k t h e c ou rt r ep or t e r i s h a v in g

19

If you'd slow down just a little bit

20

THE W ITNESS :

O kay .

So it 's like the

21

tricks are -- the first tim e is th e goal wo uld b e

22

''A '' but taere 's no way we can jump to ''A I$ We need

23

to get ''B '' and ''(


: '' down fi rs t .

24

04:42

tree structu re .

14

16

04:11

going to be the first step .

12

p e r so n

''

And I also give som e suggestions

going to the second step .

11

Rut the

If this things happen , I wou ld say , ''O kay,

10

f'

181

--.

If we ne6,d to get ''B'' and ''C'' do w n ,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR , RMR

(775) 323-5492

we

04:42

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 184 of 222


.p...

,..-'

1f)g

m i g ht n e ed ''D e' ERn d ''EIr '' th o se th in g s ba s ic a 1 ly and


,

a na lyze these who le th ng s , 1'm go kng to get a tree

st ructu re .

A fter ) get this , I need to further

a naly ze , vou know -- fo r examp le , each note on the

t re e

''B '' ''C '' ''E1 '' ''E '' t h ey a r e a s ub ta s k


:

7
8

i.s a

sub -a lgorjthm .
We need to eva luate whether o r

good a lgorithm to finish that task .

10

basically we 're don e w ith this step

11

con fident we can do th is .

12

04:42

not we have

If we do , hhen
.

W e c an - -

04:43

Next: step , m ost t kme , is 1 'm go ing to

13

w rite a code u sinq a too l , a lanquage called MATLAB


,

14

and the Math -- w ith the MATLAH cod ing p e riod --

15

m aybe , you know , a fber we need -- I need to do each


,

16

eve ry sub functon , test each , every sub function


, t he n

17

comb ine a11 those things toqether

18

the who le th ing m eet ou r goa l .

s e e w h e t he r o r n o t

19

If they do , then I 'm d one .

20

If they don 't , I need to go ba ck and r you

21

22

c4:43

:4:13

kn ow , figu re out wh y .

We do th is back and forth couple t ime s,

23

and after this , 1 'm going to , you know


, p resent the

24

result to my boss, and if m y boss thin k that ; s o kay


,

'

LIZA CHAPEN, CCRZ RMR

..-

(775) 323-5492

. . - -

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 185 of 222

)
f

then next step ts , we try to conve rt thah into a ''C ''

coder C++ code .

And until that step , basicalky t'm going

to alte r my hand -- alter m y hand , 1 on ly responsible

for , you know y the peop le -- depends on algorithm so

the eng ineer can converh hhat to ''C '' code ,

maybe , you know , tbe customer requ ires , you know ,

interface , and tfal no t re spons ibke fo r th at .

RY MR . JA KO PIN :

10

Q.

11
12

A l1 righ t .

an d th e n

You said a 1ot there .

THE COURT : I mean, I don't want to

14

curtail pour exam tnation r but what does a11 this have

15

to do w ith the issues that we 're trying to decid e

16

here ?
MR . JAKO PIN :

to do w ith th e writing o f software , of source code o f

19

eT repp id that spec ifkcakly relates to pattern

20

recogn it ion , to anoma ly detection , and th is is a

21

witness who h as w ritten code that is used fo r that ,

22

and so -THE COURT :

04:44

Well, you r Honor , this has

18

24

04:44

b it b eca use --

13

23

04:44

Why don 't we try to brea k it up a little

17

')

W ell

I th ink it 's on ly fair

for me to tell you , I really d idn 't unde rstand about

LIZA CHAPEN, CCRy RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:44

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 186 of 222


..w.

'v

()

90 percen t. o f what he sa kd , and paEt of tt ts my kac k

o f t rain ing and education in the area that he 's

talking about , and two, pa rt o f it is lanquage and

that 's not an ybody 's fault, bu t --

MR . JA KOPIN :

7
8
9

1 '11 try to brea k it up

THE COURT:

-- I'm just trying to tell you

what I wou ld want to know if I we re in your shoes .


MR . JAKO PIN :

Uh-huh .

We ll, than k you , your Honor .

11

T HE COURT :

parts o f it , if you think 1 need to know about them ,

13

it 's your time : but I'm just simply saying that 1

14

would apprec iate it if you can avoid that y to the

15

extent that you can , and still exp la in to m e what I

16

need to know about w ho se p rope rty this is , how it

17

b ec am e t h e i r p r o pe r t y , wh e n Yt w a s d e v e lo p e d , w h a t

18

about th is patent or th is copyrigh t from 1985: those

19

are the knd s of th ings I 'm go ing to have to decide .


W hat he said here to day , 1, fran kly : I

teli you very honestly do not understand .

22

So , you know --

23

M R . JA KO PIN :

Than k you r you r Honor .

.'

24

04:45

And so , aga in y the technical

12

21

04:45

into --

10

20

184

By MR . Jl yo pzx :

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:45

o4:4s

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 187 of 222


-...
)

1
t
,

You just described steps that you used to

ma ke software at oT repp id , correct?


A.

Ye s .

Q.

And is that source code that is qenerahed

at eTrepp id ?

04:46

A.

Ye s .

Q.

You gene rate one kind of source code idto

what you ca llecl MAT LA B?

A.

Yes, I used MATLAB for to test my ideas .

10

Q.

O kay .

11

A nd then another kind o f sou rce

A.

Yes .

13

Q.

C o r r ec t ?

14

A.

Yes .

15

Q.

Now , is there softw are that you have

16

w ritten at eTrepp Ld that then uses that process to

17

m o v e p a t te r n r e c og n it i o n ?

19

20

A.

wa s related to pattern re cogn it ion .

Q.

Wou ld you describe som e o f the diffe rent

kind s of so ftw are that you wrot e at eTreppid that

22

relates to pattern recognition?

24

04:46

I th in k most o f my -- a lm ost al1 my work

21

23

04:46

code that that is converted to is; called C++?

12

18

1()s

Q.

.....'

A.

For exam ple y face d etection is try ing to ,

you know, detect the face in 1ab video , and also

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:46

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 188 of 222


186
1
(

motion detection .

So i. f someone walk into a, you know , a

restrict zone , and also im age regist ration , if, you

know : the v ideo was taken from a mov ng p latfo rm .

5
6

A 11 those code y actually ,

('

And so registration was one kind of sdurce

code re latin g to pahte rn recogn ition tha t you wrote?


A.

Yes .

10

Q.

A nd sofhware that wou ld detect the face of

11

a person was another kind of source code that you

12

wrote?

13

A.

Ye s .

14

Q.

And then another kind of source code that

15

you wrote relating to pattern recognition wa s fo r

16

m otion dete ct ion?

17

A.

Ye s .

18

Q.

Did you write any source code at eTreppid

A.

Yes, 1 did .

21

Q.

O kay .

23

24

c4:47

04:47

relating to tracking of a vehic le ?

20

22

Q.

19

04:17

respon sible .

7
8

I was

04:47

So those different kinds of sou rce

codes , you would w rite in what was called MATLAB ?


A.

Yeah, the first step -- the first step is

in MATLAB.
=

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 189 of 222


%w;o

* '

18 7

be converted to C+4?
A.

Ye s .

Q.

O kay .

6
7

ls there a kind of app lication that

you eve done at eTrep pid called a nom aly detect ion?
A.

Yes .

June two thou sand -- I think June last yea r .

Q.

A nd what was that?

A.

It 's try to dete ct som ething and --

which

10

not suppo sed to be a certa in -- not supposed to

11

present in a certain image .

13

Q.

see in the p icture ?


A.

Right .

15

Q.

And that's called anomaly detection?

16

A.

Right .

17

Q.

A nd so you wrote source code fo r that at

18

eTrepp id ?

19

A.

Yes ,

20

Q.

Okay .

22

o4:4a

So tt 's something that you don 't expect to

14

21

04:48

There was someth ing T had done in

12

A nd the second step for a1l of tho se could

Q.

I did .

And is that anomaly detection a

form of p attern recognition ?


A.

Yeah .

o4:4a

Anom aly detection can consider only

23

one kind o f patte rn recognition , pattern

24

classification.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCH, RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:4s

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 190 of 222


188

Now , was a lL the wo rk Lhat you have

done while at efpreppid your orfginal work?


A.

Yes .

Q.

Did yo u use any source code that

M r . Montgom ery prov ided you in do ing that work?

A.

A s (ar as I 'm aware , no .

Q.

Okay .

that you w rote ?


A.

Ye s , T thin k so .

10

Q.

W ho repo rts to you on your team at

11

eTrepp id ?

12

A.

13

And do you want the name?


Q.

Yes , p lease .

15

A.

O kay .

''Yum i''

17

Navin , Saurabh , Krishna , M ichael,

Q.

Do certain of those eng ineers w ork on

projects that relate to source code of pattern

19

recognition?

20

23

24

04:49

Suchit a; all th ose engineers rep ort to m e .

18

22

n1:49

A 1l the eng ineer report to me .

14

21

o4:4a

Does eTrepp id own the source cod

16

Okay .

Q.

A.

Yes .

Q.

O kay .

Nav in and Saurabh and K rishna , Yong

M ian .

Do those enginee rs hav e work

stations that they use to save the ir source code on?

A. ves.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:49

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 191 of 222


-.

$
'

Q.

1()9

Do they, then , save source code that

they 've worked typicalty on their machines on a

s e rv e r ?

A.

Yeah , I think so .

Q.

And do you know the name o f that server at

eTrepp id?

A.

I t hink called SRCSERVER o r --

Q.

O ka y .

A.

Yeah , called SRCSERVER .

10

Q.

A re you awa re o f whether the eng inee rs are

Yes .

11

now being ab le to w ork on the sou rce code that is

12

stored on the SRCSERVER?

13
14

15

A.

Q.

Okay.

Any other engineers --

o4:b:

MR . FLYNN : Objection , your Honor;


h ea r s a y .

18

BY MR . JA FO PIN :

19

Q.

-- te lt you their code w as gone ?

20

MR . FLYNN :

Hearsay .

21

TH E COURT :

It is hearsay .

22

Su stained .

24

04:50

That was coup le weeks ago z and Krishna

17

23

n4:ba

told m e hbs cod e was gone .

16

j
..

'.'-

04:5:

BY MR . JA KO PIN :

Q.

Have you been able to access source code

LEEZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 192 of 222


,
.e.l
'

Tha lr, ( cannot -- what I can access is

that directory , b ut othe r people 's wo rk, 1 cannot .

Q.

O kay .

1 can on ly access

Is that directo ry for you something

A.

1 thin k so, but I didn 't t ry that .

Q.

We rt: you invo lved kn loo king for source

cod e that had been deleted at the company?

10

A.

So rry , I d idn 't unde rstand th is question .

11

Q.

We re you involved in loo king for any

12

n4:s1

sou rce cod e that had been deleted at the company ?

13

A.

Oh , no .

14

Q.

O ka y .

15

Did Mr . Montqom ery ever p rov ide you

any source cod e w ritten in MATLAB ?

16

A.

No .

17

Q.

O kay .

04:51

W ere you aw are of M r . M o n tg om e ry

18

ev er p rov iding you a program th at was kn C++ that had

19

been converted from MATLAB?

20

A.

No .

21

Q.

Okay .

'
:4:52

Could you exp la in to the Court the

22

typ e o f instructions that M r . M ontgom ery would give

23

to you for projects?

24

o4:5k

that you can access today on the SRC SERVER ?

A.

'

only there 's a di rectory for me .

fr om th e 65RC S E !kV El14?

1()()

('

'
-

A.

Most time is h e give m e a -- show m e, not

LIZA CHAPFN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 193 of 222


,...X

f'

give me -- show m e a bunch o f image sequence , v ideo

sequen ce , and so , okay , we can see there 's a vehicle

t he r e , we ca n s e e t #1e re 's w a 1 k tn$) pe o p le ove r t h er e .

C a n w e d e t ec t th a t ?

T h a t is - - no rma l1 y t h i s is 1i ke th a t .

Q.

C a n w e t ra c k t ha t .

det e c.t t h a't ?

A.

A s fa r a s I r em em L)e r r

Q.

W a s t ha t s ome t h in q tha t yo u w e re th e n

no .

re spon s ib le fo r , in fa c t , de he rm in in g h ow t o d o it ?
.

11

A.

Y e s , ye s .

12

Q.

And yolz wou ld t he n do that , and f rom t ha t r

13

A.

Ye s .

15

Q.

A nd t he n f rom tha t , t he eng inee rs wou ld

A.

T h a t 's ctor r ec t .

18

Q.

And from that , then , the software f or that

part icular appl icat ion would b e deve loped?

20

A.

Yes .

21

Q.

O k ay .

'
04:sa

An d t h e re w e r e m a n y d i f fe r en t

22

p a t t e rn r e co g n i t io n app 1 ica t io n s t h a t w e re de ve lo pe d

23

in that way?

24

04:s2

t a ke t hat MATLAB s c rip t and p ut i t into C++ ?

17

19

04:52

Y ou wo u ld t he n w r it e you r MATLAR sc r ipt ?

14

16

04 :52

D id i
ne g i ve yo u an y d i r ec t io n on ho w to

10

1(
.)y

('
.

w
-

A. Yes. And almost every one -- I think

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 194 of 222


-.

1g).
,
2

eve ry p iece of app l Lcation , every p iece of code is

done in that way .

3
4

Q.

A nd that would include the one that was

detecting the face o f the person?

A.

Yes .

Q.

A nd the one that was doing the mot ion

n4:s3

detection ?

A.

Ye s .

Q.

And the one that was doing the tracking of

10

'-

a veh icle ?

04:5a

11

A.

Yes .

12

Q.

A s well as the registration process?

13

A.

Yes .

14

M R . JAFO PIN :

15

THE COURT :

Okay .

I have nothing m ore .

M r . Flynn .

04:b3

16
17

18

C R OS S EX A M IN A T IO N

BY MR . FLYNN :

19

Q.

Is it M r . Sun ?

20

A.

Yes .

21

Q.

Dr . Sun .

22
23

(
.

24

Doctor .

o4:5a

Thank you .

You have no type of security cle arance


from the U .S . G overnm ent?

A.

No r 1 clon 't .

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

'

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 195 of 222


193

t
'

Q.

You have -- you 're not a U .S . c itizen?

A.

No.

Q.

Now , let me see if I understand you r

hestimony .

5
6

A'

O kay .

Q.

You were workinq on creating lines o f

10

codes w ith sou rce codes based on som e type o f an


algorihhm technology for facia l recognit ion?

11

A.

Ye s, that 's one of m y tasks .

12

Q.

You were working on creating lines of code

13

with source codes based on algorithms for object

14

trac king ?

15

A.

Yes .

16

Q.

On your own work station?

17

A.

N o , I w o u ld no t sa y t h at , b ec a u s e a s I

18

04:s4

I do pa rt o f that wo rk and m y group do


part of t hat work .

04:s4

21

Q.

A nd you never worked w ith M r . Montgomery ?

22

A.

What do you m ean b y that?

23

Q. But he never -- from what I just heard --

24

94:b4

exp lained before , that actually is a teamw ork .

19
20

04:53

too , but 1et me see if 1 can unde rstand .

t
.

1 had 8t little hard t im e followint; it,

He was my boss .

Maybe I m isundersto od some th ing .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 196 of 222


...)

A-

Uh -h u h .

Q.

He never gave you anything for you to do

A.

I don 't th ink 1 understand


04:55

The th ings -- part of m y work is like he


gave to m e , 1et m e do that .

Q.

Wh at d id he g ive you?

A.

It 's like , most tim e there 's a rad io

10

sequence --

04:55

11

Q.

W ell --

12

A.

-- and 1et m e do it .

13
14

O kay, you know , there 's a video sequence ,


and can you do th is?

15

Things like that .

16
17

Q.

04:s5

I thoug ht you said that he d idn 't g ive you

a n y th in g bh at y ou n ee d ed to do y ou r w o r k .

18

Maybe I m isunderstood th at .

19

A.

20

b ecause it 's like

21

okay , we hav e, you know , video sequence , can we track

22

this p erson ?

23

I 'm con fused .

your question .

6
7

yggjt)

the work vou just described?

f
.

-....

24

Oh , wh at I m ean is , in the level algorithm


any people can ask me , let 's say,

Can we , you know , de tect th is person?

This m ost o f the time , th is is Denn is 1et

me do .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

04:55

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 197 of 222

...y
1
f

Q.

That 's where 1 th ink 1 want ho get .

A l1 -- you did it by yourself?

A.

Parll o f that: yes , I did by myself .

Q.

So you got you r own source codes?

A.

Oh , yes, l th in k that 's true .

Q.

Right now, you lve got you r own sou rce

A.

weeks ago , but now I think part of m y code also

11

m issing .

12

Q.

What part is missing?

13

A.

For example, the anomaly detection , 1

04:56

thin k 1 don lt see that any mo re in m y computer .

15

T hat was talking about maybe a couple

10

Q.

Is that som ething that 's not -- the

16

anom a ly detectg
ion software that 's no longer in your

17

co m p u t e r , i s i t so m et h in g yo u c rea t e d ?

18

A.

Ye s, I d id .

19

Q.

In the last few w eeks, have you rec reated

20

04:s6

codes for a l1 the w or k you pve done ?

14

1:(5

So you created your own source codes .

.. .

it?

04:56

04:56

21

A.

N o , not. yet .

22

Q.

You can recreate it?

23

A.

Ye s, I can .

24

How lon g will it ta ke you ?

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 198 of 222


..x.
1

A.

1 re a l ly - - 1 r e a ll y d o n 't kn ow , be c a us e

My wo rk is , in the algorithm level, is

like , 1 do some p totecting and get the algorithm

down .

algor ithm .

The actual sou rce code is d iffe rent from the

7
8

if I 1m con fident we can do this, wh ich mean s 1 'm

con fident w e can find algorithm to do that .


The actual codin g actually fo r some other

11

eng ineers , 1 mean, C ++, not in the MATLAB .

12

a ve ry high level source cod e .

13

it's --

14

It 's like a --

C an I use an example here?

Q.

Su re .

16

A.

Okay .

17

Q.

I 'm just trying to get edified, and I

o4:sv

believe the judge is trying to get educated, too.

19
20

G o ahead .
A.

O kay .

MA TLAB is like , fo r examp le, is

21

just a tool and let's say if I want to build a house,

22

the MATLA B m aybe have som e, you know , bu ild ing

23

b locks, lsuke w indow s, foundation .

24

O4:b7

MATLAB is

15

18

04:57

A lgorithm is like a high level th ing and

10

1:6

that depends on -- thks is only part of the things.

If 1 want test my design, just in -- pull

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

04::7

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 199 of 222


x.x
.y9:

('

that p artkcula r window , pull that particular

foundation, pull them together, see whether or not

hhat is good , and the th ings r you know , if in com e

the ''C '' code , people have to actually bu ild that

window .

04::8

6
7

know , some tim e .

MA TLA R cod e done , m aybe , you know r in couple weeks,

but I rea Lly don 't know how soon they can d o the ''C H

10

11
12

Th at itself m iqht take, you know , I don 't

13

code .

04:b8

Q.

A. That algorithm?
Yo u 're talking about the MAT LAR or are you

talking about ''C '' code ?

04:58

16

Q.

Wh at you we re working on .

17

A.

M A T LA B .

18

;'
1.

How m any lines o f code make up -- how many

lines of code m ake up an algorithm ?

14

15

Tha t 's why, you know, I can get the

Th at is not very big ; ma ybe , you know ,

19

coup le hundred .

20

Q.

Okay .

21

A.

A t this m om ent ?

22

Q.

Ye s .

23

A.

T th in k I m ight h ave .

24

Do you have those lines of code?

I really don tt --

I m not sare ab out that .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCRZ RMR

(V75) 323-5492

c4:sB

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 200 of 222


,.e
i

('

Q.

W e l 1.. 14a v e y ou (Dhe (7ked ?

A.

W h a t?

Q.

Have you checked to see w hether you have

1:g

these lines o f code that make up the algorithms that

you worked on ?

A.

04:59

In m y machine -- what I m ean , in my

machine I don n l thin k I have , but I think lat year

my m ach ine got c loned couple times .

10

11

..,

I real Ly don 't know whethe r o r not they

still hav e that code in those clone d isk .

Q.

o4:5a

So fn the last -- have you been looking

12

fo r th ese lines o f code on this algo rithm for the

13

last few weeks?

'

14

A.

No , be(
.na us e
I w as o :1 v a c a t i. o n .

15

Q.

So you don 't know whether anything is

16

A.

I --

18

Q.

It could still be at eTreppid .

19

A.

ln last several days , m y eng ineer to ld me

the ir code wa s gon e .

21

M y code --

22

MR .

23
1.

m issing o r not?

17

20

24

04:59

o4:s9

FLYNN: I object and move to strikez

your Ho nor .
T H E c OU RT :

T h at 1s a 11 r i gh t -

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 201 of 222


....
,
.

MR .

THE COMRT :

His eng ineer told him .

That's a11 right .

I 'm n o t

goinq to consider it for the truth o f jt , but go

ahead .

BY MR . FLYNN :

n4:5a

Q.

M r . Sun, what we 're trying to find out --

A.

Uh -huh .

Q.

-- is anything that you created , o n e , yo u

can re create r correct ?

10

A.

Oh ,

11

Q.

A nd two , anything that you created , a s o f

yes .

04:59

12

the m om en tz we don 'h know whether it ls the re r o r w e

13

don't know based on your personal knowledge?

14
15

16

A.

18
19

1 thin h , ba sed on m y personal know ledge I


,

th in k it 's not there .

Q.

17

('
i

FLYHN :

19g)

'v'

......-

os:no

Now , dc) you know how many types -Do y o u kn ow a n yt h in g ab o u t th e q ov e rnm e n t

cont racts at all?


A.

No : I don 't because I 'm no t supposed to ,

20

you know , ask anything there .

21

the thing s m y b oss 1et me to do .

It's like, I just do

22

Q.

So in terms of, say, object tracking --

23

A.

Uh-huh .

24

Q.

-- do you know how many components of

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

os:oo

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 202 of 222


.-

object tracking e'lreppid was involved in, some having

to d o with governm ent contracts, some having nothing

to do with governm ent contracts?

A.

A s L said before, no , 1 don 't know about

that .

Qs::Q

Q.

Did you bac k up your work station ?

A.

A ctual ly , m y -- first, m y cmputer is not

a work station and 1 didn 't back up ; the company back

up .

10

1 don 't have anywhere to b ack up .

11

Q.

O kay .

12

A.

Yeah .

13

Q.

Where fs the -- have you checked the

14
15

05:00

The com pany backed it up ?

backup that the com pany did on you r work product?


A.

That out of my hand .

I 'm not allow ed to

16

do that , because basically what w as -- what I

17

r e sp o n s i b le i s th e a lgo r i thm in t h o se l e ve l , a n d

18

whether or not they -- how they b ack up the software ,

19

which I don 't know .

20

Q.

W as Patty Gray ever on your compute r?

21

A.

What do you m ean b y ''on m y computer''?

22

2()o

%r.

Use my com puter or --

23

Q.

Yes , w ithout your perm ission ?

24

A s rar as z ,m aware , no .

L'
.EZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

:s:ol

ns:ol

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 203 of 222


.,..
.r
2()k
1
t

S in c e f yo u know , I (io h a v e a s h a re d
d ir e c to r y , t ha t 's fo r su r e .

3
4

Q.

m is sing r ight now --

A.

a t that t ime , I was in hosp ita l, coup le people work

unde r me call me .

MR. FLYNN: Well, I object and move to


stri ke , your Hono r.
THE WITNESS :

11

M R . FLYNN :

Okay .

Buh Jet them bring them in if

THE COURT: I'm going to hear the

14

evidence .

15

weight I think t 's entit led to .

16

M R . FLYNN :

18

0s:o2

they --

13

17

There 's not a jury here.

1'11 give it the


05:02

Okay .

B Y M R . FL Y N N :

Q.

19

Let me a sk you this , sir .


If you th ink there 's something m issing

20

that you need , in the last two wee ks: have you made

21

any effort to go get it?

22

05:01

T he y s a y - -

10

12

I th in k we know something m issnq , because

Since '
ae don 't know if there 's anything

A.

A s I said be fore , I was on vaca tion last

23

coup le wee ks .

My d aughter was born 9th o f Janua ry .

24

I was on vacatLon.

LEZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:02

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 204 of 222


.....

Q.

A . Tha;k 'gou .

Q.

5
6

7
8
9

O ka y .

' 'r

zg:

C o ng ra tu 1a t .io n s o n yo u r d au (Jh te r .
.

Rut in the next few weeks , do you know of

any rea sor. why you ca nnot go find it?

A.

I thin k I m ight want to try , but I rea lly

ns:02

don 't knou whether or not f can find that .

Q.

So as of today ts date , fr purpo ses of

this hearing , you don 't know ?


A.

No .

10

MR . FLYNN :

Thank you .

11

THE COURT :

Red irect?

12

MR . JA KOPIN :

13

THE COURT:

14

MR . JAKQPIN :

15

MR . FLYNN :

Yes z your Hono r .

16

THE COURT ;

You m ay step down .

17

Y o u tr e ex c u s ed .

18

THE W ITNE SS :

19

(W itness excused .)

20

THE COURT :

21

Step forward , sir , and be sworn first .

22

THE W ITNE SS :

23

(The wtness was sworn .)

24

THE COURT: Thank you

05:02

No , your Honor .

May this witness be excused?


Yes .
0st03

T h an k y ou f o r c om i ng .

Okay .

Call your next witness .

Okay .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

0s:o3

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 205 of 222

...y

.v

203

11F1H DA LL A . ROM AN ,

ca11ed as a witne:5s, having been first duly sworn,

1 e/5t if ie d a s fo 11ow s :

5
6

7
8

9
10

l1

oblq

BY MR . JAIIOPIN :

Q.

W ou .
Ld yo u st at e and sp e 11 you r n ame r

p le a se .

A.

K en d a 1 l A . Ro man .
MR . FI,YNN :

Your Hono r , ma yb e it Would be

I b e lj ev e th i s is th e e xp e rt .

13

this poin t in p roceeding , let 's -- it 's su ch a waste

14

of time to do an expert .

1 th in k, a t

I would aubmit, if we just put Mr. Trepp

ns:n4

16

and Mr. Montgomery on the witness stand, for judicial

17

e ff i c ie n c y , c u t t h ro u g h a l l o f th is s tu f f a n d q e t t o

18

the bottom of this .

19

W e h ave not been disclosed who he is, any

20

in fo rm ation about h im .

21

put an expert on , on the eurrent state , foundational

22

state o f the re cord , is p urposeless .

23

24

05:04

quicker for me to put my objection in now .

l2

15

D (RRCT EXAMINAT 1ON

THR COURT :

We 've been given noth ing .

To

Wellr I don lt kn ow what he 's

going to say and so, I mean, it's just like the --

'
LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

ostos

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 206 of 222

....r

1
4'

you know , ''I ob je(:t..''

''W h ctt ':; yo u r g rou n d s ? ''

''I 1nl no t g o i.ng t o te l1 y ou .''

I cl()n '1. kn ow w he th e r h e ha s so m e th ing to

say that will be he Lpfu to the Court or not .

or may not, and so I can 't just arbitrarily restrict

eithe r side from putt ing som ebody on the w itn ess

stand becau se of their statu s as a 1ay w itness ,

expert w itness , whatever .

10
11

(
,

He may

Let 's go a lttle bit and we 'll see

Wel l: let 's put it this way .

13

CounsekF can you telt me what he 's going

15
16
17

MR. JAKOPIN : Yes, the subject matter is

0s:n5

background to expla tn to the Court about source code .


It 's tc) show he 's had conversations with

variou s em ployees at the company , and in his own

19

language to explain what it is that h as occurred at

20

the compa ny, and to then be able to p rovide to the

21

Court h is op in ion on the dam age that has occur red as

22

a result of what has been de leted .

24

05:05

to -- what's the subject matter going to be?

18

23

05:0b

w hat --

12

14

204

THE COURT :

A 11 righ t .

We ll r let 's take

it a step at a time.

L3ZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:06

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 207 of 222


'-J
. ze
205
1

BY MR . JAKOPIN :

Q.

4
5

backg round since high schoo) , please .


A.

Yes .

I have a Rachelo r 's Degree in

com puter science grom Rrigham Young University , 1982 ,

and that deg ree included b0th hardware and software

databases and inter-computer communications , which is

called netwo rking .

Q.

Do you have any experien ce w ith v arious

11

different languages thak are u secl for source code

12

programming ?

13

A.

Yes .

num erous zanguages, including the one s at issue in

15

this casey C++ .

16

Q.

A re you familiar with different compute r

hardw are p latfo rm s?

A.

Yes, I am .

19

Q.

A nd how about different computer software

p latfo rms?

os:07

21

A.

Yes .

22

Q.

Is there an area o f your exp ertise that

23
24

05:06

os:cv

18

20

05:06

l 've studied and programmed in

14

17

/
''

Can you give me you r educational

10

t'

Let 's Hee where we qo with it .

relates tc computer forensic s?


A.

Yes .

Fo r t he 1 as t six y e a rs : I 'v e b ee n

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 208 of 222


*M
v
206

doing expe rt w itness consulting , as well as regular

business consutting , and a 1ot of that work has been

as a computer fo rensic expert .

I 've w orked on eases fo r the government

where I 've don e data recovery: in par ticular r video .

I w as hired b y the State o f California to

recov er video from security cam eras at one of th eir

correct ion al fac izities, and l 've testi fied regard ing

tha t forensic recovery process and also the analysis

10

I 've done of the recovered data .

11

os:o8

I 've also wor ked on cases for the

12

Departmen t of Defense , particula rly the Depa rtment of

13

the N avy r as a defense expe rt .

14
15

05::7

Q.

Have you worked on technolog ies relating

to what w e 've h eard today as softw ar e comp re ssion ?

nstoq

''

16

Yes .

i 've been working w ith , in

17

p articu larr audio and video comp ression for over a

18

decade .

19

I have a number of pend ing patents in the

20

area of v ideo comp ression, v ideo t ransm ission , and I

21

bav e an FDA app roved m edical device that T wa s the

22

p rima ry invento r and developer of .

23

A.

24

Q.

And h ow about with resp ect to pattern

recognition? Do you have background with pattern

LIZA CHAPENZ CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

0s:08

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 209 of 222


z .d
.z '
v
>*
2()J
1

2
3

recogniticn ?

A.

broad -- a b road scope .

A 11 data compression, at som e .level, is

loo king fc r patterns o f materia l that can be stored

in a m ore e ffityient way .

to loo k fcr a ser ies of zero es in a row and rep lace

that serie s of zeroes with a number that rep re sents


that run length of ze roes .

11
12

a lm o st an y comp ression algorithm .

Theru

there ls this m ore speci fic pattern

14

recognition where we 're loo king fo r a face o r an iris

15

or th inqs like that , and that kind o f patte rn

16

recogniticn has just come to the forefront in the

17

last few years .

18

j'

os:oa

There fs pattern recoqnit ion bu ilt into

13

19

os:ng

A very sim ple way of doing comp ression is

10

4
:
'
,

Welk, pattern recognition has kind of a

MR . JAKOPIN :

05:09

1 'd like to tende r him , your

Honor r a s an expert .

20

THE COURT :

21

Go ahead .

22

M R . JAKOPIN :

23

BY MR . JAKO PIN :

24

I fm satisfied .

A 11 right .

Than k you .

Gettinf) b ack to source code , could you

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

ns:o9

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 210 of 222


'
', '.>n'
'v
2()g
'

--

.- -

exp la in to the Gogrt how source code is used b y the

computer?

A.

Ye s .

Computers run programs , basically

that 's what they 're designed to do 4 and the computer

program is simp ly a series of inst ructkon s for the

computer to execu te .

the com puter what to do, we could w rite the

instruct ions at a very 1ow lev ely which is called

10

mach ine languaqe ; zeroes and ones that you 've heard

11

abou t .

05:10

Bu t that 's very tedious , and so what we 've

13

don e is we 've written these hiqher level languages

14

like C++ that actually use Eng lish w ords , and you can

15

put comm ents and various other ways o f m aking it mo re

16

unde rstand able for the hum an being .

17

Qs:1Q

In order for the hum an programm er to tell

12

.-

('

05:1q

So as .
4 programmer , we , in th e text file ,

18

just like writtnq a letter, we write in the speciak

19

language -- it m igh t be MATLA B or it might be C++ o r

20

Java or one of these other languages -- and it 's just

21

an e lectro nic document that has a series of

22

instructions w ritten in the h igh level language , and

23

as a -- a s Sloan testified , there 's a comp iling that

24

takes these source code files and compiles them into

L.EZA CHAPFN, CCRy RMR

(775) 323-5492

n5:zl

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 211 of 222


.
'
209

object code and ltbraries, which then a11 get

com piled together to form the executab le p rogram .

A n d s o w he n w e t a l k a b ou t so ftw are , we

u sually td lk ab out the sou rce cocle fo r the proqram ,

a s w ell as the interm ed iate files and the

executables .

Do you have an understand ing ,

based upon you r conversations with d ifferent people

at eT reppjd , as to what sou rce code files were to be


deleted at the company?

os:11

11

MR . FLYNN:

1 object, your Honor.

12

THE COURT :

I 'm sorry?

13

MR . FLYNN: I object, your Honor.

14

THE COURT :

Hearsay?

15

MR . FLYNN :

Yes .

16

MR . JA KOPIN :

17

A 11 right .

10

Q.

n5:11

os:ll

He 's an e xpert, your Honor .

He can reqy on th ings that are not --

18

THE COURT :

Well, I think you --

19

MR . LOGAR :

Only as foundational .

20

THE COURT :

If you 're going to be

21

technical , I think you have to 1ay the foundation

22

th at these are the types of things upon which he

23

would ordnarily rely in the practice o f his

24

profession outside of the courtroom .

L'
(ZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

Os:12

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 212 of 222


.
21f)
.,. ,
;
. .,.. .
1

MR . JA HQ PIN :

That 's fine .

BY MR . JAFOPIN:

Q.

ln order to make a determ inat ion that

file s have been dttleted at a facility , what would you

norma lly do ?

A.

05:12

Well, Lt 's an industry be st practice to

have some type o f source code contro l system or a way

o f b ac king up you r so ftware .

Computers are machines and hhey b reak

10

dow n , and the storage m edium such as m agnetic disks

11

can actually decay over tim e, and so ev ery software

12

com pany l 've been invo lved in has some typ e of

13

repository wh ere they sto re their so ftware , and the

14

software js usualty organized by projects and there 's

15

lim ited access and there 's some type of tracking .

05:12

j.'

16

A nd so when I wa s b rought into this case ,

17

I specifically as ked the d irector o f R&D and Dr . Sun

18

what software methodo logy W as b eing u sed in this

19

case .

20

In m y first startup company , I actu ally

21

was the manager o f p rocessing con tro ls and tools and

22

I pu t such p rocesses in place , and then th roughout my

23

career, I 've been the CTO , chie f techno logy officer,

24

and in that posltion, I was the one responsible for

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:13

os:13

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 213 of 222


211
.- )
w ;
,
1

making su re ou r so ftware wa s secure .

So o IRe o f t14e f i rst que s t io n s I a s ke d the

employees was , ''Dict you have such an industry

standard Boftwace contro l proced ure?''

lnt ta Lly, they d id , b ut unde r

M r . Montg omery 's direction , they set up th is other

system that 's not an indu st ry standard m ethodology,

and that system wa s the SRC SERVER .

/
.

And on the SRCGERVER we re num erous

10

directorkes for the subprojects in the ET Latest, so

11

that wa s the eTrepp id Latest sou rce code .

12

Q.

A 1J righ t .

13

A.

And then also they had a work in proqress,

14

17

THE COURT :

Let m e interrupt you for a

Ob:t4

second .
What I'm conce rned ab out is , if you were

18

h ired simp ly to go to eT reppid and look at their

19

comp uters; to determ ine wh ether o r not something had

20

been de leted , outside o f the con text of litigation ,

21

would you r in that proces s, spe ak to pe op le wh o

22

worked the re and rely upon what they told you in

23

order to p ractice your profession ?

24

05:14

which wa s th e ET programm e rs .

15
16

05:13

THE WITNESS: Yes, I would.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

os:l4

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 214 of 222

7i
-)

#Y*1
i

;12

THE COU RT :

MR. FLYNN: Your Honor, may T ask one voir

I im go ing to allow it .

d ire ?

THK COURT :

Ye s, sir .

95:14

8
9
10
11

12

BY M R . FLYNN :

Q.

In the practice of you r profession , would

you first go to the chief tech nical o fficer of the


comp any irt o rder to fulfill Lh at function?
A.

In pract ice , you don bt always -- depends

In pract ice , you don n l a lw ays go to the

14

chief technology o fficer first , bu t in a small

15

com pany l ike th is , I would have go ne to the director

16

of deve lopm ent or CTO .

17

Q.

And that , o f course , Ys M r . M ontqom ery ?

18

A.

We ll , the d irector o f R &D is who I talked

20

o5:1s

to , and that was , I believe , Sloan .

Q.

Bu t the chie f technica l o fficer o f the

21

com pany , particularly w ith regard to this d ifferent

22

security cletect ion system , was M r . Montgome ry ; isn 't

23

that correct?

24

0b:14

on the si z:e o f the organization .

13

19

V ()1.R D IR E EX A M IN A T ION

A.

My understanding is that he had left the

LIZA Ci1APEN ? CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

os:15

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 215 of 222


,
'
'- .)
.. ,
)
2 13
.

('

company a qd was not -- not on site .

Q.

So you never talked to h im ?

A.

That 's correct .

going to hear from M r. Montqom ery, w ithout him having

spo ken to M r . M ontgom ery about what happen ed here r

which I b elieve is going to becom e perfectly clear to

the Court in five m inutesr th is is a11 useless

test im ony .

11
12

THF COURT :

Well , you see , I can 't -- I

14

testimony , then we ll move on and the n I f11 make that

15

evaluatio a.

Let m e hear the

0s:16

I just -- you know, as I'm sure you know,

17

I 'm sure gou 're very experienced and you know that

18

as -- I mean, I knew as a law yer when I came in that

19

the judge and the jury really didn 't get it when they

20

first wal ked in , and I 'm te lling you , I 1m in the

21

p rocess o g gett ing it , but I don 't quite get it yet .

23

24

o5:ls

It seem s to m e that the foundation has

been laid for this testimony .

22

nb:ls

can 't m ak e that determ ination .

13

16

Your Honor, I -- if you 're

10

('

M R . FLYNN :

So I fm going to 1et these people develop


their case and 1 '11 let you do the sam e thing .

If we have to go a little late to do that ,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:16

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 216 of 222


..'.
-

''
.-?

214

w e '1 1 do it .
.

Go ERl
nead .

4
5

6
7
8

9
10
'11

CONT ft1t;E D D 1RECT HXAM IN AT 1ON


BY M R . JA 3:0 P IN t

Q.

D o yo u h av e a n un d e rs ta n cii n g o f w ha t

so u r ce c o cLe h a (1 b e e n de1 e te d a t: th e comp an y ?


A.

A s I m('n t ioned be fo z'e , the re 's t h is ET

L a t e st , w h ic h k s 1)he la te st wo r k 5ng v e r s io n o f t h e
so u r ce c o (je , wh ic h wo u ld b e th e C + + code , a nd t h e

12

prog re s s c ode y wh ich wa s in th e ET p rog ramm e rs o r ET

13

development directory .

My understanding is that the majority of

1$

tho se directories -- the directorie s w ere st ill

16

there , bu t the -- or at least some o f the d irectories

17

are still the re, but the files themselves , t he s o u rc e

18

code files and the execu tab le files h ad a11 been

19

dele ted .

20
21

MR . FLYNN:

Objection to everything after,

''My unde rstan ding .''

22

Hearsay, lac ks foundation .

23

THE COURT :

24

ob:16

lib rarie s , and the n t he re wa s a 1so t h e w o r k in

14

0b:16

I p revio usly ind icated I lm

going to allow that testimony on the grounds that

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:17

05:17

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 217 of 222


.

'-. j

it 's som ethinq upon which he could reasonab ly rely as

an expert . I'kk gve it the weight I think it 's

entitled to .

Go ahead .

THE W ITNESS :

m ea sure L 3 the number o f giqabytes .

The other quant ifiab le

bytes is CA m egabyte , a billion byte s is a g igabyte


,

and then a trillion b yte s is terabyte .


A nd so on the various servers , there were

11

terab ytes of data and -- wh ich ks extreme ly large for

12

a sma ll software company to have , and on those

13

teraby te servers : there w ere , I think, around 120

14

gigabytes of data , which is a karge amount of sou rce

15

code .

05:17

05:18

16

MR . FLYNN :

17

T H E W IT N E SS :

18

nb:1v

A thousand b ytes is a kilobyte , a m illion

10

I beg your pardon , w hicb is -A la r g e a m o u n t o f so u rc e

code .

19

;?).5

r>....j

M R . FLYNN :

20

BY M R . JA KOPIN :

21

Q.

Thank you .
Os:1a

Now, do you have an opinion as to -- do

22

you hav e an understanding that the source code h as

23

not been availab le for the eng ineers to be w orking

24

with at the present tlme?

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 218 of 222


<.,e
...- :
1
226
1
1

A.

process of events that happened between December 21st

and Janua ry 10th , the ind iv idua l p rogrammers ' work

statkons nad h ad their h ard dr ives w iped out and

zeroed , w nich m akes; it very d ifficult to recove r, if

not im pos sible .

attempting to recover some o f that da ta , but they 're

only reco zering bits and p iece s and that process


hasn 't bee n comp leted .

11

05:19

A nd then there also was th is RA ID se rve r

12

that was za ken out , physically taken out of the

13

building , and m y unde rstand inq is th at has not been

14

returned .

15

MR . FLYNN: Same objection .

16

I know you fve alread y ruled y your Honor,

17

but just rzo preserve the record .

18

THE COURT :

19

05:19

The SRCS;KRVER had been era sed , and they 're

10

:45, understandinq is that through the

Yes .

05:19

The record Will reflect your

continuinq objection --

20

MR . FLYNN :

Thank you , your Honor .

21

THE COURT :

-- if you want to do it that

22

way .

23

BY MR . JA KOPIN :

24

Q.

A re you aware that there 's a recovery

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:19

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 219 of 222


... xj
xw -j
2I-/
1

A.

Yes .

Q.

While that recovery p rocess is onqoing , dc)

the engineers have the ab ility to work w ith that

source code tha t has been recovered ?

A.

access to those machines because they dve been taken

o ff the netw ork .

Q.

A nd evelu

then , ultim ately i f only a

10

certain p ercentage of source code is recovered , is --

11

let 's say 30 pe rcent o f the sou rce code is

12

recovered -- w ou ld that imp ly that 30 percent of the

13

effort is recovered, as well?


A.

05:20

I've worked on projects wherey let 's say,

15

there 's a hund red file s, and because o f a hard d isk

16

failu re , som e o f those file s could no t be re cove red .

17

Fizling in the m issing pie ce s can be v ery

18

time -con sum ing .

19

to a starting point wh en I 've lost files in the past ,

20

even fo r a very small case .

21

ns:ta

The short answe r is no w they don 't have

14

p rocess go tng on Lrying to recover th is sou rce code?

os:2o

It h as taken m e m onths to get back

us:2o

It lite rally to ok m any months of being

22

able to figu re out wha t was -- first of all , what 's

23

m iss ing ; second of all, trying to recreate that , and

24

especially difficult if the employees who wrote that

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 220 of 222


!*zW :
r
218
i
* 'Q
.

so fhware Ln the first place eithe r forgot , b e c au s e

they dkd kt a year ago, or worse case, theyfve left

the company and so the peop le w ho d id the o riginal

work are not ava ilable to recreate it

So in thts case , whe re the re 's been a

large amount of source code deleted and just

fragments of it b eing recovered , it could easily take

man yea Es o f e ffo rt to get b ac k to a point whe re the

company could be as productive as they we re on

11

December ;h1st .

Q.

05:21

G iven that the com pany has been creat kng

12

source code for seven years w ith nume rous employees

13

would it L)e your opin ion that that 's a substantial

14

amount of source code to h ave to rec reate?

15

A.

16

17

Y es .

MR . JA KO PIN :

I hav e noth ing further for

th is w itness at th is t kme , y o u r Ho n o r .

18

TH E COURT :

Do you have any questions?

19

MR . FLYNN :

Just a coup le .
:::22

21
22

ps:2l

20

05:21

10

CRO SS EXAM INAT ION


BY MR . FLYNN :

23

Q.

Do you have a secu rity clearan ce , M r . --

.
24

A. I do nc)t

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 221 of 222


:.-.,.
w.
219
.,
)

Q.

a11 the hitrd d rives?

3
4

A.

ab le to do tha ty amount of work .

Q.

How long have you been re tained ?

A.

I was first t
nontacted Thu rsday o r Friday .

Q.

How much have you been paid so far?

A.

N othlng .

Q.

How much are you go ing to get paid fo r

your testimon y here?


A.

The --

12

Q.

What 's the deal?

13

A. Oh, I'm being paid by the hour.

14

Q.

H ow much?

15

A.

Three-ninety an hour is th e rate we charge

Q.

How many hours hav e you pu t in so far ?

18

A.

I would say less than 40 .

19

Q.

So you hav en 't checked an y of the hard

d rives .

ns:22

21
22
23

24

95:22

the client .

17

20

os:22

0s:22

11

16

I ve not been retained long enough to be

10

And did you actually go check p ersona lly

Do you know how many hard d rives there


are ?
A.

I know that there ls a -- I know that there

are 14 programmers,

each of those p rogramme rs have

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-19 Filed 05/28/08 Page 222 of 222

(-.,j

two to hh ree m achirres, and som e of those m achines

have multtple drives, so they have operahing system

drives and then renlovable --

Q.

We re you in the courtroom --

A.

-- p rogram drives .

Q.

W ere you in the courtroom when

220

:b:23

Mr . Venab tes sa id that 80 percent o f the so ftw are is

still on the com ptlters?

A.

I don 'h thin k 1 was in he re at that

10

particu la r moment, but I know like the ope rating

11

system is sti ll there .

12

... )

13
14
15

It 's the source code that 's been de leted .

Q.

So urce code of ''it z'' buh you do n t know

what the 'it '' is yet e ither , do you ?


A.

We ll, the source code of each p rogrammer 's

16

w ork , and each of the programm ers is wor king on

17

d ifferent com ponents .

18
19
20
21

Q.

05:23

Bas ically , all you dv e done today is parrot

wha t the employees hav e already told you ?


A.

W ell , I also b ring the light that I have

of understand ing the technology and --

22

Q.

Understand ing --

23

A.

-- what goes into the so ftware developm ent

('

24

05:23

process , and also what is industry standard procedu re

LIZA CiIA PEN, CCR: RMR

(775) 32 3-5492

05:23

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 1 of 65

..')
-

..

- -.

,w

221
.

for p rese rving sou rce code , a nd th e n a tso th e

forensic data recovery aspects of the case.

Q.

assum ing riles are gone or deleted -- it kind of has

that intent kon ality context that som eone snuck in and

files are no longex there : for whatever reason .

if som e in ternal clev ice in the comp uter , intru sion

detection device de stro yed the files : as opposed to

11

som eone g oing n and som ehow de let ing them ?


A.

I 've done a 1ot of work r specifically

forensic -related wo rk to -- recovering deleted files

13

and the re are -- eve ry b yte of data p otentially can

14

b e a trace of in fo rmation r and so when w e 're talking

15

abou t b illions and trillions o f b yte s of data

16

are a larre number o f traces .

17

s:21

12

os:zs

So when l go in Lo do fo rensic analysis ,


I 'm loo king for in fo rm ation that 's stored in the

19

compute r, o r T 'm a tso looking at how the in form at ion

20

has been alte red , when it 's be en altered , and I am

21

ab le to recon struct what happened in num erous

22

situations .

24

the re

18

23

:5:24

A re you ab le to d iffere ntiate the reasons

10

A re you able , as an e xp e r t , t o d e te rm i ne ,

So if t here wa s a p rogram that deleted the

file, on there w izl be a trace .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

os:2s

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 2 of 65


....
rw )
222
1

lf tt was deleted by a part icular

individuat, tbere may be a log entry that shows that

ndividua t logg ing in .

the re actually have been histo ry of the commands that

we re entered , and so in som e of the cases w here I 've

gone in to do th is fo ren sic wo rk , I actua lly was able

to identi fy wh o logged in , which m achine they logqed

in from , an d t he actua l command s th ey used to delete

10

11
12

There aze -- I've worked on cases where

13

the files .

Q.

ob:25

os:26

But he re you haven 't b een around long

enough to do th at yet?

A.

That ds correct.

14

MR.

15

THE COURT :

FL YNN :

Than k you .

Any further w ith this w itness?

05:26

16
17

REDIRECT EXAM INA TION

18

BY MR . JAKO PIN :

19

Q.

20

detection device .

21

C oun se l had m entioned an intrusion


0::26

A re you aware of so ftw are compan ies who fve

22

deve loped source code p utting dev ices on that source

23

cod e to then destroy it?

24

It 's a very common practice to develop a

LFZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 3 of 65


.i
a.
-. )
,
223

fire wall , b0th ha rdware and so ftwa re , that detects

intrusion onto a network and we've heard some

testim ony about that z that there 's this Cisco router

tha t has Lim its o f what com es in , and w hen it detects

an intrus ton, ih achually loqs i : and bloc ks it .

Tha t is alm ost un iversal in comp anies that

are connected to the Internet .

8
9

0s:26

Th is concept of u sing an int rusion device


to des hroy the company fs assets is a very unusual

10

thing , and usually the CTO or the p eople in charge

11

wou td be resp onsible for m aintain ing the comp any 's

12

source cocle assets .

13

05:27

And so something that would delete the

14

only copy that the company had would b e reckless and

15

very costly to the company .

16

MR . JAKOP JN :

17

MR . FLYNN :

0s:a7

Than k y()u .

One m ore th ing s th en .

18

19
20

21
22
23
f'

24

RECRO SS EXA M INAT ION


BY MR . JA KOPIN :

Q.

:s:27

Have you ever wo rked for a company where

the governm ent o rdered that type of a sy stem ?


A.

No , I have not .
MR

FLYNN :

It se em s very unu sual .

Th ank you .

LIRA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(77b) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 4 of 65


...t..j
22 (
. ,
l

/
(

T H E CO U FT :

W itness may be

excused .

(Witness excused.)

M R . PEE F :

Y o u r H on o r , I 'm going to

proffer an a ffidavit from the United States Air Force

in which -

M r . Flynn , where Mr . Hennessy, who g ives the

affidav it . savs that, ''I understand that

M r . Montgom ery has stated that certain governmental

o fficials requ ire that eTreppid put into p lace a

11

security p roto col that would cause eTreppid source

12

codes to be'' -- ''source code to be autom atically

13

deleted if anyone attempted to access it improperly .

14

To the best o f my know ledge y no A ir Force official

15

requires such a security protocot .

''

available by telephone ff there 's an objection at al1

18

to this a ffidavit .

19

MR . FLYNN:

23
24

os:28

The only objection we have,

w e -- I th ink t should be sea led .

21
22

05:2:

I unde rstand that M r . Hennessy m ay be

17

20

05:27

I th ink it addresses this issue ra ised b y

10

16

1%
l..

A 11 r ig h t .

MR . PEEK :

W ell y w e filed it sealed , your

Hon or .
MR . FLYNN :

W e would be stuck w ith a

w ai ve r i s s;u e .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR? RMR

(775) 323-5492

ns:28

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 5 of 65

(*e*')

(w
.

knowledge

We don 't doubt that the Air Force has no

knowledge

The Ajr Force is not the agency w e 're

dea ling with in this particula r tn stance , so --

MR . PERK :

W ell, that ma y be the ir them e ,

05:29

your Honor .

THE COURT :

Well, there 's no objection to

the affidavit y then --

MR . LOGA R :

Well , it s hea rsay .

10

THE COURT :

Plus in the context o f th is

11

pa rticu lar hea ring , 50th sides have filed

12

affidavits --

la

MR . p:EK :

14

THE COURT : -- without objection, so --

15

MR . PEEK :

veah .

Chapte r 31, your Honor , perm its

hearing on affidavit, so does Rule 65, and I just

17

said that th e gentleman is ava ilable by telephone if

18

the Court wan ts to talk to the witn ess by telephone .


M R . FLYNN :

os:29

The - -

16

19

('
'

225

W e don 't doubt that the A ir Force has no

ns:29

And I subm it , you r Honor, if

20

it becomes imp ortant enough as we go on , I 'm going to

21

reserve ; we m ay have to have Mr . Hennessy on the

22

telephone .

23

THE COURT :

I 'm sorry?

24

M R . FLYNN :

If --

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:29

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 6 of 65

(.....
k

-...
.. -

THE COU1?T :

MR. PEE'
,K: Mr. Hennessy.

T H E C O UR T :

O h , M r . Hennessy r I 'm sorry .

M R . FL Y NN :

M r . Hennessy .

MR . PEF
=K :

THE COURT :

Have who ?

John Mr . He n n e s s y .

Yeah .

to: but right now I can 't judge that.


MR. FLYNN:

E'1l reserve my objection --

THE COURT :

A 1l right .

10

MR . FLYNN :

-- unti L such tim e as we

11

determ ine whe ther --

12

MR . PEEK :

Your Honor , then , w e have

T HE COHRT :

A l1 right .

Step over here

fir st to be sworn, please , sir .

ns:aa

16

17

WAR REN TREPP ,

18

ca lled a.s a w itness , hav ing been first duly swo rn ,

19

testified as follow s :

20

21

05:29

Mr . T repp , I think , who is going to testify next .

14
15

05:29

lf w e n e e d t o , we n ee d

13

22 6

D IRECT EXAM INAT ION

22

BY MR . JA KO PIN :

23

Q.

C an I h ave your nam e, p lease .

24

wa r re n T ce pp .

LCZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 7 of 65


p- ,

Q.

Wb at 's your current occupat ko n?

A.

1'm the CEO of e'Creppid Technologies .

Q.

For how long have you been that?

A.

A b o ut se ve n ye a r s r s i r .

Q.

Prior to eT reppid , what d id you do ?

A.

1 worked on -- 1 was actually sem iretired

for a wh ile m a king personal in vestments / and p rior to

that: I w orked on W all Street fo r about 20 yea rs .

Q.

Wh at 's your educational b ackground ?

10

A.

I graduated h igh school and too k some

Q.

Do you have any techn ical training ?

13

A.

Re lative to?

14

Q.

Relative to so ftwa re ?

15

A.

Noth ing that 1 haven 't been ab le to learn ,

16

with the excep tion of the time 1 spent with the

17

company .

19
20

cs:%

ns:31

c lasses in co l tege , but got no deg ree .

12

18

227

11

I+

Q.

O kay .

:5:31

Exp la in how you cam e to be inv olved

w ith eT reppid ?
A.

I w as introdu ced to Dennis by a th ird

21

party who said that Dennis had what cou ld be a great

22

opportunity for an investment in the high tech w orld .

23

Q.

Did there com e a tim e when you m et

24

Mr . Montgom ery?

LTZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

0s:31

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 8 of 65

,
'v .

, ...
.

z-

228

A.

Ye s .

Q-

wh e n w a s; t ha t ?

A.

1 b e ljeve T met him the frst t im e in '96,

''

5
6
7

1
.

Q.

Tn your initia l d iscussions , did you com e

A.

Well , Dennis be lieved that he had a

p otential to create a better com press io n pattern

recognition technology that could be developed ove r

10

tim e with the appropriate em ployees and capital to

11

bring to fru ition something th at wou ld be

12

revolutionary to the industry as is .

13

Q.

form ing eTrepp id ?

'

A.

Yes .

16

Q.

And as part of that fo rm ation , w as there a

At the end of 1998 .

05:32

series of ag reements that were entered into?

18

A.

Yes .

19

Q.

Was one o f those a Contrib ution Ag reement

20

that was signed whe re certa in technology of

21

M r . Montgome ry was sold to the company?

22

A.

That is correct .

23

Q.

And was there , then , a lso an Operating

24

o5:a2

Did there come a time th at you ended up

15

17

os:31

to some idea as to what a company was go ing to do?

14

('

and then T met h5m again in 1997 .

Agreement that was formed at that same time?

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

os:az

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 9 of 65


..,
(>.
22 9
)
.

A.

Yes .

Q.

Dtd Lhe Operating Aqreement dkctate how

3
4

the compa ny wou Ld c'perate?


A.

M R . JAKO PIN :

M R . PERH :

05:33

Th e c ou r t

W e will m ark it as

Exh ib it 2 ,. because I believe the cha rh was Exhibit 1 .

THE W ITNESS :

Your Hono r , I le ft m y

THE COURT :

t kn ow the feeling ,

13

MR . LOGA R :

Your Hono r, are we marking the

exhib its consecut Lvely ?

15

THE CO URT :

16

MR . JA KOPIN :

17

Yes .

THE COURT :

19

MR . JA KO PIN :

20

THE CO URT :

21

MR . PEEK :

T he cha rt w as m arked as

Yeah .

Th is is Exh ibit 2 .

Yes

05:33

That 's fine with me

, you r

Hono r, instead o f A , B , C .

23
24

05:33

Exhib it 1 .

18

22

05:33

g lasses over there .

12

14

f
.

Get it m arked firsh ,

MR . JAKOPIN :

10
11

l hand you a copy .

clerk --

'
l

Certain ly .

THE COURT:

It just makes it easier to

deal with .

LZZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 10 of 65

)-.-.)

MR .

(Exhibit 2 was marked for identification )

PREK :

I agree .
.

BY M R . JA KO PIN :

Q.

ls Lhis a copy of the init ial Operating

A greement that we w ere re ferring ho in hh e p revious

question ?

A.

Yes .

Q.

And at the tim e was the company known as

10

A.

It w as .

11

Q.

Referr kng to what ia page six at

05:34

12

paragraph 2 .7, do you see the paragraph th at 's

l3

ent i t le d F'u rp o s e ERn d B us i n e ss o f LLC ?

14

A.

Yes .

l5

Q.

Is i t slo ur un d e r st a nd in g t ha t w o u ld b e ,

16

''To develop , p atent , dist ribute, license and exp loit

17

in any m anner and on a worldw ide basis tha t certain

18

software com pression technology contributed b y the

19

Montgomery Trust and now owned by the LLC p ursuant to

20

the t erm s and conditions of the M ontgome ry Trust

21

Contribu tion Agreem ent and to fin ance any and a11 of

22

the foreg oing actvities''?

24

os:3q

Intrep id Techno logies , LLC?

23

230

,--'
y

That wa s collectively the b usiness?

That 's c o r re c t
.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

os:34

05:35

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 11 of 65


'.
'--'
. k
,
2 31
l

T H E CO U R'
f:

interrupttng, but it helps me if you can tell me

where th is is .

4
5

Ts th is the Amended Ope rating A greement or


is th is anothe r orte?

Th is is at page six , your

Honor , of the Ope rating Agreem ent o f Intrep id

Technolog ies --

TH E CO UHT :

10

11

13

And wa s tha t --

MR . JA KOPIN ;

M R . PEEK:

lt s the orig inal one ,

MR . JAHOPIN :

15

THE COURT :

your

It 's the origin al one .

And where is that in the

Because I've got an amended one dated two

18

thousand -- November the lst r 2001, and either -- if

19

there 's one in here I can loo k at , that 's fine .


Oth erwise , I wouldn 't m ind , if nobody else

21

does , loo king over M r . T repp 's shou lder , because I

22

want to see what we 're talking ab out .

23

24

05:35

exhib its?

17

20

os:35

Honor.

14

16

-- dated Sep hem ber 28th ,

1998 .

12

05:35

M R . JAKO PIN :

N ow , ex c u se m e f o r

MR . JA KOPIN :

I believe it wa s attached as

an exhibit to Lhe Reply, your Honor .

LEZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:35

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 12 of 65


....-.h

,
.
..
....)

.- .
.'

MR . PEEK :

MR. JAKOPIN: But 1 can hand you a copyz


if that w au zd be more efficient .

THE COURT :

t g o t th e am e nd e d an d

re stated , and I 'vo got an assignment o f patent , a n d

tha t's -- I don 't see the oth er one .


M R . JA KOPIN :
Honor .

THE COUHT :

A 11 r ight .

10

MR . LOGA R :

Your Hono r r m ay I ask what

THE COURT :

13

you come up he re and look at it .

14

M R . LOGAR ;

Just give me the tit le .

15

THE COURT :

It 's Operating Agreement o f

MR . LOGA R :

'
Vhe one that rs been mar ked a s

T HE COURT :

I can only tell you that 's

what they represent to m e .

05:a6

21

MR . LOGAR :

O kay .

Thank you .

22

THE CO URT :

O kay .

We rre on p ag e sixw

23

24

05:36

E xh ibit 2 :'

19
20

l fve been g iven -- why don ft

In trep id rechnolog ies, LLC .

17
18

os:36

you fve b een qiven by counsel?

12

16

os:a6

Here is a copy for your

11

O kay .

Well --

232

r ight?

Pa ragraph 2 .7, if I remembe r righ t?

MR . JA KO PIN :

Right .

L'
.EZA CHAPENr CCRt RMR

A nd that wa s --

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 13 of 65


u-8Y
?
''
*R'
2.
33
l
.

i
.

T i!F. C OIJRT :

M R . kTAK()PiN :

- - th e bus i ne s s o f t he

company .
T H'
. CO U !1T :

M R . P F'
.F=K :

Je 1'r y L:; lo o ki ng a t i t .

A 1 l ri(gh t .

You r 14(3nor !
' ju st -- may w e have a moment ,

W e 're 1o (ak in g a t it .
.

p lea se .
THE CO URT :

Yes .

Yeah .

10

MR . PEEK :

11

Your Honor, it is actually attached to the

Than k you .

05:34

12

Reply , bu t the pzob lem is , ih 's the last d ocument of

13

Exhibit A .

14

A who le series o f Operating Agreements are

15

attached as Exh ib it A , so I apolog ize w e didn t brea k

16

them down r but it 's actually in there .

17

18

THE COURT :

That s al1 right .

05:37

This is a

document E just got --

19

MR . PEKK :

20

THE COURT :

21

0s:3v

O ka y .

('

- - -

Yeah .
So I haven ft had a chance to

read it --

22

M R . PEEK :

23

THE COURT :

24

A1l right.

O kay .
-- w ith a w ho le 1ot o f care .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

s:37

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 14 of 65


wezh
(.w.
23 4
1

M R . JAKO PIN :

2 .7 f your Hono r .

THE COLIPT :

MR . JA KOPIN :

The Purpose and Bu siness o f

th e LL C .

05:37

MR . JuOGJ R :

Has the document been kdentified and

10

THE OOUFT ;

Exhibit 2

11
12

1 und erstand that it 's

1 --

ns:37

M R . LOGA R :

Ha s it been offered into

THE COURT:

It has not been offered into

evidence ?

13
14

Excuse me , your Honor .

o ffe red into ev idence ?

evidence .

15

MR . LOGAR: Thenr 1'11 object to any

16

reference to the body o f the d ocum en t until it is .

17

B Y M R . JA ICO PI N :

18

Q.

Exh ibit 2, w hich is the Ope rating A greement o f

20

Intrep id Techno log ie s, the agreem ent that was entered

21

into between Friend ly Cap ital Pa rtners , Fremont

22

T rust, and Montgomery T rust?

24

A.

o5:a7

M r . Trepp , is what ha s been identified as

19

23

Yeahz I 'm with you .

('

1 was reading from paraqraph

Yes .

MR. JAHOPIN: Id like to offer Exhibit 2

L (ZA C JIA PEN z CC R, RM R .

(775) 323-5492

os:aa

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 15 of 65


(..
..
/.. )
23s
.

into evidence .

MR. LOGAR: Your Honor, 1 still object.

There fs an inadequate founclation based

upon the individ ua ts that have executed th e documenh

on behalf af the p roposed partses .

6
7

THE COURT :

9
10

A re you fam iliar w ith this

THE W ITNESS :

Well, 1 know th is is the

documen t that w e put together when w e started the


busines s ia 1998 .

ns:as

11

O the r than that , I fran kly don 't -- 1 --

12

T HE COURT :

13

Are you familiar with hhe document?

14

That 's what 1 mean .

THE W ITNESS :

16

M R . PEEK :

17

THE COU1kT :

Well, I signed it .

He sgned it , your Honor .


And does it app ear to b e a

THE WITN ESS :

To the be st of m y knowledge ,

your Honor .

ns:38

21

T HE COURT :

22

(Exhibit 2 was admitted into evidence a

23

It rs adm itted .

BY MR . JAKOP IN :

('

24

os:aa

t rue and cor rect c op y of that document?

19
20

Is it

a docum ent you 'v e seen before?

15

18

'

o5:a8

document , Mr . Trepp ?

-.-- -

Q.

The Purpo se and Business of the LLC

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 16 of 65


(.'..'
6- )
236

2
A.

Yes .

Q.

What wa s your understanding o f tha h

certan softwaze comp ression techno logy ?

05:39

MR. LOGAR: Objection, your Honor.

MR. FLYHN: Object.

MR . LOGAR :

The language spea ks for itself .

10

can be shown that there 's any con fusion by any of the

11

term s u sed , the document speaks for itself and h is

12

opinion is irre leva nt and immaterial .

13

THE COU RT :

14

Go ahead .

15

16

'
r
,.

Do you see that?

t
'
z

re ferred to certain software com pression technology .

Paro l evidence ru le .
Unless it

. ,s ove rruled .
lt

BY M R . JA FO PIN :

Q.

:5:39

05:39

Can you an swer the question ?

17

T HE CO U R T :

Yes .

18

T HE WITHESS :

C learly; my und erstand ing o f

19

what -- and if th is is the proper question -- excu se

20

m e, I thin k I 1m answering w hat the que st ion is r but

21

I 'm not czystal c tear on it , b ut what I be lieved what

22

Denn is and I had agreed to do is b asically start a

23

business , use what he had to develop , w ith basica lly

24

m y cap ital , g iving him the ability to hire the

LtZA CHAPEN g CCR: RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:39

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 17 of 65


l,.w

1*e

app rop riate employuu's to develop , on an on-qoing

basis, the exploitation of technologies relating to

what he had done denzonstrations for m e ove r the prior

years .

Those dem onstrations included video

comp ression, aud io compression , patte rn recognition ,

and various and sunclry other things thah m y

expectatio n ce rtan ly was, w ith the rsght cap ital,

righ t peop le , w e w ould be ab le to deve lop ov er time .

10

THE COURT :

A11 right .

BY M R . JAKOPIN ;

12

Q.

Turn ing t,o paragraph 6 .5 .

13

A.

Yes .

14

Q.

Was the -- there 's a reference there to

the Time Devoted to M anag ement b y the manager .

16

0s:41

Was the or iginal manag er M r . Mon tgom ery?

17

A.

1 be lieve that was the case .

18

Q.

O kay .

So is it your unde rstand ing ,

19

acco rding 'no th is agreement , that he should devote

20

substantia Lly a1 l o f his time and attention and

21

efforts to the Business, cap ital ''Br'' and a ffairs ,

22

sm all ''A ,'' of the LLC during rea sonable bu siness

23

hours?

24

ns:4o

ns:4o

11

15

2 37

A. Yes

And not only tha t, 1 would certainly

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

0s:u

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 18 of 65

-. )

j
a--e

23f!

N.....z

f'

expect that if we were ma kjng a comm itment together

to b e partners in th is , I expect that he w ould

certainly be willjng to contribute h is tim e , effort s,

and energies into th is solely and exc lusively , by

v irtue o f the jact that he was go ing to own ha lf o f

the business .

7
8

formed , d id he own half of the busine ss?


A.

Abso lutely .

10

Q.

How much mone y d id you put int o the

12
13

14
15
16

A.

I think it was a m illion three hund red

thousand dollars .

Q.

Did Mr. Montgomery put in any money

in itially ?
A.

05:42
He m ade 2: contribution of his techno logy,

eve rything to date what he had creat ed fo r his

18

50 p ercent .

20

ob:41

com pany, initia lly , Mr . Trepp ?

17

19

A nd at the t ime that the bu siness was

11

Q.

os:4l

So , in theory , he got a m illion three in


stoc k va lu e, but he put no money in it .

21

M R . JAKO PIN :

Than k you .

22

T HE CLERK :

23

(Exhibit 3 was marked for identification .)

24

MR LOGA R : Counselr would you identify it

Exhib it 3 .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5192

os:42

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 19 of 65


'-v.
239
(vw
1

MR. JAHOPIN : T've had marked as Exhibit 3

the Contribu tion A greement by and between Intrepid

Technolog tes, LLC , and Dennis Montgom ery and grenda

Montgom ery a s the co-trustees o f the Montgomery

Fam ily T rust , and the contributor in Dennis

Mon tgom ery r dated and executed Sep tember 28th z 1998 .

BY M R . JA K3PIN :

Q.

Do you recognize this, M r . Trepp ?

10

A.

Ye s .

11

Q.

What is it?

12

A.

This is the deal that I re fe rred to b efore

as to what was -- Ilennis was contributing into the

14

pot for h is 50 percent interest in go ing forw ard w ith

15

the comp ang .

17

Q.

:5:43

Is th is a t rue and correct copy of this

agreeme nt?

18

A.

To the b est of m y know ledge .

19

Q.

A nd is that your signature --

20

A.

Yes, t is .

21

Q.

-- on p age l2?

22

A.

Yes .

23

24

05:42

0s:4a

13

16

for the reco rd : please .

M R . JAKO PIN :

os:43

1 '11 o ffe r Exhib it 3 into

evidence , vo ur H on o r .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 20 of 65


(.2 40

THE COURT: Any objection?

MR. LOGAR: No objection .

THE COURT :

(Exhibit 3 was admitted into ev idence .)

BY M R . JA K3PIN :

Q.

05:44

Does hlt:; aqreem ent define what it was

that M r . M ontgom ery had contrib uted to Int repid

Technologies , LLC ?

A.

To Lhe best e f m y know ledge .

10

Q.

Okay .

11
12

j
'

Adm itted .

Do you recall if pa ragraph 1 .2 .1 is

referred to as C D No . 17
A.

I don 't rem ember specifica lly ev er

13

physical ly gett ing a CD , but clearly the

14

understa nding of --

15

being given was contributed to hhe company .

16

Q.

if there wa s a C Dz what we were

com pany started , any discussion betw een you and

18

M r . Montg ome ry that there wa s certa in so ftw are

19

relating to com p ression technology that he was

20

contribut ing , b ut there was othe r software re lating

21

to patent (sic) recognition technologies that he was

22

not contr ibuting?


A.

Ab solute ly .

24

Gs:44

W as there , ea rly on in the tim e that the

17

23

05:44

MR . FLYNN : Objection; leading .

L.'
.ZA Ci1A PEN, CCRz RMR

(775) 323-5492

:5:44

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 21 of 65

Ij

f'
...j

...

M R . LOGAR :

MR. FLYNLI: And particularly, the whole

THE COURT :

Well, 1 think that the pa rol

evidence rule, one , our Gourt has mod ified the p arol

evidence rule p retty considerab ly in the la st four or

ftve years , and I hhink even be fore that , to a llow

people to ma ke exp Lanations about the ir understanding

o f the contracts and the negotiation s that they were

10

involved in to a1d the Court in understand ing and

11

interpret ing the agreem ent .

12

13

15
16

:s:4s

:5:45

1 think that the old , hard -and-fast paro l

evidence rule is dead in Nevada.

14

('

A nd parol evid ence .

thing is fraugh t w th parol ev idence which you can - -

241

I 'm so lry, you were going to say

some th ing ?

95:45
MR . FLYNN :

Your Honor, I th in k your

17

Hono r fs rationale is probab ly correct .

I don lt know

18

whether it's dead or not, but my objection is really

19

the following .

20

THE COURrr:

Go ahead .

:5:45

21

M R . FLYNN :

I th ink the -- g iv en the

22

natu re o f the fact that this is -- th is clause has --

23

thi s cont ract has an integration clause, the

24

exam inat ion sh ou ld b e extremely d irect w ith no

LFZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 22 of 65


!-*
/v
212
1

leading .

1 think Mr. Trepp should have the

respons ibi lity, withou t M r . Ja kop in 's he lp , to

explain thase th kntjs ; otherw ise , 1 thn k it would

indicate why the unde rlying rationale of the paro l

ev idence rule was trad it ionally a good ru le .

7
8

THE COURT :

W ell , I understand

that and I agree w ith the lead ing part of it .

I mean , 1 u sually r even in a trial y permit

10

a 1ot o f leading questions, because nine times out of

11

ten times they 're about issues that a re im po rtant ,

12

but if we 're talkng ab out a central is sue , 1 wou ld

13

a sk that you no t a sk leading question s about this

14

particu lar c lause or interp retation .

15

lf you want to ask him wha t he thin ks

16

about it or what he did or what h is thoughts w ere or

17

how he understands it , that 's fine , but 1et him tell

18

you what the an swe r is .

19

MR . JAKO PIN :

20

22

23

24

Fine .

05:46

05:46

We :ll do that , your

Honor .

05:46

21

A 11 right .

os:46

THE COU RT :

A 1l right .

BY MR . JA KO PIN :

Q.

With respect to the -- what 's refe rred to

as certain compression technology in this agreement ,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 23 of 65


(
2 43
...)
rw j

what w as your unde rstanding o f what was the

technology that was being contributed?

worked on tn the past , he had told me he was putting

togethe r i a a packitge , and it was something that we

cou ld sbar a on a go jng-fo rward base .

just compression technology, by any stretch of the

imagination .
He had given me demonstrations , as an

11

example, to whe re he too k the m ov ie Gunga Din and

12

basically , in front of me , showed m e how he could

13

colorize it by identifying a jacket on a person

14

running up the v alley ; the floor , the sky .

15

And then h e show ed m e -- th is w as to

16

interest m e in making an inve stm ent in the company

17

with him to 1et it grow over time .

18

as:47

It ce rtainly had -- it ce rtainly was not

10

Rasically, everyth nq that Dennis had

A.

05:17

05:47

So , b y showing me these d emonstrat ion s, it

19

was c lear ly show ing me h e had the ab ility to take

20

frame ''A '' ma ke fram e two out of it , and b asically do

21

his colorizat ion p rocess , an d the way he exp la ined

22

it , it wa s imp ossible to do it un less he wa s ab le to

23

identify specific p attern s in frame uA '' that were

24

identtcal in two .

L EZA C/G PEN, CCRS RMR

(775) 323-5492

n5:48

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 24 of 65


....

don 't know bow he did it, to be perfectly frank, but

ba sically he was ab le to , over a se ries o f frames ,

ov er a t ime frame , be able to identify p atterns in

e a c h o n e o f t h e f r am e s a nd t h en e o lo r iz e w h a t w a s a

black and white film into what then waa co lor .

o f the thing s that I saw , certainly, tha t I w as

in te rested in then ma king an investm ent in

12
13

os:48

T hat wou td have been a good e xample o f one

11

2 44

10

'

....;f

He could then assLgn from , you know -- I

conjunction with him on a going-forward basis.


Q.

o5:4a

We re there any other p roto type s that he

showed to you b efo re you made an investm ent?


A

The re were a number o f different things,

14

but they w ere a l1 thngs that were w ork in progre ss,

15

and I c learly understood , and we discussed that I w as

16

go ing to have to put a m illion , t<o m ill ion , three

17

m illion , :. substantia l am ount o f cap ital in this and

18

it was go sng to take us a m inimum of two to three

19

years to d ev elop this .

20

I mean , th is was a research and

21

development project, and I knew it was going to take

22

a long period of tim e and , frankly , I h ad sa id , ''Tt 's

23

not on ly go ing to take a 1ot of mone y; it 's going to

24

take more manpower than you could do it on your own

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

ob:4a

Qs:49

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 25 of 65


j
J* ?
24b
.
C- z . - 1

2
3
4
5
6

I
''

'

and you bette r go f Lnd som e peop le to he lp you .''

Q.

When you then initially formed the

company , what was M r. Montgom ery 's ro le ?


A.

He was the -- we tl, 1 to tal ly relied on

him fo r d ay-to-day operations .

05:4a

He had made a11 the h ring de cisions r the

firing decision .

1 have no techn ical knowledge .

was , 1 would sa y, mo re so as an investo r , certainly ,

but I certa in ly had tremendously mo re bu sine ss

10

exp erience and knowledge than Dennis did in running a

11

business, and I wou ld try to help him on an overview

12

bass , but I had no wav o f help ing him o n a daily

13

basis w itb the emp loyees , the programmers , or

14

an ything o f that klk .

15

MR . JAKO PIN :

16

T HE COURT :

Okay .

Thank you .

o5:5n

Just fo r p lann ing pu rposes , at

17

three o lclock we are go ing to sw itch reporters , so

18

we 'll take a recess at that time .

19

MR . JAKO PIN :

20

THE COUET :

21

MR . JA KOPIN :

22

(Exhibit 4 was marked for identification.)

23

MR . JA KCPIN :

24

0::49

O kay, you r Bono r .

Did you mar k som eth ing else?


I can , your Hon or .

I m arked as Exh ibit 4 an

Am ended and Restated Operating A greement , dated

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

ns:50

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 26 of 65

p- .)

January 1, 1999 .

BY MR . JA KO P IN :

Q.

Do you recoqnize that, M r . Trepp ?

A.

Yes .

Q.

ls Lhis a true and orig ina l cop y o f this

A.

Yes .

12

f
s

E clearly signed it ,

correct .

(Discussion off the record .)

05:sl

BY M R . JA FO PIN :

Q.

Refe rring to page 23, wh ich is paragraph

13

6.5 -- actually, where it says Time Devoted to

14

M anagem ent .

15

A.

Yes .

16

Q.

Do you see the same c lause that had been

osisl

17

in the previous ag reement where now M r . Montgomery is

18

the ch ief techno logy o fficer?

19

m an age r; he 's been given the title ch ief te chnology

20

o fficer , where he shall devote sub stantia lly a11 of

21

his fu ll tim e and attention and ef forts to th e

22

Business, cap ital ''B '' again , and a ffairs , sm all ''A ''

23

o f the LLC du ring reasonab le b usiness hou rs ?

24

ns:bn

T o the best o f my knowledge , that 's

10
11

246

Amended and Re stated Operating Ag reem ent ?

f..<

A.

He 's no longer the

Yes .

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

n5:s2

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 27 of 65

t. ..

'

.. .v-

was it your understanding that that is what he was

doing?

A.

Ab solutely .

Q.

Was Mr . Montgomery paid to do those

8
9

k'

During the pe rfo rmance of th is agreement ,

Q.

247

:5:52

activit ies du ring that pe riod ?


A.

O h w o f co ur s e .

T HE CLERK :

Your Honoz , that Exhib it 4 was

not form ally admitted yet .

10

MR . LOGAR :

It wasn 't even o ffe red .

11

THE COURT :

Tt wasn 't offered .

12

M R . JAKO PIN :

13

Can I have Exhibit 4 offered into

05:52

I apolog ize .

11

evidence , your Honor?

15

THE COURT :

16

Any objection?

17

M R . FLYNN :

No , your Honor .

18

THE COURT :

It 's adm itted .

19

(Exhibit 4 was admitted into evidence .)

20

(Exhibit 5 was marked for identificatfon.)

21

MR . JAKO PIN :

They d id offer it .

Ma rked a s Exh ib it 5 , an

22

Am ended and Restated Operating A greement , dated

23

November 1st , 2001 .

24

BY MR . JAKOPTN :

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

n51s3

0::s3

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 28 of 65


248
.. .-,

Q.

Do you recognize this, Mr . Trepp ?

A.

Yes .

Q.

13 th s a true and original copy o f this

exhib it?

A.

Yes , to the best o f my knowledge .

6
7

MR . JAKOl?IN :

I 'd like to offer Exhib it 5

MR. FLYMN : No objectlon.

THE COtJR'r :

11

lt 's adm itted .

(Exhlbit 5 was admitted into evidenee .)

Ds:53

BY MR . JAKOPIN :

12

Q.

13

6 -5 r Mr . Trepp .

14

A.

What page is that?

15

Q.

Th is is paqe 25 .

16

A.

O kay .

17

Q.

The pa ragraph is referred to as T im e

18

os:53

into evidence .

10

Refe rr tng again to what is in paragraph

nb:sa

Dev oted to Management .

19

t,

.--y'm.-j-

Do you see that ?

20

A.

Yes .

ns:54

21

Q.

Do you see the same clause that says that

22

M r . Montgom ery sha ll devote substantially al1 of his

23

full tim e and a ttention and effo rts to the Business'

24

capital ''BJ ' and affairs, small ''A,'' of the LLC

LIZA ('
.*
.HAPENr CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 29 of 65


z 4:
...
.eq
!.
1
(

A.

Y e s , I d tn.

Q.

And dicl he do that during the term of th is

agreem ent ?

A.

Yes , he did .

Q.

And was he paid for that?

A.

Ab so lute ly .

Q.

And were these payments for the various

different Operat ing A greem ents, those were in


add ition to the percentage ownership that he had in

11

the com pan y?


A.

MR . JA KO PIN :

MR . FLYNN :

Your Honor : aga in , I 'd eauhion

THE CO URT :

T ry not to ask so many lead ing

18

questions when we get down to the questions that are

19

important and central to the case .

20

MR . JA KO PIN ;

21

22
23
24

05:54

on a l1 the leading .

17

Nothing further with th is

exhibit rzght now .

15
16

0s:s4

That is correct .

13
14

o5:s4

10

12

('

d u r i.n g r e a so n ab l.e 13u s ine s s ho u r s?

I will do that z your Honor .

BY MR . JA KOP IN :

Q.

Do you see in these ag reem ents that

M r . Montgom ery wa s what w aa refe rred to as CTO ?


A.

Ye s .

I,1ZA CHAPFN , CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

05:55

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 30 of 65


C-

Q.

W hat were his responsibility as CTO ?

A.

He was rc,sponsible for running the

250

day-to-day busjness as far as the development of a11

of our t echnology , from the start th rough a couple o f

wee ks ago e overseeing the empkoye es , programmers that

wo rked in the company .

Q.
c o r r ec t ?

A.

That is correct .

10

Q.

What we re his responsibilities as part of

12

A.

The re were th ree people on the m anagem ent

comm ittee , and that g roup was sup posed to be -- I

14

w ou td eal l it like an executive comm ittee Lo

15

basically determ ine what the overv iew or corpo rate

16

plans for what the company w ould do on a

17

going-fo rwa rd b as ks .

Q.

19

Was he paid a salary a s a CTO ?

A.

He was pa id a salary from day one .

21

Q.

Do you remember what his most recent

23
24

05:s5

Were you paid a salary --

20

22

c5:5s

the m ana gement comm ittee?

13

18

os:ss

He was a lso on the managem ent comm ittee #

11

k
(

j.-

f
:

sala ry w as ?

A.

$300,000 .
MR . FLYNN :

Can we have a time frame , your

LIZA CHAPFN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

nsts6

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 31 of 65


251
.v
,
(*K*

Ho n o r ?

He was paid $300,000 the

last three yea rs he was employed there ; eac h yea r .

HY MR . JA FO PIN :

Q.

Did you have an understanding of alk o f

the va rious eng ineers who had been hired at eT repptd

and what they d sd ?

8
9
10
11

A.

I had Dennis alm ost -- I h ad Denn is -- we

had lunch ev ery day for almost seven years .

We

d iscussed eve ryth jng .

05:57

W hen 1 say eve rything, I w ou ld ask an

aw ful 1o L of questlons about the technica l sides of

13

the business to determ ine what else there wa s 1 could

14

do to he lp in the process .
If h e needed either m ore cap ital or mo re

16

employees or more equipm ent or whateve r th at would

17

be, that would be the genera l gist of the

18

conv ersation .

19

05:s6

Up until recently ?

12

15

THE wlqayzss:

He to ld m e when he hired peop le .

He told

20

me when he fired p eop le .

I frankly nev er got into

21

in-depth conversations as to who he would h ir e and

22

why ; it w ou ld generally b e, f'W e 're hiring this person

23

for hardware developm ent ,'' or, ''We need mo re prog ram s

24

to do software developmentr'' or something.

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

o5:b7

(775) 323-5492

05:57

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 32 of 65


252
,.v -!
... A
1
('

Genera Lly speakng , that would b e the


conversat ion .

3
4

5
6

But we had lunch eve ry day .

knew exact ly - - 1 -- we sha red in form ation every da y .

Q.

On the b usness side , what did you

A.

We ll, clearly the cap ital to , A , start the

bu siness; B , cont ributed capital when the time fram e

and the am ount of money that Denn is exp la ined to m e


he though l we needed to dev elop th e b usiness .

to th e orig inal investors and as k for a capital ca ll

13

to generate more money to operate the business.

14

A t some point , 1 got so concerned that

15

Denn is was gong to get diluted d own because he

16

could n 't a fford to p ut m ore money in the bu sin ess, I

17

then chose , throug h one of m y own pe rsonal entities,

18

to sta rt lending m illion s of dollars into th e

19

business to keep the business go ing u ntil we cou ld

20

m ake m oney .

21

m illions and m il lions of dollars .


2 004 was the first year we made a little

money .

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

gszs:

o5:s8

The company lost m oney from '99 to 2003,

23

24

ns:5a

We made a decksion that we would go back

12

22

0b:s7

contr ibute ?

11

1 m ean , we

10

'

(7V5) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 33 of 65

/*:''

And 2 005, we made a little m ore money .

THF COURT : For the record, just so we

have it ot record , 1 marked the affid av ih that was

subm itted a s Exh ilait 6 ; it 's not adm itted b ut it 's

marked ancl so the next exh ibit w ill b e Exhibit 7 .

(Exhib it 6 was marked fo r iden tification .)

MR . PEEK :

10

In fac t, actually, your Hono r,

O r did you go ahead and adm it it as per


our earlie r discussion ?

11

THE CO URT :

n5:b9

To me , you know , we 've got a1l

12

kind s of m aterial th at 's bee n subm itted here in aid

13

in opposition to this injunction and to this process

14

that 's he arsay, that 's not b een through the --

15

MR . PEEK :

16

THE COURT :

17

We don 't have an y affidavits .


-- process, and so T 'm going

MR . FLYHN :

You r Honor , i s Exhibit 6 --

that fs Exhib it A ?

20

MR . JAKOPIN :

21

THE CO URT :

N o , Exhib it 6 is the affidavit

23

M R . FLYNN :

Oh , yeah .

24

THE COURT: -- fellow from the Air Force.

22

05:59

to adm it Exhib it 6 .

18
19

05:59

I wou ld offe r Kxh ibit 6.

25'
.
5

No r it 's not .

of the --

LIZA CBAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

ob:sa

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 34 of 65


.
> 54
..
,- .
,
-

M R . F LYHN :

A nd s .
in ce you lre now admi tting it, your

So that 's been adm tted .

Honor, 1 would have to object.

be fore because it was never actually offered

at th is junction r f '11 ob ject..

THE COURT :

1 was reserving it

A 11 right .

but now

06:0:1
Well , it 's

adm itted .

(Exhibjt 6 was admitted into evidence.)

THE COU RT :

10

And Exh ibt 7 is Exhib it A to

the Amend ed A greem ent ; is that righ t?

11

MR . JA KO PIN :

12

(Exltibit 7 was marked for identification.)

13

MR. FLYNN : And I -- we object without

14

foundat ion , your Hono r .

THE COU RT :

To Exhib it 72

16

MR . FLYNN :

Y eah , until w e get som e

THE COURT :

A l1 right .

B Y MR . JARO PTN :

20

Q.

Mr . Trepp , do you recognize Exhib it A ?

21

A.

Yes .

22

Q.

What is it?

23

A.

It 's the people that own the eT reppid

24

06:00

foundation .

18
19

n6:oo

Yes, it is .

15

17

t
.

Technologe s, cLc .

L EZA CHAPEN , CCR , RMR

(775) 323-5492

06:00

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 35 of 65


e

1
(

Q.

A greem ent as updaled as of March 1st, 2003?


A.

Ye s .

MR . JAKOPIN :

1'd like to o ffer Zxhibit A

THE CLLRK :

M R . JAKO PIN :

MR . FLYNN :

T hat 's Exhib it 7 .

I'm sorry, Exh ibit 7 .

Your Honor, m ay 1 h ave a

m oment?

n6:ol

11

THE COURT :

12

(Discussion o ff the record .)

13

MR. FLYNN: We 're goinq to object, your

14

Yes .

Hono r .

15

MR . PEEK :

16

MR. FLYNN: Webre going to object, your

17

I 'm sorry?

n6:01

Hono r .

18

THE COURT :

On the grounds?

19

MR . FLYNN :

Mr . Montgom ery was a partner ;

20
21

06:00

into evidence .

10

255

ls th is a true and correct copy of the

Exhibit A Lo the Am ended and Restated Op erating

t
&

'w'J

fifty-fifty to start with .

06:01

Over his request, he wa s neve r given

22

aecess to any books and record s, if there are any

23

b oo ks and record s .

24

m eetings , there were never corporate proto co ls

There were never any corpo rate

LIZA CHAPENZ CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 36 of 65


256
A
w
y-,
..j /(.
..

complied w ith .

A11 of the records were yn us . zsopp js

back poc ke t .

v irtua lly noth jng among th corporate reco rd .

So to sub stantiate w hat is : in effect , a

com pilation , we would need ho look at the underly ing

docum ents .

t
'

M r . Montgom ery w as qiven and shown

n6:o1

So it m ay become icre levant , but at this

juncture, I bave to objech beeause we believe it's

10

basically a com pilation from underlying docum ents

11

which we b elieve are not go ing to be kep t ln

12

accordance with norma l and standard accounting

13

practices.

14

M R . JAKO PIN :

15

THE COURT :

Your Hono r --

Well, 1 th in k that 's an

16

objection that we night have to deal with down the

17

road b ut for the pu rp ose o f this hea ring , I 'm go ing

18

to admit Kxhib it 7 .

19

MR . JAKO PIH :

20

(Exhibit 7 was admitted into evidence.)

21

BY M R . JA KOPIN ;

22

Q.

06:01

06:02

Th an k you .

As of March 3rd -- as of March 1st, 2003,

23

is this a t rue and co rrect list o f a11 the various

24

investor s in In trepid Techno logie s, LLC ?

LIZA CHAPELIr CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

06:2

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 37 of 65


2 57
..,'z)
.v k
. ...-.

A.

Yes, it. is .

Q.

Are there any additional investors in

eT reppid since th at Lime?

A.

MR . JA KO l?IN :

That 's al1 1 have with re spect to

Thank you .

THE COURT :
reporte r .

(Discuss Lon off the reco rd .)

11

M R . JAKOPIN :

Honor .

We bre at three o 'cloc ky you r

THE COURT : Well, a11 I -- ordinarilye I


w o u ld n 't - -

15

This doesn 't need to be on the record .

16

(Discussion off the record .)

17

THE COURT :

18

06:02

Yo u sa id that we needed to --

13
14

06:02

We lz, I haven 't seen the cou rt

10

12

Okay .

Exh ibit 7 .

No .

A l1 right .

o6roa

Is this a good

tim e?

19

MR . JAKOPIN :

20

THE COURT :

This is fine .

Let s take -- we ll take --

21

let 's giv e her enough t im e, give you gu ys enough

22

tim e ; we 'll ta ke until 25 after .

23

Ma ke it 20 a fter .

24

MR. PEEK: Thank you, your Honor.

L IZA CHAPEN, CCR# RMR

(775) 323-5492

06:03

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 38 of 65


,xh.x,
yet
;?iit)
.)
.-..
1.

$
'

M R . F'LY hl11:

T h a n k yo u , yo u r Ho n o r .

T 14E C O U RT :

A 1 1 r ig h t .

W e '1 l b e i.n re c e s s

u n t i.l th e n .

(Re (;es :5 ta ker.)

(Enrl o f Vo lume f .)

6
7

8
9

10
11
12

t
.

13
14
15

16
17

18
19
20

21
22
23
1,

t.

24

LIZA CHAPEN r CCR r RMR

'
.

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 39 of 65

?..,.'j
1

f'

STA TE O F N EVADA

).
-.
)
)

259

ss .

COUNTY OF' WASI


4C)E )

I , L I ZA C flA Pi'
,N , O f f ic i a 1 R ep o r te r o f th e Se c o rtd

Jud i c i a 1 D i st ri c:t C ou rt o f the St a t e o f N e va da r in

a nd fo r t h e C ou n t y o f Wa sho e , do h e r eb y ce rt i fy :

Tha t a f5 :
uuch repo r te r , 1 wa s p re sen t in

Depa r tme n t N o . 9 ()f t h e abov e c o u rt on s a id da t e ,

t ime and h ou r , and I then and the r e t oo k v e rbat im

10

st e no t y p e n o t.e s o f th e p ro ce e d i ng s h ad a nd t es t im on y

l1

g.
i.ve n t he z e in .

12

T h a t. t11e fo re go i ng t r an sc r ip t i s a fu l l ,

13

true and correct transcription of my said stenotype

14

notes , so taken as a foresaid .

15

tran scrip t. was taken d own unde r m y direct ion and

16

cont ro l, and to the best o f my know ledge , skill and

17

ability .

18
19

DATED: At Reno,

That the fo rego ing

Nevada , ths

2 )5$-day

, 2006 .

20

21

L IZ

<CHA PEN , NV CCR #93

22
23

24

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

of

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 40 of 65


.

1 .,.

k )
..

)''

174611.3'7

#931:21-1:24,259.21

19211).3:z
1982(1I-20516
1985(1!-184:18
1990l1,-175:5

1
994I1j-175:5
1997I2I-175:19,

#2o6s(1I J:24
-

$300t)00(21250:23 251.2

,
'0z(aI-15:13,15:16.
126:a
'96I1J-228:3
-99(,1-2s:2!,
252:21
'it'I$1-169:18

'

1
0(
21-59222, 60:14
1c0

1(9 (1I-17::23
:(3a111-6:11
10:3Qt11-6:11
10th(1sI-43:21'
46:1.46:22,46:23*
47:1,48217,5::15.
51:1,54:13.83:21,
110:12,144:20'
153:189153:20,216:3
1$(1I-118:3
1.1:()n (a -34:22'
108:3

11tha -51:19'
144:21,153:19
12(a)-47:24,so:2.

239:
21

'
!
,.

120I1l- 215:13
12th z - slIl9.
x :1(j
13
(21-50:2'50:18
lzzlll- 3:4
44(t1- 219:24
lst)Iq - 109:18,
110:8 11(t1Q,
,
110:16,11ct21,
116:12
1s4(jI-3:s

16!
21-47:22j48:3

61
:9
500t2l-66:8,66.9

2
17:4'236:
24.
243:19,259:17

53(11.3:4

226t1l-3:14
22ndpl-34:19I

5441(1I-2:6

1999(1l-246:1
19th(1)-14:9
1:30Ial-137:7,
1'
F1:19,172:1
1a4(,I.2:17
lsttsl.1B0:2,
231:18.247:23,
2s5:3.256:22

2(
9I-4:
4,229:9,
229:19,230:2.
232:18 234:10
,
.
2M :19.234:24.
235:
22
2.zp1.230:12.
232:23,234:2
20(6l-1:15,59:22,

6
,157:16.227:8,
20
5:
71:4
23
2(3QI3,-32:22,
109:16.13512
2:00I
J1-37:18.
108:23.176:4
2001f6?J-57:17,
84:2,84'
9'145:9,
145:16,165:7,
176:17,231:181
247:23

2:02I$a1- 14:9.
14:14 28:15.49:17.
,
49:23'57:18'84:11'
84:14,85:12.86:5.
145:16 165:8,178:1
,

2:03It.
I-85:13,

85:15,252:21,255:3,
256:22
20414lc.l-1:5:3,
180:3, 252:23
2:05ru -33:22,
132:22.253:1
2006Isl- 1:21,5:1f
157:21, 172:1,259:19
203I1I- 3:10

21I1)-3:
3

212t11- 3:11

214I1I-3:11
i
zlgjlj.a:ja

35'7

23I1I-246:12
230I11-4:4
23541)-4:4
238It1-4:5
24011)-4:5
245111-4:6
24T(z)-4:6,4 1
24zs(1I-2:9

6I
BJ-4:8,253:4,
253.6 253.
8 253:17
253:18 253:21,254.8
6.s(a)-237:12,
246:131248:13
65(,,-225:16
6tu(1l-s2::$

248(1I-4:7
2sp)-248:15,

257:22
253!:1-4.
8

i 254131-4:
8.4:9,
68 15
256(1)-4:9
28thp1-231:10.
239.7
2ndI2)-39 5 39:6

'
7I1a)-1:21, 4:9,5 1,
172:1,253:5,254:9,
254:12 254:15
,
,
255:7. 255:8, 256.18,
256:20,257:7
x (1)-4:3
7ttt(2I-50:11, 50:17

3
:$Il;,-4rs, 2:$8.22,
2:
$3.::
$.2:
$9:2,
239.23.240:4
z..da -z5:j(5,
74 14.150J11
30pj-7:19. 110:4,
j14.j:$.1j4:1s.
1jsr
6.j21:2.122:ja,
21z:11.217:12
z.lIjj.zzs:ls
adp).z4rz
aruIa). :s :14.s2::$,
256.22

4
4 a -4:s. 6s:2,66:9.
zzjsrzz z45:z:$
'
'
247::,247:13,247:19
40(
z)-9s:6,219:18
4:,
000111-59:23
42i
2!-9:
4.927

5
s(5j-4:7,a4.
/:20,
;?,j.2.:2j,24,:6,24a:j()

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

A
abbreviated(1T30:21
ability(s1-19:6,

225111-2:14

2
231
11-3:13
224(11-2:17

5,Q00(zI-66:2,

66:10
sp(3I..96:6.238.18,
239:14
50,000(21-60:19.

1998IsI-166:11.
228:15,?31:11I

1
11,41-1:1s'4:3'
69
:22,70:1,121:s.
121:
6. 122:19'
156
:13.164:2,
164:10. 229:9,
229:17.240:11 246:1
1.2.4I1I-240:'10
1 z(1I-z3:1z
1 at,)-3a:17

21stIsI.33'221

34 15,34:17,34:21.
34.23,:5ti.z,216,2.
2115.10
222I11-3:12

228:4

235:10,239:7

f )

8
tja .11::24,
116:11,220:.
/
8(m (q!.5.
/:1:
$
gzjsj. 1.;8:z:5
dgst)j(jj- arj,j
a:sj1(jj-z:
s
a:()()a . 4a:zjj
48.24
atjh(a). 4:$r:$,s()(12,
sljila

9
:(a -j)j2, 2s9:a
gII(,j.j&j.:1
alol
)zIjj-2:1a
:4:
$:4..1,14(jj.z::
a:(o a .4arzjv
48:
24
9:(j.
j(jj.s:j
9t
.1
1pj-42:19,
42:
21 4:
$:2 46:15j
' 49:j
46:21'48:21
'$
* ,
z()j:z:

ablelzs!-8:20 10:4
15:9,19:3.19:4 20:4,
29:12,51:11,63:13,

126:17,148:
9

189:11,189:24.
204:20,217:
22,
219:4,221:
3 221:
7
221:21I222:
7
22?:15.237:9
243:22,244:3,244:4
absentlzl-7:22,
25:2

absolutely!1I14:2:
$

Absolutelylsl20:11.134:2,238:9.

24023,247:
4,249:
7
QbstentiortI11129:1Z
atjstractnl-jzzrs
acceptlzl-5:18.9:1
aEress(
521-17:5
20:5,20:
6,20:71

2
0:10,20:17s30:14,
30:23,31:1.31:2.
31:5.31:7,31:9,
31:13,32:15,33:6,
60:5,60:24,66:20,
6Z:3.67:16.67:23
'
07:2319Z:3,98:21,
101:8,101:11,
104:17,106:15,
111:22,112:3,112:81
113:10,113:171
113:19,116:1
'
119:14,120:18,
151i14,152:16

160:1,165:11,'
166:18,189:24,
jrmiz jatlr:s jrs rs
'
z1():1'
5 zl.
:L'
7
.
,:
242,:4'zssap
accms'sedp)- :
$z:1c
accommodatep)jzj:jj
accordancepl
ztsrjz
according(
2)l:s:jtl.z:
$.
g.
;!$)
accountel31:1z,
31:19 32:13.32:17
,
accountingI11ztz :jz

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 41 of 65


( )

?'
'.

(
'

accurate1
41-s0:4.

affidakittn-224:
5.

aisleIII-20:15

Anomalytsl-187.
22

108:20 110:6 155.14

224.
8 2?4:18 2258,

alarm (9l-49:3,

Answertll-53:2

actI11-147:16
Activelll-10Z:7
activelyI$J-9:9
activities(a 230:22 247:6
actualI1eI-27:10
28:
9 33'3 48:
9 57:1
s7:4 ss:21 s1:2
6J:1?'67:21 66:13
68:19 119:19,13925,
163:1T,196:5.
196:10 222:9
Adaptiveltq-94:51

225:16.253:3 253 21
affidakrit.s(31-18:17
225.12,253:15
afford(1I-252:1(;
aforesafd(11259:14
afterwardsI1Js2:2()
agencies(fl-1146
agency(zI-97:22,
102:
8,104:15,
106:13 127.3
127:21,225:3

49 7 49.12 49'16
49 21 50.4.505
50:14.83'17
Alarm ill-50:2
Algot-ithrrltll-196.7
algori
thm Ij41182 7.1829 1835.
la31o,1a4.19,
196 3,1X 24 196'51
195 9.19Z:12,
19F:13,193:12,
200:17.207:12
algorithm sI2)-

answ erfzj-55'16.
67:7,67'10 67:12,
73L14.93:10,105'6.
127:15.144:3 217.6
236:16,242:18
answered(3)80:19,127:6 127:14
answering lli236:20
anywayI31-10:18.
38:9,91:4
Apclll-2:12
apologizeI2)-

Arlingtonltl-2:14

arranged(3I-38.15.
151'20,151:21
articulatedI1l19:17
aspecta(11-221:2
assemblyIf,178:15
assessing(1141:13
assetsfal-223291
223:12
assignI11-244:1
assigned (
3)149:12,149:13,

141:19,145:91

agenc/st1I-106:
4

193:13!1934

233:15,247:12

149:22

145:1/ 145:18
146:7,165:19,165:20
Adaptivespl146:11
add(al-31:11
59)121149:18
addedI2)-50J16
159:18
addition(3I-19:15,
123:21,249:10
additionalI
z)-59:6,
60:151257:2
addi
ti
ons11l-73:19
address(sJ-11:231
13:11 16:24 19:13
125:2,129.17
Addresslll-70:21
addressesI11224:
6
administrativel!I137:15
administratorlq 31:17,22:11.32:13,
32:17 149:19
admissionI
61-6:3.
6:12,T:6,7:17.7:23
11:22
admitpl-253:9

ago(q -19.17
161:24 189:13
195:10 2181
2 250'
5
agree (
z)-12:11,
16:9 55:1 55.6
230:1,:!42:8
agreeableI1p-1192T
agreed(1I-236:22
agreement(1lj164:11 168:14
234:
20 237:19
239:17.240:6
241:11 242:24
246:17,247:1 249:4
Agreementpq 12:23 l4:51164:5
164:9,164:115
228:19 228:24
229'2.230:5 230'21
231:4 ?31:7,232'15
234:19I239:3
245:
24.246:6
247:22.254:10 255:3
Agreementslzl233714,249:9
agrethmentsI3177:9,228:17.249.22
allead(
31)-14:2

allow llt)-6:24,
9:11,24:10.36:8,
80J16 91:5,93:4.
148:24.2121I
214:24 241.7
allowedIB1-8:16.
9:9,67:6.105:1
172:13,172:18,
200:15
allowingI!l-91.13
allowsl1l-151t13
alm ost(:!.38:81
131:14 18$:18
191:24,207:12
223:6,251.8 251.9
alone(3I-14:18,
90:15.140:10
alter(
21-183:4
altered(2)-221:20
Altolll-2:9
AmendedIq -231:4I
245:24 246:
6,
247:
22 254:101255:2
amendedI
21231:17 232:
4
Am itill-68:7
Amits(
1j-88:
8
amountl
-q-215214

appeara -6:13
65:21,235:1Z
appeacanoesI1J5:
9
application(18)6:3,6.21,7:5,7:16.
7:20 8:13 138:22
138:23,139:11,
139:15 139:18
1392
20,139:22,
147:14 187:4
191:19s192:1
applicati
onsi8I139:4 139:24 140:3,
140:5 140:17
141:15,142:41191:
22
appreoiateI4l-13:4.
13:17,131:22 184:14
approach (1!-174:
8
appropriateE4118:5,45:10 228:10,
237:1
approvalIn-6:BI
7:6 7:13,7:22 8:17,
9:
7 21:15
appeov'eI21-8.1,
19:23
approved (
2I-6:3,

assignmentlll232:5
assi
stanceship!$J176:5
associatedI11179:20
associationj1)8:14
assum e(4!-11:3
95:4 126:
22,126:23
assum ingI11-221:4
assum ptionI1I120 12
Atd(4)-49:
4 50:2
s0:8 s0:15
attached(
61-33:16.
38:18 40:12 231:23
233:11 233:15
attackt1j-65:12
attemptedI
211()6:15 :24:13
atternpting(
1)216:8
attend(11-24:9
auention(
41-37:21
237:20 246:21,
24::
23
Attomeypl-130:22

253:17,256:18

16:10.21:22125:7,

215.17 218:6

adm ittedi13j235:21,235:22
240:
41247:9,247:181
247:19. 248:
9,
248:10,253:4,254:1,
254:7 254:8 256:20

36:
9136:19.46:
121
52:24,55:16 68:12,
/9:23,81:8,93:f4,
107:18 108:15
.
,
117:16,130:8.1312
7,
137:8,145:22 160:7
163:4 177:19
.
,
196:19,199:41
207:21,214:2'215:4.
236:14,241:
20,253:
9

218:
14.219:41
arbitlarilyI11-204:
6
244:17 252.
9
area119)-33:15,
amounts!1I-72:5
48:2151:16,72:46,
analysislzl-2 :
9, 74:8 75:5 75:18
. ,
,
221rl7
75:22.75:23,101:15,
analyzep!-181:9,
111:Z 121:4 122:
20,
1&2:
z 1825
1692
6,f84:2 205:22
,
,
AndersontN .45:17, 206:20
49:10 J6:j1 9a:2
areas(11-51:15
animal(1)-177:11
argument(21-

Admittedr
zl-4:2.
240:3
Rdmittedly!:!1zo:!2
admitting!1l-254:2
ado(1l-19:
5
advksarll!-176:
21

aidf2l-241:10,
253:112
Airz -68:18.224:5.

anomalypl12a:13 12::22
154:
7 jazr
zll 187:5,

affairspl-237:21, 22
224
:a,
1:k1
5271
225:2, 1
:1
18
z:z
(),
5:
22
.
52
3:
4,
J8
6
)7
s:
15
3.

:s:
J6

246:22.248:24

LIZA CHAPEN/ CCR; RMR

206221

10:f7.19:2

Attome#s(1!-127:1
attorneys(11-20:
5
audio(161-99:
4,
99:6 % :j(), 9tkj4,
99:16
' 99:21 100:7
100213 141:
22
j48:17'148:18,'
48:jg'j49:1
1zc:18 2% :17,237:6
Audio'(aj.99:
24,
148:23, 149:4

Augusql)-> :13

argumentative(1155:11

authori
ty(rI-16:14,
1f):x z4:
2j, 1:$0:
6,

argumentsI1j-

j:
$1:
,1
:$
($:
6rnc
,13z6
14
au
t2
ol
,l
f
f:

,6::f7

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 42 of 65


3
t-.)
Iv I
autom atic(1l-

Bartl5)-6.3.6.5

177'20

6:616:7,6:
21,7:4.

automaticallg(21135:10,224:12
auxiliary(3l-60:11
available(41-

7.5,7:1().7:17,7220,
7:23,7::!4 9:2.9:3.
10511
Bal's('I-7:8

215:231218:
4,

Barjinf
lerl
zl-49:14.

224717.225:17
Aventl
elll-2:14
average(1I-102:22
avoid(1I-184:14
aware(z4l-54.20.
78:21 79:3 81:2,
106:12 114:5
141:11,141:14,
141:18 14225
143:13,143:15,
143:23 144:4 144561
144:9,159:4,164:8,
188:
6,139:10.
190:171200:24,
216:24,222:21
awarenessI11103:18
aw fu!(1I-251:12

s
,

(
,

eachelol's!1I:(
)j5:
5
backedI5)-29:15.
30117.35:2,35:13,
2()0:j1
backgroundlzl23:23y 36:4I 81:3e
204:16,x s:4,
2% :24,227:
9
backingz -28:21,
29:22.30:1,33:12,
37:
9,38:21.210:8
backup1:2)-29:1,
29:8,32:9,32:21.
32:24,40:11,41:4I
41:5,119:51143:15,
200114
backu!)s1zI-29:12.
33:
20,38:11,38:13,
39:1.119:
6.149:24
bailifftn-24:
6

Baili
fhsl-22:
23,

'

23:3,23:
6.23:13.
lza,
z
Bal(
2l-49:14.7s:7
Bafspl-zs:14
bankm -114:12.
ll4L
zo,114:z2.
11s:1s.155:19.
156:3,161:1s
banksf;
?1-114:16,
114:19

248'5. 259.16

betterIq-23'18.

box(8I-33:16,

179:8,191:1

38:18'40:9,40:19.

burden(2l-135222,

69 16 142:17,
143:11 228:8.245'1
between(201-12.22.
14'4 47'2 48:21

41:
6.135:4,155:19
break(z1-107113,
11428 159:23
183:11 184:5 210:9

135:24
BushI11-17.8
business1271-86:4,
8;:15 99:10s 162:15

4824I57.
24.77.10.

233:15

156:)1 2% 2,

75:7
baseI:I-243:6
based (111-6:16,
27:22,104:81120:16.
178:21,193:9.
193:13,199:13,
199:14,209:8.235:3
Basedtll-82:8
basicI3J-71:22,
151:5
basis1201-6:23.
33:21,34:10,85:6,
113:4.128:3,130:9.
132:1 13223 134:21
143:2.143:18,
164:21 168:15
230:17,237:2,
244:10 245:12

91.9 130:14f133:3,
140.22 162.14I
164:5 177.101
178:11,1792'216.2
234:21,2393.240 17
beyondlzl-Z:191
160:2
big(91-47:16,54:1,
544 54.9 153:221
154:2,181:2.197:18
biltionI11-215:8
billionslll-221:15
bin(11-51:16
binariesa -146'8.
146:12, 145:15
binary(4I-146:13
146::8. 146219,147:7
Binaryl:l-146:14

breakdow n(1I-86:6
Brendayl-1:13
78:3 78:12 239:4
Brianlll-26:2
briefings!21-17:7.
17:8
brieflyp!-24:1.
25:12 26:5
briefs(11-168:17
Brigham tll-205:6
bring(s)-113:23
161:19 2n1:11
220:20 228:11
bringinga -415
41:7
broad t4I-21:3,
21:4 207:3
broughtg/I- 26:101

230:23 233:2,
235:10 236:23
237:22 238:6,238:7,
238:8, 245:9,245:11,
246:231249:1,250:31
251:13, 25225,252:81
252:10,252:13,
252:161252:19
Businesslq 230:13. 234:4.
235524.237:21,
246222,248:23
bus;(11-Z1:4
btztton(11-22:23
byte(11-221:13
bytesI5l-21527.
215:8,215:9.221:15

245:13.250:17
batter(1I-23:17

Birminghamtl)2:17

1()6:13 112:21
129:23 144:21

Bauderpl-40:41
45:1i$I49.11
Bebbititll.176:21
bt'Gam @I11-184:17
becorrkeIsI-20.3,
136:23,137:1,213 71
256:8
becorrleslll225:20
beefeclI1l-65:13
beg(1l-215:16
began I51-25:20,
25:7,26 17 65:
6
65:21
Beginllinglll-85:15
beginning(s1-29:41
30:2,383,43:1.
54:15191:8.93:
23,
143:19
behalfI3l-5:12,
6:14,23.
5:5
belong a -114:
31

114:7,114:9
belonging (
1I-156:9
s-,-- .
-,-zz,za,
zsrla
bench(t1-1z4:8
benefitI1I-167:9
Berkelzytl!-23:24
besttlpl-109:4,
109:
23 Is1:
4 210:6
224:14,:
435:19,
239:18,,
240:9.246:8

bit1181-10:19,
23:11 27:18I 28:2,
36:4 59:18, 81;9,
91:12 91:15.118:14I
138:151142:16,
170:1411:3:22.
181:17 181219,
183:121 204:10
bits(4I-42:2,
101:22,103:20,216:
9
Bitstll-102:19
btackI1l-244:6
blackboard(2)63:13,63:20
blank!2I-117:131
145:5
bl
ockI11-90:7
blocksrzl-196:23.
223:5
bodyIjI-234:16
bookst4I-T7:6,
81:161255:22,255223

155:194210:16
bucksI2I-153:22,
154:2
Budapestll!-39:3
buildI3l-143:4,
j96:21 197:4
building (4q - 28:12.
30:13. 31:8l 32:3l
34:8 41:23 43:15
43216 45:16 46:5
47:18 47:23 49:12
49:18 50:11 50:14
K :19 71:
3 71:5
71:8, 72:11 75:2,
75:24 83:17 84:12
&4:13,84:18,84:21
84222195:2,98:161
99:1,102:15.103:21,
110:14,111:12,
112:11,116:22.
124:11.124:151
143:21,146:24,

bom (1j-201:23

156:2,156:3,156:
Z,

boss(
n -176:19,
,ac,1s. lac.zo,
182:24 193:22.
19a:21
bottom I4)-118:4,
13()::s,132:18,
203:18
boughttl,-108:21

157:10,196:22
21s,1:'
buildingslll-70:19
buildspl-149:9
builtI2I-33:14,
207:11
bulklll-152:6
bunchz -zI4:13,

b
ound(11-9:10
Boxlll-161:16

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

C
cabinetI11-72:8
cabinetsI21-109:6.
115:1
calculationI11152:10
californialn -1:24,
2:9.2:1817:4,7:9,
z:18 206:6
cam era(jI- 48:4
camerasI
aI- 45724.
47:20 47:22, 48:1,
48:2 48:6, 114:23.
2% :
7
cannotjltl-9:11,
9:j2 20:5, 133:24,
134:2 136:5 181:4
190:
2 190:
4 202:4
capabilities(1I83:1
capabili
ty(,!-64:21
capaci
ty(
2I-33:1,
:$3:10

capitaljjlj.228:10,

2:
$6:
24 237:8
asz.z, zu ,lr,
246:
22 248:24
2sj:j5,2s2:7,252:8,
252:12
capitala -'
7f'
:2.4,
z8rll 2:
$4:
21
caqsl-Jzz:z4

1
51:22,151:23,
157215,178:22,

(775) 323-5492

c
ard(J;.59:17
cardiffll)-2:18

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 43 of 65

J'- $

cards111-25:19

16:Z.19.Z 126:1't

care(
:$1-81.21,

162:11.174.6,237.81 70.12 98:3 2233

81224.233:23
career(,I-210.
23
case13q -13:13
13:18.14:7.16:13,
16.17.21:21.24:18,
75:15,81:Z,91
7,
117:11I126:13
127:22,128:2,
129:12I129:13,

131:13I140212
205:151210516
210219 213:23
217:20.218:2,218:
51
221:2.237:17' 249.19
Gases(s)-173:10.
206:4.206:11I222:4.
222'6
categorieslsl180:14
cateaoryia 180:15.180:17
caution !1)-249:15
ccq21-1:24 259:21
cdtw,-s',:s,
145:10,163:17,
164:2.164:1n,

1s4:13164:15
'
..

(
'

154:18.164:20.
165:131165:16:
1s5:19.167:11,
:7(':-/-,240:11,
240113,240:14
cdst,s,-l4:,,le
1.3:19.1-'*'1n.
l.4,ls ,4.,24
,

lt'f:lz lsagz
.
.
ls3:la. lss:ls
C6RtiM :2l-1116,

111:12
centca z -cxa:,z,
249:19

ceq''-22''
2
ceroinrzn-cz:lg,
2a:s,ss,s.gzr2z'

98'21,1n4'14 1 :.,

'.

'

certi
h'11I-259:
6
chalk(1)-69:9
chalkboardi1169r13
cham bers(4114:19I 15:20, 134'7,
134:19
chancell)-233:20
cuanoelwl-alrzo
108:13 149:18
16a:11
chanrr
ed(1)-159:11
chanrj
esI1I-49:19
chaosz -44:11.
.z:1
chapllnp)-1:24,
2:9:4 ;!ts:
21

't's:':
''125:7
128:12,128:17,
136:24,lz:ln,
187:11,188:17,
217:10,224:922::29,23(,:1z,
236:1.236:s,24o:1a.
242:24
certainl
y(
:4,-6:201

ciscoyl-65 14.
citationI2I-1365,
136:14
cites(1)-127.11
citizenI11-193.1
citytl)-22.10
clarified (11-153.19
clarify(11-90:23
cl
arity(1I-13821
classest1)-227211

classification(
4)16:16 125:4, 176.24,
167:24
classitied1441-12:9,
14:5' j5:17x 16:15,
27:20, 21.24, 28:1,
28:3I 44:18, 47313,
71:14 82:24. 83:3,
aa:1()'aar2()97:12
97:13 102:2, 102:3,
102:
4 :()2:s.1c2:z.
102.8 102:101103.9,
103:11 106:9 125:4
126:19.128'17.
1z9:1. 1zg.,,12a4,
133.101140:19,
J4o:22,l4lJs,d4lfi;,

18:11,136:4,219:16

146214 146'20

clientsi$l-140:9

147:9,147.10,

Go-counselI2!*

1715'21 178.22

clone (21-73:8.
198:10
cloned f11-198E$
cose(2)-162'14,
162:15
ctuster(
21-T2.3
72:10
co(3I-5:16s80:13,
239:5
5:16,80:13
co-trusteest1)23925
code12x1-20:18'
27:8, 27212, 27:17.
27:24.28:z,28:11,
28:13,29:1929:15,
29:19 a9:22.aa:l
30:4,30:23,32:41
a2:19.3z:1a,a4:1
37:20141:24,43:6
47:11.49:24,53:5
54:19,54:22,54:23
ssia,ss:s.ss:ls,
56:21,58:10158:20
s:21-ss:24,s9:14,

cl
aakert'l-22sls 14
:a:us
a,et
14s1l:-12
ls
z2,
:l4 s
9:2:s
,5s9:
9:214.
z.6s0:
9:3.
19'
ct
2,
41
:2
59:
0,
charaaterizationtll

1ss:2,16s:4,16s::o, .sa:z:$

'4s,'4,'-o,ls,
14s's''ss''t)'
155:15.161:3.

237'24.238.3 2437
244:8,:.
45:8,245.9
Certainlylll-2294
Certificatea -65,
7:7.7:11
certificates(1I141:10
certified I
2)-1069.
107:8

aGharaaterizel

se:19 (;s:j(;
charae. - z<,z:$,

zsrj 8:;Jj(;ajgrjs

,
22:$:.
,0 '
oha. z;- 2a9,9,
z2a,ls
rl- xs,zzI
Ghecg
4s,
2:
$ ..1s,s 11a9
145:1 .;5.
/:24, z!()2j
.
cl.lecldedf,l!-sorl.
.
'
9:1s, ..10:11
1j():15 118:11
g

121:2:$,124:3.,19a:,.

19a::, -:,(m,,:$.2,9,,a
h 'kingllj-167:6
() ec
c',icagotdl- ,za,1
cxefdz,- s,,z.
z:(),z:
, 212,:
212,1.; 212,20;
2z.:1s'z.6,19'
china'ljj-175:6

clw sel'l-2s2:1z
csronol
. ogyp;1s:1:$. 126:3
chul,:-121:14
chucai
l-121:1a
ojrcujnlslt
ancesi1145:3

(..-j

z41:2:
$,242:14,

246:16j248.
21
cleanIaq-40:1.
sl,a4,a2:2,ltp:lo
clean-upltl-4021
c,eaned r,,--ta,la
clearo -las.za.
,s,,z 2,a.
, zx rzl
,
,
cleasancepel1z,14 20,,z . ,1a,
p :2j,8.1:20.8g:g,
'
2rz sz:z,
,z,,, ,:
.
'
'
s2:23.sa:2 :3.s,
' 153:8,
83:16,113:5
,
'sa,ll,,92.
22,
21a,
2a
clearancest
c2s:24,:v,1,s1,12.
s2.,,,is,ds,,02,,1,
,c2,,s
clearlytlI-zx .ls
',
aearlyx -zxo,lr
243:19,244:151
24s:
.
r 2sa:?,
.
clerkpj.69:9,
(srjz tsrz4 zx :22
.
z4.
;sa.zssr
z.
. 14:11,
cIerksj.
1.
?.:
24 1(ja:9,za:
.
/
,tsj. ja:j(),
en
t
7tj

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

6a:
4.60:6,f50:1u.

60.22:69:24y61:2.
61.3,61:13,61:16
t;1.1z.62:s,62:a.
62:15,52:18,62220,
s:$,2.isa,6,io ,.
?.
sz,pz,sz,21..
?a,,o
zs.c,,a,,z,,s,a4,'
91,9,91,1c,92.
a
9:
''1a.9:
$:22,9.,'3
100:12,:04:5,
loz,
ea,11.
,,1,
1:s:1a 11a:1()
,
'
119:
2.119:81128:10,
128:
20,128:24,
1an:4.1:,1.9,,:
,2:a.
132:15,132:19,
1:
$:
$:.,::$:
$::0.lzs'
s.
'a7:tz.apzl.
:aa,:
,.::,a,.
,,,aa,2(),
,:$9.,,,:'9,s,1za,1:,
:39:14.'aa:''
,'
139719.14021,
140:13,:40:16,
140:17,140223,
142:12,142:13,
142:21.143:6,
143:16.145:8.

145:23.145:24,
146:3.14625,146:11*

147:13,147.17
149:51149:7 150:9
150:14,150:21
151:2I151(9,152:16,
152:21I152:22,
154:11.165:20
169:
22,170:11I
170L12,178:17.
1Z8:181178:19
178:241179:1 1Z9:3,
1Z9:6,179:8 179:10
179:15,179:1E5I
182.13,183:2' 183:6'
1835181183:21,
185:4,185:7' 185:11I
186:5,186:8,186:11,
186:14 186:18
1tV t1Z,188:4 188:7,
188:1.1sa:23,
189:1'189:11,
1B9:141189:191
189:24.190:9,
190:12,19o:1s
192:1,193:12.
195:1n,196.s,

196:12,197:
4197:8
197:101 197:11.

197:12,197:1s,

197:20'198.4'
198:10,198:12
198:20.19.5:2,,
204:16,205:111
2('z:24,2na,'
2os'24'2c9,1,ze9,
4,
2na,9, 2Jo,z,c11,11,
z1*,z,21.,10,
214:12,214',.,
215:15,215:18,
2:s:2a 217:1 2,.
/:s
2:z:1(),21-/:11
.
218:6.218:12.
zjarjzl'zal
ljz'
220:
1:$,zanrbs,
221:1,222:
22,
222:
23'223:'2,
a2*:12
codect
m -gs,s.
9s'24''4t''.,14n''2.
141:21,141:
22,
141:23,151:20
codecsl
zl-95:19,
140:6
codedl')-J4cr7'
code.
s(s:
q-2a:2,
49:7,49:17,49:20.

5
0:7.50:14,50:15.
jz rj6,x tztj,syLj4,
58:5, 58:15,58:19,

(775) 323-5492

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 44 of 65


f.-...-k
!1k
,
)
)
.

59.10 60:3 61:12.

61:13,62:4,66:21.

90:15,94:22.98.20,

conjunction(21-

com plianceI1)ez:22
com plied!21-6:111
2f$6:1

98:22I99:201105:3,
106:4.106:13,
106:16,106:17.
107:2.109:11,

117:24 244:10
connectpl-64:6,
16gr4
connected(4I-

109116,109:18,

64:1g 113:
22

110:23,11327,
113:10,113120,

114:23 22z:z
connection(2I-

114:3.114:11,

e4rzrw:10

29:45 29:18 45:20,


47:15 $7:19. 50:22,
z7:2 7::7, z7:21,

165:13 199.24.
a2tjxjz

az:lz 126:11
164:
21 180:2 190:9
190:12.200:8,
200:11 200:14
zc4:18I 204:20,
209:10 210:12.
210:20,212:10.
212:15.212:21.
213;1, 214:7, 215 12.
218:3I 218:9, 218:11I

gar:s
compressingl118'j,:4
com pression1681j2:24I .J4:1a,z4:j6,
76:17 77:3,86:51
:f;.1aT86:20,86:22,
8.,
.:2Iaz:aIazzj2,
88:1' 88:13, 88:16.
88:22, 88:23I 89:2.
89:s 89:14. 90:41
90:14.94:3.94.6I
94:10I 94:20I95:3s
95.4. 96:2. 96:17,
96:24,99:4,99:6,
99:10, 99:14.99:161
99:21,99:24.100.71
100:13, 130:14,
133'4I140:6I140'8,
14629I 163:11, 164:2,

colleotivelytll109:8
collectively(:I55:9,55:19,56:20,
59:10159:24,60:5.
152:21,230:23
cellege(1j-227:11
Golorlll-244:6
colorizationi$1243:21

coloriz.eI
zI-243:13,

(
'

complexI11-63'10

1Z0:17,186:2.2.
193:9.193:13.195:1,
coding (2Q1-58:16,
58:1/,60:
6185:4.
85:20.86:20.87:7,
87:21.87224,88:12,
88:16,88:22,89:1,
89:6)9073,102217,
178212,178:13,
182:14,196:10
collectivepl54:21,82:13,145:14

zz.2), :2.13.87:14i

223:14,223:15,
223:21.227:17,
228:61 228:21,229:3.
230:8. 233:3' 238:11.
239:15.240:15.
240:17, 243:16.
245:3,249:11,250:6,
250:16, 252:21
com lhany'spl100218,223:9, 223:11

Compan#s($I-

244:5
com bination Iq 156:23,160:101
160:12.179:11,
179:13,179:16
com bine(21140:15,182:17
combinest1I-

176:16
com partm entpl153:14
com partmentasized
(1l-17:2
oom pilationrzl256:
6,256:10
com pileI4l-37'20.

147:
24

56:15,57:9.153:6

coming1121-25:171
38:
4,38:9,42:21.
43:1B,48:5,70:10,
70:11.112:10,
112:12,124:
7,202:17
Gom mand (
3l39:22.40:13.146:24
commandsI2I222:
5,222:9
com ments(1)-

com plled(7I-27:10,
28:10,56:22,139:
6,
139:21,146:21209:2
com pilerpl146:23,147:16
compilesI3)-147:3,
147:5, 208:24
compilingpl88::0, 146:17,208:23
com plainp)-51:20,

36:22

1Z6:
3,176:9'195:14.

141:12.170:16,

166:22,166:24,

complained(21-

238.1
com rl,itteet4l2s0:'?.:!s0:11,
250:13,250:14
com nlon(11-222:24
com m unications(11
-2:5.8
com paniesI2I222:21. 223:6
com rlanylzl-1:9,
1z6:18
com pany(6$118:12 26:8' 26:14,
26:18127 28:22
:6

19s:s:1ss:8?224:12

''

commitmentI1l.

51.23.52'16

s:4 89:11 89:18,


90.14 91211,91:12,
91:19 91:24.92210,
96217 96:22.96:23,
97:13.98:21I101:9,
101:12 102:22
102:24.1:3:23,
104:3 105:11.
105:22.106.21,
106:24.107'5,
107:21#115:11I
116:2,116:14.
116:24,119:141
119:16 140:4
.

208:15

53.4.53 5
com pletelq -20 10.
34:1,34,3,:4s:24,
146 3.165'21
com pleted(3134.20,352,216.10
com pletely!s13t':13,40'21,118:19.
119.11,121:16

componentsa -

compressedt11-

164.10I164:14.
1*4:20.164:24,
1s5:14.167:11,
206:15.206:171
206:20,207:4,207:7,
207:12,228:8,
230:18.236:1,236:51
237.
6,240:191
242:
24.243:8

compressiono pe
pl-74:13,76:17,77:3
compressorl
sl140:13,141:21,
141:231145:18,148:6
Computeq,)-56:10
computer(:
151-24:2.
24:
4.25:15140:14,
52:
6'56:12,63:171
71:
29.10151115:1,
148:3.160:21,

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

195.171200:Z,
200:20.200.21.
20::22,205:6.205.8,
205:16.205219,
205.231206:3,208:2,
208:4,208:6.208:8.
221:8.221:19
Gornputers(421Z0:18,89:15,90'21

114:15,115:41
115:11,115:12,
115:15,115:21,
116:2,116.6.116:24.
120.23,121:2,121:3.
121X,122:181124:3,
166:17,211:19,220:8
Com puterstzl208:31210:9
Gonceptl21-177:6.
?''2318
GoncernI5I-16:23,
126:24,129:6,
135:13,171:17
Concerned I31124:24,211:171
252:14
Goncerrls(1l-19:17
GonclusionI1136:13

Condititm sI
1I230:20
conducttxl-t4:ls,
20:8.45:8,80:8
conductedI1118:17
confer(2I-10:1.
10:8
conferences!11-

conform I11-108:10

confrontedI1I132:7
confused(1)-194:4
confusing(2I90:18 91E3
confusion(11236:10
Congratulationslll202:1

consecutively(11z:!9:14
COnSidera - 52:22.
jz.;L2g 1(jr)::$
GOnSideralgy(1).
z4j:6
consjdored(1j. 8:14
constantjy(jj.
65:12
consulo ntI11jK i4
consulted!11-99:2
consulting (21206:1,206:2
consum ingl1)217:18
contactldll-113:3
127:
24,130:
7,130:'
21
contactedlq 112:15,112:j8,
112:23, 113:2,219:6
containpl- 19:12
contained(a)144:23, 154:17
containerlll163:18
containers!s)- :3:6,
83:18. 113:
8.114:1,
1s6:21

10:6
conferencingI1110:21
confidenta 182:11,196:8,196:9
confi
dentialI2I18:20,21:16
confi
dentiality(3114:20,18:1'19:14
confi
ding!1l-24:19
configured(1J-

containsI2I-37:
5,

j1():6
contempt(1)136:10
contentts1- 16:1.
17:11. 2712z,j5z:z:
$
contents(9I- 16:7,
91:2:
$,92:1,94:17,
100:
4, 104:6,1s6::,
15.
/rjz,
j6(:s
jc z()
context
q:
- 211:
,

(775) 323-5492

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 45 of 65


. ...
.'
I
'.- .....
($
!
.

22125,225:10

..

t
'

'
j
k
'

'

185:11,18722,19019

continueI41-76:
7.

convertsI11-147'6

96:12 128:1 144.1ts


Continuedlal-3.11
214:4
continued(1)-26:12
continuing(2156:1.216:19
continuously(j1180:19
contractllal-ss:10,
65:18.65:20,66:6,
66.14.66:19.68:3,
68:5.68:16,68:20,
82:20182:22.103:11,
128:11 132:11
154:7.166:81241:23
contractor(1I-26:3
contractors(1j84:
20
contracts(1zI66:21,79:16.101:2,
103:9$104:13,
104:
20.115:8,133:s,
138:3,199:18,200:2,
2K :3,241:9
contributelzl238:3.252:
6
contributedlsl230:18,240:z.

convicted (aJ-79'8.
79:15 i?(1.5
convtition(1I-81:1
convitlced I11136:17
copietl(2l-32223
37:7
copiesllaj-34:1.
34:4 34 '
?'34:9
34:20 34.23 68:14
68:17,108:10
108.11 142:24
156:17 166:8
copy(:h11-34:4
34:17,117:7,117:12
118:15 126:2 15::6
158:7 159:5 159:19
162:11 223:14
229:5 230:4 232:2
232:7.235:18,
239:16.246:5,248.3
255:1
copyrightlll184:18
cordI1I-27:9
corepl-12:1z.
12:18 14:z
corelzi-1zs:22,

z4arls.243.2,2s2:8

17s.23

contributinga 239::3,240:2t),
240:22
contributionta!12:23. 14:5.164:s
164:9 1e4:1s.
228:19 230:21 239:
3
K ntributionr,,238:16
contributorpl2a9:6
controllq -23:13,
t2z:1e 122:1a,
219:7' 211:
4' 259:16
controlsz - zl:17,
210:21
conversationl,a 53:24 s4:12 93:s
9z:10, 9z:21, 120:2:,
124:!2' 126:9'

corporatesl2s0:1s. 2ss:23
255:24 256:4
correctlsn-13:22,
25:23 2::3 27.77
2a.s s4 5 ss:l3
ss:lz z3:14 74:17
za,2,i,:s,(),s4,:,.

1s
3:
1
'
2
s1
:1
17
8'
25
s3
2:
:2
24
'
O nvevationsz 4s:2, 4s:
24' 82:2,
132:21' 204:17,
2o9:a, zs1:2t
convertx - 1za:,:$,
178:17,
C@nverteda -

181:17, 229:6,257:8

136:17.136:19,

123.
5,122:21'

259:8

137:
2'138:11'

137.13 137:19
13824 139.16
13921,146:21.
14/'111147:15
148'4 155.13
160 18 160:19
161.2I161220.
163.12,177:16.
185 l3
CorrectionalI,l205'8
Gorrelates(1)I64'14
correspondingI1)15225
correspondsil1140:1
corrupt(1I-97:6
costlytll-223:15
Counsellaj-74:19,
79 18 106:6 114:17
138:5,204:13
222.19,238:24
counsel(12,-5:91
5:16 8.9 8:20 8.21
9.8.18:1s,21:12
ao:l3 11a:1,162:1,
232:11
19:1
countll)-8:21
country(11-34:20

Courtlaagl-1'5. 5:4,
5 19 5'21 6:12 6.23
7.18 8:5 8:15 8:18
9'6 9:14 9:1I 10:2
10:12 10:15 11:4
1117 11:20 11:24
12:2 1224 12:6
12:10 12:12 12:18
12:24 13:14 13:19
13:23 13:24 14:2
14:14 14:22 15r1.
15:3 15:5 15r7 15:8
15:14,15119I:5:21,
17.6,17:12,17:17
17:21,17:23,18:13
18:20 18:22 19:7
19:9 20:6 20:9
20212,20:20,21:1I
21:5,21:8,21:10,
22:18,23:2,23:4,
23:1.23:10,23:15,
23:17,23:20,24:10
24:20,25:1.25:6,
35:15,35:19,35:241
36:3.36:7.36:14.
42:7.42:11.45:
6,
45:14,46:9.46:12,
52:9,52:11,s2:18.
53:20.55:14,57:3,
63:21,63:22.65:4.
66:16,67:5,67:8,
6T:11,67:14,69:7,

138.13 142.16
144:1 144:12
146:13 151:4
151:13 151:16
152:15 152:19
152:23 153:2 153:5
153:7 153:10
153:16 154:51
154:10 154:15
154:22 160:5
162:21.162:23,
163:3 167:18
167:20 167:23
168:2 168:5 169:8
169:10,169:12
169:23 170:1 170:5
170:9 170:15
170218,1702
23,
171:2.171:6 171:14
171:17,172:4,172:9,
172:14,172:19,
173:
6 173:8 173:15
173:17.173:21,
174:2,174:6,174:9,
174:19 175:8 1N :3
178:7 181216
183:13,183:231
184:7.14:11,
189:21,190:21,
192:15,198:24,
199:2,201:13
202211,202:13,

counwa -J:s.

caunsel'stzl-13.
4,

86:21 s?:8,89:16
90:16,91:21,93:19.
s6:13.1.)2:2 losrz
106:5,115:24'
11s:19.120:1.120.4,
120:10.122:20.
13::23 140:1
147:1n,'
Iso:ls
1s9:8,1t
59:17,
1z9:24.1as:2,
191:17.4
199:9,
212:
23,:?13:3,

2
:
143,2
8:
22
:$2
::
2
;?2
3s
:2
12
a,
,

109:1,11I'D 1202

239:16,:?41:17,
246:9,2:19:121250:8,
250:9,255:1,2562231
2s9:1a
correcqcsl-snls,

69:11,69:14,69:18,

202216,202:201

7s$':' c'qo.a
couplegn!-2s:1a,
32:
2 3s:9 ss:9. s9:3'
ss.a',(o ,'
,s
s.
.
. loa,
11():1 113:7, 113.8
lllr:sv 119.
21,
126:1t) 13z:6, :4z:3
165:5' 168:T' 182:221
1a9:1a,19s)a, 19z:a,
197:19' 198:8, 201:6,
201:23 218:19 250:4
couplel
a)-ss:a,
s6:11
courselsl.1a:4.
as:17. 122:17,
212:17 247:7

69:22.73:18,73:22.
?5:4.79:11,79:17.
79:23,80:11,80:13.
8o,li'.so,22,a2,1o,
89:19.89:23,90:21
90:24,92:17.92:19.
92:21.92:23,93:3,
10Z:12,107:15'
107:18.1C*:2,108:5,
108:Z,108:14,
11c:22.11z:16'
121:5,124:
22,125:1
125:9,125:11,
125:13,125:14.
126:6,126:
8,127:10,
127:17,127:19,

202:24.203:23
214:5,204:16,
2% :21,204:23,
zoz,co,2c8,1,
20a:12 209:14.
209218,209:20'
211:15 21211.212:4.
213:8 213:10l
214:23,216:18,
216:21.218:18,
z22215'224:,.225:7.
225:10 225:14
225:18,225:
23,
226:1 226:3 226:6,
226:9,226:14'
229:12,229:15,

co:u
sz-141:4'
141
sze
courtl
aol-srlo
6:19I 14:9, j4rjo.
,
14:11 16:20 17:6,
21::2.6):,:e '
127:2
12.
?.
:,z
' jao':2z '

1
:/
2
:1:24
5,
12
28
9:
2,
41
19
30

1
22
9:
D9
2
29
:1
28
3.
231:
:2
10,
231:9

131:10.131:15,
131:20.132:5,13226.
132:13.132:18.
133:
s'133:19,
133:24, :34:4.

231:15,232:4,232:9,
232:12,232:15.
232:19,232:22.
2.
33:1, 233:4,2a3:a,
z:'3:17,233:20,

183:1,18316 /4:1B,7t5:16,83:11, 1
32:
241134:11'
,
M :4,93:201102:13,
134:17 161:19
,

L IZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

'

'

1
M:121134214.
134:20.135:12.
135:20. 135:23,

2
33:
23,234:3,2M:
9,
234:13,235:6,
235:12:235:17,

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 46 of 65


?
.,.Ah
7
.
?

l
!.

..

(
.

'

235:21 236:13
236.17.237210
240.1I24023 241:4
241:5.241:10
241:20,242:71
242:21,245.16,
245:20,247:11I
247:15,24-J:181
248:9,249:17,25312.
253:11,253:16.
253:21.253:24.
254:6,254:9.254:15,
254:18.255:11
255:18,256:15,
257:8,257:13.
2s7':1'?,257:2:,
258:2.259:5
CourtsI1I-63:19
courtrtm m (111*
12:15,14:13,15:23,
1829.21:15,21:181
24:9,172:17,209:24,
220:4,220:6
covering(1)-17:10
crashedI1I-52:4
create(111-57:11,
58:5:58:24.59;10I
69:41146:18,147:18.
1472
21,14923,
158:20,228:8
created112;-56:10,
87:20,145:4,146:19,
148:18,158:18,
169:21.195:1,
195:17.199:81
199:11.238:17
ce ate.sI4I-139:22,
147:41147:6,147:22
creatiag l
71-T3:10'
85:4 85:20 85:24
'
.
'
j93:8,193:12,218:11
creation ($1-76:3
crim inal(1)-129:22
critlcal(1j-135:16
Crossg?l-3:4,3:7,
3:12,53:20153:22,
192:17,218:21
CTOSSI
21-11:5,
80:23
CrO rrexam ination
I
3l-3:4,3:7,3:12
cross-exam ination
01-80:23
cross-exam iningltl
- 11:
5
crystalt1I-236:21
Cscll-1:24
ctot
s)-210:
23,
212:16,223:10.
249:
23,250:1,250:19

curios.ity(Ij-153'8
curiotls(1I-19:1
currerltI101-7:21.
30.11 75:9 84.12
84'13 96.14 145 13
159.18 203:21 227.1
c urrenttz)-3::3.
3725
curtailI11-183:14
custodyI2I-69:17.
69:18
custom erlz)180:23 18:$:z
cuta -:$s:21,
zs:23 :.03:1z
c* 6-(10114(zj.
j:jj sr/

D
daily(.q-17:7 17:8
149:24, 245:12' '
dam age(1l- 204:21
dam alles111- 41:14
dark(1I-130:5
data (411-12:24
'
Z4:13 i4:16 76:17
'
'
77:2. 8iI:4,86:17, '
86:201 EI8:16,88:22,
89:2, 89:5,89:14
'
90:4.9O.14.91r11,
94:3, 94:5,94:9.
116:9, 130r14,133:3,
141:21 145:18,
.
163:10, 164:1.
164r10,164:14,
164:20, 164:23,
165:14, 167:11,
206:5 J.
06:10 2074
'
'
'
215:11, 215:14
2j6:a g:!j2z gz
'1:j:j,
2gj::s
'
'
databases(1j2(j5::
dateI1s)- 7:19,
4::x 65:5 gzra
' '
95:24'
2,96:231
, S5:
110:11 jj():j5
117:13 163:21
163:z3,16s:6.2c2:./.
238:17 2s9:
oatedll)- 259:1a
dated (q- 231:10.
2:$1:1.2.. 2a9:.7..
245:24 247:22
datesr1j- 48:22
daughtero z()j:2:
$, ;
?o2:j
oavid 2)-2:8, 5:15
dapto-day(a1-

2455 250.3
days(s1-7.:4.806,
1034,143:3.198.19
days'(11-7219
Ddlll-68 15
deadI21-241.13,
24118
deal(1c1-12:22,
59:16, :0:16,93:13,
130 151133:3.
219 12 229:24.
239.12,256:16
dealing(xI-12.13.
60:23.61:3,225:4
cleals!1I-140:14
clealtz -85:6,
8z:12, 112.4.112.5
1jz:(;11z:a 11z:j4
decadeI11-206.18
decayIjj- 21().11
oecemberlls)1z
tr:).15:j:$,15:j(5,
2s:21.:$:::2.33.a2,
:
p :js.:
$4:j7.:$4:1().
51:1().a3:21.8625,
1zs.:2:'216:2.218:1()
decide(6!- 12:18.
jas:17 144:6
,
.
1(
;a:
2(),1a3:15,
1a4:19
gecisionI3j16a:2(),245:-/.iz52:jj
aecjsions(1)- 245:6
oeclarationx s42j7.ssrz,jt.;:a
,
jj.;.ztl,1n Lj:$
oecjarauonstl)/s:j5
.
decl
assjfy(jj. 51:7
decom pressor(111zj1.z4
oeveoaanta -5:2j.
6.14
oefendantsp)1:16 2:11
(jeflense(21-15:12,
206:13
oefensel
aj- 42:20,
4:s:z;! a:$:j4 jzz:9,
122.:2:,jza:j6.
jzgr.
; ztsrjz
define(1I-240:6
Definelll-142:16
(jefined(1)- l4lTa
definzons(1)152:1
Degreel
a -176:
2,
2:5.,
degreelzq-176:8,
205:
7 227:11

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

delay(3I-7215
13:1t; 13:16
delegatedI1I-102:1
delegatesI1)-102'3
delete(111-31:12
51.5.51:10,51:14,
53:3.107:2,135:7,
149:191149:20,
222:9,223:13
deleted fz01-20.18,
35::0,40:9,40:21j
4122141.24143:7,
45:24,49:2 50:22
51.2151:15,51:18,
51:21. 52:16,53:4,
53:6.53:11,53:12,
s3.1s,53:16,53:18,
61.22 62:2 62:5,
88*24. 89:
3,89:9,
91:23193:18,93:21,
9324I94:2,94:4,
94:1'1494:22,95:16I
100:9, 100:11I106:1I
110:
23, 111:1.
118:11, !18:20,
119:11.119:121
120:13,135:2,
135:11, 150:1.150:5,
169:
3,169:7,170:22.
171:4,190:9,190:12.
204:22,209:10.
210:4,211:20,214:7,
214:19.218:61
220:12,221:4.
221)12.221:23,
222:1,224:13
del
etingl1j-221:10
del
etionI1l-97:8
deliverI11-132.16
delivered I21- 66:24
.
67:19
delivery I1I-67:20
demfmstrationsi4I23773,237:5,243:10,
243:18
denied(11-144:12
Dennislssl- 1:12i
1:13.26:2,37:8938:5,
38:19.39:23140:5.
41:24.44:1'44:17'
46:
6,47:5,4727,48:3,
4877,49:9.49:23,
50:21S0:18,51:23,
52:2.52:3'56:2'
62:10164:15166:19,
Z1:13.72:2,72:3,
72:
9,Z2:14.72:24,
73:1,75:1i75:17,
/6:1,Z8:
3,Z8:111
82:16.86:14.104:4,

111:24.114.21I
11927,123:3 138:2,
143:17,144:11,
145:12 149.13
194:23 227:20
227.21,228:7.
235:22,239:4,239.6,
239:131.
243:3.
245:10,251.8,252:9,
252515
Dennis'(21-47:5,
51:13
Dennisontll-2:4
Departm entl/l127:9,127:20,
128:16,129:7,
206:12.2s():8
departm ent(,I-

24:17

Depttll-1J12
deptll!1)-251:21
deputyI1J-:4:11
describe!14)-12:5.
12:16,23:22,25:10,
27:5,36:21,38:1,
47:21'49:5.55:22'
96:22r149:6'154:1.
185:20
Describe11l-77:17
describedpl1s2:j7'js4:3,
156:12,157:2,157:4,
164:j5'j85:1,j94:3
describing(21114:20I152:22
description I3I66:15.66:17,113:15
descripti
vet'
zl100:
21, 103:6
du ignp)-24:2,
196:24
Designationttl-4:2
designed(1I-208:4
designing (1I-85:16
desk($)-40:17
uestroypl- 141:7,
222:2:$,223:9
destroyedI11-221:9
destructlf). 98:11
destructsllj- 98:21
detailspj- 66:ja,
143:11
detectpl-154:14.
178:3,181:1.185:
241
1a6:j()jw t: j:j:4,
191:7, 194:22
detectingpl- 192:4

de1t
ction22,
pal65:
5e
, 120:
128:13, 128:22,

(775) 323-5492

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 47 of 65

t..- )
'

l''

..

('

,...

('
''
.

128:23.1M :8.
1T6:14,176:241
177:1.183220.
185'23 186:1,
186'16.187'5,
187:15,187:20.
18/:221192:7,
195:13.195:16,
212422,221.9,222:20
detectspl-98:5
223:11223:4
determ inationIxI16:6,91:2 210:3
213:11
determ ine!8l53:17.99:21,144:5.
211i19k221:3,
226:11.250:15,
251:13
determ inedI2l44:16 118:9
determ iningI2)44:15I191:10
develop(321-27L11,
28:10,128:12,139:4.
213:22,222:24,
230:16.236:23,
237:1,237:9.244:19.
252:10
developed(121-

dial-up (11-64:4
dichotom ya 12:21 14:3 130:13
dictatet$I-229:2
died(1I-52:4
differljnt(44j-272
2z:5 31:1, 31:8,
4z:24 (4:23 5625,
'
?2:s 1(I
()r
20, 119.21,
1:$9:23 J40:3
140215 140:17,
140:22 141:14
141r16 14223
142:12 142:19
142:21 143:7
147:131148:15,
148:21 150:151
150:18 159:2,1673
179:17, 179:22.
180:13,185:20,
186:21 191:21
196:5,205:11,
205:16,205:19,
209:8.2'12:21
220:17 244:13 249:9
differentiatet1j221:7
differthntly(11180:19
diffictllt(21-216 5,

26:11I27:13128:161

217:24

28:19 55:24 150:14,


168:12,184:17,
191:19,191:22,
222:22,228:9
developertzl1472 1,206:22
developing (2127:15.5s:1
developmenttlol26:10,26:12I26:21I
212:161214:13,
220:23,244:21,
250:3,251:23,251:24
Developmentpl119:9
devicep,-98:2,
98:4,98:18.152:16,
2 :21,221:8,221:9
222:20.223:8
deviou (
41-97:23,
98:10,120:22,222:22
devotepl-237:19,
245:20,240:22
Devoteda -23'
?:1s,
246:13,24::18
Devserverlll-38:14
diagram 1
21-70:31

diffictllty!31-8:8,
22:16 ;.2:21
digita!(b1-175:16
digitally(:I-48:5
diluted(11-252:15
dim ensionalI!1..
176:2
Dinll,-243:11
(jire(
1)-212:
3
Direga)-3:11, 212.6
direct(4I-62:4
% :19 17726 241:24
oirectlloj- 3:3,3:
T4
3:1c 3:1j a:14 az:s
lz4rlz zoars 214:4,
226:21
directed (1)-147:13
ojrectinglll- 37:21
directing(1)- 127:3
directiona z11:s y.
s9:1s
directlytjj- 87:
23
uirectora - 26:9,
21c:.Iz.212:1s.
zj2:j8
dkrectories(4I211:1oj,z14:1sj,

74:8

2t4:1(
5

dialI1l-64:4

.- .

190.4,190:5,201'2.
214:13
disagree111-109 19
disappeared!:1120.10
disclose(sI129'21,130:22,
133'15,134:22,136:5
disclosed(4j24:23 136:7 136.8
203.19
discoverI1I-39:15
discovery(2I161'23 162:2
discreteI1)-169.6
discuss(2I-19:6,
j34119
discussed (sI21:17 21:19 127.13
244:15 251:10
discussion(4h80:2 127:22 240:17
253:1()
DiscussionI912j:24 szr4 70:6
172:22 1z5.7
246:10 ass.1a
257:1()257 1(5
disoussionsa 46:14 79:6 228:5
17c:1 170.2 17* 4
198:10 217 j5
disksI11-210:10
displayI11- 150:21
dissertationI
41176:11 176313,
1./-J:1a'j7720
distiaction(2I(p:2j 6:
$:1
distinguish I1j177210
djstributeIj).
230:16
oistrictsl- 1:s,1:7,
129:1s 2s9.s
dividedj1j- 72:12
divi
sions(11- 70:5
Dixonp)-43:22,
44:11 83:21, 112220,

Doctorlll-192:20
docum ent1161153:1 166:5 167:2,
16Z:4.208:21,
233:12.233:18.
234:7.234:16.235:4.
235:T.235:91235:13,
235:14,235.18,
236:11
documentationt1116:18
documents(!0124:15. 24:21 25:2
42:22,11Z:14,
133:15,162:51166:7,
256:71256:10
D0dI1)-107:8
dollarsi41-13223I
238:13,252:18,
252:22
done126)-21:141
41:7, 67:17,76:15,
87:7. 101:5.102:5.
105:2 105:10
134:17, 146:22
178:13:182:10,
182:19.187:5,187:6,
188:2 192:2 195:8
197:8,206:5 206210
208:13.220:18.
221:11,237:3
door!2I-39:18.44:8
doorsE1J-112:13
doubtl3l-167:10.
225:1,225:2
DOug(11-5:16
down 1251-64:14,
72:22 7s:17 zs:18
75:20,75:23,75:24,
z9:18, s3:
7,101:17,
114:3.172:11,
181:15, 181:16.
1:1:191181:23,
181:
24,196:5,
202:16,210:10.
233:16,249:18,
252115,256:16,
259:15
doWM taif's(11175:5,101:15,1Q5210,

157:23

123:201155:24

DII(1q -60 11,


146:16,14z.6,14a:.
r,
14a:1j j48 17
148:18 148 20
148:24j, jsl.21

DT(2l-192:21,
2:():1z
draw pl-63213
draWer111-166:18
drawers(2I-156:204.

diskI
61-163:17,

191:6, 1
13:21113:
23
1sG.11 168 pa

directaly (sj-190:3

()I1s(1!-6c:lz
rlmt:!- 72:21

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

Drexellzl-80:5
Drivelll-2:17
drive1221-33:4,
33:7 36.24 37:2
51:6,51:24,52:1.
52:7 110:13 116.8
118:22.121:16,
121:17 123:1 123:5
123:6,123:7,123:8,
145:7,158:12 161:1
170:6
Drivert:l-145:5
drivesp2I-34:7
45:21,48:18.51:7,
51:8,107:2 107%
108:1T,108:24,
109:2,110:2,116:41
116:21,117:21
143:1811442231
145:3. 145:5,145:15.
146:11.155:1la
155215,157:10,
157:13,158:11,
216:4,219:2 219:20,
219:21,220:2,220:3,
220:5
droveI1l-44:9
Dslll)-112:20
Dsstzq-83:14
157:24, 159:6,160:11
dueI2J-7:15,
130:11
dulyIzq-22:2,
174:141203:2.226:18
during!12)-14:13,
20:4159:1,59:9,
76:15.80:5.85:3,
237:22 246:23
247:6,249:1.249:3
Duringpj-s9:s,
77:1,247:1
duties pl-137:15
Dvls!-156:17,
157:9,157:15,
158:11 16627
Dvdpl-87:3, 87:4
Dvdsa -143:18,
144:24, 145:
8
dying(11-64:1'
F
Dynam icpl-145:4.

1
117
6,111:7.111:13, 14.
5:614a:13
121:9,123:17.

156:
22

drawing (:1-73:19

E
R ailIsI. 26:1a,
za:z4 51:1a sj:
2j
9'
?'
:j5
smail(jj- 32:4

e-mailsI
w-50:
21,

5():2z 52:1: s3:


4,

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 48 of 65


9
.

53'/.53:8153:11,
53:14
E-mails(11-53:9
early(4l-43.8,
137:
6 165:7 240:16
easierI1I-229.23
easily!1I-218:7
easyI11-93:8
editied11I-196:17
editedI1)-159220
editingI1!-103:3
euitionsB)-1s9:2.
159:7,159210, 160:24
editorpl-153:3
educated a -15:23,
91:6,196:18
educationI11-184:2
educational(
3123:22.205:3 227:9
effectI21-41:11
256:5
efficiency I
1)203:17
efficient(2)-207:6,
2a2:
z
effort(q -95:10.
99:20 105:21 113:9
113:19 201:21,
217:13 218:8
efforts(q-65:7,

em plciyment(al.
25:10, ti4;16.57224
empti
ed I1I-51:17
enablet1j-9i;:1is
enclypted11I-6427
Endtl)-258.5
end(9,-60:9. 68:21,
132:8 133:7 133'17
13624 148.2 228.15
ended (1)-228:13
ends(81-60:10
energiesl11-231$'4
enforcementf?l..
90:9 124:7, 124:8
124:16, 124218.
12728 129.21
engageI2I-161:23
162:
2
enginc(1s)-28:18
55:23 57:13 5828.
61:8I 62 11I63:3.
63:9,85 10 118:15
118:16.119:2,119 4
150:9,150:12
ermineert
x!-lszir
188:12.198:191199.1
engineeringIa)174:
24.176'9,180 8
Enginxi
eringlpl175:18

246:21.248:23
EiglAtl,l-57:14
either(1a1-:12,
10:1: 33:10,41:20,
75:1811> :15
113:20,124:1
125:22.135216
157:t7,165:7 170:4

188:16.'
188:17.
188:22. '
889:10I
189:15 '
191:15
196:11,:!15:23
217:4.2t$1:6
engines(1)-116:18
Englislltzl-152:14,
208:14

204:7,218:1 220:14
231:18 2s1:1s

enjoyI1I-126:12
enjoyed(,I-:2s:j1

237:
21238:3

elaboration (1Iy6i,:1s
electronicl4l25:19 27:3 179:3,
208:21

engineerspq-

enterlal-19:7,
19:10
enterecl(sI-19:11,
168:14, 222:6,
228:17 234:20

e
loq
udde
ence
3:
5 enteringI
1l-83:19
Om
be
d(
(1
11
1-1
enti (2I*15:6'
14
6:4
35:17 '
smergencytzl
*

.
95:15 97:19
'
em ployedtll-251:3
emp;oyees(1el25:22140:3,45:15,
46:7.51:
20,s2:16.

8
8:
6,88:21.2(
y4:18,
211:3 21z:24,
'

'

''

'

218:12,22::19
228:10 237:1 '
245:13.250:5,251:16
.
I

entities(zI-78:13
252:17
'
entitled pl-201:15
zjtyra.zatlrja
.
entrypl-83:16,
222:2

environmentl,l-

147:22
equipmanta 97:
23 98 12 251:16
,dI1J-,
elase
216:7

'

Ericlzl- 2:13 5:22


Ervplll-957
especially(1)217.24
E.'
squiretzl-2.4.2:5
2.8.2:12 2213. 2:16
2:17
establishI1I-98:10
established(1I9118
estimateo - 56:9
56 13. 1:9:4.109:8,
109:10. 109:23 161:
4
Et(15I-31:16,g4is.
119:1I119:9. 119:231
145:18 149:3 1498
149:10. 211:10
211:14 21428 214:12
Etaclzl-99.23
100.16
etreppid(1361-5:131
5:16 5.18 12:
21
14:4, 25:11.25:131
25:18,25:20,26:12
2e:!s,28:7 z1:1(
5
32:11I32:13,32:18,
33:12 34:2 49:
3
M *18,54:22 55:3.
55.5,55'22 55:24
59:11,62:5 62:18,
62:20. 63:2,63:6,
63;10.63:15,64:
3

174:22 180:1
180.1O,180:18
'
183:19 185'2 185'5
185.161185:21
186.181187'5
187:18,188:2 18827.
188:11 189:6.
198:181 200:1 209:91
211:11.211:18
224.101224:11
227:2.227:5 227:19
226:14,2S1:6.
254:23,257:
3
Etreppidtll-1:
9
Stv'Clll-95:6
evaluateI31-36:5
180:20,182:8
evaluationI1I213.15
events(21-45:/,
216'2
eventuallyI1J139:6
evidence(2sl9c:11 132:3 lzsrls
201:14.234:81
234:12 234:14
235:1.235:22 236:8
239:
24.240:4 241r1
241:
3I241:5 241:
6
241:13.242:6,
247:14,247:19

65:L 68:21.69:6,
M :15.78:16 7::22
'
i'
9:?,80:4 82:4.83.
2

248:
7.248:10,25428.
255:
6,256:20
exactpl-114:24,

83:8184:17 8525.
85:20,85:24186:
4
86:
9,66212,87:7
68:12.88:16,89:6

115:1
exactly(101-70:2,
102:21 130:4 144:5%
148:24, 151:8.

B9:15.90:3,90:151
91:
21,92:12.94:21,
94:22,99:6,99:20
99.24,101:1.101::1
103:81103:19,195:8

105:14.1W :5,
1
0Z
10
9721,108:18

:11'
109:18'
110:22'111:
4'
111:
23'112:18'
jj4r
#,jj4rrj,jjtj(7'
116:12, 116:19,
1ja j'ljarja'1z4:.
g'
ja, 11. l:
s :jz,
1293,129:8.130:21,
137.12,139:24,
,44:1,,41:11'
141:15,143:15,
j4:zz',0$:2.4.
166:11.166:17
166:12.1Z0:21'
,

LTZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

149:14 151. 19
15223, 152:
8,17779.
177L10 180:24
181;12 182.5,
185.23 195:13
196:14, 196:20,
243:11.244:7
except(71-15:181
21:18 70:24 115:13
119:
2 132:9 150:3
exceptionpl227:16

exchangelll-162:2
excludedI21-164:
9,
168:15
exclusion(11-1Z:14
exclusivelyI$1238:4
excuse(
2I-231:1
236:19
Excusej
:
q-181:16I
234:
6
excused I
8I167:22 172:12
,-/2:2, zzlz
202:17 202:19.
224:2 224:
3
executablellzl57:10 60:9 60:14
60:18 128:14 139:6
146:16 147:6.
147:18 148:1 149:3,
209:2 214:18
executabl
es(
i;
I6z:1g 67:22 146:9
146:15 150:20, 209:6
execute(1l-20826
executedp)-148.
:
3.
235:4 239:
7

154:19,169:20
171:15.252:4
Exactlytl)-147:19
Exam inationpa 3:3 324, 3:7 3:10,
3:11,3:11,3:12,3:13,
3:14 22:5, 53:22.
138:18.
15528,
174:17'192:17t
203:5'
212:6'
214:4.
zj8r2j'zzzrj.
y'
223:19, 226:21
examinatlonz ar
4,zrs,an azjz,
80:23'183:14'241:24
examinell)-99:20
examynjng Ijj. 1
1:s
examplepz
q- 50:1,
sqizj,.
r4:jz,w :4,
140:7 148:6 148:1z,
. 148:2-3
148:22
'
1

executiveI21-5:17
2s():1#
,
Executlvelll- 95:15
exhlbitlzn-231:24
24824 24$:14 253:
5
Exhibitl
sq - 4:3,4:4,
4:5 4:: 4:7 4::,42g
6g:)
2'
J():j1j21;5 1
12j:6'122:'1g '
1s6:1:1
229:9'
'
w ggj.y.$ rutjrjg
,
,
230:2 z.'
sa:l8q
2:$:
$:11
:
$ z:$arls
,
,

zyj
jrjtl,z:yyrja,

234:24,235:22,
za8:
22 238:23.

aar
z,;tsrza,:4::4
z4s:z'
? 245:23,
ayr
a'
zzrrja,
,

2
;:1r),a4.
ng(),
24
4z

(775) 323-5492

:21424826.

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 49 of 65


1:
..
.
'

248:10 253:4 253:5

253:6 25328 253:17

2z'
?:8
expected(,1-7:10

:
?0s:8

18:3
18:5, 24:5.24:11I,
24:13 24:19,203:12,
,
203:14
, 2032
21I
204
:
9,
2
0
6:
1
,206:3,
206
:13,207:19.
209216,21522.221.3
OXP@dise($)205
:22
experts(1I-21:19
Explainpl-57:3,
82:10.227218

explainIls;- 14:21,
16:8, 118:21.135:6,
139:1, 146:12,
151
:10,178:7,179:5'
184:15,190221.
284:16.204:19
,
208
:1, 242:
4
explained pl193:18,243:21,252:9
explainingpl44:11
explanationI1l-

83:12
explanations(1I241:0
exploittll-230:16
exploitation(1I-

Faciayl!-105:7

faciall6I-68.3,
1os:12 losrls,
,os:22 ,2,:22.
19z::0.
facgitp
esIa-4a:1a

'

face(?J- 119:15
177:j2 j85:23,
18s.24p 186:1o$
192:4 :!07.14

exittll-83:17
expectlsl-6:21
,:1.,,8/
-:,2.2:s8:,,
2:. :2
@XPeGtasona;-

21
3:1T
exped (17)

exploredpl-564.

existedI3)-34:1I

expeditiouslytll131:1/
@XPPCi
encea 205:10, 245:10
experienced ls!-

.
''

fatIt1-139 11

56:5
ExpressI11-6:10
extentpl-21.13,
184:15
extrerne(,I-47:14
extreraely!3l133:12 21s:11
241:24

exists(1I-14:3

237.2

253:18,253:19
253'21,2M :8,254:9
254:12 254:15
254.20,255:2,255:5.
255:7,255:8,256:18
256720,257:7
exhibits!2)-229:14,
231:16
exist($I-139:24
103:24,119:12
existence 111-29:10
existentll)-12:21
existingI2l-103.3,
103:5

facilitftlsl-26:23,
27:1, 42:22,68:14,
77:13 1r7:20, 81:20,
82:
9, 8:!:11, 82:17.
82:23 .I1z:4, 141 3,
210:4'

Facili
lyll-82:12
fact115)-7:16,8 11,
12:14I(50:2,66:201
79:5,76):15180:4.
106:
4 ,155:14I169:7,
191:1,
0,238'5I
241:22 253:7
,
failI2l.29:10,
135:
21
fails(:1-29:7
failureI2)-29:11.
21z:16
faira -68:11,

68:22.,183:23
fairly4
z1-34:10,
7::8 !,1!:3
,
faitN!k)-8:16
fall(fI-132:22
falls(1j-180:13
familiRrpl-205.16,
235:
6 :!3s:13
.
Fam ilya - 1:13,
j:14 2.5
9:6
far,
lTm -15:23,2821.
:s():s :
$4:
3, z5:17,
,.
77:12
327:4, 156:23,
188:6,
,.,91:8 204)24
, 250:3,
219:7, :t19:17,
fashitln(1l-148:1
fast(11-241:12

faulttl)-184.4

faxi1)-159:23
Fdqll-206:21
feasibility(1I18021
feasible(11-181:7
featurelzl-139:12,
1-/6 Ja 1-,7:2 lzz.4
177 11 177:12
177.21

Featurql)-17725

feature-rich11l139:12
featurest1)-177.14
F'ebruatyal-1:21,
s:1, 172:1

Federakq -6:10

7:17.15:7.1s:8,'
1zs.9,j2s 1:$
federalp!-lerza.
1.?.:a 1.
,:
4 126:2:
$.
,as:
2
'z', ,,',:$'

fited (sI-8214

117:10 117:15,

financiallyI1I-

132:22

224:21 225:11
filesi120)-2Z.10.
27:17127:18.27:19,
27.20,2829132:19,
35'1,35.8 5122,
51*18.51:21,53.101
54122,54:24.56:9,
56.10,56:16,56:17,
56'19,57:1,57:71

finding:I1)-15'2
tine(91-6:24 11:15,
52:69134:23 210:1
229221,231:191
242:17 25/:19
Finqal-52:13,
242:19
finishtgl-67:6.
67:11 79:10, 79:11,

5Z:12,59214I60:11I

93:5,93:10I93:11.

60:12160:15,60217,
81124,89:3,89:71
69:9.91:
22.91123.
92:1,92.22,93.18'
93:21.93:2319422,

94:11.94:12 94713

94:17. 94719.94:21,
95:11.95:16.95:24,
90:1.% :12.9z:3.
9z.:4.9'.:1s,99:22.
1('(':a.100:11,

126:9,182:9
finished(
BI-25:11,
35:
5 3516 35:7
36:11' 38:10' 138:11%
167:24

finishing!1I-34:23
firez -7c:13,223:1
fired(1j-2s1:x
,ring(,,- 24s:7
tirstlssl- 9:1:,
,,:12, laia Ja:l.?'

1z
z:
2112a14 lxrz 1(0:1:?,104:z.10::2, zj:.
:.,:o:z.;sza,'
feeds'
t
l
l
4
8
:
1
1
0
9
:
6
,
1
0
9
:
1
8
1
2
6
.
5
27:84a:23
fellow lll-253:24
109:24,110:15s
55:21 65:9 6s:1.F
fellowshipgj175:20
felona -79:8
zsrls 8o:s .

felonylll-80:24
few 1101-17:3.
37:18, 50.20I66:15,
133:12 1638
,
195:19I
198 13
, . ,
202:
3,20T:1I
fiftyI2I-2:5:20
fifty-fifty(!)-255:20
fightingIjl-132:29
figureI4I-53:14,
181.13 182.21
.
217:22.
figuredI1)-41:19
file(
431-2Q:19,29:91
30:7,30:16j31:8,
:51:10 49:22 5(5:za,
,
.
57:3'60:9,60:10,
60:181 87.3,92:31
92.
4,94:17. 1Q0:11,
103:12 104:6 104:7
106:1 ,
1()::9 ,109:s ,
'
110:1.
T.1162,
6
,
140:11,t46:l6,
146:18.146:19.
14z:
4,14z:9,147:48,
147:231148:9,
1s1:21, 1sars,
157:131165:173
24
170:
3, 208:17221:
file-sh
are(jl'- 31:
8

L IZA (:HA PEN , C CR , RM R

110:211113:20.
116:101116:11,
jjorj;?' jj(;:j:'
116:19.118:17,

6s:;?()66::4 6::2
68:5I 68:9. 6a:18,
m tjj, g
rsyty. x r,.
z6:16 r?:1 j1c:1:

1
21:
15,121.20,
123:14 15:$;1
122:
2,122:6.122714, jsgrzj 174;14
jzryzzj jrzya,
'
jzarjt5'jzarz,'
jaat5'j45yj()'
j45rj4' jvjgjgz'
jogjj.g jyyyz()
'
'
j4(j:ja, y4jkja,
Axa aj jxo ja
'-'M'CA-'' 'X*':'W'
150
:1.151J3,1515
23'
151:24,152:1I165:4,
.(6s:1($,166212,
jtz rj-/.,jysrzz,

208:24,2o9:s,209:9,
z1():4, zj4;:.
,.
,
z14:1a 2j.;'rjs,
,
zj.
;:j6'zjgrj:'
221:4 221:6 221:9
'
'
'
221:12,222:10
jjjjuustera - 13:5
'
jarjtj'jasrj
fijj
ed(j1-69:19
gillingl)-217:17
tijm jj).244:
6
finalz -56:17,
aary,,:
;(a,a:
$:j5,
jysgj-;,y4.
y.
r
(;,j4.
yrzy
finalaeIj1-s:1:$

VRZCSt11-5Z:10

ficzNffU1-230721

jayjya 'j.ytyyjjy'
j.ya;g4.j,(kj5,
1atjatj'j,j;(y,
115j:js,yyyy;gg,
jj;jgztj yjytyyrtj
.
'
z(s i.y m zgzj a rjgz,
'
,
210:20I211I2I212:9.
zjzi4' ajaza.
zjila;? 21::1 2j::6,
'
'
z2(;:j5.aztirja.
zzag:j,zzrjs ,zts yztj

nrsjlj.zz:1:
$
fjtpj. ,.
y,
:4

tyve(jjj. jzii.
jv ajr:$,
49:6.65:24 72:6
' '
108:3,125:191181:2,
zj:
$:
8 a4l:7
'
SVP-YPSV*(11-

181:
2
flesb!$1-12:4
fjoora . z4:1()
.
Z4:11,243114
j
rjoortsj- 2:6
y:jYogjyjj. rrjs
zgjy,r
jr4,r
yy,,sj
g,
3l11,3:12,3:13,5:24,

6:1,6:2.6:1:$.8:12,
11:21,12:
3, 13:3,

(77 5) 323 -5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 50 of 65


e-n;

'

13:22,14:1.1423.
1721 18:F 19224
20:z.2or1o 20:14,

255.19. 258:1
folder(131-3029
a7:2 :$7s Jo()::$

35:14,35:16 35:20
36:1 36.6 42:4
44:21I5228,52:1(),
52:17,53:23 55:12,

f
t

''

f
''

55'1B,63.19.63:23,
63:24:67:
9 67:15,
69
:
1
6,
6
9:
21I71:23.
7
3:
1
6
,
73
.
0 73:24.
74:22,79:2
10,79:14,
80:1I80:9181:13,
81
:15,89:13,90:1,
91:
17/93:15,93:16,
1K
:11,107:14,
107:17,107:19.
108:1,108:6,108:12,
108:16.115:2.
117:12,117:18,
11F
19,121:lv121:
6,
121:
:8,125:5,125710,
125:15.126:7,
130
10.132:4.132.61
132:
:15,133:7,134:2,
13425.136:31136:16.
13621
1 137:
8,137:
91
138:101138:12
'
142:14,143:22,
155:4,155:5 155:9.
'
160:4 160:8 162:17,
.
.
1
16
62:
7 22,163:6,
:19,168:1.172:4'
172:6,173:9, 174:81
174:11, 189:16
'
189:20,192:15,
192:18, 198:22,
199:1. 199:5,201:8,
201:11
,201T16
'
201:17,202:10.
202:15. 203:10,
209:11T209:13.
209:15, 212:2,212:71
213:
4,214:20.
215:16,215:19,
216:151215:29.
218:191218:22,
222:14, 223:17,
223:24, 224:7,
224:191 224:23.
225:19,225:24.
226:4, 226:8,226:10,
236:7,240:24,241:2,
241:16,241:
21,
247:17,248:8,
249:15,250724,
253:18. 253:23,
254:1,254:131
254:j6,2s5:9v
zssrla zssrls

. ....

243.6,244:
10.250.17
foundation(17135 1a, 36:2 36.16

119:10 119'23
89 18 142:15
149:10 149:14
14:5223 196:23
149:15 )50:8. 150 )() )9.722 209.21
folders11s)-3129.
21:5.12,214:22.
37:7, 48 20.48:23.
235:31254 14,254.17
48'24 94:4 94:18
foundational(
3$95.18 97:2 100:15,
42 9.203221I 209:19
118:19 118:24
four111l- 87
21 32'8
119:11 143:12 150:6 33:9 65:24. 81:231
folks11I-130;15
118:24. 144:23.
follow 11I-16:21
155:11I 155:14,
followingI
c)- 193:
5. 176:71241:6
241:19
fotlrthI1I- 177124.
follows!4I-22:3,
fragment,
sj1I1z4:15, .2c3:3,226 19 :
?1a.7
footagai!)- 48:
5
ffamef& -!1G:4,
Forcqaj- 68:18.
243:20.243.23.
z24:s 2:24:14 225.1, 244:
41250:24,252.8
225:2 2;?s:a,253:24
framest
7t-28:2.
Forda!-176:15,
110:3,110:4,110:7,
1-:6:115 Iz6:1a
1jtlrj9, 244:3,24425
forefrontI1I- 2O7 16
frankI11-244:2
foregozng(aIfranklyIn-15:9,
::
0 .2: :?5g:j2
1zj,:5,1z6.5,jg4rz(),
'
;t:$j,:1j,244:::.
259:14'
orejgrlI
a)-44.18,
251:
2
77:
22' 71r.23
fraught(1j-241:3
forensicI6)-206:3,
Fremony
l!-234:21
206:9,221:2,221:121
Fzayjx,.zlrj:6
221:17';!22:7
friendI1I-44:
6
forensi-related111- Friendlya -77:24,
221:12
78:11, 234:21
forensicsl1Ifront(sI-17:18.
205:23
72:12, 169:19.178:4,
f
orue
ti51-38:4'
243:12
e
81:2'
2,
&k:7,88:8
fruitionI,I-228:11
144220,153:15 '
Fryqzl-5:16, 18:T,
'
157:
169:11
f 12,161:16
orgotlsl-21i5$1
fos
tlllp)-212:10
Forfqll-68;15
fuf!p!-31:9,31:10.
form (
q -68:16,
85:14, 101:23,
68:20.128:18.
103:21. 176:
4.
139:19'18:221,20922 246:21, 248:23,
formall'
/(11-247:9
259212

formatlll-128:15
formatian (1)228:16
formed (al-228:24,
238:8,245:2
fonnerlll-52:22

forming(
2)-164:21,
228:14
forth I11-182:22
forwardl(8I-15:12.
127:22,137:3,
202:
21,239:14,

11

. )

Fultl)-31:13
function(
s)-152:3'
152.4,152:7,179:10,
179'
23,212:10
functionali
ties(11179'
9

functionalik (1)17 13
ftl
nctionsI51128 14,1Z9:12,
179 13,10 :17,
179.22

LIZA CHA PEN, CCR, RMR

2
46:191255:21,
25673 259:11

oam bieq,l-s6:z

26 10 26:13 28:18
55:23 56:3 56:24,
57:13 58:2 58:8,
58:11 58:19 61:8,
61:21 62:11,62:15,
63:3 63:6
1 74:12
84.2 85:9 86:241
87:1 91220.92251
92:7, 92:8.92:11.
92:14 92:22 93:22
116:171118:15
119:
2, 119:4,150.91
150:11
games(4I-25:151
2s:19, 85:23,11'
?.1
gatewayI1)-71:16
generalpl-68:24,
113:15, 251:17
General
lyl
zl-75:1.
252'1
generallyI
a;-10:
23.
146:141 251:
22
generate(
sj-5/:9,
(p:21 j5(j:2j, 185:g,
z5z:1'
z
generatedI3l-50:
6,
99:14' 185:4
generates(1)-56215
qenoratingpj.
103:3
generaticm 1l177:24
gentleman14I-9:12I
17:18, 17:
23,225:17
gentlemenlq20:15. 126:12
Gege(11-176:21
Giaogongtzl-

175:11. 175:$2
gigabyte(1I-215:8
gigabytesl
n32:22, 33:
5,96:4,
96:6'135:
26 215:6,
215:f4

gistlll-251:17
gi
ven (
:
$:1-14:23,
15:
2,20:5,46:10,
67:23, 68:19,68:20,
83:
4'83:9, 107:10.
119:13, 120:18,
128:
9,129:3. 129:9,
130:12. 145:12,
146:
6, 160:3.173:12,
203:20,232:11.
232:12124Q:15,
241:21,243:10,

oivenlll-2!8.11

glassesj1l- 229.11
G logaueqll-46:4
goalI41-11:12
181:12 181:21
182:18
golng-forwaTdpj243:6 244:10,250:17

Govemmenkzl24:17 192:23
govem m ent(43116:23 17:3, :7:4
54:4 54:8, 66.21,
67:18 79:16, 80:10,
81:21 82:3 82:20
1o1:2, 1Q2:8,1()3:
g,
107:6, 11211,112:
3,
112:14 112:22,
114:6,120:3,120:221
126:24,127:3.
128:11I 129:14,
130:7.130:15,
130:181130:20,
133:12,13873.141:
4,
1
s
4:
9,
1

0r
2
3
,
199:17 2g0:2 200:3,
,
I
206:4.22322
governmental(7)g7:22.9a:9,104:15
1Q6:
4,$* :13, I
1'
/r
srlj.2,4:9
9cabI,)-173:14
ly(zI-26:19,
911dual
4122,42:2
oraduallylll-26:17
graduatepl175:15,1Z5:17,176:6
graduatedI2ljzsrj. w .
;rl()

geantm -1Tfk$5,
1T6:22
granted(2l-B2:8.
82:23
granting(21-11:22,
83:15
Scaphiclll-24:1
Gray(91-46:2,46:
6,
64:23,86:14,159:3,
159:$6.160:15.
160:17,290:20
greatl
z)-176:20,
227:21
Gre9!!1-69:23
ground (1l-22:24
groundsI41-81:10,

2G4:2,214:24,255:$:

(775) 323-5492

groupz -45:16,

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 51 of 65


..-.
.
12

!/

50.16,72.4 145:
4

(
.

26:20 48.9 85.17.

guess(
sI-43:1
84:1,126:
6.126:8.
131:1
guessing (:)-42:6
Gurl
galfl-243:11
guy(1I-112220
guysI1)-257:21

I4irel
2l-236:24,
25121
hired;6j-26.9.
139'
3 206:6 211:13
2t;J'
6 251:19
hiring(a -245:61
251:
22
historyI1)-222:5
hitsI
al-6s:17
.
65 21 66 5
Holdpl-79:17,
9o 24.144:1
holdlz)-92:171
92:23
holidays(t1-34:19
homet
zlh-38:
7.
3822 43.4 64:2
Homez -58:3,84:8
uonestly(1)-184:
21
sonorltssl-5:11I
slgtlI6:j.6.js,.
J:22,
8:4,a:;.8r16), 9:1:$,
1c:11 1():22 j1:1r)
.
, ;jI
gj.zj,::$.2,13rj.
13.22,14.20.15:1c'
17:13,1T:20,1a:2,
18:7, 18:1()
, j8;14,

165:5 197:191
217:15,238:12
hundreds(al63:12 91:19 91r22
92:10 92:13.108:21
132:22 142:3
hud (1l-108:14

223:1 2'
51(23
head!61-132:10,
132:19 133:2,
154:17 166:13
177:12
headerI2)-151:23.
152:1
headsI2J-133:9.
136:2
l'lear1141-13:11.
19:1.23 5,69:23.
79:13,91:1s,12s:14,
132:11.135:61
135:11,173:241
201:13.?13:5.213 13
bfardllsl-16:22.
19:
2,1058.125'
6,
128:56129:13,
129:14.138:20,
139:9.140:19,
168:18,193:23,
206:15,208:10,223:2
l
w aringgn -5:7,
21:322'16.202:8.
225:11I225:16,
256:17
Heacingltl-1:20

happyI41-19:9,
19:24,127:15v128:4
H

ardtll-108:24
hardt4n -33:4'
33:
7'34:7'36:4'
36:24'37:2'45:21'
48:18.51:6'51:7'
5
1,
z:
:8,
.
g.51:
1w 23,
gz,52:
j(g:
r),
5 .
108:17, 109:2, 11c:2,
110:13'117:2
'
118:22,1z1:16
.
121:1? 123:1 123:4.
23:6 '
1
.140:
7.
143:18,
l44raz' 14s::
$'
145:15 155:11
155:15 157:
9,
j5.
/:.
1:
$ j5a:jj
158:12 161:1 170:6,
193:s 216:
4 217:1s,
219:2 p1f).19

z1r
kzj z4j:.j2
hard-and-fast(1)24jrj7
uard-coded (
11l4cr
z
Hardwarez -29:
7,

''

'

29210
-

60:19I66:8,109:13

1
16:191116:24,
119:21,139:3.139:9

Hanovecll2:9

201.
9,202:121

15
3.15
202.15,203110,
Highlands(11-22'10 207 19.209:11I

Nacl
zq-s71s s:4,
'
(5:21.7:s
Haleljl-2.4
half(o1-123:17,
:2f5r1s 128:9
130:12 238:5 238:8
Hallowaytll-78:9
hand(61-22:24'
183:
4.200:15,229:5,
232
:2
h
andedt!I-161:10
handle(sj-82:24'
1Q2:14).141:6,
180:19,180:21
lxandled(!1-141:6
KandlesI1I-148:18
Nandling(11-80:13

''

highestI
2!-12.8.

14
5'
6,193:19.250:13 1
062231106.
24,
grow 11)-243.1l
138:8 2t)5:7 205.17

''-h

hardware(11)-

209.13,209:161
212:2,213:4,216:16,
216'20.218:17,
224:4 224:22.225:6,
225:151225:19,
226:12 229'10,
229:13.229:
22,
231:7,231:13,
231:24,23228.'
232'101233:7.
233.111234:2,23416,
235.2,235:16,
23.
5:
201236:61
239'24,241:161
242:
20,245:191
245:21,247:8,
247:14.247:17,
249:15,249:20,
251:1,253:?,253:18.
254:3.254:14,255:9,
255:14.255:17I
255:14,257:12,
257:24,258:1
Honot's(2l-172
S.
241:17
Honorabl
ep)-1:7
bonored(1l-9:5

Hearsaylm-42:5,

2a:1,z()::
$,z(,:16,

hookedllj-114'23

189:20.209:14.
214122
hearsay(101-42:7,

20:24,a1.
6.22:15.
23.14.23.19'24.5'
24.14 24.24 254

ho> I2!-131:21,

42:B,45.4.52:81

52
?'189:17,
18:
91:0
'52:1'
21 225:9 253.14
'
'
heart(:?)-12:17,
15:17
held(1I-180:9
help(4I-242:3.
245:1,245:11.251:14
helperI2)-60r12,
60:1?

h
elpfulI11-214:5
helpinga -73:8,

'
, ',
25:8,35214,42:4,

42:10'44:
:1'5::17,

69:17 69:21 79.9


'
' '
7g:1() 80:7, 80:12,
'
80:18 81J13 93:15
107:1,
7'1o8:'
1,108.'
6,
108:121 117:13,
117:18'121:7'
124:18.125:10,
125:15 125:16

1?3:1
hopefulI1l-10:15
hopefullyI1I-2023
Hopefull
ylzl-22:18,
155:5
hospi
talI11-201:6
hostlll-66:7
hourt6l-43:12,
162:51162:13,
219:13,219:15,259:9
hours(71-50:4,
107:16.169:51

I
ideatxj-12:11,
zs:6,x :(
$,a7:16,
8r:g 88:14 9g:5
g6:a 9s:19 97:1,
99rja j()2:1 102::1
jozrz 1o3rg3, la :jj
104:2 104:12 1:5.4
1()z::B ,115:5.
jx ljo.155:x ,
15::: jsarzj
'
,
j6ljrx j(;::14
166:14.167:16,228:6
ideas,p)-185,:9
jdenticalI11-243:24
kdentification i
nv
,0:1,2:$0:2,g:
.
$8:2z!
245:224 24.
/22:'

2s:$:6,2s4:12
jdentified (
2j-234:7

,
234:18
identifiesIj)-16:15
identifytq -45:11
,
124:19 222:8
,
.
238:24 243;23, 244:4
ident'
ifyingI11243213
identi
tyI<)-44:23,
7s:3I z6:8, :2:3
ignorance tj)169:13
jpj-1:19

1
27:7,127:169128:
5, 219:17,237:23,
130:10.131:9,133:
9, 246:23,249:1

:8::. 245:12
helO !3l-91:6.
91:13,231:2
Hpnnessy'i
'
Fl224:
7.224:16.
225:21,226:2,226:
3,
226:4,226:
5
herebl!($)-259:6
high(9!-23:23.
23:24,175:1I196:71
196:12,205:4,
208222,227:10,

133:18, 134:Jtl'
134:16,134:24.
136:16,138:16,
142:15.143:24,
150.24,155261
159:24.161:
21,
162:18,167:19,
167221.168:1,168:3,
168:24.469:21.
171:13.17226,
172:12,173:5,173:9,
174:5.183:17.

bousex -54:4,
64:1,64:20,64:23.
196:21
Howardll)-2:4
Htmllzl-150:14,
150:15
Huangtl)-121:19
Hugolj)-136:20
humanl
'
n-177:11,
178:11 178:18,
179:1 179:
7. 2:8:7,
208:16

22
7:22
highel'lll-208:13

1
84:10,184:23,
189:16 198:23

s7:13,s7:14.58:9'

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR: RMR

'

i
lkllj-245:14
imageIs)-176:3

177:7, f8j:z, j;6ra


jazrll 1g1:1
jmages(s'
1-27:17,
2a:2 28:4 js4:
a
imaginationI$I24:$:9
kmagine(1I-128:19
imaginedI11-12:12
jmbedded($I- 146:1
jmmaterial(1lz:
$6:ja
imm edutez -

hundred(
161-54:23. js:
z4'4:2:

(775) 323-5492

impending!1!-

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 52 of 65


.
x.
1a
.

15:15

implementing(1j-

105:21
im plication(1I135:9
im plyI1I-217:12
im portanceI1I47:14
im portantlzq 168:7,225:20,
242211 249219
im possible(3)14:23.216:61243:22

impressionfljj21.):9
im proper(1I-89:18

improperlyI11-

224:13
inM epth I11-251:21
inadequateE11-

235:3
inceptionlll-57:24
incidentttl-49'8

inclined(11-162:9
include(3l-21.13.
17():1s,192:3
inoluded a -20s:z,
237:5
includes(1J-71:8
Including(3l-

160:13,160:14,

160:15
includingts)-12:18
s6:14.56:17 66:7.
205:14
lndian(1I-26:3
indicateI2l-166:5
242:5
indicateda -8:6,
153:17 214:23
inaicationlll-8:11
individual(t211:12.1s:2a,105:14'
110:
3. 122:22,123:4,
12z:01,12s:s.
127:24 21s:z,222:2,
222:3
individual'st,l122:2

individualsz -

'

.
(
.

infom lation1311..

12210,1221I.12:19.

14:6.14:18 17.1
20.5,20221,27:3.
27:6.28'22.29:6.
77:14,fI7:13.98:11,
125:4 129:3 135:15
140:20,140:22
151:14,151r16
154:16,168:8.170 8.
175:14,203:20,
221:14,221:18.
221:19,252.4

infrast
bructurqI
6126:19,;8:24,32:5,
63:14I1.9:5,84:19

initial(
21-228:5,

230:4
initialsI$l-72:21
initiateI!1-83:22

injunftion(3l168:21,168:22,
253:13

InjunctionI
al-120,
5:8,167:4
inputs (1I-66:4
inquirzlll-1s:2o
inquir/(1I-169:6
inside!41-146:1,
146:4,152:81163:17

inspectlzl-83:
61

83:16
inspection(al42:19,83:1183:6
installed gl-47:23
47:24
instanceI11-225:4
insteadi1)-229:22
instructed(
2l21:13,160.11
instrucungldl97:11
instrucuonslsl7n:13,17':10,
190:22.20a:s,2aa:9,
208:22
integration(,)241:23
integrity(11-17:16

Intellsl-28:1z,

17:41101:22,124:191
1x :2()I 1z:,:12I
!z4:1 23s:.
indulgepl-13.23.
91:1s,111:9
industry(sI- 2s:14.
21::6' 211:3'211:7,
22::
24' 22::12

5873 61:5,70:22,
!
s4:8.87:1:,
intelligencetll24:17
intelligenttsl-20:22
intend I,I-136:
22
intentionality(11221:s

inquencepl- 77:
23

inter-computert:!-

inferencepl-135:8

interpl-205:8

205:8

interaction!1)-98:
9

interactionst1)98.14
interestI6I-77:22.
77.23 129:11 1726
239:14 243:16
interestedl7I11'10 16025 168.7
16:.9 168:11
168 13 244:9
interesting I2)126.13 135:1

interesG pl-14:24
j5:4
interfaceI3I-

j7
::11,17937,183:8
intederingI2I7916 80:1()
intermediateI -

56:16 56:
22157:91

158;16.158;18

issuesj11-12:17,

158:20.159:3.

13:3$15:
2,16:5y16:i$I

159:11s159:231
160:2,160:21,
160.24,162'12
166:16
investigatingi1l129:7
investigationI3l44:19,124:201129:22
investm enttzy227:22, 243:16,
244:9, 244:12

19:13 91:7 126:12


127.8 183:151242.11
iterations!$I152:10
itselftB1-8::3
128:24 148:7
151.17 163:17
197:61236:91236:11

investments(1I-

jacket(11-243:13

22z:7
investorI1l-245:8

Jakopjqlx!- zra,
3:3 3:4 3.7 3:1()

investors(3l-

252:121 256:24,257:2
jnvitedI1j-177223
invoke(1I-17:14

involved(
281-12:8,

:
$:113:123':14J:15
11:1 21:7 21:23
22:6'23
:2124:51
25:8 25:9 36:11

36:
20 39:11 42:9.

70:20 147:49 147:23


148:5 20925

12:19.14:21 14:24
15:21 17:7,24:18

42:24 46:13, 52:13,


52:14 53:1,53:19.

intem alIfJ-221:8

58:10.58:11,60:171

55:11,79:9180:18,

Internetl:I-64:8,
'g'o 1o ztll1 za:24,
zl:4 11:$:17 113:22.
223'7
internship(1)176:17

67:2,67:20,84:1,
gs:15,85:
24,86:4,
7:1s.az:la,119:s
130:20 141:8 190'8
190:11I200:1,
210:12I227:18,

89:12,89:17,90:18,
138:1s 1z8:19,
142:18 143:24,
144:8 144:13
144:14 150:23
159:24 160:2,

interpreution(1)-

241:10

174:18,176:10,

intrudetll-6s:7

zs:3,z8:1(L39:1,

234:1/,234:24,

40:12,135:3
issuanceljl-7.19
issuetlsl-7:,:$,
12:19,15:1,80:17,
an:24,91:8,93:13,
12s:3.129:17,
135:14,136:91
205:14.224:6,
224::4,242:12
issuedld!-6:z

235:23,236:15,
237:11,2:$8:21'
239:2,2:$9:8,239:23.
240:51242:19.
242:22,245:15.
245:19,245:21,
24523,24622,
246:11,247:12,

242:14
interpretinglll241:11
lnterruptll)-211:15
interruptingI2)171'2 231:2
interruptionI1193 12
intervention(1Ils.4
lntrepid In -230:9
231.7,2z2:1s.
234:20 239:3 240:7
2s6:24
introducez -s:a3,
z:1
intreduced(1)227:20

intrusion(1212,
ss.ls' sz:caI ss:
9a4,sa:1() 9:Ja
120:21,221:8,
222:19,223:2, 223:s.
z.
23:8
inventortt)-2* :22
inventoryI$q 158:1, 158:2'158:3'
158:s 158:10

LIZA CHAPEN, COR, RMR

involvementEtq48:8.48:13,62:10
79:7185:19165:23
involves!41-12:16
15:24.61:15163:7
involving (2l132:221133:10
IpI6l-70:23,70:24,
71:1.71:2,71:6,
142:1
iris I$)-207:14
irrel
evantpl236:12,256:
8
Isaa -38:12.40:19,
*l:ls
Isa'sE1I-40:19
Isaservertsl-32:24,
33:2,3328134:13,

183:9 183:17 1M :5
184:9 184:23
184:24,189:18,
189:23 192:14
202:12,202:14,
203:6 204:15 205:2
207:18.207:22,
207:23,209:16,
210:1,210:21214:5
21s:2o 216:23
218:16.222:18.
223:16,223:20,
226:22,229:5.229:8,
229:16.229:19,
230:3,231:6.231:10,
231:14,231:23.
232:2,232:7,232:24,
233:2,23421,234:4,

247:21,247:24,
248:
6,248:11,

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 53 of 65


. ..x

249.13 249'20,
249:21.251:4
253220
254 , 254:11,
:19,255.5.255:8,
256:14I256:19
256:21 257.5.
257:11,257:19
J
akopiflsI11-242.3
Jal
ql1-167:15
Januae lel-39:51
43:2,49:1 50:11,
54
:13 96;10,144:21,
145:1G,153:18,
153:19,153'20.
157:21, 18023,
2t)1
:
23.216:3.246:1
Javqal-150:144
150215.208:20
JayI8l-43522
4:11,
83:21 112520,.14
13:2,
,
156.
:11.156:24,
157:
23

J@rlM2l- 2:5,233:6
Jessiq:l-45:17,
48
:12,49:10,76:11.
99:2.123:19,150:41
150
:6
J
essie I1!-150:13
21
> 41-4Q:4,45:1/.
49210.150:4

(
'
'

Ji
nksIzI-150:6,
150:10

jobIsJ- 6'22 25:17


29:2 30:
5 180t13
JohqlI-226:5

joined!jl-180:2
jugeB)-133:9,
196

121'13 188 15,


188.20 189 13
Krishnds111-52'4

j.
I
ab11)-185'24
Laql;-176:16
l
ack11j-1842:
Iaokedt1l- 45.4
I
ackingI1I-35'18
Iacks(s!-42:5,45:4
142.1t5 14:
$.22
21422
I
ady(1!- 122:7
I
az (2j.151r
6,
21r
:
rJ:
$

kaitqm -fs:12

.
(j
4 :9.:
u
aaqzj-zr
4j2.
6
janguagella 15().j: 152:14
15;?2 1x1z8:14q
j.
rjiljs jazrja,
184:3 2()
4:1g,
x a:!($zll?,
:j()
:08:22 236:9
Iangu'
ages(iq-5::5,
15c:16 jsljrlz
1z8:16 205:11,

102:6 1:?8:13

2()s:14 2()a:13

148:21, 168:19
184:19 I85:21
186:
21 253:12
knowirlga 168:11I'168:13

208:20
Iarget
a -32:18
:
$:
$:, 21
s:.
1! 2.
1s':.
I4
:?1t
)
:
1
7
a
j
a.
(
;
2
2
1
;
l-aqa -7:8 zr12,.j(

knowledge14zl-

7:13

29:
20 619:20 76:5.
86:31 86:BI86:11,

Iast(341-8:7,17:8,
16):a z2:13 m :21

87:6.98:9.98:13,

25:j 28:1s 37:21

98:24,961:1, 99:9,

4s:3 4722:$ 48:19


4::23 s7:1j (5:::

junctionIt) 254:5
junctureI1l 256:9

114:14.120:
7,
120:14,156:
4,159781
159:14,1592164
1&t12.167:9,
199:13-199:14,
224:14,225:2, 225:3,
235:19.239:18,
24::9,245:7.245:1n,
246:8.248:5,259:16
know nI21-68:7,
230:8
know s(N- 59:23,
13::
7,$G5.
l!f.165:22
xrlsjlnapj.sl:
22
52:
5,52:15,101:13'.

Junqzl-187:7
jutytsl-36:7,81:4j
s$:s 2c,:'
I4,21z:19

;.

keeps (3I-44724.
50:8 86):21
Kend1lII(3)-3:10,
203:1 :,
03.9
Kennyl1)56.
3
keptjr1- 30'8.
33)14 S''/'2 61:23
116:9 119:4 119:6
119:8 1.56:11
key(4t-31:4, 82:13
82:15 151:13
keyboardt1I-40 13
keys1;)-156:17I
157:10
Kietzketl;- 2:6
KiII(1j. 1(1z:7
kilobyte(:I- 215 7
kind(2r!13.a0,
16rjz 19.8 20:13
27:2 72 11 89:4
99:13 1a!
):1n
114:
24 126:13,
126:20 171:17,
178:231179:11,
180:18, 180:19,
185:7 1.
55.10 186 7
186:11, 186:J4,
187:4 1,$7:23 207.2
207:15 221:4
kinds(91-27218.

J :18.213:19.226:7
udgqll-1:7
j
ud
J ges(1I-9:19
udge:(
1l-13725
judiclalj1,-203:16
J

udlci
ayal-1:
5s
15:4,259:5
jumptll-181:22

$'

Kallurirzl-75:11.
75:14
Kadhikl
ll-75:8
KeepI
GI-10:18'
35:22,37:8,54:18,
66:3,252:19
keepiagtll-181:18

102:16,103:8,

103:12,103217,
104:18.104:19,
1D4:24,1W :29,

99:19 11o:1 1j2:15,


113:f) 1z3:23,
15'
/:
a3 162:
2, 187:7,
195:19 .
j9:z,
19a:j1 19::j3,
19g:19 2()1:y0
2o1y22 205:24,
zkt.
;$.
/ zz:ksz
24j.
6 2s1:
a
t-asja-;B:g,1 219
jate(
4)- 3g(5,16s:7,
1'
;1:,z1a:24
t
-at
esyzj-,19:1
119 9 119:23 14,
9:8.
.j(
') 21j:j1
. :4
glj:
,
. 4:9
latestp -47:12,
j4a.:. z1j
4:r)
j
ati
tude(1l-160:3

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

vh
/

14

Iatter(11-52:23
Iaw tl11- 16:13
16.17, 17324.90:9,
124:6. 124:
8.124:16.
124:18i127:3.129'20
Lavql-2:12
lawyerI41-10711.

Librarieqll-56:21
Iiorary(3l-147:23.
148:
7. 148:11
Libraryl)-148:13
license(1)-230:15
lightI2l- 130:3,
220:20

131:23 174:3,213:18

Iikely(11-19'22

1
a#l21-204:8.
209:21

Iimited(
3l-12:3
1
20:7 210115

layman's(1l-151:10
lead(1l-25718
leading1
71-240.241
242:1. 242:8.242:10,
242:13,249:161
249:1l
IearnI
4I-20:4, 36.3,
91:12,227:15
learned(2j-24:2,
125:18
leasttq -7:24,
15:239 18:6,18:16,
36:17.37:12,126:2,
1s1:6.214:16
Ieavea -73:22.
172:13,172:18
Iefttlzl- 22:241
34:21,34:24 35:9.
39:2,40:6,43:12,
47:17,107:11,
107:
20, 212:24.
218:2 229:10
Ieft-hand !1I-22:
24

Limiteqll-1:9
lim itsIj1-223:4
Iine(s1-102:16
102:24, 130:16.,
132:18 146224
Iines(
401-58:10
58:24 59:16 60:6,,
6(3:1G, 6G:22161:2,
61:7, 61:8,61:15,
62:8,62:15163:7,
67:17. 73:10 B8:11.
88215 91:10. 91:11.
103:3, 103:5,133:10,
139.
8, 139:13.
139:18 140:16
,
147:1Q1 14-f:17,
169:22. 170:12,
179717 193:8
193:12 197211
197:12,197120,
198:4,198:12
Lineq4l- 59:14,
60:3 60:4,61:17

leaE!!-1F/:12

Lin%sl-146:13

Iegal111-108:13
Iegally!11-132:17
ueqlj- 46:4

linkI!I-148:20

lendingI1J-252 18
I
ength t1l- 207:10
Iessa - 199:13,
109:16
. 1j0:
4,
1j4:1z, jj4:15,
130.13,219:,8

Lesqlj-161:6

Iettertjj.2o8:1a
Ievel(1s)-16:16,
zjz , zjijr
s,jzs:4,

Iist1111-45;19,46:7
49:16.70:12 FJ:131,
Z8:8,7879.78:10,
Z8:14'121:11,256:23
Iisted(11-158:14

Ii
stenI11-91:13
lil.!4)-23:1
litecallyI1I-217:21

Ii
tigationI1l-211:20
uzm j-1:24, 259:
4,
259:
21
uqqx!-j:9,2,:
$::9,

jao:lg 15a:j5

23():1z zx:1R

1
4219 jx ::j,1% :z,
j9
9e
12 :
a n:17,
x.
/:
:4 x a:: ztla:j3,

232:16,2z4:5,
zasa4,237:22,
23g:4,240:8, 246223,

208222

248224,2>:
24,

levels(
21-31:1,
tsj:1o

256:24
Iocalp1-142:24

uabilstr j-j::
libIj)-147:23
jjurarj
espj-s6:12,
56J14I56:16, 56:20,
s.
y.
:q. j4p4, ztlgij,
2j4:11

locatckdp!-111:12
locationI2I- 30:18,
41:19
Iocatitmsl
2I-30:14,
g4rjs
Iockedll- 31:3,

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 54 of 65

.....x

4olls 166:18

t
z

Iunch a -162 5.

.'

144:22,152:241
153:4.156:201
166:22,159:19.
169:20,207:8.
211:18,231:19,
232:13,256:6
looked(16)-39:21.
48:15,48:17,87:24.
88:24,94:24,95:1.
99:23.110:13.
115:16,116:3.
116:22,164:12.
154:13,165:2
Iooking(141-43:14,

198:6,200:211

203'24'213:181

m achirlepg)-37 1.
40:14 z.
f)718 52:4
61.23 (;1:24 71:15
zl:16 6,5:2 116.70
J17:2, 117:31121:23.
1-/8 12 178'13
178:14 178:17
178.18 178:19.
178.20 178:21.
179:7,(98:6,198:7,
198:8 :,08:10,2228
machdnes(z3!30:18 zk1:13. 42:1.
48:10 zk8:19I 51:3,
s1:9 5:9:5 70:23,
71:'/ 7,1:12 72:2
94:16 6)8:15,100:1.
106:8,,124:9,1892,
210:91;?17:7,220'1
m agnetic($)210:10
m ail(111-26:18,
28:241:52:4.51:18.
51'21.t;4:10.64:12,
97:15

23.15,237.16.
?46'19
mannertzl-149.6,
230 1'J
manpowertl;244 24
rnanf1l-28:2
maps l:l-27:18
MarchI3l-255:3.
25522
rnarklz)-69.20.
2298,245:20
Marked (21-4:2,
247:21
m arked1141-70:1,
229'6 229:16 230:21
232.17,238:23.
239:2,245:221
245.23 247:20,
253:3 253:5.253:6,
254:12
m arkingl2)-1r>4'1,
229:13
markingsItl163.20
Massachusetts I416:3. ($'5p -J:3! 7:11
Master(jJ-175:18

mail
sj
91-50:21,

Master.s(1I-176:2

235:12124229.
244:20,252:3
meaning(11-82'23
m eaninglesstsl135.5
m eans(41-31:11,
48E22 55:20,196:8
m eanttll-55:8
m easureI1l-215:6
m eclxanical(1l29:11
m edia(5I-84:71
140:11,146:61146:9,
148:8
MediaI4I-597221
59:24160:14,87:13
medicalI11-206:21
medium lll-210:10
m eetI21-124:14,
182:18
m eeting(s)-8:71
44:10 125:8. 137:5,
171:8
m eetings(2)-128:1,
255:24
m eef.s(1l-19:15
m egabyteI1)-215:8
m emberI:q-6:2,
7:2, 18:11
m emory!41-33:1,
33:3 33:5 33:6
mention(1I-54:8
m entioned(16)33:11 M :13 47:19,
48:14 84:16. 101:13.
101:16 121:13,
123:22 124:6
128:18 141:19
145:17 146:12,
214:8.222:19
merged t11-13:1
meritgIzl-131:19,
171:12

50'22 tQ :16.53:4.
53:7 5:$:
8 53:9,
53:11 t$3:14
m ain!4l-70:101
70:11 '?8:13 118 24
m aintainI4l-26 24.
69:17 4$9:18 83:19
m aintained I6130:6 41
J.7 48:9 49:
4
166:15 166:
23
m aintaining !2)30:3 223:11
maintenanceI1148:10

105:23,126:10,

majorp!-44:11,

173:10.190:8.

j'Jsrl3 !'/s:16

190:11,198:11,

(
''

m anagerlzl-5.16,

119:16q144:15,

5.17118.11'210221.

Iog(lal-31:20,35.1, 25129I:.
52:3
35:4 35:8,40;15.
5o.17,66:3. 98.6,
9::7.157:13 166'9.
222:2
Logll-31:5
Logon($I-31.5
Loga(33I-2.12
2:12,5:20,5:21,6:2,
7:1 8'5 8.ii8:24
9:13 9:16 9:231
17:13,22:15.23:18.
39:9.209:19,225:9.
229:13,232:10,
232:14,232:17,
232:21,234:6.
234:11,234:15.
235:2.236:6,236:8.
238:24.240:2.241:11
24Z:10
Logals(11-6:18
Iogged(41-32:12,
116:3,222:8
logoing(1!-222:3
Iogs(2I-50:31223:5
look(231-19:21,
40t11,40:18,88:21.
89:1.1(h0:10.105:24,
110:19.115:21,

Matlab (181-182:13.
':e2:14. 185:8,185:9,
186:22 186:241
19o:15 19o:j9

191:131191:16.
196:11 196:20,

microphonel
zl22:17,22'20
MicrosoftI4l27:13,113:17,139:3,
147:1
middleltl-32:22
m iglzttl -48:12,
117.5,128:19,143:3.
148:5.152:131
180:181182:1I197:6,
197523 202.5.
208:19,256:16
m ilitary114)-51:6,
65:9165:11.65:18,
65:20,66:6.66:141
68:3,68:14,68:16,
79:16,156:181166:91
1?3:11
M ilken t71-78:151
Z9:1,79.3179:21.
00:3180:21,8173
M ilken'sI1l-79:7
m illion(141-109:18I
110:6,110:8 110:10,
110:16I110:21,
116:12.139:10,
215:7,238:12,
238:19,244:16.
244:17
millionsI91-60:22,
6229,63:-/.132:231
166:16,252:181
252:22
m ind (6l-10:22.
11:16,21:6I45:8,
52:20.231:20
m indfulI1l-10:23
mineI11-111:2
mini(
61-171718.
156:1?.15729,
15Z':15.158:11.166:7
mini-trialI1I-131:18
minimtlm fll244:18
InlnorityI11-81122
m inute(sI-14:24,

methodologyI3I-

19:17.79:18.80:11,

z7:4 wrrl3 r/:1


78:s 78:14 81:19,
82:s 1t)j:j8 103.4
214:14
malfunctionlll41:
20
manjll-218:8
managem ent(al250:7 )
?so:l1 2so:12
Mananement(31-

197:14, j97:17,
208:19
matterl
q -6:14,
10:13, 21:11.42:12,
52:21, 125:9,204:14,
2G4:15
mean(zq -57:20,
92:23, 125:1,131:1,
131:
21 151:9
160.17,177:31

lzorzs zj()r.ja 211:.g


m ottlodsrzj-30:9,
:s4:13
Miao z -123:14,
188:21
Mjchaelt1N - 2:1,
s:23 57:22 61:24,
76:9'78:15'7g:7,
85:6'8s:
:8
'5:9
1.
1q.4 150:a, 150:6,

144:1
minutesI4l-14:1,
137:
6.163:
9,2132
0
Miss I11-160:17
mlssing (164-43115,
121:15.121:20,
122:21122:
61122:24,
1232151123:24,
145:7,158:14
165:21,195:1li

81:24

237:15 246:14

183:13,193:22,

18a:1s

248:18

196:22,197:8.

metpl-227:
231

228::$ p..e?a:4

116:201117:21150 8

207:5.207:14,
221:18.221:19,
231:21,233:5,233:
6
Iooks(
3I-71:3,
71:5,100:11
loopI1l-152:9
Iostla
q-29:
9,29:19.
217:19 252:21
low lll-208:
9
lowerizl-81:22,
Iuck($I-130:24

majotity(1!j-37:17,

material123)-15:17,
15:20 20:17, 20:18.
25:3 44:18 82:24,
i83:3 83:10 83:20
98:22 102:41 1Q2:7,
102(11 106.9
128:17 130:181
141:6, 141:7,141:8,
166:9.207:5,253:12
Math (1I-182:14

15

194:19. 196:11,

LIZA (ZI
-IAPEH , C'
CR, RMR

Michael'
sa -

195:12.198:16.
201:41201:5,201:19,

(-/75) 323-5492

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 55 of 65


,,. .'
s. .....
(L(
E;
.

217:17 217:23

..

'

('
'
.

230.20.234:22,

70:9 70:14 70:22

nobodypl-97:3,

mi
staketll-167110
mistaken I2I-

2
37:16,238:141
239:4.:,39.5,239 7,

125:11,125:16
misunderstood t2)193:24 194:18
mixedI1)-14424
modelertli-25.16
modelingtll-24:2
models(1I-150:11
modifiedlsl-31:11,
48:20I 48:22I 149:1zp
24j:5

240:7,:'40.18.
246 17.247:5,
248:22,249:231
255:19.256:3
Montlpom ery's(16129:2.5:$.8197:11.
9B'12,98:18,101 19,
104:22,106:3.
114:12,121:3#
122.19,132:10.

namepzl-22:7,
22.11 22.13 22:14,
23:9 30:19 75.8
847 88:8 92'3
121.11 123.14
1429 167:13
167:15 174:19
174:20 175:211
188:131189:5,203:71
226:23
names yl-46:91

modiing(1I-103:5

132:19,133:
2.211:6I

94:1T 95:6 95.18

5:1.6:7,7:6,172:1

modulize!1I14a:14
momenttq -19:12
j,732jd 1fs :1z,
220:10 233:7 255:10
Monday I11-46::s
moneypaj-47:9,
47:16 s4:1 s4:4
s4:jtjg(;:.; 15a:22
23::10 238:14,
238:20 244:23,
2sz:f) zw r1:
$
2s2:1s 252:20
252:21,252:24,253:1
monitora -40:12,
% :j()'64:jz
Montgomew p111:12 1:13 1:13.1:14,
1::4 8:22 13:1s
!4:19$1s:19'24:16.
26:2. 26:3. 29:21,
30217. 31:5. 31:14I
31:17, a3:20,34:9.
40:22 43:9 43:11
43:1s.44:lz,46:6,
46:15 M :1,54:3,
67:17I68:22,73:20,
78:4,78:12 81:14,
82:16,97:22.97:24,
98:10 101:
23

245:3
m ontlaI2I- 176:18,
176:19
m onths(41-32:E$:
41:18.:!17:18.217:21
m orningp-q-s:4,
5:11.5:14,6:1,6:11,
11:21.:59:2.39714.
40:5,4:$:23,43:24.
47:1.48:21,48:24
M ost 31-26.22,
181:10,190:24
m ost l'rl-12:8.
12:9,1zl:5I25:13,
25:17..10:8.43:20.
110:1II45:13,154:6,
175:3.182:12,
185:18.194:9.
194:23,250:21
mostlyI:)-11:10
motherlll-167:13
motitlnllzl-13:6,
13:8.13.9.13.11.
13:12 13:21 18:21
12a:16,1as:1,
186:16:192:6
Motion(11-144:12
Motor(2I- 176:15.
176:18
m0VeI% -35:20.

Nanyanga 175222 175.23


narrow ing (1153:13
Natlll-70'21
nationallal-14:23
15:3 129:10
nationalsla -264,
44:18
naturetsl-12:5,
14:18 15:2, 15:20,
241:
22
Navintal-188.15,
188:20
Navytj!-2()6:J3
near(z)-33:10,
72:24
necessarily(2I16:1 160:s
necessarytll-18:
6
23
(
j
xj
- 1j;
r1(,(! I
,
19:3,4c:2I 60:z, 71:1.
w :21. 125:8. 131:3,
1:$1:5 j36:1z' 13-/:6
l44rs'14a 148:a '
:s
14829 16a:19
169:12.181:13.
1:1:14 l8j:2z.
181:24 182:1. 182:4,
182:8 182:15,

176:51241:13,259:1, 210:5
259:5.259:18
Northem yl-175:9
Nevada-renotl)175:10 175:11
176:5
note(31-25:4:
nevery4l-41:
9,
125:6 182:5
43:13 43:18,43:19.
noted(1I-25:6
47:17,62:10,66:20,
notepad(1I-57:8
67:3,67:23,69:1,
Notepadill-153:1
73:14,75:17,76:2,
notes!2I-259:10,
79:20,80:20.80:211
259:14
83:8.86:19,87:20.
nothing(1zj-18:23.
93:24194:22,110:23, 51:11 e4:z'
2 113:17
119:13 120:9
115:1s 115:1z
120:18,120:20.
1js:23 116:4, 116:7,
122:17,123:23,
116:10 119:j2,
124:11,130:21,
133:2 192:14,
l
2a):a,
133:15,135:6,
203:20 218216, zs6:4
149:19.164:23,
Nothinga -219:8.
166:21,193:21,
22z:15 24a:1z
193:23'194:2'213:2,
DOticedp)- 38:1zs
251:20.254:4,
:$():1($ :s )19 4::8
,
, .
255:211 255:23'
46:j, s4ij./
255:24
notwitjw u ndinq(1j
Neveqzl-73:13,
j:$:$:11
s8:l
uovem bera new (31-50:15,
49:2:$ z:$1218 247:2:$
193:3,121:15
num jyertlgj- 50:3,
Nexttll- 182:12
s9:!9 (jj:zz a6:j:s
next1221-7214I3527, x :4 y(M:
6 jc8rx
39:2,39:17,40:14,
jjor
s 11z:z 15z:
9,

1oz:1 120:21
125:
21,125:24.
$32:21,133:8,
$33:14,133:21,
134:8,136:22,138:2,
153:11,153:20,
153:24,162:10,
164:6.169:17.188:5.
190:14,190:17,
190:22,193:21,
203:16,212:17,
212:22,21315,213:6,

19::22.2oJ:s,213::4
MoveI11-143:
22
moved(4I-49:18,
84:11,1M :13,84:18
m ovieI21-87:4,
243:11
movies!1,-27:18
movingI1l-186'4
Mp3(?1-148:17,
148:18
m ultiple(4I-34:11.
54:21,54:22.220 2

226:e 2s1:2a, 2s6:


6,
257:15
needed lq -7:20,
83:5 194:17 251:15.
252:10, 257:12
needs(2I-11:14,
21:18
negoti
ations(1)241:9
networkpzl-26:19,
31:10,32:5,40:18.
40:20,63:14,63:17I

122:1s,122:22,
123:11,123:13,
159:1,172:9,183:1,
202:3,202:20,
226:13,25325
niceUI-108:12
ni
9ht(
51-14:16,
34:
23,35:6.39:5,
43:20

2x :!9 2(v:9 21s:6,


221:j6 244:1:$
num wersg!. 49rz4,
jzarzz
numerom (41z()s:14 zj1:gj
21a:12 z2.
I:
21
Nvta -1:24, 259:21

nightedI21-6:91

224:9,227:24,
228:21.230:191

mysteryE1I-15.9

64:5,64:13.65:2,

6t;:11,65:16.70:7,

L IZA (JHA PEN , C'


.C Ft, RM 11

7
1.
4,T1:11,71:16.
84:18,84:21 85:14,

17
3:2.231:20
Nonetsl-35:16,

97:41109.13,149 16.
217:81223:2
Netpzorkpl-31.T1
70.4,70.21
networking(3131:21169:5,205:9
networksI21-64:14,
70.9
Nevadallsl-1:5.
1:9 1:22,2:6,2:14,

106.8 116.15
145:13 149:15
noneI51-31:9 36:1.
99:24,100:1,102:11
Noonlll-171:20
noon(s1-4il:17,
125:3 131:14 137:5.
162:13
norm al!2)-93:5,
256:12

normally(
2I-191:5,

6:1Z
nineI2I-51:181

242:10
ninety!11-219715

o.clockpl-34:22,

245:17, 257:11

(775 ) 323- 5492

oath(21-44:
20

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 56 of 65


.. , .

121:18.123213
125:2,125:20.

operationsI1l245:
5

68:24,116.231179:
23
overheating(1I-

10J56 101:9,101'12.
104:15 119.14.
128:
22.131:
24,
132:3 161:2211II'Y.
181:12.193.13,
198:
22,19922,
200.1.201:8,204:1I
209:1.209:11,
209.13,234:15,
235:
2 254:3 25425
254:13I255:13,
255:16I256:9

offict'127)-5:22.
6:10I7817:12,7:13,
3Z:22,3829.38:16.
39'8,33:13.39:16,
39217.41:17.44:1,
47:4,47.6,47:7,
54:14,54 6,72 19.
77:15,127:1,155 19,
158'
7,159.22.
161:18 166.19
Officelzl-113:1'?'.
139:4

131:14 135:16
1:$i':11.137:20.
13916,141:19.
143:10.143:14.
145 5,145:8,146:241
1ti1:19.154:241
156210.155.24
1b'
/:4,158:12,159:51
159:18I160:
9,163:/,
165'22 167:7
1($7:12.185:7,186:/,
187:23.19124,

opinionI41-204:21.
215:21I218:131
236:12
opportunityI4IT:24, 144:151162:11.
227:22
opposedI5I-13.9
52.23 91:111134:18,
221:
9
oppositlon!$1253:13
order(
261-5:151

29:11
overlyt
21-21:3I
21.4
overruleI1)-45'9
overruledI2136:15, 236:13
overseeing (sI250:5
oversi
ght(11-111:2
overstatementI11118:14
overview (2I-

objectingI1l-35.22
objectionllq 3s:14.42:
4,52:8,
52:10,52:17.55:11.
79:9,K :!B.
,89.121
89:17,90:18,159:24.
189:16 214:20,
236:
6.240:
24

192'3.192.61192:9,

8:17 9:7 11:4I11:8I

245:11 250215

193:11,199.
3,2262'
/1

141:
3.210:23,212.9.
212:14 212:201

208420121024,
211'2.212:2,228.19I

246:18 246:20
officcsI11-72:13
Officesp!-2:12
Officialpl-2592
4
officialI1)-224:14
officidlly(11-180:2

231:51231:12.
231:14,23117.
231:19,232:6.
232:1T.241.51244:5,
244:7,250:201252:17
OneI
5I-67:51

1s:1 17:24. J9:8,


19.10 19:21I21:16,
105:
2, 108:8,127:2,
12::12 127214,
130:23 13626 136:9
143:2 169:17I2(2:f,
2j02
3 211:231 212:10
ordered(1!-223:22
ordinarilyI2l-

ow nI1s)-23:14,
26:11 149:4, 149:24.
188:7 193:16 195:1,
195:5 19527,204:18.
238:5 238:8 244:24.
252:17 254:23
ow ned111-230:19
ownershipm - 16:2,
249:10
ownsa - 12:20.
114:14 115:3

objection1
3q-6:16I

officials(
2)-90:9.

126:11,16310.

209:23 257:13

224:10
often (1l-34:11
oId(3)-40.2,49:16,
241:12
older(1l- 37;20
on-gcping (1j-237:1
once z!- 94:13,
j.
/.
9:6
once a)- 14:14,
15:16 j.
2.
5y!
,
oneI12isI-9:j7,
9:20. 10:24,11:2.
11:
s.1!:1;!,1zr1(;,
14 jt
l .j6:14 a4:12L
. .
,
,
25:22 :50:17' 3325,
'
3:$:10 .,$7:12 38:17
aa:zo.oo:z.4j:.1s.
48:4 49:9 49:10
'
49:1>
1 49::
14 50:4
.
50:19, 51:22.57:21,
s9:1a,(50:10.so:14,
8,
61:7 63:2 63:6, 68:
68:17 (58:18 69:1
70224 71:1 71:2
.k:11,
.72:7,
.
71:s, 7''
7
6:
1
0,
73:
4,7i$:1,
78:
4,78:7,86215,
86:17.i%:22,88:2,
a:
6,93:
4,95:6,95:
7,
g:3,1()3:11. 107:8,
107217,110;19,
112:12,113:11,
113:12,113:22,
114:20,114:
21.
115:16,119:1,

165216.223'17
On*S1161-28:5

organizationt2I119 212:12

ebjectionableI!1-

objections(1I-11:6
obscenitiesI1)44
:7
observe(1I-17:24
ouse- ed tu-?s:23
bviouslll-137:1
O
(XViOUSjyI1)172:16
occasionally(2l73:2 75:20
Occasionallylll64:14
occupation(1)227:1
occurlsl-35:12
occurredI2)204:19,204:21
offern -18:1s,

officeril1I-5:18,
6:1B,26:23, 82.17.

8.23,9:
4,9:10,10:10I
11:1,11:2.25:5
35:15'36:12,36:15,
44:21 4529.89:20
91:3,142:14,203:11,
216:15. 216:19,
224:17.224:19,
225:
7, 225:141226:81
240:1I240:2,241:18.
247:161248:
8,256:16
79:12

'
1
X
'

17

234.13I247:10.
247'11.247 13 254.4

Objectlzl-100:
241

,.

object1321-7:23.
8:2 24:15 101:3

236:7

,w

234:24,239:23.
247:15, 24816,253:8
'
2ss:5
olerecja -42:11,
234:8,234:11,

38:20,46:10.59:12,

82:
6,85.151109:14v
114:
7,123:221
141.16I141:181
146:24,147.8,
205:14,208 10
OO90in6l(3l-124:20:
129.
22.217:3
oO0I
4l-1:8'5:2.
1/1:26,1/2.2

open(
i1-14:9 17:
6

70:4.70.8.110''
18 '
'
134:11,134:171
1sl:19
openedtsl-1::21.
110:17,156'111
jjj
tjrzy. jw gj' j5.
/;4j
158:4,1591
21
opecateIsI-128:21,
12974,147:
22973'252:21,3170:12,
Operati
ngllzq60:21,228:
23.229:2.
23014.231:4.231:7,
232:15,233:14,
234:19,24524.
246:6.247:221249:9.
255:2
o erating
P
pal27114,37:1'37:15'
52:1,113:16,115:19,

116:5,123:
81148:15,
148:16.220.
2,220:10

LIZA (;HAPEN, CCRz RMR

organized2I-

10 19 210:14
organizingI11137:15
orginal(
111- 12:22.
z44 flarl7. 18a.2
21.
8:3. 231:12 ,
231:14 237:16
.
$
246:5,248:3'252:j2
DriginallyI2I- 47:24.

48:8
ositll- 129:6
otherwiselll
231:2Q
m0tuerwisel
13:12.:
$j:21.132:17.

,4,g
4
out-of-statetll-9:8
outjirjea . 1s:14,
f5z:j4 6g:s
outrag@ous($l
, :7
outsetfjl-12:1a
0ujsirjejjg . zj:17,
24:6.37:1.65:16,
1jzrj jjz:z,jj2:j:5,
112:
2'
2,115:a,
11s:14 j24:14
.
,
143:20 1sa:$. 1s6:6,
209:24'211:im
over-'
nlghted(zI6:9,(;:j.
y.
ovejajjsj.5:$2j6,

packagellj-243:5

packing(1l-38:8
eagetsj- 3:2
pagepj. 1j8:
:$,
jjay4 zztjrjj z:$!:6,
irjzrzzlzzqrzj,
z4s:.jz zya:j4
248:.
15'
'

;yp.a
pagesI1)-15(
paid (j4)- 86:9,
14:s'1js:;,1js:a,
jz6:!9 21::./ 219:9
21a:1:$ aza rs zxa:s,
zstj:j'zscr
jk '
zgtjgztj,z,yyz I
ealoljl- 2:9
paperoj.(
s :$:
$
:@j
4
(
sy
j
u
j
t
i
' '
' s'
j66:19 169:23
paradoxz -132:4,
jzzr:
earagrapup).
zr
jzaz
paragrapjjx .
jjjjra zatzjz, za4:j,
zag:jz
' z4():j(),
zjs rjz'a jljz
'
248:17'
pardon(1)- 215:16
earoj(jj.z:
$(5)8

(775) 323-5492

Paroja . zzjj:j,

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 57 of 65


.,.

(
?

(
.

. ''

-h

).E$

24123 241:4 241:5.

patentaI11-206.19

171:151172.121

59:5,59:9,65:6166'4,

241.12,242.5

patterrlI2aI-103:10I 1r2:15'1:2'20'

182.141244:22,247:6

place('
q-311151

parrott1l-220.18
part1:221-34:20,

103:15,103:19.
103:24,104:16

172:2311/3:4!173.7,
174:5.1F4:7,224:4,

45:3 56:2167:13.

119.15,128212,

224'21225:5.

perjuryI1l-117210

placedt11-157:14

68:13 7I:13 83:20


12926 135 12 145:6,
165:10 184:1 184:3,
193:19.193:20.
194.6 195:10,
195:12.196:2,
228:16 242:8,250.10
Partlyj-195:4
participateI5)-8117
9:9 9:12.9:23110:6
padlcipated(1179:6
padicipatingI1J10:14
particular116121:21,50:24,97:15y
1(m:10 105:
24.
143:13 191:19.
197:1.206:5,206:17.
220:10j222:1,225241
225:11.242:14
particularlyf
sl19:19,19:22,20s:12.
212:
21,241:2
parties(
3j-21:121

128:21.142:5.177 .
183:191185:17,
185:19.185'22.
186:8,136:15,
187:21.187:231
188:18,191:221
206:23,206.24.
20772.23/:11,
207:13,207:15.
228:8.237:6
Pattol'lls(3I-20Z'51
243:23,244:4
Patty11R -46:2,
46:5,49 10,64:23,
155:14.111:24!
123:191157:1I
157:13,158:2.158'
4,
158:12,158:19,
159:31159.16.
160:16.200:20
Patty'si!l-166:8
pay(21-153:221
154:2
payinlI1I-47210
payments(1I-249:8

225:13 225.15
226'21226:5,226:12,
229'
6.229:
21,230.1.
231:12.232.1.233:5,
233:10 2337191
233:22.2352161
253:7,253:15,
255:15I257:24
penaltiesI1117:10
pending(2I*21:15
206:19
PeopleB51-31:
4.
40:24.41:22,44:23.
45:19.49711.50:17,
/5:9,75215,76:13,
82;13,82:15,191:15.
101:16,102:14,
104:23.105:10,
105:17.112:1.112:31
112:14,1121231
121:23,123:171
123:20,133:3,
154:20,1Z9:141
183:51191(3,194:
20,

perm anent(1I41.1is
pennissible(1l9 24
perm ission I4l24:8 63:19, 83:4.
200:23
permissionsl7131:8 31:10 31:
20
31:22 149:13,
149:18 149:22
perm itrq -24:22,
25:1 242:9
permitsI1I-225:15
perm itted (1I-6:J3
permitting (
c1-24:
6,
108:8
eerry)-1:7
rson(131- 101:13,
124:7 124:13
124:16 143:j4
ja1:1 1a6:11 192:4
194:22 243:1:$
2s1:22
rsonalpj- 37.10.

plain($1-152:14
Plaintifftq -1:101
2:3 3:2 5.12 13:1
15:12
plannedI21-168:5,
168:6
planningI2I-137:7.
245:16
plansI:1-250:16
Plastic(1l-163:19
platform I2)-25:15,
186:4
platformsI
2)205:17 205:20
play(rI- 148:9,
148:15,148:22,
149:j 15j:22, 152:3,
152:
7
playeclI,)-140:10
player(aj- 28:16,
58::
$ 61r4, 84:a,
j4o:8 14(j:
9, j4o:13,
j4(;:9 j48:a
,
ejayerlzj-59:22,
60:1,60:14,87:13

21:17'235:5

Pcisl-25.15

a -116:8.
Partition(
116:9
artnerlll-255:19
p
P rtnersIa-77:24.
a
234:21
Partners(1)-238:2
Parjs I4)-61r10,
72:12,148:15,1M :12
PRdylS1-27:12b
g7:j4 azr; j1srj4,
z-tg gzj
passw or(j(1sjajs ,aj:la,w :1!,
:
s :1.
,, l4srjj,
165:10, 165:14,
165:16, 165:18,
165:23.166:2,166:5,
167:10. 167:12
Iyasswordst:j-

64:7. 166:12. 166:14,


166:16.166:19.
166:
23.167:3,167:6
past(131-8:
9,26:22,
29:4 32:8 34:11,
, ,
64:9' 110:12' $11:17,
111:19. 112:6.
159:12, 217:19,24314

Patenttz
q-184:18,

230:16,232:5.240:21

peripherallyI!l12:16

pixels111-181(2

Peekllozl-2:4,2:4.
5:11.5::2,6:15.7'22.
8:19,10.10,10:13f
10:22,11:16,11:18,
13:2,13.4.17:19,
17:22.18:2,18.102
18:14,18:23120:16I
20:23,21:2.21:
6,
23:19'67:6'74:19,
79:22,80:7180:12.

211221,213:22,
21023.223:10,237:
9,
241:8.245:1.250:12,
251:19,251:20,
254:23
PeopleS(11-'--:.
Per(5l-65222.6625,
66'12,103:1.253:9
perGent114)-63:2'
63 6.81:23,110:24.

197:41201:
6.209:8,

5j:j:
5'64:2*82:14#

8o21s.1a6:6,114:17,
124:18,124:23,

116.11,125:19,
137:11,137:20,

125:12,12z:z,
:27:15,127:18,
128:
5,128:8,130:11,
131:
8,131:11I
131:16,133:11,
134:10.134:13,
134:16.1M :24.
135:19,135:21,
138:5,151:21,
162:
20,163:1,
167:21,168:3,
168:
23,169:9,
169:11.169:20,
169:24.170:2,170:6,
1Z0:10,170:17,

184:
1,217:1xl,
zy
yr
rjz,zra.
y,
238:18,239:14
Percentagel8l7Z:2,86:4.87214.
%7.1'
r'99:10.137:22,
217:10.249:10
perfectl
yl
21-213:
7,
244:2
perform I21-128:14,
170:13
pefformance(1I247:1
perllaps1
51-14:10,
16 5,62:8,63:20,

1.;s:jz
pjjase($)- :4:13

1
70:20,170:24,
171:4,171:12,

11
1:2 aI-59:1,
period(

LIZA C'HAPEN, CCR, RMR

45:7,54:12,Z1:
20.
210:22 218:1.224:10

pjayersjl).149:4

1()::j:
$.199:14'
727:7.252:17
persona11yI71.
x rjo 8j:2 j1:$:2
. ,
,
j1z:22 124:4 161:
8
219:1
Personnej!1j. 44:jz
PoIYLIaded pj16:20
Iaja(ja - 176:8,

playjngI1j- u7:g
plentysj-10925,
jtlgrjzk' jigrj.
r
pjuggeda ..
/.
j:
8,
rs :< jy:$:jj
Pjuralg!-61)13,
rjjrrj
pjus(1j.225:1()
Pm (1j-172t1
po(1j.j(;1:1(;

puijipa - z:1.
;,7;g
jo oenjxljj. - :24
pj
aoneticI1)-176:21
physical($)-31:2
plwsicall
yz 216:12.240:13
pioturea -1n1:23,
103:22,487:13
picturesI1!-2823
pieceIsI-95:22,
129:1 169:23,192:1
'
pi
ece.
sIw -42:
2.
95:22.101:22.
102:19'103:20'
1682
8,216:9,217:17

jyrytj:sr.
y.
jz,
, zq:
a6):a ,4,:4, 6s ra,
120:7'120:12,
j2o:1'
4 125:z,
12s:17'125:23,
12s:
4,'
,29:19,
13s:14 1:$6:2,136:4,
'137:1,
136:17,
203:13,217:19,
218:8,252:14
positioftI6I-26:7,
130:2,174:23,180:7.
180:9,210:24
possessionIa16:3,78:19

Pillsburylll-2:8
Pittmanlj)-2:8

pockatpj.zss::j
pointp4)-15:18,

possiblep)-44:16,

44:17,66:15

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 58 of 65

f.,.- l
possibly(31-1Z12,

70'4 141:20 151:


4

oara

6:21 7:s

10z:1.1t)7r
:,1lz8.

precludedl,l-24:18
Predatorlll-68:6
preemptt')-lsr4
prefacez -12:z,
13:20

probllym (
1-8:13.
10:3,1:!11,14:7.20:3
131:21.233:12
problemsgl-lsEls
44::2

116.181135:10.
142:91145:181146:1,
146:
4,14a:2.14a:21,
179:23,190'18
208:5,209'2,209:4.

postt
1J-155:19
pot(11-239:14
potentiala -154:7,
176:20,228:8
potentially(3I126:19,147:12.
221:13
practically(11132:16
practice(8I-108.8.
209:
23,210.6
211:
23.212:8
212:11v212:131
222:24
practicesll)256:13
pragmatically($I132:17
preI2l-56'22.103:3
pre-existingI,I-

y'

processingI
4J-

151:5 241:6
17t
5.1I 176:3 1773'
prevelRts(11-70 13
211
)21
previcusI
3l-55'24
produceI11-162.4
230:5 :46:1T
product!s1-145:17.
previouslya 177:22,181:7 1819
182:8 114:2,214:23
200 14
prim atrilyI$I-169.2
Product(11-147:1
prim a'ry11I-2X .22
productivei1IPrim rv'!1J-78:7
218'9
privacy(1l-156:13
profession(31private(tsI-18:11,
20924,211:23,212:8
64:6 661
'2 70:
23
Professorlt)71:2 111L7.111:10.
17621
111:14 111:
20
profferI1l-224:5
1J1rzz.112:
4,113.6.
program lzxl-27:11.
121:4 ,22:20,125.8
slrs sl:1o s7:s,
privatalyt1I-47:
6
58.22 59:20 94:
4
privi
lege!
2I94:6.95:15.96:8,
173211.1T312
9Z:18,102:61102:91
pro tx)-srls,6:4.
p1:4.:8, losrzo,

procedura!(31-

220.5,221'23

Program mers(11-

149:11

programmers'(sI51:4 51:9 94:16,


10Q:1 21623
programmfng 112124:3 24:4 37.7.
37:19 55:23,56.6.
57:5 101:5 150:15
15Q:17 150:19,
205:12
program s(15127:13 66:23,76224,
119:19.141:22
142:1,1422
21142'6,
142:7,142:13,
143:11,150:20,
208:3.251:
23
Progresst
71-37:6
105:9,123:
6,149:23
211:13,214:121
244:14

projectlJa;-28:1t5,
30712. 47:12. 4Z:13,
58:2.58:23.76:41
107:
24,147:20,
147:21 151:20,
1Z6715.244:21

profects(
211-30:11

11:3. 1'I:12. 11:24


procedurea 14:15 211:4,22o 24
proceduresIs127:1 4zl:14 83:17,
,
8a:j.
()
roceed 1191-11.17.
p
11:18 '11:23 12:1
13:7 13.8 13:13
.
13:1,
8,'
14:,
8,15:9.
,s,,8.,0,19,'aoa,
13::
9 '131:3 131:4,
131'8. I31:1I
proceeding (311za.,s.Jx ,1o.

PrO9fam l71-59:8,
141:20.1459.
145.17,146 7
165.19,165'20
Prograrnw isel'!59.8
prK ram m ed(3135*12,57:
6,205:13
Pre rammer113125:16,25:1iI 37:12,
s',
.
w .s',a:'.s4:s,
1021
23.102:24,
122:4.149:12 150:4
203:Z,20011T
proarammer-spl-

30:15137:3,37:6.
54:22,54:24.57:23,
59:6 67:18,71:14,
86:9.86:12,87:101
8874.119:221137:241
138:9,188:18.
190:23,210:14,
217114
PC0mPti11-39722
Pr/perl
21-16:19I
2:
$s:19
properly(11-47:1Q
propertyp)170:21,184:16,
1s.,1.
?

1q,ti,c4.,. ..:z.
45:2 46:8 85:22

coa,l:
s
Proceedings(1I-

z2(),1s
Prograrnmers(z61-

proposedt,,-zas:s
Propri
etafy (
2l-

99:22 161:1 182:23


187:11 215:24 259:7

1:19
proceedingslgl-

28.12.30:13 31:7,
34:8,36:21,36:
24,

15:
6.17:16,18:17.

37710.57:
21.59:4,

10:24 11:1,11:4
21:z
preservet
zl-97:
7,
216:17
Preservingpl:.21:1
residenta p4:
f7
24 fdt):)
presidentpl-17:z
press(JJ-65:10
eretty(1j-29:
4

1B:19 20:4,20:8,
21:
20. 24:9, 259:10
processI1sI-8:
2.
89:
8, 17
?7:
4.131:12.
185:16 192:12.
206:9,.
?11:21,
213:21 216:2,216:9,
217;1 al7:3 220.24
243:21 251:141
253:13 2s3:16
.
processes(1)-

71:10,74:1 74:4
74:23175:2,75:4.
Z6:0,76:9,76:12,
75:14,87:9;88:2,
104:24,121:9,
142:21.143:7,
143:10,149:6'
149:22,15Q:3,
211:14,214:12
219:24 229:16
'
,
245:131250:5

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR r RMR

19

preferll)-69:14
preliminaryll!21:11
Preliminaryp)1:20, 5:8,162:3
prem isesIsI-2::19'
27:7,1(x):18.111:4.
155:18
tionI1IPr
38
:6epara
preparesj-,::,6.
20:2 117:20,117:24
preparing Iaj42:17.42:22.137:16
resentt,y-,9:1z.
p

PresentingI
4I-

210222

56:2 60.11

prefacing(11-13:20
t
.

pretty(GI-34.11.

11:12,12:19
protectlll-17:15

179:23,190:14

204:20

providedI4)-7:16
25:2 128:16 188:5
providinglj1190218
publict4I-65:10,
65:21#68:
6
publiclyi11-68:7
pull(31-196:24
197:1 197:2
Pjllvertzll-2:12,
2:13 5:221173:13
purchased(
2I108:19 115:6
Purchasingtll13z:16
purchasinggl26:20 85:16
Purposelzi-230:13.
2:
$4:
4 235:24
ur
p posetm -1::8.

1x :
6 bza:l4 zss:jz

purposelesst11203:22
purposeax -3z:,4,
1:$7:z 2022.
/ 245:16
Pursuantltl-

230:19
pursuitljj-21:20
putpa -19:2(),
zl:js 4.1:18 6s:2j,
y.
.
1:jg .
;z:
aj 8a:21
91:19'111:9' 1z():2,2
lr
ssra,1:
$s:j'
() j4:
$ry'
,
143:12, 14:$:z(
')
.
,
14g:a 1492:
$
1gl:j6 i?():
$:j1
20:
$:15,203:21I
aa rla 2t. 1s
21::22 21g:17
224:10 235:9
238:10 23::14,

zza,zo a.4,,e
,
zs2:16,
puttingpj-204:7,
222:22 243:4

protectedI
41-

145:11,165:11,
165:14. 165:16
protecting(!1196:4
protocolpl224:11'224:15
protocolsI11255:24
prototypes (
j!-

244:11

provide(41-159:5,

Q
quantifiabletll21s:5
questionsllz)s():
2(), lt)(kza.
150:24I 1s4:2:$.
j7zis,2j1rz,2:a:ja,
z4zta
24a;ja
249:18 2sj:12
jk'
erp
quc )-2:3:11
quite(21-1:7:15,

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 59 of 65


20
.- '
h
)
213.21

237222 246:23 249 1

quote11I-155:11

'

reasonablyI11-

215.1

reasoqs(1)-221I
rebuttal(1l-18:6
receike(ak-8:1
102:Z 176:4
receivedtsI-6:10.
27:23,6,0'3.156:18,
175.20
recent!51-7:1I
25:17.145.14 154 7b
250'21
recently!81-25:13.
26:22.29:18.32:8.
112:5.144:17.
1s8:23,251:7

lldtzj-21t
):17.
212:18
rack(41-70:18.
72:7 85:17
rackstll-85:18
radio(11-194.9

Rai410l-33:16.
38:18 40.9 40:19
41:6 :35:3 145:
4
14s:5 145'6 216211
raisedI
a -129:19,
224:6

aam lj-170:7

.
.

recessIzI-108:2

110'5

recordingE5)-

32'1,57.2.62:7,

62:13,62:14112J.2,

122:14 230:5

48:10.48'19 48:20
66:4.115:14
records(91-7737.
11.12.II.17 77:23
Z8.15 81:16 255 22
255:
23.256.2
recovertzc)-29:8
29:13 51'
2 53:11
53:17,90:11.94.14
94:15,95:10,96:12
96:16,97:1219T:14.
97:16,97:17.105:21I
206.7,216:51216.8.

Referrlng3l230.11 246:12
248:12
refersI1l-5B:21
reflectt2)-169:13,
216:18
regardI1z1-12:1
17:
9 18:1,19:13.
21:19.85:19.101E2
103:9 104:15
104:22,107:21,
127:
3,136:10,
153:16,161:3,

217:1

169:13 212:21

125:3.:3-/:f'.$71'19
171:201245:18,258:2
Recesqzl-108:4,
258:4
recitiog(1)-45:7
reckless I1)-223.14
recogaitionpz1.
68:3.1(.3:1n 1()3:1s.
103:19.103:24.
104:16,105:7.
1()s:12.10s:15,
105:22,119:15,

recovereul?al51:11,51:17189:7,
90:5,91:22.94:17,
94:18.ss::7,95:24.
96:1.96:4 96:7
96:23197:2,100:3.
100:13,206:10,
217:5.21T:10
217:12,217:139
217:16.218:
7
j
r
y
recover gI(;j.
89*
8,95:16.100:
8,

regaruin:l1)-2% :8
registration I
31186:3,186:7,192.12
regularp,-33:21.
34:10 37:1 57:8
85:6 11323 116:8,
143:48. 206:1
regularlyIsI-57:21
zl:13. 72:15,112'9,
114:21
rejatepj-:$6:2:$I
18:18

128213,128.21,

120'17,216:
9,221:12

related(
4I-127.
8,

241:17,z4z:s
reachI51-14:14.
15:16'j2s:j6,jx ::$I
136:24
read1/31-9:20'57:8'
118:7,132:13.133:
6'
145:15'151:19
5z:j:2 '
152:2'1
?.
a:1f
'
),
178:18.j.
233:21

128:22,142:5,177'7,
ja:$:2(), ja5:17.
185:19.185:22,
186:8'186:15,
187:21I187:23,
188:19.191!22.
jgarj()'ztsrzy.
207:1. 207:2,207:11,
207:14I 207:16.
228:91237:6,240:21

recovery1141-50'
24, 127:
9.185:19' 221:12
51.1,5z:7js3:10,
rejatesI
61-139.2,
96 8,962161100:6,
1sl:1.151:2.13:19,
105'20.124:101
185:22, 205:23
206'5,206:
9,216:24.
relating (
s1-14:61
2173,221:
2
186:
8'186::5.
recreate(
sj-19s:22, jzrjg'2(s:44.
199:99217:23.218:4, 237:2, 240:19'240:20
218:14
Rejativqzl-227:13,
recreated(11227:14

readable (1j-179:1

recognize (m 239:9,246.3 248.1I


z54:z() .
recolloction(11a
zrztl
1OCOCCIX*OdSl'l5:12
reconstruct(1)-

195:19
Recrosqzq-3:5,
:$:j:$,j5s:a(zz:;:1:
ReGross
exam inationI11-3:5

relatively (11- 155:6


relax(1,-46:1il
rajuas.sj. zl
kjz,
6s:11
relevanoet31-

OCFCIO111-51716
redirecta -138:14,
160:3'160:6
Redireclsl-3:4.
3:12.138:18,202:11'
222217
referencei
4I-16:13,
19 19.234:16,237:14
referred(101121210.139:14.
148:11.178:24.
236:1,239;12,
240211,242:23,
24g:17.:4::2:$

80(24'81:10,163:2
reliable(1I-71:21
relied (
!I-245:4
reluctantI1j-124:20
relyt
4)-2@J:17,
:ltla:az'211:22.215:1
remainI1)- 18:19
remarks(1j- 12:7
remembertal46:2,6z:l4,x :a,
gs:7,123:14.16z:gz,
163:24,j65:g.1a;::$,

ionalet2lrat

readyl6)-11:17,
11:18,13:7,13:8,
38:6,43:21
reaIistic(1)-180:23
realized(1I-41215
really1161-55:8,
K :17,90:19,130:3,
1512
5I151:
6,169:6,
j::4,jq(
;tj,jrsrg,
18:
197:
23':
198
4j:
29jy
*202:5'
213:19,

reason1111-10:8'
'-

recorded(21-48:5.

referringpl-28.8

ramificationsI1Ij:$:$:20
ranI
sI-48.1.50:
24,
51:1.5$:13.65:14.
97:18 4c'
r:7 178:8
random ll)-33:6
Randgl)-za:9
rangelll-s6:2
k jl-4s:4
ran (
ratea -36:17,
96:1:$.' z!9:1t;
r'atherljl-lzzls

reading(1,-234:1

(
,.

257.16

29:16I35:11t38:4,
83:12,129:23,
132:23,1321
24,
uo x.x on o.x o.j<.0

lt
''
*son
'*1J
'**,i
L,L.''''
r'
ea
a<
se
sj

221:21
record(241-19:10.
19:11,21:11'21:
241
36:14'67:4z70:6'
103:13, 121:1,
1
129:24'172:22'

75:7,233:22.
216:17,216:18,
239:1.246:10.253:2,
253:3,255:12,256:4,
2s.
/.
rlc,,s7L1s,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

<
'o
'
4
''
.q
'*
'
p
''
q
o
.m
'
o
r
q
h
'.
z
z
s:
jz
z'
5(
)2
zj
,

rem ind(1)-153:8

removableI
2I-

123:7 220:3

removed!2I-18:8.
123:7
rendedng(1)-74:14
renoI1j-176:5
Renqq -1:22 2:61
2:14 5:1 17271
259:18
Rephrasql)-89:23
replace(11-207:8
Replya -231:24,
233:12
reportl4)-50:6,
s0:1() 188:12 1%:16
reported I1j- 122:8

Reportedlj-1:24
reporterlq - s:10
j42j2 9z:f
5 j81:17.
257:9 259:7
Rep'
orteya -22:11,
lzsrjo 259:4
reporters($j245:1.
/
reportslll- 188:10
repository(112j()
:j:$
representjzj. 8:za,
2:$z:z()

representation(3I
-

6:16 (,:18 a;1s


,esent
,ations(2lrepr
a:9 9:1
' esentative(a repr
4z:x 1!a:4
repr'
esentkng I
o.
tygrj .yayjj
'
represent,
s!aj(yzrti.
,82:$ 2()z:a
' '
z1
requestIs1-13: .
stjrq s();1() j(;j:z4,
:55
2)j 1
yequosteuja .
50:131 113:24
requjrea .aj:j9,
2z4:1()
requirerjnj.14j:4
requjrpm ent(1!j8():2a
requiresI2J-183:7,
w 4:j(;
requiringI1!. 97:23
research(1)- 244:20

Researcqlj.176:16
resarvepj. jrzg,
w saj zz6:g
'ng(jj.z54::j
reservi

reset(
21-5Q:14,
5::15

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 60 of 65


w... x)
21
resideI1?-22:9

('

111:20 111'22.

ectI
41-130:11.
20re6sp
:23,242.23.25/:6
respectfully!aI8.24 18:14
respondlll-8:10
respondinga 40:16.40:19 40:20
responsibilitiesI21-

1124.112.12.113($'
113'23.115:20
123 13.156:10.
156.12 156:13
156.22
Rouglll
/tl-59:13
route111-56.4
routerI91-65:13.

180.12,250.10

65:14,70'11I70212,

responsibilityI2I242:31250:1
responsible112126:21.29:22 29:24
30:3,183:4,183:8
186.
6,191:10.
200:17,210224
223:11,250:2
rest(91-38:241
41:12,43:13144:10
111:11,118:19.
119:8,123:18 150:5
restatedI1I-232.
5

70:20.71:19,98:3
223:3
routes!11-56:5
row (2I-1Z:18
207:8
RuI
q21-9:
4.225 16
ruleIl:j-6:12,9:6
9:11, 9;x4I9:2019 21
10.5,10.23117:14,
236:8,241r5,241:
6
241:J3,242:6
ruled 1
'l-216:16
rules(
:.
1-16:21

Restatectzll-245:24. 83:14

246:6,247:22,255:2
restrictI2)-186:3
2046
restfiction(2!70:16.71:17
resutta -6::21
182:24. 204:22
results(1I-133:22
resume(:1-73:17
reu ined Iz!-2!s.z,
219:5
retum ed(z)-118:6,
216:14
revenuel,l.99:14
rvxvenuesp)-:7:1:

reviewpl-19:19,

20:23.83:21

reviewedI1)-82.19

revolutionaty (
!1z.D :jz
ric:(!1-139:12
ridl,l-40:1
Rm q'l-1:24
roadpl-256:17
Robedll-1:
7
Rogerqll-56:3
role:1-26:23'
245:3
Romaqzl-3:10,
2ozrl!x a:a

rulingI11-126:21
run1141-27:17
28:23, 32:5.51:10,
51:14 60:15 96:12
124:
9.1.18:16.
150:21 171:9,
207:10.208:3
runablelll-27:10
runningI14J-39:1,
65:15,9t5:14.95:21
96.9.10()2
6.113:12
124210.'178:5,178:7,
178:21.:!43:14,
24s:10,:,so.
2
runs k
2l-13S:7.

14723

224:20, 224.21

S
sabotagelll-41:21
safetcs)-14:12,
:43:2n.144:22,
15s:12, :5s:16,

''

5:21
roof(
1l-48:1
t'
oflm (1% '.a!:z'

39:18,72:18.111:7.

1s7:18'1S6;s

'

111:10 111:14

sbveI2)-188:23,

189:1
saw Il()
j- 94:12.
113:12 113:21
157:18 157:22
15f
):11 159:18,
167:21 167:
6.244:8
schedule(#I171:10
scheduled11I42:19
school(jq -23:23,
23:24 2422 175:1
175:2 175:
4, 175:15
176:6 205:4, 227:10
schoolingI11-25:11
sciI1)- 153.14
science(2j-176:9,
2061:
6
Soientifiotlj1?s:1s
scopea - 160:3.
160:
6 207:3
scrpj-9:4, 9:7
screw I!)- 47:9
scriptta)- 191:13,
191:16
sealIj- 18:18
sealedlal- 14:10,
j4:l:$ j5:7 1aral),

124:2:
1,1:
$0':j,

155:18.155:22,
155724115671,156:2.
156:9. 156:21,157:1.
157:7. 157:11,
157:12.158:3,158:4,
158:6,158:16,159:3,
159:19,160:4,161:7'
161:11,161:14,
166:
4,16s:8
safesIsl-83:
z,
113:8.155:4,157:3.

RonaI
421-2:12,

250.18 250219,
25020'250:22
Sam antll1-122:5
sam plet21-27.17
11(515
satellitelll-154'3
satisfiedt1I-207.20
saurabh(21-188:15,
18820

Salal
y (1-136:20,

sealingI1j-17:15

search(41- 88:20
89:3, 162:7,162:81
seatedlal-s:s,
17;1 Joar
s
secondI1q -11:12,
58:
23I74:10l79:17I
92.17'110:4'110:5'
154:24 176:2,
180:17'
181:8,187:1,
.
2:1:16,217:23
seconda -1:
5,2:6,
259:
4

secondlyz -16:12.
42(5.1s
secrecypl- 173:1:
secrett
a)-12:16,

(srj.
/,1:u:1,1ajre,
153:9 153:10

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

153:13,156:10
156:12
secretary(31173:13
secretive!21- 12.9,
17:2
sectioni3l-72:12.
72:13.74:7
securei2I-113:8
211:1
Securitypl- 42:21
43:22,83:14
securlty(
2n -12.10
12:14, 14:23 1574
20:12.26:23.25:
24,
27:1,42:18,42:22,
47:201 7714.77220,
81:11, 82:17,83:9,
114:23,129:10
135:13, 141:3,153:8,
192:22,206:7,
212:22. 218:23
224:11 224215
see(581-10:2 10:
3.
1077, 142
22,15:
21,
17:12 21:5 24:
20
24:21,39:18,40:19.
43:15,63:21 65)15
74:19,75:23 83:1,
91:8 102:10 106.6
113:24.114:17,
116:
3,128:20. 131:31
136:
24,137:3,
144:22,156116.
15821.158:3 163'5,
163:15,164:1,
166123116724, 171:6,
182:17,187:13
191:2,191:3,193.3,

227:6
sendl2I- 7:
11.
134:18
senseI51-60:8
90:17 90:20 92:15
179:10
sentlzl-6:5 7:7
separate(
6)-3Q:18
33:3, 91:11,119:5
165:15,166:16
Septemberp)-64:
9,
231:101 239:7
sequencel71147:18 178:10
191:1,191:2 194:10,
194:13, 194221
sequential(1j148:1
series(9l-70:17%
72:14 207:
8 207:9.
208:5 208:
21
228:17 233:14 244:3
sefve(1I-179:14
sefverI
l'
q -30::
30:19 30:21I 31224,
32:2 32:
6 32:7
32:24 39:18 40:11,
64:10 72:18 94:18
95:9 1i%:3 !:4
.)
:5,
c16:11
serverlj)-30:22
sefvers(1a1- 28:23,
30:17 32:
3 32:
4,
z2:j(
),32:j:
z,33:4
39:19 64:2 64:12
71:a 72:20 j18:j1,
122:15 171:5
21s:1o, 215:13
servicea - 42:21,

1
93:
6,195:14.197:
2, 43:22sj
,8
3:15
jqar:j ztl4rj()zt)srj
oajjj

z
'
.
zjarjtl'zaarjz.
231:22,232:6,236:2,
246:16, 248:19,

248:21,249:22
seeklll-130:23
Seem (
21-16:
3,16:4
Segmentrzl-/0:23,
?1:11
sel
ectionz 1Z6714,177:21

Selfpl-24:3198:11,
98721
Self-destnzcttll98111
sel
f-destructs(
1I9*:21
Self-tatlgbtlll-24:3

sellltl-19:
4

Semiretiredp)-

se5
6
. 5:
j
y
j
sj
.
Se ( xrjjj.
31:22.:
$z:a'4a;z,
5::4. 63:1/, 64:,
cy4:11'> :2:$,64:24,
7o:ta x :19 z1:1
z1:11 72:1 72:4

72:14p211:
6

setting(r)- 38:10,
x :12. :$9::I 4a:
8,
% :19' 84:21
settlementpl- 10:6
setupllj-85:14
seven pj- 218:12,
227:4, 251:9
severaltll- 14():s
severalp)- 32:3,
z4:j2.:57:13:99:!9j

.
11a:10,13a:2aI

139:
3 139:91 198:19

(775) 323-5492

'

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 61 of 65

M*xJ
shallI41-9:819'21I

f
'

74:16.94'21.99'22

55'5 56r15 56221

207:24 208:1

154.1,'
184:13,208:51

1()0.7j100.141

56:23157:14,58:5,

208.24 209.4 209:9,

share(6!-318.
78:4,105:1I105:21
140:4,243:6
shared(3I-49.11,
201'1,252.4
sharelxoldert3l78:16.78:22.80:3
shareholderspl77:18.78:5 /8:6
78114.81:18.81:22.
82:4.82:19
sharingI11-31:11
shaw lll-2:8
sherifftll-14.11
ship(1I-140.9
shoestll-184:8
shootingI1I-46:17
shorta -42:14.
lss:s 217:s
ssotlll-16:11
sltouldertl,-231r21

211:18
Singaporelll115321
singlf,t7I-74:9.
110:4,'110:171116:6.
147:14 1$7118 148:2
singler-storyI1l74.9
singularl6l-54:18.
55:2,55.5 61:14
62:14 6)1.9
sittl:l-18:4.1s6,
89:10.6)0.2,90:12,
103:18 106:12
126:14,164:4.164 8.
167:8
sitlll.79:18
siteI4$-'?1:s.
150:13,150:17.213:1
sites(z1-2:.24,f3s:7
sittinfl(21-1n:11,

11514,143:15,
178.4,178.6,178:81
1789.178:10
178 12.183 18.
185:2,185:15.
185421,186:10
191.18,195:16.
200:18,205:7.
205.19,205:15,
209'3,210:81210:111
210:13.210:14,
210:18.211:1.21124,
215.12.218:1.220:7.
220.231222:21,
223:1.227:14.
230:18,236:1.236:5,
240.18.240:20.
251:24
Sold ill-228:21
solelyp)-238:4
solidlll-130:6

58:15,58:18,58:20,
59:10.59220,59.24,
60:6 60:24 61:3
62:4 62:5 62:18
62:20,63:2.63:6,
66'21 76:2 85:4
85:20 85:24 86:19
87:7,87:20:87:241
88:11.88:15,88:22.
89:1,89:6189:11.
89:17 90:3,90:14
91:9,91:10t91:19
92:10,93:19193:21
94'2196:17 96:22
96:23 97:13 100.12
101:9,101:12,
103:23,104:3 104:5
105:11,105:22
105:21,106:241
107:5.107721.
107:23.110:24.

210:7 211:11I214:71
214:10 214:17
215:14 215:17
215:22 217:1 217:5
217r10. 217:11I
218:6 218:12
218:14 220:12
220:15 221:1
222:22,223:12,
224:11.224:12
Sourcez -37:3
3::5 58:21. 61:11,
179:6 179:8 220:13
spaceltq-33:4,
33:7 51:6 51:8,
116:8, 116:9
sparelll-156:17
sparetlj-:57:10
speakerlll-23:14
speakingfjl-252:1
sneaks(:q- 236:9,

showllq-45:7
'

''

J'
'

showinglzl-

.'
:
i

.
..

'

-.

2;!

246:20,24822

z7:18.77:24, a1:1z.
117:9 136:9 177:24
190:24' 191:1' 204:1z
showed('
n -35:1,
sarlz, s4:12,1st5:24,
243:12 243:15
,
.
244:12
243:18, 243:19
show n!41- 44:17.
78:16'236:1(
)'256.3
shows(zI-so:3'
222:2
sllylll-33:8
sicltl.240:21
sidelloj-10:17
19:18,20:1s,22:'24.
24:11.135:16'
13s:11.2(k4:z,2s2:s
siuesI
61-10:
21.
19:23,136:2,225:11.
2s1:12
signlll-19:22
signalpj-lzsrlz
signature!2I117;14,239:19
signedI:1j-s:l4
8:17,9::,24:16, .
104:14-117:9,
133:14,228:20,
235:15,235:16.246:7
signi
ficantlll111:3
simil
arll)-148:24
simplea -59:17.
60:12, 168:19, 207:7

sim pl/IsI-45:6,

169.19

situatedI1I-:w :1z
situationizI-8:201
.44:20
situationsI11221.22
sixfal-29:s,a1::$.
102:14,137:18,

205:24,230:11'
231:6,:132:22
sizeI2k-1- :7,
212:12
skill(1)-259:16
skyfll-243:14
slate(?I-s2:1,
107:10
sleevftlll-1s3:19
sloanm -3:3,22:1,
22:8.2:,:13.1159:21'
2ce:2z.212:19
sloaffsI1j-129:19
slow rq-181:16,
181219
small'6)-212:14,
215:12,217:20.
237:22,246:22,
248:24
smalleryl-50:16.
179:s,179:9,179:11
smartt:l-177:24
snuck11)-221:
s
Snydertjl-2:5
so-call
edI1I-121:
4
softwarepl-95:15
softwaretrq -27:12,
27:14,28:10, 50:24,
51:1, 66.
:8, 65:15,

Sornedayill-26:13 115210116:2

someonetsl-e8:2:.
127:201186:2,221:5,
221:10
someplace(11Jss::s
som etim er,l180:22

sometime;:1-

105:19
som etim es(1jgaaliq4
Som ew herel4)125:14,143:20t
155:20,161:16
son(21-26:2.48:11
soonlll-197:9
zz js,
sorry(12139:10.93:12.135:17.
171:2 175:22
.
,
209:12.225:23,
226:
3,241:14,255:8,
255:15
Sorrytzl-173:5.
190210
Sort!41-65:10,81:61
129:9,135:7
sourcel
D el-20:18,
2/.8.27:9,27:12,
27'24,28:
2.28:7,
28711j28:13,29:1,
29 15,29:19,29:22,
39.1.30:4,30:21,
30'23,32:4.32:19,
33.12,34:1,40:9,
4Z11'53:
5,54219.
* 722,54:23,55:3.

LIZA CHAPEN: CCR, RMR

11s:'I4,11s:'l9.
116:24.118:10,
119:2.119:8,119:14.
119:16'128:10'
12a:2o,128:24.
129.4,131:a.132:9,
132:15.132:19,

135:5.137:12,

13?:20.138:2.
138:20.139:1,
jzqrjz;,j:s ::.,,
139:19.140:1,140:4,
140:161140:22.
141:12,142212.
142:21.143:6,
143:16,146:s.
146:14,146:19,
147:9,147:13,
147:17,149:51149:7,
1s1
:2.1s1:a,1s2:1s.

152:20,152:22,
154:11,16s:20.
lzo
:l1.179:3,
1z9:10,179:1s,
179:17.183:1,
1s5:4,185:z,1:s:1o,
1:6:7 186:11,
,
186:14*18s:18'
186:21 187:17,
188:4,188:z,188::8,
188:23. 189:1,
189:11, 189:24.
19n:8 190:12,
,
190:15, 193:9,
193:13,195:1,195:5,
195:7,196:
5,196:12'
zoxrjs 2(s:11

2:
$J
C:j1

specialq - 104:1z,
11z:8 15:$::$ 15z:14,
2o8:1a
SpecIfica - 2()7:.j3.
24:$.2:$
iscallypl.
SPFC
21:x (s :z, 1g:$:j:,

2j():1).zz$:j1,

24():1z
specifieslsl-82:22
specujatjonpj.
42:5144:22 45:4
'
spell(3I-22:11,
tzs:8 2()3:z
' l)-176:1
spendl
spentp!-38:24,
43:20'44:10'103:s,
111:17 169:5 176:7,
'
'
176:18,227:16
spiedtsj-64:8
spoken p)-9:
3
123:19, 213:6 ,
springpp-1% :20
srctll-30:22
srcserveczq 30:24 32:1, z2:9,
32:23'33:7 33:19
'
34:4 '
34:18'
3,
, 35:
'
36:23 38:13 38:
21
'
,
39:20'K :7, 41
2
1
:,
'
43:7 62:1, 95:14,
' 1* :9
100:4
5,
, 104r
104:6'117:6j $$7:7,
119:1'135:
3, 14224,
143:5'143:8, 143:12,
149:7'150:2 169:
2
,
,
,

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 62 of 65

(.
u.;
169:3 169.4 18917

statusI2l-64:13,

189'9,189:12I190.1.

204:8

190:6 21118 211:9


216'7

statub,!11-127211
statubyryt61-16:13.

ss(1l-259:1

16:17 19:20,130.6

stacklsl-144:23.
155:10.155:15.
161:3.1s1:5
staffI2I-21:12,
171:10
standizI-21.10,
;3.17,126:1,140E10,
173:1;.203:16.204:8
Stand-alonefll140:10
sondard f
41-211:
4,
211:7,220:24$256:12
Standingpl-6.61
7I.7.12
standing t1I-7'3

131.2.134 21
stayp-18:13,38:7,
129:16
Steinerlzl-172:23
172:24
stenotypeI2I259:10,259:13
steppl-202:21I
226:14
step11sl-17:20.
172:11 173:14,
181.
6 181.
81182:101
182:12. 183:11183:3.
186:23 1D-lL1I
202:16 204:24

stands(
2I-131:23,

(.

story(4I-74.8,74.
9.
128:9 130:12
strangeI:I.41.1

203:15,225:J9

submittedI5118'18 75:15I82715,
253.41253:12

streamingI2l-883.

subprojectsI1l-

142:1
Streettzl-2:9, 227.8
stretchI11-243 8
strikeliil-113:1I
120.19 142:14
163:14 163:16, 165:3
strike!zI-35.20.
42'5, 44:22,143:22,
144:6,198:
221 201:9
strongI1I-15:5
strongerlsl-65:14
structurepzl-30:7,
30 8 30:10 30:16,
63 14 70.4 70:7
7122 111:4 118:21

211:10
stlbsetlzl-176:14,
177:21
substantial(21218:13.244.1-/'
substantially(31237:20,246:20,
248:22
substantiatell)256:5
subsystem I1130:12
subtasktll-182:6
Sucbitalzl-122'5,
188:16

181:11 162:3

109:17
suggestions11I181:5
Suitelzl-2:14,2:17
summeri:l-47:23
sunI9l-3:6, 101:14,
122:23. 174:13,
174:20.192719,
192:21, 199:61210:17
sun's I1)-105:16
Sundaytll-43:3
sundryI1I-237:7
superlatives(1113:1()
supervision(3l101:19 104:231
1Q5:1iy
suppod I2j-117:15,
176:22
supportedpl-

97:7.203:7,203:21.
203:22

stockholder(1)11:13
Stopyl-90:24.
92:19.92:
21
stop(21-Z5:13.
92:24
storageITI-33:16,
83:1.8:
$:6.83:15.
83:18,210:10

176:15
supposedEil-

storel6I-30:14,

sub-networks I1)7Q 9
subdivislonsI!170:
8
subfolder(3130:121 149.11.149:21
subfolders($I-40:8
subfuncti
on(
zl182:16

subjectpj-8:17,

20Q:6,2* :8
stations(21)-33:11,
33:14,M :5,34:6.
36:22,37:8,37:11,
37:16.38:18.4824,
51:4,71:9,72:
4,72:6,
72:23 73:7 95:9

83:3 83:9,149:7,
170:8, 210:13
stor-l1161-2726,
27:16, 30:9,30:16,
33:17 :4:14,48:15,
11B:10,119:
3,
142:13 142:
224

14:4 31:
22j 129:22,
169:14 172:7
172:13 2> :14
204:15
sublicensed p)26111
submiu ionIll-

100:1,143:1I188:
23.

142:23,143:8.

21:15

216:4

189:12,207:
5,221:18

submita - 15:3,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

23
245:17

switchesI1l-Z0'17
sworn(101-14.20
21.9,22.2,1T3:16,

174:14,202:21.
202:23.203.2.
226:15.226:18
Systernlt!l-58:41
60:21 84:8
system (221-30:Z1
37:1 37:15147:20,
48:16,49:3152:1,
65:13,85:18,113:16.
115:19,116:5,123:8,
148:15,1487161
210:7.211:7.211.8,
212:22,220:2.
220:111223:22
System s(1l-27715

suggested($J-

5:12
stuckpl-224:23
steps.21-148:5.
studiedI11-205:13
185:1
studioll)-147:1
stiltI2I-25:1.
stufflll-41:1
34:24 57:20,62:1,
stuff(271-27:16
89:8 91:21,92:12,
28 1s 38:15 40:2
95:21I110.22,
411 43.17 63.11
116:121116:19,
83 1is 84:21 88:9.
117:1.1177
6,118:16, 88 1()'1()1:1a'
150.71161r1I184:15, 104:18 j2z:12.
198:10,198:18.
'128 2 130:15
214:15,214:17,
I 13.
/:16 137:23,
220:8,;.20:11,235:2
142.23 145:13
Stillmantlol-2:15,
150'13 150:14
2:17 7:? 7:1517:16.
152.8 152:13
8:4,8'12,8:16.9.24
159.18 165:21
stipulation(
6I203:17
18:16I19:7,19:16.
sub(2)-70:9. 182:7
19:21I20:2,20:23
sub-algorithm (1Istock21)-238:20
182r7

122:19,193:16,

'

storing(1I-3216

153:15
start8I-83:22,
108:8,141:20,
236:22,250:4,252:7,
252:131255:20
staded1121-2651
M :20,40:4,40'71
41:22.43:14.44:19,
55:21.65:14s131:13,
235:
9.240:1I
starting(
2j-51:1.
217:19
startup(1I-210:20
Statel
l8l-1:5,6:
6,
6:7.7 3,7:5,7:8,7:9.
7:101IL17,7L1817:20,
7:23,7:2419:2,9:3.
206:6,259:1,259:5
state(9I-5:9,9:8,
45:8152:19,iB:14I
statementpl-15:
5,
55:15,15471
Stateslzl-129:15,
224:5
station111)-41:
6,
V :4,51:1417423,
97:12.114212,121:3,

7
(
'

Stepheflt
zj-2:
4

124217 131:2 145:3,


149:81 187;10,
199:19, 250:13
Suprem ell)..6:12
surprisedI1l-16:22
surveillance(3)45222, 45:23,j15:12
sustain (
4;-4278,
42:12 s2:t9 91:4
sustainedt
zj-52:91
189:22
sustained (11- 52:11
svatekpl-57:22,
76:9 85:9
sva
'teYsI:1-61:24
swearI1j- 21:23
switchp)-40:13,

T'
tableI1I-8:21
tables(2l-72:14.
1137
Lale (11-10:5
tamperI11-90:10
tangible(2I-154:16,
168:10
Tangiralqzl-51:22,
121:13
tapered(1)-66:1
tapesI5l-156:18I
157:91 157:15,
158:11' 166:7
tasklsl-182:9
tasksM -26:171
193:11
taught(1J-24:
3
team I4l- 101:14,
105:161 188:10
teamw ork (11193:18
tech($)-227:22
technicalIn 184:11I299:
21,
212:9, 212:20,
227:12, 245:7,251:12
techniquesI,11> :23
Tectmologieqtgl1:9 5:13,12:22,
63:15,74:15,78:17,
85:20 101:2 105:81
130:21.227:
2,230:9,
231:8.232216,
234:20, 239:4,240:8,
254:24 256:24
tecbnologi
esI
5)-

83:24,84:16124
16:14,

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 63 of 65

23722 240:21
technology(as)12:24.1414,14:6,
19:
4 26.10 56:24
57:15 58:11 58:19,
61:1e 61:2:. s1'21,
62:16 74:13.74.161
84'2,84.5,86:5,
86:17.86:23,87:8,
88:1 88:13,88:17.
:::23.89.2,89:4.
8925189:14.90:41
90:15,91:20.93.22,
94:
96 3.94:20,* :2,

60:2.1595.61:15.
62:8 62 15.63:5
65.
6189 11,90:13
terabyte(21-2l5 91
21513
terabytest4I-33'8,
33:9 33. 17 215:11
term Ez)-61:171
68'2 89'21 103:6
105.5 1()5:8 249:3
term inology(21155:21 ,177'6
terms(IpI-46)23,
66.17 100:21

96.24,99:5,99:7.
99:11,99:14.99:1Zx
99:21.100:
6 100:14,
103:10, 103:15.
103:24.104.16,

1:
$02
3 1)j:10,
199:
22 230.20
236.11
testtxl. 116:15.
182:16 18529, 196 24
testified t111- 22:3,
53:24 9;h:11 114:a
J16:17 169:21
,
174:15 2.03:3 2% 8,
208:23 2.
26219
testifiespl- 81:14,
$33:8
testifylq - 114:8,
12s:2o 159:
4 226:,3
testifybw (aI-169 91
1s9:11.173.23
testimony(z t
ssrjs :
$5:17, 35:
21'
'
36.8.45:
:5,54:18,
55:4 (5a::, 8j:17.
8a:ja
' rjj.5' 1 ,
4
,2cz:
12(;:1,
s 129:
0 I
.t32 11 1a-/':11
j(;1:12 1s2:1s
,
jss:d.:
l jd
.
jz:4 zjz:a,
:
ijr
sTjz zlzrjy
a14:24'219:1o'
gzzrz gsarjo
testingk3j-34:16.
.49
37
:1
3.
37
te
xt
pl
-27:9,57.7
5z:11 sz 12 139:5
1s2:2 165:1z 208:1z
n eaterzl- 58:4,
s4:8
them ets)- 225:5
tl
w mselves (
1Izj4:j7
y (rj- 175:14
theol
z38:1g
,
thoreirlpj- zsr):11
tlleyvvelaj- 189:2.
217:
7 218:2
ttgnkinq(11- 14:j6
tj,inksr1).242:1s

715.96:16.96:18.

'

1
05:7.105:12
10
5:154105:22,
105:24, 107:22.
130:14. $33:4,
133211,133:20,
163:11,164.10,
164:14:164:20:
16
4:24.167:11.
16B:15.168:16,
193:10,210:23.
2
12:14 220:21,
22 ,
8:9.228:20,

230:18,236:1,236:5.

238:16 240:19
.
'
242:24 243:2,243:8,
246:18, 246:
19.250.4
TK hnol
' ogKlTl59
:11.64:3.78 22,
79
:7.80:4,82:4,
84717-8575.86:1,
90:3.103:8.108:18.
109:12 109:18
174:22 1/5222,
.
175:23
tediogsI1j- 208:12

telecommunicati
on

'

slll- 175:13
t
elephonels)124
:12,224:17.
2
2s
17.22s:'!:,
225:
222
te
1Q1n (41-25:14
:16.151:6,242:11
tenderp)- 207:18
tendsI1-29:10
Tennettal- 75:12,
88:4,9973
TenW31- 58:13,
58:14,60:19
tens(1t
)1- 58:1s,

104:19 ,113:14

>
tbirL;
rl-21.17.
27 12 2/:14 32:7
115'14, 145:7,227.20
tbird-padyt4!27 12. 2T.14 32:7.
115:14
TlAirdlytlI-126:
22
thoughtsj1;242.16
thousand1101f$6:11.60:20,65:244
108:23 110'18
139:10.187:7.215:7,
231:18, 238:13

132:
24.159:4,
161:17. 162:15
164.
4,164:8,167.8,
166.
4 168:6.169:2
169:1/.184520
190:6.206:15,220:18
today'
sl2I-83:8,
202:
7
together(131-95:22,
139:13, 139:19,
140215,147:5,
147:24. 179:231
182'171197:
2,20972,
235:9,238:1,243:5

Tbousanqll-66:11

tomatoes111-92714

'
rhousandsl:)t5i5:12
thousands(
:2(
)154:24158:13,58:14,
58:18 59:22. 60.2,
60:6, 60:19161:7,
61:1s, 62:8 62:15,
6325,6a:12,65:z.
65223.89:11 90:14.
133.10 139:4
T'
hreepl-81:19,
145
:3 219:
15
tl:reepq -1G:16,
24.1,26:$ 3a:8,
41.j8 78.
:5'7E:13,
81:11'
, 82:
18I86:15,
10020.118:3.
123 j:,12z:2j,
169 5:jx rz,1x :ja,
17n 1a,jzyrgz,
jstls,js():t;Iz:!()2jj
238 12 238:19,
4
244 j6 244:j8,
,
245 1z,250:12,
zsjz,257:1j
three-dimeosional
(1j- 176:2
Tj
lreertkx ty(jj.
219:15
throughouta s8:1,116:
22 210:
22
yh
ursdaytfj-219:6
tiallj- a1:9
time-consumingI11
- g1
.
/:18
titlea .232:14,
246:19
today(sN -6.17,
7:1a 11:
4 13:14
, j::,1.
,
14:a4
? 18:
:
24
2,:4,:)!:!s ($!:.$:,

tonightlll-171:9
tookllq -26:17,
26:
20,45:7151:23
5227.54712,85:1,
106:17.106:21.
106:221120:3,125:3,
217:
21,227:101
243:11,259:9
toolI21-182:13,
196:
21
tools(4I-27:11,
27:15,32:
7.210:21
Toql)-153:10
top(4I-74:7, 153:9,
153:13,154:6
total(6I-:$z:1ad
9623. 104:7,108:221
1()9:j6, 1s7:
2
yotaylj-86:1a
totallypj-40:14,
245:
4
trace(2I-221:14.
2;
?j:
24
w cespl-221:16
trackz .191:
4,
194.21

89:6.89:10,90:2,
90:12, 103:18,
:06:12.1()z:4.
1:0:22,1aj:18,

LIZA CLW PEN, CCR; RMR

trackirs tjx .

j(j(j:
z4 jtjjr:j jtjjm
101:9 11:12
104:16
' 119
1:1
,:6:191192:
:: '
193:14, 199:
22
20021 21o:1s
tradi
tionall
y(1j24::6
trafficlll-71:17
trainjngIa)-184:2
227:12
'
trainsp)-141:5
transcripta 1a:!a asa:jz zj
s :ls

Transcriptll-1:19
tfanscriptionplzra j:
s
yransjatioqlj.

24
7022)

transmissiont1)206:20
trap t1h-46:17
treea -181:11
182:
2 182:6 I
tremendously(
1l245.9
Trepax l-3:14
5:17 14:19. 15:11
9
24:16 32:161 43:4,
44:6 45:231 47:2,
47:3 48:151 54:9,
54:11 78:2, 78:3,
78:10 78:11, 78:21,
78:24, 79:6.80:3,
82:16 97:11.104:14,
125:
22 125:23.
132:21, 133:141
133:21. 13476,134:7.
153:
21. 155:23.
156:5 156:9,160:13
,
169:14,161:10
1
164:
5,164:19,
166:13 169:9,
203715,226:13,
226:1T,226:24,
234:18,235:7,
233:11,239:9,242:21
246:3.248:1.248:13.

254:20
TO P/.
Ji4l-44:
6,
166:
22,2312 1125612
trialp)-131:18,
242:
9
tricks(1I-181:21
tried(6l-40:17b
s3:jo, 53:11,115:20,
165:
24, 173:10
triesll)-982
20
trillionpl-215:
9
trillionsI1I-22::1s
trkpa .:
$4:18 zoit;
39:
2,43:6.46:191 j

12
1:17
'r

rq11-117:15
troubletll-181:18
troubleshootpl88:10
y'
rouxeshootinal)
-73:
8
truckI,I-44:8
trueIj()
J-52:6,
101:21 195:6,
235:18'239
:16,
246:s,24s:
:$,:
2.
55:1,
256:23,259:13

Trust8l-1:13,1:14,

&z'
d
!,z:
$(tlg,zzcrzc,
2> :
22,239:s

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 64 of 65


.... !
. .
25
.
trustees(2j-1.14,
239.5
truth (
q -11:11,
42:11.52.21 160:5.
162:8,199.3
truthful(1I-118r13
T'ryl'l-249:17
tryI2zI-10 18.11:8,
22.19 23.6 23:11
51:2 81.6 93.4.
sa:pa 9avlz 9z:12.
97:17.98'6.116:1.
128:20 148:221

j'
.

162:13,1z4:2,
177:,: jisz:j

(.''

183:11 184:5. 187:9,


190:z'2o2ls. 24s:11
trying(191-zs:21.
41:14 47:9 53:14,
s3:1z 65:16.90:11.
95:51135:81136:2,
1sa:23 laz:ls.
1&1:7,185:23
196:17 196:18
199:s.217:1,21z:2:$
Tuesdaypl-1:21,
5:1,172:1
tunneltll-64'7
tum l
a -49:,j.
1s2:9
turnedrl-49:20,
stxs
'ruming'
ll-237:12
tweakingI1I-103:5
T'
wql.-117:2
twosz!-7:,4.
13715,16:15.17:8.

26:
22,32:14.33:5,

,'
f
1,
.

33214,34'5.37:8,
37:13.43:12.5T:15.
59:1, 59:7, 59:9.
60:17.62:7.71:18,
72:12 8,76J16.
77:1 .174:
00:3 107:15.
.
.
110:12.111:17.
111:19.112:5
I
112:15,113:
20'
114:15'114:19.
12'
i4,122:15,
134:
21B,137:10,
137:24,140:14,
145:6,156221,
156:22,15-/:23
1T6:1,180:13'.
180:18, 184:3,187:7,
199:11I 201:2Q.
220:1% 231:17
%
24320. 243:
24,
244:16.244:18
two-storyI11-74:8

two-way(11-71:18
two-yearp!-59::.
59:
9
typetlal-14.151
15:1. 19:16,66.17,
74.13t76:17.77:3.
117222,140210.
140:11.164.2,
190:22.192722,
193:9,210.
71210:12,
21n:1s.:a3:2a
typesidl-27:51
60:17.199:16, 209:22

24322
Ullrpl-176:21
unreasonabl
elzlunusual(31-43:5.
2239%223'23
up(9gl-9:181 11:13,
14'E1,14'17.22:191
23.1 23:11,23:14,
25:11,28:
21 28:23.
a9.6. 2s:1s.29:2a,
30:11 30:17,31723,
:
$2.
8133:12,33:16,

vacatio!zts)-3-/723,
11826 198:14,
201:22 201:24
vall
ey I1I-243:14
valuetjl-238:20
variablesfdl- 1s2:.
Aznrlrspxrm'. 9n.:9
W

wpicallyl:)-1a9:2
wpingll)-:.
za:2a

34:
23.3s:
2,3s:13.
37:
9.aa:1(),3::12.

x :s alrz' sr:s,
t
s:1'
z s1:1a (s :./

U
uop)-::
3:24
ultim atelyIsI- 1sr7.
36.16I 12s:j7$ 143:z.
21z:s
undetetetz)- 95:1q,
9'r)j9
undertln - 9:4,
1;?22z j4'2() j8:1a
a
31:103(55 1a'j(M :2'
'
1j7:1'
0 jj9r'
9
.
fa2:1(5 tzz:j/
'
,
1aa:11'149:2:$'
,
.
149:24 2:)1:z, 21::s,
z5::js'
Underp!- 24:15,
J01:19, 195:18
undergladuater1117s:6
underlyinga 242:5 255:6' 256:10
unde
'
rneathjz):$0:9.jcs lz,11!:11,
119:12. 119:2:,
149:11
understandablelli208:16

understood(11244:js
unitedta - 129:15,
2a4:5
universalIjj- 223:6
unjversity(
4jj.
/s:6I j.
/5:j(;I
j.
/5:18I1s:
21
,r
universl
:
tylsj175:12, 1;rsrzj,
y.
5r
zz, !y5:
z4,
1.
176:5,x tsrs
Unlessp)- 24:21,
23(;:g
unIesstt,
1-18:
8,
54:4,54:9, 128:2,

148:14 185:16
utterlyp!-3S:1B

1625.162:16

38'21, 39:1,39:9,
39'
22,40.1,40:151
41:15, 48:3.48:8.
5/.17.587
22, 59:12,
59.
20.59.21.60:9,
6021()163:17, 64:
4,
e.
4:9.- :11.64:23,
64.24,65:13,69:9,
Z0.18,70:19171:1
J'1.11,72:4,72:11.
Z2.14,72.18,73:221
84.1.84:11.84:20.
84:21185:12 85:
22
86:s. 117:22,129:23.
131.23,132:8,133:7.

133.9,133:17.1M 2
6,
jzs.2,$4:
$:4,:4ij::
zs

169 4.1?3:14.
173:241181:10,
181:1B.183:11'
f84'5.197:11,
19Z:12.198:4.200:
6,
200:8,200:9,2()n:10,
200211,200:181
210*8,211:6.228:131
232:13,243214
UPI4l-29:18134:15,
144:17.251:7
updated Ia - 158:23
,

255:3
LIPPOCI11-Z5:22
Upso irSl3l-75:5,
Z5:6,?5:Z
QPSOIO 1
21*?6:13.
155:24
Urgency!11-13:12
urgent(
21-11:
24,
12:9
useless(1I-213:8
userI
41-31!19,
49:22.49:23,50:3
Userp!-5Q:1,50:2,
50:18
users(:I- 149:16
uses(
a)-51:6,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

62215 74L12. 84:2.


85:23'86:22186c24,
87:3 87:7 87:12,

8Z:24188:3,88'121

88.22191:20,92:5.
927?,92.8,92:11.
92:14.92:20,93:22,
94120195:3.95:4.
95:5195:19,96:2,
96:1Zr96:241110:3,
110:7,11s:13.
116:181117:1,

J
Wr
'
i'
JJJIZ'
lI1l0'1, 1
28:19114015,140:7,
140:11,14t):12,

72:5 83:24 8z:9,


9s:6,j14:6,j46):6,
1s4:20 1s6:jz,
j(m:z4'2()@:ja,
2os:10 2oa:1s
215:1()p 2:
$727, 24g:8z
2sl:e 2ss:2:$
vaultlz!- 155:191
156:3 j61:15
vegaslaj- 7:8.7:12,
7:1:$
vejliclepj- 176:14
litirzz 17.
/:j jz8:
4'
'
'
186:19'
191r
2,
192:
1c
,

vejl
jclespj-17z.14,

jzgr:
s

venables(,)jg::g()
Venabl
espsl-3:3'
22:1. 22:
8.23:9,
23:19,62:12, 72:17,
79:22 83:13 M :6,
'
91:18'
17.108:17.
1 93:
1ss:1o,1($3:7 169:1.
,
.
169:s.172:7,22G.
7

Venkat
ll-94:8

141:21,1.$.
6:9,148:s,
148:10,148;19,

151:20,151;22,

1Z0:18.185;
24,
186:4,191:1,194:13,
194:21,206:5.2* :7,
206:17,206:20,237:5
videosp!-129:s
Wcginiatll-22:10
virtuali2I-64:4,
65:2
virtually(1j-256:4
Viftuet1I-238:5
vision($I- 17613
visitll)- 42:23

v
isits(1)-4321
visualil!

- 147:
1
voice(1I- 142:1
voice-overpl142:1
Voirlal- 3:11,212:6
voi
rp)- 212:2
j
vo ume ($j-23:13
volumez -1:19,
258:5
vprka -s4:
4,s4:
g
n ItI-1:11

venkatats!-7s:11
'

76:20,149:14,

149:15,149:1z

verbati
m I1j-259:
9

verifyI1)-134:7
versiona ..143:2
214
'
:9
version-by-version
j11-143:2
VetI$1-8:1
vice(s1-5:15 6:4
6:2j,zr6,174:'
24 '
Vicetll-180:8
Videotl)-87:2
videotrq-25:14,
25:19 26:10 45:
22,
'
45:24'
, 48:
16,s6:3,
56:24, 57215' 58:1'
58:11 58:19 61:21

W aitpl-79:1T,
89:11
waiti:)-80:11
wai
verI!J-224:24
walk(
2I-172:24
'
186:2
walked (1)-213:
20
walkingrzj-173:13
'
1gj:$
walla - 70:13,
114:22'223:1
WaI111I-227:8
wants(
m -136!17.
172:16'172)j7,
225:18
warel
w use(zq -

(775) 323-5492

Case 3:06-cv-00056-PMP-VPC Document 644-20 Filed 05/28/08 Page 65 of 65


...
.
;y(;
i

'-

33:15,34.5,34.6.

f.. '' .

41:6,44'6,44:8.
45:21,4732,48.2.
-J1:12,72:1,72:13,
72:24174'9.10Q'2,
109.7.110'2
w arrenp3l-3:14
5:17.47:9149:9,56:2,
66:19I-/3:2 82:16,
86:14I111:24,
112:23,115:16,
115:221143.20,
144:21,145:12I
155:231156.22,
157:6,165717,
165:22,226:17,
226:24
W arrerfs(3l-47:61
159:19,166.6
W ashoea -1:6
259:2,259:6
wastelll-203:13
watch(1I-64:17
waterpl-173:19
W aynelll-78:7
ways(21-170:7,
208215
web (
q -28:24,66:7,
71:4s150:13I150:17,

%' -

.
1

%.

who'veI:)-222:21

37:9'38.16'4123.

wholellq -45:20.

160:1.172:21.

173:20,174:1.174.
4,

W ebservera 26:19.64:10,64:13
W ednesdayll)19:2
week111)-8:7,8:18
22:21,34:11,41:121
42:14.42:15143:1I
52:31143:4,162:2
weekend(31-46:17,
50:11,50:18
weekly (1l-149:24
weeks(231-13:15,

85:11 1:15:3 125:9


139:18 '182:2
182:18,:!33:14,
233.23 :!41:2
wife(1)-167:15
willing(1I-238:3
windohv I3)-39:22.
197:1 16)725
W indowstlt!3-J:17 3'.r:18 59:22
s9:24 ($():13 60:21
72:4 1315:22 145:4
148:14
w indowspl-37:20,
75:22 1,)6:23
w intlAropll)-2:8
w ipe(4 -sl:5 sl(;
51:10 51:14
w ipedps!-sl:ls
s1:16 5I:17 92:1
107:22 .
1s:4
.2
w ipes11I-51:7
w ipingI1I-107:9
w ireIjI-84:20
w ise(12-59:8
w itness1401-19:24,
1j:
2 11s j7:19
j8:
8 217 21:9
21:10, 21:23,2222,
22:16 6.3:23 74:20
80:14 106:7 114:18
:25:18 l2G:1
131:14 151:1,
167:21 167:24
172:10 !73:16
173:18 174:14.
183:21 ?02:13
202:20 .202:23,
203:2, 2.:13:16,2Q4'7,
2> :8 204:9 206:1
218:17.222:15,

175'9,175:11,
181:201201210,
202:18.202:19,
202:22,211:24.
215:5,215:17.224:1,
224:31229:10,235'8
235:15.235:19.
236:18 251:2
W itnesses(2I17:14I21:19
W itnessespl-3:2
w onderingI11126:4
w ord (51-120:13,
141:
23,142:15,
177:2. 177:4
W ordl4l-138:221
139:10,139:141153:1
w ordexe(11-139:7
w ordsl4l-54:11,
66:15.169:16,208:14
w ork-in-progressI1l
-123:6
Workplace(1l98:18
Works(41-22:181
48:3,130:20.180:19
world(11-227:22
worldwidelll230:17
worriedill-81:4
worse(:1-218;2

95:21,K :11,99:19;
110:1,110:12.

2252181226:18
Wi
tnesst
- !-22:13.

208218
writtengrl-28:13,

111:17,111:191
112:151113:101
157:23,180:51180:61
189:131195:101
195:191197:8,
198:13,201:201
201:23,202:3,250:5
weightk
l
zl-201:15,

23:5 238 23:12


23:16,315:10I42:14;
45:12,45:15146:11,
55:17 67:13 70:2
70:7 7920 80:20
89:21 90:19 90:22
92:18 92:20 92:22,
93:2,115:8,114219,

170:11 183:21,
185:16 190;15.
208:13 208:
22
w rote(I-142:21,
185:21 1K :8,
186:12 186:15j
187:17 188:8 217:24

215:2

124:17,138:7,

15021

welcomeI,l-174:11
whatsoeverI
2184:19,126:21
whichevertll-

j63:2j
white(11-244:6

151:12,151:15,
151:18,152:18,
152:20,152:241
153:3 153:5 153:
9

worthI1j-91:6

w rite(111-69:8
139:5 169216
176:11.179:15,
182:13 186:18
186:22 191:13
208:8,208:18
w rites (1j-28:11
w riting (cl-183:181

Y
year1191-26:6 59:1
59:9,64.9.85:1,85:3.
85:12, 106:19,175:3,
1:5.5 175:19,176:4.
176:174177:221
187:7 198:7 218.2
251:3 252:23
years(331-17.8
24:1 25:14,26:22.
28:19 29:5 34712
47:10 56:8 57:15
62:7,75.10,76216:
77:1I133:23,137:10,
13?:17,137:13,
143:17,166:10,
176:1,176.7.205.241
207:171218.8.
218:121227:4,227:8.
237:4,241:7,244:19
251:31251:9
yelling(11-44:7
yes-or-no111100:22
yesterdayI21-629
7:8
Y0ngl21-123:14
188:20
Youngtsl-205:
6
yourself141-87:21.
117:22,154:23,195:3
Yum itll-188:16

Z
Zehang(q -326,
191:14.105:16,
122:23, 174:13,
174:20
zero(4)-92:1.92:31
94'17 116:10
zeroed (1I-2165

zeroe.
s(61-51:7.
147:8,20728,207:9.
207:10,208:1()
zoneI:I-186:3

X
xpa - 3z:17,3z:2(),
/.
2.4

1s:
$r1:
!'js4:3,1s4:($,
154:13,154:19,

LIZA CHAPEN, CCR, RMR

(775) 323-5492

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi