Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
!
Integration of renewable energy
into existing energy infrastructure
V.V.N.Kishore
Professor & Head, Dept. of Energy & Environment
TERI University, Delhi
(vvnk@teri.res.in)
!"#$%"$#&'()'*#&+&,"-.(,'
/-.(,-0&')(#'#&,&1-20&'&,"'
/&,&1-20&'&,"'*("&,.-0'5,'6,75-'
8,79$+&+'-,7'&%(,(:5%+'()'+(:&'#&,&1-20&'&,"'
+4+"&:+'
6,"&3#-.(,'()'#&,&1-20&'&,"'15";'&<5+.,3'&,"'
3#57+'-,7'";&',&&7')(#'7&%&,"#-05=&7'+4+"&:+'
!(:&'>-39+;5*'*#(3#-:+?'@-+&'()'";&'A-.(,-0'!(0-#'
B5++5(,'
@$##&,"'@(,%&#,+'()'8,"'C+&'
9 @05:-"&'%;-,3&'
9 8,"'+&%$#5"4'
9 8,"'-%%&++')(#'";&'*((#'
"#$%&'$(!$)!*#+,*-+!.+,!/*.01*!+(+,-2!/$(3&4.'$(!
5%$6*%!/*,6$(!/2/%+!*(7!*(18,$.$-+(0/!9&:+3!
DEFGGFGG'
;8+!<++%0(-!/&,#+=!*!%$(-!1+,4!,+/$,7!$)!/*,6$(!70$:07+!
DEFGGFGG'
>,0/+!$)!/,&7+!$0%!*(7!18+!?>"@!$0%!38$/A!
DEFGGFGG'
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Oct-95
Mar-97
Jul-98
Dec-99
Apr-01
Sep-02
Price $/BBL
DEFGGFGG'
Jan-04
May-05
Oct-06
Feb-08
B07+(0(-!-*.!0(!+(+,-2!/$(3&4.'$(!6+1C++(!,0/8!*(7!.$$,!
DEFGGFGG'
H#(*(+&7'+(0$.(,+')(#'&,"'+&%$#5"4'-,7'
%05:-"&'%;-,3&'5++$&+'
8,"'%(,+&#I-.(,'5,'-00'+&%"(#+'J5,7$+"#4K'
7(:&+.%K'*(1&#'&"%LM'
N7I-,%&7'"&%;,(0(35&+')(#'*(1&#'3&,&#-.(,K'
"#-,+*(#"-.(,'&"%L'J+$*	%#5.%-0'";&#:-0'
*(1&#K'6O@@K')$&0'%&00+K'&0&%"#5%';42#57'%-#+'
&"%LM'
P53;&#'+;-#&'()'%5I505-,',$%0&-#'&,"'
@-#2(,'%-*"$#&'
Q-+"&#'75R$+5(,'()'#&,&1-20&'&,"''
DEFGGFGG'
!!!!!!
!!!!D+3$&,/+!.$1+('*%!$)!!!!!!!!!! !!
,+(+C*6%+!+(+,-2!
DEFGGFGG'
S(#07'+(0-#'#-75-.(,':-*'
DEFGGFGG'
!(0-#'/-75-.(,'B-*'()'6,75-'
DEFGGFGG'
N'O6!'2-+&7'-++&++:&,"'-,7'#&I5&1'
()'*("&,.-0')(#'15,7')-#:+'5,'6,75-'
JT-:5'P(++-5,K'U5,-4'!5,;-'V'UU'A'W5+;(#&L'/&,&1-20&'8,"K'T$04'DXGXM'
P5+"(#4'
S5,7)-#:'H("&,.-0'N++&++&7'-"'\]KXXX'BS'5,'GEED'
GEYZ'
GEY]9GEEX'
GEE]'
(,1-#7+'
DXGX'
[ @(:*50-.(,'V'H$205%-.(,'()'15,7'+*&&7'
#&%(#7+')#(:'Z\Z'B&"'!"-.(,+'
[ B&-+$#&:&,"+'-"'DX':';&53;"'-"'-')&1'
+5"&+'
[ B&-+$#&:&,"+'24'*#5I-"&'+&%"(#'"-^&,'$*'
[ B&-+$#&:&,"+':(#&'";-,'_XX',(L':-+"+''
!,(L'
GM'
8-#05&#'N++$:*.(,+'
@;-,3&'5,'N++$:*.(,+'
`,04'-'*-#"'()'2-##&,'0-,7+'"('2&'$+&7' GGKXXX'BS'+&"'$*'5,''')(#&+"+K'(,'3#-=5,3'0-,7+K'
V'%$0.I-"&7'-,7'-3#5%$0"$#-0'0-,7+'
DM'
ZM''
\M''
]M'
_M''
SaO'()']]'9'D]X'^S'#-.,3'
P$2';&53;"'()'DX9'ZX':'
/("(#'c5-'()'DX'9ZX':'
B-<'#("(#'&d%5&,%4'()'-#($,7'\Xe'
6,75I57$-0'S5,7)-#:+'()']9GX'BS'
%-*-%5"4'
`,04'&<5+.,3'!$2'!"-.(,+'5,'#$#-0'
-#&-+'$+&7'"('&I-%$-"&'*(1&#'
_M'
gM'
YM'
EM'
GXM'
SaO'()'b'G]XX'9'DXXX'^S'2&5,3'5,+"-00&7'
P$2'P&53;"'()'YX'9'EX':'
/("(#'c5-'YX'9'EX':'
B-<'#("(#'&d%5&,%4'()'$*"(']Xe'
6,75I57$-0'15,7)-#:+'()'D]'BS'f'gXX'BS'
%-*-%5"4'
h-#3&',&1'-,7'7&75%-"&7'+$29+"-.(,+''2&5,3'
+&"'$*'
`,04'&<5+.,3'"#-,+:5++5(,'05,&+'"('2&' A&1'"#-,+:5++5(,'05,&+'-+'#&i$5#&7'-#&'-0+('
$+&7''
2&5,3'+&"'$*'
!4+"&:5%'%(,+"#-5,"'()'5"+'5,-2505"4'"(' a;5+'5+'2&5,3'i$&+.(,&7'
-00(1':(#&'";-,'GX9DXe'*&,&"#-.(,'
()'15,7''
c-"-'2-+&7'$+&7')#(:'Z\Z'B&"'
!"-.(,+'
h5:5"&7'&<*&,%&'15";'&<5+.,3'
15,7)-#:+'j'GXX'BS'
N#($,7'_ZX'15,7':(,5"(#5,3'+"-.(,+'*0$+'
A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'
/5%;'&<*&,%&'15";'"("-0'15,7)-#:'%-*-%5"4'b'
GGXXX'BS'
c-"-2-+&'
C+&'O6!'H0-k(#:'
!&"'$*'G'+i'^:'3#57')(#'";&'&,.#&'#&35(,'()'
5,"&#&+"'
h-,7'$+&'0-,7'%(I&#'7-"-'JN7I-,%&7'U'P53;'
/&+(0$.(,'/-75(:&"&#'f'NUP//'7-"-'+&"'$+&7M'
A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'-"'GX':L-L3L0'''
@S8a'7-"-''
N,'-I&#-3&'A(#:-05=&7'*(1&#'%$#I&'&<"#-%"&7'
)#(:':-l(#'15,7'"$#25,&+'m'G'BS'
N**#(-%;'
N''G'+i^:'3#57'5+'%#&-"&7'5,'O6!'(I&#'";&'#&35(,+'()'5,"&#&+"'
H(+5.(,+'()'@S8a':&-+$#&:&,"'*(5,"+'-#&'*0(n&7'
H(+5.(,+'()'A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'*(5,"+'-#&'*0(n&7'
C+5,3'hCh@'7-"-K'+$#)-%&'#($3;,&++'()'";&'3#57'&0&:&,"+'5+'%(:*$"&7L'
Q(#'&-%;'3#57'&0&:&,"'-00'@S8a'-,7'A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'*(5,"+'15";5,']X'^:'#-75$+'-#&'
%(,+57&#&7L'
N"'";&'@S8a'-,7'A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'*(5,"+'$+5,3'+$#)-%&'#($3;,&++'&+.:-"&7')#(:'hCh@'
7-"-2-+&K'15,7'+*&&7+'-#&'&<"#-*(0-"&7'"('G'^:';&53;"''-2(I&'";&'3#($,7L'N"'";5+';&53;"'5"'5+'
-++$:&7'";&#&'5+',('5,>$&,%&'()'+$#)-%&'#($3;,&++'(,'";&'15,7'+*&&7+L'
S5,7'+*&&7')(#'";&'3#57'&0&:&,"'5,'i$&+.(,'5+'%(:*$"&7'-+')(00(1+?'
N'1&53;"'()'G'5+'-++53,&7'"('A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'*(5,"+'
N';53;&#'1&53;"'()'D'5+'-++53,&7'"('@S8a'7-"-'*(5,"+'2&%-$+&'";&+&'-#&'-%"$-0'
:&-+$#&:&,"+L'
6,I&#+&'75+"-,%&'+i$-#&'#&0-.(,+;5*'5+'$+&7'"('%(:*$"&'15,7'+*&&7+'-"''";&''G^:'-2(I&'
";&'3#($,7'0&I&0''-"'";&'3#57'&0&:&,"'
hCh@'7I&7'+$#)-%&'#($3;,&++'-#&'$+&7'"('%(:*$"&'15,7'+*&&7+'-"'YX':'-2(I&'";&'
3#($,7'0&I&0'-"'";&'3#57'&0&:&,"L'
a;5+'-03(#5";:'5+'#$,')(#'-00'3#57'&0&:&,"+L'
S5,7'Q-#:'H("&,.-0'9'6,75-'''
A8aoHhQ'e'
N#&-'
BS'
G' X9]e'
Gg]]L]D'
]D__L]]XXg'
D' ]9GXe'
GDgGYDLZD'
ZYG]\_LE\YE'
Z' GX9G]e'
]\YDGYL\_'
G_\\_]]LZE\'
\' G]9DXe'
gD\EXDLXE'
DGg\gX_LDg]'
]' DX9D]e'
\Y\_EgLgD'
G\]\XEZLG\_'
_' D]9ZXe'
GZ_XgZLEZ'
\XYDDGLgEYE'
g' ZX9Z]e'
DYEEXLGZ'
Y_EgXLZEEYE'
Y' Z]9\Xe'
Z]gDL]]'
GXgGgL_]__G'
E' \X9\]e'
ZY_\ZL]]'
GG]EZXL_Z]D'
DXE\XZ_LDg'
\D]X_ZELEGD'
a("-0'N#&-'J\'"('EM'
S5,7'Q-#:'H("&,.-0''24'HhQ'''
OS'
\]XX'
\XXX'
Z]XX'
ZXXX'
D]XX'
DXXX'
G]XX'
GXXX'
]XX'
X'
DXLXe'
D]LXe'
mHhQ''JeM'
ZXLXe'
Z]LXe'
\XLXe'
\]LXe'
C+&'()'O6!'*0-k(#:'5,'-++&++5,3'15,7'#&+($#%&'
-,7'15,7'&,"'*("&,.-0'7&:(,+"#-"&7'
N++&++:&,"';-+'";#(1,'$*'I'+53,5p%-,"'
p3$#&+'";-"'%-,'&,-20&'*0-,,&#+'V'*(05%4'
:-^&#+'"('-77#&++'0(,39"&#:'&,"'+&%$#5"4'
5++$&+')(#'";&'%($,"#4'
'
Surplus**
1996-97
626.5
1998-99
653.4*
546.4
139.4
2004-05
741.0*
619.0*
157.9*
2010-11
840.6
701.2*
178.8*
2024-25
1127.3*
938.0*
239.2*
Notes:
*
Projections based on 2.12% annual growth (same as Ravindranaths two year values)
**
a("-0'25(#&+($#%&'*("&,.-0'
!(057'25(:-++'''?''D\X''Ba(8'
`#3-,5%'1-+"&+'?''''DX''Ba(8'
'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''999999999999999'
'''''''''''a("-0''''''''''D_X''Ba(8'
'
a("-0'@(::&#%5-0'
8,"')(#'6,75-'''''''?''ZYg'Ba(8'
! !53,5p%-,"'*("&,.-0')(#'25(:-++'
DEFGGFGG'
!"#$%&'()**+(,"-".%/0"'(1-23%(3'(
&4''3/0"5(
Q-%"(#+'-R&%.,3':-5,+"#&-:5,3'
"!"#$%"$#-0'%;-,3&+'5,'";&'&<5+.,3'%(::&#%5-0'&,"',&"1(#^+'"('
*#(:("&'5,%#&-+&7'*&,&"#-.(,'()'#&,&1-20&+'
"a&%;,(0(34F*#(7$%"'7&I&0(*:&,"'&R(#"+'
"8%(,(:5%'I5-2505"4'
"H(05%4'&,I5#(,:&,"F-7I(%-%4'
'
DEFGGFGG'
!(0-#'7(:&+.%'1-"&#';&-.,3'+4+"&:'
DEFGGFGG'
LAC (Rs/kWhth)
5.00
4.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
Without Subsidy
100% use
25% Subsidy
50% use
Electricity
25% use
DEFGGFGG'
DEFGGFGG'
!(0-#'75+;'+"&-:'3&,&#-.,3'+4+"&:'
h-#3&+"'5,'";&'1(#07L'
H#(7$%&+'Ga(,F;#'+"&-:')(#'
_;#+'-'7-4'
GGX'75+;&+'()'g:D-#&-'&-%;'
6,+"-00&7'-"'a5#$:-0-'a5#$*-.'
c&I-+";-,-:K'a5#$*-.K'NH''
DEFGGFGG'
LAC (Rs/kWhth )
7.0
6.0
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.0
LPG
Solar Cooker
Without Subsidy
DEFGGFGG'
Electricity
WithSubsidy
DEFGGFGG'
DEFGGFGG'
DEFGGFGG'
DEFGGFGG'
102
Electricity
77
Fuels
L.P.G
74
Diesel
45
35
32
17
20
40
60
80
1 00
1 20
DEFGGFGG'
DEFGGFGG'
29/11/11
Q-%"(#+'-R&%.,3':-5,+"#&-:5,3'
"!"#$%"$#-0'%;-,3&+'5,'";&'&<5+.,3'%(::&#%5-0'&,"',&"1(#^+'"('
*#(:("&'5,%#&-+&7'*&,&"#-.(,'()'#&,&1-20&+'
"a&%;,(0(34F*#(7$%"'7&I&0(*:&,"'&R(#"+'
"8%(,(:5%'I5-2505"4'
"H(05%4'&,I5#(,:&,"F-7I(%-%4'
'
DEFGGFGG'
Crude oil (imported)
Crude oil (Domestic
production)
Refineries
Fuel for
Chemicals etc.
Fuel for
transportation
Fuel for
heat
Refined fuel
(imported)
Fuel for
power
generation
Bio diesel
Solar
Users
Bio ethanol
Distribution
points
Users
Wood / pellet
Gasifier
Biogas
Bio CNG
Bio
CNG
DEFGGFGG'
Users
Renewable energy for fuel substitutions
Bio diesel
Wood/pellet
Gasifier
Irrigation
pumpsets
Captive
power
Stand alone
power
>,$E+/1+7!>,04*,2!/$44+,/0*%!"(+,-2!D+F&0,+4+(1!)$,!18+!GH18!I#+!2+*,!.%*('
JK0%%0$(!1$((+3!$)!$0%!+F&0#*%+(1L!'
DXGX9GGt''
DXG_9Ggr''
G_\LZD''
DX\LYX''
GD]L]'Jg_L\eM''
G_\LY'JYXL]eM''
]gLEE''
YgLDD''
GXLEE'JGEeM''
D\LY'JDYL\eM''
DgDLY_''
\X_LgY''
]\'JGELYeM''
EX'JDDLGeM''
h53,5"&''
EL]D''
G\LXX''
P47#(''
GXLZG''
G\LY]''
XL\Y'J\L_eM''
XL]D'JZL]eM''
A$%0&-#''
_LY_''
ELG\''
/&,&1-20&+''
XLE]''
GLDE''
;$1*%!"(+,-2!'
MHHNOG!'
PQONRP!'
;$1*%!S4.$,13!'
GTRNTP!'
HORNGH!'
QVNMQ!'
QPNTM!'
`50''
`)'1;5%;'5:*(#"+''
A-"$#-0'O-+'V'hAO''
`)'1;5%;'5:*(#"+''
@(-0''
`)'1;5%;'5:*(#"+''
`)'1;5%;'5:*(#"+''
U!$)!;$1*%!"(+,-2!'
!"#$%&'()"*+,+"-./'0.#.1'2'3-'#4$'.,,5678"-'#4.#'.--5./'0$6.-09:)";#4';"5/0'<$'=>?'7$)@$-#>'57#"'ABC=DCE>'F4$'G:5)$,'+-@/50$'5,$'"H'
"+/'.-0':.,'H$$0',#"@I'H")'H$)8/+J$)'.-0'"#4$)'-"-D$-$):K'5,.:$L''
TAA!B9'B5++5(,'`2l&%.I&+'
T-1-;-#0-0'A&;#$'A-.(,-0'!(0-#'B5++5(,';-+'2&&,'0-$,%;&7'$,7&#'
";&'A-.(,-0'N%.(,'H0-,'(,'@05:-"&'@;-,3&'JANH@@M'15";'";&'
(2l&%.I&?'
;$!+31*6%038!S(70*!*3!*!-%$6*%!%+*7+,!0(!3$%*,!+(+,-2=!62!
/,+*'(-!!.$%0/2!/$(70'$(3!)$,!013!70W&30$(!*/,$33!18+!/$&(1,2N!
K0330$(!*('/0.*1+3!*/80+#0(-!-,07!.*,012!62!HRHH!*(7!.*,012!
C0%%!/$*%!6*3+7!18+,4*%!.$C+,!62!HRQRN!
;$!*7$.1!*!QX.8*3+!*..,$*/8!),$4!HRGR!1$!HRHHN!!
Y04!$)!18+!40330$(!03!1$!)$/&3!$(!3+Z(-!&.!*(!+(*6%0(-!+(#0,$(4+(1!
)$,!3$%*,!1+/8($%$-2!6$18!*1!/+(1,*%0[+7!*(7!7+/+(1,*%0[+7!%+#+%N!
B5++5(,'a-#3&"+'
'
N'Z9'*;-+&'-**#(-%;';-+'2&&,')(#:$0-"&7''
Y..%0/*'$(!\+-4+(1!
>8*3+!X!S!
>8*3+XSS!
>8*3+X!SSS!
HRGRXGQ!
HRGQXGP!
HRGPXHH!
]'%012!-,07!.$C+,!
G=RRRXH=RRR!KB!
^RRRXGR=RRR!KB!
HR=RRR!KB!
?WX!-,07!Y..%0/*'$(3!
HRR!KB!
G=RRR!KB!
H=RRR!KB!
\$%*,!;8+,4*%!
@$%%+/1$,3!Y,+*!
P!40%%0$(!\F4!
GM!40%%0$(!\F4!
HR!40%%0$(!\F4!
K*(&)*/1&,0(-!_*3+!
XX!
XX!
^=RRRXM=RRR!KB!
\$%*,!`0-8'(-!
\231+43!
XX!
XX!
HR!40%%0$(!
\$%*,!D>?!
RNHMU!
XX!
QU!
!(:&':&"&(#(0(34'#&0-"&7'%;-00&,3&+')(#'
+$%%&++)$0'5:*0&:&,"-.(,'()'";&'+(0-#'
:5++5(,'
!($#%&?/&,-%'
"W+/1!$)!,*70*'$(!&(/+,1*0('+3!$(!+(+,-2!20+%7!$)!
3$%*,!3231+43!
\]e'()'";&'I-#5-,%&'5,'";&'%(,%&,"#-.,3'+(0-#'*(1&#'
*0-,"'%-,'2&'-n#52$"&7'"('$,%&#"-5,"4'5,'cA6'JP('
&"L-0L'!(0-#'8,"K'OMK'DXGGK'**'__E9_g]M'
Q(#'HU'*(1&#'*0-,"+K'";&'$,%&#"-5,"4'5,'&,"'45&07'
5+'-2($"'ZLEe')(#'%05:-"&'I-#5-2505"4'-,7']e')(#'+(0-#'
#-75-.(,'&+.:-"&L'J@-,-75-,'1&-";&#'7-"-K'
a;&I&,-#7'-,7'H&00-,7K'!(0-#'8,"'J5,'H#&++MM'
!!Y((&*%!#*,0*60%012!$)!3$%*,!,*70*'$(!
J@$&,1+32!a,!S38*(!>&,$801L!
c5R&#&,"'7-"-'2-+&+')(#'+(0-#'#-75-.(,'5,'6,75-'
Y((*!K*(0=!JSKa!7*1*L!JDZ'0(%-.(,+K'-%"$-0'0(,3'"&#:'
:&-+$#&:&,"+K'35I&+'+"-.+.%-0'I-#5-.(,M'
SKa!J\"@=!KbD"L!Jc(&+',("'+;(1'+"-,7-#7'7&I5-.(,'&"%LM!
bY\Y!J+-"&005"&'7-"-'2-+&7'(,'%0($7'%(I&#'&"%LM!
bD"`!
K";"?b?DK!J2-+&7'(,'7-504'(#':(,";04'7-"-K'75R$+&'-,7'
75#&%"'#-75-.(,'24':(7&05,3M!
Q;S"D!
\$%*,5S\!
S\cDY"!J$+&+'aBq'7-"-')#(:'6BcM!
B"a@?!
\$4+!$63+,#*'$(3!$(!7*1*!F&*%012!*(7!,+%0*60%012!
N,,-'B-,5u+'2((^'*#(2-204':(+"'-$";&,.%K'15";';($#04'7-"-'
(,'"("-0K'75R$+&'-,7'2&-:'#-75-.(,'2-+&7'(,'0(,3'"&#:'
:&-+$#&:&,"+L'a;&'2((^';-+',("'2&&,'$*7-"&7L'
a;&'7(%$:&,"'*#(7$%&7'24'!8@'J-I-50-20&'(,'";&5#'1&2'+5"&M'
%0-5:+'"('$*7-"&'";&'(#535,-0'2((^K'2$"'7(&+',("'*#(I57&'
+"-,7-#7'7&I5-.(,'&"%L'a;&#&'-#&'-0+('+(:&'-,(:-05&+'
`2"-5,5,3'7-"-')#(:'6Bc'5+'-'"&75($+K'.:&'%(,+$:5,3'-,7'
2$#&-$%#-.%'*#(%&++L'
B&-+$#&:&,"+'5,5.-"&7'5,'+&I&#-0',&1'+"-.(,+K'2$"'";&#&'-#&'
%(,%&#,+'-2($"'i$-05"4'()'7-"-K'%-052#-.(,'()'5,+"#$:&,"+'&"%L'
B-,4'4&-#+'2&)(#&'#&05-20&'0(,3'"&#:'7-"-'%-,'2&'(2"-5,&7L'
A('%-052#-.(,')-%505.&+'($"+57&'6Bc'
d*,0*'$(!$)!SDD!C018!3$%*,!,*70*'$(!&(/+,1*0(12!
J@($#"&+4'c#L'6+;-,''H$#(;5"M'
^RNR!
QMNR!
d*,0*'$(!0(!SDD!JUL!
QRNR!
HMNR!
HRNR!
GMNR!
GRNR!
MNR!
RNR!
R!
M!
GR!
GM!
HR!
d*,0*'$(!0(!\$%*,!D*70*'$(!JUL!!
HM!
QR!
@(,%0$+5(,+'
;8+,+!03!*!3&631*('*%!.$1+('*%!)$,!,+(+C*6%+!+(+,-2!
&'%0[*'$(!0(!S(70*N!\+#+,*%!+(7X&3+3!6*3+7!$(!,+(+C*6%+3!
*,+!+/$($40/*%%2!#0*6%+N!
!c$C+#+,=!0(1+-,*'$(!$)!,+(+C*6%+3!C018!+:03'(-!+(+,-2!
(+1C$,A3!03!*!/8*%%+(-0(-!1*3A!
;8+,+!38$&%7!6+!/$('(&+7!+W$,13!1$!+#$%#+!*!!31,$(-!.$%0/2!
+(#0,$(4+(1!!1$!0(/,+*3+!18+!.+(+1,*'$(!$)!,+(+C*6%+3!0(1$!
+:03'(-!+(+,-2!(+1C$,A3!*(7!)$,!4*0(31,+*40(-!,+(+C*6%+3!
C018!*(!+4.8*303!$(!.,$4$'(-!7+/+(1,*%0[+7!+(+,-2!
3$%&'$(3N!
;8+,+!*,+!3+#+,*%!*460'$&3!.,$-,*43!0(!.%*/+=!3&/8!*3!18+!
3$%*,!40330$(N!c$C+#+,=!/$(307+,*6%+!C$,A!(++73!1$!6+!7$(+!
)$,!31,+(-18+(0(-!4+1+$,$%$-0/*%!7*1*!6*3+3!*(7!,+7&/0(-!
&(/+,1*0(12N!
!
DEFGGFGG'
;8*(A!2$&!)$,!2$&,!*e+('$(f!