Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 29

!

!
Integration of renewable energy
into existing energy infrastructure
V.V.N.Kishore
Professor & Head, Dept. of Energy & Environment
TERI University, Delhi
(vvnk@teri.res.in)

!"#$%"$#&'()'*#&+&,"-.(,'
/-.(,-0&')(#'#&,&1-20&'&,&#34'
/&,&1-20&'&,&#34'*("&,.-0'5,'6,75-'
8,79$+&+'-,7'&%(,(:5%+'()'+(:&'#&,&1-20&'&,&#34'
+4+"&:+'
6,"&3#-.(,'()'#&,&1-20&'&,&#34'15";'&<5+.,3'&,&#34'
3#57+'-,7'";&',&&7')(#'7&%&,"#-05=&7'+4+"&:+'
!(:&'>-39+;5*'*#(3#-:+?'@-+&'()'";&'A-.(,-0'!(0-#'
B5++5(,'

@$##&,"'@(,%&#,+'()'8,&#34'C+&'
9 @05:-"&'%;-,3&'
9 8,&#34'+&%$#5"4'
9 8,&#34'-%%&++')(#'";&'*((#'

"#$%&'$(!$)!*#+,*-+!.+,!/*.01*!+(+,-2!/$(3&4.'$(!

5%$6*%!/*,6$(!/2/%+!*(7!*(18,$.$-+(0/!9&:+3!

DEFGGFGG'

;8+!<++%0(-!/&,#+=!*!%$(-!1+,4!,+/$,7!$)!/*,6$(!70$:07+!

DEFGGFGG'

>,0/+!$)!/,&7+!$0%!*(7!18+!?>"@!$0%!38$/A!

DEFGGFGG'

Is there an alternative for petrol?


80
70

y = 5E-06x 2 - 0.3934x + 7098.8


R2 = 0.8959

60

Oil Price ($)

50
40
30
20
10
0
Oct-95

Mar-97

Jul-98

Dec-99

Apr-01

Sep-02

Price $/BBL

DEFGGFGG'

Jan-04

May-05

Oct-06

Feb-08

B07+(0(-!-*.!0(!+(+,-2!/$(3&4.'$(!6+1C++(!,0/8!*(7!.$$,!

DEFGGFGG'

H#(*(+&7'+(0$.(,+')(#'&,&#34'+&%$#5"4'-,7'
%05:-"&'%;-,3&'5++$&+'
8,&#34'%(,+&#I-.(,'5,'-00'+&%"(#+'J5,7$+"#4K'
7(:&+.%K'*(1&#'&"%LM'
N7I-,%&7'"&%;,(0(35&+')(#'*(1&#'3&,&#-.(,K'
"#-,+*(#"-.(,'&"%L'J+$*&#9%#5.%-0'";&#:-0'
*(1&#K'6O@@K')$&0'%&00+K'&0&%"#5%';42#57'%-#+'
&"%LM'
P53;&#'+;-#&'()'%5I505-,',$%0&-#'&,&#34'
@-#2(,'%-*"$#&'
Q-+"&#'75R$+5(,'()'#&,&1-20&'&,&#34''
DEFGGFGG'

!!!!!!
!!!!D+3$&,/+!.$1+('*%!$)!!!!!!!!!! !!
,+(+C*6%+!+(+,-2!

DEFGGFGG'

S(#07'+(0-#'#-75-.(,':-*'

DEFGGFGG'

!(0-#'/-75-.(,'B-*'()'6,75-'

DEFGGFGG'

N'O6!'2-+&7'-++&++:&,"'-,7'#&I5&1'
()'*("&,.-0')(#'15,7')-#:+'5,'6,75-'
JT-:5'P(++-5,K'U5,-4'!5,;-'V'UU'A'W5+;(#&L'/&,&1-20&'8,&#34K'T$04'DXGXM'

P5+"(#4'
S5,7)-#:'H("&,.-0'N++&++&7'-"'\]KXXX'BS'5,'GEED'

GEYZ'

GEY]9GEEX'

GEE]'
(,1-#7+'

DXGX'

[ @(:*50-.(,'V'H$205%-.(,'()'15,7'+*&&7'
#&%(#7+')#(:'Z\Z'B&"'!"-.(,+'
[ B&-+$#&:&,"+'-"'DX':';&53;"'-"'-')&1'
+5"&+'
[ B&-+$#&:&,"+'24'*#5I-"&'+&%"(#'"-^&,'$*'
[ B&-+$#&:&,"+':(#&'";-,'_XX',(L':-+"+''

!,(L'
GM'

8-#05&#'N++$:*.(,+'
@;-,3&'5,'N++$:*.(,+'
`,04'-'*-#"'()'2-##&,'0-,7+'"('2&'$+&7' GGKXXX'BS'+&"'$*'5,''')(#&+"+K'(,'3#-=5,3'0-,7+K'
V'%$0.I-"&7'-,7'-3#5%$0"$#-0'0-,7+'

DM'
ZM''
\M''
]M'
_M''

SaO'()']]'9'D]X'^S'#-.,3'
P$2';&53;"'()'DX9'ZX':'
/("(#'c5-'()'DX'9ZX':'
B-<'#("(#'&d%5&,%4'()'-#($,7'\Xe'
6,75I57$-0'S5,7)-#:+'()']9GX'BS'
%-*-%5"4'
`,04'&<5+.,3'!$2'!"-.(,+'5,'#$#-0'
-#&-+'$+&7'"('&I-%$-"&'*(1&#'

_M'
gM'
YM'

EM'
GXM'

SaO'()'b'G]XX'9'DXXX'^S'2&5,3'5,+"-00&7'
P$2'P&53;"'()'YX'9'EX':'
/("(#'c5-'YX'9'EX':'
B-<'#("(#'&d%5&,%4'()'$*"(']Xe'
6,75I57$-0'15,7)-#:+'()'D]'BS'f'gXX'BS'
%-*-%5"4'
h-#3&',&1'-,7'7&75%-"&7'+$29+"-.(,+''2&5,3'
+&"'$*'

`,04'&<5+.,3'"#-,+:5++5(,'05,&+'"('2&' A&1'"#-,+:5++5(,'05,&+'-+'#&i$5#&7'-#&'-0+('
$+&7''
2&5,3'+&"'$*'
!4+"&:5%'%(,+"#-5,"'()'5"+'5,-2505"4'"(' a;5+'5+'2&5,3'i$&+.(,&7'
-00(1':(#&'";-,'GX9DXe'*&,&"#-.(,'
()'15,7''
c-"-'2-+&7'$+&7')#(:'Z\Z'B&"'
!"-.(,+'
h5:5"&7'&<*&#5&,%&'15";'&<5+.,3'
15,7)-#:+'j'GXX'BS'

N#($,7'_ZX'15,7':(,5"(#5,3'+"-.(,+'*0$+'
A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'
/5%;'&<*&#5&,%&'15";'"("-0'15,7)-#:'%-*-%5"4'b'
GGXXX'BS'

c-"-2-+&'
C+&'O6!'H0-k(#:'
!&"'$*'G'+i'^:'3#57')(#'";&'&,.#&'#&35(,'()'
5,"&#&+"'
h-,7'$+&'0-,7'%(I&#'7-"-'JN7I-,%&7'U&#4'P53;'
/&+(0$.(,'/-75(:&"&#'f'NUP//'7-"-'+&"'$+&7M'
A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'-"'GX':L-L3L0'''
@S8a'7-"-''
N,'-I&#-3&'A(#:-05=&7'*(1&#'%$#I&'&<"#-%"&7'
)#(:':-l(#'15,7'"$#25,&+'m'G'BS'

N**#(-%;'

N''G'+i^:'3#57'5+'%#&-"&7'5,'O6!'(I&#'";&'#&35(,+'()'5,"&#&+"'
H(+5.(,+'()'@S8a':&-+$#&:&,"'*(5,"+'-#&'*0(n&7'
H(+5.(,+'()'A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'*(5,"+'-#&'*0(n&7'
C+5,3'hCh@'7-"-K'+$#)-%&'#($3;,&++'()'";&'3#57'&0&:&,"+'5+'%(:*$"&7L'
Q(#'&-%;'3#57'&0&:&,"'-00'@S8a'-,7'A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'*(5,"+'15";5,']X'^:'#-75$+'-#&'
%(,+57&#&7L'
N"'";&'@S8a'-,7'A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'*(5,"+'$+5,3'+$#)-%&'#($3;,&++'&+.:-"&7')#(:'hCh@'
7-"-2-+&K'15,7'+*&&7+'-#&'&<"#-*(0-"&7'"('G'^:';&53;"''-2(I&'";&'3#($,7L'N"'";5+';&53;"'5"'5+'
-++$:&7'";&#&'5+',('5,>$&,%&'()'+$#)-%&'#($3;,&++'(,'";&'15,7'+*&&7+L'
S5,7'+*&&7')(#'";&'3#57'&0&:&,"'5,'i$&+.(,'5+'%(:*$"&7'-+')(00(1+?'

N'1&53;"'()'G'5+'-++53,&7'"('A@8HFA@N/'7-"-'*(5,"+'
N';53;&#'1&53;"'()'D'5+'-++53,&7'"('@S8a'7-"-'*(5,"+'2&%-$+&'";&+&'-#&'-%"$-0'
:&-+$#&:&,"+L'
6,I&#+&'75+"-,%&'+i$-#&'#&0-.(,+;5*'5+'$+&7'"('%(:*$"&'15,7'+*&&7+'-"''";&''G^:'-2(I&'
";&'3#($,7'0&I&0''-"'";&'3#57'&0&:&,"'
hCh@'7&#5I&7'+$#)-%&'#($3;,&++'-#&'$+&7'"('%(:*$"&'15,7'+*&&7+'-"'YX':'-2(I&'";&'
3#($,7'0&I&0'-"'";&'3#57'&0&:&,"L'
a;5+'-03(#5";:'5+'#$,')(#'-00'3#57'&0&:&,"+L'

S5,7'Q-#:'H("&,.-0'9'6,75-'''
A8aoHhQ'e'

N#&-'

BS'

G' X9]e'

Gg]]L]D'

]D__L]]XXg'

D' ]9GXe'

GDgGYDLZD'

ZYG]\_LE\YE'

Z' GX9G]e'

]\YDGYL\_'

G_\\_]]LZE\'

\' G]9DXe'

gD\EXDLXE'

DGg\gX_LDg]'

]' DX9D]e'

\Y\_EgLgD'

G\]\XEZLG\_'

_' D]9ZXe'

GZ_XgZLEZ'

\XYDDGLgEYE'

g' ZX9Z]e'

DYEEXLGZ'

Y_EgXLZEEYE'

Y' Z]9\Xe'

Z]gDL]]'

GXgGgL_]__G'

E' \X9\]e'

ZY_\ZL]]'

GG]EZXL_Z]D'

DXE\XZ_LDg'

\D]X_ZELEGD'

a("-0'N#&-'J\'"('EM'

S5,7'Q-#:'H("&,.-0''24'HhQ'''
OS'
\]XX'
\XXX'
Z]XX'
ZXXX'
D]XX'
DXXX'
G]XX'
GXXX'
]XX'
X'
DXLXe'

D]LXe'

mHhQ''JeM'

ZXLXe'

Z]LXe'

\XLXe'

\]LXe'

C+&'()'O6!'*0-k(#:'5,'-++&++5,3'15,7'#&+($#%&'
-,7'15,7'&,&#34'*("&,.-0'7&:(,+"#-"&7'
N++&++:&,"';-+'";#(1,'$*'I&#4'+53,5p%-,"'
p3$#&+'";-"'%-,'&,-20&'*0-,,&#+'V'*(05%4'
:-^&#+'"('-77#&++'0(,39"&#:'&,&#34'+&%$#5"4'
5++$&+')(#'";&'%($,"#4'
'

Biomass availability estimates


Year

Biomass estimates (million tonnes)


Ravindranath

Biomass atlas IISC


Production

Surplus**

1996-97

626.5

1998-99

653.4*

546.4

139.4

2004-05

741.0*

619.0*

157.9*

2010-11

840.6

701.2*

178.8*

2024-25

1127.3*

938.0*

239.2*

Notes:
*

Projections based on 2.12% annual growth (same as Ravindranaths two year values)

**

Surplus biomass fraction assumed constant as given in biomass atlas of IISc


DEFGGFGG'

Source: http://lab.cgpl.iisc.ernet.in/CropReport/Default.aspx accessed on 15 Sept 2007

Potential for Biogas in India


Biogas from cattle dung
''
a("-0'2(I5,&'*(*$0-.(,'JDXXZM'''?''DgD':5005(,'
''
q&-#04'7$,3'*#(7$%.(,'JrGD'^3F7-4F-,5:-0M's'GGEGLZ':5005(,'"(,+'
''
q&-#04'3-+'*#(7$%.(,'JrZX'05"F^3M'''?'Z]gZE':5005(,':Z'F-,,$:'
''
''Biogas from poultry litter
'''
a("-0'*($0"#4'*(*$0-.(,'JGEEgM'?'Z\g':5005(,'
''
q&-#04'7$,3'*#(7$%.(,'Jr'DXX'3F25#7M'?'D]':5005(,'"(,+'
''
q&-#04'3-+'*#(7$%.(,'Jr'GG_'0F^3M'?'DEZY':5005(,':ZF'-,,$:'
'
a("-0'3-+'*#(7$%.(,'?'GELZ\':"(&'JZYg':"(&''"("-0')(#'6,75-M'
''
'
DEFGGFGG'

a("-0'25(#&+($#%&'*("&,.-0'
!(057'25(:-++'''?''D\X''Ba(8'
`#3-,5%'1-+"&+'?''''DX''Ba(8'
'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''999999999999999'
'''''''''''a("-0''''''''''D_X''Ba(8'
'
a("-0'@(::&#%5-0'
8,&#34')(#'6,75-'''''''?''ZYg'Ba(8'
! !53,5p%-,"'*("&,.-0')(#'25(:-++'
DEFGGFGG'

!"#$%&'()**+(,"-".%/0"'(1-23%(3'(
&4''3/0"5(

Q-%"(#+'-R&%.,3':-5,+"#&-:5,3'
"!"#$%"$#-0'%;-,3&+'5,'";&'&<5+.,3'%(::&#%5-0'&,&#34',&"1(#^+'"('
*#(:("&'5,%#&-+&7'*&,&"#-.(,'()'#&,&1-20&+'
"a&%;,(0(34F*#(7$%"'7&I&0(*:&,"'&R(#"+'
"8%(,(:5%'I5-2505"4'
"H(05%4'&,I5#(,:&,"F-7I(%-%4'
'

DEFGGFGG'

!(0-#'7(:&+.%'1-"&#';&-.,3'+4+"&:'

DEFGGFGG'

Economics of Solar Water Heating


6.00

LAC (Rs/kWhth)

5.00
4.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
Without Subsidy
100% use

25% Subsidy
50% use

Electricity
25% use

DEFGGFGG'

Principle of working of Scheffler


Community Solar Cooker

DEFGGFGG'

!(0-#'75+;'+"&-:'3&,&#-.,3'+4+"&:'
h-#3&+"'5,'";&'1(#07L'
H#(7$%&+'Ga(,F;#'+"&-:')(#'
_;#+'-'7-4'
GGX'75+;&+'()'g:D-#&-'&-%;'
6,+"-00&7'-"'a5#$:-0-'a5#$*-.'
c&I-+";-,-:K'a5#$*-.K'NH''

DEFGGFGG'

Economics of solar cooking (Box type)


9.0
8.0

LAC (Rs/kWhth )

7.0
6.0
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.0
LPG

Solar Cooker
Without Subsidy

DEFGGFGG'

Electricity

WithSubsidy

Levelised Annual Cost (LAC)


of electricity from Solar PV
System Capacity = 1 kWp
Capital Cost = $ 9000
OMRC =
2.0 %
CRF (8%) =
0.102
CRF (5%) =
0.08
Annual Energy Generation = 1550 kWh
LAC (8 %) = 31.5 (Rs/kWhel) or 0.7 $/kWh
LAC (8 %) = 25.8 (Rs/kWhel) or 0.57 $/kWh
Rather expensive in comparison with grid
electricity. How about other end-uses?

DEFGGFGG'

DEFGGFGG'

Economics of Renewable Electric Vehicles

DEFGGFGG'

Turbo Wood-Gas Stove

DEFGGFGG'

Comparative energy cost


for different fuels
Comparitive Energy Cost (in Rs.) for 17,500 kcal/h useful
energy

102

Electricity
77

Fuels

L.P.G

74

Diesel
45

Lignite Brown coal


Hard Coal

35

Conv entional Ov en [wood]

32
17

Producer Gas [Wood]


0

20

40

60

80

1 00

1 20

Cost of Fu el [in Ru pees]

DEFGGFGG'

Biomass gasifier system for off-grid power


(10-20 kWe) capacity

DEFGGFGG'

Village electrification Gasifier at


Village Jemara, Chhattisgarh

29/11/11

Q-%"(#+'-R&%.,3':-5,+"#&-:5,3'
"!"#$%"$#-0'%;-,3&+'5,'";&'&<5+.,3'%(::&#%5-0'&,&#34',&"1(#^+'"('
*#(:("&'5,%#&-+&7'*&,&"#-.(,'()'#&,&1-20&+'
"a&%;,(0(34F*#(7$%"'7&I&0(*:&,"'&R(#"+'
"8%(,(:5%'I5-2505"4'
"H(05%4'&,I5#(,:&,"F-7I(%-%4'
'

DEFGGFGG'
Crude oil (imported)
Crude oil (Domestic
production)

Refineries
Fuel for
Chemicals etc.

Fuel for
transportation

Fuel for
heat

Refined fuel
(imported)
Fuel for
power
generation

Bio diesel

Solar

Users

Bio ethanol
Distribution
points

Users

Wood / pellet
Gasifier

Biogas
Bio CNG

Bio
CNG
DEFGGFGG'

Users
Renewable energy for fuel substitutions

Bio diesel

Wood/pellet
Gasifier

Irrigation
pumpsets

Captive
power

Stand alone
power

>,$E+/1+7!>,04*,2!/$44+,/0*%!"(+,-2!D+F&0,+4+(1!)$,!18+!GH18!I#+!2+*,!.%*('
JK0%%0$(!1$((+3!$)!$0%!+F&0#*%+(1L!'
DXGX9GGt''

DXG_9Ggr''

G_\LZD''

DX\LYX''

GD]L]'Jg_L\eM''

G_\LY'JYXL]eM''

]gLEE''

YgLDD''

GXLEE'JGEeM''

D\LY'JDYL\eM''

DgDLY_''

\X_LgY''

]\'JGELYeM''

EX'JDDLGeM''

h53,5"&''

EL]D''

G\LXX''

P47#(''

GXLZG''

G\LY]''

XL\Y'J\L_eM''

XL]D'JZL]eM''

A$%0&-#''

_LY_''

ELG\''

/&,&1-20&+''

XLE]''

GLDE''

;$1*%!"(+,-2!'

MHHNOG!'

PQONRP!'

;$1*%!S4.$,13!'

GTRNTP!'

HORNGH!'

QVNMQ!'

QPNTM!'

`50''
`)'1;5%;'5:*(#"+''
A-"$#-0'O-+'V'hAO''
`)'1;5%;'5:*(#"+''
@(-0''
`)'1;5%;'5:*(#"+''

`)'1;5%;'5:*(#"+''

U!$)!;$1*%!"(+,-2!'

!"#$%&'()"*+,+"-./'0.#.1'2'3-'#4$'.,,5678"-'#4.#'.--5./'0$6.-09:)";#4';"5/0'<$'=>?'7$)@$-#>'57#"'ABC=DCE>'F4$'G:5)$,'+-@/50$'5,$'"H'
"+/'.-0':.,'H$$0',#"@I'H")'H$)8/+J$)'.-0'"#4$)'-"-D$-$):K'5,.:$L''

TAA!B9'B5++5(,'`2l&%.I&+'
T-1-;-#0-0'A&;#$'A-.(,-0'!(0-#'B5++5(,';-+'2&&,'0-$,%;&7'$,7&#'
";&'A-.(,-0'N%.(,'H0-,'(,'@05:-"&'@;-,3&'JANH@@M'15";'";&'
(2l&%.I&?'
;$!+31*6%038!S(70*!*3!*!-%$6*%!%+*7+,!0(!3$%*,!+(+,-2=!62!
/,+*'(-!!.$%0/2!/$(70'$(3!)$,!013!70W&30$(!*/,$33!18+!/$&(1,2N!
K0330$(!*('/0.*1+3!*/80+#0(-!-,07!.*,012!62!HRHH!*(7!.*,012!
C0%%!/$*%!6*3+7!18+,4*%!.$C+,!62!HRQRN!
;$!*7$.1!*!QX.8*3+!*..,$*/8!),$4!HRGR!1$!HRHHN!!
Y04!$)!18+!40330$(!03!1$!)$/&3!$(!3+Z(-!&.!*(!+(*6%0(-!+(#0,$(4+(1!
)$,!3$%*,!1+/8($%$-2!6$18!*1!/+(1,*%0[+7!*(7!7+/+(1,*%0[+7!%+#+%N!

B5++5(,'a-#3&"+'
'

N'Z9'*;-+&'-**#(-%;';-+'2&&,')(#:$0-"&7''

Y..%0/*'$(!\+-4+(1!

>8*3+!X!S!

>8*3+XSS!

>8*3+X!SSS!

HRGRXGQ!

HRGQXGP!

HRGPXHH!

]'%012!-,07!.$C+,!

G=RRRXH=RRR!KB!

^RRRXGR=RRR!KB!

HR=RRR!KB!

?WX!-,07!Y..%0/*'$(3!

HRR!KB!

G=RRR!KB!

H=RRR!KB!

\$%*,!;8+,4*%!
@$%%+/1$,3!Y,+*!

P!40%%0$(!\F4!

GM!40%%0$(!\F4!

HR!40%%0$(!\F4!

K*(&)*/1&,0(-!_*3+!

XX!

XX!

^=RRRXM=RRR!KB!

\$%*,!`0-8'(-!
\231+43!

XX!

XX!

HR!40%%0$(!

\$%*,!D>?!

RNHMU!

XX!

QU!

!(:&':&"&(#(0(34'#&0-"&7'%;-00&,3&+')(#'
+$%%&++)$0'5:*0&:&,"-.(,'()'";&'+(0-#'
:5++5(,'

!($#%&?/&,-%'

"W+/1!$)!,*70*'$(!&(/+,1*0('+3!$(!+(+,-2!20+%7!$)!
3$%*,!3231+43!
\]e'()'";&'I-#5-,%&'5,'";&'%(,%&,"#-.,3'+(0-#'*(1&#'
*0-,"'%-,'2&'-n#52$"&7'"('$,%&#"-5,"4'5,'cA6'JP('
&"L-0L'!(0-#'8,&#34K'OMK'DXGGK'**'__E9_g]M'
Q(#'HU'*(1&#'*0-,"+K'";&'$,%&#"-5,"4'5,'&,&#34'45&07'
5+'-2($"'ZLEe')(#'%05:-"&'I-#5-2505"4'-,7']e')(#'+(0-#'
#-75-.(,'&+.:-"&L'J@-,-75-,'1&-";&#'7-"-K'
a;&I&,-#7'-,7'H&00-,7K'!(0-#'8,&#34'J5,'H#&++MM'

!!Y((&*%!#*,0*60%012!$)!3$%*,!,*70*'$(!
J@$&,1+32!a,!S38*(!>&,$801L!

c5R&#&,"'7-"-'2-+&+')(#'+(0-#'#-75-.(,'5,'6,75-'
Y((*!K*(0=!JSKa!7*1*L!JDZ'0(%-.(,+K'-%"$-0'0(,3'"&#:'
:&-+$#&:&,"+K'35I&+'+"-.+.%-0'I-#5-.(,M'
SKa!J\"@=!KbD"L!Jc(&+',("'+;(1'+"-,7-#7'7&I5-.(,'&"%LM!
bY\Y!J+-"&005"&'7-"-'2-+&7'(,'%0($7'%(I&#'&"%LM!
bD"`!
K";"?b?DK!J2-+&7'(,'7-504'(#':(,";04'7-"-K'75R$+&'-,7'
75#&%"'#-75-.(,'24':(7&05,3M!
Q;S"D!
\$%*,5S\!
S\cDY"!J$+&+'aBq'7-"-')#(:'6BcM!
B"a@?!

\$4+!$63+,#*'$(3!$(!7*1*!F&*%012!*(7!,+%0*60%012!
N,,-'B-,5u+'2((^'*#(2-204':(+"'-$";&,.%K'15";';($#04'7-"-'
(,'"("-0K'75R$+&'-,7'2&-:'#-75-.(,'2-+&7'(,'0(,3'"&#:'
:&-+$#&:&,"+L'a;&'2((^';-+',("'2&&,'$*7-"&7L'
a;&'7(%$:&,"'*#(7$%&7'24'!8@'J-I-50-20&'(,'";&5#'1&2'+5"&M'
%0-5:+'"('$*7-"&'";&'(#535,-0'2((^K'2$"'7(&+',("'*#(I57&'
+"-,7-#7'7&I5-.(,'&"%L'a;&#&'-#&'-0+('+(:&'-,(:-05&+'
`2"-5,5,3'7-"-')#(:'6Bc'5+'-'"&75($+K'.:&'%(,+$:5,3'-,7'
2$#&-$%#-.%'*#(%&++L'
B&-+$#&:&,"+'5,5.-"&7'5,'+&I&#-0',&1'+"-.(,+K'2$"'";&#&'-#&'
%(,%&#,+'-2($"'i$-05"4'()'7-"-K'%-052#-.(,'()'5,+"#$:&,"+'&"%L'
B-,4'4&-#+'2&)(#&'#&05-20&'0(,3'"&#:'7-"-'%-,'2&'(2"-5,&7L'
A('%-052#-.(,')-%505.&+'($"+57&'6Bc'

d*,0*'$(!$)!SDD!C018!3$%*,!,*70*'$(!&(/+,1*0(12!
J@($#"&+4'c#L'6+;-,''H$#(;5"M'

^RNR!

QMNR!

d*,0*'$(!0(!SDD!JUL!

QRNR!

HMNR!

HRNR!

GMNR!

GRNR!

MNR!

RNR!
R!

M!

GR!

GM!

HR!

d*,0*'$(!0(!\$%*,!D*70*'$(!JUL!!

HM!

QR!

@(,%0$+5(,+'
;8+,+!03!*!3&631*('*%!.$1+('*%!)$,!,+(+C*6%+!+(+,-2!
&'%0[*'$(!0(!S(70*N!\+#+,*%!+(7X&3+3!6*3+7!$(!,+(+C*6%+3!
*,+!+/$($40/*%%2!#0*6%+N!
!c$C+#+,=!0(1+-,*'$(!$)!,+(+C*6%+3!C018!+:03'(-!+(+,-2!
(+1C$,A3!03!*!/8*%%+(-0(-!1*3A!
;8+,+!38$&%7!6+!/$('(&+7!+W$,13!1$!+#$%#+!*!!31,$(-!.$%0/2!
+(#0,$(4+(1!!1$!0(/,+*3+!18+!.+(+1,*'$(!$)!,+(+C*6%+3!0(1$!
+:03'(-!+(+,-2!(+1C$,A3!*(7!)$,!4*0(31,+*40(-!,+(+C*6%+3!
C018!*(!+4.8*303!$(!.,$4$'(-!7+/+(1,*%0[+7!+(+,-2!
3$%&'$(3N!
;8+,+!*,+!3+#+,*%!*460'$&3!.,$-,*43!0(!.%*/+=!3&/8!*3!18+!
3$%*,!40330$(N!c$C+#+,=!/$(307+,*6%+!C$,A!(++73!1$!6+!7$(+!
)$,!31,+(-18+(0(-!4+1+$,$%$-0/*%!7*1*!6*3+3!*(7!,+7&/0(-!
&(/+,1*0(12N!
!
DEFGGFGG'

;8*(A!2$&!)$,!2$&,!*e+('$(f!

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi