Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Meta-Analysis
Lei Liu1,3,4, Xiaomei Wu2, Limin Liu1,4, Jin Geng1,3,4, Zhe Yuan1, Zhongyan Shan3, Lei Chen1,3,4*
1 Department of Ophthalmology, The First Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang, Peoples Republic of China, 2 Department of Clinical Epidemiology and
Evidence Medicine, The First Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang, Peoples Republic of China, 3 Key Laboratory of Endocrine diseases in Liaoning Province, The
First Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang, Peoples Republic of China, 4 Liaoning Diabetic Eye Center, The First Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang,
Peoples Republic of China
Abstract
Background: Although diabetic retinopathy (DR) is considered to be a major cause of blindness, this is the first metaanalysis to investigate the pooled prevalence of DR in mainland China.
Methodology/Principal Findings: We conducted a search of all English reports on population-based studies for the
prevalence of DR using Medline, EMbase, Web of Science, Google (scholar), and all Chinese reports were identified manually
and on-line using CBMDisc, Chongqing VIP database, and CNKI database. A meta-analysis was carried out. The fixed effects
model or random effects model was used as a statistical test for homogeneity. Nineteen studies were included. The
prevalence of DR, non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy (NPDR) and proliferative diabetic retinopathy (PDR) in the pooled
general population was 1.3% (95%CI: 0.5%3.2%), 1.1% (95%CI: 0.6%2.1%), and 0.1% (95%CI: 0.1%0.3%), respectively, but
was 23% (95%CI: 17.8%29.2%), 19.1% (95%CI: 13.6%26.3%), and 2.8% (95%CI: 1.9%4.2%) in the diabetic group. The
prevalence rate of DR in the pooled rural population was higher than that in the urban population, 1.6% (95%CI: 1.3%2%),
and the diabetic population, 29.1% (95%CI: 20.9%38.9%). The prevalence of DR was higher in the Northern region
compared with the Southern region.
Conclusions/Significance: The prevalence of DR in mainland China appeared a little high, and varied according to area.
NPDR was more common. This study highlights the necessity for DR screening in the rural areas of China.
Citation: Liu L, Wu X, Liu L, Geng J, Yuan Z, et al. (2012) Prevalence of Diabetic Retinopathy in Mainland China: A Meta-Analysis. PLoS ONE 7(9): e45264.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045264
Editor: Demetrios Vavvas, Massachusetts Eye & Ear Infirmary, Harvard Medical School, United States of America
Received June 13, 2012; Accepted August 14, 2012; Published September 20, 2012
Copyright: 2012 Liu et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work has been supported by three grants: (1) Liaoning Science and Technology Project, (Project Number: 2009225005); (2) Liaoning Department of
Health Medical Peak of Construction Project, (Project Number: 2010016); (3) The Important Platform of Science and Technology Foundation for Universities,
Department of Education, Liaoning Province government, China, (Project Number: 2011195). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis,
decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
* E-mail: carol1422@163.com
Introduction
Diabetic retinopathy (DR) is one of the foremost causes of
blindness in the working age population [1]. As the prevalence of
diabetes mellitus (DM) increases globally and patients live longer,
the development of DR as a microvascular complication of DM
also rises. DR is a priority disease in the VISION 2020 initiative
for the global elimination of avoidable blindness. The World
Health Organization (WHO) has recommended its member
countries integrate a program approach for DR within their
prevention of blindness programs. In contrast to studies in Western
countries, age-related macular degeneration (AMD) and DR
appear to play a minor role as a cause of visual impairment in
elderly Chinese [2].
In mainland China, many previous reports have shown the
prevalence of DR in population-based studies, however, the
prevalence of DR varies in different samples, and the data remain
limited and localized. To date, there is no national, populationbased study of the prevalence of DR in mainland China, and it
would seem that a national, pooled estimate based on the
Methods
Search Strategy
We searched all English reports on population-based studies for
the prevalence of DR using Medline, EMbase, Web of Science,
Google (scholar), and all Chinese reports were searched manually
and on-line using CBMDisc (Chinese Biochemical Literature on
Disc), Chongqing VIP database, and CNKI (China National
Knowledge Infrastructure) database. The search keywords were:
diabetic retinopathy, prevalence, and Chinese population. A total
of 196 reports published in the period from 1991 to 2012 were
identified.
using a standardized form, designed in advance. The characteristics of the population-based studies included in this meta-analysis
on the pooled prevalence of DR in mainland China are shown in
Table 1.
Data Analysis
Meta-analyst statistical software offered by http://tuftscaes.org/
meta_analyst/was used to analyze the data. The pooled
prevalence was used to estimate the prevalence of DR in China
mainland. All meta-analyses were evaluated for heterogeneity
using the Chi-square based Q test and I2 test [3]. I2 estimated the
percentage of the total variance in all of the data under
consideration that was related to heterogeneity. The authors
suggested using 25%, 50%, and 75% to indicate low, moderate, or
high level heterogeneity. If there was moderate or high level
heterogeneity, a random-effects meta-analysis was performed by
the DerSimonian and Laird method, unless using fixed-effects
Data Extraction
The literature was searched independently by two researchers
(Lei Liu and Jin Geng). Data were extracted from each article
Figure 1. Flow chart demonstrating those studies that were processed for inclusion in the meta-analysis.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045264.g001
Beijing
Shanghai
1998
Shouzhi He [18]
Shouling Li [19]
Beijing
2009
2010
Huizhou
Handan
2010
2010
2010
2010
2010
2011
2012
Xiuqun Ye [31]
2011
Bingzhen Li [33]
Jie Xu [35]
Northern
Southern
Northern
Southern
Northern
Northern
Northern
Urban
Urban
Urban
Rural
Urban
Rural
Urban
Rural
Rural
Rural
Rural
Urban
Rural+Urban
Urban
Urban
Rural+Urban
Rural+Urban
Urban
Urban
NMFP for 45
digree field
NMFP for 45
digree field
MDOC+fundus
photography+FFA
MDOC
MFP for 45
digree field
MDOC
NMFP for 45
digree field
MFP for 50
digree field
MDOC
NMFP for 45
digree field
MDOC
MDOC
MDOC+FFA
MDOC+fundus
photography
Examination
methodolo
Rural/Urban gies for DR
ETDRS
Diabetic Retinopathy
Disease Severity Scale
ETDRS
WHO
OGTT
WHO
self-reported
history and FPG
WHO
ETDRS
ETDRS
WHO
WHO
NA
WHO
WHO
WHO
WHO
Self-reported
history
WHO
NA
WHO
WHO
WHO
WHO
Diagnosis
standard for DM
Staging of DR for
Chinese*
Staging of DR for
Chinese*
Staging of DR for
Chinese*
Proposed international
severity scales**
ETDRS
ETDRS
ETDRS
NA
Staging of DR for
Chinese*
NA
Staging of DR for
Chinese*
Staging of DR for
Chinese*
NA
Diagnosis standard
for DR
2080
.15
$40
.30
.20
.15
3580
.18
.50
.35
.25
1482
.40
.18
4487
$25
.15
.30
2574
Age
(year)
4391
10723
43762
1483
11618
29938
110660
Sample
(n)
1293
16330
5734
6830
11723
19962007
NA
3259
20062007
20032005
Jan-Dec 2009
May-Jul 2008
20072008
2001
20032005
Jul 2003Apr
2004
19941995
19941995
NA
1986
Survey day
87
94
56
27
181
17
285
38
146
37
67
90
129
total
75
130
165
2007 496
799
445
368
1046 101
2632 986
381
554
NA
114
689
137
434
356
535
326
216
534
423
DM
(n)
329
74
124
145
71
NA
69
76
49
25
107
17
273
NA
123
30
NA
88
119
NPDR
DR (n)
67
20
30
NA
18
18
74
NA
12
NA
23
NA
10
PDR
Abbreviation: ETDRS, Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study; DR, diabetic retinopathy; NPDR, non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy; PDR, proliferative diabetic retinopathy. DM, diabetes mellitus; MDOC, mydriasis direct
ophthalmoscope check; FFA, fundus fluorescein angiography; NMFP, non-mydriatic fundus photography; MFP, mydriatic fundus photography. NA, not available.
*Staging of DR by Chinese academy of ocular fundus disease.
**Proposed international clinical diabetic retinopathy and diabetic macular edema disease severity scales.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045264.t001
Beijing
Shanghai
Changzhi
Shijiazhuang
Shunyi
Shuangcheng Northern
2010
Northern
Northern
Northern
Northern
Southern
Southern
Northern
Southern
Northern
Northern
Region
Beijing
Shandong
Shenyang
Foshan
2009
Beijing
2006
Anhui
1997
Yinghua HU [17]
Daqing
1991
First Author
Area
Publication
year
Table 1. Characteristics of population-based studies on the prevalence of diabetic retinopathy (DR) in mainland China.
Results
The prevalence of DR, NPDR and PDR in the pooled general
population was 1.3% (95%CI: 0.5%3.2%), 1.1% (95%CI: 0.6%
2.1%), and 0.1% (95%CI: 0.1%0.3%), respectively, but was 23%
(95%CI: 17.8%29.2%), 19.1% (95%CI: 13.6%26.3%), and
2.8% (95%CI: 1.9%4.2%) in the diabetic group. The pooled
prevalence rates of DR were higher in the rural population, 1.6%
(95%CI: 1.3%2%), compared with the urban population, 0.8%
(95%CI: 0.3%1.7%), (x2 = 771.35, p,0.001), and higher in the
rural diabetic group, 29.1% (95%CI: 20.9%38.9%) compared
with the urban diabetic group, 18.1% (95%CI: 13.6%23.7%)
Discussion
To our knowledge, this is the first meta-analysis of DR
prevalence in mainland China. In this meta-analysis, a total of
Figure 2. A forest plot displaying the pooled prevalence of diabetic retinopathy (DR) in the population of mainland China.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045264.g002
Figure 3. A forest plot displaying the pooled prevalence of diabetic retinopathy (DR) in the diabetic population of mainland China.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045264.g003
Figure 4. A forest plot displaying the pooled prevalence rates of NPDR and PDR (A, NPDR in general mainland China population; B,
NPDR in diabetic population; C, PDR in general mainland China population; D, PDR in diabetic population).
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045264.g004
Table 2. The pooled prevalence of diabetic retinopathy (DR) in mainland China with comparisons between different regions
(North vs. South and rural vs. urban).
Region
No.
of
articles Case/Total
Pooled
Estimate (%)
95%CI(%)
Heterogeneity
I2 (%)
Q value p value
Urban
1309/219084
0.8
0.31.7
49.80
0.99
,0.001
Rural
1509/92740
1.6
1.32
48.00
0.98
,0.001
Urban
10
1309/6663
18.1
13.623.7
49.00
0.99
,0.001
Rural
1453/4357
29.1
20.938.9
49.20
0.99
,0.001
General population
Northern
13
2284/248231
1.4
0.82.5
49.80
0.99
,0.001
Southern
427/81085
0.7
0.31.4
49.50
0.99
,0.001
Diabetics
Northern
13
2724/9044
26.5
20.633.3
49.40
0.99
,0.001
Southern
427/2952
15.7
8.926.3
49.30
0.99
,0.001
General population
Diabetics
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045264.t002
Figure 5. A funnel plot of studies conducted on the prevalence of diabetic retinopathy (DR) in mainland China.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045264.g005
Acknowledgments
Thanks to Jingpu Shi, Ph.D, Professor of the Department of Clinical
Epidemiology and Evidence Medicine in the First Affiliated Hospital of
China Medical University. Thanks to the editors and anonymous
reviewers.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: LL LC LML. Performed the
experiments: LL LC ZY. Analyzed the data: XMW LL JG. Wrote the
paper: LL LML LC ZYS.
References
6. Yang W, Lu J, Weng J, Jia W, Ji L, et al. (2010) Prevalence of diabetes among
men and women in China. N Engl J Med 362: 10901101.
7. Chiang PP, Lamoureux EL, Cheung CY, Sabanayagam C, Wong W, et al.
(2011) Racial differences in the prevalence of diabetes but not diabetic
retinopathy in a multi-ethnic Asian population. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 52:
75867492.
8. Wong TY, Klein R, Islam FM, Cotch MF, Folsom AR, et al. (2006) Diabetic
retinopathy in a multi-ethnic cohort in the United States. Am J Ophthalmol 141:
446455.
9. Chang C, Lu F, Yang YC, Wu JS, Wu TJ, et al. (2000) Epidemiologic study of
type 2 diabetes in Taiwan. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 50 (Suppl 2): S4959.
10. Lee KM, Sum WM (2011) Prevalence of diabetic retinopathy in patients with
recently diagnosed diabetes mellitus. Clin Exp Optom 94: 371375.
11. Rani PK, Raman R, Sharma V, Mahuli SV, Tarigopala A, et al. (2007) Analysis
of a comprehensive diabetic retinopathy screening model for rural and urban
diabetics in developing countries. Br J Ophthalmol 91: 14251429.
12. Zhang L, Xu Y, Nie H, Zhang Y, Wu Y (2012) The prevalence of depressive
symptoms among the older in China: a meta-analysis. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry
doi: 10.1002/gps.2821.
13. Gu D, Reynolds K, Duan X, Xin X, Chen J, et al. (2003) Prevalence of diabetes
and impaired fasting glucose in the Chinese adult population: International
Collaborative Study of Cardiovascular Disease in Asia (InterASIA). Diabetologia
46: 11901198.
14. Cockram CS (2000) The epidemiology of diabetes mellitus in the Asia-Pacific
region. Hong Kong Med J 6: 4352.
15. Reynolds K, Gu D, Whelton PK, Wu X, Duan X, et al. (2007) Prevalence and
risk factors of overweight and obesity in China. Obesity (Silver Spring) 15: 10
18.
16. Sanchez-Thorin JC (1998) The epidemiology of diabetes mellitus and diabetic
retinopathy. Int Ophthalmol Clin 38: 1118.
17. Hu YH, Pan XR, Liu PA, Li GW, Howard BV, et al. (1991) Coronary heart
disease and diabetic retinopathy in newly diagnosed diabetes in Da Qing, China:
the Da Qing IGT and Diabetes Study. Acta Diabetol 28: 169173.
18. He S, Guo Y, Li Z (1997) Epidemiologic study of diabetic retinopathy in Capital
Steel Company. Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi 33: 381383.
19. Shouling Li, Yanfeng Zhou, Di Chen, Minggong Yang, Meiling Zhu (1998)
Epidemiological investigation of diabetic retinopathy risk factors. Chin J Ocul
Fundus Dis 14: 119121.
20. Wang G, Zhang F, Yuan S, Meng S, Zhu L, et al. (2001) A screening survey of
diabetic retinopathy and other chronic complications in Beijing district.
Ophthalmology In China 10: 180182.
21. Zou H, Zhang X, Wang F, Xu X, Wang W, et al. (2006) Epidemiological
investigation of diabetic retinopathy in Beixinjing blocks, Shanghai. Chin J Ocul
Fundus Dis 22: 3134.
22. Liang X, Lin J, Huang Z, Li G, Wu X (2006) Prevalence and risk factors of
diabetic retinopathy in Foshan City. Guangdong Medical Journal 27: 1552
1553.