Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
The moral responsibility argument states that and individual must have free will
because we are responsible for our own actions. Our legal system is based on this.
Furthermore, research into criminality suggests there may be a biological basis.
Prices XYY research into criminality gave an explanation of violent crimes based on
chromosome abnormality. He found that males with an extra Y chromosome were
more likely to commit crime than those with the normal XY chromosomes. However,
this has implications as it suggests we have no control over developing criminality.
Our justice system is based on free will, so therefore, criminals will be able to blame
criminal behaviour on their genes.
There are also psychological arguments for supporting determinism. The scientific
argument suggests that determinism is compatible with science because science
can give cause-effect relationships so we can then begin to predict and control
behaviour. A problem with this is that most scientific research is conducted in labs so
cannot be generalised to the real world. Also, it relies on the idea that human
behaviour is 100% predictable but Mischels theory of personality argues that people
behaviour varies in different situations so behaviour isnt consistent and thus not
predictable.
Research into the human genome project is producing evidence of genes effecting
behaviour. Zubrenko has identified a gene for depression proving it may be predetermined. However, its gender specific and can only be applied to females. There
will never be 100% genetic determinism due to the ethical implications involved.
People may begin to create designer babies that have no genetic abnormalities or
any of the genes that may lead to abnormality in behaviour. This would cause many
ethical issues and problems for society. A major concern would be the issues related
with labelling as people may be treated unequally e.g. insurance companies might
not insure a person if they are carrying a mental illness gene.