Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
THESIS
ON
SUBMITTED TO:
PROF. SUMANTA SHARMA
DEAN (PROJECTS)
SUBMITTED BY:
NAMRATA GUPTA
ALUMNI ID NUMBER: DS/08/10-M-227
PGP/SS/2008-10
1
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Table of Contents
Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………14
IDFC Product
Structure………………………………………………………………………………..17
Senior Debt
Management…………………………………………………………………………..17
Proprietary
equity………………………………………………………………………………….18
Private
Equity…………………………………………………………………………………18
Treasury……………………………………………………………………………..19
Advisory……………………………………………………………………………. 19
Project
Equity…………………………………………………………………………………21
2
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Debt Capital………………………………………………………………………………
21
Project Development………………………………………………………………..
……...22
PPP Initiatives…………………………………………………………………… 22
Results…………………………………………………………………………… 23
Key findings……………………………………………………………………… 26
Future Outlook……………………………………………………………………27
Report
Card…………………………………………………………………………………29
Approvals and
Disbursements……………………………………………………………………..30
IDFC Strategy……………………………………………………………………………
32
Recession
Strategy………………………………………………………………………........33
3
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
The competitive
edge……………………………………………………………………………….36
Online investment
portal……………………………………………………………………………...36
Personal finance
services…………………………………………………………………………..37
Product
offerings…………………………………………………………………………..37
The edge…………………………………………………………………………..37
Loans………………………………………………………………………………38
SME
loans………………………………………………………………………………..38
Loan against
Property……………………………………………………………………..……..39
The Religare
Edge………………………………………………………………………………..39
Insurance
Solutions…………………………………………………………………..............39
4
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Life Insurance…………………………………………………………………40
General Insurance………………………………………………………………………
40
Institutional
Spectrum………………………………………………………………………..41
Institutional
broking………………………………………………………………………….41
The Religare
Edge…………………………………………………………………………….41
Investment
Banking………………………………………………………………………….42
The Religare
Edge………………………………………………………………………….…43
Insurance Advisory……………………………………………………………………..
…43
Our Service
Offerings………………………………………………………………………..45
Wealth Spectrum………………………………………………………………46
Portfolio Management
Services………………………………………………………………………...46
The Edge……………………………………………………………………..…46
Arts Initiative…………………………………………………………………….47
5
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
The Film
Fund………………………………………………………………………………47
Corporate social
Responsibility…………………………………………………………………….50
Religare……………………………………………………………………………55
Recommendation…………………………………………………………………58
Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………61
Bibliography
……………………………………………………………………………………….72
Appendix …………………………………………………………………………...73
6
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Letter of Approval
Dear Chetan Sharma,
You are required to correspond with your internal guide Prof. Vijay Kr.Boddu
at boddu.vijay@iipm.edu Ph.-0124-3917414 by sending at least four response
sheets (attached along with this mail) at regular intervals before 15 th February
2010 (the last date for thesis submission).
7
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Letter of originality
8
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
THESIS SYNOPSIS
Section FN-5
Phone No 9910084918
- Conservatism or Growth.
Specialization Area Finance
INTRODUCTION
9
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
The desired area of research is the working of Indian NBFC`s, their Business
Models and the effectiveness of those Models in changing Global Environment.
Analysis of the importance of the Capital Adequacy Ratio for leading Indian
NBFC`s like IDFC, Religare.
RESCERCH OBJECTIVES
HYPOTHESIS
10
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Conservatism in Business Models of PSU NBFC`s in India should be preferred
over an aggressive business Model adopted by private NBFC`s.
RESCERCH METHODOLOGY:
Secondary Data: Business models of IDFC and Religare Ltd, Annual reports
and expected future earnings.
SCOPE OF WORK:
The scope of work lays in the study of the business models of IDFC and Religare
and their core areas of competency.
Analysis of annual reports of IDFC and Religare, Capital Adequacy ratios and
key data inputs regarding future earnings past performances in recession and
boom economic scenarios.
11
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Capital inflows into developing economies like India have many good effects
especially when it comes to investing in infrastructure, financing projects and
supporting a good economic growth.
But this capital infusion should be supported by a capital base from the
institutions which are financing projects.
Destabilized cash inflows could lead to inflation, exchange rate problems and
affect the domestic financial sector.
Private NBFC`s follow a business model which has a Capital Adequacy ratio of
1:8 which is too risky and aggressive as compared to a ratio of 1:5 by PSU
NBFC`s like IDFC.
Mr.Ashish Sharma.
Consultant (IDFC)
Academic Qualification:
12
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
B.com (H) Graduate form Delhi University, (Hans Raj College)
An analysis of the free float methodology and its importance in calculation of the
index.
ABSTRACT
13
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
History of NBFC`s in India
They cannot accept demand deposits, they cannot issue checks to customers
and deposits with them are not insured by DGIC. Both RBI and SEBI regulate
NBFC`s in India.
NBFC`s have been around in india for a long time, but have recently gained
popularity amongst institutional investors, since they facilitate the finance and
loans for rural and semi rural areas where the traditional banks are still to reach.
NBFC`s have also played a huge part in developing small businesses and
infrastructure in India, through local presence and strong customer relationships.
Basically,
14
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
There is a huge need of credit in rural India. Roughly 245 million people need
US$ 52 billion of microfinance credit.
3. Market consolidation and entry of FII`s: The smaller NBFC will get
acquired and large FII`s will come in and build franchising models to
accelerate the quality and penetration of mutual funds in rural areas.
During the boom of 1990`s the Indian Government implemented many policies
for Infrastructure development with focus on roads, telecommunications, ports
and power. Special purpose vehicles were formed. Most of these were set up as
NBFC`s. The government also implemented (PPP) Public private Partnership.
During the period of 1996-2006, 233 PPP projects were completed with a total
investment of US$69 Billion. The PPP investments grew from US$.6 billion in
1991 to US$17.1 Billion n 2006 representing a CAGR of 25%.
(Source:www.IDFC.com/wwwrbi.org.in)
15
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
The government of India is setting up new policies to attract at least 50% of the
investment from the private sector. So here the role of NBFC`s like IDFC plays a
very important role.
IDFC
16
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Product Structure:
Senior Debt Management: forms the largest component of the
company’s portfolio and accounted for 85.6 % of the outstanding disbursements.
Senior debt financing is provided through loans or in the forms of subscriptions to
debentures. Senior debt ranks ahead of other debt obligations of the borrower
with respect of security and payment.
The financing typically bears fixed rate interest with reprising mechanisms
usually effective after 5 years. Additionally senior loans may also be reprised for
changes in the credit quality of the borrower.
The product is generally much secured and has access to the assets of the
projects in case of any default. As on 31 .3 2006 79.3% of our financing were
borrowers to special purpose entities. 35.1% of our senior debt financing there is
a limited recourse to the sponsors where they undertake to meet construction
cost overruns or funding short falls. For 17.8 % of senior debt financing there is
no recourse to the sponsors.
Mezzanine products :
17
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
These subordinated financing structures have a little more risk than the senior
debt but have the potential of earning higher returns. 4.5% of the total
outstanding financing.
Proprietary equity :
The portfolio was valued at 653 crores. The overall portfolio IRR for all
investments was valued at 37%. Have made equity proprietary investments In
infrastructure related companies:
Jet- airways
ONGC
TCS
PRIVATE EQUITY:
Mobilizing and managing third party funds through a wholly owned subsidiary,
IDFC private equity ltd. The company focuses on long Term private equity
investment opportunities and also invests in listed equities in certain
circumstances. The objective is to achieve attractive returns by providing equity
risk capital to early stage and rapidly growing infrastructure focused companies.
18
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
IDFC private equity has a panel of highly regarded advisors and an experienced
team that leverages the client relationships and domain expertise of IDFC.
Treasury:
Subordinated debt for the company is provided by the government which has a
term of 50 years maturing in 2047, which has an intrest rate of 25 basis points
over the 5 year government bond, and reprises every five years. The bonds of
19
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
the company are rated LAAA by ICRA and AA+ by CRISIL which are the top in
its category.
Through the operations the company maintains its ability to repay its borrowings
as and when they mature and make new loans and investments as new
opportunities arise.
Advisory:
20
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Project Equity:
This product mobilizes and manages third party funds with an objective to deliver
and stabilize long term returns by investing in assets, equity, quasi equity and
convertibles.
The focus here is to create a diversified and a high quality portfolio of operating
and green field infrastructure assets and also use financial engineering to strike
and appropriate balance between yield and capital appreciation.
Debt Capital:
We are the lead arranger of appraisal and structure of products, syndicate the
debt commitments among other financial institutions and also participate in it.
The equity placement business is an extension of our service of assisting
companies in structuring their capital by equity financing. This product gives the
company income in terms of the fee the company charges for the expertise
comments and analysis it does for the company who wants to raise equity.
21
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
(Data source: idfc.com)
Project Development:
Project development and consulting services are provided to our clients though
our joint ventures with the states of Karnataka and Uttaranchal to promote
investments in infrastructure through public private partnerships.
PPP Initiatives:
22
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Results:
23
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
(Source: Annual Report (IDFC) 08-09)
Valuation
EPS (Rs)* P/E Ratio (x) Market Cap (Rs P/BV (x)
7.34 20.13 m) 3.10
191,562.10
24
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
25
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
26
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Key Findings:
Net interest income rose 88.9% to Rs. 1.87 billion led by 46% increase in the
loan book to Rs. 204.9 billion.
The main contributor was the infrastructure income accounting for about 89% of
the income of 1.66 billion.
The remaining part of the 210 million was counted by income from treasury
operations.
The company`s overall spread increased by 30 basis points to 2.2% over the
year
Noninterest income witnessed a more than two fold rise over the year to Rs.1.3
billion. Income from IDFC-SSKI the investment banking subsidiary of IDFC,
accounted for the majority – 48% of the other total income.
Followed by advisory and other fees that contributed to 27%. However the latter
fell to 10% on year on year basis to Rs.360 million.
Income from principal investments multiplied 3.2 times to Rs.160 million
27
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Future Outlook
EQUITY RESEARCH May 21, 2008
Newer ventures and is also witnessing higher expenses on account of
Consolidation with SSKI.
Further, strong growth in income – both net interest income (89% year on year
basis) and other income (more than a two-fold rise) more than compensated for
the expenses and resulted in a net profit growth of c.61% year on year basis.
The balance sheet showed a healthy growth of c.55% year on year basis as the
loan book increased c.46% year on year basis to Rs. 204.9 billion. Gross
approvals increased 54% year on year basis to Rs. 203.1 billion.
In an important development over the year, IDFC has diversified its loan portfolio
across sectors and is moving towards reducing its dependence on any particular
sector.
(Source: www.Indiabulls.com)
(www.e&y.com)
(www.idfc.com)
28
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
29
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Report Card:
(Source: www.moneycontrol.com)
30
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
31
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Future Outlook and Growth Prospects:
32
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Importance of the business model to Indian Growth:
IDFC was set up in 1997 by the united front government to act as a catalyst for
and help bankroll infrastructure projects in the private sector. IDFC is expected to
do what institutions like IFCI and IDBI have been doing in the past years and that
too without having any bad loans. It had to work its way out of criticisms though
most of it was unfair.
A recent study by Morgan Stanley estimates that china spent nearly $201 billion
as compared to India. The gap between India and china in terms of infrastructure
specifically roads and power is huge. The major role which IDFC has to play here
is to mobilize resources and use them in a very efficient way to get the maximum
growth.
IDFC Strategy:
First, the concept of project finance for infrastructure was then in its infancy in
India, and IDFC was the first Indian financial institution to focus on the
assessment and funding of projects in areas like roads or ports.
Second, regulations were in a mess and lending to projects in areas where the
basic rules were unclear was bound to be risky.
33
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Recession Strategy:
Any finance company derives revenue from fund-based activities and non-fund
based activities — with the latter source known as other income.
At a time when there is hardly any growth in the loan books of lenders, it is the
other income that has bolstered the books of finance companies.
IDFC’s loan book grew by only 3% in the September 2009 quarter, more or less
flat.
Interestingly, a good deal of its credit growth has come from the telecom sector.
(IDFC’s outstanding disbursements to the telecom sector increased by 32% in
the September 2009 quarter)..
With interest rates down sharply since last year, the company will find it easy to
maintain the current growth momentum in the next two quarters. Further, it will
also come on the back of depressed spreads in the corresponding period of last
year, when the Indian central bank embarked on a monetary tightening course.
34
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Investors seem to have cottoned on to this as reflected in the hike in foreign
holding in IDFC, which is now 46.7% compared to less than 40% in March 2009.
35
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Information gathered on RELIGARE :
1) Methods used: 1) Analysis of secondary data (RELIGARE Website,
Articles in newspapers,
2) Consultation with Mr.Sachin Thakur (Head NCR, Advisory (Religare)) on
the product structure and strategies followed by RELIGARE in usage of those
products.
2) Products Religare:
36
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
A highly process driven, diligent approach
Powerful Research & Analytics and
One of the "best-in-class" dealing rooms
Further, Religare also has one of the largest retail networks, with its presence in
1837* locations across 498* cities & towns. This means, you can walk into any of
these branches and connect to our highly skilled and dedicated relationship
managers to get the best services.
37
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Today, more and more people look up to ways and means which can fulfill their
financial aspirations such as Savings, Retirement planning, Tax planning &
Wealth planning, etc. All this coupled with multiple and cut throat competitive
offerings makes it very difficult for an individual to come to a decision and this
leads to the search of a partner who can help an individual understand the
complex investment instruments and make the best use of them to meet his/her
short-term and long-term financial objectives.
1. Product Offerings
Mutual Funds
Insurance - Life & General
Bonds
Deposits
IPOs
Small Savings Instruments
Loans:
38
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Structurally all business are operated through various subsidiaries held through
the holding company Religare Enterprises Limited. One such wholly owned
subsidiary of REL is Religare Finvest Limited registered with the Reserve Bank of
India as a Non-Banking Finance Company (NBFC) and is a Member of CDSL.
SME loans -
Transportation is an essential part of any business and its growth, hence now
with Religare Consumer Finance you can avail Commercial Vehicle loans for
both new and used three-wheeler, multi utility vehicle, light and heavy
commercial vehicles and high end cranes which includes LCV's, Tractor Trailers,
Buses etc.
India is growing at a fast pace, to develop its infrastructure with the same pace
Religare Consumer Finance offers loans for purchase of new and used
Construction Equipments and all earth moving machinery which includes JCB,
Excavators, Backhoe/wheel Loaders etc.
39
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Religare Consumer Finance offers the best and hassle free way to en-cash the
value of your Residential or Commercial property to finance your personal or
business requirements. These loans are available for all types of individuals and
companies.
Insurance Solutions:
Religare with one of the largest retail networks in the country offers a complete
range of insurance solutions though its 100% subsidiary company, Religare
Insurance Broking Limited (RIBL). The company holds a composite broker's
license operating in the Life, General and Reinsurance domains.
An insurance portfolio is designed from a choice of more than 3000 life and
general insurance products & plans from more than 30 companies. This one
easy window for any brand of insurance, any kind of cover, offers tailor made
insurance solutions with not just the right kind of cover but also the right mix of
cover.
Offerings include:
Life Insurance
40
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Investment Linked Plans
Guaranteed Saving Plans
General Insurance
Motor Insurance
Health Insurance Program
Travel Protection Schemes
Package Policies for SMEs
Institutional Spectrum:
Institutional broking:
41
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Highly skilled, dedicated dealing, research and sales teams
Dealing capabilities on the NSE, BSE and in the cash and derivatives segment
In-depth, detailed and insightful coverage across 16 diverse sectors and 153
companies that extends to
Economic Research
Result Expectations
Derivative Strategies
IPO Research
Mutual Fund Research
Special reports like impact of credit policy, budget, etc.
The sectors covered are FMCG, Hotels, Media, Pharmacy, Auto, Cement,
Steel pipes, Logistics, Telecom, Construction and much more
Access to international expertise and global practices established in
mature financial markets
An international distribution network servicing the needs of institutions &
corporate houses through a large global network and with the ability to
execute globally
Investment Banking:
42
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Enterprises Limited, deals in merchant banking, transaction advisory and
corporate finance servicing the Corporate, Entrepreneurs and Investors.
43
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
End-to-End solution delivery capability and in-depth understanding of the
regulatory systems.
Global presence with offices operating in nine countries besides India.
Pan India presence in 1550 locations across more than 460 cities & towns.
Powerful research and analytics supported by a pool of highly skilled Research
Analysts
Ethical business practices
Part of a large diversified Indian trans-national promoter group
Insurance Advisory:
RIBL not only provides customized solutions to individual clients but also to some
of the leading corporate houses and institutions across the country.
Our team across the country is driven by the core philosophy of creating and
delivering value to its customers. Our strengths are a team of passionate
professionals, a robust IT infrastructure and strong risk analysis teams adept at
identifying & analyzing your risks and providing you with tailor made solutions.
Value Proposition
44
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Management
Flexibility Market understanding, proactive and
customer centric
Stability Part of a large diversified Indian trans-
national group with presence in over 1550
locations across more than 460 cities &
towns in India and globally across 10
countries.
Infrastructure Human, technical, physical presence, CRM
Quality Best business practices and highest quality
service
Strategic Partnerships Alliance with global and national players to
get you the best deals
45
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Wealth Spectrum:
46
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Wealth Advisory Services:
Religare PMS currently extends six portfolio management schemes, viz Monique,
Panther, Tortoise, Elephant, Caterpillar and Leo. Each scheme is designed
keeping in mind the varying tastes, objectives and risk tolerance of our investors.
The Edge:
We serve you with a diligent, transparent & process driven approach and ensure
that your money gets the care it deserves.
47
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Arts Initiative:
With this vision in mind, Religare Enterprises Limited last year launched Religare
Arts Initiative Limited (RAI), a wholly owned subsidiary. So, while most galleries,
auction houses and art funds operate art businesses, Religare Art Initiative will
conversely leverage business for art.
Religare and Vistaar bring to you an opportunity to invest and partner with the
ever evolving and recession-proof medium of films, through VISTAAR
RELIGARE FILM FUND - India's first SEBI-approved venture capital fund in this
sector. The Fund would be focusing on identifying right opportunities in the film
industry and in turn - produce challenging, entertaining, culturally-relevant
cinema as well as growth and returns for all its investors.
48
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Results and Future Outlook:
Mar ' Mar ' Mar ' Mar ' Mar '
09 08 07 06 05
PER SHARE RATIOS
Adjusted E P S (Rs.) -2.09 3.08 1.83 0.89 -1.76
Adjusted Cash EPS (Rs.) -2.04 3.09 1.86 0.89 -1.76
Reported EPS (Rs.) -2.09 3.08 1.83 0.89 -1.76
Reported Cash EPS (Rs.) -2.05 3.09 1.86 0.89 -1.76
Dividend Per Share 0.00 2.50 1.00 0.00 0.00
Operating Profit Per Share (Rs.) -0.46 3.59 2.25 0.90 0.70
Book Value (Excl Rev Res) Per
-0.63 2.15 1.97 1.30 0.00
Share (Rs.)
Book Value (Incl Rev Res) Per
-0.63 2.15 1.97 1.30 0.00
Share (Rs.)
Net Operating Income Per Share
1.64 4.19 2.39 0.91 1.11
(Rs.)
Free Reserves Per Share (Rs.) 80.84 53.24 34.76 0.00 0.00
PROFITABILITY RATIOS
49
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Operating Margin (%) -28.09 85.83 94.04 98.43 63.82
Gross Profit Margin (%) -30.58 85.69 94.03 98.43 63.82
Net Profit Margin (%) -58.15 73.49 76.71 97.38 -159.57
Adjusted Cash Margin (%) -56.84 73.62 77.93 97.38 -159.57
Adjusted Return On Net Worth (%) -2.29 4.87 4.09 8.33 -24.11
Reported Return On Net Worth (%) -2.30 4.87 4.09 8.33 -24.11
Return On long Term Funds (%) 1.53 5.67 4.95 6.23 9.64
LEVERAGE RATIOS
Long Term Debt / Equity 0.03 0.00 0.00 0.35 0.00
Total Debt/Equity 0.03 0.15 0.01 0.35 0.00
Owners fund as % of total Source 96.52 86.45 98.80 74.00 100.00
Fixed Assets Turnover Ratio 7.42 56.93 1,860.97 6.81 0.00
LIQUIDITY RATIOS
50
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Current Ratio 97.46 2.03 1.35 0.73 0.37
Current Ratio (Inc. ST Loans) 97.46 0.25 0.83 0.73 0.37
Quick Ratio 97.38 2.01 1.35 0.73 0.37
Inventory Turnover Ratio 155.54 882.68 0.00 0.00 0.00
Approximately 5000 children die every day in India, due to lack of amenities or
nutrition. And to rectify this dismal situation, Religare Enterprises Limited has
partnered with SOS Children’s Villages of India. At a time when India’s child
mortality rate is one of the highest in the world, Religare’s commitment to this
initiative is strong and unwavering.
SOS Children’s Villages of India creates the right environment for orphaned
children, where they are looked after at “homes.” Each village has “homes” with
8-10 children, who stay together like brothers and sisters, and they have a
“mother” who looks after them as her own. The children stay there till they
complete their education, giving them and the mother a loving family in return.
51
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
The employees’ initiative has already begun with Give India Foundation, where
Employees donate a part of their salaries to their pet cause, and contribute
towards a better world.
52
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
The primary research was done on the basis of focus interviews with personnel’s
from IDFC and Religare Ltd respectively, and their views on their business
models were as follows:
IDFC:
IDFC is now at a stage where it sees a lot of projects coming its way, being a
company which has pioneered the PPP investments in India, with the growth of
the economy and the need for infrastructure investments, we have our work cut
out to deliver as promised.
In this we have limited our exposure to large scale independent power projects
(300MW).
53
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
The company`s strategy, in the last three-four years, has been to find a balanced
business model that gives us a combination of different businesses so that we
get greater stability of earnings through cycles, and also we get, over a period of
time, a better return on our capital.
There are also the regulatory constraints and other market-imposed constraints
that got attached to our business balance sheet. We were, thus, disproportional
in a business that was very capital-intensive, and the return on investments was
modest. Given our structure as a non-banking finance company, which imposes
limitations on our sources of funding, we have been at a structural competitive
disadvantage vis-à-vis the banking competitors whose cost of funds is inevitably
lower.
This is why in the last three-four years we evolved a strategy to diversify our
earning streams away from capital-intensive businesses to capital-light
businesses of different characteristics.
We are still focused on the infrastructure space, but we are building our domain
knowledge to get into the businesses that are less capital intensive.
Competing with banks for funding projects is a challenge for us since cost of
funds for the banks is relatively low. We may try to convert IDFC into a full-
fledged infrastructure-focused commercial bank in the future. IDFC Bank could
be a possibility in the years to come. It is a strategic option that makes increasing
sense as we become larger.
IDFC is still relatively small compared to the overall opportunities available in the
country. So, even though the market has moderated and investments in India’s
infrastructure sector may have slowed down, that does not necessarily mean that
54
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
IDFC will see a disproportionate slowdown. Although we will witness a slowdown
inevitably, our market share will surely rise.
Also, India’s infrastructure sector is likely to witness a lesser slowdown than the
rest of the economy. We remain very focused on lending to infrastructure
projects, investing in infrastructure sector, facilitating investments in India’s
infrastructure projects, raising capital for infrastructure sector players, providing
broad-based financial services for people who are in the infrastructure sector and
would, hopefully, be introduce new products for interested investors in the
infrastructure sector in the future.
This fiscal our business has been larger than that of the last fiscal year in terms
of the balance-sheet size. However, the pace of growth of our balance sheet has
slowed down considerably due to the current economic scenario. Due to risk
aversion, we have not participated in certain projects.
Also, infrastructure funding demand has also slowed down in the country. Many
investment plans have been delayed. Our NPAs in this fiscal are higher than the
last fiscal’s figures, as expected.
The next fiscal is expected to be slower than the current fiscal although our
market share will witness a modest growth. We are planning to raise money
through external commercial borrowing. It will not be a large amount.
Although our cost of funding has fallen in recent weeks, it has not fallen by as
much as the government securities rates have fallen because the spread of AAA-
rated paper over government securities has not fallen.
55
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Alternatively, in the next couple of years, we also see a more significant
development in the corporate debt market that will give us more room to manage
our business in the way we are today, without becoming a bank.
Also, If the process of globalization accelerates and the Indian rupee becomes
fully convertible, then we can immediately connect to the world capital markets to
meet our future funding needs.
Religare:
Financial services group Religare Enterprises Ltd intends to enter the banking
business, taking advantage of the Rs10,000 crore that its owners will receive
when they complete the sale of their stake in Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd, India’s
biggest drug maker, to a Japanese acquirer.
The family is also “open to evaluating private equity” as a new line of business as
well, Malvinder Mohan Singh, chief executive and managing director the sale of
their stake to Japan’s third largest drug firm, Daiichi Sankyo Co. Ltd in a deal that
valued Ranbaxy at $8.5 billion (more than Rs36,450 crore) after equity dilution.
“At some point of time, I think it is an integral part of a strategy for any financial
services business to have a bank,” he said, declining to specify a time frame”.
Religare Enterprises already has a venture capital unit under Religare Venture
Capital Ltd.
The banking ambitions of Singh, who runs the group’s business along with
younger brother Shivinder Mohan Singh and Religare chief executive Sunil
Godhwani, will, however, face several regulatory hurdles.
56
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Banking rules in India don’t allow a company to hold more than a 10% stake in a
bank and any change in this is unlikely in the near future.
India financial services group Religare Enterprises has acquired a majority stake
in US and UK-based fund of funds investor Northgate Capital. Reportedly valued
at $36m, the deal is the opening salvo in a $1bn spending programme Religare is
planning that will see the group invest in asset management firms across the
globe.
In terms of new horizons Religare is looking forward to new businesses like air
travel and concierge services.
Corporate Travel, Customized Leisure Travel & Air Charter Services The air
charter business is one of the largest non scheduled operators in the country and
can boast of one of the best-in-class “owned fleets”, with its hubs in Delhi,
Mumbai and Chennai. The fleet is a versatile and young combination of
Jets, turbo props and helicopters with a flying range within the Asian continent
and the Middle East. The fleet has been carefully chosen keeping in
Mind safety, comfort and convenience parameters and is commanded by pilots
drawn from the very best in the industry. The travel business is duly accredited
for complete management of both in-bound and outbound domestic and
international travel. Our 360 degree service bouquet encompasses.
57
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
To us it’s a lot of money and in the competition we are in we need to make sure
that every penny we have generates a good amount of return. That’s why we
focus more on asset creation than keeping the cash with us.
Off course we have to abide what the regulators say, but as a profit making
organization we need to look at what best we can give to our shareholders.
58
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Recommendation:
Aggressive strategy or the American way of Banking, it’s the new trend in
India. Following this and taking a good look at how private banks and NBFC`s
in India were functioning RBI cautioned the banks on the pitfalls of "doorstep
banking", where banks make their staff and agents visit the client`s homes to
get new business.
Also the Liquidity ratios and Capital Adequacy ratios with some of the NBFC`s
are a concern as they try to squeeze everything out to get an aggressive
approach to profit making, without looking at the interests of the investor and
the consumer.
I personally after analyzing the data and factors of marketing and promotion
by various companies see that aggressiveness for selling and increasing
revenues is hampering the fundamentals of capital structure and creating a
trust for tha banking industry in the market
The RBI guidelines on "know your customer" primarily deal with money
laundering. Aggressive marketing for business development should, by all
accounts, have no apparent conflict with normal banking practices. A brief
look at the probable relationship between aggressive marketing, and the high
level of non-performing assets (NPA) in the banking sector may help us
understand the reasons behind the unstated and unspoken concerns of the
RBI. Banks in India, especially the nationalized entities, never considered
`marketing' an essential tool for business. It mostly remained the domain of
the foreign banks.
The American banks especially thrived on marketing, and made it an art form.
It was since 1994, only when the new generation, technology-driven private
sector banks came into operation that marketing received a boost. A
performance driven approach to the business of banking, the desire to grow
at a fast pace, the pressure to grab a market share from the existing players
and the urgency to shore up the balance-sheet before a public issue took the
battle for business right to the doorstep of the foreign banks.
59
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
The war for market share was spearheaded by the new generation bankers
recruited from non-banking finance companies (NBFC), foreign banks,
broking houses and business schools. The staid, traditional, conservative
banker became passé. The demand for front- and back-office staff, apart from
those required for marketing or managing `relationships', forced the
headhunters and the HR managers to look at unconventional (read non-
banking) sources. Inevitably, there had to be some compromises. The
recruitment of these `bankers', therefore, came at a price. The personnel
recruited were mostly non-bankers. Few realized there was more to banking
than what was written in the textbooks, or taught in the classrooms.
The resultant impact was subtle, essentially on the attitude and the approach
to handling transactions, but more on business generation. Those in a hurry
hardly spared time to know their customers, or build relationships. Coupled
with their drive to generate the maximum business in the shortest possible
time, these hard-sell bankers also had a different mindset, which was `deal'
based, in contrast to that of a conservative, traditional banker.
In trying to beat the foreign banks at their own game, the new generation
banks burnt their fingers badly. In their zeal they failed to appreciate the fact
that the foreign banks had a highly developed system of risk management in
place, and that they were quite adept at exiting accounts at the first hint of
trouble.
60
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
This was the advice of RBI on the strategy of private NBFC` working in India
"Distribute your loans rather than concentrate them in a few hands. Large
loans to a single borrower or firm, although sometimes proper and necessary,
are generally injudicious, and frequently unsafe. Large borrowers are apt to
control the bank, and when this is the relation between a bank and its
customers, it is not difficult to decide which in the end will suffer..."
Source: www.cnbc.com
61
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Conclusion:
Through the analysis of various data and the models for both the companies,
IDFC and Religare we come to a conclusion that the businesses targeted by both
the companies are different in aspects and that both have a business model
suiting to that.
By analyzing the secondary data and performance charts of both the companies
we can say that both companies have done fairly well in terms of profits, growth
and increasing their business size in the previous year.
IDFC focusing on their core business of financing and consulting has been a
major factor for development of Indian infrastructure industry, whereas Religare
has been a company which has revitalized the microfinance industry by taking
reach and convenience to another level.
When we take a close look at the models, we see that the models are perfect
according to the business they engage themselves perfectly in the business they
look forward to as Religare having its core business of microfinance products
needs to have marketing and selling expenses and moreover it needs to be
aggressive to churn in more profits to take care of its expenses and along with
that grow at a healthier rate.
Growth and risk are two components of strategies companies select for
themselves.
Comparably the risk factor for Religare s more in their capital structure due to its
strategy and business structure, whereas IDFC supports a more robust capital
structure which involves less risk and since IDFC is supported by the
Government of India in terms of its stake and structure, the risk factor for IDFC
would always be lower when compared to a private company like Religare.
62
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
In terms of growth both IDFC and Religare have grown in a very positive manner
since they came into existence.
This clearly proves the theory by Modigliani and Miller that capital structure of a
firm does not affect the valuation of a firm.
By this we can say that it’s a structure which mainly consists of equity and no
debt component and the company has done really well in terms of its value which
has increased in spite of the recession in the previous year.
63
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
http://www.moneycontrol.com/stocks/company_info/print_main.php
The IDFC capital structure also comprises mainly of equity capital and has been
a great performer on the stock exchange and also in terms of profits.
The capital structure has not affected the company`s returns or valuations but the
only difference is that IFDC being a PSU has a greater Capital Adequacy Ratio
as compared to a private NBFC meaning that the company will be safe in case
their assets turn bad or their investments lose its value which is not the case with
Religare.
64
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
A private NBFC like Religare has to be very vigilant and resourceful when it
invests in assets and creates an reinvestment strategy for its surplus. As the
company does not maintain a very high capital Adequacy ratio, it has a rick of
devaluation or bankruptcy in scenarios like recession where the returns go on the
negative side and assets tend to lose their value.
So by studying all the research and data and with the talks with people in this
industry we come to a conclusion to our hypothesis, of “Is Capital Adequacy ratio
important for growth and sustainability” that the Capital Adequacy ratio is not
important for growth or sustainability of a company and also that the capital
structure of a company does not have any impact on the value of a firm.
65
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Response Sheet 1:
It forms the largest component of the company’s portfolio and accounted for 85.6
% of the outstanding disbursements. Senior debt financing is provided through
loans or in the forms of subscriptions to debentures. Senior debt ranks ahead of
other debt obligations of the borrower with respect of security and payment.
The financing typically bears fixed rate interest with reprising mechanisms
usually effective after 5 years. Additionally senior loans may also be reprised for
changes in the credit quality of the borrower.
The product is generally much secured and has access to the assets of the
projects in case of any default. As on 31.3.2006, 79.3% of the Company`s
disbursements were borrowers to special purpose entities. 35.1% of our senior
debt financing there is a limited recourse to the sponsors where they undertake
66
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
to meet construction cost overruns or funding short falls. For 17.8 % of senior
debt financing there is no recourse to the sponsors.
Mezzanine products:
These subordinated financing structures have a little more risk than the senior
debt but have the potential of earning higher returns. 4.5% of the total
outstanding disbursements.
Proprietary equity:
The portfolio was valued at 653 crores. The overall portfolio IRR for all
investments was valued at 37%. Have made equity proprietary investments in
infrastructure related companies:
67
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Private Equity:
Mobilizing and managing third party funds through a wholly owned subsidiary,
IDFC private equity ltd. The company focuses on long Term private equity
investment opportunities and also invests in listed equities in certain
circumstances. The objective is to achieve attractive returns by providing equity
risk capital to early stage and rapidly growing infrastructure focused companies.
IDFC private equity has a panel of highly regarded advisors and an experienced
team that leverages the client relationships and domain expertise of IDFC.
68
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
RESPONSE SHEET 2
Institutional
Retail Spectrum Spectrum Wealth Spectrum
Equity and Commodity
Trading Institutional Broking Wealth Advisory Services
Portfolio Management
Online Investment Portal Investment Banking Service.
International Advisory
Fund
Insurance Corporate Finance Management Service.
Personal Credit
Personal Loans
69
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Further, Religare also has one of the largest retail networks, with its presence in
1837 locations across 498* cities & towns. This means, you can walk into any of
these branches and connect to our highly skilled and dedicated relationship
managers to get the best services.
70
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Online Investment Portal: The Company provides a unique service of
availability of all kinds of financial products, services and advisory through the
Internet.
This is something which makes the company easily accessible and with a big
coverage area, both nationally and internationally. The Company also boats of
features such as Zero percent brokerage, Interest on cash margin, exposure up
to 20 times on your cash margin, etc. on our select product schemes available
through our highly sophisticated and customized platform
R-ACE (Religare Advanced Client Engine).
71
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Response Sheet 3:
Analysis of data and future growth patterns for IDFC and Religare done,
through focus interviews with key personnel’s.
The role of IDFC and Religare analyzed with the key inputs of these
companies representing public and private ownerships.
72
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Bibliography
www.idfc.com
www.religare.in
www.investopedia.com
www.indiastat.com
www.businessweek.com
www.financialexpress.com
www.moneycontrol.com
www.cnbc.com
73
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227
Indian Institute of Planning and Management, New Delhi.
Appendix:
74
SS (08-10) Alumni ID: DS/08/10-M-227