Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Page 1
ME105MechanicalEngineeringLaboratory
SpringQuarter2010
Experiment#3:PipeFlow
Introduction
Volumetric flow rate, pressure, and head losses are key fundamental quantities in
analyzing and designing piping systems. This experiment will introduce you to basic
measurement techniques and to some principles of pipe flow. In this experiment three
basic devices a pressure transducer, an orificeplate flowmeter and a paddlewheel
flowmeterarecalibratedandcomparedagainststandardpractice,andthenusedtomake
fundamentalmeasurementsoflossesinpipes,fittings,andpipingnetworks.
Pre-Lab Reading
Review relevant material from your undergraduate fluid mechanics courses, including (i)
Reynolds number, (ii) losses in straight pipes and the Moody diagram, (iii) Bernoullis equation
and the mechanical energy balance, (iv) orifice meters, and (v) minor losses in fittings. Some of
this material is presented below, but this lab handout is not a substitute for more extensive
background reading.
Pre-Lab Work
Prepareandsubmitanoutlinethatincludes:
Calibrations to perform
Data sets to collect
Possible sources of experimental uncertainty and a plan for quantifying these errors
Brief description of the work plan
Any equations or physical parameters that may be needed during the laboratory session
(See general lab guidelines & print out grading sheet from website).
ME 105
Page 2
PreLabExercises:
1. Hydrodynamic losses in pipe flow are characterized by measuring the pressure drop P
over a length of pipe L. If you anticipate using flow rates of 0.5 gals/min through 1/4 i.d.
smooth-wall tubing, and want a pressure drop of 10 kPa, what length, L, of tubing should you
use? Express your answer in meters. Note: You will note that this problem statement uses
mixed units, which unfortunately are a fact of life in engineering calculations. You should
know how to do unit conversions accurately and quickly. A good rule of thumb is to convert
all units to SI before doing any numerical calculations.
Hint: Assume that the working fluid is water at 20C, and refer to a standard Moody
diagramtocompletethistask.
2. The Validynepressuretransducermeasurespressuredifferencesbetweenthetwosides
of a stainless steel plate (diaphragm). It will be calibrated by applying hydrostatic
pressuretooneside.Ifwaterat20Cistheworkingfluid,whatrangeofwaterheights
shouldbeusedtocalibratethedeviceoverarangeofdifferentialpressuresfrom020
kPa?
3. Thekitincludes1/8,1/4,and3/8i.d.tubes.Ifwaterat20Cistheworkingfluidand
the transition Reynolds number is taken as 2,000, calculate the velocity and the
volumetricflowratefortransitionfromlaminartoturbulentflowforeachsizedtube.
Recordbothvelocitiesandvolumetricflowratesinyournotebookforfuturereference.
4. Thepaddlewheelflowmeterworksontheprinciplethattheoncomingflowrotatesthe
paddlewheelatafrequencythatisrelatedtotheflowrate.Therewillbesomebackflow
as the vane of the paddlewheel sweeps forward. Consider the hypothetical situation
where the flow rate vs. frequency relation is exactly linear. What would that tell you
aboutthebackflow?
5. In a standard fluids text we find the following rules of thumb for the ratio of equivalent
length to pipe diameter Le/D for minor losses due to:
Le/D
Standard elbow:
30
Standard tee: flow through run
20
flow through branch
60
Consider the flow of water at Q = 2 liters/min. through a diameter tube containing an
elbow. Use the rule of thumb to estimate the pressure drop across the elbow. Express your
answer in Pascals.
6. Referring to the pipe network shown in Figure 1, and with the aid of the development in the
handout, manipulate the energy balance to obtain a working equation for the head losses as
follows.
ME 105
Page 3
A) If p23 p2 p3 0 , i.e. the bridge is balanced, and (as is true of our setup), all the
tubing between point 1 and points 2 and 3 is the same diameter and length, the fittings are
identical, and the elevation at points 2 and 3 are the same, what is the left hand side of
equation (13)?
B) Now if in addition the diameter of the tubing at the outlets 4 and 5 is identical what is the
relationship between u4 and u5 ?
C) With all this in mind, if the outlets 4 and 5 are held such that the water exits into the
atmosphere, what is the working equation relating the elevations at 4 and 5 and the losses
in legs A and B?
2
LA
LB
1
Pump
Equipment
Omegapaddlewheelflowmeter
Validynepressuretransducerwithbleedingscrewdriver
Waterreservoirandsumppump
Teflontubingandfittingassortment
Flowneedlevalve
Orifice plate
Bucket
Balance
Stopwatch
Oscilloscope and power supply
Thermometer
ME 105
Page 4
Technical Data
Orifice plate
Upstream pipe diameter
Orifice diameter
= 9.53 mm
= 4.76 mm
System Description
You will need to set up a simple method to calibrate a pressure transducer by providing a
known pressure difference between the two sides of the transducer. In addition you will
have to construct a water-bench to perform measurements that allow you to calibrate the
pressure transducer and the two kinds of flowmeters, and investigate head loss in pipe flow,
fittings, and pipe networks. Although you will decide the specific arrangement, Fig. 2 shows
generically the layout of the flow loop.
orifice plate
pipe section
pressure
transducer
needle paddlewhee
valve flow meter
return
pump
water supply
Theoreticalorificerelations
An orifice plate is one of the most common flow measurement devices. Using a control
volume approach shown in Fig. 3, it is possible to obtain an expression for the flow
coefficientintermsoftheflowrateQ,thepressuredifferenceP1P2acrosstheorificeplate,
andthegeometricalparametersoftheflowmeter.Applyingconservationofmassforsteady
flow,
ME 105
Page 5
A1V1 A2V 2 ,
(1)
V12 P1
V2 P
gZ 1 2 2 gZ 2 ,
2
Orifice plate
(2)
Pipe
2
Control
volume
Differential
pressure
transducer
V 22
1 ( A2 / A1 ) 2 ,
2
(3)
where V is the flow velocity, A is the area, is the density, g is the acceleration due to gravity
and Z is the elevation. This can be rewritten in terms of the volumetric flow rate as a function of
the pressure difference:
Q V2 A2 A2
2( P1 P2 )
.
1 ( A2 / A1 ) 2
(4)
FortheorificeplatemetershowninFig.3,theareaA2isnotgivenbytheorificediameterd,
but rather the diameter of the vena contracta, (where the flow has a minimum cross
sectionalarea).Thisareaisunknownandwillchangewiththeflowrate.Consequently,(4)
ME 105
Page 6
Figure4:Dischargecoefficientcurvesforastandardorificeplateflowmeter.
ME 105
Page 7
P2 V 22
P1 V12
gz 2 hlT .
gz1
2
2
(6)
(It also be noted that for flow without losses, hlT = 0, and the energy equation reduces to
Bernoullis Equation.) The terms in parentheses represent the mechanical energy per unit mass
at a particular cross-section in the pipe. Hence, the difference between the mechanical energy at
two locations, i.e. the total head loss, results from the conversion of mechanical energy to
thermal energy due to frictional effects.
For an incompressible flow, conservation of mass determines V2 (since, V1 A1 V 2 A2 ) and so the
terms involving the fluid velocity are determined by geometry. If the elevation at position 2 is
known, the change in the gravitational potential is known. The net result is that if the pipe
diameter is constant and the elevation does not change, the head loss is manifested simply as a
pressure loss.
Major Losses
The major head loss in pipe flows is expressed in the following way:
L V2
hl f
,
(7)
D 2
where L and D are the length and diameter of the pipe, respectively, and V is the average fluid
velocity through the pipe. This may be taken as a definition of the friction factor, f. In general,
the friction factor is a function of the Reynolds number Re and the non-dimensional surface
roughness / D , and is determined experimentally. The plot of f vs. Re is usually referred to as
the Moody Diagram, after L. F. Moody who first published this data in this form.
Minor Losses
The head losses associated with fittings such as elbows, tees, couplings, etc. are referred to as
minor losses. In some cases, such as short pipes with multiple fittings, these losses are actually
a large percentage of the total head loss and hence are not really minor. Minor losses are
expressed as either
V2
hlm K
,
(8a)
2
where K is the Loss Coefficient and must be determined experimentally for each situation, or as
Le V 2
hlm f
,
(8b)
D 2
wherein the loss is expressed in terms of the (known) friction factor and an equivalent Le / D .
For example, an elbow creates a loss that is roughly equivalent to a pipe of length of 30 pipe
diameters (see the table in Prelab Question 4). Loss coefficients, K and/or equivalent length
ME 105
Page 8
ratios Le / D can be found in a variety of handbooks: data for specific simple fittings are
available in most undergraduate Fluid Mechanics texts.
and
pB p3 pa
where pa is atmospheric pressure. The energy equation for these two branches yields:
and
(10a,b)
2
Assume that leg A of the network consists of only a straight tube uniform tube and therefore the
head loss hLA is
hLA f A
LA VA2
.
DA 2
(11)
The head loss in leg B of the network, hLB , includes losses through the pipe itself but also any
minor losses due to the insertion of elbows, etc. In general,
hLB f B
L V2
LB VB2
f B eB B ,
DB 2
DB 2
(12)
where we have chosen to express the minor losses in terms of equivalent pipe lengths, LeB.
Subtracting (10a) from (10b) we obtain:
13
ME 105
Page 9
This particular pipe network is analogous to a Wheatstone bridge. The purpose of the electrical
version of such a bridge is to be able to measure small changes in resistance accurately. In the
hydraulic analog we measure small changes in head loss. When the bridge is balanced, i.e. there
is no flow through the leg L23, the pressures at points 2 and 3 must be the same: (otherwise, the
pressure gradient would drive a flow through the leg).
In our laboratory setup, the leg L23 viewed from the side is shaped in an arc as shown in Figure 5.
A small tightly fitting sphere is placed in the tube. Any flow in the leg will exert a drag on the
sphere and it will rise above the center. By contrast, a no flow condition will result in the sphere
positioned at zero degrees from the vertical since p23 p2 p3 0 . Thus, monitoring the sphere
position allows a coarse measurement of bridge balance.
Figure 5: Schematic of the sphere in the arched tube comprising the center leg.
Experimental Procedure:
General
You will be making a variety of measurements with water, the physical properties of which are
temperature dependent. For this reason, it is very important that you know the temperature of
the water for each measurement.
Week One
1) Calibration of the pressure transducer
The first step is to calibrate the output voltage from the Validyne differential pressure
transducer. Apply known pressure differences to the two sides of the transducer using
hydrostatic pressure. Five to ten data points should be obtained, ranging from a zero
pressure differential to a pressure differential of about 20 kPa. Perform a linear least
squares analysis of the data before week two. Try both linear and a quadratic fits and
compute the goodness of fit. If a linear fit is sufficiently accurate, record the slope and
interceptoftheresultinglineforlateruseindataacquisition.
ME 105
Page 10
Week Two
4) Major losses
Dependingonthequalityofyourdatafromweekone,youmaychosetocheckcalibrations
and/orrepeatyourmeasurementsofmajorlosses.
a) Prepare two 6 long lengths of tubing to serve as legs A and B. Set the flow rate with the
needle valve in the midrange of the pump and make sure that the tube exits are at the same
elevation. Curiously, although the two legs are identical tubing and identical lengths, the bridge
may be slightly out of balance. This could be due to a number of factors, including different
coiling of the two legs, burrs and rough edges where the tube was cut, slight differences in the
ME 105
Page 11
losses in the two elbows at points 2 and 3, etc. By raising or lowering the exit tubes, determine
which of the branches has the larger loss, and shorten the appropriate tube in order to bring the
bridge into balance.
b) Experiment with the effect of raising or lowering one tube exit elevation on the bridge
balance. In this way, you will obtain some feeling for the response time of the middle leg.
Since the small sphere is tightly fitting, there is some time lag between a change in hydraulic
resistance and the motion of the sphere. Experiment also with the effect of throttling the flow
with your finger. Explain the reasons for what you observe. Change the flow rate and observe
whether the bridge remains in balance or not. If so, why? If not, why not?
c) Re-establish a balanced bridge by returning the flow rate to the original setting. From this
point on, do not change the needle valve, as it is important for these next steps to be done at
constant flow rate. Add an elbow to one of the legs and observe the resulting imbalance. Raise
or lower one tube to re-establish the balance and record the elevation change necessary to
accomplish this. This datum will be used to compute the minor loss using the mechanical
energy balance.
d) Using the empirical rule of thumb that an elbow creates a loss equivalent to 30 pipe diameters
of smooth, straight pipe, shorten the leg containing the elbow by an appropriate length. Observe
the bridge balance or imbalance. If imbalanced, measure the change in elevation of one of the
tube exits required to re-establish balance.
Experiment Report
Pressuretransducer
The Validyne pressure transducer produces a voltage related to the pressure difference
across a thin plate. If the deflection of the plate follows the laws of linear elasticity, the
pressure will be linearly related to the voltage and the device is said to be a linear
transducer. Perform a linear leastsquares analysis of the data. Try both linear and a
quadraticfitsandcomputethegoodnessoffit.Discussthedegreetowhichthisisalinear
transducer.
Paddlewheelflowmeter
The paddlewheel flowmeter produces a pulse signal, the frequency of which is related to
the fluid velocity in the pipe. Perform a leastsquares fit of your data, using different
polynomialfitsandapowerlawrelation.Findasuitablefittingfunctionandrecordyourfit.
Towhatdegreeisthepaddlewheelalineartransducer?Aretherereasonstoexpecteither
linearornonlinearityinthecalibration?Discuss.
ME 105
Page 12
Orificeplateflowmeter
ThetheoreticalrelationbetweenQand Pisanonlinearone,namely Q (const.)C d P .
Usingloglogscales,plotyourdatapointsforQasafunctionof P.Dothedataappearto
fallalongastraightline,indicatingthatapowerlawrelationofthetype Q K (P) m might
apply?Ifso,whatism?Ifnot,whynot?
UsethemeasurementsofQvs.P,computethedischargecoefficientCdforallthedata.Plot
Cdvs.theReynoldsnumberReandcompareagainststandardcurves.
Headlossinpipeflow
Calculate the friction factors for each flow rate and tube size and plot all the data as a function of
the Reynolds number. Use different plotting symbols for different tube diameters and check for
Reynolds number scaling. Compare your data with the standard Moody diagram and discuss.
Minorlosses
Express your results for minor losses through elbows, tees and couplings both as loss
coefficients, K, and as equivalent lengths, Le / D . Compare your results with literature results for
K, and with the common empirical rules of thumb for Le / D .
Pipingnetwork
Compute the loss coefficient and the equivlent length, Le / D , for an elbow as measured by the
bridge technique. Compare it against your direct measurement and also against the standard rule
of thumb.