Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
(76)
Inventor:
Notice:
4,984,155 A
5,125,091 A
5,148,474
5,159,632
5,231,566
5,239,662
5,285,383
5,295,139
5,297,249
5,329,589
5,329,619
5,347,632
5,367,635
5,383,113
Filed:
1/1991
6/1992
9/1992
10/1992
7/1993
8/1993
2/1994
3/1994
3/1994
7/1994
7/1994
9/1994
11/1994
1/1995
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
(65)
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
ABSTRACT
Int. Cl.
G06F 13/00
(56)
(Continued)
(57)
13, 1995.
(52)
(58)
5/1997
(Continued)
(51)
Haralambopoulos et a1.
Crandall
Blutinger et a1.
Danielson et a1.
Lindsey et a1.
Palmer
Bernstein et a1.
Fraser et a1.
Page et a1.
Filepp et a1.
Bauer et a1.
Kight et a1.
WO 97/18515 A1
WO
(60)
Geler et a1.
Staas, Jr. et a1.
Dec. 2, 2010
(60)
Jan. 1, 2013
(Continued)
US 2010/0306343 A1
US 8,346,894 B2
(2006.01)
References Cited
OPERATOR
AGENT
WEB
SERVER
5513
10.4.
WEB
PAGE
POINT~OF'
SERVICE
APPLICATIONS
g:
EXCHANGE g
VAN
SWITCH
OBJECT
ROUTER
529
525
US 8,346,894 B2
Page2
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
5,404,523 A
4/1995 Dellaferaetal.
5408619 A
M995 0
5,892,821 A
5,414,812 A
995 Fir?lgetal
5,893,076 A
4/1999 Hafneretal.
5,428,792 A
5895454 A
4/1999 Hamngton
3/1999 Koreeda
3/ 1999 Henandet 31'
4/1999 Turner
5432937 A
M995 T
31
5,897,621 A
4/1999 Boeschetal.
5,434,974 A
M995 Lgfl?ggtegl ~
5,898,871 A
4/1999 Williamsonetal.
5,440,744 A
2383332 A
28333 giawgzrtdal
5,442,771 A
8/1995 Fileppetal.
5918987 A
6,1999 Gi?er
5,442,791 A
5,444,192 A
8/1995 Wrabetzetal.
8/1995 Shetyeetal.
59l3040 A
5913861 A
5446 896 A
5452433 A
5,475,819
5,455,903 A
5,890,137 A
5890161 A
8/1995 He artyetal.
9/l995 Nilfartetal
12/1995
10/1995 Milleretal.
Jolissaintetal.
'
Pale 3'
5,931,967 A
8/1999 ShlmlZuetal.
5956509
2328288 A
9,1999
38333 Kevner
996 Stutzetal
5,958,004 A
5,519,868 A
5960411 A
5537464 A
7/l996 L
5,987,500 A
11/1999 Arunachalam
6,003,085 A
12/1999 Ratneretal.
5517645 A
5,539,909 A
M996 Tjnwalligifl
5,557,780 A
5 560 005 A
5,577,251 A
5590197 A
12/19% Chenetal
5,592,378
5604 905
536133148
5664111
A
A
A
A
1/1997
2/l997
3/l997
9/1997
'
5,491,800 A
6914551 A
6,014,666 A
6049785 A
6,049,819 A
Cameron etal.
Tevanian etal
Bezvineretal
Nahan etal
6055514
6,055,567
6,073,237
6,092,053
A
A
A
A
9/1999 Hellandetal.
V2000
1/2000
40000
4/2000
40000
4/2000
Crawford
Hollandoral.
Glfford
Buckleetal.
Wren
Gallesan etal.
6/2000 Elllsonetal.
7/2000 B0e3scheta1.
5,677,708 A
6l01527 A
8,2000 Le-eune et 31
5,677,955 A
6,119,152 A
5,694,549 A
12/1997 Carlinetal.
5,703,344 A
12/1997
5706 442 A
6125185 A
Bezyetal.
V1998 Anderson et a1
6,125,352 A
88328345, A
9,2000 Boesch
'
5,708,780 A
5,710,887 A
1/1998
M998 Ch
6,135,646 A
10/2000 Kahnetal.
5,715,314 A
537153444 A
M998 paaugtal
2/l998 Dggilsheta'l
6,145,090 A
6,185,609 B1
11/2000 Yamagnohielal.
2/2001 Rangarajanetal.
5724424 A
3/l998 Gifford
'
6,192,250 B1
2/2001 Buskensetal.
5,742,762
5,737,533 A
5,742,768 A
4/1998 de
Scholletal.
Hond ..................... .. 709/219
V1998 681111910991
8389288 B1
6212634
8%
6,249,291 B1
4,2001 Geeretal
438388}
6/2001 Popp oral.
5712913 A
188888 811182113; 31
'
2,322,323 A
581332 hevmetetlal'
6,279,001 B1
5,757,917 A
M998 RS223;
6,289,322 B1
9/2001 Kitchenetal.
5,758,072 A
6295522 B1
5758327 A
998 G dn
6,301,601 B1
10/2001 Hellandetal.
5,771,354
5,774,670
5,778,178
5,780,780
5,781,631
M998
M998
M998
M998
M998
6,327,577
6,327,579
6,334,116
6,360,262
6,363,362
12/2001
12/2001
12/2001
3/2002
3/2002
A
A
A
A
A
m1
B1
B1
B1
B1
B1
9/2001 Boesch
Garrisonetal.
Crawford
Ganesanetal.
Guenthneretal.
Bur?eldetal.
5,793,964 A
5794 221 A
M11943 B1
6,453,426 B1
6/2002 Crawford
9/2002 Gamacheetal.
5,794,234 A
5,809,483 A
5,812,779 A
M998 Cien A 31
9/l998 B If et1~
9/l998 C10 aetta'l
6,457,066 B1
6,473,740 B2
6,473,791 B1
9/2002 Meinetal.
10/2002 Cockrilletal.
10/2002 Al-Ghoseinetal.
5,822,569 A
M998 hijgifanae'tal
6,486,895 B1
11/2002 Robeltsonetal.
5,826,085 A
823838; 8%
14283883 glrlliorzt 31
5,826,241 A
10/1998 Steinetal.
6574607 B1
5,828,666 A
5835 726 A
5,845,061 A
H998 Shwed
6,625,581 B1
6,2003 Cartefeta1'
-'
9/2003 Perkowskl
5845 073 A
12/1998
12/1998 carlin
Miyamoto
etal.
etal.
8838832
8%
8388A ga?esant
1
e an e 3'
5,845,265 A
M1998 W 1
6,714,962 B1
3/2004 Hellandetal.
6,839,677 B2
1/2005 Mathuretal.
5,856,974 A
5,859,978 A
M999 Grlgitsgtal
1/1999 Sondereggeretal.
8828332 8%
Z3882 885:; et 31
5,864,866 A
1/1999 Henckeletal.
693llll B1
800% Coffee
5,870,473 A
5870 724 A
2,1999 Lawloretal
'
6,932,268 B1
8/2005 McCoyetal.
5,873,072 A
2/l999 Kightet 31
6,948,063 B1
5,878,043
5,873,093 A
3/1999
2/1999 Williamson
caseyet 31 et
7,076,784 B1
7,080,051
7/2006 Crawford
Russell et
5,878,140
5,878,141
5,878,403
5,884,301
3/1999
3/1999
3/1999
3/1999
7,107,244
7,120,602
7,146,338
7,175,074
A
A
A
A
5,889,957 A
Chaum
Dalyetal,
DeFrancesco et a1.
Takano
B2
B2
B2
B2
7,177,846 B2
9/2006
10/2006
12/2006
2/2007
Kight etal.
Kitchen etal.
Kight et a1.
Mejiasetal.
US 8,346,894 B2
Page 3
7,213,003 B1
7,240,031 B1
7,251,656 B2
7,296,004 B1
7,302,408 B2
7,302,411
7,330,831
7,334,128
7,340,506
7,366,696
7,366,697
7,383,226
7,389,514
7,392,223
7,395,243
7,395,319
7,451,400
11/2007
2/2008
2/2008
3/2008
4/2008
4/2008
6/2008
6/2008
6/2008
7/2008
7/2008
11/2008
B2
B2
B2
B2
B1
B2
B2
B2
B1
B1
B2
B2
7,590,550 B2
7,600,027 B2
2001/0037318 A1
2002/0062218
2002/0152200
2003/0069922
2008/0091801
2009/0094347
A1
A1
A1
A1
A1
Ganesan etal.
Biondi et al.
Ganesan et al.
Arunachalam
Ganesan et al.
Kitchen et al.
Kight et a1.
Russell et a1.
Ganesan et al.
Zielke et al.
Harris et al.
Bales et a1.
9/2009 Schoenberg
10/2009 Yan
11/2001 Lindskog
5/2002 Pianin
WO 00/63781 A1
10/2000
OTHER PUBLICATIONS
WBX036.
Order, Motion to Bifurcate and for early trial on the Issue of Inequi
table Conduct, on Mar. 19, 2009, Dismissal with Prejudice, order
dated Dec. 30, 2009, Denied as Moot, Order Granted, signed by JJF,
CA. No. 08-131 (JJF), Allstate Docket #155.
Order, Motion to Bifurcate and for early trial on the Issue of Inequi
table Conduct, on Mar. 19, 2009, Dismissal with Prejudice, order
dated Dec. 30, 2009, Denied as Moot, CA. No. 08-132 (JJF) andC.A.
No. 08- 133 (JJF) , Dell Docket #155, signed by JJF, Order, Motion to
Bifurcate and for early trial on the Issue of Inequitable Conduct, on
Mar. 19, 2009, Dismissal with Prejudice, order dated Dec. 30, 2009,
Denied as Moot, CA. No. 08-132 (JJF) and CA. No. 08-133 (JJF),
Dell Docket #155.
WBX044.
Conduct (CA. No. 08-132 (JJF) and CA. No. 08-133 (JJF) , is
Granted Plaintiff s Surreply in Opposition to Defendants Motion to
Bifurcate and for Early Trail on, The Issue on Inequitable Conduct is
Motion to Bifurcate, and for Early Trial on, The Issue of Inequitable
Conduct (Entered Dec. 30, 2009), FedeX Docket #212.
Memorandum Opinion C.A. 08-133-JJF, and CA. 08-132-JJF
(Entered Dec. 30, 2009), FedeX Docket #215.
Defendants FedeX Corporation, FedeX Kinkos Of?ce & Print Ser
1996, WBX031.
Docket #217.
US 8,346,894 B2
Page 4
CyberCash Cash Register4Online Secure Payment Service
CashRegister Demos.retrieved May 23, 2001 http://www.webdata.
cybercash.com/demos/pp. 1-2 1996, WBX038.
OnLine,
http://www.virtualschool.edu/mon/ElectronProperty/
Open
Market
Catalog
Centre,Enterprise
ZZZ,WBX069.
Content,/www.
Content
Server?pagename:FutureTense/Apps/Xcelerate/Render&c:Artii
Business Wire, High Beam Wire, Open Market releases ?rst com
plete software solution Oct. 16, 1995, WBX070.
McCloghrie, K. et al. , RFC 1156, Management Information Base
WBX074.
Case, J. et al. , RFC 1442: Structure of Management Information for
Dr. Dobbs Journal, Jun. 6, 1995, vol. 20, No. 6, pp. 70-79,
WBX052b.
WBX076A-E.
5,1995,WBX081.
openmarket.com/cgi-bin/gxcgi/
AppLogic+FTContentServer?pagename:FutureTense/Apps/
Travel Services: Join CompuServe and See the World, Prentice Hall,
1987, WBX065.
WBX066.
nology
Overview,
http://www.microsoft.com/com/wpaper/
US 8,346,894 B2
Page 5
Allstate Uses Web Services to Quickly Create Insurance Policy Man
agement Solution, Microsoft .NET Customer Solution Case Study,
Jan. 2005, WBX098.
Mitchell et al., An Overview of the Spring System, Sun
WBX155.
Microsystems, WBX099.
cgi-bin/gxcgi/
AppLogic+FTContentServer?pagenameIFutureTense/Apps/
WBX160.
cgi-bin/gxcgi/
AppLogic+FTContentServer?pagenameIFutureTense/Apps/
WBX162.
WBX166.
iPIN
openmarket.com/cgi-bin/gx.cgi/AppLogic+FT
ContentServer?pagename:FutureTense/Apps/Xcelerate/Render
&c:Artic, WBX105.
Open Market ShopSite 5.0, Retrieved on May 15, 2001
from:<URLhttp://WWW.openmarket.com/cgi-bin/gX.cgi/
AppLogic+FTCont- entServer?pagename:Future Tense/Apps,
WBX 112.
Technology,
http://WWW.ipin.com/02proditech.html
WBX168A.
BroWser, WBX119.
Peterson, L. et al. , Computer NetWorks, A Systems Approach,
WBX168C.
WBX168E.
1996 ,
WBX135, A, B.
WBX136.
Technical
Staff,The
Conductor
Financial
Services
FrameWor :Distributed Objects on the Internet,Block Financial
1997, WBX174.
OpenStep User Interface Guidelines, SunSoft, 1996, WBX175.
OpenStep Programming Reference, SunSoft, 1996 , (12 parts)
1995WBX137.
WBX176.
WBX177.
Rose, M. et al. , RFC 1065:Structure and Identi?cation of Manage
US 8,346,894 B2
Page 6
Solaris Common Desktop Environment: Programmers Guide,
Sun Microsystems, 1994-1995, WBXl82.
The iPin Approach, http://www.ipin.com/02prod.html, 2000,
[retrieved on May 23, 2001], Interactive Transaction Services, Inc.,
WBX183.
Orfali, R. et al. , The Essential Distributed Objects Survival
search?q:cache:McscjZCZsrEJ:?ndarticles/mifmOEIN/isfl995i
MarciZZZ, WBX231.
Internet Information Commerce:The First Virtual,Jul. l995,lst
useniX.org/publications/library/proceedings/ec9S/fi
ZZZ,WBX232.
OReilly
Releases
Website,WebView,EIT,May
l2,
WBX226.
WBX258.
Retrieved
Apr.
5,
2009
ZZZ,WBX229.
DEC ObjBroker,l.0.9,Apr.
from
http://besser.tsoa.nyu.edi
3,
l996,http://209.85.l73.l32/
1994, WBX014.
ZZZ,WBX230.
NYC-#1579692-vl-WebXchangeiiiMarchi3iDELLiCom
plaint.DOC, Mar. 3, 2008, WBX217.
NYC-#1 57975 l-v l -WebXchangeiiiMarchi3iAllstateiCom
WBX061.
US 8,346,894 B2
Page 7
Wireless Solutions, An Open Market eBusiness Solution Brief,
WhitePaperOpen Market, Forrester Research TechRankings, Feb.
2001, WBX062.
Fraga, J. et al. , A Programming Model for Real-Time Applications
Travel Services: See the World Today the Compuserve Way, 1990,
pp. 409-437, McGraW Hill, WBX128.
Schmidt, D. et al.,Object-Oriented Components for High-Speed
Network Programing, Prcdgs of USENIX Conference on Object
Oriented Technologies, Monterey,CA, Jun. 1995, WBX 129.
Siegel, J ., Common Object Services Speci?cation vol. 1, Rev 1, First
Edition, OMG Doc 94-1-1, Mar. 1, 1994, WBX130A.
Common Desktop Environment: Product Glossary, SunSoft,
1994-1995, WBX131.
Common Desktop Environment: Applications Builder Users
Guide, SunSoft, 1994-1995, WBX132.
* cited by examiner
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 1 0f 13
US 8,346,894 B2
CAR DEALER
WEB SERVER
CAR
DEALER
105
BROWSE
uux
103
101
httpJ/wvmcancom
FIG. 1A (PRIOHAHT)
314
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 2 0f 13
US 8,346,894 B2
2,5.
mw>m;
ozimo290:}?
5o
wOEmhZ
M3
IMImE2oan;
60
m gom
MS.
.uvlri
US. Patent
58
$56 2 8:
Jan. 1, 2013
US 8,346,894 B2
mam
2.52
Sheet 3 0f 13
mow m
Nam
#5 2
N
.mvi
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 4 0f 13
OSI MODEL
/ .329
APPLICATION
E
PRESENTATTON
SESSION
TRANSPORT
NETWORK
DATA LINK
PHYSTCAL
FIG. 3
US 8,346,894 B2
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 6 0f 13
US 8,346,894 B2
U
I
BSER
-I>
TRANSACUONS
BUTTON
WEB PAGE 1%
FIG. 5A
WEB
USER
SERVER
1%
WEB
POINT~OF~
WW
OBJECT
PAGE
SERVICE
SWITCH
ROUTER
APPLICATIONS
51.0
FIG. 5B
529
525
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 7 0f 13
US 8,346,894 B2
POINT-OF- senvzce
APPLICATIONS
- BANK 1
519
__.............___.x9!A'.GE..;w-14
wm semen 113
FIG. 5C
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 8 0f 13
US 8,346,894 B2
5.0A8%.
__--_-I-nmw+--__---_
bw2z3i0omx.
AIM
mm3w>m?w
mum: 9H
.mvhri
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 9 0f 13
US 8,346,894 B2
USER
~~5~
---___ --__.
CAR
DEALER
wsspmeggg
FIG. 5E
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 11 0f 13
US 8,346,894 B2
WEB SERVER
(NODE)
.
123.123.123.123
--------------->
/
OBJECT 1
123.123.123.12
OTHER
OBJECTS
OBJECT 3
123.123.123.1233
OBJECT 2
123.123.123.1232
FIG. 6B
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 12 0f 13
SWH'CHING
SEHWCE
MANAGEMENT
SERVICE
US 8,346,894 B2
VAN SWITCH 5%
BOUNDARY
SEHVECE
APPLlCATiGN
SERVICE
FIG. 7
US. Patent
Jan. 1, 2013
Sheet 13 0f 13
US 8,346,894 B2
802
i
WEB SERVER HANDS OFF
REQUEST TO EXCHANGE
806
swncumeSWITCHES
coworusm
3N EXCHANGE F m
USER TO
SELECTE0 POSVC APPLICATION
T
OBJECT ROUTING COMPONENT
@
FIG. 8