Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
It was during the late 70's that I became interested in the question of the
Collegial Consecration of Russia requested by Our Lady of Fatima. At that time I
was still in the midst of my theological studies in Rome when one of my costudents at the University explained to me an aspect of the Fatima message
that was entirely unknown to me at the time. The student, an engineer from
California who came to Rome to study Philosophy and Theology, had done
extensive reading about Fatima, and it was he who explained to me that Our
Lady of Fatima had requested that the Pope consecrate Russia to the
Immaculate Heart of Mary together with all the bishops.
Previous to that time I had believed that Pope Pius XII had fulfilled Our Lady's
request when he solemnly consecrated Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary
in 1952. I explained to my friend that I had been aware of the fact that Our
Lady of Fatima said in 1917, "In the end, My Immaculate Heart will triumph, the
Pope will consecrate Russia ... and a period of peace will be given to the world."
"Didn't Pius XII fulfill that request? I asked. The engineer from L.A. then told
me about Sister Lucia's Memoirs.
bring about the conversion of Russia, after so many decades of delay, remained
undone.
In the early 1980's I began to read The Fatima Crusader on a regular basis, and
in this manner I learned about the ongoing campaign to bring about the
Consecration of Russia requested by Our Lady of Fatima. With clear, conclusive
and well-reasoned arguments, Father Gruner and his colleagues convincingly
demonstrated the urgent necessity for the Pope to fulfill Our Lady of Fatima's
request for the Consecration of Russia. The Fatima Crusader was making every
effort to persuade those who were ill-informed or misinformed that Our Lady's
request for the consecration of Russia remained as yet unfulfilled.
signed by Sister Lucia, was also dealt with in that article. More of those would
soon appear.1 However, the promoters of the Fatima Consecration Hoax did not
limit themselves to specious arguments and deceptive discourses.
The malicious campaign against Father Gruner and The Fatima
Crusader continued. For this reason I wrote yet another article: The Plot (to
silence Our Lady) Thickens. That article dealt with the scandalous campaign
of defamation that Bishop Luna orchestrated against Father Gruner and The
Fatima Crusader, and the irresponsible journalism of Father Fox.
Fact #1: Sister Lucia gives two versions of the words that Our Lady of Fatima
spoke to her in the apparition of June 13, 1929: a) "The moment has come in
which God asks the Holy Father, in union with all the bishops of the world, to
consecrate Russia to My Immaculate Heart, promising to save it by this means."
b) "The moment has come in which God asks the Holy Father to make, and to
order that in union with him and at the same time, all the bishops of the world
make the consecration of Russia to My Immaculate Heart ..."3
Fact #2: Sister Lucia wrote in a text she gave to Father Goncalves in 1930:
"The Good God promises to make an end of the persecution in Russia if the Holy
Father deigns to make, and orders to be made, by all the bishops of the Catholic
World, a solemn and public act of reparation and consecration of Russia to the
Most Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary and if in return for the end of this
persecution His Holiness promises to approve and recommend the practice of
reparatory devotion (the five first Saturdays)." (See page 405 Memorias E
Cartas Da Irma Lucia)
Fact #3: She wrote in a letter dated June 12, 1930:
"If the Holy Father will himself make a solemn act of reparation and
consecration of Russia ... as well as ordering all the bishops of the Catholic
world to do the same." (See page 411 Memorias E Cartas Da Irma Lucia)
Fact #4: On March 21, 1982, Sister Lucia declared in the presence of the
Apostolic Nuncio to Lisbon, Archbishop Portalupi, the Bishop of Leiria and Dr.
Lacerda that the Pope must select a date on which to order the bishops of the
whole world to make a public and solemn act of reparation and consecration of
Russia to the Most Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary, each in his own cathedral
and at the same time as performed by the Pope.4
Fact #5: On the afternoon of March 19, 1983, the Apostolic Nuncio, Archbishop
Portalupi met with Sister Lucia in order to establish precisely what Sister Lucy
had to say concerning the consecration of the world that the Pope had
performed on May 13, 1982. Besides the Nuncio, two other witnesses were
present, Dr. Lacerda and Father Messias Coelho. Sister Lucia declared that "the
consecration of Russia has not been made as Our Lady has demanded" and she
added, "I could not say so because I did not have the permission of the Holy
See." In that same interview, Sister Lucia explained the reasons why the Holy
Father's 1982 consecration did not fulfill Our Lady of Fatima's request:
a) Russia had not clearly been indicated as the object of the consecration.
b) Each bishop had not made a public and solemn ceremony in his own
cathedral.
Fact #6: The Pope's March 25, 1984, consecration of the world did not clearly
indicate Russia as its object and each bishop did not participate by making a
public and solemn ceremony in his own cathedral. Sister Lucia, therefore, has
www.fatima.org
already stated in 1982 the reasons why the 1984 consecration does not fulfill
Our Lady's request for the consecration of Russia. 5
Fact #7: On July 20, 1987, Sister Lucia stated to Enrique Romero in a
subsequently published interview that the consecration of Russia requested by
Our Lady of Fatima is not yet done.6
Fact #8: In an interview which appeared in the September 1985 issue of Sol
de Fatima, Sister Lucia was asked if the Pope fulfilled the request made by Our
Lady at Tuy when he consecrated the world on March 25, 1984. Sister Lucia
answered: "There was no participation of all the bishops, and there was no
mention of Russia." The interviewer then asked, "So the consecration was not
done as requested by Our Lady?" Sister Lucia answered: "No. Many bishops
attached no importance to this act."
Fact #9: Pope John Paul II on March 25, 1984, after he had consecrated the
world, twice addressed words to Our Lady of Fatima which contained a clear
admission that the Consecration that She requested still remained to be done.
His words, published in the Vatican Newspaper, the Osservatore Romano, were:
"Enlighten especially the peoples of which You Yourself ARE AWAITING our
consecration and confiding."7 Several hours later the Holy Father again
addressed Our Lady of Fatima in St. Peter's Basilica with these words:
"We wished to choose this Sunday for the act of entrusting and consecration of
the world ... of all peoples especially those who have a very great need of this
consecration and entrustment, of those peoples for whom You Yourself ARE
AWAITING our act of consecration." *(See Avvenire March 27, 1984,
page 11)
* Published in the Italian Catholic Bishops Newspaper Avvenire March 27, 1984 on Page 11.
Our Reflections on These Facts
These public utterances of the Holy Father clearly demonstrates that the Pope is
himself aware of the fact that Our Lady of Fatima is still waiting for the
consecration of Russia to be performed.
In Fact #1 we have the Blessed Virgin's own words explaining that God asks
that the Pope order all the Catholic bishops of the world to
consecrate Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary. In Fact #2 and #3 we
have Sister Lucia's handwritten text specifying precisely the same thing as the
Blessed Virgin, namely that the Pope must order all the Catholic bishops of the
world to consecrate Russia. In Fact #4, we have Sister Lucia's official and
public statement explicitly setting forth the very same conditions that she has
been consistently stating for more than fifty years, namely that Our Lady
requires that the Pope order all of the Catholic bishops of the world to
consecrate Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary.
www.fatima.org
On May 13, 1982, the Pope consecrated the world to the Immaculate Heart of
Mary. The evidence in Fact #5 establishes the fact that Sister Lucia, carrying out
her God-given mission to make known to God's ministers His (and Our Lady's)
request, states that the 1982 consecration did not fulfill Our Lady's request
for two reasons:
1. Russia was not clearly indicated as the object of the consecration.
2. Each bishop did not participate in a solemn and public manner.
In 1985 Sister Lucia says that the March 25, 1984, consecration did
NOT fulfill Our Lady's request for the same two reasons. (Fact #8.)
In Fact #9 we have the Pope's own public acknowledgement that the
consecration of Russia requested by Our Lady of Fatima has not yet been done.
It is very strange indeed that Father Fox, when he reproduced the formula of
consecration recited by the Pope on March 25, 1984, deleted this critical
passage from the text.8
www.fatima.org
computer or a typewriter.
Furthermore she told him that
Sister Lucy to this day still
writes letters (even four pages)
to her and others in longhand.
For the significance of this
see "Chronology of a
Coverup" in this issue.
These letters are so ambiguous that one of them was used as evidence in two different
articles: One used it to show that the Consecration of Russia is not yet done while the
other used it to argue that it has already been done. These letters have almost nothing
to say about Fatima, and it can be safely affirmed that their author (whoever he or she
may be) is more concerned with the post-conciliar mania for unity than with Our Lady
of Fatima's request for the Consecration of Russia. That Sister Lucia certainly did not
compose these letters is demonstrated by the fact that they contain gross errors
concerning the history of Fatima which she could not possibly have made.
2.
One must bear in mind that Maria do Fetal has already confessed to having invented
her previous statement about Sister Lucia's pronouncement concerning the
consecration of Russia.
www.fatima.org
3.
Fatima and the Heart of Mary, by Father Antonio Maria Martins, quoted by Frre
Michel de la Sainte Trinit in vol. II of The Whole Truth About Fatima, p.555.
4.
5.
I have presented this and related arguments in my Feb. 1989 article, "Woe to the
Inhabitants of the Earth", Crusader issue no. 27.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10. The letter of Sister Lucia to Father Fox (dated July 3, 1990) is a demonstrable fraud.
Sister Lucia is most certainly not the author of that letter because Sister Lucia certainly
would not have written the outright lie that is stated in that letter. The text of that letter
reads in response to the question, "If the consecration made by Pope John Paul II on
March 25, 1984, in union with all the bishops of the world, accomplished the conditions
for the conversion of Russia according to the request of Our Lady in Tuy on June 13,
of 1929"? The answer to that question reads: "Yes, it was accomplished, and since
then I have said that it was made." The underlined statement is a proven falsehood,
an outright lie. This brazen lie starkly contradicts Sister Lucia's published statements to
the contrary, made after the March 1984 consecration. From 1984 to 1989, published
statements of Sister Lucia consistently maintain that the Consecration of Russia
requested by Our Lady of Fatima has not yet been done. Alleged statements to the
contrary began to emerge only in 1989. The statement also contradicts absolutely
everything that Sister Lucia has written about the Consecration of Russia in the more
than fifty years that she has written on the subject. These facts sufficiently
demonstrate the fraudulent nature of the document in question.
11. The Fatima Crusader, issue no. 30, Winter, 1989.
www.fatima.org