Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
The Lokpal Bill has been referred to the Standing Committee of Parliament on personnel, public grievances, law and
justice. In this FAQ, we explain the process of these committees.
What is the role of such standing committees?
The system of departmentally related standing committees was instituted by Parliament in 1993. Currently, there are 24
such committees, organised on the lines of departments and ministries. For example, there are committees on finance,
home affairs, defence etc. These standing committees examine bills that are referred to them. They also examine the
expenditure plans of ministries in the Union Budget. In addition, they may examine the working of the departments and
various schemes of the government.
How is the membership of these committees decided?
Each committee has 31 members: 21 from Lok Sabha and 10 from Rajya Sabha. Parties are allocated seats based on
their strength in Parliament. The final membership is decided based on the MP's area of interest as well as their party's
decision on allocating the seats.
Who chairs the committees?
Of the 24 committees, 16 are administered by Lok Sabha and eight by Rajya Sabha. The chairperson is from the respective
house. Political parties are allocated chairs based on their strength in Parliament. Some committees such as home affairs,
finance and external affairs are customarily chaired by a senior member of an opposition party.
What will the Standing Committee do with the Lokpal Bill?
The committee has invited comments and suggestions from the public on the bill. Comments can be sent to K P Singh,
Director, Rajya Sabha Secretariat, 201, Second Floor, Parliament House Annexe, New Delhi [ Images ] -110001. These may
also be emailed to kpsingh@sansad.nic.in or rs-cpers@sansad.nic.in. The committee will examine the written
memoranda. They will also invite some experts and stakeholders for oral evidence. Based on its examination, the
committee will prepare a report with its recommendations on the various provisions of the bill. This report will be tabled in
Parliament.
Is the report decided by voting?
No. The committee tries to form a consensus while preparing the report. However, if some members do not agree on any
point, they may add a dissent note. For example, the committee on the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damages Bill had dissent
notes written by MPs from the Left parties. The Women's Reservation Bill also had dissent notes from a couple of
members.
Are the committee's recommendations binding?
No. The committee system was formed recognising that Parliament does not have the time for detailed examination and
public feedback on all bills. Parliament, therefore, delegates this task to the committee which reports back with its
recommendations. It is the role of all MPs in each house of Parliament to examine the recommendations and move
suitable amendments. Following this, Parliament can vote on these amendments, and finalise the bill.
Can you give examples when the committee's work has resulted in significant changes?
There are many such instances. For example, the standing committee on science and technology examined the Civil
Liability for Nuclear Damages Bill. The committee made several recommendations, some of which increased the potential
liability of suppliers of nuclear equipment in case of an accident. All the recommendations were accepted.
Similarly, the Seeds Bill, which is currently pending in Rajya Sabha has seen several major recommendations by the
committee on agriculture. The government has agreed to move amendments that accept many of these recommendations.
Are all bills referred to Standing Committees?
Most bills are referred to such committees but this is not a mandatory requirement before passing a bill. In some cases, if a
bill is not referred to a committee and passed by one house, the other house may constitute a select committee for detailed
examination. Some recent examples include such select committees formed by the Rajya Sabha on the Prevention of
Torture Bill, the Wakf Amendment Bill, and the Commercial Divisions of High Courts Bill. There are also some instances
www.rediff.com/news/column/explained-how-parliament-standing-committees-work/20110822.htm?print=true
1/2
5/23/13
www.rediff.com/news/column/explained-how-parliament-standing-committees-work/20110822.htm?print=true
2/2