Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
During the 1990s, a set of targeted initiatives for local development in the Portuguese
rural areas was developed that encompasses the purpose of revitalization and
rehabilitation of rural settlements, with particular focus on the enhancement of built
vernacular heritage. As part of a broader process, promoting a return to a certain
sometimes symbolic - idea of rurality, these initiatives were based upon the identity
roots as an endogenous valuing factor built upon the idea that heritage is a resource to
consider in the context of economic diversification, associated with the new emerging
dynamics. Among them, the Programme for the Historical Villages emerged as a pilotaction, and along similar lines, the Programme for the Revitalization of Villages in
Algarve tried to implement, in this region, similar strategies, objectives, principles and
good practices of intervention. The creation of the Gabinete Tcnico de Apoio s Aldeias
do Sotavento, [Office for Support of the Villages of Sotavento] (GTAA Sotavento),
offered, in this particular context, a unique opportunity to test a systematic practice of
research, training and technical capability in specific fields of the built vernacular
heritage. This intended to contribute, amongst other things and in particular, to the
required transposition of scale of research in those fields: from the macro, a more
generic and territorial scale which the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal
represents to the micro, a more specific, local and particular scale, essential to support
the practice of design and intervention in those areas. This article thus seeks to integrate
the practice of research undertaken by the GTAA Sotavento, in the generic context in
which the Survey, operates and to demonstrate its importance to the development of
its project-oriented practice, in order to contribute to the discussion and definition of
good practice models for intervention in rural areas and nuclei.
Keywords: Built vernacular heritage, regional architecture, survey, rural areas, GTAA
Sotavento
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
1.
vernacular architecture (Leal, 2009: 42) that both distanced itself from the
lovely little houses of Raul Lino, as well as the hovels of the Rural Housing
Survey3 (Idem: 19, 29);
(iii) A portrait of a world about to disappear, on the last possible moment
and in all its fullness (Pereira, 1987: IX), given the transformations that the
Portuguese rural areas would suffer over the next two decades;
(iv) One of the "four key moments in the constitution of a field of reflection
on vernacular architecture in Portugal" (Leal, 2009: 14), indicating, according to
Alves Costa (1995: 60), the very birth of Portuguese architecture.
Launched with a purpose that escaped (or was cleverly disguised from) the
political regime of the day - to break down definitively the morpho-typological
unity thesis of the Casa Portuguesa (Portuguese house) and the architectural lie
which (Tvora, 1947: 8) it presided over - and carried out by a group of young
Cf. the first article of Decreto-Lei n 40 349, the document that determines the commitment of
governmental project funding (Amaral, 1961: p. XIV).
Free translation of Inqurito Habitao Rural (Basto & Barros, 1943 & Barros, 1948).
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
Regarding this point, cf. the definition of vernacular building stated in the Charter on Built
Vernacular Heritage (ICOMOS, 1999).
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
necessary scale transposition, that is, from the national and territorial scale of
the Survey, to the local scale5.
Similarly, there has been a failure to develop an analogous study on urban
architecture, i.e. a study of the citys architecti-morpho-typological character. A
survey - of similar or even greater breadth and of the decisive (current) need to
support the rehabilitation of our urban heritage - on the premodern urban
building, that would provide multiple correlations with the Survey.
Although, in the eyes of the less understanding or those hastier in their analysis,
the Survey may have been (or still is) perceived as the last word on the
Portuguese vernacular architecture, there are more doors left open than those
which are closed.
Indeed, as Francisco Silva Dias, one of the Zone 4 team members, recognizes in
a recent interview (Villas Boas, 2011), the Survey reflects essentially a macro
analysis, necessarily generic (given the limitations of the project) and rather
more concerned about setting out the singularities of the events - and their
correspondence to the criteria of architectural modernism 6 - than its constancy,
quantity or actual relevance.
At that, despite its importance in breaking the hegemony of the Casa
Portuguesa, as well as - upon his death (Alves Costa, 1995: 60) - the
"institutionalization of vernacular architecture as a field with its own autonomy"
(Leal, 2009: 61), the Survey far from exhausts the possibilities of developing
more detailed studies. Studies that would have allowed the progression to a
second scale, a more thorough and systematic7 one, which the Survey infers
but fails to carry out.
However, as no action is well founded whether that action be restoration,
preservation or even necessary transformation - that is not supported upon a
5
An omission that, already in 1979, the Directorate of the then Portuguese Architects Association
lamented in the 2nd editions preface of the publication (Cf. Dias, 1979: XII).
As Fernando Tvora and Nuno Teotnio Pereira, the team leaders for Zones 1 and 4, admitted
(Leal, 2009: 42, 48).
In other words, the "detailed scientific inventories" recommended by the Council of Europe (CE)
(1989: 2).
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
broad knowledge of the territory within which it is carried out, needless to say
that the absence of these detailed studies has resulted in the following negative
effects, which are easy to observe.
Firstly, by allowing the Survey, without this additional degree of study and
analysis, to become a sort of catalog, a brochure or a manual (wherein the scale
is of very little operative approach, as is also far from its authors intentions),
leading to the emergence of caricatural generalizations 8 - precisely one of the
most criticized aspects in the Casa Portuguesas formulary.
And, secondly, by contributing to the breakdown in constructive traditions 9,
allowing this breakdown to be stronger and more traumatic (in terms of heritage
safeguard) than would be supposed or should have been.
However, determining the conditions that created "our old or popular houses"
and to study "the ways in which materials were employed and met the needs of
the moment" (Tvora: 1947: 11), or "to know how the Portuguese eat and
sleep, learn their building techniques and their ways of comprehending the
space, retrieve the history of architecture [and] combine fine architecture with
popular tradition" - which was what the Survey was all about (Alves Costa
1995: 61-62) -, required a much greater depth of study and analysis.
It required this micro scale of research, which did not fit the purposes of the
Survey but the very nature of vernacular architecture10 could not dispense with
in the intergenerational knowledge transmission process. Because, being those
constructive traditions breaking down 11, that micro study would have allowed
the recording and preservation of the links between modernity and tradition, and
would have established the above referred mediation.
8
That the leaflets distributed by the weekly Expresso, not long ago, under the name Casas do
Norte, Casas do Sul e Casas das Ilhas, are one of the most recent examples Cf.
http://expresso.sapo.pt/casas_tradicionais_portuguesas=f501518.
Something that the life conditions associated with rural housing so urgently required, as had
already been reported in the Rural Housing Survey (Basto & Barros, 1943 and Barros, 1948)
and other studies including those carried out within ethnology.
10
Vernacular building is the traditional and natural way by which communities house themselves.
It is a continuing process including necessary changes and continuous adaptation as a response
to social and environmental constraints (ICOMOS, 1999).
11
Something that is evident in the difficulty that is now to found, in some areas of the country,
companies, masters of works or skilled and experienced workers in the old arts of building.
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
This required scale transposition bases itself, in our opinion, in five fundamental
principles, the first of which is a, purely, academic need for greater depth to the
analysis.
Secondly, this transposition is, in itself, an act of producing history, setting
elements and essential aspects of our architectural and constructive culture in
their own place (which it has been, somehow, denied) in the history of
Portuguese architecture. Because a culture without the presence of its history is
a culture without roots and, very possibly, without meaning (Oliver, 2006: 25),
but also because History, as a tool to serve the project, can help solve the
problems of the present (Tvora, 1947: 7).
Thirdly, this
transposition
is
justified in
supporting a
strategy
for the
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
moment that the urban growth processes are showing signs of exhaustion, a
certain return to the countryside begins to be spoken about and increases the
ecological concerns. A state of the current situation that would allow the
identification leading to a better understanding of the changes that have
occurred and their determining power lines; the urgency, opportunity and ability
to safeguard what remains; as well as its importance for the refunding of this
knowledge within the discourse of sustainability, and to draw the paths to the
future.
2.
The
rediscovery
of
rurality
and
the
programmes
for
the
revitalization of villages
Carried out in a moment that would prove pivotal in the history of Portuguese
architecture, given, as stated above, the changes which occurred over the next
two decades, the importance given to the vernacular architecture that
accompanies the Survey reflects the process of patrimonialization of a whole
set of human ingenuity and culture manifestations hitherto considered minor.
This process of patrimonialization12 departs not only from the recognition of its
importance and value, but also the awareness of the need for registration and
safeguard in view of the deruralization process that intensified in Western
societies, particularly Europe, in the postwar period.
Effort
that
will
essentially
translate
into
spontaneous
movement
of
(re)discovery and return to the countryside by those who never lived there, and
only kept the idyllic image of postcards and a certain nostalgia for the lost roots
of their identity; as well as into the launch of a series of actions planned and led
or driven by European policies for local and/or rural development and supported
by Community funding.
12
Which can be fitted in what Franoise Choay (2003: 183-184) calls "ecumenical expansion" of
the concept of heritage. Cf. documents such as, and among others, the European Charter of
the Architectural Heritage (CE, 1975); the Recommendation concerning the Safeguarding and
Contemporary Role of Historic Areas (UNESCO, Nairobi, 1976); the Granada Appeal on Rural
Architecture and Regional Planning (CE, 1977); the Tlaxcala Declaration on the Revitalization of
Small Settlements (ICOMOS, 1982); the Recommendation No. R (89) 6 on the protection and
enhancement of the rural architectural heritage (CE, 1989); the Recommendation on the
Safeguarding of Traditional Culture and Folklore (UNESCO, 1989); the Recommendation No. R
(95) 9 on the integrated conservation of cultural landscape areas as part of landscape policies
(CE, 1995); and the Charter on the Built Vernacular Heritage (ICOMOS, 1999).
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
13
We are referring specifically to the installation, in some villages and rural areas, of foreign
citizen heirs, for the most part, of the liberation and environmentalist movements developed in
many European countries along the 60s and 70s of last century and looking for a new
philosophy of life more connected to nature.
14
Considered essential in view of 'failure' of the model, which had hitherto prevailed, based on
subsistence agriculture.
15
That one can match to the 60s, 70s and 80s of last century.
16
Who see them as a symbol of the poor living conditions that they intended to overcome and
forget.
17
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
Among these misconceptions emerges the absence of, either a critical reflection
on the relevance of respect for tradition and the limits of modernity, or a proper
and informed basis for the choices made which can only be supported on the
knowledge of existing reality, knowledge for which that transposition of scale
was (is) essential. Though it may have allowed, in some cases, to bring out new
perspectives and approaches, in many others, unfortunately, either it did not
translate into concrete, structural and lasting actions, or, even involuntarily,
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
gave way to the culture of pastiche18, none of them considers the importance of
proceeding, in advance, of such research and critical reflection 19.
3.
these
two
offices
consisted
of
multidisciplinary
technical
18
Even though often well-intentioned and supported in a reading, although superficial, of the
Survey. Where underscores, once again, the relevance of more detailed studies, as well as a
more thorough critical reflection on the limits and scope of the concepts of restoration,
conservation, rehabilitation and renewal and the possibilities of mediation between modernity
and tradition.
19
Being fair, however, to acknowledge that the execution times associated with these
programmes and the 'need' to do works (under the risk of loss of funding) also hardly would
allow it.
20
21
Comisso de Coordenao
Coordination Comission).
22
Desenvolvimento
Regional
(Regional
Development
and
10
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
23
11
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
Finally, throughout the programme, such action would result in the further
development
of technical projects
relating to
objectives
defined in
the
12
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
projects. This way, the office sought, through its incorporation into all projects,
to induce demonstrable effects that could lead to the awakening of that
forgotten knowledge and its associated practices, revealing their importance in
the affirmation of local identity.
The use of these traditional materials and construction techniques took place
either in interventions in existing vernacular structures, or in new construction
resorting to new architectural languages and models, always trying to establish
13
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
Among these actions, we would highlight the seminar, the workshop and the
video produced (GTAA Sotavento, 2007a, 2007b, 2007c) as well as the two
24
Recalling in this regard that, as stated by Franoise Choay "to renew living spaces with the
competence to articulate that, over the millennia, contributed with the same movement to set
men to natural environment, and make them always restart the institution of their community,
is a valid option"(Choay, 2006: 224).
25
14
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
edited books (Ribeiro, 2008a, 2008b), which, in any case, departed the
recognition of the importance, due to the singularity of vernacular architecture,
of the adoption of specific approaches, both as regards their study, both with
regard to the technical education 26. Approaches considered essential in the
process of assets valuation as a prime factor of local development and without
which it is difficult to continue the vernacular architectural manifestations in
contemporary practice, even if reinterpreted and incorporated into new
architectural languages.
In this context27, the publication of that book (Ribeiro, 2008b) espoused two
distinct but complementary purposes: firstly, (i) the fulfillment of a proposed
action centered upon the Intervention Plans; and secondly, and above all, (ii)
the accomplishment of a research, investigation and survey programme,
essential for understanding the area of action, which followed the development
of the offices project practice.
The final product of a seven year programme, this publication was regarded by
the GTAA as one of its most important works. Important as an educational tool;
important as the means of transmission to future generations of the inheritance
(heritage) bequeathed to us by our ancestors; but also important for the
opportunity to assess the validity of the generalizations associated with the
Survey and to go beyond them (and the Survey itself) as far as possible.
4.
Final Thoughts
26
In which context is included the provision of courses, within the specialist training system, for
architects, town planners, conservation personnel and construction technicians on: traditional
building materials and techniques; the durability of such materials and their possible
combination with modern materials; the cost of such traditional techniques and the conditions
regarding their present-day use or their replacement by modern techniques and materials (CE,
1989: 3), as also determines the Charter on the Built Vernacular Heritage (ICOMOS, 1999).
27
Being conscious that a conservation policy "as part of a planning policy, is only possible if there
is an inventory of properties to safeguard" (CE, 1977) and that the safeguarding of collective
memory also depends on the development of heritage researching and identifying instruments
(CE, 1989).
15
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
micro, which the purposes associated with the Survey did not allow for, but
which remain, largely, unfulfilled.
In order to progress these purposes today it is, therefore, crucial to: (i) return to
the sites of the Survey and try to understand, to learn, the transformation
process; (ii) undertake the completion of the Survey, through the production
of systematic and local atlases; and (iii) establish shared information systems
(an online supported database for example) on local construction practices and
their relationships with other disciplines (history, ethnology, anthropology).
On the other hand, and founded upon the first phase of implementation of the
programmes for the revitalization of villages, what is also demanded is: (i) the
provision of systematic information concerning these initiatives, distinguishing
them in their purposes, types, problems, difficulties, contradictions and results;
(ii) the analysis and discussion of their interventions in the light of the principles,
concepts and practices of rehabilitation; (iii) the confirmation of the relevance of
different approaches to the problematic nature of interventions in rural areas
and nuclei and define its scope; and (iv) the demonstration of the applicability of
an intervention model that views the specifics of its scale and territorial scope
seeking to sustain the design of an array of good methodological practices of
urban and architectural intervention in rural areas and the built rural heritage.
This last set of purposes is precisely the main aims of the research we undertake
and within which falls the present contribution.
16
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
Acknowledgments
To all the GTAA Sotaventos team members, in the same or different periods,
from June 2001 to December 2007 - Adlia Salvador, Alexandre Costa, ngela
Santos, Fbio Cabrita, Marta Almeida, Marta Gonalves, Marta Santos, Paulo
Silva, Pedro Ferreira, Rui Pereira, Slvia Bento, Slvia Caiado and Stefano
Malobbia - as well as to Carla Azinheira, Eugnia Teixeira and Lus Loures who
have done their degree practice with the team.
With special thanks to Stewart Seaton, who kindly revised the English version of
this paper.
This paper is funded by FCT Fundao para a Cincia e Tecnologia within the
Individual Doctoral Grant SFRH/BD/76299/2011.
This paper integrates the FCT Research and Development Project LIMECONTECH
- Conservation and durability of historical renders: compatible techniques and
materials (FCT: PTDC/ECM/100234/2008).
References
Alves Costa, A. (1995). Introduo ao Estudo da Histria da Arquitectura
Portuguesa: Outros Textos Sobre Arquitectura Portuguesa. Srie 2. Argumentos.
Porto: FAUP.
Amaral, F.K. do [et. al.] (2004 [1961]). Arquitectura Popular em Portugal. 4
Ed. Lisboa: Ordem dos Arquitectos. 2 Volumes.
Barros, H. de (1948). Inqurito Habitao Rural. Vol. 2.
Basto, E. A.de L., & Barros, H. de (1943). Inqurito Habitao Rural. Vol. 1.
Choay, F. (2006). A alegoria do patrimnio. Lisboa: Edies 70.
Conselho da Europa (1977). Apelo de Granada sobre a Arquitectura Rural e o
Ordenamento do Territrio. In LOPES, F., & CORREIA, M. B. (2004). Patrimnio
Arquitectnico e Arqueolgico. Cartas, Recomendaes e Convenes
Internacionais. Lisboa: Livros Horizonte.
17
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
18
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
19
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
20
Surveys on Vernacular Architecture. Their Significance in the 20th Century Architectural Culture
Conference Proceedings. Oporto, May 17-19, 2012
21
Vtor Ribeiro, Jos Aguiar, Miguel Reimo Costa, From the Survey on Regional Architecture in Portugal to
the local applied research.
22