Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN - 0974-2441
ResearchArticle
INFLUENCEOFPOSTDISCHARGECOUNSELLINGONHEALTHOUTCOMES
INDIABETICANDHYPERTENSIVEPATIENTS
RAMESHADEPU*ANDMADHUS
DepartmentofPharmacyPractice,JSSCollegeofPharmacySSNagar,Mysore15,IndiaEmail:adepu63@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
HypertensionandDiabetesmellitusarethechronicdisordersthataffectthepatientsqualityoflife.Diseasesandmedicationrelatedinformation
empowerspatientstoadoptpositivelifestylesthathelpinimprovinghealthoutcomesandthequalityoflife.Aprospective,randomisedstudywas
conducted to assess the impact of post discharge counselling on health outcomes in diabetic and hypertensive patients. A total of 158 patients
meetingtheinclusioncriteriawereenrolledandrandomizedintocontrolandtestgroups.Testgrouppatientsreceivedcounselingatdischargeand
inthesubsequentfollowups.Ateachfollowup,bloodpressure(BP)andcapillarybloodglucose(CBG)wererecorded.Healthrelatedqualityoflife
wasassessedusingsuitablequestionnairesatbaselineandeveryfollowup.Astatisticallysignificant(p<0.05)improvementinHRQoLwasobserved
inhypertension(HTN),diabetes(DM)andHTN+DMtestgrouppatients.Alsoabetterimprovementingoalbloodpressureandgoalcapillaryblood
glucose(p>0.05)wasobservedintestgrouppatientscomparedtothecontrolgrouppatients.Pharmacistprovidedpostdischargecounsellinghas
shownpositiveimpactontherapeuticoutcomesandhealthrelatedqualityoflife.
Keywords:Diabetes;Hypertension;HealthRelatedQualityofLife,Counselling,TherapeuticOutcomes.
INTRODUCTION
Adepuetal.
AsianJPharmClinRes,Vol4,Issue3,2011,2833
(HTN) or patients having both clinical disorders (HTN +DM) were
enrolledintothestudyaftergettingtheirwritteninformedconsent.
RESULTS
A total of 158 patients were enrolled into in to the study. Out of
them 154 patients completed all the study follow ups and 04
patientswereconsideredasdropoutbecauseofthemissedfollow
ups. The mean age of the enrolled patients was 53.04 years. No
significantdifferencewasfoundbetweentheageandgenderamong
the enrolled patients. Demographic details of the enrolled patients,
treatmentdetailsarepresentedintable1.Reductioninbothsystolic
and diastolic blood pressure from baseline and in three successive
follow ups was comparatively improved in test group patients
compared to the control group patients. However, these changes
were found statistically non significant. Influence of post discharge
counselling on blood pressure in Hypertension (HTN) group
patientsisshowninfigureNo.1.
InfluenceofEducationonQualityoflifeinDMpatientsandDM+
HTNpatients
The mean scores of the health and functional subscale, social and
economic subscale, psychological and spiritual subscale and family
subscale revealed better improvement in the HRQoL of the test
grouppatientswhencomparedtocontrolgrouppatients.Themean
scores of overall quality of life were also improved in test group
patientsthancontrolgrouppatientsfromfirstfollowuptothefinal
followup.Themeanscoresarepresentedintables4and5.
Table1:Demographicdetailsofthestudysubjects
AgeNumberPercentage
30 40
12
7.59
4150
5160
44
80
27.84
50.63
>60
22
13.92
Gender
DMC
16
Male
DMT
15
10.12
09.49
InfluenceofpostdischargecounsellingonQualityofLifeinHTN
PatientsandHTN+DMpatients
DM+HTNC
13
08.22
DM+HTNT
16
10.12
HTNC
11
06.96
HTNT
16
10.12
The test group patients with hypertension alone and with both
hypertension and type 2 diabetes mellitus showed better
improvement in the mean scores of depressed mood subscale,
positive well being subscale, self control subscale, general health
subscale, vitality subscale when compared to the control group
patients.Hence,theoverall qualityoflifeofthetestgroup patients
was better than the control group patients in both the follow ups.
Thechangesinmeanscoresbetweentestandcontrolwerefoundto
bestatisticallysignificantinboththefollowups.Themeanscoresof
allthesubscalesarepresentedintable2and3.
Influence of post discharge counselling on CBG values in DM
patients
Female
DMC
09
05.69
DMT
14
08.86
DM+HTNC
12
07.59
DM+HTNT
12
07.59
HTNC
13
08.22
HTNT
11
06.96
Education
University
13
08.22
PUC
21
13.29
Secondaryschool
28
17.72
PrimarySchool
54
34.17
Illiterates
42
EmploymentStatus
26.58
Employed
37
23.41
ChangesintheCBGvaluesweresignificantbetweentheDMtestand
the control group. In test group, the baseline mean values of CBG
were found to be 165.23, which were reduced to 143.69 at first
follow up, 133.38 and 121.54 in second and in third follow ups
respectively. Whereas in control group, the reduction in mean CBG
values was observed from baseline to second follow up. But the
elevationwasfoundfromsecondfollowuptofinalfollowup.Thisis
showninfigure2.
Unemployed
29
18.35
Housewife
58
36.70
Retired
11
06.96
Business
23
14.55
AlcoholHistory
Alcoholic
12
07.59
NonAlcoholic
136
86.07
PastAlcoholic
07
04.43
SocialAlcoholic
03
01.89
SmokingHistory
NonSmoker
156
98.74
Smoker
02
01.26
29
Adepuetal.
AsianJPharmClinRes,Vol4,Issue3,2011,2833
Anxiety
SD
Table2:HTNQualityofLifeScoresHTNgroup
Positivewell
Selfcontrol
Depressed
General
mood
being
Health
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
Vitality
Overallquality
oflife
Mean
SD
1stFollowup
Mean
Test
Control
Significance
FinalFollow
up
Test
Control
Significance
13.18 2.18
16.39 23.1
P<0.05
Mean
SD
9.59
2.29
7.34
2.05
P<0.05
Mean
SD
10.22 2.81
08.34
2.34
P<0.05
Mean
SD
8.85
2.03
6.95
2.34
P<0.05
Mean
SD
9.40
2.69
7.69
2.38
P<0.05
Mean
SD
12.62 3.06
10.43 2.19
P<0.05
Mean
SD
64.22
5.28
52.47
6.12
P<0.05
Mean
SD
15.81 2.33
14.17 2.46
P<0.05
11.88
1.36
07.39
1.90
P<0.05
13.44 2.80
8.60
2.51
P<0.05
11.74 2.03
7.17
2.42
P<0.05
11.59 2.17
8.00
2.50
P<0.05
15.40 2.39
10.43 2.35
P<0.05
79.25
6.78
52.78
6.16
P<0.05
(Significancep0.05)Legends:SDStandardDeviation,QOLQualityoflife,HTNHypertension
Table3:HTNQualityofLifeScoresHTN+DMgroup
Anxiety
Depressed
Positivewell
Selfcontrol
General
mood
being
Health
1stFollowup Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Test
Control
Significance
FinalFollow
up
Test
Control
Significance
SD
Vitality
Mean
SD
Overallquality
oflife
Mean
SD
12.57 1.64
11.34 2.08
P<0.05
Mean
SD
8.95
1.60
8.67
1.80
P<0.05
Mean
SD
9.56
2.04
9.46
2.74
P<0.05
Mean
SD
8.47
1.34
7.85
2.49
P<0.05
Mean
SD
9.04
1.52
8.53
2.47
P<0.05
Mean
SD
11.17
1.4
11.03 2.97
P<0.05
Mean
SD
57.67 11.58
58.57
5.87
P<0.05
Mean
SD
15.35 1.68
11.13 1.91
P<0.05
11.25
1.29
8.69
1.45
P<0.05
12.71 1.94
9.47
2.10
P<0.05
10.64 1.85
8.43
1.44
P<0.05
11.53 1.85
9.04
1.77
P<0.05
14.35 1.78
10.78 1.24
P<0.05
75.07
6.7
57.13
6.68
P<0.05
Legends:DMDiabetesMellitus,HTNHypertension,CControl,TTest,SDStandardDeviation
FirstFollowup
Health
and
Functioning
subscale
Mean
SD
Table4:DMQualityofLifescoresDMgroup
Social
and Psychological/
Familysubscale
Economic
Spiritualsubscale
subscale
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Test
Control
Significance
FinalFollowup
17.84
16.79
P<0.05
Mean
0.93
0.81
17.94
16.90
P<0.05
Mean
18.01
16.99
P<0.05
Mean
0.83
0.79
Test
Control
Significance
20.47
15.76
P<0.05
0.83
1.17
20.35
15.95
P<0.05
1.75
1.11
SD
0.89
0.90
SD
20.54
0.81
15.84
1.13
P<0.05
18.00
16.79
P<0.05
Mean
0.84
0.86
20.56
15.93
P<0.05
0.85
1.2
SD
17.97
17.01
P<0.05
Mean
0.79
0.73
SD
20.51
0.91
15.85
1.20
P<0.05
Overall quality of
Life
SD
FirstFollowup
Table5:DMQualityofLifeScoresDM+HTNgroup:
Health
and Social
and Psychological/
Familysubscale
Functioning
Economic
Spiritualsubscale
subscale
subscale
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Mean
SD
Test
Control
Significance
FinalFollowup
17.52
16.71
P<0.05
Mean
0.93
0.81
17.47
16.95
P<0.05
Mean
0.85
0.66
Test
Control
Significance
19.84
15.89
P<0.05
0.76
0.82
19.95
16.05
P<0.05
0.76
0.82
SD
17.28
16.78
P<0.05
Mean
0.84
0.67
SD
19.83
0.72
15.94
0.83
P<0.05
17.34
16.81
P<0.05
Mean
0.90
0.69
19.88
15.96
P<0.05
0.73
0.84
SD
Legends:DMDiabetesMellitus,HTNHypertension,SDStandardDeviation
17.37
16.80
P<0.05
Mean
0.88
0.69
SD
19.82
0.72
16.06
0.86
P<0.05
Overall quality of
Life
SD
30
Adepuetal.
AsianJPharmClinRes,Vol4,Issue3,2011,2833
Fig.4:ComparisonofchangesinCBGinDM+HTNpatients
Legends: DMT=Diabetes MellitusTest, DMC= Diabetes Mellitus
Control,BSL= Baseline,FU1=Followup 1,FU2= Followup 2,FFU=
FinalFollowup
DISCUSSION
Many studies suggest that, pharmacists can play an important role
byprovidingthecounselling,whichhasshownapositiveimpacton
health care and decreases the mortality and morbidity 19.
Hypertension and Diabetes are the common chronic disorders
wherethepatientreportslowerqualityoflifethanthepatientswith
acuteconditions.Thisstudyevaluatedtheimpactofpostdischarge
counselling on health outcomes in patients with diabetes,
hypertensionorbothdiabetesandhypertension.
Influence of Education on Blood Pressure and capillary blood
glucoseinstudypatients
Oneofthemainobjectivesofthestudywastomeasuretheimpactof
post discharge counselling on blood pressure in the hypertensive
patients and glycemic control in type 2 diabetes mellitus patients.
ThemeanbloodpressurevaluesandmeanCBGvaluessuggeststhat
thebloodpressureandglycemiccontrolwasbettercontrolledinthe
test group compared to control group from baseline to final follow
up.
Fig.2:ComparisonofchangesintheCBGvaluesinDMpatients.
Legends: DM=Diabetes Mellitus=Test, C=Control, BSL= Baseline,
FU1=Followup1,FU2=Followup2,FFU=FinalFollowup
31
Adepuetal.
AsianJPharmClinRes,Vol4,Issue3,2011,2833
with hypertension and diabetes mellitus, achieving goal blood
pressureistheimportantclinicaloutcome.
Influence of Education on quality of life in study patients with
Hypertension.
ThepsychologicalGeneralWellBeingIndex(PGWBI),agenericQoL
questionnaire was administered to the hypertensive patients in
order to measure their quality of life in previous month. This
questionnaire contains 22 questions and composed of six separate
subscales: anxiety subscale (five questions), depressed mood
subscale (three questions), positive well being sub scale (four
questions), self control subscale (three questions), general health
subscale (three questions) and vitality subscale (four questions). It
hasa6pointlikertscalefrom0to5points.
Anincreaseinthequalityoflifescoreindicatesanimprovementin
thequalityoflife.ScoresofvarioussubscalesofthePGWBIsuchas
anxiety, depressed mood, positive well being, self control, general
health,vitality.
OverallQualityofLife:Overallqualityoflifeisthecombinationof
scores in all the subscales. The test group patients showed
significant improvement in all the six subscales, which in turn has
influenced constructively on the overall quality of life in the
hypertensivetestgrouppatients.
In a review conducted by Coyne KS et al to assess the impact of
antihypertensive therapy on the HRQoL in hypertensive patients
suggestedthatpropereducationfoundverymuchusefultoimprove
theHRQoLinthehypertensivepatients25.
InananotherstudyconductedbyVivianEMtoassessthetreatment
outcomesinhypertensivepatientsshowedtheimprovementinthe
health related quality of life in the patients with pharmacist
providededucation24.
InastudyconductedbyCarvalhoSandNagaviB.G.in2006,tostudy
the influence of pharmacist provided education on health related
quality of life has shown a significant improvement in the overall
QoL scores. This improvement can be attributed to the improved
medicationadherencebehaviourintestgrouppatients26.
These studies demonstrated the influence of pharmacist provided
patient counselling on therapeutic outcomes and overall quality of
life.
Hence,inordertoimprovethetherapeuticoutcomesandtheHRQL
of HTN and DM patients, the proper education about the disease,
medicationusageandlifestylemodificationsareveryessential.The
present study has shown that the pharmacist provided education
can improve the patients therapeutic outcomes such as achieving
goal blood pressure and goal blood glucose levels, also the overall
HRQoL.
CONCLUSION
The study findings conclude that the structured post discharge
counselling showed a positive impact on health outcomes such as
glycemic control and blood pressure control and health related
qualityoflifeintestgrouppatientsinboththedisorderscompared
tocontrolgrouppatients.
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
AssessmentofqualityoflifeinstudypatientswithDM
Ferrans and Powers diabetic specific questionnaire was used to
assessthehealthrelated qualityoflifeinthediabeticpatients.The
questionnaire contains satisfaction part and importance part. Four
differentsubscalesarepresentinbothparts.Healthandfunctioning
subscale contains 14 questions, social and economic subscale
contains8questionspsychologicalandspiritualsubscalecontains7
questionsandfamilysubscalecontains5questions.Allthesubscales
ofthequalityoflifeinstrumentwereaffectedindiabetespatientsof
boththestudygroups.
10.
11.
12.
13.
OverallQualityofLife:
Theoverallimprovementwasseeninqualityoflifescore,whichisa
subtotal of the four subscales of the QLI instrument. Continuous
education and better medication and life style adherence has
improvedthepatientshealth,functioningcapacity,theirfamilyand
social relationship, psychological and spiritual aspects, and
ultimatelytheiroverallqualityoflifeintestgroup.
The similar study was conducted by R Adepu et al to evaluate the
health related quality of life in type 2 diabetes mellitus patients,
which showed the pharmacist provided counselling improved the
overallqualityoflifeindiabeticpatientsintestgroup 22.
In a study conducted by Arun KP et al to evaluate the impact of
pharmaceutical care on the clinical outcomes in diabetes mellitus
patients, the influence of pharmaceutical care showed significant
improvementinHRQoLindiabetespatientsinruralIndia27.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
32
Adepuetal.
AsianJPharmClinRes,Vol4,Issue3,2011,2833
19.
20.
21.
22.
23. VivianEM.Improvingbloodpressureinapharmacistmanaged
hypertension clinic. Pharmacotherapy. 2002;22(12):1533
1540
24. CoyneKS,DavisD,FrenchF,HillMN.Healthrelatedqualityof
Life in patients treated for Hypertension. A review of the
literaturefrom1999to2000.ClinTher.2002;24(1):14269
25. Carvalho S, Nagavi BG. Impact of community pharmacy based
patienteducationonthequalityoflifeofhypertensivepatients.
IndianJPharmEduRes2007;41(2)AprJun:164169
26. ArunKP,MuruganR,RajeshKannaM,RajalakshmiS,Kalaiselvi
R,KomathiV.Theimpactofpharmaceuticalcareontheclinical
outcomeofdiabetesmellitusamongaruralpatientpopulation.
IntJDiabCtries.2008;28(1):1518
33