Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
www.sportkon.com
PROFESSIONAL PAPER
PROFESSIONAL PAPER
STRUNI LANAK
doi: 10.5550/SP.2.2010.37
UDK: 796.015.52
STRUNI LANAK
COBISS.BH-ID: 2261272
Summary
Saetak
Strength training as an integral part of the strength and conditioning is one of the most covered themes in todays scientific and professional literature. Impacts of different systems
of training in the field of strength training can be relatively
easy measured and accurately analyzed. Through scientific
research and training practice, periodized training proved to
be more effective than non-periodized in trained subjects.
Despite the large number of scientific papers of periodization,
there are only a few direct comparative studies dealing with
the efficiency of different patterns in periodization of strength
training. Smooth linear variant of periodization is characterized by gradual continuous increase in the intensity of training stimulus. Block pattern is characterized by a sudden drop
in volume and increase intensity of training load on the
transition between blocks. Undulating variants are distinguished
by daily or weekly changes in the intensity of training stimulus. The selection of appropriate periodization patters is made
according to the training goal, sport discipline and training
experience of athletes. Question of the efficiency of different
periodization variants still remains open for the future research.
Introduction
Uvod
304
Diskusije o efikasnosti periodizacije, u velikoj meri su prouzrokovane kori{enjem razliitih obrazaca periodizacije,
koliinom varijabilnosti u okviru svakog modela, trajanjem
istraivanja kao i iskustvom sportista koji su uestvovali u
istraivanjima (Wilks, 1995). Iz tog razloga, isti autor navodi:
"Umesto kori{enja uop{tenog termina periodizirani trening
snage, treneri i istraivai bi trebali da ubudue precizno
oznae koju varijantu ili obrazac periodizacije treninga
snage koriste u svom treningu".
Jedna od retkih organizacija koja je za potrebe prakse napravila jedinstvenu sistematizaciju varijanti periodizacije
treninga snage je Australijska asocijacija kondicijskih trenera (ASCA Australian strength and conditioning association).
S tim u vezi, cilj ovog rada bila je analiza naje{ih varijanti periodizacije treninga snage koje se sreu u dana{njoj
teoriji i praksi u skladu sa ASCA nomenklaturom.
Discussion
Diskusija
Problem komparativnih istraivanja u kojima se poredi nekoliko obrazaca periodizacije treninga snage, veoma je izraen u dana{njoj teoriji i praksi sporta. I pored velikog broja
naunih radova, u dostupnoj literturi, u kojima se pi{e o
periodizaciji, postoji relativno mali broj istraivanja (Baker,
Wilson i Carlyon, 1994; Buford i saradnici, 2007; Prestes i
saradnici, 2009; Rhea i saradnici, 2002) koja su direktno
poredila efekte razliitih obrazaca periodizacije treninga
snage.
PROFESSIONAL PAPER
STRUNI LANAK
Slika 1: Blaga linearna varijanta intenzifikacije trenanog optereenja u trajanju od 12 nedelja (modifikovano prema Baker, 2007)
Figure 1: A smooth linear variant of training load intensification for 12 weeks period (modified according to Baker, 2007)
305
intenziteta trenanog stimulusa (npr. 5% od 1RM svake nedelje). Iako je ovaj obrazac (Slika 1) oznaen kao linearan intenzitet i obim u okviru jedne nedelje mogu da se menjaju nelinearno (Ibid).
Smatra se da je ovakva varijanta najpogodnija za sportiste sa
malim iskustvom u treningu snage (Ibid). Ovakav oblik poveanja
trenanih zahteva, predstavlja dobar nain za istovremeno
usavr{avanje tehnike izvoenja vebi i unapreenje snage, dominantno kod sportista nieg nivoa treniranosti. Prema preporukama Amerikog Koleda za sportsku medicinu iz 2009. godine
(Kraemer i saradnici, 2009), linearni, odnosno tzv. klasini model
periodizacije omoguuje unapreenje osnovnih komponenti
pripremljenosti i dostizanje najvi{eg nivoa odreenje sposobnosti (npr. maksimalne snage ili brzine razvoja sile - RFD) u precizno
odreenom vremenskom periodu.
Obrnuta linearna varijanta se karakteri{e visokim intenzitetom
optereenja na poetku ciklusa, koji postepeno opada pri emu
broj ponavljanja raste (Slika 2). U istraivanju Prestesa i saradnici (2009), poreeni su efekti linearnog i obrnutog linearnog
obrazca na razvoj maksimalne snage na treniranim ispitanicima.
Linearna varijanta periodizacije pokazala se znaajno efikasnijom
za razvoj maksimalne snage u odnosu na obrnutu linearnu varijantu. Sa druge strane, obrnuta linearna varijanta znaajno efikasnija od linearne varijante intenzifikacije kao i od dnevne oscilatorne varijante intenzifikacije za razvoj izdrljivosti u snazi u
zoni 15-25RM. (Rhea i saradnici, 2003)
PROFESSIONAL PAPER
STRUNI LANAK
Slika 2: Linearna i obrnuta linearna varijanta periodizacije u okviru nedeljnih mikrociklusa (Prestes i saradnici, 2009)
Figure 2: Linear and reverse linear periodization patterns in weekly micro cycles (Prestes et al. 2009)
Legend/Legenda: Linerna periodizacija - Linear periodization; Obrnuta linearna periodizacija Reverse linear periodization.
306
/ power and taper block of strength / power (Baker, 2007). sile/snage i tejper blok sile/snage (Baker, 2007). Progresija
The progression of intensity can be linear or nonlinear.
intenziteta moe biti linearna ili nelinearna.
Block variant is characterized by a sudden drop in volume Blokovsku varijatnu karakteri{e nagli pad obima i rast intenziand increase intensity of training load on the transition be- teta trenanog optereenja na prelazu izmeu blokova. Ovatween blocks. Such pronounced changes in the volume and ko nagla{ene promene u obimu i intenzitetu predstavljaju
intensity are appropriate stimulus for improvement of elite adekvatan stimulus za napredak vrhunskih sportista i omoathletes and enable progress by the delayed training effects guavaju napredak preko odloenih trenanih efekata (Slika
(Figure 3). Sharp changes of intensity can be hazardous for 3). O{tre promene intenziteta mogu da predstavljaju preveliless experienced athletes and therefore this variant can be ki {ok za manje iskusne sportiste pa se zato blokovski obrazac
recommended in training of high-level athletes (Baker, 2007; periodizacije preporuuje u treningu iskusnih sportista visokog
nivoa treniranosti (Baker, 2007; Issurin, 2009; Siff, 2000).
Issurin, 2009; Siff, 2000).
Slika 3: Blokovska varijanta periodizacije sa nelinearnom intenzifikacijom optereenja (modifikovano prema Baker, 2007)
Figure 3: Block periodization variant with non-linear intensification of training load (modified according to Baker, 2007)
307
PROFESSIONAL PAPER
STRUNI LANAK
Legend/Legenda: Nedeljna oscilatorna varijanta periodizacije - Weekly undulating variant of periodization; Intenzitet - Intensity; Obim (broj ponavljanja) - Volume (No repetitions); Nedelja - Weeks.
Looking at the whole 12 week cycle, the intensity of the Posmatrano na nivou celog ciklusa od 12 nedelja, intenzitet
stimulus progressively increases in four weeks while in the stimulusa progresivno raste etiri nedelje a u petoj blago
fifth slightly decreases and then increases again for four opada, nakon ega ponovo raste etiri nedelje. Obim je
weeks. The volume of loading is the basic parameter that osnovni parametar koji oscilira na dvonedeljnom nivou.
oscillates bi-weekly. This pattern of progression is appropri- Ovakav nain progresije trenanog optereenja, primeren
ate for the athletes who have adapted to a slight linear je sportistima koji su se adaptirali na blagi linearni obrazac
pattern of intensification or for those who respond well on intenzifikacije ili onima kojima odgovaraju promene trenabi-weekly changes in training objectives (Baker, 2007). In a nih ciljeva na svake dve nedelje (Baker, 2007). U kompacomparative study conducted by Baker, Wilson and Carlyon rativnom istraivanju koje su sproveli Baker i sradnici (1994),
(1994), the oscillatory pattern of periodization produced oscilatornim obrazcem periodizacije je ostvaren vei napremore improvement in comparison to the block variant with dak u poreenju sa blokovskom varijantom sa linearnom
linear intensification of load (16.4% compared to 11.6%). intenzifikacijom optereenja (16,4% u odnosu na 11,6%).
In coaching practice this principle advocates Poliquin (1988), U trenanoj praksi ovaj princip zagovara Poliquin (1988),
who analyzed it the throughout accumulation-intensificati- koji ga analizira kroz akumulacijsko-intenzifikacijsku varion variant (Table 1).
jantu (Tabela 1).
Tabela 1: Primena oscilatornog principa periodizacije u okviru faza akumulacije i intenzifikacije (Poliquin, 1988)
Table 1: Application of oscillatory principles of periodization in accumulation and intensification phase (Poliquin, 1988)
Altering accumulation and intensification phases according to undulating principles
Week
Intensity
Number of repetitions
Number of sets
PROFESSIONAL PAPER
STRUNI LANAK
Volume
1-2
3-4
5-6
7-8
9-10
11-12
70-75%
82-88%
75-78%
85-90%
80-85%
90-95%
10-12
4-6
8-10
3-5
5-7
2-3
30-36
20-30
32-40
15-25
20-28
12-18
Legend/Legenda: Altering accumulation and intensification phases according to undulating principles - Izmena faza akumulacije i intenzifikacije po oscilatornom principu; Week - Nedelja;
Intensity - Intenzitet; Number of repetitions - Broj ponavljanja; Number of sets - Broj serija; Volume - Ukupni obim.
Daily undulating variant of periodization is promoted by
Kraemer and Fleck (2007) and today is the most analyzed
pattern in scientific research. The foundation of this pattern
characterizes variation in training goals and load components
on daily basis from workout to workout (Table 2).
Training in different RM zones, which rotates within the
weekly cycle, allows greater progress in the power in com-
308
Tabela 2: Nelinearna periodizacija treninga snage u okviru dva nedeljna mikrociklusa (Izvor: Kraemer i Fleck, 2007)
Table 2: Non-linear periodization of strength training in the two weekly micro cycles (Source: Kraemer, & Fleck, 2007)
Day
Monday
Objective
Strength endurance
Wednesday Hypertrophy
Number
of sets
Number
of repetitions
12-15RM
8-10RM
Friday
3-4
4-6RM
Monday
Maximal strength
4-5
1-3RM
3-8
3-6 x 30-70%RM
12-15RM
Friday
Strength endurance
Legend/Legenda: Day - Dan; Objective - Cilj; Number of sets - Broj serija; Number of repetitions
- Broj ponavljanja; Monday - Ponedaljak; Wednesday - Sreda; Priday - Petak; Strength
endurance - Izdrljivost u snazi; Hypertrophy - Hipertrofija; Maxilam strength (maintaining) - Maksilamna snaga )odravanje); Maximal strength - Maksimalna snaga; Speed strenth
(Olympic lifts) - Brzinska snaga (OL).
Slika 5: Talasasta varijanta periodizacije optereenja (modifikovano prema Baker, 2007)
Figure 5: Wave-like variant of periodization (modified according to Baker, 2007)
309
PROFESSIONAL PAPER
STRUNI LANAK
Conclusion
Analyzed variants of strength training periodization are an
attempt to create a unique systematization that would allow
better monitoring and control of the training effects. It is
extremely difficult to make a clear line in the practical application of certain varieties. From these theoretical and
practical examples, it is likely that the use of only one of
those unlikely lead to optimal competitive performances.
Although relatively large number of studies monitored the
effects of different training patterns, there are no studies
with uniform protocol that analyzed and compared the effects of different periodization variants. Definitive conclusions about the optimal periodization pattern and efficiency
of the presented patterns in strength training of elite athletes
are open questions for the future research.
PROFESSIONAL PAPER
STRUNI LANAK
Reference
Baker, D. (2001). The effects of an in-season of concurrent training on the maintenance of maximal strength
and power in professional and college-aged rugby
league football players. J Strength Cond Res, 15(2),
172-177.
Baker, D. (2007). Cycle length variants in Periodized
Strength/Power Training. Strength Cond J, 29(4), 1017.
Baker, D., & Newton, R.U. (2006). Adaptations in upper-body maximal strength and power output resulting
from long-term resistance training in experienced
strength-power athletes. J Strength Cond Res, 20(3),
541-546.
Baker, D., Wilson, G., & Carlyon, R. (1994). Periodization: The effects on strength of manipulating volume
and intensity. J Strength Cond Res, 8(4), 235-242.
310
Zakljuak
Analizirani obrazci treninga, predstavljaju poku{aj da se u
okviru periodizacije treninga snage kreira jedinstvena sistematizacija koja bi omoguila bolje praenje i kontrolu trenanih efekata. Izuzetno je te{ko napraviti granicu prilikom
primene odreenih varijanti, a iz navedenih teorijskih i
praktinih primera postoji velika verovatnoa da primena
samo jednog od navedenih te{ko moe da dovede do optimalnih rezultata na takmienjima. Iako postoji relativno
veliki broj studija u kojima se prate efekti razliitih trenanih
programa i dalje je ne postoje studije u kojima se putem
unificiranih protokola prate, analiziraju i uporeuju efekti
razliitih varijanti. Definitivni zakljuak o vrsti obrazca periodizacije pomou koga se postiu optimalni efekti treninga
snage, kao i provera efikasnosti prikazanih varijanti na
uzorcima vrhunskih sportista, ostaju otvorena pitanja za
budua istraivanja.
Bompa, T., Pasquale, M.D, & Cornacchia, L.J. (2003).
Serious strength training, (pp. 233-243). Champaign
IL: Human kinetics.
Buford, T.W., Rossi, S.J., Smith, D.B., & Warren, A.J.
(2007). A comparison of periodization models during
nine weeks with equated volume and intensity for
strength. J Strength Cond Res, 21(4), 1245-1250.
Issurin, V. (2009). Block periodization Breakthrough in
sports training. (in Serbian). Data status, Beograd.
Kraemer, W.J., & Fleck, S.J. (2007). Optimizing strength
training. Human Kinetics, Champaign, IL.
Kraemer, W. J., Adams, K., Cafarelli, E., Dudley, G.A.,
Dooly, C., Feigenbaum, M.S., Fleck, S.J., ... Triplett-McBride, T. (2009). Progression Models in Resistance
Training for Healthy Adults. Med Sci Sports Exerc.
41(3), 687-708.
Peterson, M.D., Dodd, D.J., Alvar, B.A., Rhea, M.R., &
Favre, M. (2008). Undulation training for development
of hierarchical fitness and improved firefighter job
performance. J Strength Cond Res, 22, 1683-1695.
periodized programs with equated volume and intensity for strength. J Strength Cond Res, 16(2), 250-255.
Rhea, M.R., Phillips, W.T., Burkett, L.N., Stone, W.J., Ball,
S.D., Alvar, B.A., & Thomas, A.B. (2003). A comparison of linear and daily undulating periodized programs
with equated volume and intensity for local muscular
endurance. J Strength Cond Res, 17(1), 82-87.
Siff, M.C. (2000). Supetraining. Denver, USA: Supertraining Institute.
Wilks, R. (1995). Limitations in applied strength training
research: Current dilemmas and recommendations for
future studies. Strength Conditioning Coach, 3(2), 1721.
Primljeno: 1. okotobar 2010. godine
Korespodencija:
dr Vladimir Ili
Bore Prodanovia 1a
11000 Belgrade
Srbija
Telefon: +381 11 27 65 828
+381 62 66 66 81
E-mail: vladimir.ilicdif.bg.ac.rs
PROFESSIONAL PAPER
STRUNI LANAK
311