Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Copyright The College of Education and Human Ecology, The Ohio State University
ISSN: 0040-5841 print/1543-0421 online
DOI: 10.1080/00405841.2012.690307
Ruth Wright
Hildegard Froehlich
212
Story 1
After music class, 40 second-graders are lined
up two-by-two in the music room, waiting for
their homeroom teacher. In accordance with a
schoolwide policy, the music teacher gives out
stickers for those children who stand quietly. She
also gives out pops to especially well-behaved
children. Two children are still running all over
the place, refusing to line up as instructed. As
is her practice, the teacher points to the wellbehaving students and says, I like the way
Johnny is standing so quietly. Wow! Johnny, you
pick your favorite one of these really cool bug
stickers. To this, Jason, one of the out-of-control
boys, calmly but loudly responds, Johnny wears
pantyhose while looking straight ahead and
continuing to stand well out of line. Two worlds
of discourse had clashed.
Story 3
In a music lesson about the major orchestral
instrument familieswoodwinds (flute, clarinet,
oboe, and bassoon); brass (trumpet, trombone,
horn, and tuba); strings (violin, viola, cello, and
bass); and percussion (timpani, snare drum, xylophone, and bass drum)the students are asked
to summarize what they have learned. Ms. J asks,
Who can name one instrument you heard from
the woodwind family? Tim responds, Clarinet.
Ms. J says, Good, now name one instrument
from the string family. Alexis, very interested
in classical music from a young age and having
studied on her own, raises her hand and, when
called on, says, Harp. Although correct, Ms. J.
had not mentioned harp, nor was she planning
on talking about it. Her response, therefore, is,
Alexis, how about a stringed instrument that
we have talked about? An opportunity to affirm
Alexiss own knowledge base had been missed.
The Questions
Story 2
Ms. J was always intent on wanting her students to understand that they were in an environment where it was okay to share their feelings
about music in many ways. Encouraging them to
express themselves freely, she reminded them often that it was okay to speak their minds and ask
questions. One day, after a music-listening experience in which some students had really dug into
their innermost feelings and shared them with
213
214
215
216
INSTRUCTIONAL DISCOURSE ID
REGULATIVE DISCOURSE RD
217
Figure 2. The process of recontextualizing original knowledge. (color figure available online)
Outlook
Bernstein raised awareness about the relationship between representatives of the ORF and
the PRF. Those relationships, likely different for
218
References
Al-Ramahi, N., & Davies, B. (2001). Changing primary education in Palestine: Pulling in several directions at once. International Studies in Sociology
of Education, 12, 159176.
Bernstein, B. (1971). Class, codes and control, Vol. 1:
Theoretical studies towards sociology of language.
London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Bernstein, B. (1973a). Class and pedagogies: Visible
and invisible. Paris: OECD, CERI.
Bernstein, B. (Ed.). (1973b). Class, codes and control,
Vol. 2: Applied studies towards a sociology of
language. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
219
220
Copyright of Theory Into Practice is the property of Taylor & Francis Ltd and its content may not be copied or
emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.
However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.