Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
CHLOE HOGG
observed each year in Sri Lanka as the National Day of the Disappeared. To
support the relatives of the disappeared at the memorial service on October
27 this year, Amnesty activists around the world conducted candlelight
vigils and other solidarity actions. Photos of those actions were displayed at
the memorial service this year and have been widely shared on social
media.
passed on October 1 regarding Sri Lanka, in which the Council urged that
Sri Lankan government establish an accountability mechanism with
international participation in order to deal with those war crimes and other
abuses and to finally give the victims and their families truth and justice.
The UN Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances is
currently visiting Sri Lanka now for the first time in 15 years. We hope their
visit will result in important recommendations for the government to
implement that will go a long way in terms of accountability, systemic
reform, and bringing the truth to the families affected.
Q.Considering the UN Declaration of Human Rights, and your
experience in the domain, do you think that there can be a globally
agreed-on definition of human rights and what they fundamentally
entail?
A. Well, the UN Declaration was drafted by representatives from different
legal and cultural backgrounds and was proclaimed by the UN General
Assembly in 1948 as a common standard of human rights goals for all
peoples and nations. The UN Charter states that one of the purposes of the
United Nations is to promote and encourage respect for human rights. The
goals in the UN Declaration of Human Rights have been embodied in
internationally binding treaties the International Covenant for Civil and
Political Rights and the International Covenant for Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights, which are now in effect and binding on those countries
which have ratified them. Sri Lanka is one of the countries that has ratified
those covenants. The US, unfortunately, has only ratified one of them.
Q. What role does cultural relativism have in these discussions and how do
you approach it in your work?
A. In my experience, those who raise arguments about cultural relativism
tend to be the apologists for those committing human rights abuses and
not the victims. The right to be free from torture or from enforced
disappearance, does not depend on ones cultural background. People from
widely varying cultures expect to be treated with respect and to be able to
raise their children in peace and dignity. It is not a cultural construct that
someone could be held in detention without trial. It is also important to note
that often the people making those cultural relativism arguments are in
positions of power. The people affected by human rights abuses look for
international solidarity and support. The idea that culture should excuse
their government never comes up. Ultimately, I ask: whose side are you on?
Because this is real; it is not an abstract theoretical discussion.
Related Articles:
THE KEY FOR PEACE: THE INDISPENSABLE ROLE OF THE UNITED
NATIONS by CLAUDE FORTHOMME
WAKAWAKA- SHINING A LIGHT ON ENERGY POVERTY by ANDREW
BUDSOCK