Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION.................................................................2
SECTION 1. COMPARISON OF YEAR ENDED 31 MARCH 2015
AND 2014 FINANCIAL REPORTS..........................................3
SECTION 2. RATIO ANALYSIS...............................................3
1. LIQUIDITY...........................................................................3
1.1. Current ratio.................................................................................. 3
1.2. Liquid ratio.................................................................................... 3
2. SOLVENCY...........................................................................4
2.1. Equity ratio.................................................................................... 4
2.2. Debt ratio...................................................................................... 4
2.3. Debt to equity ratio.......................................................................4
2.4. Interest cover ratio........................................................................4
3. WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT........................................4
3.1. Inventory turnover.........................................................................4
3.2. Days sales of inventory ratio.........................................................5
3.3. Creditor days ratio.........................................................................5
4. PROFITABILITY...................................................................5
4.1. Gross profit margin........................................................................5
4.2. Net profit margin...........................................................................5
4.3. ROCE............................................................................................. 5
5. ASSET EFFICIENCY...............................................................5
5.1. Capital turnover............................................................................. 6
5.2. Asset turnover ratio.......................................................................6
Liquidity measures..............................................................6
Solvency measures.............................................................6
Working capital management measures...............................7
Profitability ratios...............................................................7
Asset efficiency measures...................................................8
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This report was written with the purpose of examining IJM
Corporation Berhads overall performance of financial years ended
2014 and 2015. Ratios were used to compare FY 15 and FY 14 in
order to: determine companys ability to pay its short term
responsibilities; to measure IJMs capability to meet its long term
obligations; to see how efficiently IJM is using its assets; to assess its
stock management and to analyze IJM Corp Bhd profitability.
Next we compared IJM Corporations ratio results to one of its
competitors Kumpulan Europlus Berhad, which is also one of the
biggest conglomerates in Malaysia mostly concentrated in
construction business. Afterwards, key performance indicators for
each IJMs divisions were identified with its target summarized and
performance analyzed followed by evaluation of KPIs. By analyzing
all the ratios calculated, comparison made we came into conclusion
that IJM regressed over a year, therefore we tried to figure out the
possible reasons of the decline in each of its sectors and give
recommendations. Also we have discussed the main limitations of
using ratios to measure a companys performance.
INTRODUCTION
IJM Corporation Berhad founded in 1983 is one of the leading
conglomerates in Malaysia. With the headquarters located in
Petaling Jaya, Selangor it is one of the 823 companies listed on the
Main Market of Bursa Malaysia Securities Market, with the ticker
symbol IJM:MK.
Group structure:
Construction
Property
Industry
Plantation
Infrastructure and others
IJMs central business is construction, with the motto Excellence
through quality this year IJM Construction Sdn Bhd won the best
builder award. It also became one of the main suppliers of essential
materials for constructing not only in Malaysia but outside as well.
Its property development arm, IJM Land Berhad, recommended itself
as one of the foremost property developers in Malaysia. IJM Corp.
Bhd also operates in plantation, after the successful investment into
oil palm plantations back in 1985 it continues putting a great
amount of emphasis on this division.
IJM established its presence in 10 other countries, besides Malaysia
with its primary focus in India, China and Indonesia. In this report we
are going to measure the financial performance of this company by
2015
2,6
2014
2
Liquid ratio
2,4
1,9
Change
0,6 % increase
(by 30%
increase)
0,55 increase
(by 27%
3
increase)
1.1. Current ratio. IJM Corporations current ratios for present and
previous years show that it is in a good financial health, because its
current assets are twice its current liabilities. Over one year the
current ratio has increased by 30% from 2 to 2,6% making a
difference of 0,6%, however it is not necessarily a good thing (Elliot
2009: 686) it could be a sign of inefficient control over working
capital as poor stocks and accounts receivables control.
1.2. Liquid ratio. It again shows that the IJMs financial position is
in a healthy condition. In both years the company proved that it
has enough cash on hand to pay its bills. Moreover, the company
has increased its ability to pay its current liabilities by 27% since
year of 2014. It could possibly say that the company is rapidly
converting receivables into cash.
2. SOLVENCY
Equity ratio
Debt ratio
Debt to equity
ratio
Interest cover
2015
0,48
0,51
2014
0,48
0,50
1,05
1,04
5,2
7,1
Change
Stable
0,01% increase
(by 2%
increase)
0,01% increase
(by 0,96%)
1,9% decrease
36% decrease
2.1. Equity ratio. IJMs equity ratio has been stable from 2014 to
2015. Shareholders own 48 % of the assets and creditors own the
rest. This number is considered to be average and generally not so
appealing for new investors, in fact if shareholders portion was
bigger it would look more attractive for potential investors.
2.2. Debt ratio. According to Cunningham (2004: 209) if the
companys debt ratio is too high then it may not be able to borrow
money or need to pay a higher interest rate to borrow, which makes
a company to be less financially flexible. IJMs saw a little change,
growth for 0,01 %
2.3. Debt to equity ratio. Those companies with a higher ratio in
the eyes of creditors are seen as unreliable for financing their
money in and a lower debt to equity ratio is equal to stable
business. In IJM Corporation there has been an imperceptible
change over 1 year. Just like the equity ratio (which revealed that
almost half [48%] of IJMs assets are owned by investors) this ratio
has proved again that shareholders and creditors have
approximately an equal stake in the assets.
2.4. Interest cover ratio. If the companys interest cover is above
4
2015
6,9
2014
10,3
Changes
3,4% decrease
75 days
49 days
185 days
166 days
26 days
difference
19 days
difference
2014
Gross profit
margin
18%
24%
13%
17,9%
ROCE
6,6%
10,2%
Change
6% decrease
(25%
decrease)
4,95%
decrease
(36,8%
decrease)
3,6% decrease
5
(54,5%
decrease)
4.1. Gross profit margin. The IJM Corporation experienced a
perceptible drop over a year, thus making a company retain less on
each ringgit of sales to spend on its obligations. Even though the
cost of goods in 2014 was higher, it still shows better results in
gross profit margin compared to present year results. The decline
could probably be explained by poorer sales performed in 2015 with
difference of RM000 558,199
4.2. Net profit margin. We can see that there is a slight regress
from previous year, a decrease of 4,95%. Roughly speaking, in
previous year 17% from every ringgit in revenue was profit,
compared to 13% in 2015.
4.3. ROCE. The most attractive ROCE for investors is when its high
and stable (Elliot 2009:684). We see a significant decrease in the
IJMs ROCE of 3,6% compared to last year, when a company made
profits of 10 cents from every ringgit invested in capital employed.
5. ASSET EFFICIENCY
2015
2014
Change
1,2
Asset turnover
0,32
0,5% decrease
(by 71 % decrease)
0,05% decrease
(by 18 % decrease)
0,27
5.1. Capital turnover. In this present year IJM could not use its
working capital as efficiently as it did last year and suffered an
evident decrease. This could be explained by higher investment into
stocks a company did in this year compared to last year.
5.2. Asset turnover ratio. Asset turnover ratios for construction
companies tend to be lower and since IJMs core business is
construction 0,27 and 0,32 are average. A decrease of 0,05% a
company has experienced since last year.
SECTION 3. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPETITOR
PERFORMANCE KUMPULAN EUROPLUS BERHAD.
KEB or KEURO has been incorporated only in 2000 and in 3 years it
has been in a Bursa Malaysia List; its core business is construction.
The company has divisions similar to IJMs.
1. Liquidity measures
KEURO
Current ratio
Liquid ratio
2015
5,93
5,91
2014
0,57
0,56
Change
5,36% increase
5,35%
2015
0,88
0,11
0,13
7,76
2014
0,41
0,58
1,43
3,38
Change
47% increase
47% decrease
1,3% decrease
4,38% increase
2015
8,67
2014
8,90
Changes
0,23%
decrease
7
Days sales of
inventory
44 days
50 days
6 days less
IJM group decreased its ability to supply its goods quickly by 3,4% as
compared to KEURO, which also saw a decrease but only by 0,23%.
IJM is facing more inventory cost as compared to previous year. This
means their operational efficiency has decreased.
In 2015 IJM took 26 more days to turn over its inventory compared
to year of 2014. However, for KEURO number of days sales of
inventory only went down from 50 days to 44 because sales of
goods increased.
4. Profitability ratios
KEURO
2015
2014
Gross profit
margin
Net profit margin
5,21%
21,7%
4,95%
17,84%
ROCE
6,08%
19,5%
Change
16,49%
decrease
12,89%
decrease
13,42%
decrease
2015
2014
Change
4,17%
-13.61%
2,45%
3,4%
17,78%
increase
9,5% decrease
Property
Target
The Construction
division has acquired
the order of projects
worth RM 7.0 billion
in FY 15. The major
projects secured are:
West Coast
Expressway (RM
2,828.00 million),
New Deep Water
Terminal at Kuantan
Port Phase 1 (RM
1,188.03 million),
Radia - Mixed
Development project
in Bukit Jelutong (RM
435.34 million),
Potpourri
Commercial
Development project
in Ara Damansara
(RM 355.68 million),
Commercial
Development project
in Damansara Utama
(RM 396.00 million)
and Puteri Cove
Residences Mixed
Development project
in Johor Bahru (RM
538.50 million).
In the coming
financial year, the
property division has
planned to work on
new projects in
Performance
The construction
division of the
company has
achieved revenue of
RM 1224.31 million &
PBT of 184.84 million
against RM 2080.8
million & RM 168.17
million in 2014. This
resulted in 41%
decrease in revenue
and 10% increase in
terms of PBT. Higher
PBT was due to the
better profit margins
which were derived
from the completion
of several projects
such as: PERKESO
Rehabilitation Centre,
Platinum Park Phase
3, EMU Depot,
Jelutong Expressway,
Stage 3 and Pahang
Selangor Raw Water
Transfer.
Industry
Plantation
To sustain this
division by higher
crop production
through exploring
more areas for
plantation in
Indonesia and make
use of them.
14 revenue of RM
2,224.96 million. PBT
of FY 15 was RM
494.66 million which
showed a decline of
34% as compared to
financial year of
2014 PBT of RM
748.66 million.
Industry division
achieved revenue of
RM 926.77 million
and PBT of RM
125.60 million in FY
15. Their core
product PSC
(Pretensioned Spun
Concrete) faced high
competition this year.
Nevertheless the
revenue from PSC
increased by 2% and
the PBT dropped by
17% as compared to
FY 14.
In FY 15 the revenue
of this division
experienced an
increase of 3% (RM
667.67 million) as
compared to the
financial year of
2014 (RM 646.98
million) due to higher
sales volume. On the
other hand the PBT
was declined by 18%
as compared to
previous year, due to
the fluctuation of
foreign exchange.
Formula
Current assets
Current liabilities
Definition
Helps to
understand the
liquidity of a
company and
measures the
ability to pay
back its shortterm obligations
Limitation
In the calculation this ratio
includes inventories as well,
which in the end displays
incorrect liquidity position,
hence inventories cannot
always be considered as
liquid. For instance some
companies have large
11
Liquid
ratio
Current assetsinventories
Current liabilities
Is used to find
out how the
company, by
using its quick
assets (cash or
anything that
can be easily
converted to
cash), can pay
its upcoming
obligations.
Equity
ratio
Total equity
Total assets
Measures how
much of a
companys
assets are
owned by
investors. The
high equity ratio
demonstrates to
investors that
the company is
worth their
investments,
since so many
other investors
have a faith in a
company and
already
financing their
investments in
it.
Cannot be an indicator of
companys solvency; timing
again is important here
since debts could be paid
out already before the
calculations were done, it
doesnt measure its ability
to pay those debts.
Moreover if the
shareholders portion of the
companys assets is bigger
it doesnt necessarily mean
that the company is able to
make more money for
investors in the future.
12
Debt
ratio
Total liabilities
Total assets
Presents the
percentage of
total assets
provided by
creditors.
Debt to
equity
ratio
Total liabilities
Totalequ ity
Compares a
companys total
equity to total
debt. The lower
the ratio is the
trust worthier
the company
will be for new
investors.
Interest
cover
ratio
This ratio
determines
whether a
company can
pay its interest
on its loans in a
particular period
of time.
Inventor
y
turnover
Net sales
Inventories
Measures how
quickly a
company uses
its supply of
goods over a
given period of
time.
Days
sales of
inventor
y
Inventories
x 365
Cost of sales
Shows how a
company
manages its
inventory, in
how many days
a company can
turnover its
inventory.
Creditor
days
Trade payables
x 365
Purchases
Gross
profit
margin
Net income
x 100
Cost of sales
Net
profit
margin
Net income
100
Net sales
Measures how
much income is
kept in a
company as
compared to the
total sales
overall efficiency
of the business.
ROCE
Capital
turnover
Net sales
Money a
business
has in
(Current assetsCurrent liabilities
)
hand to spend
on its operations
after paying its
bills,
demonstrates
how efficiently a
company is
turning cash into
sales.
Asset
turnover
Total sales
Total assets
As Elliot suggested,
Although this ratio can act
as a good guide to company
Calculates the
average number
of days a
company takes
to pay its
suppliers.
Reveals how
much income a
company makes
after paying off
its cost of sales.
Measures a
companys
ability to use its
14
assets to
generate sales;
a higher number
is more
favorable.
REFERENCES:
Annual report (2015) IJM Corporation Berhad [online] available from
<http://www.ijm.com/web/investor/annualReports.aspx> [13
October 2015]
Annual report (2015) Kumpulan Europlus Berhad [online] available
from <http://klse.i3investor.com/servlets/staticfile/269330.jsp> [27
October 2015]
Beirne, T., Dauderis, H. (1991) Financial accounting. An introduction
to decision making. Orlando: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
Elliot, B., Elliot, J. (2009) Financial accounting and reporting.
Gasport: Ashford Colour Press Ltd
Elliot, B; Elliot, J. (1993) Financial accounting and reporting.
Hertfordshire: Hall International Ltd
Cunningham, B., Nikolai, L., Bazley, J. (2004) Accounting information
for business decisions. Mason: South-Western, a division of
Thompson Learning
15
Current ratio =
Current assets
Current liabilities
2.60061971
9,360, 524
4, 554,233
= 2.05534587
Current assetsinventories
Current liabilities
11,182,930783,912
=2.41831891
4,300,102
9,360,524592,802
=1.92518082
4,554,233
2. SOLVENCY
2.1. Equity ratio
Equity ratio =
Total equity
Total assets
9,575,537
19,730,689
= 0,48531184
16
8,950,272
18,398,468
= 0,48646833
Total liabilities
Total assets
10,071,865
19,730,689
= 0,51046697
9,317,543
18,398,468
= 0,50643037
Total liabilities
Total equity
10,071,865
9,575,537
9,317,543
= 1,04103462
8,950,272
= 1,05183292
1,019,357+ 242,682
242,682
= 5,20038157
17
1,416,314 +231,195
231,195
= 7,12605809
Net sales
Inventories
5,448,282
783,912
= 6,9501194
6,006,481
592,802
= 10,1323562
Inventories
x 365
Cost of sales
783,912
x 365=
3,767,422
DSI (2014) =
592,802
x 365= 49,7845878
4,346,179
75,9479241
Trade payables
x 365
Purchases
18
2,014,477
x 365=
3,958,532
2,038,086
x 365= 166,899562
4,457,180
185,746662
4. PROFITABILITY
4.1. Gross profit margin
Gross profit margin =
Net income
x 100
Cost of sales
713,041
x 100=18,926497
3,767,422
1,075,656
x 100=24,749464
4,346,179
Net income
100
Net sales
713,041
100
5,448,282
= 13.0874466
1,075,656
100
6,006,481
= 17.9082561
4.3 ROCE
19
ROCE =
1,019,357
x 100
(19,730,6894,300, 102)
= 6,606081
ROCE (2014) =
1,416,314
x 100
(18,398,4684,554, 233)
= 10,230352
5. ASSET EFFICIENCY
5.1. Capital turnover
Capital turnover =
Net sales
(Current assetsCurrent liabilities )
5,448,282
= 0,79157608
11,182,9304,300,102
6,006,481
= 1,2497123
9,360,5244,554,233
Total sales
Total assets
20
5,448,282
19,730,689
= 0,27613237
6,006,481
18,398,468
= 0,32646637
Current assets
Current liabilities
533,947
89,922
5.93
138,872
241,405
= 0.57
1.2.Liquid Ration
Liquid ratio =
Current assetsinventories
Current liabilities
533,9472,133
=5.91
89,992
133,8721.562
=0.56
241,105
2. SOLVENCY
21
2.1.Equity Ratio
Equity ratio =
Total equity
Total assets
665,179
755,333
8,950,272
18,398,468
= 0.88
= 0.41
2.2.Debt Ratio
Debt ratio =
Total liabilities
Total assets
10,071,865
19,730,689
= 0.11
9,317,543
18,398,468
= 0.58
Total liabilities
Total equity
90,154
665,179
241,349
= 1.43
168,290
= 0.13
22
2.4.Interest Cover
Interest cover =
40,485+5,985
5,985
32,869+13,783
13,783
= 7.76
= 3.38
Net sales
Inventories
18,500
2,133
= 8.67
13,910
1,562
= 8.90
Inventories
x 365
Cost of sales
2,133
x 365=
13,910
DSI (2014) =
13,910
x 365= 50 days
11,429
44 days
23
PROFITABILITY
4.1.Gross profit margin
Gross profit margin =
Net income
Cost of sales
916
=5.21
17584
32,869
=21.7
11,429
Net income
100
Net sales
916
100
18,500
= 4.95%
2,481
100
13,910
= 17.84%
4.3 ROCE
ROCE =
24
ROCE (2015) =
40,845
(755,33389,922)
ROCE (2014) =
32,869
(755,333241,105)
= 6.08%
= 19.5%
5. ASSET EFFICIENCY
5.1.Capital turnover
Capital turnover =
Net sales
(Current assetsCurrent liabilities )
18500
= 4.17%
533,94789,922
13,910
= (13.61%)
138,872241,105
5.2.Asset turnover
Asset turnover =
Total sales
Total assets
18,500
755,333
= 2.45%
13,910
409,639
= 3.4%
25
26