[RUBRIC FOR PROCESS SIMULATION LABORATORY (CPE613)]

SEPT- JAN 2016

Related Programme Outcomes :

PO3: Ability to design and conduct experiments, as well as to analyse and interpret data.
PO9: Ability to function effectively as an individual and in a group with the capacity to be a leader or manager as well as an effective
team member.

Programme Outcome #3: Ability to design and conduct experiments, as well as to analyse and interpret data.
CONTENT

Procedure

LEVEL 1
(0)
No procedure
given

LEVEL 2
(1-2)
-

Process Flow
Diagram
(PFD)

No PFD given

Workbook

No workbook

LEVEL 3
(3)

LEVEL 4
(4-5)

TOTAL
MARKS
(100)
/10

Many steps
missing from
procedure.
No systematic plan of data
gathering
presented or
plan is grossly
incomplete.

Some steps
missing from
procedure.
Set up
diagram is
inaccurate,
not
referenced.
Incomplete
sentences are
used.

Procedure
describes all
steps of
experiment in
clear order.

Much
information
missing from
PFD.
PFD is not
appropriately
label
Much

Some
information
missing from
PFD.
PFD is not
appropriately
label
Some

PFD is
appropriately
labelled.

/20

All the

/30

[RUBRIC FOR PROCESS SIMULATION LABORATORY (CPE613)]

attached

information in
the workbook
is missing or
wrong

Question &
Answer

Not answer
questions

Discussion

No discussion
given

Many
questions are
not answered
correctly.
Poorly
presented
with little
reference to
the results
and can also
be
misinterpreta
tion of the
results.
No linkage
made with
theoretical
principles.

information in
the workbook
is missing or
wrong

Level 1 Unacceptable/ Fails to meet expectations

Some
question is
answered
correctly.
Somewhat
demonstrates
understandin
g of principles
affecting
results and
possible
sources of
error.
-

SEPT- JAN 2016

information
given in
workbook is
correct and
appropriately
labelled.
The entire
question is
answered
correctly.
Clearly
demonstrates
understandin
g of principles
affecting
results and
possible
sources of
error.
The meaning
of results and
their validity
is discussed
with clarity
and insight,
using
statistics to
quantify the
discussion

/10

/30

[RUBRIC FOR PROCESS SIMULATION LABORATORY (CPE613)]

SEPT- JAN 2016

Level 2 Meeting expectations but incomplete

Level 3 Meeting expectations
Level 4 - Exceeds expectations

POINTS FOR DISCUSSION

Objective
Summary of the process
Purpose of each equipment
Principle work of each equipment; e.g separation process
Fact/ theory of separation based on physical properties of each components
Fluid package- the suitability of application
Different result obtained by using different fluid package need to be well explained
Recommendation/ suggestion for improvement or futher detailed discussion
Attachment of result obtained from different fluid package
Summary of the result