Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Hydraulicfracturingisanunconventionaldrillingtechniqueofoilandnaturalgas
extraction which requires the pumping of mixture of water, sand, and useful
chemicalsathighpressuresintoawelldrilledvertically,andthenhorizontallyintothe
rocks.Fracking has no doubt revolutionized the oil and gas industry and thus creating
emerging potential petrol-states from none OPEC countries like U.S, Canada and
China. Environmental impacts of fracking ranges from surface water contamination,
earthquake and seismic activitiy, emission of greenhouse gases, release of air
pollutant, disruption of human activities to intoxication of underground water water.
Hydraullic fracking has a lower Energy Return on Investment (EROI) in comparison
with the conventional oil drilling technique, as the extraction processes are more
complicated and thus involve huge financial commitment. More energy is required to
extract the oil than in turn will generate energy. While fracking involves huge capital
investment, however, hydraulic oil plays have the opportunity to be repeated many
times. For instance if five wells are drilled on a spread across 100,000 acres, and the
five wells are repeatable, another 1,000 more wells could be drilled.
Fracking innovation may boost economies and local demands for natural gas in U.S,
Australia, Canada and China, However, oil-exporting and totally dependent
economies may be in for the shock of their economic lives. A number of countries are
highly vulnerable to a potential trade quake as a result of change in US oil imports
including Angola, Congo, and Nigeria. Short term and long-term impacts of oil price
fall include inflation, budgetary adjustment in totally oil-dependent exporting
countries, reduction in international trade volumes due to drop in GDP, fall in standard
of living for countries whose citizens live on the edge, reduction in local national
expenditure which is evidenced in Nigeria and Venezuela, rise in rate of employment.
The insignificant concentration of unconventional oil in the Middle East and higher
concentration of non-conventional oil in once oil importing states may strike a
balance in global oil trade.
1.0 Introduction
Innovations in hydraulic fracturing and horizontal drilling have by and large
engineered high-tech revolution in natural gas and oil extraction. This twenty-first
century break-through, this competitive-advantage renaissance in oil and gas
exploration has in a way relegated to the background the age-old comparative
advantage theory that oil rich states have cashed in on for centuries to monopolize the
oil global market. Fracking radical breakthrough has engineered huge production feat
in oil and natural gas production in the United States and other former major oilimporting countries. The revolution is the product of strides and advances made in oil
and natural gas production technologynotably, a novel combination of horizontal
drilling and hydraulic fracturing. Substantial availability of local energy resources
benefits the United States by drastically reducing dependence on imported energy and
diversifying the economy (CFR, 2013).
Fracking operations involves preliminary survey of the target reserve, drilling
production operations and post-production activities. The high pressure attempts to
produced and enlarge fractures in the geological formation and induce the flow of oil
and gas resources. Environmental impacts of fracking can be threatening and these
impacts include surface contamination, ground water intoxication, emission of
greenhouse gases, pervasive air pollution and induction of earthquakes and earth
tremors (Zhenbo etal., 2014).
Hydraullic fracking is said to have a lower Energy Return on Investment (EROI) in
comparison with the conventional oil drilling technique, as the extraction processes
are more complicated and thus involve huge financial commitment. Basically, more
energy is necessary to extract the oil than in turn will generate energy. However,
despite the lower EROI, oil producers are employing unconventional sources more
and more, to try to keep up with the increasing oil demand (Clara, 2013).
Fracking innovation may boost economies and local demands for natural gas in U.S,
Australia, Canada and China, However, oil-exporting and totally dependent
economies may be in for the shock of their economic lives. A number of countries are
highly vulnerable to a potential trade quake as a result of change in US oil imports
including Angola, Congo, and Nigeria. A surge in fracking in China with the same
size in the trade shock would double the domino effect. The total estimated effects
from a reduction in US oil imports from African countries amount to US$32 billion.
The net impacts on exporters will depend on their ability to find other markets, and
the conditions under which they do so (Zhenbo etal., 2014).
This report aims to review hydraulic fracturing operations, analyse its cost
implications, environmental impacts and assess how worthy of investment it is in
comparison with conventional oil drilling technique.
2.1.2 Production
Awellisdrilledverticallytothedesigndepth,thenturnsatrightangleandcontinues
horizontallyforseveralthousandfeetintotheshaleappraisedtocontainthetrapped
naturalgasandoil.
Amixtureofwater,sand,andassortedchemicalsisinjectedintothewellatveryhigh
pressureinanattempttoproducedandcreatefissuresintheshalethroughwhichthe
oilandgascanbeextracted.
Naturalgasandoilescapethroughtheperforationsandisdrawnbackupthewellto
thegroundsurface,whereitisprocessed,refined,andshippedtomarket.Flowback
recedestothesurfaceafterthehydraulicfracturingprocesscycleiscompleted(CWA,
2015).
.
Figure 2.1.2 A typical fracking process (CWA, 2015)
Globally acceptable practices require the use of a larger volume of flowback fluid to
be recovered from a well relative to the volume of injected fluid after hydraulic
fracturing is completed (Golder Associates, 2010b). The Australian government
suggests that the quality and quantity of the ebbing fluid must be keenly monitored
until a volume is removed equivalent to 150 per cent of the fluid used in the fracking.
This would ensure that all water used for the fracking is carefully separated and
removed (DEHP, 2013).
A number of techniques exist for directly or indirectly gauging fracture growth.
Nonetheless, all of these methods have drawbacks in field requirements, resolution
and the range of measurable fracture properties. The methods include: detection of
radioactive tracers, if they have been used, in the hydraulic fracturing fluid or
proppant, temperature surveys to detect fracturing fluid which is typically a different
temperature to the water in the well, production logs or down hole video to assess
where most water is entering the well; and tiltmeter and micro-seismic mapping
(Bennett et al., 2005).
2.1.3 Refining
Distillation is a widely common processing method in oil refineries. Shale ga is distilled into
constituents fractions at different boiling point ranges, each of which are then processed
further if required. The process of shale oil distillation is done by gasification of oil at high
temperatures (LI, 2015).
Pyrolysis is a process where rich organic matter is decomposed at high temperatures in the
absence of oxygen (LI, 2015).
Filtering is a common technique for separation of solids from fluids (liquids or gases). This is
done by subjecting the mixture through a medium which allows only passage of fluids of
certain density (LI, 2015).
Virtually all fraction constituents are chemically treated before undergoing for final packaging
for end use. The technique of treatment varies with the type of fractionate and the intended
use of the finished product (LI, 2015).
Reheating is executed by recirculating hot air gas into feed stock or input shale gas one of the
refining technique of shale oil where either hot air gas is re-circulated into the feed stock, or
input shale oil is shifted to the compartment for subsequent extraction of design product (LI,
2015).
conventional well might cost $1 million to install, a well placed into one of the shale
plays utilizing hydraulic fracturing may cost several millions of dollars (Terrence,
2012). (Liu etal., 2013) reported that on extreme, it costs between $1.5-2.5 million to
dig a well via hydraulic fracturing and the median cost is $600,000 per well
The depth of the well is directly proportional to the cost of drilling. While a
conventional well might cost $1 million to install, a well placed into one of the shale
plays utilizing hydraulic fracturing may cost several millions of dollars (Terrence,
2012). (Liu etal., 2013) reported that on extreme, it costs between $1.5-2.5 million to
dig a well via hydraulic fracturing and the median cost is $600,000 per well.
thus limiting the number of long-term investors that can participate in these
investment opportunities. Nonetheless, investors that are able to invest in the future of
U.S. energy can likely benefit from the potential for a higher interests than before
considering the increased technological efficiencies (Morgan, 2013).
manage the oil fall than the Soviet Union was, but it is likely to suffer from the
unavoidable cuts in imports and spending, and the sanctions will aggravate its
economic situation more. Irans economy is in worse shape because it had a less
prudent economic policy and the sanctions on export had added insult to injuryworsened its fate which could be linked to the current crisis engulfing its territory.
Nigeria, inspite of an improved macro-economic policy in comparison with the past
oil booms, is going to be drastically affected due to its near complete dependence on
oil sales as its mainstay of the economy. This could result to a decrease in standards of
living and worsened the socio-political instability currently eating deep into its fabric
(Francisco, 2015).
3.3.1.2 Social impacts
The short-term impact of falling oil prices has been worrisome. Prior to the current
trying moments of oil price fall, oil exploration has been a major source of lucrative
employment opportunities. Approximately 500,000 jobs were created in the energy
sector since the wind fall ended. Expenditure on oil exploration hardware, rigs,
pipelines and other paraphernalia has also been strong. However, with plunging oil
prices, such spending is drastically gone down in U.S (Barry, 2014).
Social welfare programmes are getting their fair share of the oil fall shock. A number
of western countries have re-adjusted their state funded welfarist programmes in
respond to the oil fall. This would have direct effects on the downtrodden
beneficiaries of this programs who struggle from hand to mouth (Barry, 2014).
Low prices may consequently catalyze energy-security tension and become a source
of worries. The low oil prices are milking US shale and other top end dealers. A
number of investors have been coerced to to significantly cut down their investment
budgets to sort of create safety net for emerging new reality. Expenditure on
exploration and production has fallen one-fifth in 2015. The tendency of further cuts
is likely (Ivana, 2015).
3.3.1.3 Political Impacts
Fallen oil prices could arm-twist Saudi Arabia, on one hand and Iran
on the other and together with oil-producing its allies to the
bargaining table on vested interest: oil. A consensus and
compromise between these interests and U.S could go a long way to
ameliorate the heightened level of geopolitical instability and
sectarian upheaval in the Middle East as a whole. The frequency and
protracted severity of the Syrian imbroglio and the insurgency that
it has driven the Gulf into and its environs can not be
overemphasized. However, the possibility exists that all these
interests in the regional tussle for power and control will be seeking
for panacea to doused the escalated embers of socio-political
violence that has held the troubled state of for example Syria to
random (Gregory, 2015). Iran, an oil reliant state where oil makes up
for as much as 75 percent of its GDP, the government would need
an oil price of $127 a barrel to stabilize its machinery of governance
(JD, 2014). Presently, Iran more than ever needs a bilateral ties with
global powers that be to advance its nuclear program that would lift
sanctions limiting its oil sales.
9
U.S and its European allies had schemed to gradually again place sanctions on Russia
if Putin refuses to act diplomatically to douse and ease unrests in Crimea. That way
sanctions could be gradually lifted if Russia takes prudent steps (Steven, 2014).
ItisestimatedthatthenationofSaudiArabiahasprobablycommittedapproximately
$100billionofitsreservesinitswarcampaignagainstAmericasascendancyinthe
oilmarketpyramid.Theoilkingdomsdecisiononeyearagonottocutproductionto
supportoilpriceshasdriventhepriceofbothBrentcrudeandWestTexas
Intermediatedownbelow$50abarrel,butSaudiArabiawillhavetospendalotmore
towinthebattle(Nathan,2015).
would likely not cover the monetary need of its expenses, and its dependence on its
share of the central governments revenues becomes more critical to its own fiscal
well being (Nathan, 2015).
4.0 Conclusion
Hydraulicfracturingisanunconventionaldrillingtechniqueofoilandnaturalgas
extraction which requires the pumping of mixture of water, sand, and useful
chemicalsathighpressuresintoawelldrilledvertically,andthenhorizontallyintothe
rocks.Fracking has no doubt revolutionized the oil and gas industry and thus creating
emerging potential petrol-states from none OPEC countries like U.S, Canada and
China.
Environmental impacts of fracking ranges from surface water contamination,
earthquake and seismic activitiy, emission of greenhouse gases, release of air
pollutant, disruption of human activities to intoxication of underground wwater.
Hydraullic fracking has a lower Energy Return on Investment (EROI) in comparison
with the conventional oil drilling technique, as the extraction processes are more
complicated and thus involve huge financial commitment.
More energy is required to extract the oil than in turn will generate energy. While
fracking involves huge capital investment, however, hydraulic oil plays have the
opportunity to be repeated many times. For instance if five wells are drilled on a
spread across 100,000 acres, and the five wells are repeatable, another 1,000 more
wells could be drilled.
Fracking innovation may boost economies and local demands for natural gas in U.S,
Australia, Canada and China, However, oil-exporting and totally dependent
economies may be in for the shock of their economic lives. A number of countries are
highly vulnerable to a potential trade quake as a result of change in US oil imports
including Angola, Congo, and Nigeria. Short term and long-term impacts of oil price
fall include inflation, budgetary adjustment in totally oil-dependent exporting
countries, geo-political intrigues, reduction in international trade volumes due to drop
in GDP, fall in standard of living for countries whose citizens live on the edge,
reduction in local national expenditure which is evidenced in Nigeria and Venezuela,
rise in rate of employment. The insignificant concentration of unconventional oil in
the Middle East and higher concentration of non-conventional oil in once oil
importing states may strike a balance in global oil trade.
11
5.0 REFERENCES
1. Abbas, A.A., Rafik, N., and Ashkan, A., 2014, Oil Price Pass-Through into
Domestic Inflation: The Case of Iran, International Journal of Energy Economics and
Policy Vol. 8, No. 67.
2. Abubakar, A., 2015, The Impact of Global Fall in Oil Prices on the Nigerian Crude
Oil Revenue and Its Prices, Proceedings of the Second Middle East Conference on
Global Business, Economics, Finance and Banking (ME15Dubai Conference), Paper
ID: D508.
3. Andrew, B., 2014, Falling oil prices impact economic trends, Triangle Business
Journal, I.D 4, No.330.
4. Andrew, B., 2015, Cost of Shale Oil versus Conventional Oil, available online at<
http://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/051215/cost-shale-oil-versusconventional-oil.asp (Accessed on 26/11/2015).
5. Barry, R., 2015, What do Falling Oil Prices mean for U.S in the Short term and
Long
term,
Washington
Post,
available
online
at<
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/12/16/plunging-oil-prices-aredoing-obamas-foreign-policy-for-him/ accessed on (04/12/2015).
6. Behrens and Associates, 2006, Gas Well Drilling Noise Impact and Mitigation
Study, Prepared for the Gas Drilling Task Force, Fort Worth, TX, available online
at<http://pstrust.org/docs/GasWellDrillingNoiseImpactandMitigationStudy.pdf
(Accessed on 26/11/2015).
7. Beckwith, R., 2010, Hydraulic Fracturing: The Fuss, the facts, the Future. Society
of Petroleum Engineers Report.
8. Bennett, L., Calvez, J.L., Sarver, D.R., Tanner, K., Birk, W.S., Waters, G., Drew, J.,
Michaud, G., Primiero, P., Eisner, L., Jones, R., Leslie, D., Williams, M.J.,
Govenlock, J., Klem, R.C. and Tezuka K., 2005. The Source for Hydraulic Fracture
Characterization. Oilfield Review 17:42-57.
9. Clara, P., 2013, Oil Production from Unconventional Sources: Fuel of the Future,
available
online
at<
http://www.decodedscience.org/oil-production-fromunconventional-sources-fuel-of-the-future/33192 (Accessed on 25/11/2015).
10. Clark, C., Burnham, C.H., Harto, C., and Horner., 2013, Hydraulic Fracturing
and Shale Gas Production: Technology, Impacts and Regulations, available online
at<http://www.afdc.energy.gov/uploads/publication/anl_hydraulic_fracturing.pdf
(Accessed on 20/11/2015).
12
only
at
<
http://www.wipo.int/export/sites/www/patentscope/en/programs/patent_landscapes/do
cuments/lexinnova_shale_oil_and_gas.pdf(Accessedon02/12/2015).
13
at<
28. Nathan, V, 2015, Saudi Arabia Preparing to Fuel it $100 million War with Debt,
available online at <http://www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2015/11/10/saudiarabia-preparing-to-fuel-its-100-billion-oil-war-with-debt/ (Accessed on 01/12/2015).
29. Rogers, R., Ramurthy, M., Rodvelt, G. and Mullen, M., 2007, Coal bed methane:
principles and practices, 3rd edition, report by Halliburton.
30. Stephenson, C.J., Crabb, T.M., Orrego, G.V. and Khaan, M.B., 2003, Effective
Prop-pant Flowback Control Following Hydraulic Fracturing Treatments in Shallow
Reservoirs. SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, 5-8 October, 2003,TX.
31. Steven, H., 2014, Plunging Oil Prices are Doing Obamas Foreign Policy For
him,
Washington
Post,
available
online
at<
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/12/16/plunging-oilprices-are-doing-obamas-foreign-policy-for-him/ (accessed on 01/12/2015)
32. Taleghani, A.D., 2009, Analysis of Hydraulic Fracture Propagation in Fractured
Reservoirs: an Improved Model for the Interaction Between Induced and Natural
Fractures, PhD Thesis, University of Texas at Austin.
33. Transparency Market Research, 2015, Hydraulic Fracturing Market Projected To
Continue,
Oil
and
Gas
Finance
Journal,
online
article,
available
at<http://www.ogfj.com/articles/2015/06/global-hydraulic-fracturing-market-projected-tocontinue-growth.html (Accessed on 27/11/2015).
14
35. Zhenbo etal., 2014, The Development Implications of the Fracking Revolution,
Odi,
available
online
at
<http://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/odiassets/publications-opinion-files/8886.pdf (Accessed on 21/11/2015).
15