Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Whitening Options
The oldest form of whitening, the in-office procedure using 35% hydrogen peroxide, has a long history of tooth sensitivity and gingival irritation,
affecting 10% to 90% of patients according to recent figures.3-5 Some sensitivity has been severe enough to require strong medications, and some dentists premedicate their patients with nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs to
minimize sensitivity.6 Because in-office whitening often takes more than 1
appointment to achieve the maximum lightening,7 appointments generally
are scheduled at least 1 week apart to allow the discomfort to dissipate.8
Newer OTC products, such as strips and wraps, also cause sensitivity,
although the gingival irritation often is greater than the tooth sensitivity.9-12
As with any treatment, the higher the concentration of peroxide, the greater
the incidence and severity of tooth sensitivity as well as the potential for
gingival irritation.13 Even shorter wear times of strips with higher concentrations have demonstrated greater sensitivity than strips with lower concentrations worn longer.12
Tray whitening with 10% carbamide peroxide is the most popular form of
whitening today (Figure 1), but it also causes tooth sensitivity as the main
side effect.14 Earlier studies tried to determine if there were predictors for sensitivity; however, only inherent patient sensitivity (a history of sensitive
teeth) and more than 1 application per day had any correlation.15 All other
factors, such as age, gender, exposed dentin or cementum, cracks, pulp size,
allergies, decay, etc, were not predictable indicators for sensitivity.15
Contributing factors include the use of rigid trays, the amount of soft tissue
contact, the vehicle carrying the peroxide, the viscosity of the material, different flavors, and patient habits.15 A review of all of the clinical trials on
whitening indicates that 25% to 75% of the treatment groups (receiving the
active ingredient of peroxide) experienced sensitivity. Interestingly enough,
20% to 30% of the placebo groups (not receiving peroxide) experienced sensitivity.16 Just wearing a tray alone can produce about 20% sensitivity.13
Vol. 26, No. 9 (Suppl 3)
11
Whitening Ingredients
There are 2 main ingredients used in
whitening: hydrogen peroxide and carbamide
peroxide. Carbamide peroxide breaks down
into hydrogen peroxide and urea. A 10% solution of carbamide peroxide is roughly 3.5%
hydrogen peroxide and 6.5% urea.17-21 The
hydrogen peroxide further reduces to water and
oxygen, and the urea to ammonia and carbon
dioxide. While both carbamide and hydrogen
peroxide are used for whitening, their properties are quite different. Hydrogen peroxide is
very unstable and releases all of its peroxide in
30 to 60 minutes (Figure 2).22-26 It applies a
rapid rush of peroxide to the pulp and is cited
as causing more sensitivity than carbamide peroxide at the equivalent dose. Carbamide peroxide releases about 50% of its peroxide in the
first 2 to 4 hours, then the remainder over the
next 2 to 6 hours.17,19 Hence, it is more of a
time-release approach, which causes less sensitivity. For the most effective whitening per
dose, carbamide peroxide products work better
overnight while hydrogen peroxide, because it
becomes inactive so quickly, works better when
used during the day for 30 to 60 minutes.
Higher concentrations of either peroxide cause
a greater insult to the pulp and more sensitivity. Patients who are interested in the fastest
whitening possible often request higher con-
Sensitivity Occurrence
Tooth sensitivity with whitening usually
affects the smaller teeth, such as the maxillary
laterals and the mandibular incisors. This sensitivity does not necessarily occur during treatment but can occur as long as 8 hours after
treatment. It can be a generalized tooth sensitivity, but it is often described as a sharp shooting pain or zinger to 1 or 2 teeth. The etiology of this sensitivity results from the easy
passage of the peroxide through the enamel and
the dentin to the pulp, which takes 5 to 15
minutes (Figure 3).28 Further proof of this passage of peroxide is the research that has shown
that the dentin changes color next to the pulp
as fast as it does next to the dentin-enamel
junction.29 Hence, sensitivity results from the
insult of the peroxide on the nerve and may be
considered a reversible pulpitis. The major factor for the degree of tooth sensitivity is the
patients inherent sensitivity and pain threshold levels, but that is also magnified by higher
concentrations of peroxide and pressure on the
teeth from trays or occlusion.
Generally, sensitivity occurs in the first 2
weeks of treatment, often in the first few days.30
Sensitivity decreases as the teeth are accustomed to the procedure, but occasional singleday episodes of sensitivity may occur over the
Figure 1Facial view before whitening treatment of the maxillary teeth with 10% carbamide peroxide (left) and after treatment (right).
Whitening offers a dramatic esthetic change with minimum cost and effort. The main side effect is tooth sensitivity.
12
50
Hydrogen peroxide
Carbamide peroxide
40
30
20
10
0
0.5
1.5
2.5
3.5
4.5
Hours
Figure 2The release of peroxide from carbamide peroxide is much different from that of hydrogen peroxide. Hydrogen peroxide releases all of its peroxide in 30 to 60 minutes, with a quick decline. Carbamide peroxide releases about 50% of its peroxide in 2 to 4 hours,
then experiences a slow decline.
13
reduced. Potassium nitrate has almost an anesthetic effect on the nerve. A recent study
demonstrated that applying potassium nitrate
for 10 to 30 minutes in a whitening tray could
be successful in reducing sensitivity in over 90%
of patients, allowing them to complete the
whitening procedure successfully.37 Tray application could be used either before or after the
whitening treatment. Because pain can occur
remotely from the whitening treatment, potassium nitrate could be used as needed during the
day or night. In severe situations, potassium
nitrate could be substituted for the whitening
material on alternating nights of wear.
There are 2 primary sources of potassium
nitrate: professional formulations or OTC products (Figure 5). The most familiar source is
desensitizing toothpaste. In the United States,
only potassium nitrate at a maximum of 5% is
allowed by the Food and Drug Administration
to be used in desensitizing toothpastes, because
this material and concentration have the best
scientific evidence for treating tooth sensitivity.
Hence, all flavors of Sensodyne,a, a popular
desensitizing toothpaste, now contain potassium nitrate (some flavors previously contained
strontium chloride or other ingredients), as do
all other desensitizing toothpastes (Colgate
Sensitive Maximum Strength,b, Crest
Sensitivity Protectionc, etc). Desensitizing
toothpastes have been shown to be effective,
but about 2 weeks of brushing is required for
effective sensitivity reduction.38 Tray delivery of
potassium nitrate for 10 to 30 minutes, much
like tray delivery of peroxide, seems to be much
more effective for acute sensitivity. There is one
caution regarding the use of desensitizing toothGlaxoSmithKline Consumer Healthcare, LP, 800-652-5625;
www.dental-professional.com
Colgate Oral Pharmaceuticals, 800-2-COLGATE; www.colgate.com
c
The Procter & Gamble Company, 800-492-7378; www.crest.com
a
14
d
e
f
Figure 4Tray design can influence sensitivity and depends on the type of whitening material used, patient concerns/habits, tooth alignment, and gingival condition. (A) single-tooth tray; (B) temporomandibular dysfunction tray; (C) nonscalloped tray; (D) scalloped tray.
15
RELIEF (5%)
(Discus Dental)
Desensitize! (5%)
(Den-Mat)
UltraEZ (3%)
(Ultradent)
Included in some
whitening systems
Sensodyne
all 8 products are
5% potassium nitrate
Crest Sensitivity
Protection
Colgate Sensitive
Oral-B Rembrandt
Whitening for Sensitive
Teeth
Other toothpaste
Figure 5There are both professionally supplied and over-thecounter sources of potassium nitrate.42
16
Tooth VAS
Control
toothpaste
16
Potassium
nitrate
toothpaste
12
10
11
12
13
14
Whitening Days
Figure 6Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) values of sensitivity during whitening from a recent study are less with prebrushing for 2 weeks
using a potassium nitratecontaining toothpaste (Sensodyne) compared to a regular fluoride-containing control (from J Clin Dent:41 Used
with permission).
Vol. 26, No. 9 (Suppl 3)
17
70%
Control toothpaste
60%
Potassium nitrate
toothpaste
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Days 13
Days 47
Days 814
Figure 7After prebrushing with a potassium nitratecontaining toothpaste, the percentage of patients experiencing sensitivity is less for
each group of days of whitening treatment (from J Clin Dent:41 Used with permission).
Figure 8Tray application of potassium nitratecontaining toothpaste (left) for the treatment of tooth sensitivity caused by whitening,
exposed dentin, or prophylaxis (right).
18
Conclusion
Many options exist for treating whitening
sensitivity. Prebrushing with a potassium
nitratecontaining toothpaste can reduce or
avoid sensitivity from whitening. Tray application of potassium nitrate can be an effective
episodic treatment for sensitivity. Treatment
time variations, use of different concentrations
of material, and varying tray designs all can be
part of a sensitivity management program. It is
far better to try to avoid or minimize sensitivity using these methods than to treat sensitivity
after it occurs. Even with all of these options,
there are still some patients who cannot manage their sensitivity and elect to terminate the
whitening treatment. Sensitivity seems to be a
multifactorial event that cannot be entirely
controlled in every patient. Additionally, some
patients may have an exaggerated response to
Vol. 26, No. 9 (Suppl 3)
any dental treatment, for which other treatments including psychological counseling are
required.59 However, the majority of patients,
after a proper dental examination, history, and
radiographs, can find an appropriate method
ie, adjustment of treatment time and material,
brushing with a desensitizing toothpaste containing potassium nitrate, or tray application of
potassium nitrateto minimize any sensitivity
they may encounter and successfully complete
the whitening process.
Disclosure
The author is a consultant to Ultradent
Products, Inc, Colgate Oral Pharmaceuticals;
Discus Dental, Inc; Marion Laboratories;
Procter & Gamble Company; ArchTek Inc;
and GlaxoSmithKline. He receives grant support from Colgate Oral Pharmaceuticals;
Ultradent Products, Inc; Marion Laboratories;
and ArchTek Inc. He is a sponsored speaker for
Colgate Oral Pharmaceuticals; Ultradent
Products, Inc; Discus Dental, Inc; DENTSPLY
International; and GlaxoSmithKline, and he
receives product support from many whitening
companies.
References
1. Haywood VB. Frequently asked questions about bleaching.
Compend Contin Educ Dent. 2003;24:324-338.
2. Haywood VB. Current status of nightguard vital bleaching.
Compend Contin Educ Dent. 2000;21(suppl 28):S10-S17.
3. Papathanasiou A, Bardwell D, Kugel G. A clinical study
evaluating a new chairside and take-home whitening system. Compend Contin Educ Dent. 2001;22:289-296.
4. Lu AC, Margiotta A, Nathoo SA. In-office tooth whitening: current procedures. Compend Contin Educ Dent. 2001;
22:798-805.
5. Kugel G, Ferreira S, Sharma S, et al. Clinical trial assessing
light enhancement of in-office tooth whitening [abstract]. J
Dent Res. 2005;84(spec iss A). Abstract 0287. Available at:
http://iadr.confex.com/iadr/2005Balt/techprogram/abstract_
60184.htm. Accessed May 5, 2005.
6. Goldstein RE. Bleaching discolored teeth. In: Esthetics in Dentistry. 2nd ed. Hamilton, Ontario: BC Decker Inc; 1998:263.
7. Goldstein CE, Goldstein RE, Feinman RA, et al. Bleaching
vital teeth: state of the art. Quintessence Int. 1989;20:729-737.
8. Al Shethri S, Matis BA, Cochran MA, et al. A clinical evaluation of two in-office bleaching products. Oper Dent.
2003;28:488-495.
9. Kugel G, Aboushala A, Zhou X, et al. Daily use of whitening strips on tetracycline-stained teeth: comparative results
after 2 months. Compend Contin Educ Dent. 2002;23:29-34.
10. Gerlach RW, Zhou X. Comparative clinical efficacy of two
professional bleaching systems. Compend Contin Educ Dent.
2002;23:35-41.
11. Gerlach RW, Sagel PA, Jeffers ME, et al. Effect of peroxide
concentration and brushing on whitening clinical response.
Compend Contin Educ Dent. 2002;23:16-21.
12. Gerlach RW, Sagel PA. Vital bleaching with a thin peroxide
gel: the safety and efficacy of a professional-strength hydrogen
Compendium / September 2005
19
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
20