Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Member ASHRAE
Fellow ASHRAE
ABSTRACT
The rates of water evaporation from indoor and outdoor
swimming pools in active use have been measured and
compared with evaporation rates from unoccupied pools and
with values calculated by the equation W=(95+0.425 v) (pwpa)Y, where W is evaporation rate, lb/h ft2; v is air velocity at
water surface, ft/min.; pw is saturation vapor pressure at water
temperature, in. Hg; pa is saturation vapor pressure at air
dewpoint, in. Hg; and Y is latent heat at pool temperature, Btu/
lb. In undisturbed pools, evaporation rates were measured and
found to be 74% of the rates obtained by use of the equation.
Rates of evaporation from pools in active use increase with the
number of swimmers, rising 40% to 70% above the rates from
a quiet water surface. Measurements of evaporation from a
pool in use by 15 to 20 swimmers per 1,000 ft2 were found to
average 26% higher than the rate calculated by the equation.
where
W
v
pw
pa
INTRODUCTION
The design of equipment for heating water in indoor and
outdoor swimming pools and for heating ventilation air in
indoor pools requires reliable information on rates of heat loss
from the pools. Such information is also needed for predicting
energy quantities and costs and for estimating the savings
obtainable by use of energy conservation measures. Proper
sizing of water heaters, air heaters, ventilation fans, heat
exchangers, dehumidification systems, and numerous accessories and the evaluation of heat recovery systems, pool
covers, and other energy saving equipment are directly
involved.
In indoor pools, virtually all the heat supplied to the pool
water is dissipated to air in the natatorium by evaporation.
Radiation and convection transfers are usually negligible.
Moisture entering the air must be removed either by ventilation (requiring fresh-air heating when outdoor temperatures
are appreciably below 80F) or by condensation in a dehumid-
(1)
This formula was based on the results of measurements of evaporation from a shallow pan of water over which air was passed
in a wind tunnel. Water losses were correlated with vapor pressures, humidities, and air velocity.
Investigations of evaporation from open outdoor tanks by
Rohwer (1931), from outdoor Florida pools by Root (1983),
from five outdoor pools in Switzerland by Molinaux et al.
(1994), and from measurement of condensate recovery from
dehumidifier systems in German pools by Labohm (1971),
Biasin and Krumme (1974), and Reeker (1978) have produced
widely differing results. Variations in test conditions, uncertain measurement accuracy, and departures from typical pool
designs have prevented significant use of any of these findings, thus leaving the ASHRAE relationship generally used
for estimating pool evaporation and the requirements for heating and ventilation.
Charles Smith is a research scientist and George Lf is professor emeritus and founding director of the Colorado State University Solar Energy
Applications Laboratory, Fort Collins, Colo. Randy W. Jones is a federal energy program specialist with the U.S. Department of Energy,
Golden, Colo.
514
515
TEST FACILITIES
Indoor Pool
A municipal facility in Fort Collins City comprises three
pools; a 1,200 ft2 wading/play pool, a 900 ft2 therapy pool, and
a 13,000 ft2 athletic/fitness pool (Figure 2). The three pools are
mechanically independent, having separate water recirculation, heating, chemical treatment, and make-up water systems.
The pools share the same natatorium space and equipment
area. The large athletic pool selected for this study has a total
water volume of 526,000 gallons (4.38 million pounds).
The pools were open to swimming and other activities
each day for 8-12 hours. The large pool served a number of
activities at one time, such as swimming, diving, and aquatic
exercise. The number of people in the pool varied from 1-2 and
up to more than 150.
Pool-water
temperatures
were
thermostatically
controlled normally at 80F - 82F. The room air was normally
at 85F and 50% relative humidity. Automatic humidity
control regulated the supply of fresh air and the operation of
exhaust fans. The entire complex is served by the same heating
equipment, so fuel used specifically for pool heating could not
be measured.
Outdoor Pool
The site for testing the outdoor pool in active use was the
same as used earlier for the inactive pool tests. The pool is
operated by a neighborhood association and is open for
approximately three months in the summer. Its total surface
area is 4125 ft2 and contains 144,000 gallons of water (1.2
million pounds). Buildings, trees, and fences are set back at
least 20 ft, so the pool is relatively open to wind and solar radiation exposure (Figure 3). Radiation losses from the pool are
directly to the sky.
The pool is maintained at temperatures near 83F by a
thermostat in the return water line. Natural-gas billing records
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
Measurement of Temperatures, Humidity,
and Air Velocity
The rate of evaporation from a water surface is proportional to the difference between the vapor pressure of the
liquid water and the partial pressure of water vapor in the
immediately adjacent air. Determination of these two quantities requires the measurement of water temperature, air
temperature, and air humidity (or dew point). Air and water
temperatures were measured with calibrated T-type thermocouples, with voltage recorded at six-minute intervals by use
of a desktop computer-controlled data-acquisition unit.
Differences between sensors and between repeated measurements with the same sensor did not exceed 0.1F.
Air humidity was obtained by monitoring the dew point
temperature with a dew-point hygrometer. This instrument
was calibrated against a secondary dew-point temperature
standard immediately prior to use. The limit of departure of
0.2F corresponds to a humidity difference of approximately
0.6%.
Outdoor wind speed was obtained by the use of a rotating
cup anemometer located at the edge of the pool, 1 ft above the
water surface.
Determination of Evaporation Rate
516
Two methods have been used for determining evaporation rates. One procedure involves the precise measurement of
the change in water level during an extended period when no
ASHRAE Transactions: Research
518
TABLE 1
Indoor Pool*
Test
reference number
Evaporation
heat rate,
Btu/hft2
pw - pa,
in. HG
Inactive pool
evaporation heat rate, Evaporation ratio,
active/inactive
Btu/hft2 (Equation 2)
4.1
.69
2.4
49.7
.603
44.0
1.13
3.9
.74
7.6
55.7
.521
38.0
1.47
3.7
.87
2.6
71.2
.881
64.3
1.11
4.2
.91
7.4
64.5
.621
45.3
1.43
2.8
.65
7.2
68.8
.692
50.4
1.36
9.4
1.43
.7
44.5
.544
39.7
1.12
3.2
.63
8.9
58.1
.554
40.4
1.44
3.6
.59
0.0
48.9
.633
46.2
1.06
13.0
1.67
0.0
37.9
.553
40.3
0.94
10
3.0
.48
1.6
48.2
.570
41.6
1.16
11
2.7
.45
12.7
50.7
.455
33.2
1.53
12
1.1
.25
13.0
69.1
.609
44.4
1.56
13
1.5
.36
12.2
71.0
.591
43.1
1.65
14
.75
.18
13.8
72.4
.585
42.7
1.69
Pool temperature, 81.5F - 82.5F; air temperature, 80F - 83F; air relative humidity, 45% - 55%.
TABLE 2
Outdoor Pool
Test
Test
reference duration, Swimmers/
1000 ft2
number
h
Average
water temp.
during test
period
Measured
depth
Wind
change
velocity, (decrease),
mph
in.
Evap.,
lb/hft2
Equiv.
evap.
heat rate
(1045xG),
Btu/hft2
Calculated
evap. heat rate
from inactive
pool at same
pw - pa, wind speed,
in. HG
Btu/hft2
Evap.
ratio,
active/
inactive
5.3
7.5
82.2
2.2
0.147
0.144
151
0.811
112
1.34
4.0
6.3
82.9
1.3
0.091
0.118
123
0.871
96
1.28
5.9
6.5
81.7
1.1
0.105
0.092
96
0.721
75
1.29
3.4
6.5
83.5
0.5
0.063
0.096
100
0.772
65
1.54
3.6
1.9
84.0
1.5
0.058
0.083
87
0.690
80
1.08
4.0
1.2
82.7
2.8
0.096
0.125
131
0.809
128
1.03
6.5
2.2
81.2
2.0
0.083
0.128
134
0.840
111
1.21
4.2
8.0
83.2
1.4
0.082
0.101
106
0.751
85
1.25
3.8
3.9
82.0
2.8
0.110
0.150
157
0.822
130
1.21
10
5.6
4.1
81.9
2.9
0.148
0.137
143
0.754
121
1.18
11
4.8
3.9
83.1
2.7
0.136
0.147
154
0.773
120
1.29
12
4.0
4.4
83.0
2.2
0.094
0.122
128
0.668
92
1.40
520
Persons /1000 ft
0.5
1.00
1.23
1.46
1.93
2.40
1.28
1.57
1.87
2.47
3.07
10
1.47
1.81
2.16
2.86
3.55
15
1.665
2.06
2.45
3.24
4.03
521
1.
Study more than one indoor pool and use the most direct
method of measurement possible, such as the use of a
mechanical dehumidifier. the condensate can then directly
be measured.
2.
REFERENCES
ASHRAE. 1987. 1987 ASHRAE HandbookHVAC Applications, p. 4.7. Atlanta: American Society of Heating,
Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, Inc.
ASHRAE. 1991. 1991 ASHRAE HandbookHVAC Applications, p. 4.7. Atlanta: American Society of Heating,
Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, Inc.
ASHRAE. 1995. 1995 ASHRAE HandbookHVAC Applications, p. 4.7. Atlanta: American Society of Heating,
Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, Inc.
Biasin, Von K., and W. Krumme. 1974. Evaporation in an
indoor swimming pool. Electrowarme International, pp.
a115-a129. May (Germany).
Carrier, W.H. 1918. The temperature of evaporation.
ASHRAE Transactions 24: 25.
Jones, R., C. Smith, and G. Lf. 1994. Measurement and
analysis of evaporation from an inactive outdoor swimming pool, Solar Energy 53(1): 3.
Labohm, G. 1971. Heating and air conditioning of swimming
pools. Gesundheits Ingenieur, pp. 72-80. March (Germany).
Molinaux, B., B. Lachal, and O. Guisan. 1994. Thermal
analysis of five outdoor swimming pools heated by
unglazed solar collectors. Solar Energy 53(1): 21.
Reeker, J. 1978. Water evaporation in indoor swimming
pools. Klima & Kalte Ingenieur, no. 1, pp. 29-32. January (Germany).
Rohwer, D. 1931. Evaporation from free water surfaces.
Tech. Bulletin no. 271, U.S. Dept. of Agriculture.
Root, D. 1983. How to determine the heat load of swimming
pools. Solar Age, pp. 20-23. November.
Smith, C.C., R. Jones, and G. Lf. 1993. Energy Requirements and Potential Savings for Heated Indoor Swimming Pools. ASHRAE Transactions 99(2): 864.
soil condition
pool insulation
3.
4.
The condition of the deck area affects greatly the evaporation rate of an indoor pool. Wet deck areas that retain water
add considerably to the evaporation rate, that does not
reflect in the heating requirement of the pool water.
5.
Randall Jones:
1. The scientific value of this study can be best assessed
in the context of the whole series of pool evaporation rate
experiments conducted by the authors. The series investigated
evaporation rates in indoor and outdoor pools, under quiet and
active conditions. Quiet indoor and outdoor pool results have
been reported in ASHRAE Transactions DE-93-12-3 and
Solar Energy Journal, July 1994, respectively. The purpose
was to aid engineering professionals in sizing and designing
pool HVAC equipment, estimating pool energy use, and
predicting savings from pool energy conservation measures.
In all, 2 indoor and 1 outdoor facilities were used. One of
the indoor facilities contained 3 separate pools, so a total of 5
pools were investigated. For the quiet pool studies, evaporation rate measurement was determined by the most direct
method possible, measurement of volume loss by high precision measure of water level change. Secondary measurements of pool energy inputs from the heating system and
losses by measurement of temperature drop and radiation and
calculation losses for the outdoor pool were used to confirm
water level measurements. Our confidence in this method
was aided by the following results:
DISCUSSION
Reinhold Kittler, Chairman, Dectron, Inc., Montreal,
Quebec: The scientific value of this study would be enhanced
with the following:
522
523