Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
EXHIBITS
TO RESPONSE TO SUSAN HUNTS
OPPOSITION TO
ATTORNEYS LIEN
(November 10, 2015)
7/8/15 Email agreeing to accept 850,000 to 900,000 dollars. See also, Exhibit 4:6.
2.
8/12/15 3:41 p.m. Email (two choices: Say what you want or settle and get the money.
See also Exhibit 4:42.)
3.
8/12/15 5:06 p.m. Phone Conversation (Susan would go ahead and sign with nondisparagement provisions, and it could be communicated to defendants because she was
available tomorrow to come down and sign. See also Exhibit 4:45.)
4.
5.
Release with Press Releases, Final Versions, signed by Curtis Hunt & Defendants.
6.
Early Settlement Letters sent to Christopher Duffy and Heather White, dated October 6,
2014 and December 18, 2014, copied to Susan Hunt and her sister.
7.
8.
9.
Press Reports Re: Susan Hunts complaints about Robert Sykes (sampling).
10.
Tweets and Re-tweets, and Facebook Postings from or instigated by Susan Hunt Re: Sykes
(various dates).
11.
12.
Case
Case2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW Document
Document17-17
50-6 Filed
Filed11/17/15
09/30/15 Page
Page11of
of79
Case
Case2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW Document
Document17-17
50-6 Filed
Filed11/17/15
09/30/15 Page
Page22of
of79
Attorneys investigation of the Incident, the Department of Justices investigation of the Incident,
or the settlement agreed upon in this Release, to the Press Release attached hereto as Exhibit 1.
Claimants further agree to close all social media accounts that contain negative comments about
Releasees or, alternatively, remove all such negative posts and comments to those posts.
Releasees agree that they will not defame or disparage Claimants in a defamatory or
disparaging manner in any medium or to any person or entity without limitation in time and they
will not encourage or condone others doing so. Releasees agree to limit their statements
regarding the Incident, the action filed in the United States District Court, District of Utah
entitled Hunt, et al. v. Schauerhamer, et al., Case No. 2:15-CV-00001-TC, the Utah County
Attorneys investigation of the Incident, the Department of Justices investigation of the Incident,
or the settlement agreed upon in this Release, to the Press Release attached hereto as Exhibit 2.
Releasees have read and reviewed the Press Release attached hereto as Exhibit 1 and
shall not object to the distribution of such Press Release. Claimants have read and reviewed the
Press Release attached hereto as Exhibit 2 and shall not object to the distribution of such Press
Release. Claimants and Releasees agree they will make no public statements other than those
contained in the Press Releases attached as Exhibits 1 and 2 relating to the Incident, the action
filed in the United States District Court, District of Utah entitled Hunt, et al. v. Schauerhamer, et
al., Case No. 2:15-CV-00001-TC, the Utah County Attorneys investigation of the Incident, the
Department of Justices investigation of the Incident, or the settlement agreed upon in this
Release.
The parties agree and acknowledge that the non-disparagement and confidentiality
provisions of this Release are material terms of the parties agreement, the absence of which
would have resulted in all Parties refusing to enter into this Release. In the event of a violation of
the non-disparagement provision and/or confidentiality provision of this Release, the nonbreaching parties shall have the right to monetary relief, regardless of the number of instances of
alleged breaches. If a person or entity not a party to this release makes a disparaging comment
about Releasees, Releasees shall have the right to publicly respond to such comments in a nondisparaging manner without being found to have breached the non-disparagement and/or
confidentiality provisions of this Release. Claimants shall not have the opportunity to publicly
respond to any statements made by Releasees under such circumstances. If a person or entity not
a party to this release makes a disparaging comment about Claimants or Darrien Hunt, Claimants
shall have the right to publicly respond to such comments in a non-disparaging manner without
being found to have breached the non-disparagement and/or confidentiality provisions of this
Release. Releasees shall not have the opportunity to publicly respond to any statements made by
Claimants under such circumstances.
Releasees further agree they will not object to a request by the Hunt family to the Utah
County Attorney to release Darrien Hunts personal effects.
Page 2 of 5
Case
Case2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW Document
Document17-17
50-6 Filed
Filed11/17/15
09/30/15 Page
Page33of
of79
Claimants warrant that all outstanding liens of any kind arising from claims Claimants
have asserted as a result of the Incident have been or will be satisfied with the funds received in
exchange for this Release. Claimants further represents that neither they, Darrien Hunt, nor any
dependent (or former dependent) family member is presently eligible for or has ever been
enrolled in or received benefits under Medicare or Medicaid. Claimants agree to indemnify and
hold Releasees harmless from any claims, attorneys' fees or other expenses that might be
asserted against it by any lienholder or other third party as a result of the claims Claimants have
asserted as a result.
CLAIMANTS FURTHER STATE THAT THEY HAVE CAREFULLY READ THE
FOREGOING RELEASE OF ALL CLAIMS, KNOW THE CONTENTS THEREOF, HAVE
CONSULTED WITH THEIR ATTORNEY CONCERNING THE CONTENTS THEREOF
AND SIGN THE SAME AS THEIR OWN FREE ACT.
DATED this
COUNTY OF
day of September, 2015, personally appeared before me, Susan Hunt, who
On the
duly acknowledged to me that she executed the foregoing Release of All Claims and upon her
oath, duly acknowledged to me that she executed the same as her own free act and deed.
NOTARY PUBLIC
Residing at:
My Commission Expires:
lim
Scis si i)04n4a
DATED this 15.4/1 day of September, 20!1to ni
ZdVS
Curtis Hunt
STATE OF
: ss.
COUNTY OF WITH THE U1)41TED STATES ARMED
Case
Case2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW Document
Document17-17
50-6 Filed
Filed11/17/15
09/30/15 Page
Page44of
of79
On the 10 day of September, 2015, personally appeared before me, Curtis Hunt, who
duly acknowledged to me that he executed the foregoing Settlement Agreement and Release of
All Claims and upon his oath, duly acknowledged to me t he executed the same as his own
ael.-atict deed.
ARY PUBIF
Residing at:
/ 04 5'4)44. / ,J/4P471
My Commissi6nExpires:
DATED this
By Susan Hunt
Personal Representative of the
Estate of Darrien Hunt
STATE OF
:SS.
COUNTY OF
Before me, the undersigned notary, personally appeared Susan Hunt, to me known to be
the person who signed the foregoing instrument, who did duly acknowledge under oath that the
information contained therein is true and correct and that she executed the same on behalf of, and
with full power and authority to bind the above-named signatory.
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME this _ day of September, 2015.
My Commission Expires:
Notary Public
Residing at:
Page 4 of 5
Case
Case2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW Document
Document17-17
50-6 Filed
Filed11/17/15
09/30/15 Page
Page55of
of79
DATED this
By Mark Christensen
City Manager
STATE OF
)j
COUNTY OF /,/t
My Commission Expires:
Notar~lublic
Residihg at:
LORI A. YATES
voTARYPUBUC-STATE OF UTAH
3MMISSION# 6507n
Page 5 of 5
Case
Case2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW Document
Document17-17
50-6 Filed
Filed11/17/15
09/30/15 Page
Page67of
of79
The family of Darrien Hunt has resolved its lawsuit against the City of Saratoga Springs and its
officers related to Darrien's death. As previously stated, Darriens family believes that Darriens
death was not justified and that the Utah County Attorneys investigation was not impartial.
However, it is important for families to have closure in order to begin the healing process.
The family is gratified that the Saratoga Springs Police Department now has functional body
cameras. Both citizens and law enforcement benefit from the use of body cameras, as we have
seen with encounters between citizens and officers in other instances.
Nothing can replace Darrien in the hearts of his family. With this resolution, the family will try
to move forward while honoring Darriens memory. In furtherance of the parties desires for
closure, there will be no further written or oral comment by the parties or their representatives.
Case
Case2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW Document
Document17-17
50-6 Filed
Filed11/17/15
09/30/15 Page
Page79of
of79
10 Exchange Place, 11th Floor
Salt Lake City, Utah 84111
Main: 801.521.9000
www.scmlaw.com
Heather S. White
LAWYER
Direct: 801.322.9125
Cell: 801.201.7220
hsw@scmlaw.com
PRESS RELEASE
Today the family of Darrien Hunt, the City of Saratoga Springs, and its officers settled the
lawsuit related to Mr. Hunts death for $900,000. The City and the officers involved in the
incident dispute the Hunt familys claims that the officers acted inappropriately, including the
familys allegations that Mr. Hunt was shot in the back while on the ground and that he was
targeted because of his race.
Officers do not have the time to analyze and debate about how to respond to a situation, which is
what occurs during the litigation process. While the Utah County Attorneys Office concluded
the shooting was justified, the current climate surrounding law enforcement makes defending
civil rights cases costly and risky, even with favorable facts. The Citys insurance carrier and the
City determined that settling the case removes that risk. It additionally provides closure and
allows all parties - the Hunt family, the City and the officers - a chance to heal and move on from
this very public, emotionally-charged case.
Settlement of the Hunt familys claims will allow the City and the officers to continue to direct
their time and energy toward serving the citizens of Saratoga Springs in a positive manner. The
City and the officers again express their condolences to the Hunt family for their loss and wish
them well as they move forward. In furtherance of the parties desires for closure, there will be
no further written statements or comments by the parties or their representatives about the
incident or the facts and circumstances surrounding it.
Svr<ES
McAt-LISTER
I.AW ilFFIL:ES PLLT
3l I So. State Street, #240
Attomevs:
Robert B. Sykes
Alyson C. McAllister
Of Counsel:
Rachel L. Sykest
fAlso licensed in Idaho
October 6,2014
Heather S. White
SNow, CrrRrsrsNspN & ManUNEAU
10 Exchange Place, Eleventh Floor
P. O. Box 45000
Salt Lake City, Utah 84145-5000
Re:
Dear Heather,
I have been asked by my clients to inform you that we are in the process of preparing
a Complaint. I suspect I will have the final version drafted in around ten days. We are gathering
information for it as we speak.
I have also been instructed by my client to inquire whether or not there is interest in
trying to resolve this case prior to filing. It would seem to be a prudent thing to do. Please make
inquiries and let me know. We have a figure in mind as an opening offer, but if there is no interest
in doing this, it makes no sense to disclose it now. Please advise at your earliest convenience.
I am enclosing
a copy
of this for Mr. Dufff, who I noted is the adjuster on the case.
Very truly yours,
I
Robert
Susan Hunt
Cynthia Moss
Christopher Dufff
RBS:dcc
SvmES
MCAILISTER
LAw (tF F t(- E: I'LLI
Attomeys:
Robert B. Sykes
Alyson C. McAllister
OfCounsel:
Rachel L. Sykesf
October 6,2014
Christopher Dufff
c/o Heather S. White
SNow, CrrusrpNspN & MenrrNEAU
10 Exchange Place, Eleventh Floor
P. O. Box 45000
salt Lake city, utah 84145-5000
Re:
I noticed you were copied on Ms. White's earlier letter. It is nice to have you on
the case.
Yey\rutv
ecc:
Susan Hunt
Cynthia Moss
RBS:dcc
SvKEs
McALLISTTR
1,,1,\.*
I I So. State Street, #240
Salt Lake City, UT 841I I
(801) 533-0222 phone
Attomevs:
Robert B. Sykes
Alyson C. McAllister
rll ii.-lr
i'L
Lt.OfCounsel:
Rachel L. Sykest
fAlso licmsed in Idaho
December 18,2014
VIA EMAIL
Re:
Enclosures
ecc:
RBS:ss:dcc
Date
Received
Item Description
10/9/2014
10/9/2014
10/9/2014
10/9/2014
10/9/2014
10/22/2014
10/23/2014
10/31/2014
11/12/2014
11/12/2014
11/12/2014
10/2/2014
10/24/2014
10/31/2014
10/30/2014
11/14/2014
# of
Pages
Submitted By
9
2
2
2
7
7
3
3
5
5
5
M. Dell'Ergo
Judge Davis
Judge Davis
Judge Davis
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
C. Grunander
Judge Laycock
Judge Laycock
Judge Laycock
Judge Laycock
3
26
52
13
2
J.Robinson
S.Finch
J. Robinson
M. Dell'Ergo
S.Finch
J.Robinson
S.Finch
J. Robinson
M. Dell'Ergo
S.Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
14
1
1
50
1
1
13
2
P. Johnston
Schauerhamer, SSPD
Deb Moultrie, FNS
J. Wright, SSPD
P. Johnston
Schauerhamer, SSPD
Z. Robinson, SSPD
Unified State Lab
P. Johnston
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
P. Johnston
P. Johnston
C. Crawford
H. Christensen
P. Johnston
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
10
1
1
1
1
2
2
R. Hales
Judson, SSPD
Deb Moultrie, FNS
R. Hales
Judson, SSPD
R. Hales
Z. Robinson, SSPD
Unified State Lab
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
R. Hales
R. Hales
R. Hales
C. Crawford
H. Christensen
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
1
1
J. Edwards, LI
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
M. Dell'Ergo
S. Finch
S. Finch
S. Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
JT Jensen, SBI
S. Finch
*Can only b
4
1
1
C. Manis, SSPD
L. Fox, UCSO
Z. Robinson, SSPD
S. Finch
S. Finch
S. Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
S. Finch
S. Finch
I:Drive
Aaron Jones
Aaron Jones
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
S. Finch
S. Finch
S. Finch
S. Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
Received By
Evidence
Location
COURT DOCUMENTS
1
1-1
1-2
1-3
1-4
1-5
UCAO REPORTS
2
2-1
2-2
2-3
2-4
2-5
2-6
2-7
2-8
2-9
3
3-1
3-2
3-3
3-4
3-5
3-6
3-7
3-8
4-5
4-6
4-7
4-8
4-9
4-10
4-11
4-12
4-13
4
4-1
4-2
4-3
4-4
M. Dell'Ergo
I:Drive
M. Dell'Ergo
I:Drive
M. Dell'Ergo
I:Drive
M. Dell'Ergo
I:Drive
M. Dell'Ergo
I:Drive
M. Dell'Ergo
I:Drive
Judge Laycock
I:Drive
C. Grunander
I:Drive
*Waiting for Judicual Review
*Waiting for Judicual Review
*Waiting for Judicual Review
CRIME SCENE
9/15/2014
9/15/2014
9/15/2014
9/15/2014
11/14/2014
Page 1
8
1
1
2
11/14/2014
11/14/2014
Item Description
Scene Sketches
Doug Squire's Case Report
Lee Fox's Supplemental Report
GSR swabs Schauerhamer's upper door frame PR#UCP49486
GSR swabs Schauerhamer's lower door PR#UCP49487
GSR swabs Schauerhamer's spotlight PR#UCP49488
Bullet fragment recovered from back window of vehicle (#10)
PR#UCP49375
Bullet fragment recoverd from side of vehicle (#10)
PR#UCP49376
Casing located in parking stall near Panda Express
PR#UCP49377
Magazine w/ 14 rounds located in street near Top Stop
PR#UCP49378
Casing located in parking lot near vehicle (#10)
PR#UCP49379
Casing located in parking lot near vehicle (#10)
PR#UCP49380
Casing located in parking lot near vehicle (#10)
PR#UCP49381
Mini flashlight located in street near Top Stop PR#UCP49383
Casing located in parking lot near Panda Express & body
PR#UCP49384
Casing located in parking lot near Panda Express & body
PR#UCP49385
Bottle lid located in street btwn Credit Union & Top Stop
PR#UCP49386
Live Cartridge located in street near Top Stop
PR#UCP49387
Casing located in street near Top Stop PR#UCP49388
iPod Mini located on body PR#UCP49389
Ear Buds located on body PR#UCP49390
Blood Swab taken by Squire PR#UCP49391
Samurai Sword PR#UCP49392
Chain of Custody docs
Sword Cover PR#UCP49393
Chain of Custody docs
Samsung Cell Phone recovered from body PR#UCP49373
Pix of Officer's vehicle
Judson's Body Cam Video
Body Cam Property Field Report and L ruler
9/11/2014
9/10/2014
9/11/2014
9/10/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/18/2014
10/20/2014
4-20
9/10/2014
4-21
9/10/2014
4-22
9/10/2014
4-23
9/10/2014
4-24
9/10/2014
4-25
9/10/2014
4-26
9/10/2014
4-27
9/10/2014
4-28
9/10/2014
4-29
9/10/2014
4-30
9/10/2014
4-31
9/10/2014
4-32
4-33
4-34
4-35
9/10/2014
9/10/2014
9/10/2014
9/10/2014
9/10/2014
10/30/2014
9/10/2014
10/30/2014
9/10/2014
4-36
4-37
4-38
4-39
4-40
4-41
5
5-1
5-2
5-3
5-4
5-5
5-6
5-7
5-8
5-9
5-10
5-11
5-12
5-13
Submitted By
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
Evidence
Received By
Location
S. Finch
I:Drive
S. Finch
I:Drive
S. Finch
I:Drive
D. Squire, UCSO UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
D. Squire, UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
I:Drive
UCSO
I:Drive
UCSO
P. Burnett, SSPD
P. Burnett, SSPD
S. Finch
S. Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
T. Wallace, OPD
T. Wallace, OPD
T. Wallace, OPD
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
6
6-1
6-2
# of
Pages
5
16
5
3
2
5
14
6
7
6
11
3
16
4
T. Wallace, OPD
M. Dell'Ergo
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
2
1
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
11/14/2014
Page 2
Date
Received
9/11/2014
9/10/2014
9/11/2014
7
7-1
7-2
7-3
7-4
7-5
7-6
S. Liddiard, AF
S. Liddiard, AF
S. Liddiard, AF
C. Crawford
Paul Cook
S. Liddiard, AF
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
2
1
7
1
1
2
1
1
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
Brian Pedocki
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
2
1
4
1
B. Davis, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
C. Crawford
B. Davis, SBI
A. Allred
S. Finch
S. Finch
C. Crawford
G. Knapp
A. Allred
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
12
1
1
1
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
2
1
B. Davis, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
C. Crawford
J. Robinson
S. Finch
S. Finch
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
8
1
1
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
C. Crawford
D. Ventrano, LP
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
C. Crawford
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
1
1
B. Davis, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
C. Crawford
A. Allred
S. Finch
S. Finch
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
I:Drive
14
14-1
1
1
6
1
8
1
13
13-1
13-2
13-3
13-4
12
12-1
12-2
12-3
12-4
12-5
Evidence
Location
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
11
11-1
11-2
11-3
11-4
Received By
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
10
10-1
10-2
10-3
10-4
10-5
10-6
Submitted By
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
J. Swenson, LE
9
9-1
9-2
9-3
9-4
9-5
9-6
# of
Pages
9
1
1
8
8-1
8-2
8-3
8-4
8-5
8-6
8-7
8-8
Item Description
Sgt. Ferrell's Rpt RE Wride's Intv
Pic of Wride day of incident
Wride's Scene Diagram
11/14/2014
Page 3
Date
Received
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/10/2014
9/10/2014
9/11/2014
15
15-1
15-2
15-3
15-4
15-5
J. Stilson, AF
J. Stilson, AF
J. Stilson, AF
C. Crawford
J. Stilson, AF
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
C. Crawford
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
2
1
2
1
B. Davis, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
C. Crawford
J. Robinson
S. Finch
S. Finch
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
2
4
1
1
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
7
1
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
4
1
1
7
1
1
S. Liddiard, AF
S. Liddiard, AF
S. Liddiard, AF
S. Liddiard, AF
S. Liddiard, AF
S. Liddiard, AF
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
2
1
1
4
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
K. Flinton, SSPD
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
S. Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
2
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
2
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
S. Finch
S. Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
2
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
S. Finch
S. Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
9/29/2014
9/29/2014
ALYIA HUNT
23
23-1
23-2
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
22
22-1
22-2
1
1
4
1
1
21
21-1
21-2
21-3
20
20-1
20-2
20-3
20-4
Evidence
Location
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
19
19-1
19-2
19-3
19-4
19-5
19-6
Received By
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
18
18-1
18-2
18-3
18-4
Submitted By
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
Orson Ludvigson
J. Swenson, LE
17
17-1
17-2
17-3
17-4
17-5
# of
Pages
1
7
1
2
1
16
16-1
16-2
16-3
16-4
Item Description
(1) CD: Ludvigson's Intv Audio
Det. Loveridge's Rpt RE Ludvigson Intv includes officer notes
Pic of Ludvigson day of incident
Pix taken by Ludvigson of scene
Ludvigson's Scene Diagram
11/14/2014
Page 4
Date
Received
24
24-1
24-2
24-3
# of
Pages
Submitted By
Received By
Evidence
Location
1
2
3
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
T. Wallace, OPD
S. Finch
S. Finch
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
2
3
1
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
G. Knapp
S. Finch
S. Finch
J.Robinson
G. Knapp
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
S. Finch
I:Drive
S. Finch
I:Drive
9/29/2014
9/29/2014
9/30/2014
9/25/2014
25
25-1
25-2
25-2a
25-3
Item Description
26
26-1
27
27-1
9/10/2014
27-2
9/25/2014
G. Knapp
I:Drive
9/17/2014
G. Knapp
I:Drive
29-1
29-2
29-3
29-4
29-5
29-6
29-7
29-8
29-9
29-10
29-11
29-12
29-13
29-14
29-15
29-16
29-17
29-18
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/30/2014
9/30/2014
9/30/2014
9/30/2014
9/30/2014
9/30/2014
9/30/2014
9/30/2014
10/2/2014
10/2/2014
10/2/2014
10/7/2014
10/7/2014
10/7/2014
9
1
2
1
6
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
D. Ventrano, LP
T. Duncan, SV
T. Duncan, SV
T. Duncan, SV
A. Rhoades, BYU
A. Rhoades, BYU
A. Rhoades, BYU
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
29-19
10/15/2014
W. Raab, BYU
J. Robinson
I:Drive
29-20
29-21
29-22
29-23
29-24
10/15/2014
10/15/2014
10/15/2014
11/14/2014
11/14/2014
5
7
1
2
1
W. Raab, BYU
W. Raab, BYU
W. Raab, BYU
J. Sutch, LIPD
J. Sutch, LIPD
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
9/12/2014
9/12/2014
9/11/2014
9/26/2014
10/27/2014
10/28/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
28
28-1
WAL-MART VIDEO
29
LEHI PD REPORTS
30
30-1
30-2
30-3
30-4
30-5
30-6
30-7
30-8
30-9
6
2
1
2
1
5
1
6
1
9
1
3
HUNT AUTOPSY
11/14/2014
Page 5
1
2
11
8
Date
Received
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
31
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
31-5
9/11/2014
31-6
9/11/2014
32
Submitted By
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
M. Dell'Ergo
Received By
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
D. Squire
Evidence
Location
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
UCSO
3
1
10
2
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
I:Drive
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
I:Drive
1
1
9
2
1
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
3
1
10
1
1
1
C. Crawford
Mike Veenendaal, UVD
Mike Veenendaal, UVD
Mike Veenendaal, UVD
Mike Veenendaal, UVD
Mike Veenendaal, UVD
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
C. Manis, SSPD
C. Manis, SSPD
C. Manis, SSPD
C. Manis, SSPD
C. Manis, SSPD
C. Manis, SSPD
T. Duncan, SV
T. Duncan, SV
T. Duncan, SV
T. Duncan, SV
T. Duncan, SV
T. Duncan, SV
N. Sandoval, PPD
N. Sandoval, PPD
N. Sandoval, PPD
N. Sandoval, PPD
N. Sandoval, PPD
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
9/15/2014
9/16/2014
9/16/2014
9/16/2014
9/16/2014
9/16/2014
34
34-1
34-2
34-3
34-4
34-5
34-6
34-7
34-8
34-9
34-10
34-11
34-12
34-13
34-14
34-15
34-16
34-17
34-18
34-19
34-20
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
9/11/2014
33
33-1
33-2
33-3
33-4
33-5
33-6
# of
Pages
31-1
31-2
31-3
31-4
32-1
32-2
32-3
32-4
32-5
Item Description
Black Underpants PR#318905
Brown Hair Elastic PR#318906
Bullet removed from upper right lung PR#318909
Bullet fragment located in head hair PR#318910
Bullet & bullet fragments taken from left hip PR#318911
Nail clippings taken from right hand PR#318900
White Sheet under body PR#318902
Head hair PR#318907
Blood Spot Card PR#318908
Bullet taken from left elbow PR#318912
Hunt's Fingerprint card PR#318913
Nail clippings taken from left hand PR#318915
Black Shoes PR#318916
11/14/2014
Page 6
10
4
2
1
1
1
2
13
1
14
1
11
1
9
1
1
2
1
Date
Received
10/10/2014
11/14/2014
11/14/2014
11/14/2014
11/14/2014
Item Description
Audio: Cpl. Taylor Intv. (CD maintained in item #60-2)
Sgt. Eastman's Intv Rpt RE Sgt. Christensen
Sgt. Christensen's Scene Diagram
Sgt. Eastman's Intv Rpt RE Det. Robinson
Det. Robinson's Scene Diagram
9/15/2014
10/27/2014
35
35-1
35-2
I:Drive
I:Drive
2
1
2
1
T. Peterson, LEPD
T. Peterson, LEPD
T. Peterson, LEPD
T. Peterson, LEPD
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
1
1
1
C. Ray, LE
C. Ray, LE
A. Allred
A. Allred
C. Ray, LE
C. Ray, LE
A. Allred
A. Allred
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
2
C. Ray, LE
C. Ray, LE
A. Allred
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
3
1
1
1
2
C. Ray, LE
C. Ray, LE
C. Ray, LE
C. Ray, LE
C. Ray, LE
A. Allred
A. Allred
A. Allred
A. Allred
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
2
1
1
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
J. Swenson, LE
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
D. Ventrano, LP
J. Robinson
I:Drive
G. Knapp
I:Drive
B. Monson
G. Knapp
I:Drive
2
1
8
1
1
E. Hernandez
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
E. Hernandez
E. Hernandez
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
K. Zundel
G. Knapp
I:Drive
EDGAR A. HERNANDEZ
9/18/2014
9/22/2014
10/7/2014
9/18/2014
9/22/2014
9/29/2014
45
45-1
9/16/2014
44
44-1
44-2
44-3
44-4
44-5
43
43-1
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
PAM BARNES
42
42-1
9/19/2014
9/19/2014
9/19/2014
9/19/2014
9/19/2014
41
41-1
Z. Robinson, SSPD
T. Peterson, LEPD
40
40-1
40-2
40-3
40-4
40-5
2
1
39
39-1
39-2
39-3
39-4
39-5
Evidence
Location
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
38
38-1
38-2
Received By
J. Robinson
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
C. Crawford
37
37-1
37-2
37-3
37-4
37-5
4
1
2
1
Submitted By
S. Dibble, SPD
J. Sutch, LIPD
J. Sutch, LIPD
J. Sutch, LIPD
J. Sutch, LIPD
36
36-1
36-2
36-3
36-4
# of
Pages
KIM ZUNDEL
11/14/2014
Page 7
46
46-1
46-2
9/29/2014
9/29/2014
9/29/2014
9/29/2014
9/29/2014
9/30/2014
10/7/2014
51
SPRINGVILLE PD REPORTS
51-1
10/2/2014
52
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
S. Finch
S. Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
2
1
3
1
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
1
1
1
1
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
JT Jensen, SBI
S. Finch
S. Finch
S. Finch
S. Finch
S. Finch
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
2
1
J. Buhman
D. Orcutt, UCAO
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
T. Duncan, SV
J. Robinson
I:Drive
A. Rhoades, BYU
J. Robinson
I:Drive
3
1
7
1
A. Rhoades, BYU
A. Rhoades, BYU
A. Rhoades, BYU
W. Raab, BYU
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
3
8
D. Oliver, UCSO
D. Oliver, UCSO
T. Duncan, SV
D. Oliver, UCSO
D. Oliver, UCSO
T. Duncan, SV
D. Oliver, UCSO
D. Oliver, UCSO
T. Duncan, SV
D. Oliver, UCSO
D. Oliver, UCSO
T. Duncan, SV
D. Oliver, UCSO
N. Sandoval, PPD
N. Sandoval, PPD
N. Sandoval, PPD
N. Sandoval, PPD
N. Sandoval, PPD
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
JENNIFER HAMPTON
10/7/2014
53
10/7/2014
10/7/2014
10/2/2014
10/7/2014
10/7/2014
10/2/2014
10/7/2014
10/7/2014
10/2/2014
10/7/2014
10/7/2014
10/2/2014
10/7/2014
10/3/2014
10/3/2014
10/3/2014
10/3/2014
10/3/2014
54
54-1
54-2
54-3
54-4
54-5
54-6
54-7
54-8
54-9
54-10
54-11
54-12
54-13
54-14
54-15
54-16
54-17
54-18
1
1
53-1
53-2
53-3
53-4
Evidence
Location
I:Drive
I:Drive
9/26/2014
52-1
Received By
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
SBI REPORTS
50
50-1
Submitted By
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
49
49-1
49-2
9/25/2014
9/25/2014
10/17/2014
11/3/2014
48
48-1
48-2
48-3
48-4
48-5
# of
Pages
1
6
47
47-1
47-2
47-3
47-4
Item Description
(1) CD: Zundell Intv Audio
Investigator Knapp's Rpt RE Zundel's Intv
UCSO REPORTS
11/14/2014
Page 8
1
7
1
7
1
8
1
2
1
8
1
1
Date
Received
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
11/6/2014
11/6/2014
11/6/2014
11/6/2014
11/6/2014
11/6/2014
11/6/2014
55
55-1
55-2
Evidence
Location
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
2
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
2
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
I:Drive
I:Drive
1
6
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
G. Knapp
I:Drive
I:Drive
2
4
N. Sandoval, PPD
N. Sandoval, PPD
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
2
1
3
1
1
1
3
1
1
1
3
1
1
1
3
1
3
1
3
1
4
4
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
J. Stilson, AFPD
B. Wilding
B. Wilding
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
S. Dibble, SPD
J. Robinson
I:Drive
S. Dibble, SPD
J. Robinson
I:Drive
1
1
1
1
1
59
59-1
59-2
59-3
59-4
59-5
59-6
59-7
59-8
59-10
59-11
59-12
59-13
59-14
59-15
59-16
59-17
59-18
59-19
59-20
59-21
59-22
59-23
Received By
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
A.Allred
A.Allred
A.Allred
A.Allred
A.Allred
A.Allred
A.Allred
58
58-1
58-2
Submitted By
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
J. Randall
J. Randall
J. Randall
J. Randall
J. Randall
J. Randall
J. Randall
57
57-1
57-2
# of
Pages
4
56
56-1
56-2
Item Description
Dep. Eckles Incident Rpt
Audio: Eckles Intv (CD maintained in item #60-2)
Eckles Scene Diagram (aerial google map)
Sgt. Dibble's Intv Rpt RE Eckles
Audio: Simons Intv (CD maintained in item #60-2)
Sgt. Dibble's Intv Rpt RE Simons
Sgt. Randall's Intv Rpt RE Officer Stidham
Sgt. Randall's Intv Rpt RE Officer Nelson
Nelson's Scene Diagram (whiteboard drawing)
Sgt. Randall's Intv Rpt RE Officer Redmond
Redmond's Scene Diagram (whiteboard drawing)
Sgt. Randall's Intv Rpt RE Officer Flinton
Flinton's Scene Diagram (whiteboard drawing)
60-1
10/10/2014
60-2
10/10/201
60
SALEM PD REPORTS
11/14/2014
Page 9
Date
Received
Item Description
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
10/10/2014
61
61-1
61-2
Submitted By
Received By
Evidence
Location
1
1
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
2
2
2
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
S. Dibble, SPD
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
J. Robinson
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
I:Drive
UHP REPORTS
62
62-1
62-2
62-3
62-4
# of
Pages
11/14/2014
Page 10
q t 1Cl
Case #:
1'1.5>
#6-1
14-96
9/11/14
JR
o<;fov
fl(J#B .
Time o/'Occurrence:
Namc:bCi~lG\(\(~--ill~c
DOB:
Addres
Phone:
3', LJ 0,___
.~ Age:
~--,-fi_
_,
City/State/Zip
Notice: You are nottfied that statements you are about to make may be presented to a magistrate or judge in lieu
0/yOW' sworn testimony at a preliminary examination. Pursuant to Utah Code Annotated 76-8.. 504 and Utah Code
Annotated 76-8-506, it is a crime to knowingly provide false information in this written statement.
"-1ru
.~l{tJJ2, W;1;L09Q
By my sif,rnature below, J certify that this statement is true, accurate, and complete, to the best of my
knOW
WItness
,~
By my signature below, I certify that I obtained this statement without coercion or duress under
circumstances guarantying its reliability:
Agent
Witness Statement
Case
Name:
y)/\ laV\ i- ~y rd
ill ~\A V
e
\
Q,.{2~yd.
ibr~MvQ ~r. bl(lQk PctY\i2 M1.4 _.<t V<d kloodje
+C- lO alad \ Iko 1M had eo. r bkds I n _ Car:r i hj
0\ ~Uj Qy at {JJ} a biD Dk;, C()lje.v () t1. /+.
..
\,I to. S
G\At\
Signature: _ _ _ ._ _
>_
__
._-,----
\-\-
Date:
- - -_.-
f>
'-----------------1 CAOOo9G
CASE #
('
Wu.1
1'
f'
P'
!L( AfOY:)a r
J#15-1
14-96
9/12/14
JR
/ Lj 55 Ot; i{;TO
Shel'l:ff James O. Tracy
Voluntary Statement
De u
Name:
L.-;Sp~n ~,r
Date
:---,q~~/!l=----:;.(-:~~_ _
Addr
Phon
City:
DOB:
Time:
10:; /J 111
NOTICE: Pursuant to Section 76-8-504.5, Utah Code Annotated, 1953 as amended. you are notified that statements you are about to make
may be presented to a magistrate or judge in lieu of your sworn testimony at a preliminary examination. Any false statement you make and
that you do not believe to be true may subject you to criminal punishment as a Class A Misdemeanor.
I do give this statement of my own free will. I understand that I have the right to remain silent, that anything Tsay can be used against me in a court
oflaw, that I have the right to talk to an attorney, and to have him present when Tmake this statement, that if! cannot afford an attorney one will be
so desire. I understand that I have the right to stop answering questions at any time.
abov ,I make the following statement.
tAe
Dispatch: 801-794-3970
page_I'---_of
9/11/2015
MomofDarrienHuntsayssherejected$900Ksettlementofferinson'sdeath
Case 2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
Document 50-10 Filed 11/17/15 Page 1 of 10
MomofDarrienHuntsayssherejected$900Ksettlement
offerinson'sdeath
Family,friendsrememberswordcarryingmanonanniversaryofpoliceshooting
death
ByBenLockhartandMcKenzieRomero,DeseretNews
Published:Friday,Sept.1120159:30a.m.MDT
SARATOGASPRINGSOntheoneyearanniversaryofherson's
shootingdeathatthehandsofpolice,SusanHuntvowedThursday
thatshewon'tacceptasettlementwithpolicethatdoesn'texplicitly
clearhimofwrongdoinginthefatalencounter.
DarrienHunt,22,diedwhentwoSaratogaSpringspoliceofficers
shothimsixtimesinthebackafterheunsheatheda3foot
souvenirkatanaswordhewascarryingandranfromthemneara
PandaExpressrestaurantonRedwoodRoad.Theofficershad
confrontedHuntashewalkeddownthestreetwiththeswordon
hisback,whichfamilymemberssaywaspartofaJapaneseanime
costume.
SusanHunttakeshersonKerahnand
sisterCindyMossbythehandsandtakes
offonarun,followingthelaststepsofher
sonDarrienHuntonSept.10,2015,in
SaratogaSprings.DarrienHuntwasshot
andkilledbypoliceoneyearago.
(ScottGWinterton,DeseretNews)
Flankedbydozensoffamilymembersandfriendsatthesiteofthe
shootingThursday,Huntannouncedshedeclineda$900,000civil
settlementwiththecityofSaratogaSpringsandthetwoofficers
whoshotherson,sayingshewouldhavebeenrequiredtostayquietabouttheincident.
"Tomeitwasagagorder(saying),'Heres
hushmoney,donteversayDarriensname
again,'"shesaid."Ihopetherewillbealegacy
insteadofahushorder."
Anattorneyforthecitydeclinedtocomment
aboutanyoffer.
WellwishersgatheredThursdayonthelawn
oftherestaurantnearthespotwhereHunt
wasshottoreleaseballoonsintothesky,play
hisfavoritemusic,andretracehisfinalsteps.
SusanHunthunchedoverwithemotionand
wasconsoledbyfamilymembersafter
completingthewalkaround.
SusanHuntwithhersonKerahnandsisterCindyMossholdeachother
atthespotwhereDarrienHuntwasshotandkilledbypolicein
SaratogaSpringsontheoneyearanniversaryofhisdeath,Thursday,
Sept.10,2015.(ScottGWinterton,DeseretNews)
http://www.deseretnews.com/article/print/865636522/MomofDarrienHuntsayssherejected900Ksettlementofferinsonsdeath.html
1/4
9/11/2015
MomofDarrienHuntsayssherejected$900Ksettlementofferinson'sdeath
Case 2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
Document 50-10 Filed 11/17/15 Page 2 of 10
"Ifeelsadlythatthemajorityof(SaratogaSpringsresidents)wouldpreferthatIjustshutupandgo
away,"shesaid."ButthetruthisDarriendidntswingtheswordattheofficers."
CrystalBrownwritesanoteasfamilyandfriendsofDarrienHuntgatherThursday,
Sept.10,2015,inSaratogaSpringsontheoneyearanniversaryofHunt'sdeath.Hewas
shotandkilledbypoliceofficers.(ScottGWinterton,DeseretNews)
Kerahn"KJ"Huntretracedhis
brother'slaststepsbyhimself
Thursdaymorningtocommemorate
hisfinalmomentsalive.Hewas
mostlyquietwithreportersinthe
afternoon,butsaidhewasthereto
showloveforhisslainbrother.KJ
Huntalsoworepatchesofothermen
whohavebeenkilledrecentlyin
policeshootings.Henamedeachman
ashepointedatthepatches.
"Thelistgoesonandon,"hesaid.
KJHunt,21,alsocarriedakatanaswordwithhimashewalkedaroundtheshoppingareawherehis
brotherwaskilled.PoliceapproachedhimThursdayafterreceivingcomplaints,accordingtohis
mother.
"SaratogaSpringssaidtheygotcallsfrommultiplepeopleandtheypulledhimover,"SusanHunt
said."Iremindedthemitsanopencarrystate."
CindyMoss,anaunttoDarrienHunt,spoketosupporters,includingseveralthatworeGuyFawkes
masksandcarriedflagsassociatedwiththeAnonymousactivistmovement.Mosslamentedwhatshe
callsalackoflegitimateoversightforpolice.
"Thebadthingsthatweseeasafamily
istheyreallowedtomakeanydecision
andnotbeheldaccountable,"Moss
said.
Shealsosaidtheinvestigationbythe
UtahCountyAttorney'sOfficeintothe
shootingwascharacterizedby"secrets
keptandliestold"thatcloudthereality
ofwhatactuallyoccurred.
"Itshurtful,veryhurtfultousasa
familythatpeoplewouldthinkhe'dhurt
anyone,"shesaidofhernephew.
FriendsandfamilyofDarrienHuntgatherThursday,Sept.10,2015,inSaratoga
SpringsontheoneyearanniversaryofHunt'sdeath.Huntwasshotandkilledby
police.(ScottGWinterton,DeseretNews)
InJanuary,theHuntfamilyfileda$2millioncivilrightslawsuitagainstSaratogaSpringsandthe
twoofficerswhoshotHunt.Thelawsuitcallstheofficers'useofdeadlyforceunlawfulandexcessive.
http://www.deseretnews.com/article/print/865636522/MomofDarrienHuntsayssherejected900Ksettlementofferinsonsdeath.html
2/4
9/11/2015
MomofDarrienHuntsayssherejected$900Ksettlementofferinson'sdeath
Case 2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
Document 50-10 Filed 11/17/15 Page 3 of 10
Thefamily'sobjectiveisn'tapayout,butratheranacknowledgementthattheshootingofDarrien
Huntwasbrutalandunnecessary,SusanHuntsaid.
"Itwasnothingdowith(money),ithastodowith
clearinghisname,andwithtruthandjustice,"she
said.
Thefamilylastweekdismissedtheirattorneyinthe
lawsuit.RobertSykes,wholistscivilrightsand
policemalpracticecasesamonghisnotable
experience,saidThursdayhereceivedamessage
fromthefamilylastweekrequestinghisfilesonthe
case.
SusanHunttalkswithhersonKerahnasfamilyandfriendsof
DarrienHuntgatherThursday,Sept.10,2015,inSaratoga
SpringsontheoneyearanniversaryofHunt'sdeath.Huntwas
shotandkilledbypolice.(ScottGWinterton,DeseretNews)
"SusanHuntwantedtogoadifferentroute,"Sykes
said."Idon'treallyknowwhathappened."
Sykesdidnotelaborateonthedifferenceofopinion.However,HuntsaidshedroppedSykesbecause
hewantedtoacceptthesettlementofferfromSaratogaSprings.
"Hewasthinkingitwasagreatdealandagoodwaytogo,"shesaid.
Thefamily'snewattorney,PaulLydolph,ofLehi,
declinedcommentThursday.
TheofficersSaratogaSpringsPoliceCpl.Matt
SchauerhamerandofficerNicholasJudson
werefoundlegallyjustifiedintheshootingby
UtahCountyAttorneyJeffreyBuhman.Buhman
saidatthetimethattheofficersreasonably
believedHunt,whowasstillcarryingthe
unsheathedswordasheran,posedathreatto
patronsinnearbystores.
Overthepastyeartheshootinghasattracted
wavesofattention,inpartbecauseoftheoutcry
fromHunt'sfamilyandfriends.
FamilyandfriendsofDarrienHuntgatherThursday,Sept.10,
2015,inSaratogaSpringsontheoneyearanniversaryofHunt's
death.Huntwasshotandkilledbypolice.(ScottGWinterton,
DeseretNews)
Huntbelieveshersonwaskillednotbecausetheswordhecarriedposedathreat,butbecauseofthe
colorofhisskin.DarrienHunt'saunthassaidthathernephewhadhadpreviousencounterswith
Schauerhamerandtheofficer'sjudgmentwasbiasedbyhisunfoundedassumptionsaboutthe22
yearold.
http://www.deseretnews.com/article/print/865636522/MomofDarrienHuntsayssherejected900Ksettlementofferinsonsdeath.html
3/4
9/11/2015
MomofDarrienHuntsayssherejected$900Ksettlementofferinson'sdeath
Case 2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
Document 50-10 Filed 11/17/15 Page 4 of 10
Theshootinghasalsobeenthesubjectofan
investigationinitiatedearlierthisyearbytheU.S.
Attorney'sOfficeandtheFBI.Thatinvestigation
isstillunderway,aspokeswomanfromtheU.S.
Attorney'sOfficeconfirmedThursday.Noupdates
havebeenreleased.
BalloonsriseintotheskyasfamilyandfriendsofDarrienHunt
gatherThursday,Sept.10,2015,inSaratogaSpringsontheoneyear
anniversaryofHunt'sdeath.Huntwasshotandkilledbypolice.
(ScottGWinterton,DeseretNews)
SusanHuntsaidshecalledtheFBItwoweeksago,
askingforanupdate.Theyreportedlytoldher
theywerereachingtheconclusionoftheir
investigation.However,Huntcriticizedthat
investigationaswell,sayingtheygatheredallof
theirinformationfromSaratogaSpringspolice.
"Whatkindofindependentinvestigationisthat?"
sheasked.
Meanwhile,SusanHunthasbeenthesubjectofherownlegaldispute.Huntwaschargedearlierthis
yearwithmisdemeanorsstemmingfromaconfrontationwithSaratogaSpringspolice.Shehas
pleadednotguiltytointerferingwithanarrestingofficer,aclassBmisdemeanordrivingona
deniedlicense,aclassCmisdemeanorfailingtodisperse,aclassCmisdemeanoranddisorderly
conduct,aninfraction.
Hunt'sattorneyinthatcase,Ron
Yengich,submittedadiversion
agreementtoSaratogaSpringsJustice
CourtonWednesday,accordingto
courtdockets.Iftheagreementis
signedbyJudgeCarolynHoward,the
casewillessentiallybeputonholdfor
anagreeduponamountoftimeuntilit
iseventuallydismissed,contingenton
goodbehavior.
"Itwasahugerelief,butitwassucha
boguschargeanyway,"Huntsaid.
FamilyandfriendsofDarrienHuntwalkonthesidewalkThursday,Sept.10,2015,
inSaratogaSpringsneartheareawherehewasshotandkilledbypoliceoneyear
ago.
(ScottGWinterton,DeseretNews)
Howardindicatedinanorder
ThursdaythatshewillhanddownadecisionontheagreementataSept.18hearing.
Email:blockhart@deseretnews.commromero@deseretnews.com
Twitter:benlockhartnews,McKenzieRomero
Copyright2015,DeseretNewsPublishingCompany
http://www.deseretnews.com/article/print/865636522/MomofDarrienHuntsayssherejected900Ksettlementofferinsonsdeath.html
4/4
9/11/2015
DarrienHuntsmothersayssheturneddown$900,000settlementfromSaratogaSprings|TheSaltLakeTribune
Case 2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
Document 50-10 Filed 11/17/15 Page 5 of 10
DarrienHuntsmothersaysshe
turneddown$900,000settlement
fromSaratogaSprings
BYPAMELAMANSONANDERINALBERTY
THESALTLAKETRIBUNE
PUBLISHED:SEPTEMBER11,201507:28AM
UPDATED:SEPTEMBER11,201507:37AM
SaratogaSpringsAsshemarkedthefirst
anniversaryofhersonsfatalshootingby
police,DarrienHuntsmothersaidshehas
turneddowna$900,000offertosettleher
lawsuitagainstthecityandtwoofficers.
Thesettlementwouldhavebarredherfrom
commentingaboutthecase,accordingto
SusanHunt,whosaidthatprovisionwas
unacceptable.
Thatsnotgoingtoclearhisname,she
saidThursday.AndIcouldnot,ingood
conscience,agreetothat.
TrentNelson|TheSaltLakeTribune
Photos,notes,flowersandawoodenswordatamemorial
toDarrienHuntSundaySeptember14,2014atthe
SaratogaSpringsPandaExpress,whereHuntwasshot
andkilledbypolice.
HuntsaidshehashiredthelawfirmofthelateJohnnieCochrantorepresentherin
thefederallawsuit.Nocourtdateshavebeenset.
About35peoplegatheredThursdayafternoontomourn22yearoldDarrienHunt
andcallforpoliceaccountabilityatthesitewherehewasshotfatallyatabout9:30
a.m.onSept.10,2014.
SaratogaSpringsPoliceDepartmentCpl.MatthewSchauerhamerandOfficer
NicholasJudsonconfrontedHuntafterapasserbycalled911toreportamanwitha
samuraiswordwaswalkingatRedwoodRoadandStateRoad73.Hisrelativessay
Huntwascosplayingorcostumedroleplayingasacartooncharacterand
carryingaswordthatwasnotaweapon,butacostumeaccessorywitharounded
http://www.sltrib.com/csp/mediapool/sites/sltrib/pages/printfriendly.csp?id=2933436
1/2
9/11/2015
DarrienHuntsmothersayssheturneddown$900,000settlementfromSaratogaSprings|TheSaltLakeTribune
Case 2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
Document 50-10 Filed 11/17/15 Page 6 of 10
blade.
TheofficerssaytheyfiredseveralshotsafterHuntswungtheswordatthem,and
theygavechasewhenheranawayfromthem.Schauerhamerfiredseveralmore
roundsduringthechasebeforeHuntwhowasshotsixtimescollapsedneara
restaurantat1413N.RedwoodRoad.
ProsecutorssaidpolicewerejustifiedinshootingDarrienHuntbecausethey
believedhewasathreattoshoppersatanearbystore.Thelawsuit,though,
contendsthattheshootingviolatedthecivilrightsofHunt,whowasblack.
OnThursday,Huntsyoungerbrother,KerahnHunt,reenactedDarrienHunts
walkatabout9:30a.m.,wearingasimilarcostumeandcarryingasimilarsword.
SusanHuntsaidpolicereceivedmultiplecallsThursdayaboutthatwalkandthree
officerssurroundedhersontocheckonwhathewasdoing.
AtThursdaysevent,someoftheparticipantswrotenotesoncardsandtiedthemto
balloonsthattheyreleasedtocommemorateDarrienHunt.
Theythenmarchedtherouteofhiswalkbeforehewasshot,andSusanHuntwalked
arminarmwithKerahnHuntandhersisterCindyMossendingatthespot
wherethebulletsstrucktheirson,brotherandnephew.
Thatwasprettyhard,SusanHuntsaid.
AndtoKerahnHunt,itsyetanotherreminderofhowhisbrotherisgone.
Itspainfuleveryday,hesaid.
Stillpendingisafederalinvestigationoftheshooting.SusanHunt,whosaid
ThursdaythatshespoketwoweeksagowithDepartmentofJusticeandFBI
officials,expressedconcernthatthefederalinvestigatorsdonothaveallthe
availableevidence,includingsurveillancevideofromtwobusinessesinthevicinity
oftheshooting.
Mybiggestconcern,shesaid,isforthetruthtobetold.
pmanson@sltrib.com
Twitter:@PamelaMansonSLC
Copyright2015TheSaltLakeTribune.Allrightsreserved.Thismaterialmaynotbepublished,broadcast,rewrittenor
redistributed.
http://www.sltrib.com/csp/mediapool/sites/sltrib/pages/printfriendly.csp?id=2933436
2/2
10/27/2015
ksl.comCitysays$900KsettlementwithHuntfamilyshouldbeenforced
Case 2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
Document 50-10 Filed 11/17/15 Page 8 of 10
CLICKHEREtoprintthispage
Citysays$900KsettlementwithHuntfamilyshouldbeenforced
October26,2015
SALTLAKECITYSusanHuntandtheestateofDarrienHuntarenotdisputingevidencepresented
bySaratogaSpringsregardinga$900,000settlement,"theysimplyignoreit,"anewcourtfilingsays.
ThelatestroundinthewarofwordsbetweentheHuntfamilyandSaratogaSpringsofficialswasfiled
lastweekinfederalcourt.
DarrienHunt,22,wasshotandkilledfollowingaconfrontationwithtwoSaratogaSpringspoliceofficers
inSeptember2014.Hewascarryinga3footsouvenirkatanaswordwhenhewasshotsixtimesinthe
back,withmostoftheshotshittinghimashefledfromofficers.
TheUtahCountyAttorney'sOfficedeterminedtheofficerswerelegallyjustifiedintheshooting.In
January,theHuntfamilyfileda$2millioncivillawsuitagainstSaratogaSpringsandthetwoofficers
whoshothim,callingtheofficers'useofdeadlyforceunlawfulandexcessive.
InSeptember,thelawsuittookanunexpectedtwistwhenSusanHuntsaidshehadrejecteda$900,000
settlementofferandfiredherattorney,RobertSykes,whosheclaimedwasnotauthorizedtoacceptsuch
anoffer.ButSaratogaSpringsofficialsinsistshehadagreedtoitandaskedafederaljudgetoforceher
totakethemoney.
Inthecity'sreply,filedOct.20byattorneyHeatherWhite,shereiteratesthatanagreementwasreached
onAug.7.
"(Ms.Huntandtheestate)donotdistinguishthelawsubmittedbydefendants,theydisregardit.Their
oppositionmemoisahighvolume,zerosubstanceaffronttoboththeevidenceandthelaw,"White
wroteinSaratogaSprings'responsetoHunt'sresponseoutliningherreasonsthatnosettlementwasever
agreedupon.
Whitesaidasettlementwasreached,thatSykeshadauthoritytoacceptasettlement,andthatemails
wereasufficientformofbindingthesettlement.
"AttorneySykesreceivedfromHeatherWhite,counselforthedefendants,a$900,000offerofsettlement
fortheclient.AfterconsultingwithSusanHunt,attorneyRobertSykescontacteddefendants'attorney,
https://www.ksl.com/index.php?sid=37110645&nid=481
1/2
10/27/2015
ksl.comCitysays$900KsettlementwithHuntfamilyshouldbeenforced
Case 2:15-cv-00001-TC-PMW
Document 50-10 Filed 11/17/15 Page 9 of 10
HeatherWhite,andacceptedthisofferonbehalfofSusanHunt.CurtisHuntalsoacceptedthesettlement
offerof$900,000,"accordingtocourtdocuments.
ThecityalsoasksthejudgetosanctionHuntfor"breachingtheconfidentialityofthesettlement
agreementandneedlesslyprolongingthislitigation."
Thecourtdocumentsadditionallystate:
"Ms.Huntcontendssheshouldnotbesanctionedbecauseshedidnotbreachthe
confidentialityprovision,asnosettlementwasreached.However,asshownabove,Ms.Hunt
hasadvancednocogentargumentagainsttheenforceabilityofthesettlementagreement,and
shehasignoredundisputedevidenceandbindingcaselaw.Itisclearasettlementwas
reachedandshebreachedtheconfidentialityprovisionwhenshetoldthemediathatshehad
rejectedthesettlementofferandwasbeingpaid'hushmoney.'Moreover,shehasprolonged
thislitigationbyobstinatelyopposingfinalizationofthesettlementinthefaceofclear
evidenceandlaw."
AhearingtopresentoralargumentsincourtontheissueisscheduledforDecember.
Inaseparatemotion,Huntclaimssheshouldn'thavetopaySykes'attorneyfeesbecauseofhis
representation.
Earlierthismonth,SykestoldKSLNewsthatthemotiongivesa"falseimpression"oftheworkhis
officedid.
"Everythingthatwedid,thatourfirmdidandthatIdid,wascompletelylegal,ethical,competentand
withfulldisclosure,"hesaid."Thosepaperscontainmany,manyfalsehoods,inaccuracies,
mischaracterizationsandpartialtruths.TherearesomanyIcan'tcommentonthemall."
SykesisexpectedtofilehisresponsetoHunt'smotioninfederalcourtthisweek.
https://www.ksl.com/index.php?sid=37110645&nid=481
2/2
(Redacted)
(Redacted)
(Redacted)