THE AUSTRALIAN

Wollongong University accepts thesis on

vaccine ‘conspiracy’
KYLAR LOUSSIKIAN | THE AUSTRALIAN| JANUARY 13, 2016 12:00AM

PhD thesis extracts.

The University of Wollongong has accepted a PhD thesis from a prominent anti-
vaccination activist that warns that global agencies such as the World Health ​-
Organisation are colluding with the pharmaceutical industry in a massive
conspiracy to spruik immunisation.
Judy Wilyman, the convener of Vaccination Decisions and Vaccination Choice,
submitted the thesis late last year, concluding Australia’s vaccination policy was not a
result of independent assessment but the work of pharmaceutical industry pressure on
the WHO.
The WHO convened a ​“secret emergency committee” funded by drug firms to
“orchestrate” hysteria relating to a global swine flu pandemic in 2009, Ms Wilyman
said in her thesis.
“The swine flu pandemic of 2009 was declared by a secret WHO committee that had

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/higher-education/wollongon…onspiracy/news-story/dbd57d8909779f4d82ece7b9ab8d520a 13/01/2016, 05:32

Page 1 of 5
ties to pharmaceutical companies that stood to make excessive profits from the
pandemic,” she wrote.
Several medical researchers and public health advocates have slammed the PhD thesis
— to be awarded through the university’s School of Humanities — with some calling
for it to be sent to the university’s academic board for review.
Ms Wilyman has been the subject of controversy for several years, most notably
falsely linking vaccination with autism and questioning whether a family was paid to
use their young daughter’s death to promote vaccines.
In October, she circulated an interview on her Vaccination Choice Facebook page in
which anti-vaccination campaigner Sherri Tenpenny suggested Nazi scientists had
“infiltrated” new medication research and were working to make “everybody on the
planet sicker”.
Senior immunology academic John Dwyer, spokesman for the Friends of Science in
Medicine, said he would write to the university and express his concerns. “The ​-
candidate (Ms Wilyman) has endorsed a ​conspiracy theory where all sorts of
organisations with claimed vested interests are putting pressure on WHO to hoodwink
the world into believing that vaccines provide more benefits than they cause harm,”
Professor Dwyer said.
“Many well-established concepts in science are being challenged in this thesis with no
data to support the conclusions provides and while the candidate has been
controversial for some time with her anti-vaccination stance, the important issue is
how a leading university has allowed this thesis to go for review and for her to be
given one of the highest degrees a university can award.
“I’d like to see the academic board ask for a review, for a please explain, from the
faculty and the supervisor.”
The thesis was supervised by Brian Martin, a professor of social sciences at the
university with a long history of supporting controversial PhD candidates.
Another of Professor Martin’s students was Michael Primero, associated with Medical
Veritas, a self-described journal of “truth in health science” that alleged the
Rockefeller Foundation had declared a war on consciousness through the imposition
of musical tuning standards.
Professor Martin dismissed concerns about the paper, saying they were “not genuine
concerns about quality and probity but instead part of a campaign to denigrate
viewpoints they oppose”.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/higher-education/wollongon…onspiracy/news-story/dbd57d8909779f4d82ece7b9ab8d520a 13/01/2016, 05:32

Page 2 of 5
Ms Wilyman’s thesis cited a 27-year-old paper that claimed there was no clear link
that human papillomavirus infection is causally related to cervical cancer, despite more
recent work suggesting 70 per cent of cervical cancer is related to HPV.
“The promotional campaigns for HPV vaccine misrepresented the risk of HPV
infections and cervical cancer to women in different countries,” Ms Wilyman wrote.
“This was done in order to create a market for the vaccine.”
The paper included figures showing the incidence of cervical cancer separated by
developed or developing regions, which appear to incorrectly exclude China, North
Africa and western Asia. Public Health Association of Australia chief executive
Michael Moore said it was important not to “lightly dismiss a PhD” that had been the
subject of half a decade of work.
“However, this PhD is based on the concept of undone science, implying there is not
enough research about the issue or that the research is inappropriately funded,” said
Professor Moore, the incoming president of the World Federation of Public Health
Associations.
“On the contrary, the vast majority of research in Australia, including through the
National Centre for Immunisation Research and Surveillance, is government-funded
and the overwhelming consensus of academics supports the efficacy of vaccination.”
Orthopedic surgeon and vaccination campaigner John Cunningham said Ms
Wilyman’s understanding of the immune system was “flawed and oversimplified”, and
the thesis “had been produced within a vacuum and without an appreciation of medical
science”.
The university’s vice-chancellor, Paul Wellings, ​ has​ repeatedly declined to answer
questions about Ms Wilyman’s research but a spokesman said the university stood by
it.
“UOW ensures research is undertaken according to strict ethical and quality standards
and supports researchers’ academic freedom of thought and expression,” he said.
“UOW does not restrict the subjects into which research may be undertaken just
because they involve public controversy or because individuals or groups oppose the
topic or the findings.”
UOW declined to name external examiners who approved the thesis.
When contacted, Ms Wilyman said she was busy.
Reader comments on this site are moderated before publication to promote lively and civil debate. We encourage your

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/higher-education/wollongon…onspiracy/news-story/dbd57d8909779f4d82ece7b9ab8d520a 13/01/2016, 05:32

Page 3 of 5
comments but submitting one does not guarantee publication. We publish hundreds of comments daily, and if a
comment is rejected it is likely because it does not meet with our comment guidelines, which you can read here. No
correspondence will be entered into if a comment is declined.

email SIGN UP NOW

FROM THE HOMEPAGE

Doping bombshell hits AFL G
CHIP LE GRAND
The greatest drugs scandal in Australian sport will wreak havoc across the AFL for months.

D F
video

Liberal moderates flex muscles G

S A R AH M ART IN
A factional brawl within the Liberal Party risks engulfing Malcolm Turnbull in the lead-up
to this year’s election.

Thesis on vaccine ‘conspiracy’ G

K Y L AR L O U SSI KIA N
The University of Wollongong has accepted a PhD thesis from a prominent anti-vaccination
activist that warns of a global conspiracy.

Alert hours after threat known G

PAIGE TAYLOR, ANDREW BURRELL
Authorities knew a bushfire was so ​serious that it was ‘too late to evacuate’ more than six
hours ​before they warned residents.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/higher-education/wollongon…onspiracy/news-story/dbd57d8909779f4d82ece7b9ab8d520a 13/01/2016, 05:32

Page 4 of 5
F

Chemical fights suicide thoughts G

J OH N R OS S
A new type of antidepressant could prove as effective as ketamine, but without its
disastrous side-effects.

Open borders crack melting pot G

J E N NIF E R O R IE L
Leaders such as Germany’s Angela Merkel are wrong to support open door policies when
they are shown to be so flawed.

War over alcohol and violence G

R I C K M O RTO N
A prohibition-style argument about the role alcohol plays in bad behaviour has broken out
between academics.

Quality of mercy is all: Francis G

TESS LIVINGSTONE
Human beings should not be defined only by their sexual tendencies, the Pope says in a new
book.

One-third boost to climate aid G

J A R ED O W EN S
The PM’s pledge of $1bn to help ​developing nations combat global warming will require
spending to be boosted by at least a third.

Two shot at Nepean hospital

A police officer and a security officer have been shot at Sydney’s Nepean Hospital.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/higher-education/wollongon…onspiracy/news-story/dbd57d8909779f4d82ece7b9ab8d520a 13/01/2016, 05:32

Page 5 of 5