Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
doi:10.1111/j.1468-1331.2006.01138.x
World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland; bDepartment of Neurology CHUV, Lausanne, Switzerland; cDepartment of Neurology,
The Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland; and dDepartment of Neurology, Bispebjerg University Hospital, Copenhagen NV,
Denmark
Keywords:
epidemiology, Europe,
incidence, prevalence,
stroke
Received 8 November 2004
Accepted 12 January 2005
Reliable data on stroke incidence and prevalence are essential for calculating the
burden of stroke and the planning of prevention and treatment of stroke patients. In
the current study we have reviewed the published data from EU countries, Iceland,
Norway, and Switzerland, and provide WHO estimates for stroke incidence and
prevalence in these countries.Studies on stroke epidemiology published in peer-reviewed journals during the past 10 years were identied using Medline/PubMed
searches, and reviewed using the structure of WHOs stroke component of the WHO
InfoBase. WHO estimates for stroke incidence and prevalence for each country were
calculated from routine mortality statistics. Rates from studies that met the ideal
criteria were compared with WHOs estimates.Forty-four incidence studies and 12
prevalence studies were identied. There were several methodological dierences that
hampered comparisons of data. WHO stroke estimates were in good agreement with
results from ideal stroke population studies. According to the WHO estimates the
number of stroke events in these selected countries is likely to increase from 1.1 million
per year in 2000 to more than 1.5 million per year in 2025 solely because of the
demographic changes.Until better and more stroke studies are available, the WHO
stroke estimates may provide the best data for understanding the stroke burden in
countries where no stroke data currently exists. A standardized protocol for stroke
surveillance is recommended.
Introduction
Routine mortality statistics indicate that there are
considerable dierences in stroke mortality between
dierent European countries with several East European countries having high and increasing stroke
mortality rates whilst low and decreasing rates are
reported from most West European countries [1].
Projections for the European region suggest that the
proportion of the population aged 65+, in which most
stroke events occur, will increase from 20% in 2000 to
35% in 2050, and the median age will rise from
37.7 years in 2000 to 47.7 years in 2050 [2]. The projected population for Europe will decrease from
728 million in 2000 to 705 million in 2050, thus the
dependency ratio will shift with fewer young people
supporting an increasing proportion of elderly people.
This will be a tremendous challenge for societies and
health systems.
2006 EFNS
581
582
T. Truelsen et al.
and written in English. Data collection had to be predetermined to include descriptive epidemiological data
on stroke (rst, rst and recurrent, or recurrent stroke),
and present crude age- and sex-specic data on stroke
incidence, and/or prevalence. In each paper the following elements were searched and assessed: methods
of case ascertainment; whether the denition of stroke
was in accordance with the WHO stroke denition [3];
type of event (rst-ever-in-a-lifetime, rst and recurrent); stroke subtype denition (ischemic stroke, intracerebral hemorrhage, subarachnoid hemorrhage,
undetermined, and all stroke events combined); diagnostic methods used; data collection type (hot or cold
pursuit); study duration; statistical method used for
sampling; size of study population; response rate; total
number of strokes. Whilst this information is available
online
at
http://www.who.int/ncd_surveillance/
infobase/web/StrokeWeb/index.aspx the present study
includes only selected items.
WHO estimates of stroke incidence and prevalence
selected Member State. This approach eectively assumes that short-term and long-term age-sex specic
CFR for stroke are constant within all countries.
Projections and comparisons of data
Results
Incidence studies
583
or older [1521]. Studies of subtype of stroke suggested that rates of ischemic stroke and intracerebral
hemorrhage were higher in men than in women
whereas rates for subarachnoid hemorrhages were
higher in women, or no gender dierences were
reported. One paper on stroke incidence in a multiethnic population demonstrated higher rates in blacks
than in whites [22].
Prevalence studies
Details on prevalence are shown in Table 2, and sexand age-specic rates are listed in Appendix 3. There
were 12 publications, including one multinational [23],
on stroke prevalence from six countries. The majority
of studies were from populations in Italy (n 4) or the
UK (n 3).
Three of the studies did not use age limits whilst the
remaining concentrated on elderly people with dierent
lower (55 or 65 years) and upper (84, 96, or 100 years)
age limits. Most studies included data for both men and
women. In total, 92 309 events were included in the
source populations in which the number of prevalent
cases was registered. Whilst type of stroke event (rstever, recurrent, all strokes) was stated in four studies
[2427], none of the studies provided separate rates for
subtypes of stroke.
The WHOs estimates for stroke incidence and
prevalence
1992 to 1996
Jul 1994 to Jun 1995
1993 to 1995
Jun 1992 to May 1993
Jul 1986 to Jun 1987
Jan 1994 to Dec 1998
1994 to 1998
Jan 1996 to Dec 1996
1986 to 1988
1984 to 1987
1985 to 1987
Nov 1993 to Oct 1995
Aug 1989 to Aug 1990
Aug 1989 to Jul 1991
1995 to 1998
Jan 1989 to Dec 1989 and
Nov 1996 to Dec 1997
Dec 1972 to Dec 1973 and
Jan 1985 to Dec 1988
UK [53]
Sweden [29]
Italy [35]
Portugal [15]
Poland [54]
Italy [30]
Italy [38]
UK [56]
Norway [39]
UK [57]
The Netherlands [58]
Germany [36]
Germany [65]
Italy [20]
Italy [34]
Sweden [21]
Italy [59]
Italy [60]
Sweden [61]
Lithuania [62]
Italy [18]
UK [37]
Germany [67]
Data collection
Study reference
Case ascertainment
2 625 000
80 774
621 966b
322 500
234 533
118 723
234 533
24 496
41269
211 389
826
174 875
12 218
1 140 000
430 000
100 330
69 295
5308
7721 (100)
101 450
176 186
534 287
182 285
5632
123 112
182 000
123 503
297 838
Sample size
(% of responders
if dropouts/
non-responders)
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever and recurrent
First-ever and recurrent
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
Event type
11909
(555)
(386)
(456)
(1254)
(255) + (343)
(612)
(138)
(174)
(474)
(56)
(89)
(1316)
447
973
(752)
593 (432)
433 (333)
(432)
(354)
(124)
932 (642)
633 (462)
408 (321)
(688)
330
(388)
(819)
Number of
all strokes
(rst-ever)
584
T. Truelsen et al.
Finland [68]
Sweden [72]
Finland [17]
Sweden [76]
Case ascertainment
101 122
19 698
238 948
Not stated
380 000
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
8 882 792rmd
113 100 + 136 850 + 183 199
86 487 + 90 542
First-ever
First-ever
First-ever
Event type
148 277
160 000
200 191 + 224 126
Sample size
(% of responders
if dropouts/
non-responders)
(234)
(882)
5262 (4243)
(1186)
6083
13 908
8163
(429)/(262)
(43 389)
(244) + (255) + (594)
(1130)
(667) + (829)
5904
(998) + (1318)
(219) + (189)
Number of
all strokes
(rst-ever)
a
Sudden onset of focal brain dysfunction resulting from occlusive or hemorrhagic lesions of the vascular supply of the brain, or global brain dysfunction with documentation of subarachnoid or
intraventricular hemorrhage; symptoms persisted for over 24 h, or the event led to death within 24 h (excluded subdural and traumatic hemorrhages).
b
Stroke diagnosis was based on all available medical information. In case of no hospitalization, mention of a cerebrovascular accident in the GP records was required to conrm the self-reported
information. When possible, information on signs and symptoms was used in the nal classication. In case of hospitalization, the diagnosis of a neurologist was used. Prevalence rates are calculated for
self reported strokes.
c
Information on stroke was derived from three different sources of information: self-reported, key informant, and hospital linkage system (ICD-9; codes 430438 for stroke). Only stroke patients with a
denite history of acute focal symptoms (hemiparesis or acute aphasia) were included.
Estonia [32]
Denmark [77]
Denmark [19]
Sweden [75]
Sweden [74]
Finland [73]
UK [31]
France [71]
Estonia [16]
Finland [69]
Sweden [70]
Data collection
Study reference
Table 1 Continued
585
1993
Jan 1995 to Jun 1996
Not stated
UK [79]
UK [80]
UK [81]
Study design
18827
27658
2000/88
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Cyprus
Czezh
Republic
Denmark
Finland
France
Germany
Greece
Iceland
Ireland
Italy
Malta
UK
12
19
24
37
74 131
191 253
653 630
1391 1105
1784 1325
Switzerland
15
23
30
46
80 201
184 384
580 987
1250 1708
1628 2009
Estonia
9
14
18
28
49 131
109 316
364 899
837 1696
1113 2096
Latvia
9
21
17
42
60 215
152 533
588 1541
1395 3131
1857 4032
Hungary
11
11
21
23
98 107
288 212
1216 690
3312 1381
4671 1697
Lithuania
9
14
19
28
74 126
187 315
647 877
1493 1621
1990 1992
Poland
21
14
42
27
99 124
192 295
672 918
1396 1946
1732 2521
Slovakia
8
15
16
31
63 146
154 366
585 988
1569 1852
2214 2314
Slovenia
18
16
36
32
103 153
231 381
721 1126
1584 1870
2087 2098
10
20
81
203
789
1637
2021
2534
11
3544
21
4554 119
5564 284
6574 847
7584 1567
85+ 1889
12
13
25
26
93 123
175 287
565 905
1265 1796
1657 2234
8
47
17
93
69 362
148 842
530 2299
1359 3769
1887 4262
20
12
39
24
149 132
390 298
1431 804
3193 1413
4153 1682
8
8
15
16
57 122
143 294
498 841
1207 1579
1647 1943
6
8
13
17
65
58
164 171
535 515
1287 1074
1767 1401
6
16
12
32
49 129
110 301
329 845
822 1512
1158 1809
9
27
18
54
94 367
209 877
652 1858
1453 2641
1925 2953
12
25
133
407
1171
2473
3284
18
37
455
1155
2563
3963
4656
14
27
27
54
205 367
587 877
1645 1824
3539 2607
4757 2953
14
17
29
35
141 268
332 670
907 1404
1680 2029
2070 2320
9
17
17
34
138 250
332 613
882 1255
1659 1619
2081 1706
12
7
25
14
103 156
289 469
800 1132
1459 1568
1792 1654
4
21
9
41
58 194
183 612
631 1467
1102 2344
1251 2784
11
22
139
296
858
1754
2244
Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women
Sweden
7
30
14
60
119 194
347 351
1449 882
2918 1514
3513 1771
Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women
Belgium
2534
13
10
19
12
10
5
17
3544
26
20
37
23
20
11
33
4554 153
69 139
84
83
40 271
5564 324
172 312
186 229
134 678
6574 877
613 812
550 672
463 1989
7584 1631
1376 1446
1237 1752
1726 3474
85+ 2005
1801 1754
1661 2535
2753 4056
The Netherlands
Norway
Portugal
Spain
Age
Austria
Table 3 Stroke incidence estimates, the World Health Organization, men and women per 100 000
415
Not stated
104
Not shown
29 + 60
22
Not shown
146
75
189
285
53
Number of strokes
Luxembourg
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
First and recurrent stroke
First and recurrent stroke
First-ever strokes
First and recurrent stroke
Not stated
Event type
The diagnosis was based on history of stroke with permanent paralysis, paresis or aphasia, or occurrence of paralysis or paresis, after exclusion of other causes.
19841994
19881992
Jul 1986 to Dec 1986
Mar 1992 to Jun 1993
1 April 2001
Mar 1992 to Feb 1993
1987
Not stated
Not stated
Data collection
Study reference
586
T. Truelsen et al.
587
68
130
1418
2524
5966
9760
12 098
18
131
38
250
349 1566
902 4432
2617 9714
3726 13 444
3035 15 631
28
59
710
2032
4583
5816
4757
53
114
661
1523
3584
4920
4627
73
156
1228
2877
5569
6492
5296
38
79
697
1769
3746
4741
4402
68
142
982
2517
4603
5710
5742
55
104
838
2037
6996
14 686
21 217
95
198
1283
2862
5608
6979
5942
57
119
984
2994
6628
8994
9548
52
72
108
150
647 1661
2108 4320
4772 8326
6434 10 893
6669 11 456
106
222
1363
3326
6153
7631
7391
50
94
857
1589
4041
7101
9288
93
177
952
2021
5016
7918
9315
33
63
455
847
2062
3911
5639
48
91
415
1094
2933
5132
6926
32
62
554
1155
3090
5750
7953
43
81
827
1800
4550
7428
9127
40
76
509
1061
3017
5698
7805
68
130
965
1973
4714
7306
8527
2% increase/5 years
Stable incidence rates
2% decrease/5 years
1.800.000
1.700.000
1.600.000
1.500.000
1.400.000
1.300.000
1.200.000
1.100.000
1.000.000
2000
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
109
208
1400
3020
9038
16 185
20 578
42
282
80
538
589 2770
1060 5841
3049 14 151
6060 21 026
8534 22 701
73
72
139
138
919
851
1464 1798
3780 4962
6752 8583
8681 10 733
62
119
893
1924
5059
8260
9824
2534
3544
4554
5564
6574
7584
85+
Men Women
Men Women
Men Women
Men Women
Men Women Men Women
Men Women
Men Women Men Women
Men Women
Men Women
Latvia
Estonia
UK
Switzerland
Sweden
Spain
Portugal
Men Women
Men Women
Men Women
Hungary
Lithuania
Poland
Slovakia
Slovenia
58
111
787
1639
5167
8878
10 422
107
99
203
188
1022 1180
1914 2666
4854 6968
8441 10 582
10 944 11 291
42
95
80
180
548 1129
1114 2552
3416 6149
7038 9872
10 178 12 425
132
79
252
150
1044
868
1708 1864
4777 5095
8178 9172
9681 12 237
52
85
99
161
702
950
1464 2148
4140 5318
7537 8522
9954 10 454
66
126
788
1417
3998
7066
8668
55
104
838
2037
6996
14 686
21 217
46
114
87
217
535 1481
1122 3318
3524 8497
6646 14 616
8759 19 308
50
83
95
158
465
992
857 2172
2324 5472
4218 8947
5553 11 072
118
225
1048
1849
4064
6242
7371
67
127
695
1490
4168
7148
8890
87
150
165
285
775 1652
1484 2887
3820 6529
6554 10 032
8342 11 497
39
196
74
374
1103 1607
2637 2658
8965 5869
15 171 8974
17 156 10 198
25
99
48
189
171 2037
553 4604
1507 11 959
3112 18 711
4881 21 192
59
113
380
929
2354
4215
5998
65
124
804
1476
3568
6260
8362
2534
77
56
114
3544
147
106
218
4554 1163
634 1072
5564 2246
1304 2185
6574 5359
3791 5052
7584 8656
6807 7830
85+ 10 619
8733 9403
The Netherlands
Norway
Women Men
Women Men
Women Men
Women Men Women Men
Women Men
Women Men Women Men
Women Men
Women Men
Women Men
Women Men
Women Men
Men
Age
Germany
France
Finland
Czezh Republic Denmark
Cyprus
Belgium
Austria
Table 4 Stroke prevalence rates, estimates from the World Health Organization, men and women per 100 000
Greece
Iceland
Ireland
Italy
Luxembourg
Malta
Women
Discussion
In the present study we have reviewed stroke studies
published since 1993 on incidence and prevalence from
Members States of the European Union and three
EFTA countries. Incidence data were available from
studies in 14 countries and prevalence data from studies
in six countries. The majority of these studies were
based on observations in urban populations and predominantly from West European countries. Only 16
incidence and three prevalence studies met ideal criteria. WHO estimates were often close to rates from
588
T. Truelsen et al.
10000
Males
Females
1000
100
10
1
1
10
100
1000
10000
Conflict of interest
Authors alone are responsible for views expressed in
signed articles, which are not necessarily those of the
World Health Organization.
589
Acknowledgements
B.P.-J. is supported by research grants from the International Stroke Society, and World Federation of
Neurology. The WHO Stroke InfoBase is supported by
the International Stroke Society, and World Federation
of Neurology.
References
1. Sarti C, Rastenyte D, Cepaitis Z, Tuomilehto J. International trends in mortality from stroke, 1968 to 1994.
Stroke 2000; 31: 15881601.
2. World Population Prospects 2004, at http://esa.un.org/
unpp/index.asp?panel=2.
3. Asplund K, Tuomilehto J, Stegmayr B, Wester PO,
Tunstall-Pedoe H. Diagnostic criteria and quality control
of the registration of stroke events in the MONICA project. Acta Medicine Scandinavica Supplement 1988; 728:
2639.
4. World Bank World Development Report 1993. Investing in
Health. Oxford University Press for the World Bank, New
York, 1993.
5. Murray CJL, Lopez AD. Global Health Statistics. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 1996.
6. Mathers CD, Bernard C, Iburg KM, et al. Global Burden
of Disease in 2002: Data Sources, Methods and Results.
GPE Discussion Paper No. 54. World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 2003.
7. World Health Organization. The World Health Report
2003: Shaping the future. World Health Organization,
Geneva, Switzerland, 2004b.
8. Truelsen T, Begg S, Mathers CD, Satoh T. Global Burden
of Cerebrovascular Disease in the Year 2000. GBD 2000
Working Paper. WHO, Geneva, Switzerland, 2002. GBD
2000 Working Paper available at http://www.who/evidence/bod.
9. Hardie K, Hankey GJ, Jamrozik K, Broadhurst RJ, Anderson C. Ten-year survival after rst-ever stroke in the
Perth Community Stroke Study. Stroke 2003; 34: 1842
1846.
10. Terent A. Cerebrovascular mortality 10 years after stroke:
a population-based study. Stroke 2004; 35: e343e345.
11. Loor HI, Groenier KH, Limburg M, Schuling J, Meyboom-de JB. Risks and causes of death in a communitybased stroke population: 1 month and 3 years after
stroke. Neuroepidemiology 1999; 18: 7584.
12. Hankey GJ, Jamrozik K, Broadhurst RJ, et al.. Five-year
survival after rst-ever stroke and related prognostic
factors in the Perth Community Stroke Study. Stroke
2000; 31: 20802086.
13. Bronnum-Hansen H, Davidsen M, Thorvaldsen P, Danish MONICA Study Group. Long-term survival and
causes of death after stroke. Stroke 2001; 32: 21312136.
14. Dennis MS, Burn JP, Sandercock PA, Bamford JM,
Wade DT, Warlow CP. Long-term survival after rst-ever
stroke: the Oxfordshire Community Stroke Project.
Stroke 1993; 24: 796800.
15. Correia M, Silva MR, Matos I, et al.. Prospective community-based study of stroke in Northern Portugal.
Incidence and case fatality in rural and urban populations. Stroke 2004; 35: 20482053.
590
T. Truelsen et al.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
71.
72.
73.
74.
75.
76.
77.
78.
79.
591
592
T. Truelsen et al.
M
F
M
Norway [39]
UK [57]
Mr
Mu
Fr
Fu
M
M
F
All
UK [56]
Italy [55]
Italy [30]
Poland [54]
Portugal [15]
All
M
F
All
M
UK [53]
Sweden [29]
Italy [35]
Sex
Study
First
First
IS
ICH
SAH
UND
All
All
IS
ICH
SAH
All
First
All
All
All
All
IS
ICH
SAH
IS
ICH
SAH
All
All
All
All
First
Recurr
First
Recurr
IS
ICH
SAH
UND
All
IS
ICH
SAH
UND
All
First
Type
8
11
233
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
9 (047)
4
4
2
1
3 (18)
2 (05)
2 (05)
0
7 (114)
7 (114)
2 (05)
4 (18)
0
12 (322)
014
2024
7 (216)
4 (112)
1 (06)
0
13 (430)
11 (328)
0
5 (0.827)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
9 (052)
1519
0
11 (062)
6 (034)
0
0
5 (126)
0
0
0
20 (1112)
19 (269)
19 (1105)
7 (040)
44
53
19
19
2529
4044
50 (199)
25 (391)
38 (1489)
24 (1056)
14 (542)
5 (127)
15 (544)
0
10 (336)
20 (1111)
95 (45174)
61 (13178)
84 (43147)
3539
5054
366 (232549)
155 (74285)
259 (178363)
216 (156299)
54 (28103)
18 (653)
114 (75173)
41 (2182)
16 (546)
466 (276737)
405 (280565)
177 (76348)
286 (196404)
324
408
134
189
120 (49191)
44 (186)
11 (032)
0
175 (89260)
93 (32154)
10 (031)
21 (150)
0
125 (54195)
5559
6064
127
126
263
45
61
241
22 (656)
175 (113259)
9 (132)
14 (251)
9 (032)
21 (461)
0
7 (039)
60 (24124)
223 (128361)
19 (269)
209 (117345)
186 (denite diagnosis)
27
8
117
275
429
(51183)
(199351)
(342516)
72 (26157)
93 (40183)
83 (45140)
82 (48140)
13 (346)
13 (346)
56 (29107)
19 (655)
6 (135)
73 (15213)
164 (96263)
141 (52307)
160 (99244)
88
96
71
96
51 (697)
10 (030)
0
0
62 (12111)
44 (187)
22 (152)
11 (033)
0
77 (20134)
4549
7074
652
(521784)
1119
(8621376)
1241 (9271626)
725 (515993)
951 (7651170)
800 (664964)
132 (84209)
15 (453)
581 (479704)
79 (47132)
28 (1266)
1128 (8201515)
728 (551943)
787 (5481094)
649 (511812)
533
761
323
435
603 (423783)
126 (44209)
28 (167)
28 (167)
785 (580991)
300 (185415)
69 (14125)
12 (034)
12 (034)
392 (260524)
454 (139768) 1009
(5341476)
615 (252979) 1212
(6671757)
486
605
348
449
579 (463718)
74 (37133)
27 (769)
34 (1179)
727 (542952)
701 (527911)
6569
1833
(11282537)
772
854
1399 (11831654)
215 (135325)
39 (5141)
186 (112290)
1994 (15912472)
1697 (13902053
1844 (14192360)
1770 (14172177)
1801 (15302118)
1379 (11441660)
266 (174406)
13 (272)
1273 (10821496)
212 (143315)
27 (978)
2095 (14672901)
1055 (7601426)
1972 (14542615)
1111 (8901368)
647
818
774
1014
1435 (10291841)
389 (177600)
30 (088)
0
1854 (13922315)
833 (5811084)
218 (89347)
20 (059)
119 (24214)
1189 (8881490)
2442 (16553229)
7579
2628
(17573498)
1984
(12222747)
1384
1358
1259
1778
1092
1798
8084
9094
1952
2407
2056
2152
1937 (14702499)
167 (54389)
33 (1184)
900 (5931305)
3346 (23194684)
2882 (21823747)
1622 (8012442)
432 (9856)
0
108 (0320)
2162 (12153110)
1338 (8131862)
482 (167796)
0
161 (1342)
1980 (13422618)
2878 (18442488)
3285 (25524172)
3168 (25563897)
3048 (23004029)
389 (178846)
0
1935 (14972499)
407 (233711)
0
1327 (4872889)
1252 (6672142)
1961 (11213184)
1832 (13842380)
8589
95100
593
Italy [60]
Italy [59]
Sweden [21]
Italy [34]
Italy [20]
IS
IS
UND 0
6 (013)
6 (013)
12 (222)
4 (010)
6 (013)
10 (119)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
014
1.94 (0.23
6.99)
2.73 (0.56
7.97)
2.73 (0.56
7.97)
3.64 (0.99
9.31)
9.09 (4.36
16.72)
4.57 (1.48
10.67)
0.91 (0.02
5.09)
1.83 (0.22
6.6)
7.32 (3.15
14.41)
5.99 (2.2
13.05)
23.98 (14.82
36.71)
22.15 (13.85
33.61)
9.63 (4.62
17.7)
4.81 (1.56
11.24)
36.59 (25.79
50.48)
15.98 (9.14
25.96)
2 (0.247.21)
20 (458)
20 (458)
13 (146)
0
55 (23108)
7(138)
14 (150)
14 (150)
0
36 (1183)
54 (21111)
54 (21111)
15 (154)
0
124 (70200)
22 (279)
59 (25116)
14 (150)
7 (138)
103 (56173)
6064
170
230
(40660) (120470)
120
210
(30470) (110390)
150 (100250)
20 (070)
30 (1080)
172 (60278)
38 (091)
211 (86335)
184 (75293)
0 (00)
184 (75293)
200 (125302)
90 (43165)
0
18 (264)
309 (214432)
74 (35136)
89 (46155)
7 (038)
14 (159)
186 (120275)
All IS
ICH
UND
M IS
ICH
All
F
IS
ICH
All
M IS
ICH
SAH
UND
All
F
IS
ICH
SAH
UND
All
M All
F
All
M IS
All
All
Sex Type
The Netherlands M
[58]
F
Study
Appendix 1 Continued
7074
760
900
(5401080) (6301270)
310
570
(190500)
(400820)
400 (320510)
60 (30100)
140 (100210)
978 (6691248)
51 (0123)
1030 (7121347)
373 (205540)
78 (2155)
451 (267635)
631 (473820)
210 (124331)
11 (0.261)
81 (32166)
936 (7421160)
350 (255469)
171 (105258)
0
70 (32133)
576 (452725)
6569
8084
9094
95100
2853 (23243467)
3303 (24874294)
2550
3340
6980
(15904110)
(16706680) (22502160)
2060
2650
3310
(15602720)
(18603800) (17806160)
690 (490980)
110 (40250)
1660 (13302070)
1570 (6082392)
315 (0753)
1896 (8332958)
2539 (15143563)
441 (10873)
2980 (18734087)
2083 (10393728)
0
0
378 (451364)
2462 (13094210)
2885 (21553779)
221 (60565)
0
499 (228948)
3607 (27844580)
3250 (15906290)
6690 (50108870)
8589
1831
2878
(16272053) (24783326)
1682
2795
(14591930) (24763144)
1810
1990
(13602400) (14002830)
1430
1170
(11101810) (8601890)
900 (7501090)
180 (120270)
420 (320560)
1329 (8121734)
212 (4421)
1542 (9852099)
1106 (7361435)
130 (3257)
1236 (8451626)
1261 (9091702)
60 (7216)
30 (0.7167)
210 (84432)
1562 (11602046)
951 (7391207)
96 (38197)
13 (072)
151 (75270)
1212 (9721490)
7579
594
T. Truelsen et al.
M
F
All
Vibo, Estonia
All
All
All
19 (435)
15 (227)
17 (727)
10 (518)
6 (310)
3 (0.99)
6 (310)
6 (310)
2 (07)
0 (06)
0 (017)
1 (04)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3.9 (1.68.1)
2
6
3
3
(08)
(022)
(07)
(07)
10.7
3 (017)
5 (019)
4.5
1.4 (08)
1519
2024
3034
6 (311)
34 (2055)
12 (818)
12 (818)
4 (113)
2 (010)
0
0
6 (216)
2 (019)
0
0
0
2 (010)
19 (934)
9 (320)
2.7 (0.39.8)
0
1.4 (07.6)
5.1 (1.413)
2529
4044
25 (1538)
67 (36115)
30 (2142)
30 (2142)
7 (032)
0
7 (032)
0
14 (243)
22 (656)
0
7 (034)
0
29 (1066)
9.6 (3.520.9)
18.1
32 (1560)
34 (1051)
30.8
8.4 (3.118.2)
230 (208252)
131 (117145)
70
20
40
3.1 (0.811.9)
4.2 (0.912.2)
8.2 (317.7)
3539
5054
184 (64304)
114 (30198)
145 (74216)
57 (26108)
35 (1863)
21 (750)
47 (2873)
48 83076)
81 (60107)
91 (50152)
156 (71296)
87 (68110)
96 (56156)
16 (350)
16 (350)
0
128 (80195)
32 (1174)
32 (1174)
16 (351)
0
81 (44137)
62.8 (42.289.7)
47.5 (689)
98 (60152)
78 (43123)
112.7 (51174)
130
170
150
22.2 (13.235.1)
13.2 (6.623.6)
13.6 (6.824.3)
28.8 (18.442.8)
4549
Rates are shown for rural (r) and urban (u) populations.
All 1, 2, 3: incidence rates in West Lambeth, Lewisham and North Southwark, and Tunbridge Wells.
All
Germany [65]
Germany [36]
UK [22]
UK [64]
UK [63*]
All
All
All
All
All
All
All
All
All
IS
ICH
SAH
UND
All
IS
ICH
SAH
UND
All
IS
All
Greece [40]
UK [37]
Italy [18]
All 1
All 2
All 3
M
F
White
Black
Other
All
M
SAH
All
All
All
All
All
All
All
All
All
All
All
M
F
M
F
All
M
F
All
M
F
M
0
0
0
10
10
10
2 (012)
0
0
0
SAH
ICH
Lithuania [62]
ICH
014
Sweden [61]
Type
Sex
Study
Appendix 1 Continued
6064
7074
209 (140300)
144 (105192)
120 (78176)
254 (204314)
124 (90168)
185 (153222)
358 (268471)
306 (158535)
219 (188253)
160 (102240)
19 (359)
9 (045)
0
188 (125273)
136 (85206)
42 (1789)
25 (766)
0
203 (140286)
147.4 (115.1
185.8)
327 (156499)
178 (73283)
239 (146333)
409 (303541)
388 (319468)
403 (316507)
531 (446629)
403 (336478)
438 (387494)
1003 (7731281)
956 (5231604)
496 (444551)
531 (401690)
66 (26139)
0
13 (163)
610 (470779)
353 (265463)
74 (37134)
9 (044)
5 (026)
437 (338557)
408.1 (345.7
481.6)
1161 (7891534)
1052 (7671301)
1092 (8631298)
478 (353603)
750
730
740
599 (485732)
445 (354552)
662.4 (512813)
370
240
300
308 (237394)
136 (90196)
240.3 (162319)
195.9 (125267)
1550
1320
1420
25.3 (13.842.5)
101.1 (74.8
133.6)
16.5 (7.132.5)
61.5 (42.685.9)
6569
550
330
430
22.2 (11.837.9)
13.8 (627.2)
29 (16.946.5)
50 (33.571.8)
5559
8084
911 (8171013)
2165 (14713072)
1506 (7222770)
934 (8411034)
1017 (7331377)
203 (89401)
0
68 (12213)
1288 (9661685)
957 (7641185)
207 (123330)
16 (176)
33 (984)
1197 (9801448)
887 (766.2
1028.1)
1201 (5751826)
1499 (10641933)
1415 (10571774)
1860
1780
1820
879 (6831115)
898 (7371083)
1275.3 (1023
1503)
1165.5 (937
1394)
650
2560
1760
208.1 (160.6
265.2)
12.8 (3.532.8)
128.9 (97.6
167.1)
27.1 (1447.4)
7579
9094
2265 (6063925)
1916 (11052728)
1993 (12622724)
1874 (16132166)
6410 (307411788)
2907 (9446783)
1972 (17082265)
1932 (12162920)
242 (43758)
0
242 (43758)
2415 (16063491)
1594 (11962084)
0
0
374 (216605)
2013 (15642554)
1153.2 (923.71418.5)
2137.1 (15682706)
3390
2110
1913 (11992896)
1887 (14822369)
3218.9 (25023936)
27.8 (965)
12.3 (0.368.6)
167 (112.7238.4)
147.8 (69.7237.3)
8589
95100
595
Sweden [72]
France [71]
Estonia [16]
IS
IS
All
All
All
M
F
M
All
All
5.6 (1.813.2)
8.1 (3.216.7)
19982000
506 (416614)
748 (612913)
128.5 (89.9177.9)
264.1 (206.6332.7)
251 (167364)
269 (154436)
230 (119402)
161.7 (149175)
296.4 (276317)
455 (364
569)
222 (167
294)
83 (45139)
1301 (65
234)
35 (7103)
102.9 (93
113)
55.6 (4963)
21.9 (12.934.6)
21.7 (20.123.2)
182 (87277)
51 (1101)
45.5 (32.162.4)
35 (1471)
30 (687)
39 (11100)
26.1 (2131)
21.8 (1726)
1994
69.2 (5286.5) World standardization
1994
40 (29.450.6) World standardization
19982000
32.4 (30.634.2)
19911993 17 (1026)
19911993 29 (2141)
19931995
18 (1521)
18 (1521)
ICH 1992
SAH 1992
All
19931995
18 (1422)
99 (92106)
SAH 1992
IS
1992
187 (175199)
5 (029)
10 (058)
9.5 (712)
6.6 (49)
30 (2535)
1992
17 (727)
13 (125)
20 (535)
014 1519 2024 2529 3034 3539 4044 4549 5054 5559 6064
ICH 1992
IS
1993
All All
1993
All
1993
All
19851988
19851988
All
Finland [69]
Finland [68]
All
All All
1997
All
Germany [67]
1997
All
Italy [66]
1997
Study
1821 (1277
2365)
1755 (1144
2166)
1780 (1452
2108)
3070 (23293811)
2787 (19543620)
3459 (19794939)
1392 (873
2465 (9885077)
2103)
1137 (805
2073 (12073317)
1558)
1219 (930
2174 (13933239)
1573)
1630 (1476 2559 (20673051)
1784)
156 (108
49 (19117)
204)
30 (951)
0
1485 (1392 2892 (26253159)
1578)
153 (123
154 (92216)
183)
39 (2454)
51 (1587)
2147.7 (1626.6
756.3 (643.2 1621.7
883.6)
(1398.1
2782.6)
1871.1)
463.3 (381.8 1183
1734 (1406.12115.4)
557.2)
(1027.6
1355.3)
1223 (954
2296 (17423027)
1568)
1296 (1102 2716 (23613125)
1525)
979 (718
1240)
629 (443
815)
783 (628
938)
731.1 (673
789)
594.9 (557
633)
647 (410
970)
573 (392
808)
602 (453
782)
596
T. Truelsen et al.
Denmark [77]
Denmark [19]
Sweden [76]
Sweden [75]
Sweden [74]
Finland [73]
All
M
F
M
All
All
All
All
IS
ICH
All
IS
ICH
All
SAH
All
All f and r
SAH
All
All f and r
All
All
All
M
F
M
All
UK [31]
All
All
All
M
F
M
Finland [17]
Type
Sex
Study
Appendix 2 Continued
19881993
19881993
19901991
19871989
19871989
1998
1998
1998
1998
1998
1998
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
1991
19871991
19871991
19901991
20022004
19891991
19891991
20022004
Year
014
2024
325 (281376)
398 (346458)
17.3
0
1519
3034
17 (832)
15 (730)
252 (239265)
143 (134152)
41
18
59
28
5
33
5.2
6
2529
4044
36 (2255)
48 (3270)
15
160
199
40
76
88
16 (257)
47.8
20.9
27 (769)
3539
5054
99 (45221)
152 (79291)
78 (53110)
176 (138222)
54 (20117)
155
90.4
73 (33138)
4549
6064
296 (208
4219)
561 (423746)
181 (137234)
358 (295431)
388
108
396
242
51
293
175 (100284)
397.2
217.1
177 (103284)
5559
7074
824 (653
1040)
556 (444698)
514 (418626)
754 (625902)
1217
172
1389
638
90
728
12
1059
1360
44
657
959
408 (271589)
708.3
553.2
646 (470868)
6569
8084
1460 (1143
1839)
1504 (1252
1792)
1746 (1375
2263)
1250 (994
1573)
1606.8
1615.4
942 (656
1310)
1051 (789
1371)
7579
9094
95100
2189 (15772958)
1738 (9732867)
1508 (10172152)
1972 (11493158)
8589
597
598
T. Truelsen et al.
039
4044
4549
5054
5559
6064
8084
8589
90100
9600
550
10 200
7900
10 700
9800
9100
10 000
1468 (9052228)
5900
4800
2600
7500
3400
7900 (4700
11 200)
3400 (1400
5300)
5800 (3900
7600)
409.8
573
492.9
2992.8
1069
1959.8
2500
1600
11 500 (6500
16 400)
7400 (3900
10 800)
9600 (6600
12 600)
5649.7
4424
4977.7
5000
3300
16
36
11
25
14
25
000 (4500
100)
600 (3900
100)
700 (7300
000)
6341.5
8042
7332
8900
6700
0
3074
11 600
10 500
3250 (15906290)
16 800 (11 30024 100)
6690 (50108870)
19 700 (15 70024 300)
2160 (1500
3020)
1140 (6901780)
F
Both
7579
9300
3600
5000
Both
UK [80]
1st
Rec
UK [81]
M
7074
Italy [25]
Male
39.6
M
41
Both
40.5
The Netherlands [24]
M
F
Sweden [21]
M 1st
M
F 1st
F
UK [79]
M
6569
1640 (1230
2150)
4680 (3600
5970)
3390 (2560
4400)
3980 (3330
4770)
11 010 (8750
13 650)
7970 (64809730)
9110 (7850
10 570)
8220 (4370
14 050)
10 410 (7700
13 730)
9840 (7550
12 600)
6990 (3330
10 650)
5130 (2030
8220)
14 360 (9350
19 370)
7730 (3970
11 490)
7140 (3250
11 040)
11 230 (6700
15 760)
205 (183230)
42 (3355)
1100 (02610)
510 (01490)
4760 (1730
7800)
3080 (6505500)