Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Source: Middle East Journal, Vol. 3, No. 4 (Oct., 1949), pp. 441-454
Published by: Middle East Institute
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/4322116 .
Accessed: 02/05/2014 11:42
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Middle East Institute is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Middle East
Journal.
http://www.jstor.org
THE
OF
DEVELOPMENTS
COMMENT
QUARTER:
AND
JUNE
THE
CHRONOLOGY
I
AUGUST
31I,
1 949
441
442
A CoalitionGovernment
for Egypt
After five years of internal struggle, Egypt
again acquired,on July 26, a governmentbased
on the coalition of the four major political
parties: the Wafd, the Liberal, the Saadist,
and the Nationalist, together with a numberof
independentministers.The announcedpurpose
of the coalition was to preparefor the regular
quadrennial elections due to be held in October.
Husayn Sirri Pasha, the new Prime Minister, was a non-party man who had held the
post from fall I94I to February I942, when
the Germans were threatening Egypt from
al-Alamein. Known for his friendly feelings
toward foreigners in general, he also had the
respect of the political parties because of his
independent position. His appointment as
Prime Minister by King Farouk was a reassuringsign for the stability of Egypt. For the
past five years, since King Farouk dismissed
the Wafdist Cabinet of Nahas Pasha in October 1944, the country had known one of its
most delicate political periods. Two prime
ministers had been assassinatedwhile in office;
terrorism, riots, demonstrations, and strikes
had been widespread; and Egypt had met with
failure in its attempt to revise its treaty with
Great Britain and assert its power in Palestine. The stock market had reachedits lowest
point, business had been slow, foreign capital
had started moving out of the country because
of increasinglyrestrictive measures,and xenophobic feelings had been whipped up by such
fanatic organizations as the Moslem Brotherhood.
With the situation elsewhere in the Middle
East coming to a boil-the defeat in Palestine, the attempted coup d'etat of Anton
Saadeh in Lebanon, the successful coup d'etat
of Za'im in Syria-King Farouk was wise
enough to realize that a similar crisis might
occur in Egypt if the internal political struggle
was permitted to continue. With the Wafd
included in Sirri Pasha's Cabinet, feelings
began to cool off and signs of confidence to
reappear:businesswas alreadymore active, the
stock market was rising, hundredsof internees
were released, and the sequestration imposed
on Jewish commercial establishments was
Syria'sSecondCoup d'Etat
MarshalHusniZa'impassedfromtheSyrian
sceneas unexpectedlyand as effortlesslyas he
had appeareduponit. On August 14, a group
of armyofficers,headedby Col. SamiHinnawi,
arrestedand executed,after a summarytrial,
both Marshal Za'im and Prime Minister
Muhsinal-Barazi.The coupd'etatwas otherwise bloodless,andtherewas a total absenceof
publicdisturbance.
The Syrianpeopleaccepted
the new changeas quietlyas theyhadaccepted
Marshal Za'im's own coup the previous
March.
The new turn of eventswas only indirectly
a counter-move.Col. Hinnawi immediately
madeclear that he was neitherreversingthe
actionof March,in whichhe hadbeeninstrumental, nor attemptingto set himself up in
Za'ini'sstead.On the contrary,he insistedthat
he and his associateswere merely returning
the previouscoupd'etatto its trueaims,which
they felt MarshalZa'imhad abused.As proof
of theirgoodintentions,Col. Hinnawinamed
HashimBey Atasi, a formerpresidentof the
republic,as provisionalprime minister,and
of a coalichargedhim with the appointment
tion cabinetto take over the affairsof state
and make preparationsfor the electionof a
ConstituentAssembly.
The oppositionto MarshalZa'im'sregime
was basednot so muchon what he had done
as on the mannerof its doing.It hadnot been
443
444
Afghanistan-Pakistan
Conflict
In the earlypartof March 1949, when the
Governor-Generalof Pakistan, Khwaja Nazimuddin, referred to the Tribal Area and the
NorthwvestFrontier Province as "an integral
part of Pakistan," the latent undercurrentsof
conflict between Afghanistan and Pakistan
suddenly rose to the surface again, and were
intensified by a bitter Afghan radio and press
campaign directed against the Pakistan Government.
The roots of the present conflict can be
traced back to I893 when Sir Mortimor Durand proposedthe Durand Line, to mark the
geographical limits to which Great Britain
and Afghanistan could go in mixing in the
affairs of the tribes along their frontiers. At
that time Afghanistan accepted the line as its
own eastern border.From there to the frontier
of India was "Free Tribal Territory" whose
inhabitants, closely akin to the frontier Afghans, retained their tribal autonomy. When
the Dominion of Pakistanwas formed in 1947,
a plebiscitewas held to determinewhether the
people of the Northwest Frontier Province,
largely Pathans, desired to become a part of
Pakistan or India. The results of the plebiscite, and the jirgas, or local parleys, subsequently held in the Tribal Area, indicatedthat
the tribes were in favor of becoming a part of
Pakistan, and were thereafter so considered.
An early Afghan reaction was reflected in a
statement made by Abdol Hosayn Aziz, the
Afghan Minister to the United States and
representativeto the UN, when, on September 30, 1947, he voted against the admission
of Pakistan to the UN on the grounds that
the recent plebiscite was "unfair." Later the
Afghan Foreign Minister, Ali Mohammad,
said that the results of the plebiscite were
achieved by "economicforce."
No further action was taken by either the
Afghan or Pakistan governments until the
445
Chronology'
General
'949
June I9: Trade union leaders from eight Eastern
countries meeting at Geneva -all
opposed to
the Communist-dominated World Federation
of Trade Unions -voted
to set up an Asian
Federation of Labor. The countries were Turkey, Japan, China, the Philippines, India,
Pakistan, Iran, and Indonesia. Other countries
expected to join the federation were: Syria,
Israel, Ceylon, Burma, Siam, and Afghanistan.
July 5: An Anglo-French conference began at the
British Foreign Office in London for the purpose of working out an approach to the disposition of former Italian colonies; Israel's
frontiers; the change of regime in Syria; and
economic problems in connection with President Truman's Point Four Program.
July 2': A British diplomat's parley on the
Middle East was opened in London by Foreign
Secretary Ernest Bevin.
Afghan'istan
(See also Pakistan.)
'949
June 4: The Afghan Government imposed restrictions on the movement of vehicles across
the Pakistan-Afghan border.
June I2: According to a report in Afghan News,
a Pakistani aircraft dropped five bombs on
Moghalakai, killing approximately 15 persons.
June i6: Najibullah Khan, Afghan Ambassador
to India, accused Pakistan of a "provocative"
attitude toward Afghanistan. Pakistan denied
the bombing of Afghan territory, and declared
that the plane was hit by rifle fire from the
ground.
June 20: Alfred John Gardener, a Counselor in
the British Foreign Office, was appointed
British Ambassador to Afghanistan to succeed
Sir Giles Squire.
June 23: Sardar Faiz Mohammed Khan, Afghan
Ambassador to Great Britain, said that his
country would seek British aid in its dispute
with
Pakistan
of 7,000,000
cated.
Egypt
(See also Palestine Problem.)
1949
June i8: It was reported that Egypt had sent
Marshal Husni Za'im, Syrian Chief of State,
an assurance of Egyptian support in case of
conflict with Iraq.
June 22: The Egyptian Government refused permission to 4 trade union leaders to attend a
conference in Geneva to set up a new trade
union international independent of the Communist-dominated World Federation of Trade
Unions.
June 24: Latest reports on narcotics in Egypt
showed that in the previous thirteen months
$8,ooo,ooo worth had been seized by the police.
June 26: The Egyptian Chamber of Deputies
approved an arms budget of L. E. 23,000,000
(about $ioo,ooo,ooo). This was about six
times the amount of the military budget before
the Palestine war, and represented about one-
447
guards were woundedin a 4-hour battle between police and more than 200 communist
prisoners in a jail on the outskirts of Calcutta.
June i6: Four representatives from the Princely
State of Jammu and Kashmir took seats in
the Central Indian Constituent Assembly.
They were Sheikh Mohammad Abdullah,
Prime Minister; Mirza Afzal Baig, Revenue
Minister; Maulana Mohammad Saeed, General Secretary of the Kashmir National Conference; and Pandit Moti Ram. (India Today,
July.)
June i9: The Chandenagore referendum approved, by an overwhelming vote, the merger
of the French colony with India.
June 23: A trade agreement between India and
the United States, United Kingdom, and
French zones of Germany was signed at
Frankfurt. (Government of India Information Service [GIIS], July I4.)
June 27: One Indian was killed and several
wounded when rival unions, one of them communist, clashed at the American-owned
National Carbon Company factory in a Calcutta suburb.
June 28: In accord with new regulations, the
property and fortunes of India's native Princes
were reduced by about one-fourth. A preliminary report by the States Ministry said
that the Princely property thus far divided
20
persons were
Iran
'949
I2:
Israel
(See also Palestine Problem.)
'949
449
ItalianColonies
Jordan
450
KashmirProblem
1949
June 6: Truce proposals put forward by the UN
Commission for India and Pakistan were rejected by both sides.
June IO: The UN Commission agreed unanimously to make further efforts to obtain a
truce agreement that would reconcile the
points of view of the governments of India and
Pakistan.
June 28: The senior member of the UN Commission negotiating the Kashmir dispute, Dr.
Alfredo Lozano, resigned, but agreed to continue as a member temporarily. (India Today,
July.)
July 26: Pakistan and India reached an agreement on a cease-fire along a 400-mile line
running from Manawar in the south to Keran
in the north, then east to Marol and Glaciers.
The Burzil Pass would remain under Pakistan
control, but an area 5 miles to the south of the
Pass would be freed of both Indian and
Pakistani troops. (N. Y. Herald Tribune,
July 28.)
dug. 8: The UN Commission invited India and
Pakistan to a joint meeting under the Commission's auspices to implement the truce
agreement in Kashmir.
dug. i8: The UN Commission announced that
it had called off a joint Indian-Pakistani Conference scheduled to be held August 22 to
implement the truce agreement, since "both
India and Pakistan have claimed the right to
incorporate Kashmir."
dug. 30: President Truman appealed to India
and Pakistan to settle their dispute over Kashmir as the first step in a policy to prevent the
spread of communism throughout Southeast
Asia by eliminating unrest and steadying political conditions in that area.
Lebanon
(See also Palestine Problem.)
'949
June 9: A newspaper plant in Beirut was partly
burned and some persons injured following
meetings of the Phalange and the Syrian
National Party.
July 4: The Lebanese Cabinet began organizing
a full-scale suppression of the activities of the
Syrian National Party as a result of recent
attacks on gendarmerie posts.
July 7: Lebanese Government troops arrested
Anton Saadeh, leader of the Syrian National
I2:
Pakistan
(See also Afghanistan, Kashmir Problem.)
I949
451
PalestineProblem
452
July 27: In his final reportto the SecurityCounthat the restriccil, Dr. Buncherecommended
tive truce conditionsbe lifted in favor of the
four armistice agreements which had been
signedby Israel andthe Arab states.
At the Lausanneparley,the Arabs accepted
Israeli proposalsfor handlingthe entry into
Israeli-held territory of wives and children
of Arab headsof familiesin Israel.
aug. 3: Arab delegationsto the UN Conciliation
Commissionannouncedthat they had agreed
to discussIsrael'sconditionalofferto acceptthe
returnof a numberof Arab refugees.
aug. 4: Moshe Sharett announcedthat the
Israeli Governmentwould be willing to resettle reportedlyIoo,ooo Arab refugees.The
number included 25,000 already there and
I0,000 who would return under the reunion
of familiesprogramalreadyagreed upon.
The U. S. and Great Britain voluntarily
offered to restrict arms shipments to the
Middle East to amounts reasonable for
security.
aug. 6: The Arabs agreed to the Israeli proposal to free blockedbankaccounts.The Arab
delegationto the UN ConciliationCommission
told the general committee that they were
preparedin principleto free Jewish accounts
in Arab banksup to an amountequivalentto
Arab accountsfreed in Israeli banks.
Aug. 8: Semyon K. Tsarapkin, Soviet delegate
to the UN, recommendedto the Security
Councilthat the UN withdrawfrom Palestine,
leavingIsrael and the neighboringArab states
free to reach final peace settlementswithout
"outsidepressure"or interference.
JUly
20:
Israel and Syria signed an armistice Aug. Ii: Dr. Ralph J. Bunche, Acting UN Mediagreement. Both sides agreed to keep their
ator for Palestine,was relieved of his duties
military forces behind their international
by the Security Council, which instructed
frontiers, and to establish demilitarized zones
Israel and the Arab states to continueobservin the contested areas. Syrian forces were to
ing the armisticeagreements.
be withdrawn from the eastern shore of
A compromiseplan on the Arab refugees
southern Lake Galilee and from the eastern
being preparedby the UN ConciliationComshore of Lake Hule, leaving those waters in
missionwas reportedto call for the return of
the hands of the Israelis. Unrestricted civil
250,000 Arabs to Israel and to requireIsrael
life would be resumed in the demilitarized
to relinquishthe lower part of the Negev,
zones until final peace negotiations were
possiblyofferingthe Gaza strip, now held by
established. The agreement also called for a
the Egyptians,in return. The U. S. was rewithdrawal of all defensive forces to lines
portedlypreparedto underwritethe cost for
three and a half miles on either side of the
resettlingthe Arabs, and to permit Israel to
armistice line.
retain all other territory acquiredafter the
29,
I947.
453
Persian Gulf
1949
May 28: A decree was issued regardingjurisdiction over the territorial waters of Saudi
Arabia and a proclamationconcerningcontrol
of the sea-bed and sub-soil off the Persian
Gulf coastof the Kingdom.(Text in American
Jour. of InternationalLaw, July, pp. I54-7.)
June 5: The Sheikdomof Bahreinissued a proclamation concerning its control of the sea bed
Saudi Arabia
(See also Persian Gulf.)
1949
dug. 27: The Saudi ArabianLegationin Cairo
issued a statement denying reports that the
governmentwas willing to ship oil to Haifa.
June 23: The U. S. received a one-year extension of its operational rights in the strategic
B-29 air base at Dhahran in an agreement
signed by representatives of the United States
and King Ibn Saud at Riyadh.
Syria
(See also Palestine Problem.)
I949
454
I7:
Turkey
I949
June 2: Turkey allocated $i8,297,872 for the
purchaseof 29 new cargo and passengerships
by
I952.
The TurkishForeignMinisterreportedthat
a Turkish diplomaticcourier died of bullet
wounds receivedwhile on Russianterritory.
June 8: The Turkish Government imposed
travellingrestrictionson diplomatsfrom Eastern Europe,keepingthemwithinthe city limits
of Ankara and Istanbul.
June 9: Col. General AbdurrahmanNafiz
Gurman replacedGeneral Salih Omurtak as
Chief of the GeneralStaff.
Cemil Sait Barlas, Minister of Commerce
and Economy,was transferredto the post of
Minister of State, where he was to act as coordinator between the government and the
EuropeanRecoveryProgramin Turkey, succeeding Nurullah Esat Sumer.Vedat Decleli
was appointed Minister of Commerce and
Economy.
July I: A military reorganizationlaw placing
Turkey's general staff under the authorityof
the Minister of National Defense came into
effect.
July 8: The governmentannouncedthat its newly drafted electoral law was ready to go to
the NationalAssembly,andwas expectedto be
in force before the I950 general elections.It
providedfor secret voting and publiccounting
of ballots, with representativesof all political
parties supervisingthe voting. (N. Y. Herald
Tribune,July 9.)
July 9: Foreign Minister NecmettinSadakconfirmed reports that Marshal Za'im of Syria
had askedTurkey to supplymilitary instruction to the SyrianArmy.
aug. 8: Turkey was approvedfor admissionto
the Council of Europe by the Committeeof
the Council at Strasbourg,France.