Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 10

Teaching Forum

Der? Die? Das? Easing the Struggle to Learn Definite Articles


Jennifer Bjornstad
Valparaiso University

Teaching the definite article of each and every German noun (and for
those of us non-native speakers, learning those definite articles ourselves) may at times seem like an uphill battle, a struggle not even worth
mounting. But like it or not, gender is an essential part of the German language. As we well know, the entire case systemwith all of the definite
articles, indefinite articles, der-words, ein-words, personal pronouns,
possessive pronouns, relative clauses, and adjective endingshinges on
whether a given noun is accompanied by der, die, or das. Start on
a false basis, and the whole structure crumbles.
For many nouns, repeated encounters with the words in context and
targeted practice are the only ways our students will eventually match
each noun to its proper gender. But for a surprisingly large set of nouns,
there are guidelines that can point the way to a correct gender determination. In my language classes, I provide my students with many opportunities to learn the definite articles of nouns in a natural way, through large
volumes of free readingthirty minutes per calendar day in my intermediate fourth-semester classand I encourage them to learn the gender of
each noun in their online flashcard work. But I also take them through a

carefully constructed set of activities designed to teach them the guidelines that do exist for determining noun gender. These guidelines can be
learned explicitly and applied immediately, giving the students a quick
boost in accuracy and new-found confidence with the German case system.
I often start the process of introducing my students to what I refer to as
the Gender Rules and Tips with a brief discovery-learning lesson. I remind the students of the rules and tips they already know (even if it is only
the fact that nouns referring to men take der and nouns referring to
women take die) and explain that there are many other such regularities in the language that they probably have not yet noticed. I tell them
that together, the class will work out what some of these other regularities
are. Each student is given a data bank, and pairs of students work together to make a series of hypotheses about the rules and tips governing
gender assignment. The data bank consists of a simple table of nouns
with their definite articles: der Professor, das Hndchen, die
Lampe.

69

70

UP 47.1 (Spring 2014)

Data Bank

Hypotheses

The Data Bank is a word list engineered to enable students to infer the
rules and tips, with multiple instances of each so that students can confirm their hypotheses while navigating around a few carefully chosen exceptions to the rules. After about ten minutes of pair work, I call the group
back together. As students offer their hypotheses and we fill in a master
chart together, I am able to correct, clarify, or expand on what they say
and to call attention to the evidence that supports each hypothesis and
any exceptions. This initial activity allows students to discover some of
the patterns on their own, involving them in the process and beginning to
make the guidelines memorable.

Make a table of your hypotheses. Write down your guess at the rules
or tips under the corresponding definite articles.
der

die

das

words for men

Lists of Gender Rules


Data
Look through these words to try to puzzle out what rules or tips there
are for determining the gender of a noun (der, die, or das). Some rules
have to do with the ending of the wordform; others have to do with the
category of the wordcontent.
das Hndchen

der Wein

das Bier

das Radio

die Decke

das Kind

die bung

der Vater

der Professor

das Lamm

das Schwimmen

der Onkel

die Republik

das Trinken

der Wagen

der
Kommunismus

das Auto

die Musik

das Essen

der
Rassismus

der Garten

der Whisky

die Lampe

das Baby

die
Wohnung

das Gepck

das Gesicht

das Auge

der Kognak das Mdchen

Next I provide students with a more comprehensive list of the Gender Rules and Tips. Although this list always goes beyond the limited
scope of the discovery lesson data set, I am careful not to overburden
them with a lengthy list unless they are at the most advanced levels. In beginning classes I stick with a simple list that includes basics such as names
of the days, months, and seasons (der) and nouns ending in heit and
schaft (die). In intermediate classes I expand to a list that includes more
obscure vocabulary and more complexities, such as names of most young
animals (das) and most nouns ending in al, ar, ier, and on, if they do
not refer to people (das). Not until our Senior Seminar course do I give
them a comprehensive list of rules and tips that I have gathered from various
sources, which includes some amusing ones such as Names of most rivers
outside Germany except for those ending in a, or e, which are feminine
(der). In each list, I include example words that the students are likely to be
familiar with to illustrate each of the categories: der Herbst, die
Freiheit, das Kalb, das Signal, der Mississippi. I treat the list as a reference sheet, printing it on colored paper and three-hole punching it so
that they can keep it in the front of their binders and refer to it often.

UP 47.1 (Spring 2014)

The final step, obviously, is to get students to actually learn the rules
and tips and to practice using them. I have converted each of the lists into
a set of flashcards that are posted on the website of the online flashcard
program Anki. Students simply add the flashcards to their Anki decks
and practice until they know the information by heart. On each card,
they are asked a question: What is the definite article for words ending
with keit? and they mentally provide an answer: die. Then they click
a button to check their answer and another to rate themselves. Did they
find the question hard? easy? very easy? The program uses the rating information to assign the next repetition of the cardsoon, if the student
did not know the answer at all, or later, if the student was able to answer
very easily. Additional decks of cards quiz example words: What is the
definite article of the word Universitt? The spaced repetition algorithm
on which the program is based assures an efficient use of students study
time and durability of the knowledge through continual review.1
I use class time to reinforce what the students have learned on their
own. Each day for a week or so, we spend five minutes on a fast-paced
practice session that makes sure the students are making the rules and
tips automatic not only in response to the written prompts that Anki provides, but also to oral ones I provide in class. The practice session uses a
two-stage scaffolded approach that allows all students to participate and
calls for maximum accountability.
In the first stage of the practice session, students respond to cues with
one of three cards (der, die, and das), which they have picked up
as they entered the room. The cards are simply 3 x 5 index cards with a
1 Praising the Anki program and similar systems (SuperMemo, Mnemosyne, Memrise) is
beyond the scope of this article, but I urge anyone interested in bettering students basic
knowledge of historical dates, past participles, vocabulary items, or any other facts to look
into the idea of spaced repetition upon which these programs are based. Except for
SuperMemo, these programs are free. The decks I have created for the Gender Rules and
Tips are available on Ankis Shared Decks page, at http://ankisrs.net/. Download the
program, then click the Get Shared button to search for the decks.

71

piece of colored paper with der (red), die (blue), or das (green)
glued to the card, front and back, laminated for durability. I say a noun,
and the students simply show the card they believe is correct, simultaneously. With this method, there is safety in numbers and the anonymity
of silence. The affective filter stays low, because if students need a hint,
they can glance from side to side to see what their neighbors think. After
students have had a second to think and respond, I give the correct answer orally and hold up the correct card to reinforce the answer with a visual confirmation. Because the cards are color-coded, I can see at a
glance approximately how many students know the correct answer and
which students are having difficulty. Because the cards are two-sided, the
students can see their answers as they hear and see the correct answer, reinforcing correct answers and identifying incorrect ones. The pace is
quick and energizing, and everyone is engaged, because everyone must
answer every time.
In the second stage of the practice session, students take more individual responsibility for correct answers. I have the students put the cards
away, and we move to oral, individual response. I do not take volunteers,
but rather call on students, using the cold call technique. I say the word,
pause for about one second, then say a students name: Demokratie[pause]Katherine. Stating the question first before calling on a
particular student to answer ensures that all students are involved at all
times, because they never know when they might be called on. Each
time, they need to listen carefully to the question and formulate an answer. I move quickly from question to question and from person to person, stopping only if the original answer given is incorrect to give a quick
Nein and switch to another student. Occasionally I follow up by having
a student state the relevant rule or tip (answering the simple question
Warum?) or by having the class as a whole repeat the correct article
and noun to solidify the sound of the pair in their ears and the feel of it in
their mouths: die Demokratie!

71

72

Beyond these quick targeted practice sessions that I conduct while the
students are in the initial stages of learning the rules and tips, I use some
class time throughout the semester to give students more contextualized
practice using the gender rules and tips in an activity I call, simply,
Tafelarbeit. All students work at the board simultaneously; I call out a
sentence in English and each student writes an equivalent German sentence on the board. While the class is writing, I can easily assess each students ability and I can coach them through any tricky spots, reminding
them what tools they can use to write accurate sentences. When it comes
to the definite articles, I feed the students reminders about the rules and
tips: Some of you dont have the correct definite article for Sommer.
What do the Rules and Tips tell us about times of year? Rightall of the
seasons are der-words. Remember that the same is true for the days of the
week and the months of the year. Many of you are having trouble with
the gender of Republik. What words does Republik rhyme with? How
about Musik? or Fabrik? Ahaso its a die-word, just like the other
words that end in ik. Are we talking about one car or two? Right, two.
So youre right that its der Wagen because it ends in en and its not an
infinitive. But in this case we need to write die Wagen because its plural. Before long, the students have the rules and tips memorized and can
use them when composing sentences. What they then know by heart and
can produce accurately in a controlled setting serves as an excellent basis
for more synthetic, creative, and authentic language work.
Assessment of students ability to use the gender rules and tips is natural and ongoing in the activities described above. In addition to this informal assessment, I include items on summative quizzes and tests that are
specifically designed to test students ability to apply their knowledge of
noun gender in a formal context, where getting the right answers makes a
difference in their grades. Sometimes I ask for the definite articles in a
completely uncontextualized format: ____ Mittwoch, ____ Realitt,

72

UP 47.1 (Spring 2014)

____ Lamm. At other times, I combine the testing of noun gender with
that of other grammar points, for example, with accusative and dative
prepositions: von ____ Baby, mit ____ Wagen, fr ____
Universitt. And of course when students do writing on formal assessments where grammatical accuracy is one of the grading criteria, their
application of the gender rules and tips plays a role in the grade they earn.
In conclusion, I believe that learning the rules and tips that govern the
gender assignment of certain sets of German nouns is an efficient way to
boost accuracy quickly. It is really not very difficult for students to learn
the fifteen rules of thumb listed on my Level I Gender Rules and Tips list.
By memorizing just fifteen pieces of information, they can instantly identify the genders of hundreds of the nouns that are common at a beginning
level: der Onkel, der Verkufer, der Franzose, der Schler, der Koffer, der
Professor, der Kuchen, der Computer, der Freitag, der Frhling, der
Wein, die Lehrerin, die Amerikanerin, die Schwester, die bung, die
Freundschaft, die Freiheit, die Musik, die Religion, die Universitt, die
Metzgerei, die Biologie, die Lampe, das Essen, das Gemse, das
Mdchen, das Auto, das Museum, das Baby, and many more.
At the same time that students are gaining in accuracy, they are also
gaining confidence in their ability to understand the way the German
language works. Especially at the beginning stages of language learning,
dealing with what seems like an arbitrary system can be frustrating for
students. In my experience, just this little handle on a corner of the German language can make students feel more at ease with the rather baroque case system that seems to loom over everything they try to do with
the language. If they know they can count on these patterns to give them
clues about the gender assignment of a fairly large number of common
words, then the article-noun pairs that need to be learned by rote seem
less harassing and the whole language-learning process more manageable.

BJORNSTAD: GENDER RULES

Level I Gender Rules and Tips List

73

Nouns ending in heit and schaft


die Freiheit, die Freundschaft

Nouns from foreign words ending in ei, ie, ik, ion, and tt
die Bckerei, die Energie, die Musik, die Religion,
die Universitt

Most nouns ending in -e (exceptions: those with prefix Ge- and


those denoting males)
die Lampe, die Decke, die Kreide

15% of the words not covered by the rules and tips

Masculine (der)

Nouns referring to male persons, their professions, and their


nationalities
der Vater, der Student, der Amerikaner

Most nouns ending in en, er, and or


der Garten, der Computer, der Professor

Most nouns ending in ismus


der Kommunismus, der Rassismus, der Sozialismus,
der Sexismus

Names of the days, months, and seasons


der Montag, der Februar, der Herbst

Names of alcoholic drinks (exception: das Bier)


der Whisky, der Wein, der Kognak

Infinitives used as nouns


das Schwimmen, das Essen, das Trinken, das Schlafen

Most nouns starting with Ge


das Gepck, das Gesicht

Most nouns ending in chen


das Mdchen, das Hndchen

60% of the words not covered by the rules and tips

Feminine (die)

Neuter (das)

Nouns referring to female persons, their professions, and their Most nouns ending in o and um
nationalities
das Auto, das Studium
die Mutter, die Lehrerin, die Amerikanerin
Names of most young people
das Baby, das Kind
Nouns ending in ung
die Wohnung, die bung
25% of the words not covered by the rules and tips

74

UP 47.1 (Spring 2014)

Level II Gender Rules and Tips List

Feminine (die)

Masculine (der)

Nouns referring to male persons, their professions, and their


nationalities
der Vater, der Student, der Amerikaner

Nouns referring to female persons, their professions, and their


nationalities
die Mutter, die Lehrerin, die Amerikanerin

Nouns ending in ung


die Wohnung, die bung

Most nouns ending in ich, ig, and ling


der Wellensittich, der Honig, der Fremdling

Nouns ending in heit, keit and schaft


die Freiheit, die Freundlichkeit, die Freundschaft

Most nouns ending in el, en, er, and or


der Schlssel, der Garten, der Computer, der Professor

Nouns from foreign words ending in ade, age, anz, ei,


enz, ette, ie, ik, ine, ion, isse, itis, ive, tt and ur
die Limonade, die Etage, die Allianz, die Bckerei, die
Konferenz, die Palette, die Energie, die Musik, die Religion,
die Kulisse, die Bronchitis, die Perspektive, die Universitt,
die Klausur

Most nouns ending in -e (exceptions: those with prefix Geand those denoting males)
die Lampe, die Decke, die Kreide

15% of the words not covered by the rules and tips

Most nouns ending in ismus


der Kommunismus, der Rassismus, der Sozialismus, der
Sexismus

Names of the days, months, and seasons


der Montag, der Februar, der Herbst

Names of alcoholic drinks (exception: das Bier)


der Whisky, der Wein, der Kognak

60% of the words not covered by the rules and tips

BJORNSTAD: GENDER RULES

Neuter (das)

75

Many nouns ending in nis, -sal


das Verhltnis, das Schicksal

Infinitives used as nouns


das Schwimmen, das Essen, das Trinken, das Schlafen

Names of most young people


das Baby, das Kind

Most nouns starting with Ge


das Gepck, das Gesicht

Names of most young animals


das Kalb, das Lamm

Most nouns ending in chen and lein


das Mdchen, das Blmlein

25% of the words not covered by the rules and tips

Most nouns ending in ment, ma, o, and um


das Fundament, das Schema, das Auto, das Studium

Most nouns ending in al, ar, ier, and on, if they do not refer to people
das Signal, das Formular, das Papier, das Stadion

76

UP 47.1 (Spring 2014)

Level III Gender Rules and Tips List


Masculine (der)

Nouns referring to male persons, their professions, and their


nationalities
der Vater, der Student, der Amerikaner

Most nouns ending in ich, ig, and ling


der Wellensittich, der Honig, der Fremdling

Most nouns ending in el, en, er, and or


der Schlssel, der Garten, der Computer, der Professor

Most nouns ending in ismus


der Kommunismus, der Rassismus, der Sozialismus,
der Sexismus

Names of the days, months, and seasons


der Montag, der Februar, der Herbst

Names of alcoholic drinks (exception: das Bier)


der Whisky, der Wein, der Kognak

Names of earth and rocks


der Ton, der Granit

Names of directions and winds


der Norden, der Fhn

Names of mountains, lakes and types of precipitation


der K2, der Bodensee, der Hagel

Names of cars and trains


der Audi A6, der Rheingold

Names of most foreign rivers (except for those ending in a, or


e, which are feminine)
der Mississippi

Names of most times of day


der Morgen, der Abend

Names of most types of money


der Dollar, der Euro, der Yen

Names of many large male animals


der Br, der Elephant, der Stier

60% of the words not covered by the rules and tips

BJORNSTAD: GENDER RULES

77

Feminine (die)

Nouns referring to female persons, their professions, and their


nationalities
die Mutter, die Lehrerin, die Amerikanerin

Nouns ending in ung


die Wohnung, die bung

Nouns ending in heit, keit and schaft


die Freiheit, die Freundlichkeit, die Freundschaft

Names of cardinal numbers


die Eins, die Zweiunddreiig

Names of planes and ships


die Messerschmidt, die Lusitania

Names of most types of flowers and trees


die Iris, die Pappel

15% of the words not covered by the rules and tips


Nouns from foreign words ending in ade, age, anz, ei,
enz, ette, ie, ik, ine, ion, isse, itis, ive, tt and ur Neuter (das)
die Limonade, die Etage, die Allianz, die Bckerei, die
Konferenz, die Palette, die Energie, die Musik, die Religion, Infinitives used as nouns
die Kulisse, die Bronchitis, die Perspektive, die Universitt,
das Schwimmen, das Essen, das Trinken, das Schlafen
die Klausur
Most nouns starting with Ge
Most nouns ending in e (except for those with the prefix Ge
das Gepck, das Gesicht
and those denoting males)
die Lampe, die Decke, die Kreide
Most nouns ending in chen and lein
das Mdchen, das Blmlein
Names of German rivers (except for rivers in the southwest,
which are masculine)
Most nouns ending in ment, ma, o, and um
die Donau, die Elbe
das Fundament, das Schema, das Auto, das Studium

78

UP 47.1 (Spring 2014)

Most nouns ending in al, ar, ier, and on, if they do not refer to people
das Signal, das Formular, das Papier, das Stadion

Many nouns ending in nis


das Verhltnis

Names of most young people


das Baby, das Kind

Names of most young animals


das Kalb, das Lamm

Names of letters and musical notes


das Z, das C

Names of colors
das Blau, das Purpur

Names of fractions
das Viertel, das Zehntel

Names of hotels, cafs, and cinemas


das Kempinski, das Sacher, das Odeon

Names of most metals, materials, and chemical elements


das Silber, das Porzellan, das Neon

25% of the words not covered by the rules and tips

Sources
Ashworth-Fiedler, S. (2003). Teach Yourself Quick Fix German Grammar. New York:
McGraw-Hill.
Dippmann, G., and Watzinger-Tharp, J. (1999). A Practical Review of German Grammar. 3rd
edition. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Durrell, M. (2003). Using German: A Guide to Contemporary Usage. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi