Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
You always have the same God, but acting in a new way
Marcionites write off the OT God – they say the Father of Jesus is nicer
Those who wrote the NT see God as the same God – you can’t understand who Jesus is
without knowing the OT God
Palestine
1. Held by the Ptolemies until 198 BCE – they lost to Seleucids
2. Antiochus IV Epiphanes 175-163
- defiled Temple in 167
Maccabean Revolt
1. Mattathias in Modin
2. His son, Judas Maccabeus becomes leader – 166-160
3. John Hyrcanus, grandson of Mattathias, leader and eventually king, 134-104
Politics in Palestine
1. There is unrest after the death of John Hyrcanus in 104 BCE
- assassinations – these went on everywhere
- civil war ensues and both sides appeal to Rome
- Rome calls for a cease-fire
- the Roman Senate debates and considers claims of both sides
- some side with one group, others side with the other and one thinks
they’re going to lose, so they send a message to start fighting again
- Rome says, you violated our cease-fire, so the other guys win
- they send in a general, Pompey (one of the original Triumvirate)
2. Pompey sacks Jerusalem in 66 BCE and Jewish independence is over
- the new ruler is a vassal who reports to the governor of Syria, who used to be
1
king of the Seleucid Empire
- back to where they started at beginning of Maccabean Revolt
- It’s an abomination – no graven images - and the people hate Rome, so the
people take it down
- Herod rounds up people and executes them
- He had the Roman army come in at night with banners flying in Jerusalem and a
2
riot ensues – lots of people executed
- People hate him despite any good things he did
- He keeps things in turmoil
- Cruel in his personal life – gets paranoid and has most of his family executed –
the 3 sons he has left are in jail and on his deathbed, he ordered their
execution, but this was not carried out
- When he died, his sons took over
Herod Antipas – until 39 CE – Jesus on trial
Deposed by his nephew
Philip - ruled a good section of Palestine until 33 or 34
Archelaus – in Judea, so bad the Romans banished him to Gaul and the
the territory was given to Syria, after 10 years of ruling;
In Luke, Archelaus ruled Bethlehem, so Family moved to Nazareth
No one liked these guys because they represented the Romans
There were constant revolts going on
- especially at time of feasts
- small groups felt anointed by God to get rid of Romans and they always lost
The Jews in the rest of the empire were just trying to live in peace, not seen as problem
By the 1st century CE, more Jews live outside of Palestine than in it
They were minorities in their cities
1. Portrays a type of person, who you were, not details of your life
- details were not important to ancient biographies
- Lives of the 12 Caesars – lots of incorrect details – what they showed was what
kind of person you exemplified, for example, Greedy or Virtuous
2. Aim more important than factual correctness
3. Many want to mold character
- read it and try to be like them
- look at how a person personifies ambition, or another quality
- don’t expect you to change, you are who you are as you’re born – Hercules as
a baby was already wrestling snakes and winning
- no concern for factual data
- they let you see who Jesus is
- theological writings
4
Gospels
1. Give context to give meaning
- to understand a particular thing about who Jesus is
- written differently to different audiences – Gentiles or Jews
- each gives a particular impression of who Jesus is
- chosen for canon because they give the best Christian theology, not the best
facts
Luke researched – talked to eyewitnesses, preachers and read other writings about Jesus
- he will write an “orderly account”
- will show you who he understands Jesus to be
- Luke has excellent writing skills
1. Written for Gentile audience, so Jews & Gentiles are equal in the kingdom of God
- explains Jewish customs
- gives special attention to Gentiles in the stories, all over the place
- non-Jews are important parts of stories
- Jesus begins his ministry in Galilee for the first few chapters, then crosses the
Sea of Galilee to a Gentile area (Decapolis)
- A whole section where Jesus crosses back and forth, doing for Gentiles what he
did for Jews on the other side of the Sea
- Gerasene demoniac is the first contact with Gentiles – an exorcism
- Jesus’ first miracle for Jews was an exorcism, then for Gentiles
- Jesus feeds 5000 Jews, then does same for Gentiles
- to show equality in the kingdom, Gentiles are just as important to God as Jews
6
- the centurion at the foot of the cross is the one who says this was the Son of God
- nobody else got it - the one guy who finally figures out who Jesus is
- the kingdom is about Gentiles
8. Mark writes around 70 CE – Temple fell that year – devastating for Jews & Christians
8
- Mark explains why
- what are we supposed to think when the only Temple to our God is destroyed?
- Mark helps readers understand:
Jesus goes to the Temple everyday in Jerusalem
Fig tree with no figs – so Jesus tells it to die (Mark says it wasn’t the
season for figs) – goes to Temple and turns over the tables – they go back
to tree and it’s dead
Fig tree = temple
Jesus was closing the Temple, not cleansing it – it’s no longer bearing fruit and its
time is over
Importance of story is that Jesus closed it – 60 years before the Romans do
Jesus goes back to Temple the next day – (5 UK football stadiums would fit in it)
and predicts its destruction – so the fall of the Temple is not devastating to
us
Combination of stories gives meaning and theological statements so you can see
Meaning
Stories do not mean things by themselves
What we need to know is “what does it mean?”, not exactly what was done or
said or the data – gospels give interpretation
There are 3 endings to Mark – but the abrupt ending is probably the actual ending
- the other 3 seem to be added to fill in what’s there
- best manuscript evidence has Mark end at chapter 16, verse 8:
where the women run away from the tomb afraid and said nothing
- resurrected Jesus never really seen in Mark, if you don’t count the others
Begins with Jesus’ ministry and ends with it – Mark quits with the ministry of Jesus
- everything you need to know about who Jesus is, you already have
- look at Jesus’ ministry to know Jesus, according to Mark
1. Mark presents Jesus as a person of power (always on the go, active, is on the ball)
- talks about Jesus in the way Romans envisioned important people (busy!)
- 1st part: everything happens immediately – a key word in Mark, Mark’s fave
- word is dropped in NRSV a lot
- 2nd part: on the way – moving, busy – does amazing, powerful things along the
9
way
- Jesus as recognizable person of position and power
Matthew - very different from Mark, although many of same stories & order
1. Written for Jewish Christians
- presents Jesus as Messiah of Judaism, as most important identity of Jesus
- genealogy of Jesus gives him the right Jewish credentials
- Jesus fulfills the promises attached to the Messiah
3. Great Commission – teaching them to obey everything God commands, the law
- at end of Matthew - “make disciples of all nations, teaching them to obey
all I have commanded you,” sends out disciples
- you follow commands of Jesus to do what God wants you to
- story in Mark about what goes in your mouth doesn’t make you unclean
- they don’t eat unkosher food - this story means something diff to Matthew
- Matthew’s church keeps the law carefully
- Jesus never said “don’t keep the law”
Matthew means the same thing as Mark, but in Judaism, Jews had ceased using the name
of God, to not take name of Lord in vain, hesitant to mention God by name
- so instead of “God,” Matthew uses Heaven
- doesn’t mean angels playing harps, etc.
- this helps us see who Matthew is writing for: Jewish Christian community
who continues to keep the law
Luke and Matthew have these discourses that Jesus says that Mark doesn’t have
Think that Mark was written first
– then Matthew and Luke wrote after that, based on Mark and “Q”
When Jesus interprets the Law, Matthew wants you to understand that the
meaning was embedded in the commandment
Adultery – deals with thoughts as well as actions, no lust, seeing people as things for your
own enjoyment
Love neighbor = everybody in the whole world, not just those like you
Point is to get to the true intention of the Law, what God has always intended
Matthew’s church sees the Law as a good thing when understood correctly
- deals with how you understand God’s will
- how you get to what God intends for your life
Beatitudes, Lord’s Prayer brought together by Matthew to make the Sermon on the
Mount
Grouping of these sayings may have been traditional since Matthew and Luke both use
them
(Paul says Gentile Christians are not allowed to keep the law, only Jewish Christians
- God saves Jews as Jews and Gentiles as Gentiles)
12
Primary point of Matthew’s gospel is theological, not historical
- Matthew doesn’t care where Sermon happens
**They tell you Jesus is uniquely from God
– if you get this, you get Matthew’s point
- from birth stories, an aggressive way to make this point
- among the Jews, this is a strange thing to say
- among Greeks, gods were having babies with humans all the time
Matthew cemented that identity for Jesus as from God, he is truly the Son of God
Fulfillment quotations
- Matthew says, this was done to fulfill what was spoken by the prophet
- example: “Out of Egypt I have called my son.” Hosea 11 – not a prediction
but an account of when God brought Israel out of Egypt
- Matthew quotes passages and says they’re about Jesus, when they fled to Egypt
“Immanuel” – Isaiah 7
- Matthew brings this passage into the narrative
- “God is with us”
Matthew does this to help you understand who Jesus is
- Jesus fulfills 5 scriptures just being born and going to Egypt
Everyone fulfills the scriptures in Matthew, even Herod
- All accords with what God intends to do
- Fits the pattern of the same God of Israel who has always acted
- God has the same character – acts the same way in the world
- repetitions of acts of God, by using OT passages
Matthew reads his perspective, the life of Jesus, into the passages
– is aware of his doing this
- bringing new meanings to the OT texts
- these were the only scriptures they had and read them in light of who Jesus is
Questionable whether Matthew the disciple (aka Levi) is the actual author, probably not
- Matthew himself worked a lot with Jewish Christians
Matthew has Jesus meets disciples in Galilee and gives them the commission
Commission emphasizes obedience
The way to go about pleasing God, how to keep the law
Luke (11-12-02)
Luke talks against the wealthy – one piece of evidence of idea that he’s an ex-slave
- he would have been smarter than his owners and may have resented them
telling him what to do
1. Fulfillment of prophecy
- In Matthew, everything Jesus does fulfills scriptures
- this is God acting in the world, happening the way God planned
- fulfillment automatically happens
- even as a baby, Jesus fulfills scriptures without trying to!
- In Luke, a different way of seeing fulfillment
- Jesus fulfills scriptures on purpose
- even says so, “to fulfill scripture”
- Jesus knows what his job is, so he does it
- Spirit of God leads him to do things
- Luke explains why Jesus did these things and makes connection between
Hebrew scriptures and Jesus
16
- Jesus knew the scriptures
2. Ministry of Jesus is the working out of God’s plan for world redemption
- everyone has a part to play in God’s plan
- everyone acts out their part of the script
- God has laid out the plot and now the characters must do what they’re supposed
to do
- God’s plan foretold and prefigured in scripture: God acted this way then and
now
- Luke understands himself to be writing a history as the Deut. Historians did,
giving a theological reading to it
- “Salvation History” - story of how God has acted among us (doesn’t mean how
people get saved), aka Holy History (in German)
- Luke divides history into different eras – God acting in different ways in the
different eras
- Moses, life of Jesus, time after Jesus of church
- same God, same character, but different ways of acting in the
world
Genealogy in Luke 3
- goes all the way back to God
- we are all children of God, but Jesus is the only one who acts like it
- who we were intended to be, like the archetypal human being
- Jesus makes that relationship possible for us
- this is all added meaning to term “Son of God”
John the Baptist said Herod was wrong for marrying his brother’s wife
- John hollers at Herod whenever he’s out in public
- John gets thrown in jail and doesn’t understand why he‘s been there so long
- so he sends his disciples to Jesus and asks, are you the one?
- Jesus has them spend the day with him, and says, you have seen the blind
healed, the possessed released, and good news to the poor - so that’s
how you know he is the one
- In Luke, shepherds – 3rd shift shepherds at that – were told and they find Jesus
in a stable, in a feeding trough
- Luke is the only gospel with a stable
- identifies Jesus with the poor because the rich would have been able to find a
room
- Matthew: big expensive gifts for Jesus the king
- Luke: Jesus is for the poor
Not trying to be historically precise, but are trying to show the meaning of Jesus’ life
- each gospel gives important readings of Jesus’ life but are different
Jesus is born, then they go to Jerusalem on the way home from Egypt
- first born son is taken to Temple for dedication and make sacrifice
- Luke likes to show characters as pious, following the law
- Simeon, an old man, reveals Jesus is Messiah
- he had been promised he would not die until he saw Messiah
- Anna, the prophetess recognizes Jesus
- she always stayed in the Temple
- a man AND a woman identify Jesus - a balance that Luke wants you to see
At age 30 – he is baptized
Do the stories of Jesus ring true to who God is and reveal the love of God
- how God acted in the life of Jesus
Seen differently in each gospel
- each one has something important to say of who Jesus is and what God
accomplished through Jesus
Faith of church is what the apostles say life and death of Jesus mean
- did not rely on historical or Jesus’ own interpretation of himself
When we tell stories, we leave out information
Everything we know about Jesus is interpretation and theology
The search for the historical Jesus is irrelevant
-those who do and write about it have Jesus end up being just like them
Christianity is not based on history but on the meaning of events in Jesus’ life, as the
apostles determined
Others were brought back from the dead in the Bible and it didn’t change the world,
so this transformation was important
Something big and important and new in the world - resurrection
Matthew doesn’t have a temple emphasis because its leadership was bad and it was
destroyed
Luke stays with it even though it was destroyed
John
John has:
- 3 cycles instead of 1 of Jewish feasts
- several trips to Jerusalem instead of one
Jesus is in Jerusalem a lot and also in Samaria (he wasn’t there much in
the Synoptics)
- Jesus’ ministry lasts 3 years
- Chasing people out of the Temple comes early in his ministry in John
- John tells different stories, has different sources
- if he were John or one of the 12, it would be strange because John stories are left
out of the synoptics, and even his brother James left out
- John was from Galilee, and the book is concerned with Jerusalem
- from a person of Judea, not John
- we don’t know who wrote the core of the book or the 1st draft, only that he
was called the Beloved Disciple
- someone who believed in Jesus and was pleased to be his associate
- whoever it was, they became a leader in the church, had a community
around him
24
Unique features of John: the whole thing
- arrangement of stories
- the stories included
- where he begins - at eternity: in the beginning was the Word...
- pre-existence of Christ
- the only one that does this
- one idea that it was written last because this theological idea developed later
- seen also in Philippians 2 - the hymn in it is earlier than the gospels
- it attributes this same idea to Christ
- 15-20 years after Jesus’ death this was taught
- in John, Christ is equal with God in eternity and in creation
- says Jesus was equal with God, so it’s not exactly monotheist
- difficult idea to work out
- trinitarian formulas were developed to deal with it
- John presents us with significant problems in thinking consistently about
who God is and how God was related to Christ
- sometimes have to reframe what John was thinking about because
it doesn’t fit the usual categories we deal with
- he wasn’t the only person to have this idea
- prologue may have been separate at first, from others
They didn’t see it violating the idea of one God - “I and the Father are one.”
25
No one could have caught onto his first answer
Something happened to Jewish Christians that turned them against their fellow Jews
- chapter 9, story of man born blind
- verse 22, parents were Jewish and part of synagogue
- shows that John’s church was thrown out of synagogue
- these were Jewish Christians who still went to synagogue, kept laws
- harsh language against the Jews reflects that experience of being thrown out
- they made claims about Jesus in the synagogue (perhaps) and were expelled
- writers and editors of John were Jewish
Acts
Part 2 of Luke-Acts
- there are thematic similarities
- story of the early church, where started and how spread
- 30 years are covered
- it’s a selective history
- Luke chose episodes to give the reader a particular understanding of how
God works in the church
Judaizers:
- talks about how the church could spread as it does, helps church reject the
Judaizers who said even Gentile Christians had to keep the laws and
convert to Judaism (circumcision, food laws, Sabbath)
- this was the biggest battle of the early church and it had to move beyond
Judaism
- Jesus as Messiah became a sect within Judaism
- the message went beyond Judea - spread to a Samaritan and then to Gentiles
- this was a real struggle in that Jews saw themselves as the people of God and
that someday everyone would convert to Judaism
- the Jews felt that people would come to them, but the new radical idea
was that the Christians would go out to the nations
- this struggle went on for 400 years
Look at Acts:
- Peter stories - he raises dead guy, etc
- Paul stories - he does the same things Peter does
God does the same things through Peter and Paul
- there had been question if Paul was a legitimate apostle
- Acts says he was
Acts says the church is a mixed community and that Judaizers are wrong
28
HIGHLIGHTS OF ACTS (11-19-02)
That first day, 3000 became Christians and devote themselves to apostles’ doctrine and
fellowship
- Luke wrote Acts and he was always on the side of the outcasts and 2nd class, and
against the influential
- so he has them form an ideal community, where they had all things in common,
they sell what they have and share it
- the result is that more people are converted every day
- this is the only time he presents the church in this way
- because it didn’t always happen that way and it didn’t work
- the Jerusalem church eventually ran out of money
- the ideal thing Christians do is share their possessions
More and more Jews begin to listen in Jerusalem and Judea, nowhere else
- people were there from all over the world because it was Passover
- they stay because of becoming Christian, sell their possessions
- keeps them in Jerusalem and Judea
- the gospel was only in Judea at this time
The most important story in book of Acts after chapter 2 is the conversion of Cornelius
- he is a good man, gives alms, prays to God
- angel shows up when he’s praying one day and says to send for a man named
Peter in Joppa and he will tell you what I want
- at the same time, Peter is taking a nap on the roof of the house and has a dream:
a sheet comes down from heaven, full of unclean animals. A voice says,
kill and eat. Peter says, no, I’ve never eaten anything unclean. Voice
says, what I say is clean, don’t you say it’s unclean. He awakens, goes
back to sleep and has this dream again. He ends up having it 3 times.
- he goes downstairs, and Cornelius’ people arrive and ask for him, saying an
angel says he’s to come and see Cornelius
- he goes with them but says he’s not really supposed to be with them, but had
a dream, so it should be OK
- Cornelius meets them outside as they arrive
- Peter preaches to Cornelius and his family and the Holy Spirit comes onto them
just like it did on the apostles at Pentecost
- Peter thinks if God accepts them, we should too
- so he baptizes them
Then Peter must go back to Jerusalem and face the church there
- he took Gentiles in without converting them first to Judaism, for the first time
- if they had been converted to Judaism before baptism, no problem
31
- but this was a problem
Jerusalem church meets him and says, how could you have done such a thing?
Luke spends a lot of time and space on this story – tells it twice here and a 3rd time in
Acts 15
- Luke says the whole church rejoiced
- the time when the first Gentile comes in
- all the details matter
- this is an important story, who characters are (if Paul let them in, they would
have thought, well of course Paul would let them in)
- especially important that Peter let them in – apostle to Jews
- it wasn’t Peter’s decision – it was God’s decision
- he had to take them after God did
- it was an act of the Spirit that God accepted the Gentiles
- the turning point in what Christianity was to be
Caused quite a stir, but was somewhat acceptable because it was just one family
Cornelius and family were like Gentile mascots of the church, showing the church’s
broad-mindedness
What happens when you get too many Gentiles?
Paul tells this same story in Galatians 2 where 2 missions are set up:
- Paul says he went, by revelation from God
- he says they shake hands and create two separate missions:
Paul to preach to Gentiles, Peter to Jews
Jews and Gentiles didn’t always get along as well as indicated in Acts
Galatians church had both kinds in it
- this caused difficulties
- how do you eat together? How do you fellowship together?
- problem with eating affected Lord’s Supper
This council authorized the mission to Gentiles that does not bind Law of Moses on them
- a letter was sent saying to reject the culture around idolatry (not eating meat
sacrificed to idols, not drinking blood, nothing strangled, and no
fornication)
In Jerusalem, he told it would be good for him to go to the Temple, to put down rumors
- but he is arrested for supposedly taking a Gentile into the Temple
- Acts says he didn’t
- he is imprisoned and eventually goes to Rome and is in prison there 2 years
- story of Acts stops there because it’s likely Paul was executed, and Luke never
shows Christians being found guilty by Roman judges
- there is an unlikely theory that Paul went back to Asia Minor
Acts tells story of the progress of Christianity through this area of the world
and it followed that first part of Acts where Jesus says I want you to be witnesses
in Judea, Samaria and the rest of the world
They end up covering the rest of the world
God has a hand in all of this
- God’s Spirit coming in the beginning of the church
- this is an eschatological community
- an act of God that Gentiles come in, with support from experience of God’s
Spirit and from scripture, here’s what the prophets meant
– spread of Christianity throughout the Gentile world
34