NAUG-A PROJECT

Comments Resolution Sheet

Document No.

V-2151-100-A-070_000

Vendor

Maloney

Date: 17.02.16
Sl. No

Document /
Drawing No. Rev. No.

Document Title

Sheet No./
Section

001

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please show plant North as per equipment actual orientation on plot plan drawing.

Noted

002

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please confirm and show equipment installation elevation.

Noted

003

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Provide holes for anchor bolts, in the flange of main perimeter beams of skid base. Holding
down bracket to be removed.

Noted

004

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please delete this min base thickness dimension.

Noted

005

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please provide transportation, lifting and inplace analysis calculations for reference.

Noted

006

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

JGC Comments

Please include design code (ASCE 7-05) and basic parameters in drawing notes, as shown
below:
A- Wind loads are calculated as per ASCE 7-05 with below basic parameters:
i. Basic Wind Speed [3-sec gust, 50 year recurrence] : 96 mph
ii. Exposure Category : C

Maloney Response

JGC reply

Remarks

OK. Please update anchor bolts arrangement in drawings.

Noted

B- Seismic loads are calculated as per ASCE 7-05 with below basic parameters:
i. Short Period Acceleration (SS) in %g : 18.6
ii. 1-Sec Period Acceleration (S1) in %g : 5.3
iii. Site Class: C

1 OF 1

Washer (ASTM A36) for over size holes shall be required to cover the hole (supply by JGC).
Vendor to confirm washer thickness and size and field welding requirement based on shear Noted
force.

OK. Please show anchor bolts sectional view (as per SAMPLE provided in comments) in the
drawing.
Also, please specify washer thickness, size and field welding requirements on drawing.

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please confirm,
1) Operating load is:
DEAD Load + Content Load or Content load only
&
2) Test load is:
DEAD Load + Test Fluid Load or Test Fluid load only.

Dead load is the empty weight, not the hydrotest

-. Please confirm max load on Operating load : Empty weight + Fluid/gas weight during operation
OR only Fluid/gas weight during operation.
-. (why max load on empty condition is same with operating condition ..?)
-. Please confirm max load on Hydrotest are : empty weight + Fluid/gas weight during hydrotest OR
only Fluid/gas weight during hydrotest.

009

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Over size holes can be provided

OK. Please specify hole size on drawings.

010

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

011

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

012

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please check that selected anchor bolts size is safe for all loading conditions

Noted

013

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Indicate these bolts are supplied by Maloney for clarity

Noted

014

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Add ERECTION Condition.

Noted

015

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Delete Please.

Noted

016

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please confirm, Test load is:

DEAD Load + Test Fluid Load or Test Fluid load only.

017

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Total Dead Load = 29.8+29.8+44.8+44.8 = 149kN is less than max dead load of 17400kg
specified in plan. Check please.

018

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please confirm, operating load is:

DEAD Load + Content Load or it is Content load only.

019

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

T.O.C Elevation = 100.050m

020

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

021

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please show framing arrangement of skid base. Indicate size of skid beams and their
location.

Noted

022

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Please check wind and seismic load values. Please provide wind and seismic force
calculation for reference.

Noted

023

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

Sleeper support will be provided shown in grey color (parallel to 4m edge of skid base).
Please confirm this is ok for skid base design.

024

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

1 OF 1

V-2151-100-A-070_000

FOUNDATION AND ANCHOR BOLT DETAILS DISCHARGE COALESCER FILTER SKID N53-U-0004

008

007

Please provide slotted or over size holes (maximum possible size) based on beam flange
size.
Select and specify anchor bolts as per JGC standard drawing D-000-1320-005.

This can be done if the required, although it goes against the concept of using a loose bracket with
Please select and specify anchor bolts from JGC Standard Drawing as commented.
vertical slotted hole

Please delete this additional holding down bracket and provide holes for anchor bolts, in the
Noted
flange of main perimeter beams of skid base.

OK. Please delete additional holding down bracket and update anchor bolts arrangement in
drawings accordingly.

Please delete additional holding down bracket.

Dead load is the empty weight, not the hydrotest

Vendor response is not clear.

The confirmation was required for Test Loads whether the given Test load value includes dead load
of equipment or is this load in addition to the equipment dead load? i.e.
-> Test load = DEAD Load + Test Fluid Load
OR
-> Test Load = Test Fluid load only

We will check and reconfirm

Ok, Please update drawings based on confirmation.

It is dead load + content load

OK

Noted

Please elaborate this live loading condition.

1) Please reconfirm the loading values and direction (+ve or -ve) at each support A1~A4, Live platform loads are assumed to be temporary, nozzle/pipework loads depend on plant operation.
B1~B6) separately.
The live nozzle/pipework load is an additional load from the pipework on the vessel nozzles. It does OK
2) The live nozzles/pipe work loads are additional to operation load i.e. total load at anchor not include the operating or dead load from the skid, they need to be added
point will be operation + live (nozzles), confirm please?

Noted. The structure will be designed for the worst case spans between H.D. fixings. Therefore OK. Based on Vendor confirmation, it is recommended to show foundation at anchor point as
extent of clients civil bases is irrelevant.
marked in Attachment 3.

In the table, foundation loads shall be presented for each load case separately, not for load
Noted
combinations as per PIP STC01015. Please confirm and delete this note.

1 of 1