Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
JOURNAL OF
OTOLOGY
NOISE INDUCED HEARING LOSS IN CHINA: A POTENTIALLY COSTLY PUBLIC HEALTH LSSUE
Shi Yongbing , William Hal Martin
Abstract
Hearing loss and tinnitus are among the most common consequences of long term noise exposure and remain an under-addressed heath issue in most developing nations including China. The rapid industrialization and life style changes in China increase the concern over noise exposure and noise induced hearing loss
(NIHL). Research on NIHL in China is limited. The current paper reviews studies published in English and
Chinese language literatures regarding noise exposure and NIHL in China. Their implication on the Chinese population is discussed. The possible utility of a research model such as the Dangerous Decibels as a
means to increase understanding of the scope of NIHL among the Chinese population, to educate the general public in China (especially the young) about NIHL and its prevention, and to study effects of language
and cultural factors on international information dissemination and behavioral interventions is proposed.
Key words: noise, noise-induced hearing loss, China
Introduction
Noise hazard can cause many health problems. Hearing loss and tinnitus are among the most common consequences of long term noise exposure. Other health issues such as anxiety and hypertension have also been reported to be related to noise exposure. While noise hazard has been extensively studied in industrialized countries, it remains an under-addressed heath issue in most
developing nations including China. China is the largest
developing country in the world. As it is rapidly industrialized in the past few decades, occupational noise exposure and noise exposure in daily life among its population are on the rise and there is an increasing concern
over the potential health consequences of such exposures. In recent studies, in addition to other environmental factors such as lack of relaxation and physical exercise, frequent extra work shifts and air pollution, noise
pollution is ranked number four to contribute to a
sub-healthy status in the Chinese population[1]. Noise exposure has also been shown to be a significant determinant of hypertension prevalence in China, trailing only
Affiliation:
Oregon Hearing Research Center NRC04
3181 SW Sam Jackson Park Road, Portland, OR 97239,
USA
Corresponding authors:
SHI Yong-bin
Emailshib@ohsu.edu
51
and can be a devastating condition in some cases. Studies in mostly developed countries suggest that prevalence of tinnitus among the general population is about
15% and increasing[30, 31]. It is reasonable to assume similar or worse tinnitus prevalence in China. Tinnitus will
likely become a significant problem for China if hearing
loss continues to increase in the country.
The Significance of NIHL in China
The significance of NIHL in China is probably greater
than in some other countries, considering Chinas population of 1.3 billion and its efforts to develop its economy and to improve living conditions for its people. In
addition to the loss of productivity and life quality to NIHL, the cost of rehabilitation for hearing-impaired individuals can be un-proportionally heavy for China as a
large developing country. Of major hearing aid brands
sold in China, the Oticon hearing aids carry relatively
low prices. Prices of Oticon hearing aids in China range
from $240 to $3,400 per piece depending on the model,
with a median price at $919[32]. Assuming that 0.186% of
the 1.3 billion Chinese population have profound hearing
loss that require hearing assistance 5, more than $ 4.4 billion will be needed to just fit the 2,418,000 people each
with two median price Oticon hearing aids. The real
cost to help these people is certainly higher since some
of these people will not be able to benefit from hearing
aids due to the severity of their hearing loss and will likely need more costly solutions such as cochlear implants.
Albeit China has enjoyed probably the fastest economic
growth in its history for the past couple of decades, personal wealth in China remains far behind compared to
major developed countries, mainly due to the size of its
population and wealth distribution patterns. The International Monetary Fund estimated that China's annual per
capita income in 2008 was equivalent to $3,180[33]. Providing appropriate care for increasing numbers of individuals with hearing loss can be a significant drag on
Chinas economic development. In addition to financial
burdens, the significance of loss of employment and productivity due to hearing impairment can be tremendous
to China as a country that needs to support 20% of the
world
s population, which is also rapidly aging.
Despite the above-mentioned efforts, systematic research is needed to comprehend the scope of the problem, develop effective intervention instruments, assess
impact of interventions, and monitor trends of NIHL for
the Chinese population. Constant surveillance of noise
exposure and NIHL among the population is needed as
social and industrial lives constantly change. In addition
to obtaining updated information on the prevalence and
incidence of NIHL, it is important to understand factors
that contribute to NIHL. To achieve this goal, appropriate research tools need to be developed and updated to
ensure acquisition of accurate and relevant information.
The tools must also be appropriate to the Chinese language and culture for them to be effective in the countr
As previous studies have suggested, noise exposure in
modern society is no longer limited to occupational activities. As a result, research on noise exposure and NIHL
must not simply focus on workers in manufacturing enterprises, but include the general population and their environment. Young people including children of various
ages especially need to be studied, as early identification
of problems provides an opportunity for early intervention and potentially improved outcomes, and is consistent with principles of preventive medicine. Successful
control of noise exposure will be the most cost-effective
intervention for NIHL. Research of noise exposure in
children is especially important as they are in a period
critical for developing long term behavior patterns. This
is probably the best opportunity to nurture behaviors that
may lead to lasting voluntary protection against NIHL.
As indicated in previous studies, in addition to social and
demographic factors, behavior patterns can also affect an
individuals attitude to noise exposure[41]. Information
regarding non-occupational noise exposure is especially
important also because such environments are more dynamic and difficult to regulate than in industrial settings.
How Research Models Such As Dangerous Decibel May Be Useful in China
Dangerous Decibel is a hearing health promotion
partnership initiated by a group of hearing scientists at
the Oregon hearing Research Center (OHRC), which focuses on noise exposure, NIHL and its prevention in
school age children and the general public. It is a joint
effort by the OHRC, the Oregon Health & Science University Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Oregon Museum of Science and Industry, Portland
State University and the University of Northern Colorado. The project takes a non-traditional approach that
combines efforts from research institutions, the public ed54
15853105.htm
[4] Liu XZ, Xu LR, Hu Y, Nance WE, Sismanis A, Zhang SL, Xu
Y. 2001. Epidemiological studies on hearing impairment with reference to genetic factors in Sichuan, China. Annals of Otology,
Rhinology & Laryngology. 110(4):356-63.
[5] Liu X, Xu L, Zhang S, Xu Y. 1993. Prevalence and aetiology
of profound deafness in the general population of Sichuan, China.
Journal of Laryngology & Otology. 107(11):990-3.
[6] Tang Y, Bu X, Yao Q, Xie Q, Qian M, Hu Y, Yu Y. 2001. [Audiological findings of the aging across the urban and rural of Suzhou]. [Chinese] Lin Chuang Erh Pi Yen Hou Ko Tsa Chih-Journal of Clinical Otorhinolaryngology. 15(7):315-7.
[7]http://www.hb.xinhuanet.com/health/2009-03/04/content_
15853105.htm
[8] http://www.39kf.com/focus/ktpd/2007-03-02-329395.shtml
[9] Luo WZ, Miyashita K, Takeda S, Wang YX, Li SC. 1996.
Hearing impairment among young Chinese in a rural area. Morioka I. Public Health. 110(5):293-7.
[10] Zhi S, Sheng W, Levine SP. 2000. National Occupational
Health Service policies and programs for workers in small-scale
industries in China. Aihaj. 61(6):842-9.
[11] Liu X, Guo Z, He J, Liang Y, Feng J. 2008. [Study on the
dose-response relationship for noise-induced hearing loss in workers using individual hearing protection]. [Chinese] Zhong Guo Zhi
Ye Yi Xue-China Occupational Medicine. 35(6):477.
[12] Wang J, Gao J, Wang R. 2007. [A survey on career years and
occupational noise-induced hearing loss]. [Chinese] Ting Li Yu Yuan Yu Ji Bing Za Zhi-Journal of Audiology and Speech Pathology.
(15): 458.
[13] Chen H, Lin L, Liu L, Liu Q, Lai L. 2006. [A survey on
noise-induced hearing loss]. [Chinese] Xian Dai Yu Fang Yi
Xue-Modern Preventive Medicine. 33(6):948.
[14] Xia Y, Wang Q, Li Y, Mu H, Wu X. 2006. [Investigation on
noise induced hearing loss for locomotive drivers in Wulumuqi
railway board]. [Chinese] Tie Dao Lao Dong An Quan Wei Sheng
Yu Huan Bao-Railway Labor Safety and Environment Protection.
33(6):293.
[15] Liu L, Kang W. 2007. [Hearing among locomotive drivers].
[Chinese] Lin Chuang Yi Yao Shi Jian-Clinical Medicine Practice.
15(10):180.
[16] Cai Y, Zhang W, Chen S. 2005. [Study on Noise Induced
Deafness in Five Metals Factory]. [Chinese] Hebei Medicine. 11
(10):875.
[17] Zhong Y, Xie W, Chen P. 2005. [A survey on noise exposure
in four industries in Gongguan]. [Chinese] Zhong Guo Zhi Ye Yi
Xue-China Occupational Medicine. 32(6):61.
[18] Du W, Zhang R, Hou M. 2005. [An investigation on noise
hazards in the the cement enterprises]. [Chinese] Zhi Ye Wei
Sheng Yu Ying Ji Jiu Yuan-Occupational Health And Emergency
Rescue. 23(3):150.
[19] Lu J, Shao L, Wang J, Yang Y, Huang Y, Zhu W, Zhao Y.
2003. [The dose-response relationship between noise exposure
and prevalence of noise-induced hearing loss in man aircraft maintenance workers]. [Chinese] Zhong Guo Gong Ye Yi Xue Za
Zhi-Chinese Journal Of Industrial Medicine. (5):277.
[20] Tu B, Gui L. 2000. [Study on Noise Induced Deafness in Linen Textile Factory]. [Chinese] Gong Ye Wei Sheng Yu Zhi Ye
Bing-Industrial Health And Occupational Diseases. 26(2):9.
[21] Liou SH. 1994. Occupational disease profile in Taiwan, Republic of China. Industrial Health. 32(3):107-18.
References
[1] Xie YM, Liu BY, Piao HY. 2006. [Exploration on the common
characters of sub-healthy people based on clinical epidemiology].
[Chinese] Zhongguo Zhong Xi Yi Jie He Za Zhi-Chinese Journal
of Integrated Traditional & Western Medicine. 26(7):612-6.
[2] Zhao Y, Zhang S, Selvin S, Spear RC. 1993. A dose-response relationship for occupational noise-induced hypertension. Schriftenreihe des Vereins fur Wasser-, Boden-, und Lufthygiene. 88:
189-207.
[3]http://www.hb.xinhuanet.com/health/2009-03/04/content_
55
[22] Ma G, Tian Y, Ju T, Ren Z. 2006. Assessment of traffic noise pollution from 1989 to 2003 in Lanzhou City. Environmental Monitoring & Assessment. 123(1-3):413-30.
[23] Li HJ, Yu WB, Lu JQ, Zeng L, Li N, Zhao YM. 2008, Investigation of road-traffic noise and annoyance in Beijing: a cross-sectional study of 4th Ring Road. Archives of Environmental & Occupational Health. 63(1):27-33.
[24] Bu G. 1992. [Prevention of noise induced hearing loss in musicians of Chinese opera]. [Chinese] Chung Hua Erh Pi Yen Hou
Ko Tsa Chih - Chinese Journal of Otorhinolaryngology. 27(2):
73-5, 124.
[25] Smoorenburg GF. 1993. Risk of noise-induced hearing loss
following exposure to Chinese firecrackers. Audiology. 32(6):
333-43.
[26] Chung JH, Des Roches CM, Meunier J, Eavey RD. 2005.
Evaluation of noise-induced hearing loss in young people using a
web-based survey technique. Pediatrics. 115(4):861-7.
[27] ebh.ewsos.com/2008/12/3548.html
[28] Li J. 2008. [A survey on hearing among the youth in Baise
City]. [Chinese] You Jiang Min Zu Yi Xue Yuan Xue Bao-Journal
of Youjiang Medical College for Nationalities. 30(5):823.
[29] Wong TW, Van Hasselt CA, Tang LS, Yiu PC. 1990. The use
of personal cassette players among youths and its effects on hearing. Public Health. 104(5):327-30.
[30] Axelsson A, Ringdahl A. 1989. Tinnitus--a study of its prevalence and characteristics. Br. J. of Audiol. 23(1), 53-62.
[31] Nondahl DM, Cruickshanks KJ, Wiley TL, Klein R, Klein
BE, Tweed TS. 2002. Prevalence and 5-year incidence of tinnitus
56