CIVIL PROCEDURE

Case Outline Rules 6-14

Rule 6
Section
Sec. 2, 3

Case Title
Zaida Alberto v. CA
Flour Daniel v. EB Villarosa
Bank of Commerce v. Planters Bank

GR #
119088
159648
154470

Date
Jun 30, 2000
Jul 27, 2007
Sep 17, 2012

Sec. 5

Tropical Homes v. CA
Lucia Miranda v. Esperanza Besa

111858
146513

May 14, 2007

Jul 30, 2004

Sec. 6

Mel Velarde v. Lopez

UST v. CA

153886
124250

Jan 14, 2004

Oct 18, 2004

Sec. 7

Spouses Meliton v. CA
Felipe Yulienco v. CA
Financial Building v. Forbes Park
Evangeline Alday v. FGU Insurance
Tan v. Kaakbay Finance
Lafarge v. CCC
Korea Exchange Bank v. Judge Gonzales

101883
131692
133119
138822
146595
155173
142286

Dec 11, 1992

Jun 10, 1999
Aug 17, 2000
Jan 23, 2001
Jun 20, 2003
Nov 23, 2004
Apr 15, 2005

Sec. 8

Florencio Ruiz v. CA
Ligon v. CA
Petron v. Spouses Cudilla

101566
127683
151038

Aug 17, 1992

Aug 7, 1998
Jan 18, 2012

Sec. 11

Samala v. Victor
Allied Bank v. CA
British Airways v. CA
Erasmo Tayao v. Rosa Mendoza
ACDC v. CA
CDCP v. Cuenca
Sarmiento v. CA
Philtranco v. Paras

L-53969
123871
121824
162733
160242
163981
152627
161909

Feb 21, 1989

Aug 31, 1998
Jan 29, 1998
Apr 12, 2005
May 17, 2005
Aug 12, 2005
Sep 16, 2005
Apr 25, 2012

Sec. 12

Lafarge v. CCC
Bank of Commerce v. Planters Bank

155173
154470

Nov 23, 2004

Sep 17, 2012

Rule 7
Section
Sec. 2

Case Title
PCIC v. PNCC

Sec. 3

Citation

GR #
185066

Date
Oct 2, 2009

Buklaran v. CA
Dadizon v. Bernadas
Jocson v. CA
SOPA v. Santos
Galicto v. B.S. Aquino

158158
172367
162836
152579
193978

Jan 17, 2005

Jun 5, 2009
Jul 30, 2009
Aug 4, 2009
Feb 28, 2012

Sec. 4
Verification

Robern v. Judge Jesus Quitain

Torres v. Specialized
Christine Chua v. Jorge Torres
Rolando Clavecilla v. Spouses Quitain
Fernando Go v. CA
Marohomsalic v. Cole
Tible & Tible v. Royal
Hipol v. NLRC
Negros Planters v. Presiding Judge
Vallacar Transit v. Catubig
Pagadora v. Ilao
Vicencio v. Villar

135042
149634
151900
147989
163745
169918
155806
181818
179878
175512
165769
182069

Sep 23, 1999

Jul 6, 2004
Aug 30, 2005
Feb 20, 2006
Aug 24, 2007
Feb 27, 2008
Apr 8, 2008
Dec 18, 2008
Dec 24, 2008
May 30, 2011
Dec 12, 2011
Jul 3, 2012

Sec. 5
None

Uy v. Land Bank
Ponciano v. Judge Parantela
Arquiza v. CA
Eastland v. Mortel
Mandaue v. Isidto

136100
133284
160479
165648
181051

Jul 4, 2000
May 9, 2000
Jun 8, 2005
Mar 23, 2006
Jul 5, 2010

Section
Sec. 5
Defective

Case Title
BA Savings Bank v. Roger Sia
BPI Leasing Corp. v. CA
Torres v. Specialized
Expert Travel v. CA and KAL
Spouses Estares v. CA
Levi Strauss v. Vogue Traders
Daniel Aninao v. Asturias Chemicals
Concepcion Ancheta v. Metrobank
PAL v. FASAP
Shangr-la v. DGC
Wilson and Peter Go v. Rico

Citation

GR #
131214
127624
149634
152392
144755
132993
160420
163410
143088
159938
140862

Date
Jul 27, 2000
Nov 18, 2003
Jul 6, 2004
May 26, 2005
Jun 8, 2005
Jun 29, 2005
Jul 28, 2005
Sep 16, 2005
Jan 26, 2006
Mar 31, 2006
Apr 25, 2006

Panfilo Abaigar v. Jesus Abaigar

RBA v. Salvaa
Teresa Gabriel v. CA
Chinese YMCA v. Remington Steel
Altres v. Empleo
Mediserve v. CA
RP v. Coalbrine

167003
175020
149909
159422
180986
161368
161838

Oct 23, 2006

Oct 4, 2007
Oct 11, 2007
Mar 28, 2008
Dec 10, 2008
Apr 5, 2010
Apr 7, 2010

Cebu Metro v. Euro-Med

Vda. De Formoso v. PNB
Atty. Bautista v. Judge Causapin

164757
154704
07-2044

Oct 18, 2010

Jun 1, 2011
Jun 22, 2011

Medado v. Heirs of Consing

186720

Feb 8, 2012

Galicto v. B.S. Aquino

Cosco v. Kemper

193978
179488

Feb 28, 2012

Apr 23, 2012

Sec. 5
False

Cladius Barroso v. Judge Ampig

Espinosa v. CA
RMC v. Siesenando Singson

138218
128686
150798

Mar 17, 2000

May 28, 2004
Mar 31, 2005

Sec. 5
Forum
Shopping

Tirona v. Judge Alejo

Land Car v. Bachelor Express
Evelyn Paradero v. Judge Abragan
Nordic Asia v. CA
Reyes de Leon v. Del Rosario
HSBC v. Cecilia Diez Catalan
Guaranteed Hotels v. Josefina Baltao
Korean Exchange Bank v. Gonzales
Levi Strauss v. Vogue Traders
Spouses de la Cruz v. Pedro Joaquin
Manuel Laxina v. Ombudsman
Amando San Juan v. Miguel Arambulo
Angel and Maritoni Sadang v. CA
Spouses Cruz v. Spouses Caraos
Wacnang v. Comelec
St. Mary of the Woods v. ROD
SOPA v. Santos
Phil Pharma Wealth v. Pfizer

129313
154377
158917
111159
152862
159590
164338
142286
132993
162788
153155
143217
140138
138208
178024
174290
152579
167715

Oct 10, 2001

Dec 8, 2003
Mar 1, 2004
Jul 13, 2004
Jul 26, 2004
Oct 18, 2004
Jan 17, 2005
Apr 15, 2005
Jun 29, 2005
Jul 28, 2005
Sep 30, 2005
Dec 14, 2005
Oct 11, 2006
Apr 23, 2007
Oct 17, 2008
Jan 20, 2009
Aug 4, 2009
Nov 17, 2010

Medado v. Heirs of Consing

186720

Feb 8, 2012

GR
149468
190710

Date
Oct 23, 2006
Jun 6, 2011

Rule 8
Topic
Sec. 1

Case Title
Marie Jao v. China Banking
Lucas v. Lucas

Citation

Sec. 4

Soriente v. Estate of Concepcion

160239

Nov 25, 2009

Sec. 5

Associated Bank v. Montano

Luistro v. CA

166383
158819

Oct 16, 2009

Apr 16, 2009

Sec. 7

Tiu v. PB Com
Eastern Shipping v. Prudential
Ledda v. BPI

151932
174116
200868

Aug 19, 2009

Sep 11, 2009
Nov 21, 2012

Sec. 8

Filtex & Villanueva v. CA

Permanent Savings v. Velarde
Titan Construction v. David
Equitable Card v. Capistrano
Cua v. Wallem

119800
140608
169548
180157
171337

Nov 12, 2003

Sep 23, 2004
Mar 15, 2010
Feb 8, 2012
Jul 11, 2012

Sec. 10

Teraa v. De Sagun
PBCOM v. Spouses Go
RP v. SB

152131
175514
166859

Apr 29, 2009

Feb 14, 2011
Apr 12, 2011

Sec. 11

Union Bank v. Spouses Tiu

173090

Sep 7, 2011

GR
143286
151149
153567
152496
157594

Date
Apr 14, 2004
Sep 7, 2004
Feb 18, 2008
Jul 30, 2009
Mar 5, 2010

Rule 9
Topic

Sec. 1

Case Title
Villanueva v. CA
Katon v. Palanca
Aquino v. Aure
Anunciacion v. Bocanegra
Toshiba v. CIR

Citation

Sec. 2

Financial v. Forbes Park

Reyes-De Leon v. Del Rosario
Loadmaster v. Glodel

133119
152862
179446

Aug 17, 2000

Jul 26, 2004
Jan 20, 2011

Sec. 3

Diaz v. Diaz

135885

Apr 28, 2000

Viron v. Pantranco
Oaminal v. Castillo
Cerezo v. Tuazon
Acance v. CA
Sablas v. Sablas
United Overseas Bank v. Rosemoor
Monzon v. Relova
Santos v. PNOC
David v. Judge Fruelda
BDO v. Tansipek
San Pedro v. Heirs of Enana
Juliano-Llave v. RP
City of Manila v. Te
Otero v. Roger Tan
Magtoto v. CA

117020
152776
141538
159699
144568
172651
171827
170943
170427
181235
190754
169766
169263
200134
175792

Apr 4, 2003
Oct 8, 2003
Mar 23, 2004
Mar 16, 2005
Jul 3, 2007
Oct 2, 2007
Sep 17, 2008
Sep 23, 2008
Jan 30, 2009
Jul 22, 2009
Nov 16, 2010
Mar 30, 2011
Sep 21, 2011
Aug 15, 2012
Nov 21, 2012

Rule 10
Topic

Sec. 2, 3

Case Title
Spouses Tirona v. Judge Alejo
Leonardo Andres v. Serafin Cuevas
Armand Nocum v. Lucio Tan
Bautista v. Maya-maya Cottages
PPA v. WG&A
Biglang-Awa v. PTC
Limbauan v. Acosta
Tiu v. PB Com
Lisam v. Banco de Oro

Citation

GR
129313
150869
145022
148361
158401
158998
148606
151932
143264

Date
Oct 10, 2001
Jun 29, 2005
Sep 23, 2005
Nov 29, 2005
Jan 28, 2008
Mar 28, 2008
Jun 30, 2008
Aug 19, 2009
Apr 23, 2012

Sec. 4

Zosimo Godinez v. CA

154330

Feb 15, 2007

Sec. 5

Spouses Mercader v. DBP

PEF v. PII
Lolita Ayson v. Marina Enriquez
Azolla Farms v. CA and Savings Bank
Royal Cargo v. DFS Sports
Wenceslao v. Freyssinet
Panganiban v. Spouses Roldan
Spouses Dela Cruz v. Concepcion

130699
120384
152438
138085
158621
166857
163053
172825

May 12, 2000

Jan 13, 2004
Jun 17, 2004
Nov 11, 2004
Dec 10, 2008
Sep 11, 2009
Nov 25, 2009
Oct 11, 2012

Sec. 6, 7
Sec. 8

APT v. CA
Soriano v. CA
Planters Development v. LZK Holdings
Lambino
Judge
Cagungunv.v.Presiding
PDB

81024
100633
153777
169551
158674

Feb 3, 2000
Aug 28, 2001
Apr 15, 2005
Jan
Oct 24,
17, 2007
2005

Ada v. Baylon

182435

Aug 13, 2012

Rule 11
Topic

Case Title

Citatio
n

GR

Date

Sec. 7

Chan v. Chan

150746

Oct 15, 2008

Sec. 10

Del Monte v. Dow Chemical

179232

Aug 23, 2012

Sec. 11

Crisologo-Jose v. Land Bank

Paramount Insurance v. Ordoez

167339
175109

Jun 22, 2006

Aug 6, 2008

Rule 13
Topic

Case Title

Citatio
n

GR

Date

133496
145213

May 9, 2005
Mar 28, 2006

Sec. 2

Rene Ramos v. Antonio Lim

Jimmy Go v. Judge Abrogar

Sec. 3

Heirs of Miranda v. Miranda

179638

Jul 8, 2013

Sec. 4

Atty. Julius Nery v. Judge de la Pea

05-1896

Apr 29, 2005

Sec. 6

Spouses Tagle v. CA

162738

Jul 8, 2009

Sec. 7

Spouses Belen v. Chavez

RP v. Resins

175334
175891

Mar 26, 2008

Jan 12, 2010

Sec. 8

Cheng v. Javier

182485

Jul 3, 2009

Sec. 10

Land Bank v. Heirs of Alsua

Tomawis v. Tabao-Caudang
PAL v. Heirs of Zamora

167361
166547
164267

Apr 2, 2007
Sep 12, 2007
Mar 31, 2009

Sec. 11

Maceda v. De Guzman
Teresa Gabriel v. CA
Tible & Tible v. Royal Savings
Reyes v. NLRC
Quileste v. People
City of Dumagete
Pagadora v. Ilao
Aberca v. Ver
Mojar v. Agro Commercial
Indoyon v. CA

164947
149909
155806
180551
180334
168973
165769
166216
187188
193706

Jan 31, 2006

Oct 11, 2007
Apr 8, 2008
Feb 10, 2009
Feb 18, 2009
Aug 24, 2011
Dec 12, 2011
Mar 14, 2012
Jun 27, 2012
Mar 12, 2013

Sec. 13

Government v. Aballe

147212

Mar 24, 2006

Sec. 14

Heirs Lopez v. Judge Enriquez

David Lu v. Paterno Lu Ym
Delfin Tan v. Benolirao
St. Mary v. ROD

146262
153690
158380
174290

Jan 21, 2005

Aug 4, 2009
Oct 16, 2009
Jan 20, 2009

GR
139895
152776
147369
158407
130974
172555
159421
177077
167230
183802
161952
170122
171916

Date
Aug 15, 2003
Oct 8, 2003
Oct 23, 2003
Jan 17, 2005
Aug 16, 2006
Jul 10, 2007
Aug 20, 2008
Jul 14, 2009
Aug 14, 2009
Sep 17, 2009
Oct 2, 2009
Oct 12, 2009
Dec 4, 2009

140081
142272
149625
175109
169919
167545

Jun 23, 2005

May 2, 2006
Sep 28, 2007
Aug 6, 2008
Sep 11, 2009
Aug 17, 2011

Rule 14
Topic
Sec. 6, 7

Sec. 11
Domestic
Corporations

Case Title
Lazaro v. Rural Bank of Balagtas
Oaminal v. Castillo
Spouses Jose v. Spouses Boyon
Domagas v. Jensen
Manotoc v. CA
Alegar Corporation v. Alvarez
Potenciano v. Barnes
Sansio v. Mogol
Spouses Galura v. Math-Agro
Wong v. Koyama
Sagana v. Francisco
Garcia v. SB
Pascual v. Pascual

Tysons Super v. CA
Aboitiz v. CA
Weena Express v. Rapacon
Paramount Insurance v. Ordonez
BD Long Span v. Ampeloquio
Atiko Trans v. Prudential

Citation

Sec. 12
Foreign
Corporations

HSBC v. Cecilia Diez Catalan

Pioneer v. Guadiz
Atiko Trans v. Prudential
NM Rothschild v. Lepanto

159590
156848
167545
175799

Oct 18, 2004

Oct 11, 2007
Aug 17, 2011
Nov 28, 2011

Sec. 13 - Public

RP v. Domingo

175299

Sep 14, 2011

Sec. 14

Santos v. PNOC
NM Rothschild v. Lepanto

170943
175799

Sep 23, 2008

Nov 28, 2011

Sec. 15

Romualdez v. Licaros
Rosalino Acance v. CA
Velayo-Fong v. Spouses Velayo
Perkin Elmer v. Dakila Trading
Regner v. Logarta

150656
159699
155488
172242
168747

Apr 29, 2003

Mar 16, 2005
Dec 6, 2006
Aug 14, 2007
Oct 19, 2007

Sec. 16

Montefalcon v. Vasquez
Santos v. PNOC
Palma v. Judge Galvez

165016
170943
165273

Jun 17, 2008

Sep 23, 2008
Mar 10, 2010

Sec. 19

Gonzales v. CA
Rosalino Acance v. CA
Santos v. PNOC

150908
159699
170943

Jan 21, 2005

Mar 16, 2005
Sep 23, 2008

Sec. 20

Gonzales v. Balikatan
Santos v. PNOC
Anunciacion v. Bocanegra
Wong v. Koyama
Garcia v. SB
Rapid City v. Villa
Palma v. Judge Galvez
Atiko Trans v. Prudential
NM Rothschild v. Lepanto

150859
170943
152496
183802
170122
184197
165273
167545
175799

Mar 28, 2005

Sep 23, 2008
Jul 30, 2009
Sep 17, 2009
Oct 12, 2009
Feb 11, 2010
Mar 10, 2010
Aug 17, 2011
Nov 28, 2011