Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Between March 1991 and February 2002 Sierra Leone was engulfed in a bloody and
protracted civil war in which tens of thousands of people were killed, many more injured,
over half of the population displaced and millions of pounds worth of property destroyed.
Much of the violence unleashed, particularly on the civilian population, was the work of
child soldiers. The phenomenon of child soldiers raises many issues of childrens wellbeing, although this phenomenon is not unique to Africa.
In this paper, I briefly analyse the reasons for and the nature of the conflict, in
particular the social forces which impelled children to join social movements challenging
for state hegemony. I focus on how peripheral capitalism has impacted on the Sierra
Leonean family and how the ensuing political and economic crises have left Sierra
Leonean children with little security, forcing them to turn to family surrogates (social
movements) for protection. I examine the processes of demobilisation, rehabilitation and
reintegration of former child combatants and some of the problems and challenges to
social work and social workers working with traumatised children from war ravaged
communities in African nations. I suggest that Tonnies dichotomy between
Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft offers a useful framework for social work education
in this context.
Keywords: Child Soldiers; Gemeinschaft/Gesellschaft; Social Movements; Trauma
Introduction
In an article published in this journal, Jacob Kornbeck (2001) draws attention to the
usefulness of Ferdinand Tonnies analytical dichotomy, Gemeinschaft/Gesellschaft
Correspondence to: Tunde B. Zack-Williams, Professor of Sociology, Department of Education and Social Science,
University of Central Lancashire, Preston PR1 2HE, UK. Email: tzackwilliams@uclan.ac.uk
ISSN 0261-5479 print/1470-1227 online # 2006 The Board of Social Work Education
DOI: 10.1080/02615470500487085
120 T. B. Zack-Williams
121
diminishing, social work ignores Gemeinschaft skills at its peril. Furthermore, the
application of Gemeinschaft to social work education can no longer be an option: it
must be an integral part of the social work curriculum.
The theme of cultural relativity and diversity is also raised by Laird (2004),
pointing to the failure of conventional social work tasks and practice to address the
critical socio-economic needs of communities living in sub-Saharan Africa. She
writes: academia in sub-Saharan Africa continues to find itself on the receiving
end of American and European paradigms (which) the development of
indigenous approaches (p. 706). In her view, conflict management strategies are
bound to fail if they are simply replicas of the Euro-America genre. Williams et al.
(2001) commenting on a similar situation in social work education in the Caribbean,
describe it as the most critical and urgent challenge that confronts us (Caribbean
scholars and practitioners) as we move into the 21st century (p. 68). They condemn
the practice of appropriating theoretical shelf social work theories from abroad and
apply(ing) them uncritically to the context of the Caribbean (p. 68). I shall return to
these questions, including that of culturally relevant therapy for ex-child combatants
in Sierra Leone. However, before addressing these concerns I need to discuss
some ethical issues in the process of studying vulnerable children, who have been
over-researched.
Ethics and Methods of Researching Child Soldiers
This study is the result of three short fieldwork visits to Sierra Leone in August
September 2001, December 2001 and December 2002. Prior to these visits I had
conducted fieldwork in Sierra Leone as well as authored manuscripts and articles on
the political economy of underdevelopment in that country. However, by the time I
arrived in the field after the civil war in August 2001, I found that many of the former
child soldiers had started showing signs of research interrogation fatiguetired of
being interrogated about their experiences in the bush by researchers and journalists.
A number of them claimed that the researchers interest was to further their careers.
One former child combatant observed: We feel like animals in the zoo, people come
to talk to us, but our plight remains the same. These concerns raised an added moral
dilemma relating not just to the issue of value interference, but to the responsibility
of the researcher to the respondents, particularly minors and young people who had
experienced both physical and emotional abuse at the hands of the state (and its
agents) as well as adjuncts of civil society. There was no vetting of people who wished
to interview the youngsters; under what conditions; with or without parental or
guardian consent, issues which are all fundamental to the rights of the child in the
developed capitalist societies. Child protection legislations have remained weak in
Sierra Leone, based on the ideological premise of the following maxims:
N
N
122 T. B. Zack-Williams
Nah Government Pikin, i.e. a child belongs to the Government, and in the case of a
failing or failed state (as was the case of the Sierra Leone state), no one champions the
right of the child.
N
N
I had established prior contacts with significant numbers of people in the NGO
community who were prepared to accommodate and help me out. The fact that I was
accorded this honour meant that the young people were less apprehensive and felt
more at ease.
The informal nature of the interviewing process and the desire not to disrupt the
routine of the various organisations I visited won the admiration of many field
workers.
My knowledge of the socio-political terrain of the country as well as knowledge of the
local lingua franca, won over many otherwise suspecting people.
123
former combatants, as well as with library research. I was able to gain information
without subjecting any ex-combatant to any form of interviewing or questioning.
Whilst in Sierra Leone, I visited a number of child protection agencies, local and
international NGOs and government departments including: Child Advocacy and
Rehabilitation (CAR) of the Sierra Leone Red Cross; Children Affected by the War;
National Committee for Distribution, Demobilisation and Reintegration (NCDDR);
Handicap International; UNICEF; CARITAS Freetown; Children Associated with
War (CAW); Conciliation Resources; UNAMSIL; The International Red Cross; the
Ministry of Gender and Social Welfare; Adventist Development and Relief Agency
(ADRA); Family Home Movement; Christian Brothers; Christian Childrens Fund;
Forum for African Women Educationists (FAWE); and the Commission for the
Consolidation of Peace. I spoke to many officials and read many policy documents.
In the Child Advocacy and Rehabilitation Project in Waterloo village on the outskirts
of the capital, I met many of the ex-combatants who were going through a
community sensitisation process. The security alert following the invasions of the
capital after 1997 and 1999, as well as the attempt by the RUF leadership to take over
the government of the country in a putsch in May 2000, led to extra security concerns,
further constraining the work of researchers. In many of these agencies, there were no
clear policies regarding their relationship with researchers and in many cases it was
simply a question of the idiosyncrasy of the person in charge.
Family Transformation, Childrens Vulnerability and the RUF
Studies of former child soldiers highlight the effects of a rupture in the
intergenerational bargain (Zack-Williams, 2001), the ambiguity of the current
generation, the state and global capitalism. This can lead to anomie in the
socialisation process and to alienation of a significant section of the population,
leading to bellicose contestation of the state.
The incorporation of invisible soldiers (Brett & McCallan, 1998) into social
movements contesting state hegemony in African states is partly a consequence of the
technological and ergonomic developments in gun manufacturing which have
drastically reduced the size and weight of assault rifles, as well as the sense of
alienation felt by children. It has been estimated that in Sierra Leone some 10,000
child combatants fought on either side of the civil war (Sesay, 2003). Furthermore,
Peters & Richards (1998) estimate that large numbers of children were killed,
injured and mutilated, with half of the RUF combatants being between 8 and 14 years
old.
In earlier works I drew attention to the events leading to the civil war in Sierra
Leone, as well as the causal factors including: economic mismanagement; the impact
of Structural Adjustment Programmes; the absence of political and economic
transparency; corruption; the social exclusion of young people and the crisis of the
Sierra Leonean youth (Zack-Williams, 1999; Zack-Williams et al., 2002). Next, I
focus on how family transformation has left the Sierra Leonean child very vulnerable
and exposed to propaganda of social movements.
124 T. B. Zack-Williams
The transition to peripheral capitalism over the past four decades and the effects of
structural adjustment programmes in the last two decades have impacted on the
traditional Sierra Leonean family, leading to its atomisation. To understand why
African children, brought up in an essentially Gemeinschaft environment, with strong
reciprocal bonds of sentiment and kinship, are now being pulled towards social
movements challenging the existing order, one has to question this assertion of a
static extended family and its elasticity to cope (Zack-Williams, 2001).
The emergence of peripheral capitalism not only leads to the proletarianisation of
sections of the working population by destroying pre-existing modes, but by
conserving some of the latter to serve the needs of accumulation, peripheral
capitalism denies the proletarianised masses the welfare provisions which are taken
for granted in capitalism of the centre (Zack-Williams, 1995). The super-exploitative
nature of imperialism, imposed upon local kleptocratic political and economic
structures, has led to capital flight, uneven development and the inability of local
social institutions such as the family to cope with the exigencies of life within
peripheral capitalist formations. The result is additional burdens on the family, in
contrast to capitalism of the centre where the traditional functions of the family have
been eroded by state-sponsored institutions. One way families have tried to cope with
such crises in the past is through the wardship (mehn pikin) system. This system,
designed to promote the childs future prospects, involves fostering him/her to more
affluent families, friends or relations; it is potentially exploitative (Bledsoe, 1990).
These children often are deprived of education, whilst having to do chores for
children of their foster parents, in order to free the latter to study. Bledsoe points out
that whilst modern education is highly valued, it creates ambivalence, as modern
knowledge and the way it is taught disrupt the ideal relationship of debt and
recompense linking master and student (Bledsoe, 1990, p. 81). In short, fostering and
the wardship system tend to produce a mass of alienated young people in the country.
Many of them quit these exploitative networks, heading straight for the large towns. In
the era of intensive structural adjustment programmes, which have witnessed the
introduction of cost recovery policies in welfare provision, many children have been
squeezed out of the educational system, swelling the ranks of street children.
Children and young people in Sierra Leone are exposed to high levels of
vulnerability as economic stagnation prevents the transition from Gemeinschaft
livelihood to Gesellschaft existence. The law neither provides the security or
protection taken for granted by Gesellschaft political and administrative structures
(UNICEF, 1989). From a very early age, children in Sierra Leone cease to be a
liability, dependent on the family, instead they soon become an asset as a source of
income to the family.
Class and gender statuses play overarching roles in child labour and child
soldiering: in any relatively poor Sierra Leonean family especially those below the
poverty line children are introduced to the concept of work as early as the age of
three years (UNICEF, 1989, p. 40). Not only can rich parents send their offspring
away from the areas of conflict, but also, recruiters prefer to concentrate on those
who can resist least effectively (Ibid.).
125
A major recruiting ground for child soldiers has been the group usually referred to
as street children. Whilst this phenomenon is often associated with the favellas of
Latin America and the shantytowns of Southeast Asia, this is a reflection of the
transmogrification of the Sierra Leonean family form. This group consists of a diverse
collection of young deracinated boys who live on their wits, stealing, undertaking
casual jobs as labourers, hangers-on, as bras (haulers of fishing boats to their
moorings), pushers of barrows (Omolankes). To the young street children (the
Greens) these bras (big brothers) represent parent substitutes: they protect them
from other street children as well as other bras. They may also provide them with
night shelter; in return their proteges would work for them, steal and hand over
the loot to their bras, as well as soliciting prostitutes (koros) for them. Life on the
street can be extremely hazardous for these children, especially the Greens. For many
deracinated children, military life provided a surrogate family relationship, protection from abuse as well as empowerment. Both government and rebel forces
abducted many children, who were socialised into violence shortly after their
capture to prevent them returning to their villages. Furthermore, youthful
combatants with ruptured support systems make loyal fighters with no social
responsibilities and their size renders them invaluable for espionage work (Peters &
Richards, 1998).
Demobilisation and Rehabilitation
The complex political emergencies triggered off by the conflict and the large number
of children involved led to concerns among child protection agencies about the
trauma experienced by children and the immense work needed to address their
needs. These concerns culminated in the project Children Associated with War
(CAW), which led the military government in 1993 to demobilise some 370 child
combatants (Wisman, 1994). Many of these children showed symptoms of war
trauma, malnutrition and numerous skin infections as well as sexually transmitted
diseases. The project, led by UNICEF and funded by the British and Canadian
Governments and the Catholic Mission, involved advocacy work, education and
community sensitisation (Wisman, 1994). The rehabilitation programme consisted of
psychosocial counselling (de-traumatisation), health screening, provision of food and
other basic necessities, education and skills training (Dridi, 2004). The major agency
for demobilisation was UNAMSIL.
Under the scheme, cohorts of ex-child combatants were brought to the centre and
the aims of the 12-week programme included monitoring their health status and
coping ability for life away from the centre. Other activities included counselling,
literacy classes, sports, singing and recreation. In preparing children for reintegration
into society, attempts were made to reconcile them with parents. Those who
completed the sensitisation process were then attached to tradespeople to be trained
as tailors, masons, carpenters, mechanics and at the end of the training small grants,
loans and tool kits were made available to trainees to facilitate their social and
economic reintegration into the local community (Dridi, 2004).
126 T. B. Zack-Williams
127
with the aid of some straws, signifying the transition from the old sinful life in
exchange for the new one. A chicken or goat would be slaughtered as sacrifice to
appease the ancestors, supervised by traditional rulers.
Conclusion
This paper focuses on the vulnerability of children and young people in war-torn
Sierra Leone, pointing to the collapse of social coping mechanisms such as the
wardship system, which resulted in the rise of the phenomenon of street children,
from which many child combatants were recruited. I have also taken up the challenge
posed by Kornbecks article on the efficacy of Tonnies dichotomy: Gemeinschaft and
Gesellschaft skills in social work practice and education. Indeed, the inability to
deliver the Western approach of skilled psychiatrists and psychotherapists has
impelled child protection agencies to turn to Gemeinschaft skills to meet this
shortage. However, for the transition to civilian life to be smooth and successful, we
will have to move beyond the culturally relevant therapeutic approach, which may
tend to strengthen gerontocracy at the expense of the young fighters. It is imperative
that the views of ex-child combatants should be incorporated within discussion of
national planning and for this group to be provided with opportunities and skills to
enable them to contribute to national development. As Dridi argues:
To ignore the special needs of the young fighters emerging from war is a sure
technique to backslide rapidly into renewed warfare. Untreated and neglected,
many war-traumatised youthful ex-combatants will readily take up arms when the
conditions around them are ripe or their perceived needs are inadequately or too
slowly met. (Dridi, 2004, p. 127)
While the analyses of issues for child soldiers in Sierra Leone may read like a
project in exotica, it is important to note that many of the issues raised in this paper
are also relevant to social work practice in the West; children of refugees and asylum
seekers from war-torn societies are now part of the caseload of many social workers
in Western countries. This has major implications not just for social work practice,
but more importantly, social work education. Social work curricula will now have to
take diversity seriously to incorporate the study of Gemeinschaft skills, and the policy
of leaving the study of Gemeinschaft to practice-oriented in-service training
(Kornbeck, 2001, p. 251) will have to be abandoned. Social work curricula will have
to be globalised to incorporate other cultures in order to incorporate diversity.
Social work education ignores these global trends at its peril.
Acknowledgements
The field trip for this study was made possible by a grant obtained from the British
Academy. I want to thank the Academy for its generosity. My sincere thanks also go
to my colleague, Pat Cox, Department of Social Work, University of Central
Lancashire, for reading and making valuable comments on earlier drafts of this paper.
128 T. B. Zack-Williams
References
Asante, M. K. (1988) Afrocentricity, Africa World Press, Trenton, NJ.
Bledsoe, C. (1990) No success without struggle: social mobility and hardship for foster children
in Sierra Leone, Man, New Series, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 788.
Brett, R. & McCallan, M. (1998) Children: The Invisible Soldiers, Radda Barren, Save The Children,
Sweden.
Dridi, B. A. L. (2004) Child-soldier rehabilitation and reintegration programmes: effective
antidotes to war, in The Quest for Peace in Africa, ed. A. G. Nhema, International Books,
Addis Ababa.
Gbla, O. (2003) Conflict and post-war trauma among child soldiers in Liberia and Sierra Leone, in
Civil Wars, Child Soldiers and Post Conflict Peace Building in West Africa, ed. A. Sesay,
AFSTRAG, Lagos, pp. 167196.
Keto, T. C. (1989) The African Centred Perspective of History, K.A. Publications, Blackwood, NJ.
Kornbeck, J. (2001) Gemeinschaft skills versus Gesellschaft skills in social work education and
practice. Applying Tonnies dichotomy for a model of intercultural communication, Social
Work Education, vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 246261.
Laird, S. E. (2004) Inter-ethnic conflict: a role for social work in sub-Saharan Africa, Social Work
Education, vol. 23, no. 6, December, pp. 693709.
Marsh, I. (ed.) (2002) Theory and Practice in Sociology, Prentice Hall, p. 34.
Peters, K. & Richards, P. (1998) Why we fight: voices of youth combatants in Sierra Leone, Africa,
vol. 68, no. 2, pp. 183210.
Richards, P. (1996) Fighting for the Rain Forest: War Youth & Resources in Sierra Leone, James
Currey, Oxford.
Sesay, A. (ed.) (2003) Civil Wars, Child Soldiers and Post Conflict Peace Building in West Africa,
AFSTRAG, Lagos.
UNICEF (1989) The Women and Children of Sierra Leone: An Analysis of Their Situation, Vol. 1.
1989, Ministry of National Development and Economic Planning, Freetown, Sierra Leone.
Williams, L., Maxwell, J., Ring, K. & Cambridge, I. (2001) Social work education in the West
Indies, Social Work Education, vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 5773.
Wisman, S. (1994) Programme Review of the Children Associated with the War (CAW) Project,
Freetown, November.
Zack-Williams, A. B. (1995) Tributors, Supporters and Merchant Capital: Mining and
Underdevelopment in Sierra Leone, Avebury, Aldershot.
Zack-Williams, A. B. (1999) Sierra Leone: the political economy of Civil War, 19911998, Third
World Quarterly, vol. 20, no. 1, February, pp. 143162.
Zack-Williams, A. B. (2001) Child soldiers in the civil war in Sierra Leone, Review of African
Political Economy, vol. 28, no. 87, March, pp. 7382.
Zack-Williams, T., Frost, D. & Thomson, A. (2002) Africa in Crisis: New Challenges & Possibilities,
Pluto Press, London.