Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
This article is about the historical event. For other uses, crew and four prisoners from Bounty. The 10 surviving
see Mutiny on the Bounty (disambiguation).
detainees reached England in June 1792 and were court
martialled; four were acquitted, three were pardoned and
three were hanged.
Christians group remained undiscovered on Pitcairn until 1808, by which time only one mutineer, John Adams,
remained alive. Almost all his fellow-mutineers, including Christian, had been killed, either by each other or by
their Polynesian companions. No action was taken against
Adams; descendants of the mutineers and their Tahitian
consorts live on Pitcairn into the 21st century. The generally accepted view of Bligh as an overbearing monster
and Christian as a tragic victim of circumstances, as depicted in well-known lm accounts, has been challenged
by late 20th- and 21st-century historians from whom a
more sympathetic picture of Bligh has emerged, supported by admiration for his superb seamanship in naviFletcher Christian and the mutineers turn Lieutenant William gating the launch to safety.
Bligh and 18 others adrift; 1790 painting by Robert Dodd
Background
Bounty and her mission
BACKGROUND
1.2
Bligh
1.3 Crew
Main article: Complement of HMS Bounty
Bounty's complement was 46 men, comprising 44
Royal Navy seamen (including Bligh), and two civilian botanists. Directly beneath Bligh were his warrant
ocers, appointed by the Navy Board and headed by
the sailing master John Fryer.[20] The other warrant ofcers were the boatswain, the surgeon, the carpenter,
and the gunner.[21] To the two masters mates and two
midshipmen were added several honorary midshipmen
so-called "young gentlemen" who were aspirant naval ofcers. These signed the ships roster as able seamen, but
were quartered with the midshipmen and treated on equal
terms with them.[22]
Most of Bounty's crew were chosen by Bligh, or were recommended to him by inuential patrons. William Peckover, the gunner, and Joseph Coleman, the armourer, had
been with Cook and Bligh on HMS Resolution;[23] several others had sailed under Bligh more recently, on the
Britannia. Among these was the 23-year-old Fletcher
Christian, who came from a wealthy Cumberland family descended from Manx gentry. Christian had chosen
a life at sea rather than the legal career envisaged by
his family.[24] He had twice voyaged with Bligh to the
West Indies, and the two had formed a master-pupil relationship through which Christian had become a skilled
navigator.[25] Christian was willing to serve on Bounty
without pay, as one of the young gentlemen";[26] Bligh
gave him one of the salaried masters mates berths.[25]
Another of the young gentlemen recommended to Bligh
was 15-year-old Peter Heywood, also from a Manx fam-
2.2
Cape to Pacic
3
troduced Cooks strict discipline regarding sanitation and
diet. According to the expeditions historian Sam McKinney, Bligh enforced these rules with a fanatical zeal,
continually fuss[ing] and fum[ing] over the cleanliness of
his ship and the food served to the crew.[42] He replaced
the navys traditional watch system of alternating fourhour spells on and o duty with a three watch system,
whereby each four-hour duty was followed by eight hours
rest.[43] For the crews exercise and entertainment he introduced regular music and dancing sessions.[44] Blighs
despatches to Campbell and Banks indicated his satisfaction; he had had no occasion to administer punishment
because, he wrote: Both men and ocers tractable and
well disposed, & cheerfulness & content in the countenance of every one.[45] The only adverse feature of the
voyage to date, according to Bligh, was the conduct of
the surgeon, Huggan, who was revealed as an indolent,
unhygienic drunkard.[44]
2
2.1
Expedition
To Cape Horn
EXPEDITION
The Bounty party spent their time at Adventure Bay in recuperation, shing, replenishment of water casks and the
felling of timber. There were peaceful encounters with
the native population.[59] The rst sign of overt discord
between Bligh and his ocers occurred when the captain
exchanged angry words with William Purcell, the carpenter, over the latters methods for cutting wood.[60][n 6]
Bligh ordered Purcell back to the ship, and when the carpenter stood his ground, Bligh withheld his rations, which
immediately brought him to his senses, according to
Bligh.[60]
On the nal leg of the journey to Tahiti, further clashes
occurred. On 9 October Fryer refused to sign the ships
account books unless Bligh provided him with a certicate attesting to his complete competence throughout the
voyage. Bligh would not be coerced; he summoned the
crew and read the Articles of War, at which Fryer backed
down.[62] There was also trouble with the surgeon Huggan, whose careless blood-letting of able seaman James
Valentine while treating him for asthma led to the seamans death from a blood infection.[63] To cover his error the surgeon reported to Bligh that Valentine had died
from scurvy,[64] which led Bligh to apply his own medicinal and dietary antiscorbutic remedies to the entire ships
company.[65] By now Huggan was almost incapacitated
with drink, until Bligh conscated his supply. Huggan
briey returned to duty; before Bounty's arrival in Tahiti,
he examined all on board for signs of venereal disease,
and found none.[66] Bounty came to anchor in Matavai
Blighs rst action on arrival was to secure the cooperation of the local chieftains. The paramount chief,
Tynah, remembered Bligh from Cooks voyage 15 years
previously, and greeted him warmly. Bligh presented the
chiefs with gifts, and informed them that their own "King
George" wished in return only breadfruit plants. They
happily agreed with this simple request.[68] Bligh assigned
Christian to lead a shore party charged with establishing
a compound in which the plants would be nurtured.[69]
Whether based ashore or on board, the mens duties during Bountys ve-month stay in Tahiti were relatively light.
Many led promiscuous lives among the native women
altogether 18 ocers and men, including Christian, received treatment for venereal infections[70] while others took regular partners.[71] Christian formed a close
relationship with a Polynesian, Mauatua, to whom he
gave the name Isabella after a former sweetheart from
Cumberland.[72] Bligh remained chaste himself,[73] but
was tolerant of his mens activities, unsurprised that
they should succumb to temptation when the allurements of dissipation are beyond any thing that can be
conceived.[74] Nevertheless, he expected them to do
5
their duty eciently, and was disappointed to nd increasing instances of neglect and slackness on the part of
his ocers. Infuriated, he wrote: Such neglectful and
worthless petty ocers I believe were never in a ship such
as are in this.[70]
Huggan died on 10 December. Bligh attributed this
to the eects of intemperance and indolence ... he
never would be prevailed on to take half a dozen turns
upon deck at a time, through the whole course of the
voyage.[75] For all his earlier favoured status, Christian did not escape Blighs wrath. He was often humiliated by the captainsometimes in front of the crew
and the Tahitiansfor real or imagined slackness,[70]
while severe punishments were handed out to men whose
carelessness had led to the loss or theft of equipment.
Floggings, rarely administered during the outward voyage, now became increasingly common.[76] On 5 January
1789 three members of the crewCharles Churchill,
John Millward and William Musprattdeserted, taking
a small boat, arms and ammunition. Muspratt had recently been ogged for neglect. Among the belongings
Churchill left on the ship was a list of names that Bligh
interpreted as possible accomplices in a desertion plot
the captain later asserted that the names included those
of Christian and Heywood. Bligh was persuaded that his
protg was not planning to desert, and the matter was
dropped. Churchill, Millward and Muspratt were found
after three weeks and, on their return to the ship, were
ogged.[76]
MUTINY
water.[99] During the following hours the loyalists collected their possessions and entered the boat. Among
these was Fryer, who with Blighs approval sought to stay
on boardin the hope, he later claimed, that he would be
able to retake the ship[94] but Christian ordered him into
the launch. Soon, the vessel was badly overloaded, with
more than 20 persons and others still vying for places.
Christian ordered the two carpenters mates, Norman and
McIntosh, and the armourer, Joseph Coleman, to return
to the ship, considering their presence essential if he were
to navigate Bounty with a reduced crew. Reluctantly they
obeyed, beseeching Bligh to remember that they had remained with the ship against their will. Bligh assured
them: Never fear, lads, I'll do you justice if ever I reach
England.[100]
3.2
cell, Bligh grabbed a cutlass and challenged the carpenter to ght. Fryer told Cole to arrest their captain, but
backed down after Bligh threatened to kill him if he
interfered.[120]
On 2 June the launch cleared Cape York, the extreme
northern point of the Australian continent. Bligh turned
south-west, and steered through a maze of shoals, reefs,
sandbanks and small islands. The route taken was not
the Endeavour Strait, but a narrower southerly passage
later known as the Prince of Wales Channel. At 20:00
that evening they reached the open Arafura Sea,[121]
still 1,100 nautical miles (2,000 km; 1,300 mi) from
Coupang.[122] The following eight days encompassed
some of the toughest travel of the entire journey, and by
11 June many were close to collapse. The next day the
coast of Timor was sighted: It is not possible for me
to describe the pleasure which the blessing of the sight
of this land diused among us, Bligh wrote.[123] On 14
June, with a makeshift Union Jack hoisted, they sailed
into Coupang harbour.[114]
3.3
MUTINY
Adams
otilla of war canoes headed for the ship, Christian used
[144]
and
20
Polynesians,
of
whom
14
were
women.
a four-pounder gun to repel the attackers. At least a
dozen warriors were killed, and the rest scattered. Undeterred, Christian and an armed party surveyed the island,
and decided it would be suitable for their purposes.[134]
However, to create a permanent settlement they needed
compliant native labour, and women. The most likely
source for these was Tahiti, to which Bounty returned on
4.2
4
4.1
Retribution
HMS Pandora mission
oners were mostly kept bound hand and foot until they
reached Coupang on 17 September.[160][161]
The prisoners were conned for seven weeks, at rst in
prison and later on a Dutch East India Company ship,
before being transported to Cape Town.[162] On 5 April
1792 they embarked for England on a British warship,
HMS Gorgon, and arrived at Portsmouth on 19 June.
There they were transferred to the guardship HMS Hector
to await trial. The prisoners included the three detained
loyalistsColeman, McIntosh and Normanto whom
Bligh had promised justice, the blind ddler Michael
Byrne (or Byrn), Heywood, Morrison, and four active mutineers: Thomas Burkett, John Millward, Thomas
Ellison and William Muspratt.[163] Bligh, who had been
given command of HMS Providence for a second breadfruit expedition, had left England in August 1791,[164]
and thus would be absent from the pending court martial
proceedings.[165]
10
5 PITCAIRN
Mutineers, and to criminate Captain Bligh.[179] Blighs
position was further undermined when the loyalist gunner Peckover conrmed that much of what was alleged in
the Appendix was true.[180]
Bligh commanded HMS Director at the Battle of Camperdown in October 1797 and HMS Glatton in the Battle of
Copenhagen in April 1801.[14] In 1805, while commanding HMS Warrior, he was court-martialled for using bad
language to his ocers, and reprimanded.[181] In 1806
he was appointed Governor of New South Wales, in Australia; after two years a group of army ocers arrested
and deposed him in the so-called Rum Rebellion. After
his return to England Bligh was promoted to rear-admiral
in 1811 and vice-admiral in 1814, but was not oered
further naval appointments. He died, aged 63, in December 1817.[14]
Of the pardoned mutineers, Heywood and Morrison returned to naval duty. Heywood acquired the patronage
of Hood and by 1803, at the age of 31, had achieved
the rank of captain. After a distinguished career he
died in 1831.[177] Morrison became a master gunner,
and was eventually lost in 1807, when HMS Blenheim
Admiral Lord Hood, who presided over the Bounty court martial foundered in the Indian Ocean. Muspratt is believed
to have worked as a naval steward before his death, in
or before 1798. The other principal participants in the
Muspratt, through his lawyer, won a stay of execution court martialFryer, Peckover, Coleman, McIntosh and
by ling a petition protesting that court martial rules had othersgenerally vanished from the public eye after the
prevented his calling Norman and Byrne as witnesses closing of the procedures.[182]
in his defence.[172] He was still awaiting the outcome
when Burkett, Ellison and Millward were hanged from
the yardarm of HMS Brunswick in Portsmouth dock on
28 October. Some accounts claim that the condemned 5 Pitcairn
trio continued to protest their innocence until the last
moment,[173] while others speak of their manly rmness
5.1 Settlement
that ... was the admiration of all.[174] There was some
unease expressed in the pressa suspicion that money
After leaving Tahiti on 22 September 1789, Christian
had bought the lives of some, and others fell sacrice to
sailed Bounty west in search of a safe haven. He then
their poverty.[175] A report that Heywood was heir to
formed the idea of settling on Pitcairn Island, far to the
a large fortune was unfounded; nevertheless, Dening aseast of Tahiti; the island had been reported in 1767, but its
serts that in the end it was class or relations or patronexact location never veried. After months of searching,
age that made the dierence.[175] In December Muspratt
Christian rediscovered the island on 15 January 1790,
heard that he was reprieved, and on 11 February 1793 he,
188 nautical miles (348 km; 216 mi) east of its recorded
too, was pardoned and freed.[176]
position.[183] This longitudinal error contributed to the
mutineers decision to settle on Pitcairn.[184]
4.3
Aftermath
11
5.2
Discovery
6 Cultural impact
The perception of Bligh as an overbearing tyrant began
with Edward Christians Appendix of 1794.[197] Apart
from Blighs journal, the rst published account of
the mutiny was that of Sir John Barrow, published in
1831. Barrow was a friend of the Heywood family;
his book mitigated Heywoods role while emphasising
Blighs severity.[198] The book also instigated the legend
that Christian had not died on Pitcairn, but had somehow
returned to England and been recognised by Heywood
in Plymouth, around 180809.[199] An account written
in 1870 by Heywoods stepdaughter Diana Belcher further exonerated Heywood and Christian and, according
to Alexander, cemented ... many falsehoods that had insinuated their way into the narrative.[198]
12
Among historians attempts to portray Bligh more sympathetically are those of Richard Hough (1972) and Car- [7] Morrisons journal was probably written with the advantage of hindsight, after his return to London as a prisoline Alexander (2003). Hough depicts an unsurpassed
oner. Hough argues that Morrison could not have mainfoul-weather commander ... I would go through hell and
tained a day-by-day account of all the experiences he unhigh water with him, but not for one day in the same
derwent including the mutiny, his capture and the return
[203]
ship on a calm sea.
Alexander presents Bligh as
to England.[81]
over-anxious, solicitous of his crews well-being, and utterly devoted to his task. He was unfortunate in his tim- [8] The historian Leonard Guttridge suggests that Christians
ing; the story of the mutiny became public knowledge
psychological state may have been further aected by the
venereal disease contracted in Tahiti.[87]
when the Romantic poets rst commanded the literary
scene. Blighs chief apologist was Sir Joseph Banks, while
[9] Bligh listed these provisions in his journal as 150 pounds
Christian was championed by Wordsworth and Coleridge.
(68 kg) of bread, 28 gallons (130 litres) of water, 20
Poetry routed science, wrote the Baltimore Sun's repounds (9.1 kg) of pork, and a few coconuts and breadviewer of Alexanders book, and it has held the eld
fruit salvaged from Tofua. There were also three bottles
ever since.[202] In 1998, in advance of a BBC documenof wine and ve quarts of rum.[105]
tary lm aimed at Blighs rehabilitation, the respective depassed, pursued
scendants of the captain and Christian feuded over their [10] The straight through which the loyalists
[113]
by
natives,
is
still
called
Bligh
Water.
contrary versions of the truth. The programmes presenter, Dea Birkett, suggested that Christian versus Bligh [11] Morrison and his men created a seaworthy schooner.
has come to represent rebellion versus authoritarianism,
When HMS Pandora arrived in Tahiti in March 1791,
a life constrained versus a life of freedom, sexual represin search of mutineers, the schooner was conscated and
commandeered to act as Pandora's tender. The schooner
sion versus sexual licence.[204]
13
References
14
15
Online
Darby, Madge (2004). Bligh, Sir Richard Rodney
(17371821)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.) (Oxford: Oxford University
Press). doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/2648. (subscription
or UK public library membership required)
David, Andrew (2004). Cook, James (1728
1779)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography
(online ed.) (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/6140. (subscription or UK
public library membership required)
Erskine, Nigel (1999). Reclaiming the Bounty".
Archaeology (Boston: Archaeological Institute of
America) 52 (3). Retrieved 18 May 2015.
16
Frost, Alan (2004).
Bligh, William (1754
1817)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography
(online ed.) (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/2650. (subscription or UK
public library membership required)
History of Pitcairn Island. Guide to Pitcairn.
Auckland: Government of the Islands of Pitcairn,
Henderson, Ducie and Oeno. 2000. Retrieved 30
April 2015.
Newspapers
EXTERNAL LINKS
8 Further reading
Minogue, Tim (22 March 1998). Blighs v Christians, the 209-year feud. The Independent (London). Retrieved 20 May 2015.
Bibliography
Alexander, Caroline (2003). The Bounty. London:
Harper Collins. ISBN 978-0-00-257221-7.
Barrow, Sir John (1831). The Eventful History of
the Mutiny and Piratical Seizure of HMS Bounty: Its
Causes and Consequences. London: John Murray.
OCLC 4050135.
Bligh, William (1792). A Voyage to the South Sea,
etc. London: Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty. OCLC 28790.
Dening, Greg (1992). Mr Blighs Bad Language:
Passion, Power and Theatre on the Bounty. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0521-38370-7.
Guttridge, Leonard F (2006) [1992]. Mutiny: A History of Naval Insurrection. Annapolis, Maryland:
Naval Institute Press. ISBN 978-1-59114-348-2.
Hough, Richard (1972). Captain Bligh and Mr
Christian: The Men and the Mutiny. London:
Hutchinsons. ISBN 978-0-09-112860-9.
McKinney, Sam (1999) [1989]. Bligh!: The Whole
Story of the Mutiny Aboard H.M.S. Bounty. Victoria, British Columbia: TouchWood Editions. ISBN
978-0-920663-64-6.
Stanley, David (2004). South Pacic (Eighth ed.).
Chico, California: Moon Handbooks. ISBN 978-156691-411-6.
Tagart, Edward (1832). A Memoir of the late Captain Peter Heywood, R.N. with Extracts from his Diaries and Correspondence. London: Engham Wilson. OCLC 7541945.
9 External links
Fateful Voyage original source documents
17
10
10.1
10.2
Images
File:Admiral_Hood_1783.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/1d/Admiral_Hood_1783.jpg License: Public domain Contributors: (Original text: 'thePeerage.com person page 15214, here; this painting was published in: Hood, Samuel;
Hannay, David (ed) ) Original artist: Joshua Reynolds
File:BOUNTY_RUDDER_FROM_THE_FIJI_MUSEUM._SUVA,_FIJI_ISLANDS.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/
wikipedia/commons/5/55/BOUNTY_RUDDER_FROM_THE_FIJI_MUSEUM._SUVA%2C_FIJI_ISLANDS.jpg License: CC BY-SA
3.0 Contributors: Own work Original artist: Jerrye & Roy Klotz, MD
File:Bounty_Voyages_Map.png Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6c/Bounty_Voyages_Map.png License:
GFDL Contributors: I stitched together two maps from Online Map Creation (which uses GMT,[1] an open source software licensed
under GNU GPL[2]), and changed their color scheme. Voyage lines are based on File:Bountya.jpg, the map on this web page, and books
on the Bounty such as Alexander, Caroline (2003). The Bounty. London: Harper Collins. ISBN 0-00-257221-4. Original artist: Ruhrsch
(<a href='//commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Ruhrfisch' title='User talk:Ruhrfisch'>talk</a>)
File:Bounty_bay.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/1a/Bounty_bay.jpg License: CC-BY-SA-3.0 Contributors: Own work Original artist: Makemake at German Wikipedia
File:Commons-logo.svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/4/4a/Commons-logo.svg License: CC-BY-SA-3.0 Contributors: ? Original artist: ?
File:HMS_BOUNTY_II_with_Full_Sails.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/44/HMS_BOUNTY_II_
with_Full_Sails.jpg License: CC BY-SA 3.0 Contributors: Own work Original artist: Dan Kasberger
18
10
10.3
Content license