Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
David A. Sheppard
6. Piles do not resist the soil mass except in the butt area, under certain circumstances.
7. The use of restrained pile foundations does not alter the horizontal response of the structure.
8. Embedded piles are bent into curvatures of various radii when layered
soils undergo cyclic movement.
9. Lateral shears and moments in the
pile butt area are reduced by as much
as 85 percent when the pile cap is restrained by grade beams, basements, or
by the otherwise keying into the soil.
10. Critical moment-curvature locations in restrained pile foundations are
at the pile/pile cap interface and
deeper, at the point of fixity in the soil
mass. Free standing (cantilevered) pile
structures and unrestrained pile caps
have a potential plastic hinge region at
a point of high shear and moment at the
pile/pile cap interface.
EXISTING PILE
TEST INFORMATION
Several series of tests have been conducted in California to ascertain the
elastic and post-elastic behavior of particular prestressed concrete piling sections. Details of three of these tests are
summarized below:
1972
K^ YLO/ %JDV )
K=
1972
R = 2.3 x 10 -4 IN.-'
600
(0.22f'c A9)
43'-I"
R"4967"(420')
K= R=2.0x 104IN.-I
Fig. 1. 1972 Santa Fe Pomeroy pile tests.
1974
p-20KAT FAILURE
200K
=4.5"
30'-0"
R = 3600 (300')
K=R=2.8x 10-4IN"
Fig. 2. 1974 Santa Fe Pomeroy pile test.
22
(0.23fc Ay)
1976
(pS =0.003)
P/2-24'
2.5"
--
(0.35f AG)
21'-O"
R - 3175" (260')
K = R = 3.1 x IO4IN.-'
12" SO.
6-3/18 "4270K
STRANDS
23
2
P
12"
P/2
P/2
ULT.=4K
(ps =0.021)
P/2
J.
300 K
300K
A ULT. =8.5"
(0.35fc A9)
21'-0"
K ULT.
R 934" (78')ULTIMATE
=R
I0.7X I04IN-'
6-x/16"4'270K STRANDS
W8.5 COLD DRAWN
WIRE SPIRALAT2'o.c.
(JAS =0.021 )
POST-TENSIONING DUCT
FOR AXIAL LOAD
APPLICATION
24
Fig. 5. 1976 PCMAC pile test program. Axial load of 301 kips (1.35 x 10 6 N) applied by
post- tensioning 12- -in. diameter, 270 ksi (12.7 mm 0, 1860 MPa) strands. The duct
was subsequently grouted. (Photo courtesy: Herb Brauner, J. H. Pomeroy & Co., Inc.)
Fig. 6. 1976 PCMAC pile test program. Test frame set-up with Specimen 1 in place.
Hydraulic jacks on both sides were used to apply cyclic loading, and at the same time
simulate lateral restraint as would be provided by the soil. (Photo courtesy: Herb
Brauner, J. H. Pomeroy & Co., Inc.)
PCI JOURNAL/March-April 1983
25
Fig. 7. 1976 PCMAC pile test program. Specimen 1 after failure. W3.5 spiral wire at ti
in. c/c (5.4 mm (A at 150 mm) (Ps = 0.003) did not provide adequate confinement.
Sudden brittle failure occurred after first cracking. (Photo courtesy: Herb Brauner, J. H.
Pomeroy & Co., Inc.)
also determined that more testing is required to be able to make more definitive detailing recommendations for prestressed concrete piling. Some of the
items learned were:
1. The standard W3.5 spiral steel
spaced at a 6-in. (5.4 mm 4) at 150 mm)
pitch does not provide sufficient confinement in the post-cracking situation,
i.e., induced curvatures over 2.5 to 3.0 x
10-' (1.0 to 1.2 x 10-5 mm-') result in
sudden brittle failures in all cases.
2. The level of axial force used in the
1976 tests was too high; a more realistic
value, reflecting actual imposed dead
load and reduced live load plus seismic
effects plus downdrag, would be:
0 .2 .f^ A,, = Pe
Fig. 8. 1976 PCMAC pile test program. Specimen 2 at conclusion of test. W8.5 spiral
wire at 2 in. c/c (8.3 mm at 50 mm) (Ps = 0.021) continued to provide adequate
confinement despite post-elastic deformation exceeding four times that producing first
cracking. (Photo courtesy: Herb Brauner, J. H. Pomeroy & Co., Inc.)
27
Asp
SPIRAL _
PITCH -asp
Ssp
%SPIRAL-
2A p
h Ssp
(EQUATION I)
ps
ps
_ VOL SPIRAL
VOL CORE
Tr ds p A sp 4 Asp
=
lT dsp
4 .Ssp
dspssp
(EQUATION 2)
SPIRAL CONFINEMENT
PERCENTAGE (GERWICK)
SPIRAL CONFINEMENT
RATIO (ACI )
29
20"
400.
^_
6.0 RICHTER
(NO SOIL F^
1
j i
^^r
IIIIIAII,i
1 ^V
10
II
12
or
U=
Mu <
0.20
0M.
and
RECOMMENDED SEISMIC
DESIGN PROVISIONS FOR
PRESTRESSED PILING
The dual response criteria for designing structures for earthquakes is presented in the recommended lateral
force requirements of the Structural
Engineers Association of California," as
well as in ATC 3 -06. 12 Prestressed concrete piling should be designed for serviceability in a moderate earthquake, in
addition to being capable of developing
ductility at critical points of potential
plastic hinging in order to dissipate energy generated by a maximum probable
PCI JOURNAUMarch-April 1983
PQ
<0.3f,A,
and those areas of embedded piling below the ductile range where
not subjected to curvatures from
layered soil movements during an
earthquake:
p8 ' 0.003
b. Embedded portions of piling subjected to curvatures from layered
soil movements during earthquake
p S = 0.014
*Not applicable to hollow-core piling sections.
31
0,
01
Jz
vu
W
>
W J W J
x-
00
U N
U31
f
II I
W PS =0.021
11.5htf
^N^,U2:'
2h
T
J
- j--
^, l
BENDING
MOMENT
or coneswnuess bum
= 0.45 -
P3
fvs^
A9
(A^
ductile range
2. At the potential plastic hinge region immediately below the pile
cap, for a distance of two pile diameters, provide spiral reinforcing in accordance with the
following equations:
1 (0.5 + 1.25 PQ
Jf^
A9
Eq. (3)
32
^
= 0.12 f
(0.5 + 1.25 PQ
Eq. (4)
Vu
U)
xz "'
VO
z
p
>_
COO)
L_
,.
<W
ai
oN
CO
wJ
N
^^
II
II I
I I II
X
W
1.5 h+f
Ps=0.021
M42*
P5=0.003
BENDING
MOMENT
rig. 13. condition 2 Unrestrained long slender piles in cohesive or cohesionless
soils in which pile cap is free to translate (see Reference 17).
33
W
0
Z
Vu
ZZ
_
, r
,o
met a
^' :^
II Ise".. ^
I`a
Qc
MW
MP d
v (ci^
N N
W J
0
c0i
2h
CANT.
Z
LU
Ps =0.021
?
o
=
.`;
IL
=.:
I I
I II I
I I
W
J
',
M u2
1.5h +f
2h
Ps =0.003
BENDING
MOMENT
Fig. 14. Condition 3 Cantilevered/free standing piles unrestrained at top and free
to translate (see Reference 17).
d,r
in.
D39 ,
in.
Inner Spiral
p 8 = 0.021
A39, in.2
12 square
14 square
16 square
18 square
20 square
24 square
8
10
12
14
16
20
9
11
13
15
17
21
0.085
0.11
0.13
0.15
0.17
0.22
15 octag.
18 octag.
24 octag.
11
14
20
12
15
21
0.12
0.15
0.22
f,' = 6 ksi
Pe= 0.2ffA,,
f8
AD ,
in.2
A^,
in.2
Eq. (3)
Asp + A8 9
in.2
Outer Spiral
AB p
142
194
254
322
398
574
186
268
473
57
87
123
165
214
330
104
165
330
0.048
0.039
0.034
0.030
0.028
0.024
0.025
0.020
0.014
0.22
0.22
0.22
0.23
0.24
0.25
0.15
0.15
0.15
W14 @ 2"
Wil @ 2"
W9 @ 2"
W8 @ 2"
W7 @ 2"
W4 C` 2"
W3.5 @ 2"
-
p8
NOTE: The current ACI Code limitation on the value of f,, , to 60 ksi (413 MPa) is ignored in these
tables.
Inner Spiral
p3= 0.021
Asp , mm2
A
mm2
A^,
mm2
pp
Eq. (3)
Asp +
A89
mm2
0.37x105
0.56x105
0.79x10
1.06x10
1.38 x 101
2.13x105
0.048
0.039
0.034
0.030
0.028
0.024
141.9 10.7 mm @ 50 mm
141.9 9.5 mm @ 50 mm
141.9 8.6 mrn 4 @ 50 mm
148.4 8.1 mm (A @ 50 mm
154.8 7.6 mm 0 @ 50 mm
161.3 5.7 mm @ 50 mm
305 square
356 square
406 square
457 .square
508 square
610 square
203
254
305
356
406
508
229
279
330
381
432
533
54.8
71.0
83.9
96.8
109.7
141.9
0.92 x105
1.25x105
1.64 x 105
2.08 x105
2.57 x 105
3.70x105
380 octag.
457 octag.
610 octag.
280 305
356 381
508 533
77.4
96.8
141.9
96.8
96.8
96.8
Outer Spiral
A..
5.4 mm 4, @ 50 mm
-
FABRICATION AND
INSTALLATION
CONSIDERATIONS
The use of heavier spiral in prestressed concrete piling changes the
manufacturing technique used by most
producers in setting up their pile lines.
PCI JOURNAL/March-April 1983
rn
T.,I.i . , A
'
d39,
12 square
14 square
16 square
18 square
20 square
24 square
8
10
12
14
16
20
W3.5 @ 6"
W3.5@4W'
W3.5 @ 3W'
W4 @ 3 1/z'
W5 @ 4"
W5 @ 3"
W6 @ 2"
W7 @ 2"
W8.5 @ 2"
W10 @ 2"
Wil @2"
W14 @ 2"
15 octag.
18 octag.
24 octag.
11
14
20
W3.5 @ 4"
W4 @ 3Ye
W5 @ 3'
W8 @ 2"
W10 @ 2"
W14 @ 2"
in.
ps =
0.003
0.014
A,
Ds9,
PH*
in.
Asp
in.
254
314
380
452
531
707
113
154
201
254
314
452
12
14
16
18
20
24
0.020
0.017
0.014
0.013
0.011
0.009
W12 @ 2"
W12@2"
W12 @ 2'
W12 @ 2"
Wil @2"
Wil @ 2"
346
452
707
177
254
452
15
18
24
0.015
0.013
0.009
W12 @ 2"
W12 @ 2'
Wil @ 2"
Ag,
H = h + 6,
p8 =
in.
in.
W8.5 @ 2"
W11 @ 2"
W13 @ 2"
W15 @ 2"
W17 @ 2"
W22 @ 2"
180
200
22 0
24 A
260
304)
W12 @ 2"
W15 @ 2"
W22 @ 2"
210
24
30 'A
ps =
0.021
*p. = 0.45
f
v'n
A
(A^
11
f/ = 3 ksi
fuse = 70 ksi (ASTM A-82)
PQ= 0.2ffAg
3-in. cover
NOTE: The current ACI Code limitation on the value of f, to 60 ksi (413.4 MPa) is ignored in these tables.
I0.5 + 1.25
l i,
Pe
A
0
C-
C
z
C,
Table 162. Spiral confinement for various prestressed concrete piling sections using ASTM A 82 wire (S.I. units).
Spiral Arrangement for Various Values of p,
Pile Size
h, mm
dsp
mm
H =
p, =
0.003
p, 0.014
8.3 mm 0 @ 50
9.5 mm (A @ 50
10.3 mm 4) @ 50
11.1 mm 4 @ 50
11.8 mm @ 50
13.4 mm 0 @ 50
457 0
508
560 (A
610 (A
660 0
762 0
1.64 x 10
2.03 x 10
2.45 x 10
2.92 x 10
3.43 x 10
4.56 x 10
0.73 x 10
0.99 x 10
1.30 x 10
1.64 x 10
2.03 x 10
2.92 x 10
533 0
610 0
762 (A
2.23 x 10
2.92 x 10
4.56 x 10
1.14 x 10'
1.64 x 10
2.92 x 10
380 octag
457 octag.
610 octag.
= 41.3 MPa
50
mm
clear
*p8 =
0.45
f (-_ 8
cover
y8p
P, = 0.2f f Ag
f,,p = 482 MPa
C')
V
A,
mm2
203
254
305
356
406
508
,@
A9,
mm
305 square
356 square
406 square
457 square '
508 square
610 square
h + 150
pg = 0.021
55
55
55
15
5
mm2
A`\
f, = 20.7 MPa
fe
55
55
55
55
D..,
p;
Asp
305
356
406
457
508
610
0.020
0.017
0.014
0.013
0.011
0.009
9.9 mm @ 50 mm
9.9 mm @ 50 mm
9.9 mm @ 50 mm
9.9 mm @ 50 mm
9.5 mm @ 50 mm
9.5 mm @ 50 mm
380
457
610
0.015 9.9 mm @ 50 mm
0.013 9.9 mm @ 50 mm
0.009 9.5 mm @ 50 mm
mm
)
` A
76 mm clear cover
s,
epe.r^.,a
. i i
oc
CLEAR COVER
TYP. FOR C.I.P.
BUILD-UP
3H
SPIRAL REINF. IN
P/S PILE UNIT
(Ps = 0.021)
E1
e:
a
z
a
3"
O
OO
0aaza
xv>aw
g o w a
N a-aLLcn
a =4
> Z w J
Y>a Uw
Qwla3
Q J F J O
w wZ
J Cr to
FIELD PLACED
SPIRAL REINF.
AS= EQ. (3)
^d
o
I..: w
z ^
3"
"CLEAR
2COVER
TYP. FOR P/S PILE
w<nao
38
2h
21ICLEAR COVER
^'
I ^41CLEAR CLEAR
ASP
w +a
OUTER SPIRAL
INNER SPIRAL
g a
Asp
P/S CONC.
N_
O
O a
n .
^N It
39
Fig. 1.7. Pile set-up rig in Kie-Con Plant (Peter Kiewit Sons), Pleasanton, California.
Note how the W3.5 (5.4 mm 4) spiral wire collapses accordion-style for easy placement
during mold set-up.
Fig. 18. Heavy wire coil confinement cage. Kie-Con yard superintendent in Pleasanton,
California, demonstrates the coil spring characteristics of a W1 1 (9.5 mm) spiral cage, 8
in. (200 mm) in diameter on a 2-in. (50 mm) pitch.
41
2'-0" BROOM
OR 90 0 BEND
SUMMARY AND
CONCLUSIONS
Design and detailing recommendations are presented for prestressed concrete piling subjected to earthquake
loading. Ductility is improved by con-
31_0..
STRAIGHT
STRANDS
UIIII
IiIII
1
BOTTOM OF
C.I.P. PILE CAP
II
II
Fig. 21. Prestressed concrete pile showing fixed pile/pile cap connection using -in.
(12.7 mm) diameter or less exposed strands.
42
BOTTOM OF
C.I.P. PILE CAP
Id
DOWEL SLEEVES
INSIDE SPIRAL
REINFORCING
SECTION
Fig. 22. Fixed pile/pile cap connection using mild steel dowels.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The author wishes to express his
gratitude to Edward Margason, Vice
President of Woodward-Clyde Consultants, for permission to cite freely from
his excellent papers which laid the
groundwork for the positive steps that
are being made to insure proper design
of prestressed concrete piling to resist
seismic forces. Thanks also to Ben C.
Gerwick, Jr., Consulting Engineer, and
Professor, University of California, for
explaining the background for his design recommendations; and to Herb
Brauner of J. H. Pomeroy & Co. Inc. for
his untiring efforts expended in practical examination of pile performance,
and for sharing these experiences.
43
NONCRITICAL
ZONE(P,=0.003)
SPIRAL
REINF.
LAP
SPLICE ZONE
2 TURNS
2htT,,
^...,..
12(305mm)
* INCREASE TO ,pp =0.014 IN LAYERED SOIL CONDITIONS
12
Fig. 23. 12 in. (305 mm) square seismic resistant pile (UBC Seismic Zone 4).
2"(5omm)CLEAR
d Sp= B "(2OOmm)
n,
C-
0
C
C)
NON-CRITICAL
ZONE (P$= 0.003)*
DUCTILE ZONE(P5=0.021)
33
z
NO ADDL.
CONFINEMENT
REQUIRED
SP LICE ZONE
2 TURNS
LAP
P/S STRANDS
\i \! \i \i \i\I\I
SPIRAL.
REINF.
W15 AT 2"c-c
(11.1 mm AT 50mm PITCH)
_I
W4 AT 3'/2 "c-c
T^ (5.7mm AT90 mm)
2"(5omm)CLEAR
d5p=I4(356mm)
18" (457mm)
OCTAGONAL
Ultimate Approx.
Yield
Tensile
Strength, Strength,
ksi
f, ksi
Size, Diameter
Ultimate
Tensile
Strength,
MPa
Approximate
Yield
Strength
fv$p, MPa
4.1
4.9
6.4
7.9
1810
1740
1650
1520
1364
1316
1253
1151
198
191
182
167
262
252
240
221
8 ga/0.162 in.-W2
6 ga/0.192 in.-W2-9
'/a in./0.250 in.-W5
5/is in./0.312 in.-W7.5
Size
Diameter,
mm
Table 2A2. Ductile confinement chart for ASTM A648 steel wire (U.S. units).
W7.5 Wire
Pile Size
h, in.
d$p,
in.
in.2
in.2
P.
Eq. (3)*
Ag,
12 square
14 square
16 square
18 square
20 square
24 square
8
10
12
14
16
20
142
194
254
322
398
574
57
87
123
165
214
330
0.020
0.017
0.014
0.013
0.012
0.010
15 octag.
18 octag.
24 octag.
11
14
20
186
268
473
104
165
330
0.011
0.008
0.006
f' = 6 ksi
2-in. cover
e=
Pe
f'
0.45 .
= 0.2f,A ,,
W5 Wire
SSp,
in.
Eq. (3)*
17/8
1%
1'/z
1Y2
0.018
0.015
0.013
0.012
0.011
0.009
2'
2Y2
2'
0.010
0.008
0.005
13/4
13/4
sap,
in.
1%
1%6
1 Y4
Mlle
1%
1
13/a
13/4
/A
l
`- - 1) (0.5+ 1.25 feAe
l
Table 2B2. Ductile confinement chart for ASTM A648 steel wire (S.I. units).
7.9 mm Wire
Pile Size
h, mm
Ag,
Sgp,
P8,
S8P,
mm2
A^,
mm2
p8
mm
Eq. (3)*
mm
Eq. (3)*
mm
305 square
356 square
406 square
457 square
508 square
610 square
203
254
305
356
406
508
0.92 x 105
1.25 x 105
1.64 x 105
2.08 x 105
2.57 x 105
3.70 x 105
0.37 x 105
0.56 x 105
0.79 x 105
1.06 x 105
1.38 x 105
2.13 x 105
0.020
0.017
0.014
0.013
0.012
0.010
48
44
44
41
38
38
0.018
0.015
0.013
0.012
0.011
0.009
35
33
32
30
29
29
380 octag.
457 octag.
610 octag.
280
356
508
1.20 x 105
1.73 x 105
3.05 x 105
0.67 x 105
1.06 x 105
2.13 x 105
0.011
0.008
0.006
64
64
64
0.010
0.008
0.005
44
44
51
f' =41.3MPa
50 mm cover
f'
*P8
= 0.45 ,,
f ,
P=0.2f,A
g
e
46
6.4 mm Wire
d8P,
P
/
Diameter,
in.
Area,
in?
0.207
0.225
0.244
2r
0.253
2
1'
0.265
0.273
0.283
0'/z
0.295
0.307
2/0
0.331
3/0
0.363
4/0
0.394
0.034
0.035
0.040
0.045
0.047
0.050
0.050
0.055
0.055
0.059
0.060
0.063
0.065
0.068
0.070
0.074
0.075
0.080
0.085
0.086
0.090
0.095
0.100
0.103
0.110
0.120
0.122
0.130
0.140
0.146
0.150
0.160
0.168
0.170
0.180
0.189
0.190
0.200
0.220
0.240
0.260
0.280
0.310
5/0
0.431
6/0
0.462
7/0
0.490
"W"
Wire Size
Diameter,
in.
Diameter,
mm
Area,
mmz
W3.5
W4
W4.5
0.211
0.225
0.240
5.4
5.7
6.1
22.6
25.8
29.0
W5
0.252
6.4
32.3
W5.5
0.264
6.7
35.5
W6
0.276
7.0
38.7
W6.5
0.287
7.3
41.9
W7
0.298
7.6
45.2
W7.5
W8
W8.5
0.309
0.319
0.328
7.8
8.1
8.3
48.4
51.6
54.8
W9
W9.5
W10
0.338
0.347
0.356
8.6
8.8
9.0
58.1
61.3
64.5
Wil
W12
0.374
0.390
9.5
9.9
71.0
77.4
W13
W14
0.406
0.422
10.3
10.7
83.9
90.3
W15
W16
0.437
0.451
11.1
11.5
96.8
103.2
W17
W18
0.465
0.478
11.8
12.1
109.7
116.1
W19
W20
W22
W24
W26
W28
W31
0.491
0.504
0.529
0.553
0.575
0.597
0.628
12.5
12.8
13.4
14.0
14.6
15.2
16.0
122.6
129.0
141.9
154.8
167.8
180.7
200.0
47
REFERENCES
1. Margason, Edward, "Pile Bending
During Earthquakes (Effects of Ground
Movement and Shaking on Piles),"
Lecture given on March 6, 1975 as a part
of an ASCE/University of California at
Berkeley sponsored seminar on design,
construction, and performance of deep
foundations.
2. Jennings, Paul, "Engineering Features
of the San Fernando Earthquake," Report, California Institute of Technology,
Pasadena, June 1971.
3. Brandow, Gregg, and Leeds, David,
"Reconnaissance Report, Imperial
County, California Earthquake, October
15, 1979," Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, Berkeley, California,
February 1980.
4. Margason, Edward, "Stability of Piles in
Seismically Loaded Soils," Paper presented at the 5th Danube European
Conference on Soil Mechanics and
Foundation Engineering, CSSR, Bratislava, September 5-7, 1977.
5. Brauner, Herbert A., Slides of 1976
Cyclical Tests of 12 in. Square Prestressed Concrete Piling, sponsored by
the Prestressed Concrete Manufacturers
Association of California (20 slides with
commentary).
6. Bertero, Brauner, Fotinos, Gerwick, Lin,
and Seed, "Aseismic Design of Prestressed Concrete Piling," Paper presented at the FIP Congress, New York
City, May 25, 1974.
7. Margason, Edward and Holloway,
Michael, "Pile Bending During Earthquakes," Paper presented at the 6th
World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, New Delhi, India, 1977.
8. Gerwick, Ben C., Jr., Construction of
Prestressed Concrete Structures, John
Wiley & Sons, Inc., Englewood Cliffs,
New Jersey, 1971.
9. ACI Committee 318, "Building Code
Requirement for Reinforced Concrete
APPENDIX - NOTATION
A^ = area of core of spirally reinforced
pile section, measured to outside
diameter of spiral
Ag = gross area of pile cross section
Abp = area of transverse spiral wire
(one leg)
D = dead load, or related internal
moments and forces (unfactored
service load)
DSp = diameter of confined concrete
core contained by outer spiral.
cage in cast-in-place concrete
pile build-up or in precast pile
section in plastic hinge region,
measured center-to-center of spiral reinforcement
d39 = diameter of confined concrete
core in pile section, measured
center-to-center of spiral reinforcement
E = load effects of earthquake, or related internal moments and
forces (unfactored service load)
f = distance from point of beginning
of passive resistance of soil to
lateral pile forces, to point of
maximum moment in pile below
soil surface (see Reference 17)
= specified compressive strength
of concrete
fv$ = specified yield strength of spiral
reinforcement
H = overall gross width or diameter
of pile build-up
h = overall gross width of precast
pile section
K = curvature of bent precast pile
section, taken as the inverse of
the radius of curvature (1/R )
L = live loads, or related internal
moments and forces (unfactored
service load)
ld = development length of vertical
reinforcing
49