Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Thanks to Allah SWT, for His blessing, we can solve this internship report on time. Also, thanks to Mr. Husnul
Abady, M.T as our supervisor in PPBJ department for the guidance, because of that we can get new experience
and knowledge.
The outlines of this report such as spare parts management, demand and classification and forecast for next
period. Doing this project report helped us to enhance our knowledge about implementation of some forecasting
techniques in the real problem. Through this report we come to know about importance of team work and role of
We hope who goes through it will find it interesting and worth reading. All constructive feedback is cordially
invited
Table of Contents
Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember
Surabaya
1. Executive Summary.......................................
2. Motivation and Background........................... 2
3. Scope Of Work...............................................
4. An Overview of PT Petrokimia Gresik............. 4
5. Organizational Structure of PT Petrokimia Gresik
6. Procurement Process.....................................
Contact:
7. Spare Parts Management Framework............
15
@nurranisiti@gmail.com
8. Spare Parts Demand and Classification......... 27
@firdausiganisalihati@gmail.com
9. The Forecasting of Spare Parts Demand........ 30
10.
Methodology.............................
11.
Data and Process......................
12.
Analysis.....................................
13.
Conclusions...............................
1
3
10
14
39
19
21
22
14.
15.
References................................
Appendixes...............................
Internship Report
23
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This report provides an analysis of forecast of some spare parts in re-order level goods. The method use in this
research are single exponential smoothing, Crostons method and SBA method. In data and process section, we
only provide one sample calculation, and the others calculation attached in appendix. The spare parts use in this
research are grind stone, conveyor fastener, v-belt, bearing, pressure indicator and valve.
Tambahin analisa
Berdasarkan hasil perhitungan didapatkan hasil error terkecil yaitu dengan menggunakan metode SES
dengan presentase rata-rata error sebesar 23,24%, sedangkan untuk metode SBA yaitu sebesar 26,25%
dan metode Crostons sebesar 36,72%.
Internship Report
SCOPE OF WORK
The Boundaries & Purpose
In this experiment, we can discuss about how the paramaters that can affect the recipe of the cupcake and how
to reduce the variation in the variable that affect on it.
The problems scope or boundary in this experiment are as follows :
1. Only using spare parts in re-order level goods,
2. History demand data from 2011 until 2014
The main purpose of this experiment is:
1. To predict demand spare parts in next year
Page 2
Internship Report
2012) includes PT
Province,
and
produced
ammonia, urea fertilizer and ZA, and now it has various businesses
producing phosphoric Acid based fertilizer. Since 2005, PT Petrokimia Gresik has developer organic fertilizer
plant named petroganik indicating the spirit of continuous innovation and care to the environment of all
elements of the company. PT Petrokimia Gresik produces various kind of fertilizers, so PT Petrokimia Gresik
becomes the most complete fertilizer plant in Indonesia.
The Vision of PT Petrokimia Gresik si to be a fertilizer and chemical produser having high
competitiveness whose products are most wanted by consumers. Also, the mission of PT Petrokima Gresik
are:
1. To support national fertilizers supply in order to achieve food self sufficiency program,
2. To increase companys retur to facilitate the companys day to day operation as well as its
development program, and
3. To develop the business potential to support the national chemical industries and to be active in
community development.
The purpose and objective of PT Petrokimia Gresik is to executing and supporting the government policy
in the field of economy and national development in general, and in the field of industry, trade, service, and
transportaion especially (Annual Report, 2011).
Page 3
Internship Report
Company Location
PT Petrokima Gresik located at A. Yani Street and has a land area of 450 ha, but that has been handled by 300
ha. The area covers an area of land occupied 10 villages in three districts, namely:
o District of Gresik, includes sub district Ngipik, Karangturi, Sukorame, and Tlogopojok.
o District of Kebomas, includes sub district Kebomas, Tlogopatut, and Randu Agung.
o District of Manyar, includes sub district Romo Meduran, Coastal Corner, as well as the village Tepen.
Chosen areas above as the location of the PT Petrokimia Gresik is the result of a feasibility study in 1962 by
the Preparatory Committee Industry Project or Badan Persiapan Proyek Industri (BP3I), coordinated by the
Ministry of Basic Industry and Mines with the following considerations:
Near to the largest fertilizer consumer area, namely plantations and sugarcane farmers.
Close to the port to facilitate transportation of plant equipment during construction, raw material procurement,
production and distribution of results through the navy.
Close to the center of power plants.
Page 4
Internship Report
"PT Petrokimia Gresik determined to become producers of fertilizers and other chemical products that are highly
competitive and most popular consumer products."
In Bahasa:
PT Petrokimia Gresik bertekad untuk menjadi produsen pupuk dan produk kimia lainnya yang berdaya saing
tinggi dan produknya paling banyak diminati konsumen.
Page 5
Internship Report
Page 6
Internship Report
In Bahasa:
Dengan hati yang bersih berdasarkan lima sila Pancasila, PT Petrokimia Gresik berusaha mencapai
masyarakat yang adil dan makmur untuk menuju keagungan bangsa.
Supporting Infrastructure Unit
Special Pier
PT Petrokimia Gresik has facilities pier for own purpose or Dermaga Untuk Kepentingan Sendiri (DUKS)
sized 819 x 36 m with a capacity:
1.
2.
o
o
This dock is also equipped with loading and unloading facilities, which form two bulk loading crane, crane
unloading a versatile, two conveyor unloading raw materials, belt conveyor for the transportation of solid
materials, and pipeline facilities for transporting liquid materials.
Water Purification Unit
1. In Gunung Sari (Surabaya), from Brantas River sent to Gresik using a pipe along the 22 km, 14 inch
diameter and a capacity of 700 m3 / h.
2. In Babat, from Bengawan Solo River to Gresik via pipeline 55 km, 28 inch diameter, and the installed
capacity from 1700 to 2500 m3 / h.
Belt conveyor
As the supporting transportation infrastructure of raw materials and products, there are belt conveyor which
connected the pier with factories in production units I, II, and III with a total length of about 22 km.
Industrial Plant Equipment Unit
To support the maintenance of existing plant and can be used for fabrication and machining plant equipment
order another company that is managed by the Ministry of Equipment and Machinery.
Power Plant
The Company has three power plant units, namely:
1. From the gas turbine generator with a capacity of 33 MW to meet the needs of the process in the
production units.
2. From the steam turbine generator with a capacity of 20 MW is also consumed to meet the needs of the
process.
3. From PLN with a capacity of 15 MW is used for non-process such as hospitals, residential, office, GOR,
mosques, and others.
Waste Processing Unit
Page 7
Internship Report
PT Petrokimia Gresik perform waste management by using a system of reuse, recycle and recovery (3R) with
the support of: liquid waste with a capacity of 240 m3 / h, control facilities gas emissions in each production unit,
including bag filters, cyclonic separator, dust collector, electric precipitator (EP), dust scrubbers, etc.
Distribution Center
PT Petrokimia Gresik has a Warehouse Distribution Center in Medan, Lampung, Padang, Cigading,
Banyuwangi, Makasar and Gresik.
Laboratories
Production Laboratory, Calibration Laboratory, Laboratory of Chemical Test, Mechanical Test Laboratory,
Electrical Testing Laboratory, Valve test, Air Permeability Test, etc.
Page 8
Internship Report
Picture 3.
Organization Structural of Planning and Control Goods and Services (PPBJ) Departement
Department of planning and monitoring of goods and services (PPBJ) in charge planning what items are
needed by the user to support the production process as well as monitoring the performance of suppliers and
monitoring goods received from suppliers regarding the conformity of the goods to the specifications given when
making the order.
Operation & Supply Chain Engineering
Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember Surabaya - 2016
Page 9
Internship Report
Based on the level of consumption, the items are classified into five categories, namely Re Order Level
(ROL), Insurance (Z), intransit (I), Non Stock Item (H) and Surplus (E). For the category H and I are determined
by the users and for the category ROL and Z, the planning is done by the department based on the PPBJ with the
historical data and the company's plans in advance.
This department has six sections:
Planning material goods
This section is responsible to planning the amount of material, controlling the amount of inventory in the
warehouse, planned deadline for procurement, and to give the owner estimate. The availability of material is
divided into two categories: material stock and non-stock material. Material stocks implement the plan by using
quantum maximum and minimum based on historical data, the input of user-related and operational data on the
most important items. While the non-stock material without prior planning because the material is new, so there is
no historical data is earlier.
At the planning material, there are six sections, namely:
Staff planning plant I
Staff planning plant II
Staff planning plant III
Staff planning non-plant and general items
Staff planning of BB / BP / BD
Staff planning of ROL and insurance items
Services planning
This section is in charge of planning for the procurement of suppliers in the treatment plant, construction of
the plant, plant equipment repair and cleaning service.
Identification and evaluation techniques
This section is responsible to identify the material from giving up material specification category. And other
tasks is to evaluate the technical goods offered by the supplier or from the procurement process. In addition, this
section is also responsible for giving PartNumber on each material. Part of this material are signals that allow a
user to request the desired needs to deserahkan the PGM department.
At the Identification and evaluation techniques, there are four sections, namely:
1. Staff of mechanical and workshop
2. Staff of Electrical and Instruments
3. Staff of production, non factories and general items
4. Staff of data reporting services
Monitoring and receipt of goods and services
Warehouse of material
Warehouse assigned to accept the goods or materials that come from suppliers, storing goods or materials for
the plant, taking care of material goods well, and serve the people who need the goods to run the production,
especially user. Goods in the warehouse is not a raw material for production. Any goods stored in the warehouse
of materials have been verified before being placed on each of the warehouses that have been classified for each
item.
Operation & Supply Chain Engineering
Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember Surabaya - 2016
Page 10
Internship Report
Page 11
Internship Report
Procurement Process
The procurement process began with the demand for goods or material needs of the user that called the
Material Requisition (MR) or request materials for the maintenance process called the Maintenance Material
Requisition (MMR). Then the user deliver on the plan located on each - each plant, and Candal of each - each
plant will deliver these requirements to the Candal PPBJ. If the required material needs have been available in the
warehouse, it will be immediately given by create a pick list or PB as a requirement for the user to take the goods
in the warehouse. However, if the goods are not available in warehouse, then this demand will continue to be
made a requisition (PR) by the planning section of the material.
In the PR created by Planning Material section, and it should be listed the value of the Owner Estimate (OE)
which can be used as a reference in the offer which will then be submitted to the Department of Procurement.
Then the procurement department will tendering an offer or invite to suppliers who can supply the goods in
accordance with the PR that has been made. After found the appropriate supplier, PPBJ can make purchase order
(PO) to the supplier contained the items specification. Every purchase order has a due date, so supplier must
fulfill the order before the due date.
When the supply arrived, then identifications and evaluation techniques section checking the items, whether
the items come in accordance by specifications or not. If the items or goods are appropriate, then, PPBJ will make
a PB. And the goods or item will send to warehouse, then sending a MMR to user.
Page 12
Internship Report
Manufacturing part
Demand type
Life cycle impact
Source of demand
Source of randomness in
demand
manufacturing lines
Traceable
Spare part
Spare part is a supporting component of primary machine. Based on Oxford dictionary, spare parts means
a duplicate part to replace a lost or damaged part of a machine. Each time the machine is damaged it needed spare
parts replacement, so the availability of spare parts is essential. Some of the items below are an example of
machine spare parts, namely:
1
Grinding Stone
Grinder is a tool that serves to soften or to sharpen workpieces made of metal. The function of grinding stone
is as follows:
1
2
Page 13
Internship Report
For cutting.
Sharpening cutting tools.
Types and Functions of the grinding stone is different in its use, the following function of some type:
1
Flat Rock Grinding wheels, to perform grinding cutting tools such as hand tap, countersink, drill bits,
2
3
and so forth.
Cut wheel grinding wheels, to perform grinding cutting tools such as cutter, lathe chisel, and so forth.
Dish grinding wheels, a very shallow cup-style grinding wheel. The thinness allows grinding in slots
5
6
high alloy steel which is able to maintain its hardness characteristic at high temperatures.
Cylindrical grinding wheels, to perform grinding diameter in a type of product.
Saucer Grinding Wheels, a special grinding profile that is used to grind milling cutters and twist drills.
It is most common in non-machining areas, as saw filers use saucer wheels in the maintenance of saw
blades.
Diamond Grinding Wheels, used to grind hard materials such as concrete, gemstones etc.
Picture 6. Grinding Stone cutoff wheels for stationary saws 356 x 25,4 x 3 mm
Page 14
Internship Report
Conveyor Fastener
Conveyor is a mechanical system that has the function of moving goods from one place to another.
Conveyor is widely used in industry to transport vast quantities of goods and sustainable. Fasteners
used to combine multiple parts or components into an assembly component.
Page 15
Internship Report
V-belt
V-BELT used to transmit power from one shaft to another shaft through a pulley that rotates at the
same speed or different. V-belt pulleys is one element that serves to transmit engine power as well as
chain sprocket and gear.
Page 16
Internship Report
Bearing Ball
Bearing is a machine element that serves to limit elative motion between two or more components of
the machine to keep it moving in the desired direction. Bearing in charge of keeping shaft in order to
always rotate about the axis, or also maintaining a linear moving parts in order to stay on track. Bearing
capability in lowering the friction depends on several factors, namely the fineness of metal balls or rollers,
the smoothness of the inner surface and outer surface to resist the rolling of the balls or rollers. Balls and
roller serves to receive loads received from the outside. There are two types of load on the bearing to be
accepted that the burden of radial and thrust loads.
horizontal shaft
Foot step or pivot bearing is bearing designed on a vertical shaft to hold the load in parallel to the
The type of bearing is usually dependent motion principles, mechanisms, materials and usability.
Here are some types of bearings can be used in industry:
Operation & Supply Chain Engineering
Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember Surabaya - 2016
Page 17
Internship Report
Ball Bearing
Ball bearings are the most common types of bearings, used in many technical applications, from
machinery to household appliances. Bearing is quite simple but it has an effective rotation. So this
makes bearing the most widely used because it can handle both of rotary load (radial load) or
compressive load from the side (thrust load). However, this is only used for applications that load
is not too heavy. In ball bearing, the load transfer from the outside (outer race) into a series of balls
in, and then get into the inner race. Because the shape of the ball is round, the contact between the
inner race and the outer race is very minimal, so rotation is very soft.
Roller Bearing
The easiest illustration of this roller bearing type is a conveyor belt where load bearing given quite
heavy. As the name implies, roller bearing in the form of a cylindrical roller. So contact between
the inner race and the outer race is not reliant on a single point as the ball bearing, but in line (the
width of the roller). Because the fulcrum wider or more than one point, then the strength of the
foundation of the load is also greater. Roller bearing is also varied including needle bearing, which
uses a cylinder with a diameter that is very small, because of that, is equated with a needle
Roller Thrust
Appropriate by its designation, roller thrust bearing in the form of roller bearings that can
withstand fairly heavy loads, commonly used in gear sets such as transmission or gear box, where
it took home and the rotating shaft
Tapered Roller
Bearings of this type has two parts opposing directions on the roller bearing. Thus, two roller
bearings can withstand the load of two-way trust them.
Magnetic Bearing
Magnetic Bearings are bearing most modern with working power or high speed. Usually use in the
system of certain systems and devices such as the flywheel. With the help of this magnetic
bearing, the flywheel can float on a magnetic field. Some types of flywheel can rotate more than
50 thousand rpm. Compared with the usual roller bearing or ball bearing to be directly melted in
this speed, because the magnetic bearing has no moving parts.
Page 18
Internship Report
Valve
Valve is a device attached to the piping system, which serves to regulate, control and direct the fluid
flow rate by opening, closing or partially closing the fluid flow. Valve has an important role in an industry
such as the oil and gas industry which includes jetting into the distillation column and control ignition in
the furnace.
Valve can be operated manually, either by using handles, levers and pedals, etc., in addition to
manually operated valve can also be operated automatically by using the principle of change of flow,
pressure and temperature. The change will affect the diaphragm, spring or piston so that it will
automatically move the valve to open and close system.
Page 19
Internship Report
Here are various types of valve with the characteristics and workings of each:
a
Gate Valve
This type is designed to open and close the flow by way of closed and fully open so that the valve
is not suitable to regulate the flow rate due to less accurate in terms of controlling the amount of
flow.
Plug Valve
Has the same function as gate valve with the closing or opening the flow as a whole. However,
some application of this valve is used to control the flow as the gas flowing.
Ball Valve
These types can be operated on the fluid temperature is -450 F to -500 F, ball valve is a type of
quick opening valve which requires only 1/4 full rotation from the closed position to fully open.
Globe valve
The flow of the valve changes direction so as to produce large enough friction even in the wide
open. This valve type is quite important when used for tight closing, especially in the gas stream.
Needle Valve
Basically, this type is used in the instrument, gage and meter line service. This valve can be used
for throttling with very accurate and can also be used at high pressures and high temperatures.
Diaphragm Valve
This valve has the advantage to have a quiet and fluid flow will flow unimpeded, this type is
excellent for flow control and flow very tight closure even though in the pipeline contained
suspended solids. Diaphragm valve suitable for corrosive fluids, viscous material, fibrous
materials, sludge, solids in suspension, gas and pressurized air.
Butterfly Valve
A valve to a low pressure with a very simple design that is used to control and adjust the flow, to
fully open and fully closed only needed fourth round.
Page 20
Internship Report
Check valve
This type have been designed to prevent backflow, check valve consists of several types such as
lift check, check and ball check swing.
Traps Valve
The function of the trap is to remove condensate from the steam piping (steam) in the absence of
steam that go wasted. Trap valve consists of three types of float traps, and inverted bucket trap
bucket trap. Trap sized adapted to discharge capacity of the actual or effective valve area is not
based on the size of the intlet and outlet pipe connections.
Page 21
Internship Report
Pressured Indicator
A pressure gauge is a measuring instrument that is used as an indicator of a change in pressure in
the process equipment.
Page 22
Internship Report
that often occurs in the procurement management in the manufacturing industry. Based on Ingegneria, Di,
Gestione, & Sistemi (2010) the characteristics of the spare parts demand are as follows:
1.
Table 2.
The characteristics of the spare parts demand
Slow moving or smooth, this items have a behavior which is similar to that of the
2.
3.
single demand,
Erratic, the fundamental characteristics is the great variability of the requested quantity,
4.
1. Special parts:
- Parts which can cause the cessation of the production process if broken
- The use that can be used for longer
- It is difficult to procure rapid or sudden
- Relative more expensive
- Must be placed in a special room
- Large diameter
2. Medium parts:
- Parts that must be present, but not causing substantial losses
- Used in standard time
- Not too difficult in the procurement process
- Medium price
- Must be placed in a special room
- Diameter smaller
3. Common parts:
- Parts that do not result in a big loss if damaged
- Use of which must be replaced
- It is not difficult in the procurement process
- The price is relatively cheap
- Placed in a normal room
- Average diameter
Based on (Ingegneria et al., 2010) Ghobbar et al. (2003, p.2105) suggest some cut values which allow a
more detailed characterization of the intermittent standard of spare parts demand. The intermittent
consumption of a spare part, as shown in Figure x.x (Ingegneria et al., 2010).
Where,
time
0
Page 23
Internship Report
Page 24
Internship Report
ADI = 1.32
Slow moving Intermittent
CV = 0.49
Erratic
Picture 14.
The categoriesLumpy
of the spare parts demand
For a valuation of this double characterization of spare parts demand, two parameters recognized in international
field are utilized:
ADI
CV
average demand.
ADI =
ti
i=1
CV =
Where
i=1
A company that will procure usually would see previous demand historical data to determine how many items
to be ordered for the next procurement. Demand forecasting do to meet the needs of production, so before the
next production do then the items required to be immediately available.
Forecasting is the process of estimating future demand in terms of quantity, timing, quality and location for
desired products and services. Forecasting is one of activity in medium range operations planning on operations
management. The purpose of forecasting is to reduce or clarify the uncertainty of the future conditions. Most
production forecasting system are built upon extrapolating time series data, so, organization or manufacturing use
an historical data or record of past activity. Since even todays rapidly changing environment fundamental
relationship still hold, this is a reasonable assumption as long as the look backward is not too far back and the
look forward is not too far distance.
Operation & Supply Chain Engineering
Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember Surabaya - 2016
Page 25
Internship Report
Forecasting have some characteristics, first is usually wrong, because there is an excess or shortage of goods
in the forecast, it is related with accuracy level. So, procurement team department must have enough data to do
forecast. Second is aggregate forecast are more accurate, because we no need forecast in detailed, since more
detailed will be less accuracy. Next is the longer forecast horizon the less accurate the forecast will be. Fourth is
forecast should include a measure of forecast error and a good forecast is more than single number.
Forecasting Method
In brief, a lot of forecasting methods have been elaborated and studied in the field of spare parts demand.
Table 4. Forecasting methods
Methods
Single
exponential
smoothing
Crostons
method
Inputs
- Historical data
- Smoothing constant
- Historical data
- Interval between
present and last
SyntetosBoylon
approximatio
n
Moving
Average
Weighted
moving
average
Additive
winter
non-zero demand
- Smoothing constant
- Historical data
- Interval between
present and last
non-zero demand
- Smoothing constant
- Historical data
- Number of data to
considerate
- Historical data
- Number of data to
Description
It adopts a smoothing
Mathematical Model
Exponential smoothing
Exponential smoothing
Arithmetic mean
demands
Mean of past n demands
Arithmetic mean
considerate
- Historical data
- Smoothing constant
- Trend constant
- Periodicity constant
- Width of periodicity
- Exponential
introduction of additive
smoothing
- Sum of components
winter
introduction of additive
smoothing
- constant
- Trend constant
- Periodicity constant
- Exponential
smoothing
- Product of
components
Page 26
Bootstrap
method
- Width of periodicity
- Historical data
- Number of re-
Modern approach to
Probabilistic
(re-sampling)
sampling
- Width of a sample
- Historical data
- Interval time T
binomial formula to
- Punctual value of the x
forecast
demand to forecast
Based on human
- Historical data
- Number of neurons
intelligence, it learns from
- Number of layers
a training set the
- Leaming algorithm
- Function of error
connection between inputs
Poisson
method
Neural
network
Probabilistic
Internship Report
model
model
(binomial distribution)
Not
mathematical
model
Moving average
Moving average is one of stationary demand pattern, means not follow the trend and seasonality.
Moving Average (MA) is a popular method for averaging the results of recent sales history to
determine a projection for the short term. This method used to smooth the time series data that bumpy.
How to use this method is to take average of n last data.
F t = D i
i=1
Where,
n=number of periodsthemoving average
D i=demand period i
Page 27
Internship Report
This forecast formulation is to calculate the demand for period 4, because we use three first demand.
To forecast period 5, each average is moved ahead one period each time.
Where,
i=the weighted for period i
D i=demand period i
The weight
( ) that is assigned to each of the historical data periods. The total of assigned
Exponential smoothing
The simplest exponential smoothing method is the single smoothing (SES) method where only one
parameter needs to be estimated. This method requires the number of periods best fit plus two years of
sales data, and is useful for items that have both trend and seasonality in the forecast. You can enter the
alpha and beta factor, or have the system calculate them. Alpha and beta factors are the smoothing
constant that the system uses to calculate the smoothed average for the general level or magnitude of sales
(alpha) and the trend component of the forecast (beta).
Ft = (last salesdemand data )+ (1 )( last forecast )
Fn +1=D n + ( 1 ) F n
Where,
=weighting factor=
2
N +1
Page 28
Internship Report
Crostons Method
This method is developed on 1972 by Croston, then is known as a Croston method. Calculation of
Crostons method using the number of demand and inter-arrival time between demands. The main
changes from the previous forecasting methods are forecasting renewed only when there is a demand and
not renewed when forecasting time interval has elapsed as usual exponential smoothing. Crostons method
not only focus on the big demand, but also considers the time between the request into the calculation. So
this model is suitable for forecasting spare parts that have intermittent demand patterns.
Crostons method is separating the renewed demand () and demand interval (). In the review
period t, if there is no demand in that period, the estimate of demand and inter-arrival time at the end of
time t, and , respectively remain unchanged. If there is a demand then Xt> 0, so the estimates are
updated with:
Ft +1=
Zt
pt
{
{
{
Zt=
Z t1 , if X t=0
. X t + (1 ) Zt , if X t >0
q t= q t1 +1,if X t=0
1, if X t > 0
pt =
p t1 ,if X t =0
. qt1 + ( 1 ) . p t1 ,if X t >0
Where,
X t =actual demand dataon period t
Z t =average demand forecasting on period t ( positive value )
pt =range average between demand nonzero observed on period t
q=range onlast demand
Page 29
Internship Report
SBA Method
Syntetos - Boylan Approximation (SBA) methods is a correction to the Crotons method. Syntetos
and Boylan (2001) showed that the original Crotons method is biased. To correct this bias then
2 .
Zt
( 2 ) . p
Ft +1= 1
Where,
Ft =forecast for the next period
Z t =average demand forecasting on period t ( positive value )
pt =range average between demand nonzero observed on period t
3 ERROR MEASUREMENTS
Error is generally measured in two ways, deviation and bias.
a Deviation
Deviation used to measures address the amount that the forecast is in error, whether in a positive or
negative direction. The deviation is normally measured by the mean absolute deviation (MAD).
E =Dt F t
Error ( t )
1
Page 30
Internship Report
MSE recognizes that large errors are disproportionately more expensive than small errors
2
Et 2
|F tDt|
n = n
Where,
Ft =forecast for the next period
D t =demand period t
n=number of periodsthemoving average
Where,
|F tDt|
n
100 =
Et
Dt
100
n
Bias
Bias is a tendency of the forecast to be either consistently higher than or consistently lower than
actual. Bias is same as mean forecast error (MFE). This used to measures average deviation of forecast
from actuals and we want MFE to be as close to zero as possible, so it can be minimum bias. But, zero
MFE does not imply that forecasts are perfect (no error), it only that mean is on target
( DF )
n
Page 31
Internship Report
Where,
Ft =f orecast for thenext period
D t =demand period t
n=number of periodsthemoving average
Order quantity
Re-order Level
the Re-Order Level in its simplest form. For example, item ABC has a supply lead time of 7 days, with a usage of
50 per day would give a Re-Order Level of 7 days x 50 = 350 units.
Safety Stock. It is use to cover instances where supply orders are not received on time, or we would like to keep
additional stock on hand for emergency situations. The Safety Stock can be a simple calculation such as having 2
days-worth of stock on hand at all times or a more complex calculation based on short-term future demand. By
including Safety Stock the Re-Order Level would now be calculated from:
Re-Order Level = (Lead Time x Demand per Day) + Safety Stock
Page 32
Internship Report
The Re-Order Quantity does not enter into this calculation as that quantity is based on other factors such as
Holding and Ordering Costs. This parameter merely triggers an Ordering action based upon when the current
stock has reduced to the Re-Order Level.
METHODOLOGY
A
Page 33
Internship Report
Page 34
NO
Part No
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
045564.7
045566.0
039444.0
000381.5
035312.7
035313.9
009172.8
009452.3
054093.6
030774.9
Internship Report
Item name
Grind stone A
Grind stone B
Grind stone C
Bearing, Ball
Conveyor A
Conveyor B
Pressure indicator A
Pressure indicator B
Valve, Powered
V-belt
Page 2
Internship Report
The following table is shows the usage and availability spare parts in warehouse in recent month (April 2016).
Total quality on hand is recent exist amount of goods at the warehouse. Assign is shows a number of recent usage
by user. And available is the rest spare parts available in warehouse.
Table 6. Usage and Availability Re-Order Level Goods in Warehouse on April 2016
Name of Goods
GRIND STONE -- BATU-GERINDA-102X16X3,4MM -- FLEXOVIT
GRIND STONE -- BATU-GERINDA-356X25,4X3MM -- FLEXOVIT
GRIND STONE -- A36PB-180X6.4X22.23MM -- K-FLEX
BEARING,BALL,ANNULAR -- BEARING-6204.2RS -- AKG
CONVEYOR BELT FASTENER -- 1,5E-STEEL -- FLEXCO
CONVEYOR BELT FASTENER -- 1E-STEEL -- JACKSON
PRESSURE INDICATOR -- MODEL S X 500 A4D D18 -- SCHUH
PRESSURE INDICATOR -- MEX5-DF60-F19 -- BAUMER
VALVE, SOLENOID 2 WAY -- HE-8025-B-224 -- ASCO
BELT,V -- V-BELT-C-109 -- BANDO
Total of
Quantity On
Hand
2250
248
100
843
1050
750
10
12
2
48
ASSIG
N
300
0
0
6
0
0
6
0
0
6
In this research we use historical demand data from 2011 until 2014 which is have different in every years,
even there is a big different demand in some spare parts. Based on expertise, that problem is a common condition
because a decisive whether more or less demand is user. Furthermore, the demand also follow the condition of
each machine. The following table shows the usage of re-order level goods from 2011 until 2014 along with the
averages:
Page 3
AVA
Internship Report
2011
5450
1377
1850
1945
1125
350
37
17
2
6
Usage Total
2012 2013
3050 2790
976 1494
3350 500
2386 1823
600 1200
250
200
24
25
10
25
0
2
3
0
2014
3780
1515
300
2396
700
400
55
30
0
63
Averag
37
13
15
21
90
30
3
2
2
2
The pattern of demand for spare parts consists of four categories: slow moving, intermittent, erratic, and
lumpy. So, to determine the pattern we needs to calculate using of ADI and CV. This calculation use all chosen
spare parts for twelve periods. The following table show it:
Table 7. Demand Rate of Re-Order Level Goods Using ADI and CV
Demand
Per.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Total
ADI
STD
Avg.
CV
Grind
stone A
Grind
stone B
Grind
stone C
Bearing,
Ball
Conv. A
Conv.
B
0
500
320
550
449
0
0
656
518
0
543
232
3768
1.25
255.96
314.00
0.82
0
0
140
105
130
150
153
147
0
102
120
294
1341
1.00
83.35
111.75
0.75
0
150
60
140
190
150
110
160
0
120
180
240
1500
1.00
73.17
125.00
0.59
160
120
0
110
330
450
58
290
0
200
280
140
2138
1.10
137.52
178.17
0.77
0
50
90
0
66
95
140
110
135
0
0
220
906
1.25
70.00
75.50
0.93
0
0
30
40
25
15
14
18
13
0
0
145
300
1.13
39.96
25.00
1.60
Pressure
indicator
A
0
0
3
7
1
2
0
0
10
0
0
12
35
1.50
4.32
2.92
1.48
Pressure
indicator B
0
5
0
1
0
1
0
0
6
0
0
8
21
2.00
2.86
1.75
1.64
From table 7, we know that in ADI calculation, v-belt have the highest number and the lowest number are
valve and grindstone B and C. In CV calculation, valve have the highest number and grindstone C have the
lowest number. For more details, table 8 shows the value ADI and CV as well as a category for each spare parts
Operation & Supply Chain Engineering
Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember Surabaya - 2016
Page 4
0.2
0.6
Deman
Period
F, 0.2
d
314
1
0
251
2
500
301
3
320
305
4
550
354
5
449
373
6
0
298
7
0
239
8
656
322
9
518
361
10
0
289
11
543
340
12
232
318
Average
CV
0.82
0.75
0.59
0.77
0.93
1.60
1.48
1.64
3.46
1.37
F, 0.6
314
126
350
332
463
455
182
73
423
480
192
403
300
Internship Report
Category
Erratic
Erratic
Erratic
Erratic
Erratic
Erratic
Table 9. Forecast and Error for Grindstone
A Using SES Method
Lumpy
Lumpy
Erratic
Lumpy
Grind stone A
MAD,
MAD,
MSE,
MSE,
MA
e, 0.2
e, 0.6
0.2
0.6
0.2
0.6
0.
Table 8. Spare Parts Demand Pattern
-314
199
15
196
76
-298
-239
334
157
-289
203
-86
-314
150
-12
87
-6
-182
-73
233
38
-192
140
-68
314
199
15
196
76
298
239
334
157
289
203
86
201
314
150
12
87
6
182
73
233
38
192
140
68
125
98596
39617
232
38489
5799
88972
56942
111489
24561
83535
41282
7440
49746
98596
22428
146
7597
31
33056
5289
54433
1453
36845
19718
4656
23687
From table 8 we know that grind stone, bearing, conveyor fastener and valve are erratic, while pressure indicator
and v-belt are lumpy.
Table 9 menunjukkan hasil peramalan permintaan item Grindstone A dengan menggunakan metode single
exponential smoothing. Dengan menggunakan data permintaan masa dan alpha 0.2 didapatkan hsail peramalan
untuk 12 periode selanjutnya. Nilai rata-rata error yang didapatkan dengan menggunakan metode SES adalah
21% hasil ini lebih kecil dibandingkan dengan menggunakan metode Crostons yaitu sebesar 32,87% yang
ditunjukkan pada Tabel 10. Tingkat error dengan menggunakan SBA method lebih besar dibandingkan dengan
Crostons. Tingkat error pada metode SBA yaitu sebesar 33,39% yang ditunjukkan pada Tabel 11. Untuk
perhitungan peramalan permintaan dan error untuk 9 item sparepart lainnya dapat dilihat pada Apendix 1.
Table 10. Forecast and Error for Grindstone A Using Crostons Method
Period
(t)
Demand
(Xt)
Gt
Zt ()
0.2
0
0
Pt
Ft
e, 0.2
MAD,
0.2
MSE,
0.2
MAPE,
0.2
0.00
Page 5
0
40
5
36
17
0
0
51
30
0
37
37
2
500
320
550
449
0
0
656
518
0
543
232
1
1
1
1
2
3
1
1
2
1
1
100.00
144.00
225.20
269.96
215.97
172.77
269.42
319.14
255.31
312.85
296.68
Average
0.20
0.36
0.49
0.59
0.87
1.30
1.24
1.19
1.35
1.28
1.23
0
500
400
461
457
248
133
218
268
189
244
500
-180
150
-12
-457
-248
523
300
-268
354
-12
500
180
150
12
457
248
523
300
268
354
12
54.18
250.41
Internship Report
250000
32400
22500
156
209077
61295
273400
90255
71845
125481
145
94712.8
6
Page 6
100
56
27
3
0
0
80
58
0
65
5
32.87
Internship Report
Table 11. Forecast and Error for Grindstone A Using SBA Method
Period
(t)
Demand
(Xt)
Gt
1
2
3
4
5
6
0
500
320
550
449
0
0
1
1
1
1
2
656
518
543
232
7
8
9
10
11
12
Zt ()
0.2
0
0
100
144
225.2
269.96
215.968
172.774
4
269.419
5
319.135
6
255.308
5
312.846
8
296.677
4
Pt
Zt/Pt
Ft
e, 0.2
MAD,
0.2
MSE,
0.2
MAPE,
0.2
0.00
0.20
0.36
0.49
0.59
0.87
0
500
400
461
457
248
0
0
450
360
415
412
0
500
-130
190
34
-412
0
500
130
190
34
412
0
250000
16900
36100
1134
169352
0
100
41
35
7
0
1.30
133
223
-223
223
49649
1.24
218
120
536
536
287499
82
1.19
268
196
322
322
103802
62
1.35
189
241
-241
241
58195
1.28
244
170
373
373
139211
69
1.23
242
220
12
12
80.16
247.76
153
92666.2
0
Average
33.39
Analysis
Analisis untuk hasil yang telah didapatkan adalah sebaga berikut. Figure 1, 2, dan 3 menunjukkan grafik
peramalan permintaan sparepart Grind stone A dengan menggunakan metode SES, Crostons, dan SBA dengan
menggunakan nilai alpha sebesar 0.2. Semakin kecil nilai alpha yang digunakan , maka kana semakin baik. Hal
ini dikarenakan akan menghasilkan hasil peramalan yang tidak berbeda jauh dengan data masa lalu.
Grind stone A
800
600
400
Amount
200
0
Demand
Ft (0.2)
Ft (0.6)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Period
Page 7
Internship Report
Grind stone A
800
600
Demand
400
Amount
200
Ft
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Period
Grind stone A
800
600
Amount
Demand
400
Ft
200
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112
Period
Figure 4 menunjukkan hasil MAPE untuk 10 item spare part yang digunakan pada penelitian ini. Nilai MAPE
terbesar yaitu pada sparepart pressure indicator A sebesar 57,37% dengan menggunakan metode Crostons,
sedangkan nilai MAPE terkecil yaitu pada sparepart batu gerinda B sebesar 0.33% dengan menggunakan metode
SBA. Rata-rata nilai error terkecil yaitu dengan menggunakan metode SES sebesar 23,24%, selanjutnya dengan
metode SBA sebesar 26,25% dan metode Crostons sebesar 36,72%.
Batu gerinda B
Batu gerinda C
Valve, Powered
Conveyor A
Bearing, Ball
Conveyor B
Pressure indicator B
30.00
Pressure indicator A
V-belt
20.00
Batu gerinda A
60.00
50.00
40.00
10.00
0.00
SES
CR
SBA
Page 8
Internship Report
Conclusions
Page 9
Internship Report
Page 10