Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Paper
Series
Selected
Research
Papers
on
Social
Banking
and
Social
Finance
No.
9
Institute for Social Banking | ISB Paper Series, No. 8, October 2011 | www.social-banking.org
Institute
for
Social
Banking
|
ISB
Paper
Series,
No.
8,
October
2011
|
www.social-banking.org
Abstract
This
paper
critically
reviews
the
body
of
knowledge
regarding
the
question:
What
competences
enable
social
bankers
to
excellently
perform
their
job?
First,
a
look
into
literature
of
vocational
pedagogy
and
Human
Resource
Development
sharpens
the
understanding
of
what
can
be
understood
by
the
term
competence.
Subsequently,
equipped
with
a
constructivistic
method,
the
author
analyses
existing
definitions
of
specific
competences
of
social
bankers.
These
focus
much
on
values
and
personal
competences
of
social
bankers.
Social
banks
multidimensional
core
business
and
values
can
lead
to
dilemma
situations.
To
cope
with
these
situations,
dilemma
competence
is
proposed
to
be
included
in
the
competence
definitions
of
social
bankers
on
the
performance
level.
Based
on
literature
of
sustainability
management,
the
author
develops
a
concrete
decision
making
process
to
deal
with
dilemmas
in
the
field
of
social
banking.
Institute
for
Social
Banking
|
ISB
Paper
Series,
No.
8,
October
2011
|
www.social-banking.org
Katharina Beck
Kyffhuserstrae 14
50674 Kln
Germany
katharina.beck@kathabeck.de
0049 176 23 17 57 79
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
!"#$%&'$(
This assignment critically reviews the body of knowledge regarding the question: What
competences enable social bankers to excellently perform their job? First, a look into literature of
vocational pedagogy and Human Resource Development sharpens the understanding of what
can be understood by the term competence. Subsequently, equipped with a constructivistic
method, the author analyses existing definitions of specific competences of social bankers. These
focus much on values and personal competences of social bankers. Social banks multidimensional core business and values can lead to dilemma situations. To cope with these
situations, dilemma competence is proposed to be included in the competence definitions of
social bankers on the performance level. Based on literature of sustainability management, the
author develops a concrete decision making process to deal with dilemmas in the field of social
banking.
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
!
"#$%&!'(!)'*+&*+,!
Image index.................................................................................................................................................... 2!
1! Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 3!
1.1! Topic................................................................................................................................................. 3!
1.2! Sources and Methodology ............................................................................................................. 4!
1.3! Ethical and other considerations.................................................................................................. 5!
2! Competences........................................................................................................................................... 5!
2.1! Competences in the fields of vocational training and HRD .................................................... 5!
2.2! Constructing a competence definition......................................................................................... 7!
2.3! Intermediary result.......................................................................................................................... 9!
3! Specific competences of social bankers.............................................................................................. 9!
3.1! The context: social banks .............................................................................................................. 9!
3.2! Critical review of existing competence definitions of social bankers ...............................10!
3.2.1! Specific competences: Focus on values .............................................................................11!
3.2.2! Holistic view...........................................................................................................................12!
3.2.3! Focus on individual responsibility ......................................................................................14!
3.3! Dilemma competence ..................................................................................................................14!
3.3.1! Two cases of dilemmas in social banking ..........................................................................15!
3.3.2! The challenge to decide on equally important values ......................................................15!
3.3.3! Proposal for a decision making process in dilemma situations......................................16!
4! Conclusion and outlook ......................................................................................................................17!
5! Bibliography ..........................................................................................................................................18!
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
-.#/&!0*1&2!
Picture 1: Competence cluster by Sloane et al (2004). ............................................................................ 6!
Picture 2: Competence dimensions in a reference model by Schlmer (2009)................................... 7!
Picture 3: Competence dimensions and forms of learning by Arnold & Gonon (2006: 97)............ 7!
Picture 4: The boundary approach of constructing a competence definition by Stoof et al (2002:
353) ........................................................................................................................................................ 8!
Picture 5: "The perfect social banker" (Verhagen 2010) ......................................................................12!
Picture 6: A perfect social banker, designed by co-workers of GLS Bank, Germany .....................13!
Picture 7: Dimensions of existing competence definitions of social bankers. ..................................14!
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
3 -*+4'15)+0'*!
1.1
Topic
Every organisation depends on the individuals who constitute the organisation. The co-workers
knowledge, skills and values essentially contribute to the success of an organisation. This paper
reviews the existing body of knowledge on what makes persons who work in social banks
competent and successful social bankers.
From a macro-economic viewpoint, banks as intermediaries between borrowers and lenders
enable the functioning of the real economy by the efficient allocation of resources. From a
micro-economic viewpoint, private banks, being businesses, work with the business objective to
maximise their profits. Co-workers of a bank, just like in any other organisation, contribute to
achieving the goal of their organisation, which in business is to maximise profits. Overall
commercial competences enable them to do so.
Social banks business objectives explicitly lie not in maximising profits (Scheire and Martelaere
2009). Their goals focus on their role as servants to and enablers of the real economy. They make
use of their unique role as allocators of money with the aim to further the common good
(Institute for Social Banking 2011). Social banks (also called ethical, values-based, green,
sustainable or mission-driven banks) do not have one measurable goal (more profit), but
base their activities on the triple bottom line of people, planet and profit. Social bankers, like coworkers in general, need to contribute to achieving the goals of their organisation. As the goals of
social banks are different from conventional (banking) business, social bankers are assumed to
need specific competences to perform their job properly, in addition to their banking and
financial know-how (Cabarrubia 2010; Khn 2005).
What are the (specific) competences of a social banker?
I work at the Institute for Social Banking (ISB), an organisation whose mission is to inspire and
train persons for social banking. We conduct seminars, workshops, lectures, trainings and a
summer school on social banking. To generate more knowledge from practice and to reflect on
this practice, we have also developed the MA Social Banking and Social Finance. As a basis for
the design of our offers we have taken and developed several assumptions and views on social
banking specific competences. Most of these are based on practical experiences of closely
related persons to social banking and finance, including the founder of the institute and the co3
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
workers of the ISB (including myself). However, since the foundation of the institute there hasnt
been a review on what others and we at the ISB understand as competencies for social bankers.
So, with this paper I intend to reflect on and further develop my / our own understanding of
competences of social bankers.
The relevance of the question is closely connected to practice: social banks are growing quickly in
terms of balance sheet and number of co-workers. The need for training on social banking
specific competences increases as many new co-workers come from conventional banks who
need to learn about social banking to ensure that they are able to contribute to the multidimensional goals of their values-based company (Cabarrubia 2009).
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
6 7'.8&+&*)&,!
Competence is a term used in many ways in every-day and professional life usually without
reflecting on how we use it. It is important to detect individual views and underlying assumptions
on the term competence (Stoof et al 2002). Imagine a competent teacher, a competent banker or
a competent sailor. To me, competence in all three cases means to be able to excellently
perform a job. The specific competences themselves though differ depending on the job
situation. Competence can also refer to a status or an allowance, e.g. to have an externally
attributed competence to decide something.
1st
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
Within the last two decades, competences have become an integral and central part of the general
language in vocational education. They have often been integrated in the development of
trainings and other HRD activities. Lists, schemes and dimensions of competences and,
connected to these, certificates for competences, have become very popular.
That competence means an ability to perform well in a job is a tacit agreement in literature.
However, beyond this understanding, there is no clear definition of competence. Boundaries of
its meaning blur when comparing it with other terms like expertise, qualification or capabilities.
Arnold and Gonon (2006: 96-98), for example, see an increasing overlap between the terms
competence and qualification within the last 20 years. Earlier, competence had been associated
rather with subjective complex abilities of the individual, qualification as the ability to conduct a
task in a satisfying way. Today, in Arnold and Gonons view, the term competence is used for
both: individual personal competences and task-specific competences. These then lead a person
to excellently perform her3 job.
Competence definitions today have an overarching character. A common view is to see them as a
combination of knowledge, skills and values/attitude (e.g. Perry 1995 in Stoof et al 2002: 347).
Another possibility to conceptualise competence is by dimensions. These often include jobspecific/functional/professional, methodological, communicational, social and/or selfmanagement competences4 (Figures 1-3 show different models and ways to present dimensions
of competence). These dimensions serve as a basis to then list specific competences inside each
dimension.
I use the female pronoun only, the male pronoun should be read as implicit.
Many other names for dimensions can be found, e.g. language comptence, ethical competence,
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
Picture 3: Competence dimensions and forms of learning by Arnold & Gonon (2006: 97).
Available schemes, lists and tables to define competences are so manifold that some already
speak of an inflationary use of competence dimensions (Sloane et al 2003: 163). Arnold (in
Huisinga & Lisop 1999: 94) questions the strengths of the term competence for vocational
pedagogy and is interested if competence is only a nice metaphore (Wrmemetapher) or really
an analytical category.
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
Constructivism can help here (de Haan & Rlcker 2009; Stoof et al 2002; Kraker et al 2007).
From a constructivistic perspective, it is not the final goal to find the one and only true
definition of a term, but that the definition should be viable5 and adequate for the context in
which it is being used (Stoof at al 2002: 347). In addition to the general advantage of this
pragmatic approach not to get stuck in discussions on the wording of definitions, the goal of
practical viability goes hand in hand with the practitioner relevance that this paper aims to have.
Stoof et al (2002) propose a methodology to construct ones own competence definition, and in
my opinion, it can serve to sharpen ones eyes on existing competence definitions as well.
Therefore, parts of their approach can help to better analyse the body of knowledge on the
competences of social bankers (see chapter 3.2).
At first, Stoof at al (2002) propose to analyse the situation: Who are the persons who design the
definition (people), what is the definition going to be used for (goal) and what are the
characteristics of the organisation in which the definition is going to be used in (context).
After this, they introduce the boundary approach of competence (see figure 4), a method to be
flexible about the boundaries of ones competence definition.
Picture 4: The boundary approach of constructing a competence definition by Stoof et al (2002: 353)
The term viability is taken from von Glaserfeld (1995) in Stoof et al (2002: 347).
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
9 :8&)0(0)!)'.8&+&*)&,!'(!,')0#%!$#*;&4,!
3.1 The context: social banks
Before we apply our sharpened competence lens on the existing definitions of specific
competences of social bankers, we need to remind ourselves of the specific job-environment in
9
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
which social bankers work: social banks. In Europe, in nearly every country there is a social bank6
or socially oriented financial service provider7. Even though each of these banks has their own
unique mission and history, there are several common denominators of social banks.
They are values-driven (De Clerck 2009) organisations with the aim to further the common
good (Institute for Social Banking 2011). The motivation to support participatory, ecological,
social or cultural projects in society drives them. Already the slogans of these banks imply their
mission-driven self-perception: Todays bank for a better tomorrow (Alternative Bank
Switzerland), The highest interest is for all (Banca Etica, Italy) or A different bank for people
who want a different world (Charity Bank, UK).
As businesses, social banks need to generate income, but maximising profits is not the goal of a
social bank (Scheire & Martelaere 2009). Their explicit focus is on the impact they have on the
real economy (what is financed). With positive and negative criteria they select projects and
investments in the social and ecological domains. Most social banks transparently publish where
they invest their customers money. This goes along with their value to be in an open dialogue
with all their stakeholders.
Social banks are committed to the triple bottom line of people, planet, profit (GABV 2011)
and clearly connected to the concept of sustainable development or sustainability8, with its typical
three pillars: the social-cultural, ecological and economical dimension. The core business of social
banks therefore is multi-dimensional, pursuing multiple goals.
What competences does it take to work in a bank committed to sustainability? What do the
existing definitions of competences of social bankers say?
10
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
Some individual co-workers of social banks, HR departments of social banks and the Institute for
Social Banking have to my knowledge so far developed explicit views on the specific
competences of social bankers (Cabarrubia 2009; Verhagen 2010; Khn 2006; Institute for Social
Banking 2007; Beck 2010; Kufer and Beck 2011). The goals of these definitions were connected
to create learning environments for co-workers of social banks, e.g. with the aim to develop the
human capabilities to deliver sustainable banking (GABV 2011a). The definitions have been
used in different contexts. First, within the social banks themselves, second, within the trainings
and offers of the Institute for Social Banking, for example.
Ability to listen and an interest for the customers and for the world
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
As well Francisco Cabarrubia (2009), head of the Zurich branch of Alternative Bank Switzerland
(ABS), says that a values-based bank needs co-workers who
Have an intrinsic motivation (personal values and goals)
Are values-based / can identify with the organisational culture (social-ecological goals
before profit)
Have a conscious behaviour and reflection of values
Do not only pursue monetary goals.
12
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
Amongst others, ABS demands of its co-workers a strong ecological interest. In practice, this
might include that a person is expected to set value on a low carbon mobility also in personal life
(Cabarrubia 2009: 13-15).
In my own trainings with co-workers of a social bank, I ask participants to design their own
perfect social banker and/or to list the competences a social banker should have (see picture
6).
The results are similar. A social banker e.g. eats organically, wears organic cloths, reflects on
the meaning of money, has a vision of a better world. I sometimes call social bankers super
bankers (Beck 2011) who combine the technical banking know-how with a save the world
ambition, knowledge on eco-social topics and great abstraction competences.
Using the five dimensions of the inside-out approach of Stoof et al, the existing definitions of
competences of social bankers have the following characteristics (see picture 7):
1. Very personal (vs. task-specific)
2. The whole group / team needs to have the competence (vs. a single individual)
3. It is a universal competence within the entire domain or profession (vs. for a specific
function)
4. The competence has to be present on different levels (vs. being one stage in the course of a
development)
13
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
5. If these competences are teachable has not been topic of most of these definitions. Most
scholars assume that formally teaching values is hardly possible (Stoof et al 2002).
However, the training offers of the Institute for Social Banking try to do exactly this.
14
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
10
15
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
I have developed this process based on reflections on various conversations I had with social bankers and on
Ehnert et al (2009), Mller-Christ (2009).
11
16
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
< 7'*)%5,0'*!#*1!'5+%'';!
My research question was to find out what makes a social banker able to excellently perform her
job. Reviewing definitions of competences of social bankers, a social banker needs to have
technical banking skills and ethical/values competences. The specific competences (the
ethical/values competences) focus much on the whole person of a social banker. They are
assumed to be valid for the whole group of social bankers and to be universal (not task-specific).
Derived from the multiple core businesses of social banks and exemplary shown with two cases,
I have detected that a specific task of social bankers is to decide in dilemma situations. Therefore,
I have introduced a process of how to decide in cases of a dilemma, which could broaden the
existing competence definitions that focus on the subjective complex abilities, by a more
performance-related competence.
In my eyes, two questions remain open:
First, how can the social banking specific competences be trained? I could not deepen this
question within this paper, but to train values and subjective complex competences is regarded to
be a challenge. This is also seen in practice. According to Alexander Schwedeler, member of the
board of Triodos Bank, Germany, it is harder to train the values-part that social bankers need
for their job, than training the banking techniques to a non-banker with the right values-set
(personal conversation). Some of the methods we already use in the trainings at the Institute for
Social Banking shall inspire to sharpen an opinion and build values competence. We have often
stayed on an abstract level and not explicitly applied these to concrete performance levels,
though. My proposal for a performance-related training is to work with specific dilemma cases
and go through the process of dilemma management. Social bankers would be encouraged to
transparently reflect on a concrete decision, on the underlying assumptions and values and to get
into dialogue with each other about the multi-dimensionality of their organisations and about
each persons individual values. Another next step could be to analyse and compare the existing
values trainings that the social banks conduct in-house.
Secondly, are the social banking specific competences really applicable to all social bankers? A
general identification with the organisations values is probably relevant for all co-workers. But
when we get closer to the performance level: What about specific social banking competences for
specific departments? Those social banks that are growing quickly are developing more
specialised departments. To offer professional financial services, they today hire more specialists
than generalists as new co-workers. A more detailed look at social banking competences for
specific departments might be needed.
17
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
= >0$%0'/4#8?@!
Arnold, R., Gonon, P. (2006) Einfhrung in die Berufspdagogik.
Beck, K. (2010) Competencies for Social Banking. In: Vandemeulebrouke, V., Kufer, K., Beck, K. (2010)
Networking Social Finance http://www.social-banking.org/research/literature-articles/ [accessed
15 September 2011].
Beck, K. (2010a) Final report GABV HC study, unpublished report to the Steering Committee of the
Global Alliance for Banking on Values.
Beck, K. (2011) Meine neue Rolle als Social Banker. Wer bin ich jetzt eigentlich? Unpublished power point
presentation.
Forschungskonzept Nachhaltiges Management (2011), University of Bremen http://www.wiwi.unibremen.de/gmc/forschung/fkonzept.htm [accessed 15 September 2011].
De Clerck, F. (2009) Ethical banking, http://www.social-banking.org/research/literature-articles/ [accessed
27 September 2011].
De Haan, G., Rlcker, T. (2009) Der Konstruktivismus als Grundlage fr die Pdagogik, Berliner Beitrge zur
Pdagogik, Band 7.
Ehnert, I., Arndt, L., Mueller-Christ, G. (2006) A sustainable management framework for dilemma and boundaries
in autonomous cooperating transport logistics processes. In: International Journal of Environment and
Sustainable Management, 5 (4), 2006.
GABV (2011), About us http://www.gabv.org/AboutUs/ [accessed 04 September 2011]
GABV (2011a), Developing Human Capital http://gabv.org/AboutUs/GABVsGoal/developing-humancapital.htm [accessed 04 September 2011]
Institute for Social Banking (2007) Entwurf: GLS Kompetenz- & Aus-/Fortbildungs-Matrix unpublished
working paper.
Institute for Social Banking (2011) Our definition of Social Banking, http://www.social-banking.org/theinstitute/what-is-social-banking/ [accessed 03 August 2011].
Institute for Social Banking (2011a) MA Social Banking and Social Finance. The Course http://www.socialbanking.org/masters/the-course/ [accessed 03 August 2011].
Institute for Social Banking (2011b) Certificate in Social Banking. Course 2011/2012. Broshure at
http://www.social-banking.org/certificate/ [accessed 03 August 2011].
18
Competences of social bankers. A critical review of a body of knowledge with a proposal to integrate dilemma management.
Katharina Beck
Cabarrubia, F. (2009) Erkenntnisse und Methoden zur Ermittlung der speziellen Anforderungen an Social Banker,
unpublished research paper within the MA Social Banking and Social Finance.
Kufer, K., Beck, K. (2011) GABV Human Capital Action Track unpublished presentation.
Kraker, J. de, Lansu, A., and Dam-Mieras, R. van (2007) Competences and competence-based learning for
sustainable development. In: Kraker, J. de, Lansu, A., and Dam-Mieras, R. van (Eds.) (2007) Crossing
Boundaries. Innovative Learning for Sustainable Development in Higher Education.
Khn, J. (2006) Besondere Fhigkeiten fr fr MitarbeiterInnen in Social Banking, unpublished paper for the
Institute for Social Banking Training and Research.
Moser, H. (2003) Instrumentenkoffer fr die Praxisforschung.
Mller-Christ, G. (2008) Expertise: Widerspruchmanagement und Nachhaltigkeitsentscheidungen, SCB
Werkstattberichte Nr. 5.
Husinga, R., Lisop, I. (1999) Wirtschaftspdagogik.
Verhagen, E. (2010), Values driven human resource management, speech at the 3rd International Summer School
on Social Banking, unpublished presentation.
Sloane, P.F.E., Twardy, M., Buschfeld, D. (2004), Einfhrung in die Wirtschaftspdagogik.
Stoof, A., Martens, R. L., Van Merrinboer, J.J.G., and Bastiaens, T.J. (2002), The boundary approach of
competence: A constructivist aid for understanding and using the concept of competence. Human Resource
Development Review, 1: 345-365.
Scheire, C., de Maertelaere, S. (2009) Banking to make a difference. A preliminary research paper on the
business models of the founding member banks of the Global Alliance for Banking on Values,
http://www.social-banking.org/research/literature-articles/ [accessed 27 September 2011].
Schlmer, T. (2009) Berufliches Handeln und Kompetenzen fr Nachhaltiges Wirtschaften. Ein referenzmodell aud der
Grundlage theoretischer und empirischer Explorationen Schriften zur Berufs- und Wirtschaftspdagogik,
Band 6.
19