Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
JUNCTURES
SELECTED SPEECHES AND STATEMENTS
GPH-MILF Peace Process
20122016
GPH Panel Secretariat
Editor
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We would like to express appreciation to the different authors for permitting the publication
of their speeches, statements and/or essays included in this book.
Special thanks go out to the members of the Editorial Team for their hard work as well as
to the rest of the staff of the GPH Panel Secretariat for their assistance in collecting the
manuscripts that have been compiled in this book. We also thank the OPAPP Creatives
Team and Bangsamoro Communications Unit for the cover design and photographs.
We acknowledge the assistance of Engr. Mohajirin Ali from the MILF Panel Secretariat,
and Mr. Abdulla Cusain from the Bangsamoro Transition Commissions Communication
Team for their inputs.
Lastly, we are grateful for the financial assistance of the the Australian Department of
Foreign Affairs and TradeTechnical Assistance Facility (DFAT-TAF) in the publication of
this book.
This book is a publication of the Government Peace Negotiating Panel for Talks with the Moro Islamic
Liberation Front (GPNP-MILF) of the Office of the Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process.
Managing Editor
Associate Managing Editor
Copy Editors
Indexer
Layout Artist
Cover Artist
Front Cover Photo
Contents
List of Acronyms
xi
PART I. Speeches
Signing of the Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro
15 October 2012
Malacaan Palace, Manila
Speech of President Benigno S. Aquino III
Speech of OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles
Speech of MILF Chair Al Haj Murad Ebrahim
3
8
11
16
23
26
30
38
41
47
51
55
vii
viii
60
65
68
71
78
80
85
90
96
99
103
106
110
115
126
133
Contents
ix
137
142
145
151
153
156
159
165
169
173
179
183
192
196
202
205
210
216
218
222
Statement of GPH Panel Chief Negotiator Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer on the
Status of the Draft Bangsamoro Basic Law (21 July 2014)
224
227
228
Statement of GPH Panel Chair Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer on the Transmittal
of the Bangsamoro Basic Law to Congress (10 September 2014)
230
Statement of GPH Panel Member and NCMF Secretary Yasmin Busran-Lao on the
Transmittal of the Bangsamoro Basic Law to Congress (10 September 2014)
232
Statement of International Supporters for Peace in the Philippines (15 October 2015)
234
Let Us Not Lose Time: Open Letter to the Philippine Congress from the Government
and MILF Peace Panels (26 November 2015)
237
240
Statement of GPH Chief Negotiator Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer on the Adjournment
of Session of the 16th Congress of the Republic of the Philippines (for the Christmas
Season) (17 December 2015)
241
Statement of GPH Chief Negotiator Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer on the Adjournment
of Session of the 16th Congress of the Republic of the Philippines (to give way
to the May 2016 National and Local Elections) (3 February 2016)
242
244
Joint Statement of the GPH and MILF Peace Panels at the Special Meeting in Kuala
Lumpur (30 May 2016)
246
Index
249
List of Acronyms
AFP
AHJAG
AFP PPO
ALS
ARMM
ASEAN
BBL
BCF
BDA
BGEN
BIAF
BIFF
BIR
BLBAR
BOI
BTA
BTC
CAB
CCCH
CHED
COGs
CPC
CPP
CSOs
xi
xii
List of Acronyms
DA
Department of Agriculture
DD
Doctor of Divinity
DC
DepEd
DENR
DFAT-TAF
DILG
DND
DOF
DOH
DPWH
DSWD
DW
EDSA
EU
FAB
FASTRAC
FET
GDP
Decommissioned combatant
Department of Education
GEN General
GPH
GZO
GRP
HB
H.E.
HiPeC
HoR
ICG
ICP
ID
His Excellency
xiii
List of Acronyms
ID
Infantry Division
IDPs
IDB
IMT
INGOs
IPs
IPRA
J-BIRD
JCMP
JICA
JNC
JPSC
JPST
JVMAT
LEO
LGU
LTC/LtCol
LTGEN
MGEN
MILF
MinDA
MNLF
MOA-AD
NCMF
NDF
NEDA
NGO
NPA
NSC
OMI
xiv
OIC
List of Acronyms
OIC Officer-in-charge
OP
PAPP
OPAPP
PDAF
PDC
PhilHealth
PNP
R.A.
RPGs
SB
SJ
SLP
SMS
SONA
TESDA
TFDCC
TIN
TJRC
TOR
TPMT
UN
UNDP
UNSCR
US
USAID
VMAT
WE Act 1325
XU
Rocket-propelled grenades
Senate Bill
Society of Jesus
PART I: SPEECHES
Signing of the
Framework Agreement on the
Bangsamoro
Malacaan Palace, Manila
15 October 2012
Speech
is Excellency Dato Sri Mohammad Najib bin Tun Haji Abdul Razak,
Prime Minister of Malaysia; Madame Datin Paduka Seri Rosmah Mansor;
Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile; members of the Senate present; Speaker
Feliciano Belmonte; members of the House of Representatives; Secretary Albert
del Rosario; Secretary Ging Deles; Executive Secretary Paquito Ochoa and the
other members of the Cabinet present; Datuk Sri Anifah Haji Aman, Minister
of Foreign Affairs, Malaysia; Datuk Seri Mustapha Mohamed, Minister of
International Trade and Industry; Datuk Sri Dr. Ahmad Zahid bin Hamidi,
Minister of Defence; of course, Al Haj Murad Ebrahim, Chairman of the MILF;
Mohagher Iqbal, Chairman of the MILF Panel; Dean Leonen, Chairman of
the Philippine Negotiating Panel; His Excellency Ekmeleddin hsanolu of the
Organisation of Islamic Cooperation; Datuk Tengku Dato Ab Ghafar Tengku
Mohamed, the very able Malaysian facilitator of the GPH and MILF peace talks;
excellencies of the Diplomatic Corps; members of the Malaysian delegation;
members of the MILF and GPH panels; fellow workers in government; honored
guests; mga minamahal ko pong kababayan:
Magandang hapon po sa inyong lahat.
Today, we sign a Framework Agreement that can finally seal genuine, lasting
peace in Mindanao. In full view of the Filipino people, and witnessed even by
our friends from different parts of the world, we commit to peace: a peace that
will be sustained through democratic ideals; a peace that heals and empowers;
a peace that recognizes the many narratives of the Filipino people and weaves
them into a single, national aspiration for equitable progress.
We understand all too well the cycle of suffering that our people have had to
go through for the past two generations. We have seen children torn from their
homes, and communities, driven away from the land they have tilled. We have
seen lives lost and justice sought, but because of the systems failure to provide
avenues for understanding and effective redress of grievances, many resorted to
the path of vengeance and violence.
Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak (top center left) and President Aquino, along with Malaysian
Facilitator Tengku Ghafar (bottom center), MILF Chair Murad (third from left), and Office of the
Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process (OPAPP) Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles (third from right)
applaud as MILF Peace Panel Chair Mohagher Iqbal and GPH Peace Panel Chair Dean Marvic
Leonen shake hands at the signing of the FAB. (Photo by OPAPP)
remained an astute statesman who realized that progress lay in building consensus
among the many stakeholders in the region. He led not with dogmatism or
hardened ideology, but with a flexibility and open mindedness borne of trust.
We all owe him our collective thanks.
I also thank the governors of the ARMM provinces for their support of
this agreement, and thank them in advance for the hard work they will certainly
exert so that todays signing leads to positive changes in their provinces. To
ARMM Governor Mujiv Hataman, and Governors Jum Akbar of Basilan,
Mamintal Adiong Jr. of Lanao del Sur, Toto Mangudadatu of Maguindanao,
Abdusakur Tan of Sulu, and Sadikul Sahali of Tawi-Tawi: With your support,
it is now only a matter of time before your region truly fulfills its promise. May
I also acknowledge the presence today of the following other governors of areas
beyond the ARMM but are adjacent to it. Starting with Governor Emmylou
Mendoza, Governor Migs Dominguez, Governor Plaza, Governor Dolfo del
Rosario, Governor Dimaporo. Their presence today tells me that they will help
our ARMM governors work even harder to obtain their goals.
Let me now echo both panels challenge to the people: Much work remains
to be done in order to fully reap the fruits of this Framework Agreement. We
have commitments to fulfill, people to lead, and dreams to achieve. The details
to be laid out in the annexes, in particular, provide us with a solid opportunity
to expand the common ground whose principles we have already articulated
through the agreement. I am confident that our faith in each other, and in the
Filipino people, will not waver, and in fact will only grow even stronger in the
years to come.
But as the saying goes, the devil is in the details. We are now at the beginning
of a comprehensive agreement that will map out the detailed steps, detailed
commitments, and detailed programs that will lead to the fulfillment of our longterm goals. We are committed to enabling our partners to transform themselves
to a genuine political party that can help facilitate the regions transition towards
a truly peaceful and progressive place. This year the government has committed
8.59 billion pesos for the Transition Investment Support Plan, on top of the
12.93 billion pesos already allocated through our budget. We are committed
to giving the region its rightful share, not just now but each and every time,
confident that it will redound to the benefit of all citizens, and will not just line
the pockets of a very select few.
And to all the partners who have long sought this peace, and who have
committed to its fruition in the coming yearsour friends from the international
community, the academe, and civil societythank you from the bottom of our
hearts. The Filipino people share this victory with you.
The ceremony was also graced by senators, congressmen, members of the Cabinet, and
ambassadors. (Photo by OPAPP)
I ask the entire nation, and the entire world, to join me in imagining: a
Mindanao finally free from strife, where people achieve their fullest potential.
A child in Lamitan will be offered the same education as a child in Quezon
City; the sick of Patikul will gain access to the same healthcare as those in Pasig;
tourists visiting Boracay will also have Sulu in their itineraries; a businessman
will earn a profit whether he sets up shop in Marikina or Marawi. People will
be empowered; they will gain knowledge and marketable skills that will thrust
the economy forward. From constant displacement, there will be now a stable
employment. Children who have had to witness immeasurable suffering will
now get to witness a harvest; sons and daughters who have had to sweep bullet
casings from their yards will now get to pick fruit; families who once cowered
in fear of gunshots will now emerge from their homes to a bright new dawn of
equity, justice, and peace.
Together, we move forward with a conviction to lift each other, so that
in turn, our nation may grow and reach greater heights. We implore God, or
Allah, to continue guiding all of us, so that our dreams may turn into concrete,
tangible realities.
Thank you and good afternoon.
Speech
And somewhere in Mindanao, a girl named Salama also shares our joy today.
She was in grade school in the town of Kabuntalan, Maguindanao, when, one
day in August 2008, the first sounds of gunfire broke out as military and rebel
forces engaged in battle.
Salama tells the story of that afternoon: I was so scared that I cried. Our
teacher yelled at us, telling us to take cover, but we wanted to go home because
we were worried about our parents and siblings I was a grade three pupil then.
I had to stop my schooling because of the war.
Another story: when 13-year old Reina Marie Doria of Koronadal City
learned about our Framework Agreement, she said: I received this news with
joy, especially for us who may be the ones to experience the fruits of the peace
process.
One person in this room never gave up hope. From day one of his leadership,
he seized the peace, forged and hammered it and polished it to its sterling
radiance.
His mother, our beloved President Corazon C. Aquino, was known
throughout the world as an icon of democracy.
President Benigno Simeon Aquino III, from this day forward, shall be
known as the president who made the Bangsamoro possible.
Thank you, Mr. President, for being the moral compass of the Mindanao
peace process, for guiding us through the negotiations, and for keeping our
minds firm and our hearts, buoyant.
Today, a child will grow up in our generation embracing the identity of
the Bangsamoro and grow up with pride in a political, cultural, and geographic
identity respected in the four corners of the world.
We see the beginnings of a once-rended family that has finally come together
as onediverse in beliefs, passionate always, and perhaps, arguing all the time,
but still a family resolved to face the future and all its challenges, together.
And to those who have died without seeing the sunlight of peacethose
felled by bullets, and those cut down by hunger because of the ravages of warwe
bow our heads in offering you this day.
I have been an advocate of peace almost my entire life, but this is the first
time that I have seen such broad and overwhelming support as we are now
seeing for the agreement that we are about to sign today.
My gratitude goes to the courageous work of our civil society partners who
coaxed and prodded and pushed us forward.
The same is true for our partners in the international community, who
brought enduring aid and camaraderie from their respective organizations,
nations, and peoplesdirect to the arena of conflict.
We extol the media, including the social media, for sowing the messages of
peace that kept our peoples hopes up all over the world.
Please join me in applauding and honoring the work of the GPH and MILF
peace negotiating panels and our esteemed Malaysian facilitator, Tengku Dato
Ab Ghafar Tengku Mohamed.
10
Dato Tengku Ghafar once said that both panels were on the same page
but looking at different paragraphs. He was the editor-in-chief who aligned the
paragraphs on the page.
So many challenges await us, but the bridge of trust that spans this room
is strong enough to withstand the trials ahead, however difficult they may be.
We shall hold up that bridge with the force of our dreams and ideals, enabling
it to bring our entire society together and enrich the democratic institutions
we all hold dear
Until we all breach the firmament of hope and arrive together, finally, in the
bright realm of greatness as one people, under one Republic, sharing one destiny.
May God bless us all.
Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process Teresita Quintos Deles greets MILF Chairman Al Haj
Murad Ebrahim at the doors of Rizal Hall, moments before the signing of the Framework Agreement
on the Bangsamoro on 15 October 2012. (Photo by OPAPP)
Speech
ood afternoon.
His Excellency President Simeon Aquino III; His Excellency Prime
Minister Dato Sri Mohammad Najib bin Tun Haji Abdul Razak; Her
Excellency Datin Sri Rosmah Mansor; Ms. Kris Aquino; His Excellency,
Professor Ekmeleddin hsanolu, OIC Secretary General; excellencies of the
Foreign Diplomatic Corps; honorable members of the Presidents Cabinet;
honorable members of the Prime Ministers Cabinet; honorable members of the
Government Peace Panel; members of the MILF delegation; honored guests,
friends, brothers, sisters in Islam:
Again, good afternoon.
Assalamu Alaikum.
Your Excellencies:
I must confess that this is the first time in my life to step in the grounds of
Malacaang. Never in my wildest dreams since I was a child or when I joined
the Bangsamoro struggle more than forty years ago I did imagine that one day, I
will see the interior of this building that once housed the Spanish and American
Governors General and now, the Presidents of the Philippines. Today, I am here
not as a tourist, nor as a politician who seeks personal political favors from the
President of the Philippines, but as the humble Chairman of the Moro Islamic
Liberation Front mandated by our brothers and sisters on the ground and by
the Bangsamoro people to witness a historic agreement with the Government
of the Republic of the Philippines under the leadership of President Benigno
Simeon Aquino III that would, InshaAllah, usher in a just and enduring peace
in the Bangsamoro homeland.
It is in this context that I come in peace and to forge a partnership of
peace on the basis of the Framework Agreement between the MILF and the
Philippine Government.
Your Excellencies, almost five centuries of foreign invasions and dominations
have given birth to what we now call the Bangsamoro question. In the course of
11
12
these centuries of conflict, we have seen the loss of our traditional Moro Sultanates.
Expropriation of our sovereignty as a free Moro Nation and consequently, our
relegation into a state of captivity, that eradicated our Bangsamoro identity and
reduced our ancestral homeland into small parcels of gerrymandered territories
called provinces all of which led to the marginalization of our people within a
larger dominant Philippine society that barely took cognizance, if at all, of our
forebears and broken struggle for freedom even before the Philippine Republic
saw the light of day in 1898 and in 1946.
This unjust condition that sustained this conflict in our generation made
it inevitable for the Moro Liberation Movements to emerge. And from the
womb of the Moro Liberation Movement, would be born the Moro National
Liberation Front and consequently the Moro Islamic Liberation Front. The peace
negotiations that took place first in 1976 in Tripoli, Libya, under the auspices of
the Organization of Islamic Conference and unto 1996 in Jakarta, Indonesia,
between our brethren in the MNLF and the Philippine Government were all
geared towards addressing historical and foreign grievances of the Bangsamoro
people. But unfortunately, the negotiation came short of going further deep into
the root cause of the Moro question. Thus, the appropriate political formula
to correct the historical and current injustices committed on the Bangsamoro
people remain elusive. Political palliatives and economic cosmetics under the
rubric of counterinsurgency which were successively put in place to resolve
the Moro question prove to be failed experiments in political autonomy, the
latest of which is the ARMM, and so that conflict remain that has invariably
taken a heavy toll on the lives, properties, and livelihoods of our peopleMoro
indigenous communities and settlers in Mindanao and Sulu.
Under such dire circumstances, peace negotiations were unable to alter let
alone normalize the adversarial relationship between the Bangsamoro people and
the Philippine State, and it was this adversarial relationship that continued to
fund the armed sovereignty-based conflict in our homeland and that construct
the attainment of a just and enduring peace as requisite to normalization. It was
for this reason that the Moro Islamic Liberation Front under the leadership of
the late Chairman and Mujahideen Sheik Salamat Hashim, may Allah Subhanahu
Wa Taala accept his sacrifices, decided to engage in peaceful negotiations with
the Philippine Government in 1997. The basic principle underlying this most
important decision by the MILF leadership is that negotiated political settlement
is the most civilized and practical way to solve the Moro problem. This principle
laid down by Sheik Salamat Hashim became a consistent policy.
13
We in the MILF Central Committee did not waiver and vacillate in pursuing
it to the end despite the devastating three all-out wars in 2000, 2003, and 2008
waged by previous regimes against the MILF. This was the legacy of Sheik
Salamat Hashims leadership which I, when I took over the leadership of the
MILF after he passed away in 2003, inherited and continued to pursue with
unflinching determination and with great personal sacrifice despite tremendous
pressures from some restive quarters of our Moro populace on one hand, and
provocation by forces hostile to the Bangsamoro cause on the other, to abandon
peaceful negotiation and relentlessly take the path of war.
Today, it humbles me to say before you that we have stayed the course. Our
perseverance has prevailed over those whose obsession is to perpetuate war and
conflict in Mindanao and Sulu for self-aggrandizement. Today, after almost
sixteen years of hard negotiations, interfered with armed confrontations on
the ground, we have inked the most important document in the chapter of our
historya landmark document that restores to our people their Bangsamoro
identity and their homeland, their right to govern themselves, and the power
to forge their destiny and future with their very hands.
Today, we are here to celebrate a victory for the Bangsamoro people and the
Filipino nation that is shared by the international community and the Muslim
world, the victory earnednot by warbut by that collective desire tempered
by the inner nobility of human nature to restore justice and peace to a troubled
land. Today, we are here to put an end to the adversarial relationship between the
Bangsamoro and the Philippine nation and what makes this more significant and
quite touching on our part is that this is happening under the administration of
President Noynoy Aquino whose martyred father, Senator Ninoy Aquino, and
mother, the late President Cory Aquino fought on the same side of the fence
with us against the dictatorship that devastated our homeland and the lives of
thousands of our people.
Today, we extend the hands of friendship and partnership to the President
and the Filipino people as we jointly embark on the historic journey to rebuild
our homeland, institute justice and occupation, end the reign of violence, and
restore normalcy to the lives of the masses of our people in Mindanao and Sulu
with the Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro. We pray never to see
again refugee camps crammed with old folks, women, and children wallowing
in squalor and misery, as well as never again witness the recurring wholesale
violation of human rights that comes with oppression, all of which deface the
landscape of our Bangsamoro homeland and denigrate the lofty human values
long held by its civilized and just society.
14
Today, I would also like to announce to all that we dedicated this Framework
Agreement on the Bangsamoro to our departed leaders: the late MILF Chairman
Salamat Hashim, the late MILF Vice Chairman Ali Abdul Mimbantas, Ustadz
Abuhalilyaya, Ustadz Sainon Zaman, among others, and to all our Mujahideen
martyrs whether MILF or MNLF. They sacrifice their lives for the cause of
Allah and for the Bangsamoro. To them and to all peace loving people in this
country, this agreement shall stand as our greatest tribute.
Let me also have this opportunity to call on an appeal to our MNLF brethren
to support the Framework Agreement and take this historic journey with us to
rebuild our Bangsamoro homeland on the gains given to us by the agreement.
This is not the time for recriminations; this is the time for unity, the time for all
of us to think, act, and speak as one Bangsamoro as we summon all our strengths
to face the daunting task of home rule.
Finally, on behalf of the Bangsamoro people and the Moro Islamic Liberation
Front, may I extend our heartfelt thanks to His Excellency President Benigno
Simeon Aquino III; His Excellency Prime Minister Dato Sri Najib bin Tun
Haji Abdul Razak; His Excellency Dr. Mahathir Mohammad the former Prime
Minister in whose term of office, peace negotiations were done in Malaysia; to
His Excellency Ekmeleddin hsanolu, Secretary General of the Organisation
of Islamic Cooperation, OIC; and to the Malaysian Facilitator and Secretariat;
likewise, to all the state and non-state actors that composed the International
Contact Group (ICG), the Government of the United Kingdom, Turkey,
Saudi Arabia, Japan, and its international NGO components, Conciliation
Resources, Muhammadiyah, The Asia Foundation, Centre for Humanitarian
Dialogue, The International Monitoring Team (or the IMT) and its Civilian
Protection Component, Malaysia, Brunei, Libya, Japan, Norway, Indonesia,
and the European Union, the Non-Violent Peace Force, Mindanao Peoples
Caucus, Mindanao Human Rights Action Center, and Muslim Organization
of Government Officials and Professionals, and to all those world organizations
and countries that sent their message of support to the Framework Agreement
such as the United Nations, the European Union, United States of America,
United Kingdom, Switzerland, Australia, Indonesia, Japan, and the Organisation
of Islamic Cooperation, as well as to those individuals and those in and out of
the homeland who believed in the justness of our cause, and who bear with us
through thick and thin in our long struggle for justice and peace. We convey
our sincerest gratitude.
Thank you and May Allah Subhanahu Wa Taala may be with all of us.
Launch of the
Sajahatra Bangsamoro
11 February 2013
Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao
Talumpati
16
17
The first seeds of trust were planted as the MILF leadership and I met
face-to-face in Japan in August of 2011. We watered those seeds with patience
and fortitude and nourished them with hope: When some quarters called for
a blanket, all-out war against Moro rebels in October of 2011 after a bloody
encounter between lawless elements and the military, we responded with a
targeted pursuit of all-out justice against the bandits involved. And again wed
like to thank the MILF who are partners in seeking this all-out justice. The
peace negotiations moved forward unhindered by secrecy and manipulation, and
propelled by solidarity towards the shared goal of empowering every Filipino in
the ARMM. Others have stumbled in the past, and we were determined not to
make the same mistakes, we were determined not to succumb to indiscriminate
knee-jerk reactions borne out of anger, or to cast aside true consensus, or favor
concealment over transparency in negotiations. And so, in October of last year,
the first fruits of our hard work became enshrined in a Framework Agreement
on the Bangsamoro, which was signed by both panels and was witnessed by
Moros, civil society, and government stakeholders in Malacaang.
18
President Aquino is welcomed by MILF Chair Murad OPAPP Sec. Deles at the Bangsamoro
Leadership and Management Institute (BLMI) in Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao on 11 February
2013 for the launch of the Sajahatra Bangsamoro.
19
Pres. Aquino speaks before guests from national and local government agencies, various
civil society organizations and beneficiaries of the Sajahatra Bangsamoro Program. (Photo by
Malacaang Photo Bureau)
20
President Aquino, MILF Chair Murad, OPAPP Sec. Deles and TESDA Director General Emmanuel Joel
Villanueva award scholarship grants to beneficiaries. The Sajahatra Bangsamoroliterally peace
and prosperity upon the Bangsamorois aimed at delivering quick-gestation and high-impact
health, education and livelihood projects to Bangsamoro communities. (Photos by Malacaang
Photo Bureau)
21
agency, mga ulama, mga CSOpati na rin po ang ating security sector lahat
po ng pinaghirapan natin, mapupunta sa wala. Abot-kamay na po ang bunga ng
kapayapaang kay tagal nating inaasam-asam; ngayon pa ba tayo panghihinaan
ng loob?
22
ko ho talaga. Pag nagsasalita sila, walang nagsasabing: Ano ang akin? Parating:
Ano ang para sa amin? Parating inuunawa iyong pinakamaliit, bago yong
pinakamataas. Iniintindi yong nakakarami bago yong sarili. Eh kung ganyan po
ang mga numumuno sa atin, eh paano po tayo mapipigilan sa ating pag-asenso
at maging kaganapan na po iyong lupa ng pangako ng Mindanao ay maging
pangakong nakita na, namalasan na, at talaga namang nangyayari na?
Ako poy hindi na magpapakahaba, tulad ho nyo, tama na yung salita,
dirediretsyo na tayo sa gawa. Mayroon pa tayong natitirang three years and four
months. Dapat naman ho sanay, sabi nga kanina ni Chairman, kailangan maging
permanente ito at hindi depende sa mga taong nag-uusap ngayon. So kailangan
po nating paspasan lahat ng ginagawa natin para nga maging permanente na
ito. At pagdating ng panahon nga ho, siguro naman ho pag natapos na po yong
termino ko, baka naman may ipagkaloob na ho sa atin ang Diyos, maghohoneymoon ho tayo. Siyempre, baka maimbita ako ni Chairman at sabihin
niya dito ka muna magmeryenda at turista na tayo sa ARMM dahil ganoon na
katahimik. Dahil ako naman po ay pareho nyo. Darating ang panahon, kung
papalarin po akong may susunod ho sa akin, ay maipamana natin sa susunod na
salinlahi: hindi na karahasan, hindi na pananakot, hindi na kaba ngunit talagang
tanda na lahat ay maaatim o makukuha ng Pilipinong nakakaisa. Magagawa po
natin yan wag lang tayong bibitaw sa pagtitiwala sa isat isa.
Magandang araw po. Maraming salamat po.
Speech
It was not so long ago when we were in a similar jam-packed event to witness
a milestone in our history unfold. Apat na buwan na po ang nakakaraan mula
nang sinaksihan ng buong bansa at ng ibang panig ng mundo ang paglagda
sa Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro noong Oktubre 15, 2012 sa
Malacaang. The event, and the agreement, which we now refer to as the FAB
for brevity, promised the dawning of a beautiful morning to wake up to after
the nightmares of violent armed conflict.
Ngayon po, ako ay nagising sa umagang kay ganda. A beautiful sunny
morning full of happy anticipation to take part in yet another milestone in our
peace efforts.
Ang FAB ay isang kasunduan na nagbigay ng roadmap para sa kapayapaan
at kaunlaran sa rehiyong ito na matagal nang apektado ng digmaan. Sa loob
ng nakaraang apat na buwan, tatlong beses na pong nakabalik sa negotiating
table ang ating mga peace panels, kasama ang kani-kanilang mga eksperto na
bumubuo ng Technical Working Groups or TWGs, para sa patuloy na paguusap at pagsusulat ng mga annexes na, kasama ng FAB, ay magbubuo ng
comprehensive peace agreement.
As stated in the FAB, there are Annexes (1) on Power-Sharing, (2) on
Wealth-Sharing, (3) on Normalization, and (4) on Transitional Arrangements
and Modalities. Ang mga aneksong ito ang magdedetalye ng pagbuo o
pagtatalaga ng Bangsamoro na ipapasok sa panukalang batas na bubuuin ng
Transition Commission at isusumite para isabatas ng Kongreso bago mageleksyon sa 2016.
Tulad ng nasabi natin noong nakaraang Oktubre, marami pa ang mga
pagsubok na ating kakaharapin sa prosesong pangkapayapaan. Subalit
23
24
Like we said on
that historic day in
October 2012, so many
challenges await us, but
the bridge of trust that
we have painstakingly
built is strong enough to withstand the trials ahead, however difficult they may be.
The trust is exhibited anew in a partnership with the leadership of MILF
to immediately bring the benefits of peace to its combatants, their immediate
families and communities, and those most vulnerable to conflict, particularly
the internally displaced persons, women, and children. This partnership is what
we are launching today as the Sajahatra Bangsamoro Program.
25
Welcome Address
26
27
new set of skills necessary for the governance of our people. To the credit of the
GPH, it is certainly a bold step for government to partner not with the usual
institutions of government, but with one of its adversaries, in a remarkable
journey to peace. This building is a towering commitment of that partnership
and an edifice of our shared hope and vision for the future of our people.
It is equally an enduring symbol of the partnership between us and the
international community, notably the Japanese people, who shared with us the
vision of peace and who so kindly funded the construction of this building which
is now becoming a popular venue for workshops and trainings to capacitate
our people. Mr. President, I shall be candid with you as I have always been. We
welcome these initial dividends of peace. We welcome development. We welcome
the continuing partnership between the MILF and the GPH. Indeed, as Muslims
and revolutionaries, we dream of the dawning of peace and development for our
people. But while we indeed welcome this sincere gesture of government to make
immediate the dividends of peace to our people, we caution all not to lose sight
of the imperative and the challenges of the works aheadthat of achieving in
the soonest possible time the signing of a comprehensive compact between the
MILF and the GPH. Development is so important. Yes, it is so important that
it must stand, and stand alone, on the solid foundation of permanent peace. A
peace that is achieved by addressing the fundamental political issues that has
fuelled this conflict and consumed the energy and resources of this region and
this country. This goal, therefore, must remain the single most important task
of this partnership, for only when we achieve this can we truly be assured of
real development not only in this region but also for this country. The MILF
stands ready as your partner in this journey.
Further development can only be effective where it is people-centered.
One that is determined and undertaken by its ultimate beneficiaries. One that
empowers people and its processes, empowering. It cannot be dictated from
the center, for ownership is essential. We recognize, however, that the type
of development strategy that the President has undertaken today, where the
beneficiaries determine the kind of development, is remarkable. This, however,
must be institutionalized and should not depend on the kind of President that
sits in power. This must be institutionalized, and it can only be institutionalized
when we shall have signed a comprehensive compact that creates a new relation
between us and the central government. We recognize also that by undertaking
joint development projects with government even before a comprehensive
compact is signed, we might be putting in jeopardy some critical strategy that
has guided our struggle for a long time. We are indeed, treading on uncharted
28
and certainly dangerous path. But this revolution beyond strategy has been
guided by one single principlesincerity and trust in Allah. Allah says in the
Holy Quran, Surah Al-Anfal, verse 61: But if they incline to peace, you also
incline to it, and (put your) trust in Allah. Verily, He is the All-Hearer, the
All-Knower. Beyond the question of strategy, we have always believed in the
justness and the legitimacy of our cause. This and the enduring commitment and
dedication of our people cannot be defeated by any strategy. It is this thought
and the oft-repeated pronouncement of sincerity of the President that give us
solace in this difficult process. For, indeed, it takes more courage to wage peace
than to wage a war.
We appeal then to the international community for patience and
understanding. It is our sincere belief that we cannot jump immediately into
massive programs for development without the solid foundation of a permanent
and durable peace. We cannot mislead you and lure you into investing the
hard-earned money of your taxpayers into development without the assurance
of durable peace. The last thing we wanted to see would be development and
infrastructure laid to waste in seconds because of war. Help us achieve that peace,
and together we can move with confidence towards development.
Thank you and Wassalamu Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatoh.
DOH Sec. Enrique T. Ona (left) and Pres. Aquino distribute PhilHealth cards during the Sajahatra
launch at BLMI in Maguindanao.
Signing of the
Comprehensive Agreement on the
Bangsamoro
27 March 2014
Malacaan Palace, Manila
Speech
Talking personally with Chairman Murad, I felt that he, like me, was
prepared to come to the table not as an adversary, but as a friend who shared
a singular aspiration for peace. After all, if both parties approached the table
asking only how to win, or how to give up the least, then there could never be
a meeting of the minds. His points made it apparent that neither he nor any
30
31
32
MILF Chair Murad, Malaysian Facilitator Tengku Ghafar, Prime Minister Najib Razak, President
Aquino, and OPAPP Sec. Deles, together with the MILF and GPH Peace Panels applaud the signing
of the CAB as MILF Peace Panel Chair Iqbal and GPH Peace Panel Chair Prof. Miriam Coronel
Ferrer exchange copies of the signed document.
to permanence. And now, after all his achievements, he willingly steps aside.
That is the sort of leader we need: Focused on the other, and not on himself.
We thank everyone whose faith never faltered in this journey. To the people
of Indonesia and President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono: We truly appreciate
your solidarity. As a member of the International Monitoring Team, Indonesia,
along with Brunei, Japan, Malaysia, Norway, and previously the European
Union and Libya, was integral in creating the peaceful environment that
proved conducive to the negotiations. Our people extend their gratitude to the
members of the IMT. We also thank the International Contact Group: We
reiterate our gratitude to Japan, whose graciousness proved crucial in winning
a once elusive trust between the Philippine government and the MILF; the
United Kingdom, whose experience in resolving conflict provided a shining
example as we embarked on our own journey; other member-countries such
as Saudi Arabia and Turkey; and the NGO-members of the ICGthank you
33
The historic event was attended by senators, congressmen, members of the Cabinet, Mindanao
governors and local chief executives, officials of the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao
(ARMM) Regional Government, ambassadors, and local and international civil society leaders.
Hundreds of MILF members also witnessed the event.
34
of the Filipino people. We will never forget the support you have given, and
continue to give us.
If we sustain the momentum for peace, by 2016, the MILF will have shed
its identity as a military force and transformed itself into a political entity,
casting its stake in democracy by vying for seats in the Bangsamoro elections.
The Bangsamoro shall form a perimeter of vigilance against the spread of
extremism; it shall act as a bridge of moderation among the great faiths of the
various constituencies in ASEAN. From this shared security, we shall enhance
the era of prosperity that is dawning upon our region, and harness its energies
towards creating a regime of opportunity and inclusivity where no one is left
behind. As the Bangsamoro matures, it shall serve as the gateway to trade,
investment, and cultural exchanges within the Brunei Darussalam-IndonesiaMalaysia-Philippines East ASEAN Growth Area and its environsigniting a
virtuous cycle of security, development, and equitable progress for the peoples
of the entire region.
This is our vision for the Bangsamoroand just as the Agreement we
are signing today did not appear magically out of thin air, so too will our next
steps have to involve the same trust and long-term thinking that brought us to
this shared triumph. At this point, the Bangsamoro Transition Commission is
hard at work in drafting a Bangsamoro Basic Law that is equitable, practical,
and empowering, and which serves the interests of the entire nation. It is a law
that will have to pass my personal muster as a President pledged to do justice
35
Our mission now is to draft and pass this law so that it will be presented
to the people for ratification in a plebiscite. Our goal: to have the Bangsamoro
Transition Authority in place by 2015, when it will serve as the interim
Bangsamoro government until the elections in 2016. In this manner, the people
themselves will turn the tide of strife into an era of peace and equitable progress;
they themselves will prove that the democratic space is vast enough to address
every Filipinos grievances and concerns.
We thus call on everyone to widen the avenues for trust and positive
engagement; let us cast aside past prejudice and contribute to the atmosphere
of optimism that has, for the first time in a long while, become prevalent in
Muslim Mindanao. It should be the paramount concern of all people of goodwill
to do their part: Let us exchange our bullets for ripening fruit, our cynicism
for hope, our histories of sorrow for a future of harmony, peace, and prosperity.
We must remember that, for so long, Muslim Mindanao has been left in
the margins. The amount of attention that the national government granted
it ebbed with the electoral cycle, and this broken system was exploited by the
powerful few who lorded it over everyone else. For generations, fellow Filipinos
in the region were embroiled in a cycle of poverty, injustice, and violence. The
huge imbalance between Muslim Mindanao and the rest of the country served
to breed resentment, and consequently insurgency. When the Bangsamoro
people felt that they had no redress within the system, they then tried to address
their grievances from outside of the system. We must, therefore, give them a
significant boost up, so that they can catch up: If we are to truly address the
root causes of conflict, we must close the gap between the region and the rest
of Filipino society.
I have to state that I fully empathize with our Muslim countrymen. Like
them, my family experienced how impossible it was to achieve redress of
legitimate grievances, as we were oppressed by a dictatorial government.
What is being presented before us now is a path that can lead to a permanent
change in the status quo in Muslim Mindanao. But as with all change, its
36
success depends on our continuous vigilance. We must admit that there are
those who will champion the status quo to preserve themselves in positions of
power and wealth. Maintaining this requires holding back the majority, for any
sign of individual or collective advancement is a threat. Maintaining fear and
insecurity allows them to prey on the entrepreneur whose success is rewarded by
kidnapping; the farmer who improved the rough land only to have it grabbed;
the student whose very promising future is cut short by a bomb; the pensioner
who, seeking security, falls prey to the unscrupulous pyramid scammer; or those
mired in desperate times and desperate situations who fall victim to false prophets
from either side. These people ask, and have been asking, the legitimate question:
What did we do to deserve this? The simple answer is: You dont; no one does.
My father taught me: If you tolerate the abuse of the rights of one, it sets the
stage for the abuse of your own rights. The only correct action then is to stand
up for your brother whose rights have been abused; otherwise, we will only be
condemning ourselves to suffer the same fate.
The majority who deserve an opportunity to improve their lot in life, who
stand to benefit from the onset of peace, stand at the crossroads with us: On one
hand, will we be held back by an untenable status quo? Or, together, will we as
an entire nation rise and prosper? To those who will not join us, I ask: Are you
really that confident that we will have another singular opportunity like the one
we have today? Do you really think that the confluence of factors such that exists
today will happen againwhen the Filipino people and their government are
committed to redressing a historic injustice; where the international community
has thrown its full support behind the achievement of peace; and when we have
already fixed an electoral system that was designed to subvert the sovereign will
of the people?
May this also stand as a warning to those who wish to derail our path to a
final, lasting peacethose who wish to sow divisiveness for self-interest, and
those who continue to wield arms to pursue their own agendas: So many people
have suffered for so long; so many of our stakeholders have worked so hard to
arrive at this point. I will not let peace be snatched from my people again. Not
now, when we have already undertaken the most difficult and most significant
steps to achieve it. Those who want to test the resolve of the State will be met
37
I have always said that being President is not the easiest of jobs; the fight to
change the status quo is even more daunting. I do not want to just take my turn
on a merry-go-round that goes nowhere but round and roundto perpetuate
or even exacerbate existing problems. I would rather ride the horse that actually
leads to a definite destination. And in this journey, there will always be obstacles
to national transformation, just as there will always be those who seek to disrupt
any sort of momentum that we have gained. At times it seems as if the selfish
few can fatally hamper the future of so many. There are, however, days like this:
days when our collective philosophy of sincere consensus-building yields the
most enduring of results; days when we can stand witness to the hard work
of our people; days when we can be filled with hope despite all the challenges
that remain. There are days when we can find time to reflect on what we have
achieved in less than four years: in this case, the end to decades of conflict, and
the beginning of development and prosperity for the Bangsamoro. Today, we
have proven that not only can our people dream again; but, in fact, we are now
beginning to achieve our dreams.
We have exhibited tremendous trust and commitment, which has gotten us
this far. Today, let us commit to being more energetic advocates of this rightful
path.
In the coming months and years, let us exert even greater effort into making
the path of peace more inclusive, inviting more to join this advocacy and to
contribute to the peaceful and progressive future that we are envisioning.
Welcome Remarks
38
39
One night in August of 2008, amidst the distant clap of cannons and gunfire,
Ibrahim woke up to the sight of hundreds of children of all shapes and sizes,
in front of his house.
The children were apparently told by their parents to flee their homes for
safetyby themselves, without food, with only the clothes they wore on their
frail bodies.
In ragtag fashion and with the bravado of hardy sons and daughters of war,
they crossed the Libungan river in bancas to safer sanctuary, and landed, luckily,
at Ibrahims front door.
Ibrahim called out to others in the community. They took in the young ones
in different homes, fed them, and sheltered them in the madrasah.
In a state of confusion, the child refugees or bakwits would cry themselves
to sleep and wake up not knowing where their parents were. It was weeks later
that their parents came for them and brought them back home, when the guns
were silent for a while.
Ibrahim would later lend his 10-hectare ancestral land to these childrens
families, whose areas of residence kept changing, depending on where and when
it was safedepending on when and where the bombs fell or the guns roared.
Today those families are sheltered in Ibrahims ancestral land and are being
served by the governments shelter assistance program.
And on this day itself, as they hear the words said in this historic ceremony,
they are finally invested with hope in a permanent peace, the hope that their
children will finally have the chance not only to survive, but to live and to thrive
in an enduring community.
We stand here today to declare that, henceforth, no family shall be forced
to drive their children away for fear of their being maimed and wounded by
conflict, and that no child has ever again to cross a raging river and knock on a
strangers door to beg for protection.
Outside these gates, parents, students, and children are in Luneta flying kites
for peace, while our allies from many noble persuasions are in Mendiola and
Quiapo in solidarity with us. In various areas in Mindanao, people have turned
major roads green with waving peace flags and will be holding peace-tahan
events to celebrate todays momentous occasion.
The signal and prayers are so strong and unrelentingno more war, no more
children scampering for safety, no more evacuees, no more lost school days or
school months, no more injustice, no more misgovernance, no more poverty, no
more fear and no more want.
40
Speech
41
42
our forty years in bygone eras and to leave the present in an age of lasting peace,
justice and prosperity.
Seventeen months ago we were also assembled in these revered halls of
Malacaang Palace to witness the signing of the Framework Agreement on the
Bangsamoro. In the midst of natural disasters and political turmoil, we have risen
above the challenges and braved the elements of adversity as we completed the
four indispensable Annexes and the Addendum to the Framework Agreement
on the Bangsamoro.
Now we have come full circle as we are again gathered here today to witness
the signing of the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro. We in the
MILF and our counterparts in the GPH have pushed the ends of reason in
coming to this point of forging a negotiated political agreement that not only
promises but guarantees mutual recognition, respect and restoration of the
legitimate rights of the people in the Bangsamoro.
With the signing of the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro the
legitimate aspiration of the Bangsamoro and the commitment of the government
of the Philippines to recognize and address those aspirations are now sealed
and witnessed by all peace-loving peoples of this nation and the whole world.
43
past. The MILF recognizes as a milestone the 1996 GRP-MNLF Final Peace
Agreement, but its inherent flaws, weaknesses, and fate for the last eighteen
years must not hinder the MILF from securing for the Bangsamoro a far better
negotiated political settlement of the Bangsamoro Question.
I would like to impress upon all of you that the MILF does not and will never
claim sole ownership of the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro.
The MILF recognizes the unalterable reality that the valiant efforts and
sacrifices of countless people for freedom and self-determination of the entire
Bangsamoro contributed in no small way towards the achievement of this
agreement.
The only interest of the MILF is the emplacement of the system as agreed
upon by the parties. Upon the establishment of the new Bangsamoro political
entity, the role of the MILF may be likened to a gatekeeper for the duration
of the transition period where after such period, the keys to the gate will be
willingly handed over to the democratic will of the Bangsamoro. To be overly
emphatic, it will not be a government of the MILF, but the government of the
Bangsamoro.
44
Please allow me to pay tribute to the departed leaders of the MILF whose
teachings and valor shall live within our hearts, namely, the late MILF Chairman
Salamat Hashim, the late MILF Vice-Chairman Abdulaziz Mimbantas, Ustadz
Abuhalil Yahya, Ustadz Ali Abdul Aziz, Ustadz Abdul Jamil, Ustadz Sainon
Zaman; the so called big 5, Commanders Tops Julhani Diego Silang, Adan
Abdullah, Tony Falcon, Mohammad James Bond, Yahya Luksadatu; and many
others and to all our Mujahideen martyrs whether MILF or MNLF.
The determination and resolve of these great leaders have catapulted us to
where we are today. To my fellow Mujahideen and the Bangsamoro people: Our
journey towards peace has borne us this agreement.
Our urgent call for support include our brothers and sisters, Mujahideen and
revolutionaries in the other liberation organizations. The support we ask of you is
not merely in keeping your optimism in the whole process but more significantly
in lending your hands and participation in the realization of the objective of the
process. Let us all stand as willing witnesses to the end of atrocities and uprising
to the Bangsamoro homeland and see to it that it remains that way.
In parting, I commend the tireless and consistent efforts of all those
instrumental in forging this agreement particularly H.E. President Benigno
Simeon Aquino, H.E. Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak, H.E. Dr. Mahatir
Mohamad under whose term in office as Prime Minister the peace negotiation
were started and done in Malaysia; the Malaysian facilitator Tengku Dato Abdul
Ghafar bin Tengku Mohamed and the able secretariat.
45
The MILF extends its heartfelt thanks also to all the state and non-state actors
that comprise the International Contact Group (namely the Governments of the
United Kingdom, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, and Japan) and its international NGO
components Conciliation Resources, Muhammadiyah, Centre for Humanitarian
Dialogue, and Community of SantEgidio as well as former member (The Asia
Foundation); the International Monitoring Team continuously led by Malaysia
since 2001 and joined by Brunei, Libya, Japan, Norway, Indonesia, and the
European Union and its Civilian Protection Components (the Nonviolent Peace
Force, Mindanao Peoples Caucus, Mindanao Human Rights Action Center,
and the Muslim Organization of Government Officials and Professionals);
and to the numerous world organizations and countries that have signified a
strong support to the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro such
as the United Nations, European Union, United States of America, United
Kingdom, Switzerland, Australia, Indonesia, Japan, and the Organisation of
Islamic Cooperation.
Finally, to the GPH-MILF peace panels: GPH panel chair Professor
Miriam Ferrer, previous chairperson Secretary Jesus Dureza, Secretary Silvestre
Afable, Secretary Rodolfo Garcia, Ambassador Rafael Seguis, Associate Justice
Marvic Leonen and others; Brother Ghazali Jaafar and the late Ali Abdul
Mimbantas who both served as the chairman of the MILF peace panel, and
brother Mohagher Iqbal whose extent as chair of MILF peace panel this
Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro has been signed. I also pay
tribute to the invaluable contribution of Lanang Ali, Datu Michael Mastura,
Robert Maulana Alonto, Abdulla Camlian, Datu Kinoc, and all those who serve
in the MILF peace panel and its various structures both currently and those
who served earlier.
Above all, thank you for the guidance of those people who stood and
continuously stand by in our journey towards just and lasting peace. Before I
end this message, allow me to extend my heartfelt and profound expression of
sorrow and condolence to the families of the victims of the missing Malaysian
Airlines flight 370 bound for Beijing from the Malaysian capital of Kuala
Lumpur last March 8. It was already officially reported that the fated plane
had crashed into the remote part of the Indian Ocean. I salute the Malaysian
government headed by H.E. Datu Najib Razak for the superb handling of the
tragic incident which claimed the lives of 239 passengers and crew. Thank you
very much. May Allah Subhanahu Wa Taala always bless us all. Allahu Akbar,
Allahu Akbar, Allahu Akbar.
Speech
Ang proseso tungo sa kapayapaan ay para sa lahat ng Pilipino. Samasama tayong lahat sa pagsulong, pagbantay, at pagkalinga sa tunay at ganap
na kapayapaan, dahil sama-sama rin tayong makikinabang sa kaunlaran na
kaakibat nito.
We all know that we cannot simply talk peace forever. We need to build the
structures for it and prepare the communities for the transition from conflict to
peace, while bringing down the barriers that have kept it away. With the signing
of the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro last March, all of these
components are not only possible, but very much within our reach.
Thus, the inclusive nature of and approach to the peace process in Mindanao
and across other peace tables is your theme personified. And I thank the
European Union, the Italian Government, and the Spanish Cooperation for
supporting this historic Conference on Interreligious and Intercultural Dialogue
for Peace.
Should I start with some updates? First, let me allay some fears and slay a few
rumors about the so-called delay in the submission of the proposed Bangsamoro
Basic Law (BBL) to Congress. Our political road map is firmly in place and
we are fully confident that we are installing a process which will ensure, within
an acceptable and doable time frame, that the BBL which will be enacted by
Congress will live up to peoples expectations as a measure worthy of broad-based
47
48
support, and one that is faithful to our Constitution. In this regard, all parties
concerned are striving to meet the standards set by the President at the historic
signing of the CAB for the BBL to be a law that is equitable, practical, and
empowering and which serves the interests of the entire nation.
49
or of any other faithwill be left behind. Each will enjoy the benefits of good
governance, social equity, and most of all, the rule of law, in a society of cultural
and religious diversity. This inclusivity is mirrored by how the BTC was formed,
with representatives of Muslim, Christian, and indigenous people appointed as
commissioners. The envisioned Bangsamoro ministerial government will also
have allotted seats to ensure that diverse voices will be heard as part of policymaking and good governance. The central government will always uphold its
role to ensure that unity in diversity flourishes and that peaceful coexistence
and shared prosperity shall be the norm in a Bangsamoro era.
The good news is that even as we have yet to complete the political transition
as defined in the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro, the work of
implementing the Normalization Annex has already begun and milestones
along this comprehensive post-conflict track will also soon become apparent.
The good news is that even as we have yet to complete the political transition
as defined in the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro, economic
gains are clearly on the horizon, and even in the pipeline.
50
During this dialogue, let us open our minds and hearts, and be generous
in sharing what we consider our most important needs and heartfelt desires
in the Bangsamoro society that we want to shape. Conflicting opinions and
positions will arise, but that is what dialogue is all about. Amid such differences
lie our determination to identify the issues we need to address and iron out as
a reconciled, if not united, whole.
Remember what Nelson Mandela once said? He had posted the challenge:
Sometimes it falls upon a generation to be great. You can be that generation.
What our forebears dreamt about, we now have a duty to fulfill.
With that, I would like to end the way I beganwith extreme gratitude to
the organizers of this Interreligious Dialogue and to every participantthank
you for keeping the faith, thank you for supporting the peace process.
Salamat sa inyong mataimtim na pagmamahal sa bayan. Magsukol.
The 2011 Ramadan meeting thus began on a high note even though it was
subdued by the fact that it was fasting month. Our negotiating partners had to
endure the hunger and thirst even though we had adjusted our meetings to end
by around noontime. By midday, the Muslims in the talks have had nothing
to eat and drink for around six hours, and had been awake since around 4 a.m.
They would also need to say their noontime prayers, and await the breaking of
the fast at sundown (which was around 7 p.m. in Kuala Lumpur).
During the 2011 Ramadan, on 22 August, the first day of talks, we handed
over GPHs proposal to the MILF Panel. This was our 3-for-1 package made
51
52
But it could not be helped, and so we did have negotiations in the Ramadan
that followed.
Our second Ramadan together was during the 30th FET that began on 7
August 2012. We had by then overcome the 2011 Ramadan impasse. In April
2012, the first substantive document was signed. This was the Decision Points
on Principles that reflected the initial consensus such as the recognition of the
legitimate grievances and identity of the Bangsamoro, the unacceptable status
quo, the creation of a new political entity with a ministerial form of government,
an agreement to define the power-sharing and wealth-sharing arrangements
between the Central and Bangsamoro governments, reiteration of respect for
vested property rights and other basic rights, including the right to meaningful
political participation of women.
By 2012, we were faced by the formal split of Umbra Kato and the coming
out of the Bangsamoro Islamic Freedom Fighters (BIFF). In the first week
of August, as we prepared for our travel to Kuala Lumpur, the BIFF attacked
several army detachments of the 6th Infantry Division in Barangay Bagan in
Talayan all the way to Brgy. Kauran in Ampatuan and Brgy. Tugal in Midsayap.
But unlike in 2011, we were now united to forge ahead despite this specific
challenge that had further complicated an already complicated process. In this
53
round we created our first two Technical Working Groups (TWGs)on Powerand Wealth-Sharing. So our delegations had increased significantly, with three
members each for each TWG.
As you know, it wasnt easy to get to the completed Annexes. The WealthSharing Annex was signed eleven months later, in July 2013. The Annex on
Power-Sharing was signed sixteen months after, in December 2013. But in any
case, prior to these signed Annexes, we managed to come up with the second
major document that laid down the road map. This is the Framework Agreement
on the Bangsamoro which was signed in October 2012 at the Malacaan Palace.
Things were looking up in Ramadan 2012, despite the difficult issues on the table.
Our third Ramadan was during our 38th Formal Exploratory Talks held
on 8-13 July 2013.
Much was expected of us in this round after a long interregnum due to the
holding of the May 2013 election. Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process
Ging Deles had sent out appeals to her prayer warriors: Please pray for patience,
insight, and understanding for the parties to find common ground in mind and
heart and bringing the good news for the Filipino people during the first week of
Ramadan. Individually, we whispered our individual hopes and intentions for
a good outcome.
We were a big group. In this round, the Third Party Monitoring Team was
convened for the first time. It was at that time the latest mechanism added to
the infrastructure, whose purpose is mainly to monitor the implementation of
the yet-to-come comprehensive agreement.
As usual, we adjusted our meetings to end around noon. Still, in our common
desire to accomplish our task, we worked overtime, day in, day out. The four-day
meeting lasted for six days.
There were many tense and volatile moments throughout. The hard issues on
the table were on the taxes to be devolved to the Bangsamoro, and the sharing
formula with regard to government revenues on mineral and energy resources.
There was the matter of how to describe these resourcesfrom strategic and
non-strategic minerals in Republic Act 9054, to eventually our three categories,
namely, metallic and non-metallic minerals, and fossil fuels.
54
We were now on our sixth day. It was a Saturday, 13 July. Still unable to
settle the remaining issues, we broke off our session past midday. We were not
sure what would come next. Then it was agreed to convene again.
It was a close call. Our negotiation ended at around 10 p.m., with only the
document in final form still to be formally signed. Both sides made difficult but
also constructive decisions. With perseverance and clarity of purpose, we returned
home with the signed Annex on Revenue Generation and Wealth-Sharing.
After two annexes, we knew there was no turning back. Halfway through
the four annexes, you dont give up. You just move forward. And so we did and
completed the CAB.
This is our short story of the Ramadans during our formal negotiations.
Now we will enter our fourth Ramadan later this month of June, not as
negotiating partners but as partners in implementation, partners in building
peace and prosperity for one all in the Bangsamoro.
We wish our Muslim brothers and sisters renewed strength and vigor as they
embark on this years Ramadan later this month of June, so that together we will
be very strong in seeing through the implementation of our peace agreements.
Thank you very much.
GPH Panel Chair Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer (left photo) and MILF Panel Chair Mohagher Iqbal
(right photo) exchange pleasantries with former MNLF Spokesperson Abasalom Cerveza at the
holding area of the conference entitled, Peace Is Living Together: Religions and Cultures in
Dialogue for Peace and Reconciliation in Mindanao held at Notre Dame University in Cotabato
City. Looking on is NDU President Rev. Fr. Eduardo G. Tanudtanud, OMI. The conference was also
organized by the Community of SantEgidio and the Archdiocese of Cotabato in cooperation with
Muhammadiyah. (Photos by OPAPP)
Mohagher Iqbal
CHAIR, MILF PEACE PANEL
eventeen long years of hard and protracted peace process between the Moro
Islamic Liberation Front and the Government of the Philippines is by any
standard not a short engagement. Certainly, a lot of significant lessons both
good and hard have been earned as a result of this engagement.
55
56
majority with the minority and marginalized groups at the receiving end would
require a long haul, not only on the success of the revolutionary struggle but
even of the peace negotiation itself. Two things emerge to be too hard to share
and given by the state: power and resources. Add the hatred, mistrust, prejudices,
enmities between and amongst peoples and communities, and the oppressive
and exploitative laws and policies of governments, expect, as we experienced and
suffered excessively therefrom, the consequence that can hardly be doubted: a
hard and protracted peace process.
The personal factor in the peace negotiator plays an important role on how
the peace process develops and is being pursued. Individual styles, background,
and views can either hasten or impede the flow of the negotiation and its
outcome. It is not true to say that military men are not good negotiators. My
experience tells me that they can be as good as any negotiator of other profession
or training. However, the most effective negotiator is one who fully understands
the nature of the problem to be addressed and is fully committed to solve it. Of
course, the success still depends on the policies of the parties principals. They
are the real decision makers.
It is very hard to read real intention, but even in the case of good ones
there are always beyond, in terms of consequences, good or bad. Therefore, in
negotiation there is little difference, if any, between what appears to be good
and bad intentions. Both require anticipation, vigilance, and good planning, and
well-studied countermove. A successful negotiators motto is: Prepare, prepare,
prepare.
There is little room to doubt that the GPH-MILF peace process started, on
the part of government, not really to solve the Bangsamoro Problem despite its
billing that it is intended to solve it. However, for the MILF, the intention was
pure and untainted, but it was also fully aware that the process is going to be
long and hard. Therefore, it was more of a tactical move especially on the part of
government to use the pacific undertaking as image-building and to gain time
including strategic advantage over the MILF militarily while the MNLF was put
at the helm of power and groomed to deliver or lose direction as a consequence
of the never-before-experienced complex situation. Any revolutionary movement
which has lost its core values or had none at all in the various transitions or
changes that take place in the course of time will certainly be eaten up by the
system that it sought to replace.
57
58
the adoption of a policy of need to know basis to protect the unnecessary and
unintentional disclosure of information and, without stating, including betrayal
of comrades.
Alongside trust, truth is also an effective weapon in dealing with the strong
and the powerful. Truth hurts, the Bible says, but it sets you free. The truth is
as hard to tell, as it is to hear, but fairness, consistency, and strength flow from it.
You cant handle the truth! Thats the famous line from A Few Good Men,
a play by Aaron Sorkin produced on Broadway in 1989 and as a movie in 1992.
Thirteen years later, the American Film Institute named this line the twentyninth greatest American film quote of all time.
The MILFs boldness to engage even the most powerful states and
multilateral groupings like the United States, Japan, the United Kingdom,
Australia, and the European Union in the search for real and just peace in
Mindanao is anchored on this. We believe in the ultimate truthfulness and
legitimacy of the Bangsamoro peoples cause and therefore, we are not afraid
to engage anybody, groups or states.
International Conference on
The Consolidation for Peace for
Mindanao (COP6)
2325 June 2014
Hiroshima, Japan
Keynote Address
First of all, I would like to congratulate and thank the organizers of this
conferencenamely, the Research and Education for Peace of the Universiti
Sains Malaysia (USM) and the Japan International Cooperation Agency
( JICA)for the perseverance and vision that have made possible the holding
of the 6th Consolidation for Peace Program (or COP6). Starting in 2006, the
two partner organizations have managed to organize this gathering of multistakeholders almost every year-and-a-half to look into and accompany the
peace processes in Aceh, Mindanao, and Southern Thailand, with three of the
six conferences, including this current one, focused solely on Mindanao.
To have kept faith with the Mindanao peace process for the last eight
years has certainly required patience and fidelitymaybe the better word is
tenacity?and I must surmise also a good dose of hope and imagination, as
these past years have seen some of the darkest hours of a peace process that,
truth to tell, hardly stayed on track, moving from good to bad sometimes in an
instant, yet somehow recovering ground in ways no one could have foretold.
That we are able to come together on the eighth year for the sixth such
gathering certainly speaks to us and to the world of the power of tenacity and
hope in making peace. And I thank USM and JICA for not letting go and not
giving up, together with the rest of us here and the many others who have been
part of this process and the many more who are joining us and expanding our
ranks everyday.
There are many veterans of the COP process who are with us this morning
may I ask those who have attended every COP from no. 1 to todays no. 6 to stand
up and be acknowledged? Let us give them a big round of applause for being
among the faithful pilgrims for peace. On the other hand, there are some who
are attending the COP for the first time. And the rest of us are COP veterans
in varying degrees. The COP has truly grown to embrace a wide communitya
60
61
OPAPP Sec. Deles (left) and MILF Chair Murad deliver their
keynote addresses on 23 June 2014, at the 6th Consolidation
for Peace for Mindanao (COP6) entitled Post-Agreement
Implementation: Building Capacities for Peace of the Bangsamoro
Stakeholders at the Hiroshima International Convention Center.
COP6 Mindanao was organized by the Research and Education
for Peace Unit of Universiti Sains Malaysia and the Japan
International Cooperation Agency. (Photos by OPAPP)
On my part, this
is only my second
COP and, it turns out,
also my second time
to deliver one of the
Keynote Addresses. I
joined the COP family
only in 2012, for COP5.
When COP1
was held, I had just
left government and
the peace process was
beginning to move into
shaky ground, with
unsteady leadership in
OPAPP and the survival of the Arroyo presidency increasingly under threat.
In 2008, the striking down of the MOA-AD by the Supreme Court ushered in
a period of darkest despair and terror. Fortunately, enough people of goodwill
persevered to produce a Declaration of Continuity for Peace Negotiations
with which the past administration passed a battered peace torch to the Aquino
government.
COP5 was held in January 2012, in Penang, like all the earlier conferences.
The Aquino presidency was midway into its second year and the resumption
of formal peace negotiations was nearing the completion of its first year. And,
oh, what a year 2011 was for the peace process! Formal talks had restarted in
Kuala Lumpur in February, which renewed process, perhaps not so unexpectedly,
encountered difficult re-birthing pains which caused the President to embark
on a short trip that, however, gained gold mileage for the peace process and
firmly lodged Japan in the annals of Philippine peace history, by hosting that
first meeting between the President and Chairman Murad which startled the
world and reenergized the struggling and straggling peace negotiations.
62
But it would still be far from easy. In September, with talks held during
Ramadan, the MILF rejected the GPH 3-for-1 proposal, which rejection the
GPH promptly rejected. Hardly had the parties recovered from the setback,
with the decision to go back to a clean slate at the peace table, when the Al
Barka crisis broke out in October. This tragic misencounter could have brought
us back to vicious violence, except that President Aquino firmly said no to allout war and instead sounded the true leaders call for all-out justice. Once we
heard it, we knew it was what the country needed to hear and to accomplish.
And, thus, the peace process crossed safely over to 2012.
63
In July, when Congress reopens, the President will submit the proposed
Bangsamoro Basic Law for priority enactment. In turn, our legislators, through
the leadership of the House of Representatives and the Senate, have committed
to pass the Bangsamoro Basic Law before the year ends, bringing about much
needed political and socioeconomic reforms under a new regional government.
This will be followed by a plebiscite early next year in the areas under the scope
of the law, ensuing a brief transition period until regional elections are held in
May 2016.
As we move to achieve these political milestones, the parties have also begun
to put in place a comprehensive and sustainable normalization process that will,
through a multi-track approach, ensure that the weapons and the forces of the
MILF are put beyond use and communities are transformed from conflict and
despair to hope, productivity, and a chance to rebuild and renew.
We dare to say it is a democratic process striving to burst into full bloom.
From that rare and historic meeting between our President and Chairman
Murad in Narita almost three years ago, we are now at the cusp of an enduring
peace. The Aquino administration, with the help, support, and encouragement
of our CSOs, local governments, other stakeholders and the international
community, shall continue to strengthen the politics of reconciliation and the
ramparts of a permanent peace.
64
We have come to envision the Bangsamoro, with its favored location sharing
our common borders with our neighbors in the south, as the anchor and sanctuary
of common prosperity and collective securityin the Philippines, in Asia,
and across the globe. The partnership between the MILF and the government
continues to blossom into a feast of possibilities that continues to excite our
neighbors in Asia and beyond. The global community is furthermore in awe
and admiration of the strong flank of Filipino women at the forefront of the
Bangsamoro peace process.
Let us strive to identify and address potential problems and loopholes
involving the socioeconomic enablement of the newly minted region, the
formal establishment of its governance structure, and the most crucial process
of normalization. Through this forum, let us identify and strengthen our
preparations in developing the means to build the required capacities that will,
in turn, create legitimate and viable, all-inclusive and lasting peace for Mindanao
and the entire country.
Our work is never-ending but that is what great journeys are all about.
In the end, let me, on behalf of the Philippine government, thank each and
everyone of you here, and the institutions and communities you represent, for
accompanying us on this unique and historic quest for a just and lasting peace.
As we have struggled to overcome every obstacle in the past, let us carry on and
never falter, no matter what problems and challenges lie ahead.
In January 2012, I ended my speech with these words: I know that, in our
hearts, peace has won. I said then: I do believe, and I continue to believe that,
on the peace table are miracles waiting to happen.
Today I say again: Whatever difficulties lie ahead, and we can be sure
there will be many, let us not give up. Today I again say: I believeI persist in
believingthat miracles await to happen in the post-agreement implementation
phase to usher in the Bangsamoros sustained peace and development.
Maraming salamat and good day. Arigatou gozaimasu.
Everyone knows that the signing of the CAB on March 27, 2014 was just
the beginning. Like in a graduation ceremony, it marked what one has achieved
after years of hard work. But it also signals the beginning of the next phase in
a graduates life: survival, success in the real world.
The first challenge that we face is the element of time. The real world is
governed by calendars, and the endless ticking of the clock, marking time and
deadlines. We have so many things to do and so little time to put everything
in place:
65
66
The MILF too will have to confront their organizational challenges. They
will have to bring all their commanders, religious leaders, and mass base on board.
They will have to develop patience and confidence in the process. They will need
to tame the fears that cause paranoia, rumor mongering, and emotional outbursts.
They will need to go beyond their immediate circle of trusted personnel and tap
into the younger, professional pool of Bangsamoro and Bangsamoro supporters
who are willing to help. They will have to guard against the opportunists and
the envious.
In other words, our second challenge is ourselves, the main parties to the
Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro.
The third challenge is how to sustain public trust and support. As of now,
there is sufficient support that has carried us through this far. But this is not
enough. There are others who do not want this process to succeed, who continue
to use violence to derail our progress. There are many what ifs, and many
people do not give their full support unless they have all the guarantees. We
tell them that only God can give all the guarantees. But God will help those
who help themselves.
The fourth challenge has always been with us. That is the challenge of
inclusivity. Mindanao, the Bangsamoro, are not monolithic entities. There are
multiple narratives, multiple identities, multiple claimants, and stakeholders.
67
There must be a just share of the benefits for everyone. There must be a just
recognition of the rights and legitimacy of the different stakeholders. Peace
dividends are not spoils of war. There must be an equitable distribution of the
dividends of peace.
Because four is not a lucky number in most oriental societies, I must add a
fifth challenge. And that challenge is how to ensure that the goodwill coming
from the international community, from countries like Japan and agencies like
JICA, is used judiciously and effectively; that the support empowers a broad
base of the women and men in the communities, and not just some; that these
engender autonomy and self-reliance, not dependence.
Time is short and I hope I met the challenge of saying most everything
that has to be said in a few minutes.
Mohagher Iqbal
MEMBER, MILF PEACE PANEL
n every post-agreement period, there are always hard challenges ahead. The
case of the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro (CAB), signed
between the Government of the Philippines (GPH) and the Moro Islamic
Liberation Front (MILF) on 27 March 2014, is not an exception. In fact, with
its complex and multi-tiered approach, not so much seen in other conflict
resolution models in other parts of the world, expect the challenges ahead to
be also complex and stunning. The parties should not expect a short haul. This
early, I must confess, we are already feeling the heat.
First and foremost of the hurdles is for the successful implementation of the
CAB: Because the CAB is merely a piece of paper, it will not implement itself.
It takes the intervention of people and their sincerity and decisiveness to make
sure that this agreement will be implemented true to its letter and spirit. Many
a good agreement fails to address a particular problem and halt the conflict,
because in the end, there is that tendency especially of the powerful partner to
dilute the content of the political document like the CAB when the legislated
form takes place. The consequence would be that the other party, usually the
insurgent side, will be forced to swallow the hook, line, and sinker offered to it or
reject it outright. In both scenarios, the conflict will continue to exist, oftentimes
with much more fury, because in the first case, other armed groups, usually the
more radical ones which do not believe in peace negotiation, will condemn
the perceived sell-out and will carry on the struggle. In the second scenario,
rejection of the watered down legislation would be the handiest recourse of the
other party, say the MILF.
But right now I still have that faith with President Benigno Aquino III
that he would not allow the impending full success story of the GPH-MILF
68
69
Anent to this is the lingering possibility that the next president sitting in
Malacaang Palace will not pursue the policy of President Benigno Aquino III
of putting to rest the armed conflict in Mindanao. This is not to say, however,
that the MILF negotiation with the government is with the executive branch
of government only. The deal has always been with the Government of the
Philippines (GPH) and whoever is elected as President is duty bound to honor
and implement any agreement entered into and signed by the GPH and, in this
case, the CAB with the MILF.
Be this as it may, experience tells us that every president who came to
power has diverse policy formulations on the conflict. Some merely used it to
buy time; others either resorted to it for image building as peace-makers or to
prove a thesis that the problem in Mindanao can be settled purely by military
means; still others, in the case of former President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo,
had the stigma of sincerity to solve the conflict but seriously lacking in the will
to push it. Instead of saving the peace process, she chose to save her neck by
not signing the Memorandum of Agreement on Ancestral Domain (MOAAD) in August 2008.
There are other challenges ahead of us, but I am sure the moment a good
BBL comes out of Congress, everything gradually falls into place and becomes
70
easy. This is especially true to the issue of decommissioning of MILF firearms and
forces and putting them beyond use, which the MILF considers as an ultimate
sacrifice for the sake of just settlement of the conflict in Mindanao. The ultimate
interest of the Bangsamoro, which is securing for them a real self-governing
entity, requires an ultimate sacrifice.
The truth is that while decommissioning is not about surrender or destruction
of firearms, which is no-no for the MILF, but just the same, it is about parting
away with something that the MILF and the Bangsamoro people had banked on
effectively in defending their limbs and properties especially during the height
of Martial Law from 1972 to 1986. More importantly, without the military
power of the MILF, its political power is greatly suspect and will be reduced to
a pushover organization.
Multi-sectoral delegates of COP6 happily flash the peace sign at the end of the three-day series
of sessions focused on issues and challenges in building sustainable peace in conflict-stricken
Mindanao. (Photo by JICA)
Speech
ext year, the world will mark seventy years since the terrible power of
nuclear weapons was first unleashedright here in the City of Hiroshima.
The tragedy that took place in this city on 6 August 1945, involved a previously
untested type of uranium bomb and claimed over a hundred thousand lives. It
was followed by the use of a plutonium bomb in Nagasaki on 9 August 1945,
inflicting, again, over a hundred thousand casualties in a city that was actually
a secondary target. Heavy ground haze and smoke obscured the city of Kokura,
the real target, leading to the decision to bomb Nagasaki instead.
A fundamental question arises from this tragedy: What did the peoples of
both Hiroshima and Nagasaki do for them to pay the ultimate price of war? The
tragedy that was the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, seven decades later,
only reminds us the futile results of conflict, and impress upon us the collective
responsibility we hold in defending the rights of our respective peoples to live
not only without fear, but to live in a world where peace is a shared reality by
all nations.
It is therefore fitting that we are gathered in this city consecrated to the
principle of the preservation of peace, to discuss how the combatants of yesterday
can become partners for the avoidance of future conflict. In this regard, I believe
that the Philippines, which also paid a colossal price in lives and material damage
in war, has something significant to share when it comes to setting aside conflict
and achieving reconciliation and harmony.
On the 27th of March of this year, in the garden of Malacaan Palace,
representatives of my government and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front
forged an agreement that promised an end to more than four decades of strife
in Mindanao, an agreement that opened a new chapter of solidarity in our
nations narrative.
The agreement, which was witnessed by those who had worked with us and
by the international community, was the culmination of the hard work that all
stakeholders and partners put into opening this chapter of peace for Mindanao.
While it is the task of Filipinos to work out peace in the Bangsamoro, the
71
72
President Benigno S. Aquino III and other guests at the three-day International Conference on the
Consolidation for Peace for Mindanao (COP6) in Hiroshima, Japan. (From left to right) Professor
Kamarulzaman Askandar (University of Sains Malaysia), Al Haj Murad Ebrahim (MILF Chair),
Governor of Hiroshima Prefecture Hidehiko Yuzaki, Secretary Albert F. Del Rosario (Department of
Foreign Affairs, the Philippines), JICA President Akihiko Tanaka, Secretary Teresita Quintos Deles
(OPAPP), GPH Panel Chair Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, and MILF Panel Chair Mohagher Iqbal.
(Photo by Gil Nartea/Malacaang Photo Bureau)
73
74
75
76
to serve, we can ensure our equitable advancement. And because our peace is
based on justice, it is a peace that will last; and it will serve as a firm foundation
for development and security.
I believe this is the very essence of all our efforts and of our gathering today:
It is by working together to boost the capacities of the people of the Bangsamoro
that we can truly enable them to succeed, and show them that peace, stability, and
harmonywhether in Mindanao or in the wider international environment
are both possible and sustainable. This can be done if we can harness trust and
friendship towards a reasonable, mutually beneficial consensus.
I believe that all of us here today are bound by this hope. This is why my
administration will work doubly hard to ensure that free, peaceful, and democratic
elections for the Bangsamoro government will take place come 2016. This is why
our government will continue to take on programs and implement projects that
will empower more Filipinos to contribute to the growth of our nation. This is
why, even in the face of immense challenge and difficulty, the Filipino people
will continue to tread the straight and righteous path to progressbecause we
know that true, inclusive growth affects individuals, communities, nations, and
the entire world. It is with this commitment that we will continue to work with
all partners of goodwill.
For the longest time, my brothers and sisters in the Bangsamoro have
sought to live dignified, productive, and peaceful lives. Today, this vision is
within reachnot only for them, but for all of us. It is a vision that motivates
all of us to finish the journey we had taken. Through our sustained solidarity, I
am confident we can and will fulfill the promise of peacea promise that will
illuminate not only our own path, but also that of generations to come.
I would like to add that if solidarity among Filipinos and with other nations
of goodwill, like Japan, like Malaysia, and others, can bring about peace, then
it is incumbent on all nations to look at our regional circumstances and ask of
themselves if conflict should be considered inevitable. While it is undeniable
that tensions do exist in our part of the world, and that it can even be said that
we have entered into an era of brinksmanship, all of us have it in ourselves not
to be prisoners of our past.
Should we not strive, instead, to firmly learn from the pastand by so doing,
unchain ourselves from the inflexibility and unilateral attitudes that caused so
much conflict within living memory? If lives were needlessly sacrificed to achieve
power and prestige, is it not our obligation not only to the present and future
generations, but to millions of innocent dead cut down by conflict, to firmly
insist that losing any life is a price none of us can afford to pay?
77
President Benigno S. Aquino III delivers his speech at the Consolidation for Peace for Mindanao
(COP6) held at the Sheraton Hiroshima Hotel on June 24. The international conference
focused on key issues in the Mindanao peace process including socioeconomic development,
institutionalization of the Bangsamoro Government, and developments on the normalization
process for MILF combatants. (Photo by Gil Nartea/Malacaang Photo Bureau)
In the face of rising tensions in our region, our shared future lies in the
appreciation of three basic truths. First, that there has to be a right and wrong;
second, that we have to champion what is right; and third, most crucially of
all: that in championing what is right, we are always conscious that conflict is
not the necessary course. Principle is no obstacle to peace; but war annihilates
everythingincluding principle. I ask you, and all peoples of goodwill, to take
a similar path of dialogue and negotiation to achieve mutual understanding,
justice, and prosperity.
Whenever it seems that the path to peace is filled with so many obstacles,
when our spirits are tested and our faith in the processes are shaken, those of
us who are in a position to make decisions must remember what happened
here in Hiroshima, and in Nagasaki, and in the many places that have faced
and are now experiencing conflict: If we falter, it is the innocent who will pay
the ultimate price.
Thank you and good day.
Concluding Remarks
Even properly laid out plans, however, can be waylaid along the way. There
will be bumps and obstacles which may distract us. But we need not be. We
need to continually focus on the endgamethe correction of historical injustice
and the upliftment of the quality of our life of our peoplealmost two million
people living in poverty and many, many more who need our help. It is our
personal and collective responsibility to help them. Our people expect no less.
That is our key challengehow to make the ordinary man or woman on the
street see and feel that there is hope, that there will be a change for the better.
That it is no longer business as usual.
Kailangang makita nila at maramdaman nila na may pagbabago.
For this to happen, the key is good governance and leadership by example.
Governance that is inclusive, governance that is participatory, governance that
is transparent, and governance that is accountable to the people.
Managing change is never easy; The tasks of implementation can be daunting
but we should never get daunted. Together we shall overcome, InshaAllah.
Maraming salamat po sa inyong lahat, and may God bless all of us in our
collective journey towards a just and lasting peace.
78
n the signed agreement between the government and the MILF, we have
listed several rights that we consider most important and must therefore
be guaranteed in the negotiations and in the future Bangsamoro government.
One of these rights is the right of women to meaningful political
participation and freedom from all forms of violence. I would like to focus on
the aspect of political participation. Why the emphasis on the political?
In the Philippines, including among the Moros and other indigenous
peoples, women already play important social and economic roles. They dominate
the schools. They are both buyers and sellers in the marketplace. Over the decades,
more and more women have worked overseas to sustain their families. As a rule,
they do most if not all of the household chores while also helping out in the farm.
It is in the arena of politics that they have been less visible. Yet it is politics
that makes decisions on our everyday lives. It is in politics that one gets
known beyond ones neighbors and clan. It is politics that charts the future of
communities, children, country, and the world.
Those in politics make the decisions. They decide whether an army goes to
war or bids for peace; to respect the ceasefire and allow the displaced to return
to their communities, or not; to make and unmake or modify recommendations;
to sign or not to sign a peace agreement.
If politics is so important, why are women often left out of it? If negotiating
peace is so important, why should there not be more women on the table? If
sustaining the peace is crucial, why shouldnt women become actively involved
in building peace on the ground?
The peace negotiation between the government and the MILF provides an
interesting story of how women increasingly became important participants in
the formal process or what we call Track 1 Peace Building, which takes place at
the highest level of the state. It is also a developing story on how active political
participation is cascading down to the grassroots.
80
81
It can be said that as the talks progressed, so did the awareness on the part
of everyonegovernment, the MILF, domestic and international civil society
organizationsof the need to consciously bring in more women to meaningfully
participate in peace-building.
The talks under President Benigno Aquino III began with only one woman
in both government and MILF panelsmyself, a senior member next to the
chair. Afterwards, the government added one another woman who comes from
the affected region. She is Yasmin Busran Lao, who now heads the National
Commission on Muslim Filipinos. From one, we became two female negotiators.
We were joined by many other women in the government secretariat, the legal
team, and later the technical working groups.
On the other hand, the MILF delegation at the talks held in Kuala Lumpur
used to be all-male. We understood it was hard for the MILF to reconstitute its
panel, whose members came from the different Moro ethnic groups.
So how did it become possible that more women eventually joined the
MILF delegation?
By creating more spaces, and putting more seats inside the negotiating
room, the MILF was able to remedy the situation. The agreement to bring in
consultants allowed lawyer Raissa Jajurie to join the MILF delegation, sometimes
alone, eventually with one or two other women. Raissa became a regular fixture
in the talks when she was invited to the MILFs Technical Working Group, and
later as the sole woman-nominee of the MILF to the Bangsamoro Transition
Commission.
Over time, the MILF also loosened up their restrictions on the women
who joined their delegation. Previously, as is demanded traditionally by Islamic
custom, the lone woman had to be accompanied by a male relative when traveling.
Afterwards, when other women joined the meetings in Kuala Lumpur, the more
practical arrangement of the women as co-protector of each other became the
norm. Raissa no longer had to convince her father or her brother to travel with
her to Kuala Lumpur.
Several more women came to the talks as domestic observers. Another
woman came when Conciliation Resources, an organization that sits in the
International Contact Group or ICG, invited Emma Leslie (as an alternate) to
represent the organization. The ICG is made up of Japan, the United Kingdom,
Turkey, and Saudi Arabia, Conciliation Resources, the Centre for Humanitarian
Dialogue, Muhammadiyah (an Indonesian organization), and the Community
of SantEdigio. All their representatives were men, except for Emma.
82
When the first government chair was appointed to the Supreme Court in
November 2012, I was considered to replace him as the chair of the government
negotiating panel.
President Aquino was initially concerned about having a woman chair the
panel, not because he doubted womens capability. After all, his mother was the
leading figure of the people power revolution that ousted the Marcos dictatorship
in 1986. She was also the first-ever woman President of the Philippines.
President Aquino was concerned about how ready the other sidean Islamic
organizationwas in having to negotiate with a woman-chairperson. Indeed
the MILF said, they were not used to negotiating with a woman. For one thing,
supposedly, in their culture, they dont quarrel with women.
To the MILFs credit, they gave it a try. They said they will respect any
negotiator regardless of gender and ethnicity. They quarrelled with me too, and by
now they are used to me and all the other women as partners in the negotiations.
In all, as consultants, observers, members of the ICG and technical working
groups, and chairs, we saw the number of women grow inside the negotiating
room and, currently, in the various mechanisms that we are creating for the
implementation of the agreement.
The process of bringing in more women has been slow, but it has become
irreversible.
The women in the negotiation did not represent any womens organization.
As such it was very important for us to link up with the womens groups. The
womens networks outside of the talks expected us to carry through the gender
agenda. They did their own networking with Moro women and organizations
so that together they can bring the issues of women to the talks.
All-women organizations and networks remain important vehicles for
womens empowerment. With men around, many women tend to take the
backseat. But among themselves, they are able to develop their leadership. This
leadership is evident in the family with an absentee father/husband, and in the
evacuation centers where the women and children take shelter.
All-women settings are the staging ground for future leadership in the
community-at-large of men, women, etc. They are avenues where women are
able to prove their capabilities and earn the respect of the men.
It is important at this stage of empowering women to ensure that women be
included in all the undertakings, from training to planning and implementation
83
of various activities. At the same time, there must be special programs and
activities for women specifically, across the different ethnic groups, political
organizations, and classes to make sure that more women are given the chance. In
this manner, they also serve as bridges to the other cleavages that divide society.
Women themselves must believe in the art of the possible. Sometimes we
are resigned to the way things are. But through discussion and learning from
each other, we can believe that change is possible.
These are just some of the ways that women are defining for themselves
what meaningful political participation could mean.
Theres still a long way to go, but the journey has begun.
Thank you very much.
Transmittal of the
Proposed Bangsamoro Basic Law
to Congress
10 September 2014
Malacaan Palace, Manila
Talumpati
oong magsimula po ang ating termino, ang sinabi natin sa ating mga
kababayan: Puwede na muling mangarap. At ngayong araw nga po,
pinatutunayan natin: Hindi lang tayo nangangarap; tinutupad na natin ang
ating mga mithiin. Isang malaking hakbang na naman ang nagawa natin
patungo sa isang mas mapayapa at mas maunlad na Mindanao. Sa pamamagitan
nitong panukalang Bangsamoro Basic Law, nabibigyan natin ng hugis ang
pagsasakatuparan ng mga prinsipyong nakapaloob sa ating Comprehensive
Agreement on the Bangsamoro.
Noon nga pong nakaraang SONA, humingi ako ng pang unawa sa ating
Kongreso ukol sa batas na ito. Kinailangan po natin ng sapat na panahon upang
mahimay ang bawat probisyon ng ating panukalang batas. Mahaba at mabusisi
po ang prosesong ito dahil nga inilatag natin ang bawat detalye ng pagpapatupad
ng ating adhikain para sa Bangsamoro. Tinitiyak ko po sa inyo: Pinanday ang
Bangsamoro Basic Law upang maging makatwiran, makatarungan, at katanggaptanggap sa lahat, Moro man, Lumad, o Kristiyano.
Nagpapasalamat ako sa pakikiisa ng mga pinuno at kasapi ng MILF, sa
pangunguna nina Chairman Al Haj Murad Ebrahim at Mohagher Iqbal,
ng ating masisipag at magigiting na peace panel sa pangunguna naman nina
Secretary Ging Deles at Chairman Miriam Coronel Ferrer, gayundin sa atin
pong Bangsamoro Transition Commission, stakeholders, mga miyembro ng
Gabinete, at sa ating mga katuwang sa ibang bansa, upang tuluyang mailimbag
sa kasaysayan ang bagong kabanata ng kapayapaan at pagkakaisa sa bansa.
Tiwala ang nagdala sa atin dito. Sa kabuuan ng negosasyon, nakita
kong talaga namang desididong makarating sa isang kasunduan ang bawat
panig. Napatunayan po natin: Sa panahong hindi natin iniisip kung paano
makakapanlamang, narating natin ang isang sitwasyon kung saan lahat ay panalo.
Ngayong mayroon na tayong panukalang batas, matibay ang aking pananalig
na sang-ayon ito sa ating Saligang Batas; na matapat ito sa mga prinsipyo ng
ating Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro; na sinasalamin nito ang
ating kolektibong pagsisikap tungo sa pag-unlad na walang naiiwan.
85
86
87
Pres. Benigno S. Aquino III delivers his message during the turnover of the proposed BBL in a
formal ceremony witnessed by government executives, local government officials, legislators,
and members of Peace Panels and the Bangsamoro Transition Commission at the Rizal Hall of
Malacaang Palace. (Photo by Malacaang Photo Bureau)
88
Bangsamoro Transition Commission Chair Mohagher Iqbal formally turns over the draft Bangsamoro
Basic Law (BBL) to House Speaker Feliciano R. Belmonte and Senate President Franklin Drilon
while Pres. Benigno S. Aquino III, OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles and Executive Secretary
Paquito Ochoa Jr. look on. (Photo by Malacaang Photo Bureau)
Speech
lease join me in welcoming the latest addition to our big family, the
Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission or TJRC.
The CAB did not provide the TJRC with specific parameters. The mandates
given to the TJRC are broad. They appear simple, but they are not. They revolve
around three key phrases: legitimate grievances, historical injustice, and human
rights violations.
90
91
TJRC Chair M Bleeker, Special Envoy and Head of the Task Force on Dealing with the Past and the
Prevention of Atrocities (TF DwPA) of the Swiss Federal Department of Foreign Affairs, explains the
Commissions mandate and conceptual approach in a public event held at Alnor Hotel in Cotabato
City on 4 October 2014. (Photo by OPAPP)
Transitional
The transitional in TJ is not about abrupt starts and ends. Transitional
doesnt mean transitory, temporary or a mere passing of time. Transitional here
may be thought of us something that connects or provides the link. It connects
the historical past and links that past to the transforming present that would
usher in the new, shared future.
That transforming moment, for our Moro brothers and sisters, the different
communities in Mindanao and the rest of the country, is now. The moment
for a future of just peace is now. The moment for change, reform, and new
opportunities is now. It is upon uslet us not lose it.
This transition is the link between the historical past and the future-thatis-yet-to-be-made. We need to deal with the past that brought us our wars,
generated the distrust, and kept us apart from each other as communities and
92
peoples. Only in doing so can we bring everyone closer to the shared, desired
future.
Justice
Justice is an everyday word, a household name. Everybody wants to believe
they are on the side of justice. Justice, wed like to think, founds many of our
perceptions and our actions. It rears its head in the most ordinary moment but
it looms large in times of momentous change.
In one of the hotels where the GPH panel often stays when in Kuala
Lumpur, a sign at the elevator says, Durian and mangosteen are not allowed
inside the rooms. Most everyone who saw this commented, Why also
mangosteen? Durian, okay, but mangosteen too? It didnt seem just. It offended
our ordinary sense of justice.
Justice for Aquino! Justice for all! or JAJA was the rallying call that brought
masses of people out on the streets after Ninoy Aquino was assassinated in 1983.
In three years time, the movement for justice against the abuses of the Marcos
regime, including the rigging of the 1986 snap election, was vindicated. Justice
was a principle that loomed large in the upheaval against the Marcos government.
Justice is political and personal. It can mean many different ways in different
times in different contexts to different people. When its there, they see it. They
affirm it.
But what is this justice that people see and seem to know? Or, the opposite,
what is this injustice that people feel and reject? Injustice as it is happening
seems more easily felt as a negative force, while the positive force that is justice
may be more amorphous. It may simply mean a general sense of well-being. Or
a certain act that eases the pain or erases the anger.
What about injustices of the distant past or what have been referred to
as historical injustice? How does one untangle complex histories, claims, and
grievances? Where does one begin and end?
Unraveling historical injustice would not be achieved using black-and-white
lenses or simplified dichotomies of friend-enemy, victim-oppressor, especially in
wars where effectively all suffered lossesalthough it is true, that some suffered
more, and some types of injustices were worse than others.
This is specially so in the case of the Bangsamoro Question. The case has
been made against calling the matter on hand as the Bangsamoro Problem. Our
93
Moro friends have counteredwe are not the problem; you are. Therefore it
must be called the Philippine problem. But the problem as we know did not
start only with the Philippine government but rather during colonial times.
Reconciliation
Re + conciliation.
To bring back that was set apart. To restore. To bring together again and
find a synthesis in the contradictions that existed. The assumption being that,
in the beginning, we, our neighbors, and our ancestors and their ancestors
including their spouses and descendants, were not born enemies of each other.
Rather, along the way, things happened that drew us apart, eroded the trust, and
generated the fear, anger, and hate.
To re-concile means finding our groove again.
Like keys that unlock doors, there are many different grooves to those
emancipatory keys. No one key fits all. But with the right keys, something kept
closed is opened up. The rooms connect again. The fear to move from one room
to another is removed. Theres that feeling of well-being, and it feels good.
Without reconciliationwith the other, with ones selfwe will continue
to live with resentment and distrust of the other.
For most parts, human rights advocacy in the Philippines operated in the
mode of expose and opposean uncompromising stance to overthrow the whole
94
To the TJRC:
In your work, you will encounter many stories and several strands to a
single story. You will find several competing dominant and much, much more
marginalized narratives that have merely begun to be heard.
Your biggest challenge is how to produce an inclusive synthesis of all these
stories. How to ensure that they would all be inside the frame that you would
use. Moreover, that frame must set people free to find their own happy ending.
We would be presumptuous to think that the only TJR that will happen is that
which will fall under the rubric of this process or the programs that will follow.
Many people have taken the step forward to heal the wounds way before
we were here. We should ask them how they helped to heal themselves, from
where they drew their strength, what insights they can share to othersthese
would be the most valuable input because they are already lived experience.
The work of the TJRC and its outcome must set off a process that does
not control, formalize, bureaucratize, nor narrow down the avenues, but rather
generates, in addition to the states, people-driven initiatives to do TJR. As
it generates the public discourse on TJR, it must also inspire more and more
95
The TJRC is joined by various stakeholders, including the GPH and MILF Peace Panel Chairs and
representatives from the government agencies, LGUs, local and international nonprofits, multilateral
agencies, academe, and media, during the Commissions public event at Makati Shangri-la on 11
October 2016. (Photo by TJRC)
individual acts of justice and reconciliation at a time and in ways deemed right
by the individuals concerned.
This TJRCs potentially greatest contribution would not only be in filling
the institutional gaps but in pointing to how we can effectively replace the T
(transitional) in the J and R with an S for sustainable, or SJR.
If the TJR is to become sustainable, our efforts must eventually transform
social, economic, political, and personal relationships.
Our efforts must produce the needed state policies and institutions that
would be responsive.
Our efforts must make us more human, with faith and trust in the humanity
that is in each one of us. Only this shared sense of humanity will unite us whatever
identity we self-ascribe to or are other-ascribed.
Our initiatives must produce a norm-change. Change the hate to love. Move
from distrust to trust. Shift from monologue to dialogue. Entrench the sense of
personal and collective accountability, and strengthen the desire to build peace.
Nobody said it would be easy.
Rest assured that this panel, this government, this administration, share these
goals and will work with you and the other stakeholders cooperatively and proactively.
InshaAllah, all the goodwill shall prevail.
Speech
Mohagher Iqbal
CHAIR, MILF PEACE PANEL
What a contrast, indeed. And if I may say so, the physical transformation is
a fitting analogy to what we desire for in the process of transitional justice that
has formally commenced in Kuala Lumpur last 27 to 29 September.
96
97
amply demonstrated,
sometimes the
prevailing justice system
itself is the very source
of grave inequities and
tool for repression and
oppression. In fact, the
legitimate grievances of
our people are hardly
addressed by the
existing laws. Thus, we
have to look for other
paradigms.
For communities MILF Chair Iqbal addresses participants and guests during
like ours which are trying the TJRC public event in Cotabato City on October 4. Seated
to emerge from conflict behind him are the members of the TJRC: MILF designate Atty.
Ishak Mastura (leftmost), TJRC Chair M Bleeker (3rd from left),
s i t u a t i o n s f r o m GPH designate Atty. Cecilia-Damary (5th from left); TJRC Senior
abnormal conditions to Adviser Mr. Jonathan Sisson (seated, rightmost); as well as Swiss
normalized oneswe Ambassador Ivo Sieber (second from left) and GPH Peace Panel
Chair Miriam Coronel Ferrer (seated, center). (Photo by TJRC)
have to ensure that both
judicial and nonjudicial
measures are effected to give true justice to victims of state-sponsored, stateabetted, or state-consented violence and, equally important, to guarantee that
no repetition of such violence by state apparatuses would be repeated.
Again, I wish you more luck as you now attend to the work of the
Commission.
Thank you.
Speech
99
100
investment as well as its benefits to the community and people have to be fully
explained, understood, and hopefully internalized by the datus. The ground
rules have to be set, made explicit and made clear from the very start. Principles
and practices of good corporate governance have to be understood to avoid
any subsequent misunderstanding. In short, the key role of the datu cannot be
overemphasized.
There is plenty of idle land in the area. Before entering into any agreement,
however, on the use of land, rigid due diligence has to be done to make sure
that the land is not subject to conflicting claims. That is why as a matter of
course, the datu is always a witness to any agreement thereby making him also
accountable for the security of tenure of the land just in case any adverse claim
comes up later on.
Since the region is the most underdeveloped in the country, naturally the
mandated minimum wages are the lowest. Labor availability is not a problem,
but the literacy level of people is very low. For many who will be employed, it
could very well be their first job. That is why there is a lot of training necessary
both in terms of skills and value formation. One continuing challenge is how
to integrate the business with the communitys cultural system. As the datu is
the recognized leader in the community, he needs to be briefed on plans and
programs affecting people, like the introduction of piece work rates, quality
incentives, cost savings incentives, and the personnel code of conduct. The
reward and punishment system has to be very clear so that when necessary, the
datu can be asked to help in implementing necessary disciplinary action on
errant employees. Since there are no labor unions in the Bangsamoro, the datu
is most often consulted on actions affecting people as they look up to him for
any extra guidance.
101
GPH Panel Member and former DA Secretary Senen C. Bacani briefs and updates members and
representatives of the Philippine Chamber of Commerce and Industry, The Asia Foundation, and
Australian Aid on the Bangsamoro Basic Law and the GPH-MILF peace process. (Photo by OPAPP)
Opening Remarks
103
104
The 2014 PDF served as an avenue to present the Bangsamoro Development Plan (BDP)
to development partners. The BDP is a short- and medium-term plan aimed at jumpstarting
sustainable development in conflict-stricken Bangsamoro areas. (Photo by OPAPP)
Pres. Aquino greets and spends a light moment with (from left) NEDA Sec. Arsenio
Balisacan, MILF Panel Chair Mohagher Iqbal, MILF Vice-Chair for Political Affairs Ghazali
Jaafar, MILF Chair Al Haj Murad Ebrahim and OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles. (Photo
by Malacaang Photo Bureau)
105
A lasting peace can only be attained when the causes of discord are fully
addressed. And, the roots of conflict will only be truly eliminated when every
citizenregardless of creed, gender, or ethnicityis able to enjoy good health,
education, and quality of life; to live with freedom, honor, dignity, and justice;
and to contribute his or her talents, potentials, and capabilities to the betterment
of his or her community and society.
An old African proverb says, If you want to go fast, go alone; but if you
want to go far, go together. As we proceed with the process of establishing and
activating the Bangsamoro, may we continue to nurture the spirit of harmony
and cooperation that has brought us to a new beginning for the Bangsamoro,
for Mindanao, and for the Philippines.
Let us not forget, however, that there will always be those who will feel left
out in this process, whose voices may not be heard in this forum. So even as we
bring our minds together in this event, let us continue to listen, be sensitive to,
and consider others views and sentiments to ensure that development will truly
be inclusive and that the gains we achieve will last.
Thank you all, and may we have a productive forum.
Welcome Statement
It is said that the way we treat people is what they become in time.
For centuries we treated our Muslim brethren like second class citizens,
which made them first class warriors. Today we accord them the respect and
dignity deserving of the best of Filipinos, which will make them first class
nation-builders.
Welcome to the Philippines Development Forum on Bangsamoro!
From the very start, we were confident that the Moro Islamic Liberation
Front could muster the will and capacity to hammer out a development
plan based on equity, social justice and inclusive growthonce they had the
opportunity to settle down upon the end of conflict.
We now see the ripening fruit of their robust hearts and minds.
This is part of our common vision and pledgethat no one shall be left
behind, whether in the assurance that homes shall no longer be rended by war,
or in the assurance that fields will be tilled and deliver the earths bounty to one
and allregardless of creed, origin and social station.
This plan will come to fruition just as sure as the sun rises every day.
It will gain in strength from the solidarity forged by the brave hearts of
this nation. It will be propelled by the skill and acumen of the best minds that
have gathered in this hall. It will be driven by a national leadership that knows
not how to retreat or to surrender when it comes to facing the most profound
challenges of his people.
106
107
Once more, Mr. President, salamat po. You have invested so much, and risked
so much, to bring us all to the doorstep of peace and development in Mindanao.
The people have never had such a great champion of such deep humility.
In viewing our horizon, I cannot but think of the Marshall plan that brought
the world together after the Second World War.
The plan dealt with anything and everything from medicines to mules,
grants, funds, credit, factory and railway equipment, knowledge, technical support
and communications.
Throughout the continent, it provided nets for Norwegian fishers, wool for
Austrian weavers, and tractors for French farmers. It succeeded in generating
jobs, putting food on tables, rebuilding factories, roads, and bridges.
Where the Marshall Plan was a strategic move to forestall the march
of communism over the impoverished millions of Europe, our Bangsamoro
Development Plan is our very own shield against the raging forces of extremism
that are advancing to the shores of other lands.
I do not say that development is an absolute shield against extremism, but
I earnestly believe that development gives us a sharper edge to cut extremism
before it makes inroads into the most vulnerable communities. This is the best
way forward.
The Bangsamoro Basic Law and the Bangsamoro Development Plan are
two sides of the same cointhe coin of human security, the way of life we all
aspire and live for.
And human security can only be had under the rule of law. Where
governance and persons in authority are imbued with legitimacy and credibility,
development advances unimpeded. This is our shared dictum with the MILF.
The BBL, when passed, shall build the political trust that is necessary to
enable the national and regional governments to share leadership and resources
to build a strong democratic system based on our Constitutionwhere the voice
of the people is supreme and decisions are made in their interest and welfare.
108
OPAPP Sec. Deles briefs Pres. Aquino who is flanked by members of the cabinet
and representatives of the MILF leadership as they head to the PDF. (Photo by
Malacaang Photo Bureau)
OPAPP Sec. Deles and Chair Ferrer talk to The Asia Foundations Dr. Steven Rood
and Australian Embassys First Secretary Warren Hoye during a break at the PDF
in Davao. Behind them (standing) is World Banks Sam Chittick. (Photo by OPAPP)
109
The Bangsamoro Development Plan shall ensure that the wealth of the
region, reinforced by the wealth of the entire nation, is deployed to serve the
common good and welfare, and the true ends of social justice.
I salute the MILF and the BDA for their sterling service to country
in coming up with a development plan drafted by the Bangsamoro for the
Bangsamoro.
Let me also recognize the enormous contribution of government institutions
such as the NEDA, DOF, ARMM and other national line agencies, individual
consultants, and other experts who assisted the BDA and MILF in drafting
this plan.
Finally, we acknowledge the support and inputs of our partners from the
World Bank, JICA, the UN, and other friends and allies in the international
community.
Lets all roll up our sleeves for the implementation phase. Mindanao cannot
wait. The Filipino people cannot wait.
Let us welcome the bright dawn and the Bangsamoro that will rise into a
new day.
Thank you so much. Shukran.
Keynote Address
Whenever I get the chance, I make it a point to thank anyone and everyone
who helped us throughout the peace process with the Moro Islamic Liberation
Front. For instance, just the other day, when I met with a number of journalists
from Japan, I reiterated our gratitude to their country, for helping to facilitate
an early meeting between myself and our brothers from the MILF, a meeting
in which both sides were reassured of the others sincerity, and in which we
began to rebuild trust.
I do this because the value of lasting peace for a region like Mindanao is
beyond measure. For years, our countrymen in areas affected by conflict had been
shackled by violence, injustice, and impunity; they were deprived of opportunities
to succeed; and prosperity was seemingly reserved only for a few. Now, however,
as Mindanao is becoming an increasingly stable environment, we can see that
the region is on the cusp of a profound transformation: from being a Land of
Promise to being a Land of Promises Fulfilled.
In March of this year, the efforts of everyone involved in the peace process
culminated in the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro, a final
peace agreement between the Philippine Government and the MILF. Now,
more than ever, it is vital that we focus on getting through the next steps in
the process: getting the Bangsamoro Basic Law passed in Congress, which
110
111
Our work to ensure the success of the peace process runs parallel with our
ongoing efforts to eliminate systems that are prone to abuse, and to uplift our
countrymen in the region, even before the Bangsamoro Basic Law is passed.
After all, attaining peace also means eliminating unjust milieus, or situations
dire enough that people begin seeing violence as a solution.
This thinking has guided our efforts in Mindanao from day one. It is why
one of our first major institutional reforms was the synchronization of the
elections in the Autonomous Region of Muslim Mindanao with our national
elections. It laid the foundations for change by forcing those running for office
to contend with one another on a level playing field. In effect, it put an end to
the abuse of elections by national and local leaders alike, and to the mindset that
ARMM communities were mere vote banks that one could sell to the highest
bidder during national elections.
Government has likewise been active in expanding the menu of opportunities
for our countrymen in conflict-ridden areas. After all, no one can deny that they
have been deprived of legitimate opportunities to succeed, which is why we are
giving them a significant boost up, so that they may catch up. This is what we
aim to do with the Sajahatra Bangsamoro Program. Through the SBP, we are
improving the living conditions of several Bangsamoro communities by offering
cash for work, technical vocational training, study grants, and health insurance
premiums, amongst others. The goal: to give them the necessary skills and services
to take advantage of opportunities that arise, and to allow them to win back
control of their destinies. We are confident that the Bangsamoro Development
Plan can be harmonized with these efforts, and build on the progress we have
made at the soonest possible time.
112
and other infrastructure projects in Mindanao, and next year, the government
Congress willingintends on investing even more. For 2015, the DPWH budget
for Mindanao will be at P63.13 billion.
There has also been a sea of change in terms of business interest in Mindanao.
The numbers, again, tell the story: In the Davao Region alone, inbound missions
of companies from Japan, China, Korea, and other members of the Brunei
Indonesia Malaysia PhilippinesEast Asia Growth Area have drastically
increased, from 18 in 2012, to 37 in 2013, and to 51 in just the first ten months
of 2014. On top of this, we have heard of plans to expand and diversify from
several companies from vastly different industriesfrom energy, to coconut
products, to palm oil, and various other consumer products.
Indeed, more than at any other point in history, the Mindanao we all aspire
for is within reach. The progress is palpable, and it is apparent that our efforts
are having a profound effect. Nevertheless, I believe that, in forums like this, we
are given an opportunity to contribute our individual voices, with the goal of
accelerating the positive change in the region, and we must take full advantage
of such opportunities.
113
Pres. Aquino delivers his message before over 500 delegates from various development partners
and investors attending the special Philippines Development Forum (PDF) on the Bangsamoro
at the SMX Convention Center in Davao City on 5-6 November 2014. He was joined on stage by
(seated, LR) DBM Sec. Florencio Abad, DILG Sec. Mar Roxas II, MILF Vice-Chair for Political Affairs
Ghadzali Jaafar, DOF Sec. Cesar Purisima, MILF Chair Al Haj Murad Ebrahim, NEDA Sec. Arsenio
Balisacan, MILF Panel Chair Mohagher Iqbal, and OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles. (Photo by
Malacaang Photo Bureau)
With the help of everyone present here today, I am certain we can do much
more. If we continue thinking of new, better ways to accelerate development
in the region; if we continue to work with perseverance and creativity; and,
above all, if we always remember that the end goal of our efforts is to uplift our
fellowmen and allow them to live full, dignified lives, then I am certain we will
achieve what we have hoped for all these years. Together, we will realize our
vision of a new Mindanao: one seen by the global community as a region of
skilled, talented, and peace-loving people, of vast natural gifts, and of boundless
progress and prosperity.
Thank you for your time and good day.
Commencement Address
Media reports tell us that some quarters have questioned the wisdom of
honoring at your commencement exercises three personalities caught in the eye
of that very storm. That is why I find doubly heartwarming Xavier Universitys
decision to stand by its invitation and to confer on my colleagues the Fr.
William Masterson, SJ Award and on myself an Honorary Doctorate in the
Humanitieswhich, I must confess, truly thrills me because there is no other
way I could ever earn a postgraduate degree in the normal way.
Thank you, XU, for giving me my first toga custom-made for me. I shall
wear it proudly. I am delighted to be a member of Batch 2015!
I started my peace work in 1986, shortly after we ousted the dictator through
the worlds first ever people power uprising. After decades of painstaking effort
to push the cause of peace not just in Mindanao but in the entire country, seeking
to address all armed conflicts that continue to divide the Filipino nation, it is
an oddly strange experience to now be pilloried and damned for standing up
for peace. It is oddly strangeand sadthat, in the face of such inexplicable
115
116
OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles (center) is bestowed by the Xavier University an honorary Doctor
of Humanities, honoris causa, for her contributions to peacebuilding and women empowerment
in Mindanao. (Photo by OPAPP)
117
little bit about myself beyond what has come out in media, which pieces of my
personal narrative will connect to the reality of the firestorm that threatens to
engulf our country today.
And so, in the course of the next half-hour or so, please allow me to share
with you two stories: the first is my own, and the second is the tale of conflict
in Mindanao. And, thirdly, one or two things you and I can do to help pull us
through this murky chapter of our countrys history.
With your permission, I dare to begin with my story:
Here I must confess that I had in fact already drafted a few pages when I
asked myself: Will I not be boring you to tears, if not to death, with my account
of been there, done that?
Four-and-a-half decades ago, I was sitting where you are now, fresh out
of college and ready to plunge into lifes heady waters. As an English major
graduate of Maryknoll College in Quezon City (neighboring school to Ateneo
de Manila), I thought I knew early what I would be: a writer. Yes, a writer.
But I also knew I had nothing to write about, as yet, so I proceeded to gather
much-needed experience by accepting a job teaching English literature and
composition to high school senior students at my alma mater.
118
alone owns the platform. After one year of full-time teaching, I decided I had had
enough of the hard work. But it was fun, and I know my students still remember.
My second insight is this: Know your DNA, and affirm the best that it has
given you.
You see, why not? has led me down the path of alternative education,
alternative careers, alternative parenting, alternative lifestylesa cultural
revolution, no less, when you are up against martial law. It has led me to leave
teaching; embark on the then-untraveled, meandering path of non-profit NGO
work; enter government in my golden years, and then leave it before the term was
ended. It led me to take up public service a second time with a president who
pointed the way to a straight pathDaang Matuwid. Why not? has caused
me to choose to stand upeven when batteredagain and again for peace.
But let me start where I should.
In 1972, it rained for forty days over Central Luzon and students of
Ateneo de Manila, where I was employed as a project officer in its extension
office, volunteered to help flood victims, first through relief work which
quickly transitioned to rehabilitation and social development undertakings.
This involvement would also impact on their own lives. With social work as a
weekend commitment, it compelled these middle- and upper-class students to
119
This quest for alternative careers was born in the disconnect between
weekday and weekend. And so, Social Development Index, or INDEX for short,
came into being which I founded along with Karen Taada and Jojo Deles, who
would become my life partner in embracing the joys of marriage and family
life and the challenges of our lifetime social causes. INDEXs motto could very
well have been: Not all roads lead to Makati, for corporate life is not the only
choice there is. Pursuing a cycle of action and reflection, inspired by the author
of Conscientization, Brazilian Paulo Freire, we realized that social structures are
propped up by the kind of lifestyles we maintain. So how to develop an alternative
lifestyle? How can you be an alternative doctor? How can your profession be
of service to others?
Service should infuse ones whole life and work, and not be a mere salve of
conscience undertaken during weekends.
INDEX was founded after five years of martial rule. For student activists,
Marcoss declaration of martial law had laid out the stark choice of giving
up the fight and embracing convention or dropping out of school and going
underground. But we found there could be another way. A more nuanced
response was possible: Go for training, finish a course, yes, but serve the people
in your chosen profession or vocation. And, having chosen another way, you
needed back-up. You had to develop a counter-culture, a group to travel with,
otherwise kakainin ka or you risked burn-out.
And so, law graduatesonce they passed the barformed alternative law
groups, such as SALIGAN, to do lawyering for farmers, labor unions, and
battered women. Graduates of medical and nursing courses set up alternative
health centers, such as Healthdev, which sent doctors to the barrios and
explored and promoted alternative, meaning more natural, healing practices. I
look around me today and see familiar faces who had passed through INDEX
formation programsI knew Frs. Bobby Yap, Karel San Juan, Cel Reyesalso
Jet Villarin and Danny Huangwhen they were transitioning from school
to profession or vocationwhich must tell people how truly old I am! Atty.
Tony La Vias wife, Titay, was an INDEX girl. In fact, it may be said that the
core of the first-generation NGO community had been very much shaped or
influenced by INDEX. Truly, the pursuit of why not? has led to meaningful
paths and new possibilities.
120
OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles, GPH Panel Chair Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer and MILF Panel
Chair Mohagher Iqbal at the start of the 76th Commencement Exercises of the Xavier University
Ateneo de Cagayan on 26 March 2015 with Xavier University President Roberto C. Yap SJ (center)
and Archbishop of Cagayan de Oro Most Rev. Antonio J. Ledesma, SJ, D.D. (far right). (Photo by
OPAPP)
You see, while pursuing their alternative careers, the INDEX people were also
meeting and falling in love and marrying. The problem started when the children
came. HE pursued his career unencumbered, but SHE now had the double
burden of work, as in a job, and babies. Where did such blatant inequality spring
from? And so, my INDEX work led to yet another questing and questioning,
another door opening: that of gender, starting with the formation of PILIPINA,
which is arguably the first home-grown explicitly feminist organization in the
country. We probed the dynamics of mother-daughter relations, we reshaped
parenting to achieve more equal sharing of its responsibilities as well as its joys,
we created alternative rituals to mark the passages in our lives. I could go on for
hours, but I will not because, yes, I knowwe have time limits.
121
Let me just say that the tension, and partnership, between the genders
constitutes such a central and delicious and non-negotiable part of my life. I could
not have developed my other abiding passion, my lifes work of peace, without it.
What I have given you is a glimpse of my personal narrative. We all have
our personal narratives. Knowing from whence we came defines us, gives us
roots and a sense of identity, becomes source of our strength to face whatever
fate may have in store for us. We treasure our personal narrative and we try to
do our best to protect it so that we can bequeath it, proud and untarnished, to
our children to be passed on to their children and the generations still to come.
How much more if it is a collective narrative? How much more if it is
a collective narrative that goes back since time immemorial incorporating
remembrance of past glory as well as torment over heart-breaking tragedies?
How much more if it is, as the 1987 Philippine Constitution asserts is true for
two regions of the country, namely, Muslim Mindanao and the Cordilleras
regions which share (and I quote from the Philippine Constitution) a common
and distinctive historical and cultural heritage, economic and social structures,
and other relevant characteristics ?
And so I now turn to the other narrative. Let me talk about Mindanao
your Mindanao, our Mindanao. And since this simple primer style is not hard
to do, let me continue in this manner. In this second half of my speech, let me
raise four questions:
My other grand passion, peace, really took off with EDSA. EDSA in 1986
was a nonviolent peoples uprising that marked the end of martial law. It was
as if the conflict in Mindanao had ended. A pall had lifted from our lives after
fifteen long years.
People from the various social movements were undertaking their sectoral
agenda, and the Cory Aquino government was initiating peace talks with the
CPP-NPA-NDF. Members of the unarmed social movements, who had also
122
fought the dictatorship but never took up arms, felt that the peace talks were too
important to be left to the combatants. We, unarmed citizens, were stakeholders
too and we needed to have our agenda in, hindi lang agenda nila. Besides, what
if both sides, the government and the communist insurgents, hardened in their
positions, as in fact they did? What if one side walked out, as in fact happened?
What then? And so the Coalition for Peace was born.
But peace was not a sometime thing which people rallied around when
there was gulo somewhere. Peace work was not seasonal but was constant,
ever-watchful, building and rebuilding as many times as needed. And so the
Gaston Z. Ortigas Peace Institute, or GZO, was founded by Karen Taada, Risa
Hontiveros, and myself, with males like Ed Garcia and Randy David helping in
the birthing. GZO provided greater rigor and structure to peace work.
Let me now turn to my next question:
123
Now I wish to talk about faultlines. We know about the faultlines on the
surface of the earth, which, when there is a movement of the rock on either side,
releases energy which causes an earthquake. But there are faultlines etched in our
national psyche as welldivisions or rifts based on philosophical, ideological,
religious, or ethnic differences, which may lie undisturbed for years but so quickly
flare into vicious if not violent confrontation when provoked, often unintended,
sometimes by accident.
I wish to talk about two particular faultlines that help explain the
undercurrent of anger and resentment against the MILF and Muslims. The
Mamasapano tragedy has brought to boiling point this anger and resentment,
which, in turn, threaten to emasculate, if not derail, the Bangsamoro Basic Law.
The first faultline, divide if you will, is them vs. us, the second is north vs.
south. Them vs. us bespeaks of a deep-seated dualism cemented by culture
and history. It relates to the Crusades in Europe that waged war against the
Muslim Moors to reclaim the Holy Land. When the Spaniards came to the
Philippines, Moors would be transmuted into the Moros of the south. Spanish
colonial Catholicism then painted Muslims as the otherthe heathen, the
infidel. That this dualism is bred into our psyche resurfaced into light in the
wake of Mamasapano: Traydor ang Muslim, Hindi pwedeng pagkatiwalaan
ang Moro. And the unspoken: Let the BBL pay the price.
Party-list representative Djalia Hataman shared this story on television
with Boy Abunda recently. At a leadership training seminar in Basilan, she
asked a young woman from Al Barka what she wanted most, and the woman
said: Saan po ba kami makakuha ng ID o certificate o kahit anong kasulatan na
nagsasabing mabubuting tao kami? (Where can we get an ID or certificate or
whatever document that says that we are good people?)
The second divide is north vs. south: Divide and conquer. Spanish
colonizers pitted local chieftains against each other, as in the Battle for Mactan,
for which we immortalize the fearless Lapu-Lapu with a fish and a song. The
north-south divide has ramified over time, taking root in the most unlikely
places, as in Mindanao and Cebu joining forces against an imperial Manila
at NGO assemblies.
In the furor ensuing over Mamasapano, we see a difference in the calls
coming out of the south and north. Why is it that wars alarms ring loudest in
the safe confines of Congress, for instance? But close to ground zero, the people
flee even as they cry out for peace. Other sectors in Mindanao have publicly
124
issued appeals for peace as well: the religiousboth Christian and Muslim,
businessboth big and micro, the academe, civil society. And rightly so, because
Mindanao bears the brunt of the fighting, although the entire country must pay
the price of war. Which brings me to my next question:
What are the costs of the conflict?
Fresh statistics are staggering: It is reported that there are now well over
100,000 refugees since the military launched its offensive against the Bangsamoro
Islamic Freedom Fighters (BIFF) barely one month ago. And it costs 2 million
pesos daily to feed those who seek shelter in evacuation centers. But the statistics
are chilling if we start counting from the year 2000 throughout most of the
decade, when war became a way of life and evacuation was synonymous with
survival for whole populations in Central Mindanao and elsewhere.
For most of the decade, the death toll on both sides, including civilians and
combatants, was pegged at 150,000. But other sources say it could be double that
number. And that is speaking of the dead. The living must go on living even if
it means being nearly forever on the run.
Do you know why the GPH panel defends to their last tattered nerve the
peace process with the MILF? For three years, the ceasefire heldfor three years,
beleaguered families and communities experienced a sense of normalcy, planting
their crops and harvesting them, enrolling their ten-year-olds in first grade,
buying pots and pans and new clothes, daring to dream for their childrens future.
Deaths we can count. Budgets we can figure out. Injuries we can treat. But
there are wounds that cannot heal.
Congresswoman Sandra Sema of Maguindanao tells the story of a woman
she met when she visited an evacuation site housing the new, although perhaps
not first-time, evacuees in her province. The woman had a daughter, around
eight years old. The woman recounted how a soldier had come to talk to her
and, while they were talking, started patting her daughter on the head. She
asked the soldier, Do you have a daughter of the same age? Yes, he said. The
woman told Bai Sandra she suddenly felt pity in her heart for him. She and her
daughter were at least safe together at the evacuation site, but it was possible
that he would not return to his daughter alive.
And quoting Sitti Djalia again, who, in turn, quotes a soldier friend of hers:
The moment you decide to go to war, you lose your humanity. In war, there
are no winners, only losers.
125
Finally: What will it take to break this impasse, in the short term, and to transform
the conflict, in the long term?
There are many things to say, many thoughts to share, many feelings to
vent. But let me end with words from two women, one a Muslim, the other
myselfa Christian.
Let us celebrate our diversity, honor our differences and affirm our
commonalities. We pray to the same God (Allah for Muslims)a God of peace,
justice, love, and compassion.
And our greetings are nearly identical, word for word. The Christian
salutation Peace be with you elicits the response And also with you. The
Muslim greeting Assalamu AlaikumPeace be with you evokes the reply Wa
Alaikum AssalaamAnd upon you be peace.
Let us stop fighting and killing each other. That is a dead end. Let us beat
our swords into plowshares and turn our spears into pruning hooks. Let us
overcome the enmity, bias, and prejudice of generations and share time and
space, weave our dreams together, so that, finally, The Bangsamoro story is also
the story of the Filipino.
Again, thank you from the bottom of my heart, and good day.
In the midst of all of these, it needed courage to stand firm, to call for
sobriety and reason.
The other members of the Board: Dr. Antonio La Via, Dr. Dulce
Dawang, Madam Ma. Teresa Alegrio, Mr. Manuel Engwa, Mr.
Eduardo Pelaez, and Bienvenido Santos;
126
127
GPH Panel Chair Miriam Coronel Ferrer and MILF Panel Chair Mohagher Iqbal with Xavier University
President Roberto C. Yap SJ (center) present their newly received Fr. William F. Masterson SJ Awards
for their exemplary contribution to the Mindanao peace process. (Photo by OPAPP)
Our beloved Jesuit priests who sit on the Board: Fathers Antonio
Moreno, Joel Tabora, Mars Tan, Rene Tacastacas, Celerino Reyes,
Eric Velandria, and Karel San Juan.
Gayun din kay Mayor Oscar Moreno of Cagayan de Oro, at
Archbishop Antonio Ledesma, guests of honor.
When the fog of Mamasapono hovered thickly over the political landscape
Fr. Yap raised the question: Should Xavier University still proceed in conferring
the awards?
This, he asked, in his moving piece published by the Philippine Daily Inquirer
on 25 February 2015.
And the answer was a statement of conviction: We believe that the answer
should be yes.
128
That conviction moved me to tears. I had held these tears back, even as, in
the televised hearings of the congressional hearings, we saw big men shed tears.
The tears that I shed were of gratitude. Gratitude to all of you who have
taken the trouble to tell us that we are not alone.
The tears were also born out of admirationfor the courage to speak up
against the prevailing sentiments, in the belief that, using Fr. Yaps words: The
spirit of peace is the Holy Spirit of God. It can soar over ashes and shattered
houses and give hope where seemingly there is none.
Dear Xavier University leaders, your decision was and remains controversial.
I thank you for your courage in upholding the 29 November decision of the
Board of Trustees to confer the Masterson Award to Mr. Mohagher Iqbal and
myself, and the doctor of humanities, honoris causa to Secretary Deles today,
graduation day.
Kami pong tatlotulad ng kalakhan sa inyoay Pilipino, kapwa ninyo
Pilipino. Sanay di na kailangan pang ipakita ni G. Mohager Iqbal ang kanyang
passport para patunayan sa inyo na siya ay isang Filipino citizen. Bagamat, kung
ang iba sa atin ay ituturing ang sarili na Ilokano, Bisaya, Tagalog, ang turing po
ni G. Iqbal sa kanyang sarili ay Bangsamoro.
Ang tingin ko po kay Fr. William Masterson ay kindred spirit. Tulad niya,
marami kaming pagsubok na dinaanan sa pagtulak ng aming misyon.
At marami pang nakaabang.
Like the advocates of the peace process, Fr. Masterson was misunderstood
and became the subject of controversy when he made the bold move of
transferring Ateneo de Manila to Quezon City.
We are honored to follow the footsteps, experience the pain, and draw
courage from the great pioneer after whom this award is named, Fr. William
Masterson, SJ.
129
We follow his footsteps and walk together with all past awardees and all of
you who believe in this journey.
***
And yet peace seems hard to achieve. War has, in fact, figured prominently
in human history.
Tingnan na lang natin kung paano natin minamarkahan ang mga kalendaryo
ng ating buhay at kasaysayan.
Older folks who experienced World War II, refer to prewar, wartime, and
postwar. Our history books are splattered with all the great and fateful battles
fought, lost or won. Our images of the past are of battle cries and flag-waving
with a bolo or a gun in hand.
More often, we commemorate revolutions, but not the end of wars, nor the
forging of peace.
It asks us to put aside pride, and to respect the feelings of the other persona
friend, a neighbor, even a complete stranger.
Hinihingi ng landas na mapayapa ang kabutihan sa lahat ng tao. Abraham
Lincoln in his inaugural called this the better angels of our nature.
130
To seek peace is to nurture trust. The scriptures said, Love your enemies
For if you love those who love you, what recompense would you have? And
if you greet your brothers only, what is unusual about that? Of course you must
also love and greet your sisters, and all the others who are different from you.
Peace indeed is tough love. Do be perfect the verse goes on, just as your
heavenly Father is perfect.
Wow! We all know how hard it is to be perfect! How often do you get
perfect scores on your test? Maybe only Paolo here, your class valedictorian and
summa cum laude, who gets perfect scores in Math.
Peace can only mean constant striving.
Peace requires new templates. It is so much easier to do the same things the
same way. So much easier to stay within ones or the institutions comfort zones.
But to seek peace means taking extraordinary steps to change the patterns
of our human existence, of politics and society.
That is why to seek peace, is to be bold, to take risks.
Who would question the wisdom and foresight now of a green and sprawling
Ateneo de Manila campus along Katipunan Avenue?
***
We knew that the signing of the CAB on 27 March 2014 was just the
beginning. Like in a graduation ceremony, it marked what one has achieved
after years of hard work. But it also signalled the beginning of the next phase
in a graduates life: survival, success in the real world.
131
Mindanao, the Bangsamoro, are not monolithic entities. There are multiple
narratives, multiple identities, multiple claimants and stakeholders. There must
be a just share of the benefits for everyone. There must be a just recognition of
the rights and legitimacy of the different stakeholders. Peace dividends are not
spoils of war. There must be equitable distribution of the dividends of peace.
We are proud to say that the ceasefire between the government and the
MILF has remained steadfast, with no direct hostilities taking place between
the two parties since November 2011until Mamasapano, on 25 January 2015.
Even so, that ceasefire has been restored. Mahirap isipin kung ano ang
sitwasyon ngayon kung sumabog muli ang gera, di lamang sa BIFF kundi pati
na sa MILF.
Right now, the biggest challenge is how to recover and sustain public trust
and support for this peace process. Andyan pa naman ang tiwala, pero di pa sapat.
We know we need to continue to engage the members of Congress and the
general public on the many items that would need to get into the law in order
to put in place a more democratic, accountable and representative autonomous
government in the Bangsamoro.
We call on the Congress of the Philippines to give this to the Bangsamoro as
their legacy. The House of Representatives under the leadership of Cagayan de Oro
Representative Rufus Rodriguez and Speaker Feliciano Belmonte have gone out of
their way to shepherd this process. It already held thirty-six consultations nationwide
and spent millions of peoples money to get all the input and inform the public.
132
Sec. Deles, Chair Ferrer and Chair Iqbal pose with officials from Xavier University. Also in photo
are Xavier University Pres. Robert C. Yap SJ (left), Xavier University Board of Trustees member
and Ateneo Law School Dean Tony La Via (third from right, at the back row) and Cagayan de Oro
Archbishop Most Rev. Antonio J. Ledesma, SJ, D.D. (rightmost). (Photo by OPAPP)
This opportunity that will end the fighting between the government and
the MILF is too good to pass on to the next Congress.
Dear friends and mentors, in the next months, there will be ups and downs,
even more eruptions of some kind of violence that cast doubts on the viability
of the process, although I pray that Mamasapano is already the worst thing
that could happen.
Certainly, we cannot lose heart.
Were on our toes. We have taken the leap of faith, but our eyes are wide
open.
Courage is supposedly a quality of the mind and spirit.
But the root word in Latin from which it is drawn means heart. So it must
be all of thesemind, spirit, heart. A certain mastery of the totality of ones
being, a center of gravity that touches the ground.
Lapat sa lupa habang inaabot ang alapaap.
Speech
Mohagher Iqbal
CHAIR, MILF PEACE PANEL
Frankly speaking, since I was informed of this award, I have never stopped
asking myself whether or not I am worthy of this recognition. Reading on the
life and work of Fr. Masterson who was a man of exceptional foresight that even
the great General Douglas MacArthur was said to have invited him to Manila
to set up a relief program for children that distributed medicine, clothing and
food stuff, one can feel a little bit awed. I am, however, consoled by the fact that
we share the same sentiments when he once said that we had no right to exist
unless we immersed ourselves in the problems of our milieu.
I guess that this is the challenge to every one of us who had the opportunity
to go to school. That once we have acquired the rudimentary skills and knowledge
in school, we should: all immerse ourselves in the problems of our times. For
what good is education if not to solve the more complex problems of our times?
Looking back at my own personal journey, after I defended my thesis and was
awarded my masters degree in political science in 1972, I went straight to
immerse myself in the milieu of my time: the Bangsamoro Problem.
I headed straight into the jungle and joined the Moro National Liberation
Front (MNLF). Initially, I was a foot soldier and then rose to become a political
officer. We were even forced not to use our legal names and use aliases to protect
our families and friends from retaliation and retribution by the Martial Law
regime. Our goal, however, was fundamental: to defend the lives and properties
133
134
of the Moros, who were then already the object a genocidal campaign by the
Martial Law regime in Manila.
To go to the forest and take up arms was not an easy decision to make. It was
not for sheer desire of adventure or the need for limelight and fame that pushed
me to barter a life of safety in the city to one that was laden with dangers in
the jungle. On at least three occasions, I had brushes with death. On the lighter
side, food was scarce and at times none at all. At one time, my group and I had
to survive by eating kangkong for three straight days, because we were sealed off
from the outside by government troops.
Furthermore, it was not bravery that made me stay to this day in the
service of the MILF. It was rather my commitment to the cause of my people
for deliverance that made me persevere in all those four decades of trials and
tribulations.
In the beginning, the word peace was never part of the vocabulary of the
day. Of course, as a Muslim, I know the value of peace, because it is ingrained
in Islam, which means peace. I knew also that war is temporary, because man
is necessarily peaceful.
At that time, the only things the government offered to us were bullets and
bombsor surrender. By then thousands of Moros had already died in the hands
of state forces and their paramilitary allies. This started from the massacre of
sixty-four Moro trainees in Corregidor Island in March 1968 to the onslaught
of the so-called fanatic group called Ilagas (rats) in 1970 to 1971. These mass
slaughters worsened since the declaration of Martial Law in September 1972
and onward.
It is true that peace negotiations had commenced as early as 1975 that led
to the signing of the Tripoli Agreement in Tripoli, Libya, the following year.
This culminated in 1996 when the GRP-MNLF Final Agreement on Peace
was signed between the government and MNLF. But judging from what had
ensued therefrom, those agreements were not meant to solve the armed conflict
in Mindanao and secure permanent peace therein, but rather, they were used to
perpetuate the effective strangulation of the Moros.
In the case of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, to which organization
I belonged since 1977, we waited for twenty long years before we had the
chance to talk peace with the government. This happened in January 1997 when
President Fidel Ramos offered the olive branch of peace to the MILF. Perhaps
135
unknown to most of you, the ceasefire agreement was signed here in Cagayan
de Oro City on 18 July 1997.
And all of these work, commitment, and sacrifice are for people like you.
Come to think of it, my dear graduates! It is you, the youth and young of today,
who will reap the fruits of peace in the future. It is not us, your elders, who will
benefit from this. I urge you, therefore, to join our journey of peace! Speak up
and be heard! Ask questions. Propose solutions. The future is yours. You have
a stake in it.
Finally, let me say once again my heartfelt gratitude for this recognition of
our efforts at building peace. I say our because while I personally accept this
award, I accept this on behalf of all those who seek and strive for peaceboth
Bangsamoro and Filipino. Peacemaking is never a one mans effort. It is the
collective effort of men and women of goodwill who seek a better and peaceful
future for the next generation.
To end, let me paraphrase a quote from Thomas Paine: We fight not to
enslave, but to set a nation free and to make room upon the earth for honest
men and women to live.
As you graduate from formal schooling this morning, let that be our common
resolve: Not to enslave but to make space for honest men, women, and children
to live their lives in peace, in abundance, in faith.
Thank you very much, and good morning to all.
Awarding Ceremony,
Hillary Rodham Clinton Award
for Advancing Women,
Peace, and Security
22 April 2015
Georgetown University, Washington DC
Acceptance Speech
our Excellencies:
It provides a road map for a new set of more democratic, representative, and
accountable political institutions.
It taps diverse modes for delivering socioeconomic programs to
decommissioned combatants, the internally displaced, and communities long
affected by the conflict.
The Agreement also seeks ways to carry out transitional justice, to thread
together the tattered fabric of social life and heal the wounds of centuries of
conflict that began under Spanish and American colonial rule. We hope it will
reconcile families, political groups, tribes, and communities alienated from each
other by prejudice, vendetta, and injustice.
137
138
Finally, the agreement of March 2014 offers a model for conflict resolution
and politically negotiated solutions to armed conflicts. It drew from experiences
in Northern Ireland and Aceh, and it now informs ongoing efforts in Myanmar
and Southern Thailand.
***
Three out of six government signatories to the agreement are women, with
myself as the Chair. The MILF panel were all men. In all, just three of the twelve
signatories are women. Still, its a big leap: Nearly all past negotiations were
exclusively done by men.
These three women were not alone. They were backed up by a strong and
active contingent of women outside of the formal table. From them, we got
the strength and fortitude to see the process through, a delightful dynamic of
women inspiring fellow women.
Our peace process, indeed, was informed by the very goals of this award:
to protect women against all forms of violence and advance the role of women
in attaining peace and security in and outside of their homes. I speak especially
of the women in the Bangsamoro, who have endured the burden of strife, and
who must now secure their places in the public sphere as equal partners in peace
and development.
***
The road to peace has not been easy. The momentum toward peace almost
ground to a halt last January, when Special Action Forces of the Philippine police
launched an offensive against militants belonging to the Jemaah Islamiyah. The
operation took place in the vast marshland of Central Mindanao where MILF
members also reside.
139
of resentment against the MILF, the peace agreement, and the draft law that
would establish a new autonomous government in Muslim Mindanao.
Before long, the public discourse slid into bigotry against the Moros, the
MILF, as well as Muslims in general. Centuries of distrust and hatred resurfaced.
Lost in the vitriol were the goals of the process: to stop the bloodletting that had
counted more than 120,000 lives lost in combat since the 1970s; to bring to the
fold the biggest non-state armed group in the country, and enable its moderate,
reformist leadership to prevail over the more radical and violent ideologues.
As I speak right now, the ceasefire remains in place. But the vision of lasting
peace is being shut out by the narrow horizons of certain political elites, and
by a public fed with misinformation and driven by prejudices bordering on
Islamophobia.
And misogyny, too. If former secretary Hillary Rodham Clinton has been
called a funny lady in the course of her drive to find peaceful solutions and
creative compromises in one area of conflict, I in turn have been called a dumb
bitch, a traitor, and a weak negotiator who bartered away the country to the
Muslims/Moros.
Ms. Clinton wrote in her book, Hard Choices: It is the unfortunate reality
that women in public life still face an unfair double standard an outrageous
sexism, which shouldnt be tolerated in any country.
I know only too well how true this is. Yet we have gone this far in our peace
process. There should be no turning back.
I am now a grandmothermy granddaughter, along with my sister Sheila
Coronel, is here with me today. I dont want Kaleigh Ysabelle here to inherit a
country divided by prejudice, dishonored by sexism, and stunted by the narrow
vision of members of its political class.
I have met many, many grandmothers in Mindanao who reject the same,
and ask for respect and dignity for all.
Thank you Georgetown University Institute for Women, Peace, and
Security for this award, and to all you ladies and gentlemen for making peace
and rejecting war.
Special thanks also to all the other men and women who have provided our
work with all the back-up support. Maraming salamat po.
140
Chair Ferrer receives the Hillary Rodham Clinton Award for Advancing
Women in Peace and Security from former US Senator and Secretary
of State Hillary Rodham Clinton (center) and Georgetown University
President John J. DeGioia at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C.
on April 22 (April 23, PH time). (Photo by Georgetown University)
Ceremonial Decommissioning
of MILF Weapons and Combatants
16 June 2015
Old Provincial Capitol, Simuay, Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao
Mohagher Iqbal
CHAIR, MILF PEACE PANEL
142
143
The first road leads us to a dark and fearful Bangsamoro areawithout hope,
without peace, and without justice. It leads to a Bangsamoro where peoples lives
are shorter, where children do not have good education, where young men and
women have no jobs, where natural resources are exploited to the detriment of
the Bangsamoro people. It leads to a Bangsamoro where fear and insecurity reign
and tyranny continues. It is a sad and terrible wasteland. This is the preferred
scenario painted by those who do not want a good BBL or Bangsamoro Basic
Law to pass into law.
The second road leads to a Bangsamoro that is prosperous and free. It is a
Bangsamoro where children can dream to be whoever they want to be and are
given the opportunity to reach their dreams. It is a Bangsamoro where people are
healthy and live their lives in accordance with their deepest values and religion. It
is a Bangsamoro that is at peace and one with their brother and sister Filipinos.
It is a Bangsamoro with a bright future. This is the hope and aspiration of the
Philippine government under His Excellency President Benigno Simeon Aquino
III and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front led by Brother Chair Al Haj Murad
Ebrahim. This is also the hope and sincere expectation of the Government of
Malaysia, as third country facilitator, under His Excellency Prime Minister Dato
Sri Haji Mohamman Najin bin Tun Haji Abdul Razak.
Now the question: Which Bangsamoro do we choosea dark and insecure
Bangsamoro? Or a Bangsamoro that is happy and peaceful?
Frankly speaking, this decision is one of the most difficult decisions we have
made so far in more than four decades of harsh struggle. Whereas throughout the
course of history, we have always armed ourselves in defense of our homeland,
people, and Islam; but today, we have reversed the natural flow of that long
narrative. We have agreed to undertake this symbolic decommissioning of our
weapons and put them beyond use. We want to show the world that the MILF
will and will always comply with obligations set forth in signed peace agreements.
Today, we say to the whole world: If you want peace, prepare for peace.
144
People sometimes commit the mistake that firearms are our main strength.
They are wrong. Firearms are not the source of our main strength. We are a
minority in a small nation. We do not have armies. We do not have navies. We
almost have nothing. And yet, our main strength is the love, affection, and faith
of the Bangsamoro people. As long as the Bangsamoro people support us, we
shall persevere and we shall struggle. It is for the Bangsamoro people that we do
everything. The Bangsamoro people is the beginning and the end of our struggle.
In so doing, we beseech the Almighty to reward us in the day hereafter. Once
again, we say with more vigor: If we want peace, prepare for peace.
Thank you and good day to all!
Hours before the start of the program proper, members of a Joint Peace and Security Team (JPST)
brief the 145 men who made up the first batch of MILF-BIAF members decommissioned in June
2015. The former combatants underwent a registration process and have since been provided
basic services and capacity-building interventions through the Task Force for Decommissioned
Combatants and their Communities (TFDCC). (Photo by OPAPP)
Speech
Ang ating Malaysian facilitator Tengku Dato Ghafar; ang ating panels
kasama ko po ngayon ang iba pang kasapi ng government panels na sina dating
secretary Senen Bacani at Secretary Yasmin Busran Lao; ang JNC o ang Joint
Normalization Committee na siyang nangangasiwa sa kabuuang programa
ng normalisasyon sa pamumuno ni Usec. Zenonida Brosas at saka Mohamed
Nasif ng MILF; ang ating Independent Decommissioning Body na siyang
mangangasiwa sa decommissioning sa pamumuno ni Ambassador Haydar Berk;
ang Third Party Monitoring Team na magbabantay sa lahat ng implementasyon
na isasagawa natin sa kabuuan ng Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro,
sa pamumuno ng dating EU Ambassador na si Ginoong MacDonald; ang TJRC
o ang Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission na magbibigay sa atin
ng kanilang rekomendasyon kung anong dapat isagawa para maging tuloy-tuloy
na yung reconciliation and healing sa ating mga lugar na datiy apektado ng
145
146
Wala na sigurong iba kundi upang ipagpatuloy ang ating nasimulan. Our
main purpose here indeed is nothing else but to continue what we have started.
Sa kahabaan ng panahon natin nag-peace talk, sa labing-limang buwan na
sinimulan natin ang full blast implementation mula nang pirmahan natin ang
CAB noong Marso 2014, marami tayong naging pagsubok.
Naantala tayo sa kalakhan ng ating itinakda. Niyanig tayo sa init ng mga
tanong na itinapon sa atin sa harap ng mga kamerat matinding alingasngas ng
radyo na bumatikos sa ating layunin at gawa.
Ang desisyong ito ay hindi naging madali. Hindi ito isang subo ng kanin,
na dahil mainit ay basta iluluwa na lamang. Ito ay isang paninindigan.
Ano nga ba ang ibig sabihin ng decommissioning? Unang-una sa lahat,
hinding-hindi natin ginagamit ang salitang surrender o pagsuko dahil itong
prosesong ito ay naging bunga ng isang pag-uusap na nakabatay sa hustisya.
The process will fully respect the dignity of everyone concerned. To put beyond
useito ang ginagamit nating expression kaugnay ng decommissioning, isang
147
sitwasyon na wala nang gamit, wala nang silbi ang baril, wala nang saysay na
makipagdigma, dahil ang problema ay nahanapan na ng kalutasan.
IDB Member retired LtGen. Rey Ardo (left) guides MILF Chair Al Haj Murad Ebrahim and President
Benigno S. Aquino III as they inspect the 75 weapons and firearms of the MILF that were
decommissioned. Also with them are GPH Peace Panel Chair Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer and
OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles. (Photo by OPAPP)
148
Noong Janaury 16, inabot ng MILF ang listahan ng unang pitumputlimang baril na made-dekomisyon. (Yan ang nakikita ninyo ngayon dito sa
inyong likuran.)
The 145 Bangsamoro Islamic Armed Forces (BIAF) combatants undergo the process of registration
on 16 June 2015. The BIAF is the armed wing of the MILF. (Photo by OPAPP)
149
Ang mga opisina para sa IDB at ang mga mekanismo natin dito sa Cotabato
city ay naisaayos na.
Nakapagdaos na tayo ng training para sa siyam na kasapi ng JVMAT at
tatlumpung JPST na mapoposte dito sa arms storage site. Iba-ibang topic
din ang napag-aralan ng mga JPST tulad ng information-gathering, forensic
photography, security management, at protocols.
Naitalaga na natin ang mga kasapi ng ating Task Force for Camps
Transformation para sa anim na previously acknowledged MILF camps na siyang
mangangasiwa sa socioeconomic development program dito sa mga pamayanan
at sa general area nitong mga natukoy na kampo.
150
Gracing the Ceremonial Decommissioning of MILF weapons and combatants are (from left): GPH
Peace Panel Chair Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, DILG Sec. Mar Roxas, MILF Chair Al Haj Murad
Ebrahim, President Benigno S. Aquino III, OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles, Malaysian Facilitator
Tengku Dato Ab Ghafar Tengku Mohamed, DND Sec. Voltaire Gazmin, MinDA Chair Luwalhati
Antonino, IDB Chair Amb. Haydar Berk, ARMM Reg. Gov. Mujiv Hataman, and MILF Peace Panel
Chair Mohagher Iqbal (not in photo). (Photo by OPAPP)
katulad ninyo, sabi nila. Gusto rin namin ng marangal na hanapbuhay. Pagnanasa
rin namin ang maaliwalas na kinabukasan para sa aming pamilya. Hangad din
namin ang mapayapat maunlad na pamayanan. Kayo, kami ay pareho lang. Lets
give peace a chance. Ibalik natin ang tiwalat pagmamahal sa isat isa.
Sa madaling salita, ano nga ba ang rationale nitong pagtitipon natin? Ano
nga ba ang dahilan kung bakit andito tayo ngayon?
Wala na sigurong iba kundi: because we choose peace. Because we are staying
the course of peace, sa hirap at ginhawa, in sickness and in health. Hanggang
makarating tayo sa ating inaasam na patutunguhan.
Magtulungan po tayo.
Speech
As the IDB head, I want to thank the governments of Brunei and Norway
for their support to the IDB. As chairman, on behalf of the members of the
IDB, I would like to underline that we are proud to be part of this historic,
courageous peace process. We will perform the important task entrusted to us
meticulously and objectively.
Mr. President, together with Chairman Murad, you are writing history and
we want to congratulate both of you. I have no doubt that not only the present
generation, but also the next generations in the Philippines will admire your
visionary statesmanship as they enjoy peace and stability. The impact of this
process is not limited to the Philippines. It will also send strong signals of peace
and cooperation to the whole region and beyond.
They say that those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat
it. Today, we are realizing the first decommissioning; decommissioning of
seventy-five firearms and 145 combatants. Although it is regarded as a symbolic
one, it will be a role model for the subsequent ones. Besides, we are aware of
the difficulties of the way to peace. And, despite all these difficulties, I believe
this ceremony is a very significant step that demonstrates the sincerity and
commitment of the MILF to peace.
151
152
Yes, I refer to economic programs. But apart from it, as a normal, civilian
citizen, their safety and security, their rights under the Constitution of the
Philippines should also be ensured.
Speech
For some people, the event today is about statistics145 MILF fighters
and seventy-five firearms. But this is not about statistics. This is something
deeply personal to us.
As I look at the faces of each of our 145 brothers here this morning, I see
145 stories of struggle, of pain, of hopelessness, and even of death. Yet I also see
145 stories of hope and faith that indeed peace is near and that all the sacrifices
have been worth it. I see not only their stories but my story as well and the
stories of all the mujahideen that have given their lives, their intelligence, and
their talents to the struggle to protect the Bangsamoro people. What we have
today, then, are not the stories of only 145 fighters.
The road to this symbolic decommissioning has not been an easy one.
Frankly, within the MILF, our conversations on these matters still continue. This
is expected because the struggle is an integral part of our identity. This decision,
however, is rooted in our firm commitment to comply with the principled
agreements we have signed with the Philippine Government. This decision was
helped in part by the fact that we know that the President understands and feels
what we have been going throughhow it is to be under an oppressive regime,
to thirst for justice and to have a firm resolve that it should never happen again.
153
154
Some people think that allowing the start of decommissioning despite the
fact that the BBL is yet to be passed is a sign of weakness. It is not. It is a sign
of strength. For our strength lies not in firearms but in the love and affection of
the Bangsamoro people. Without the support of the Bangsamoro people, we
may have all the arms in the world and yet there will be no victory. But with the
affection and esteem of the Bangsamoro people intact and the platform to pursue
their best interests without undue interference, nothing would be impossible.
To allay the mistaken notion of some members of our society and the gross
misreading of information that some elements of the media seem to be invariable
predisposed to: this event is not a process of surrender.
The weapons that are gathered here are to be submitted to the International
Decommissioning Body (IDB), headed by the representative of Turkey with
members from Norway, Brunei, and two each from the GPH and MILF; and are
to be stored in a designated place agreed on by the Parties. This is an important
point in the decommissioning process that we have to be very clear about, lest
155
I am aware of the question that bugs everyones mind that casts undue
suspicion on the timing of the symbolic decommissioning given that the BBL,
which is the product of the FAB and the CAB, is still facing uncertainty in
Congress. I understand this feeling for I, too, was initially bothered by this
question of timing. However, as Muslims, we have to trust Allah Subhanahu Wa
Taala and affirm our duty and obligation in the peace agreement.
Nevertheless, let me reiterate our publicly pronounced position on the BBL.
We will only accept a BBL that is in compliance with the letter and spirit of
the FAB and CAB and its annexes. This is the official position of the Central
Committee of the MILF.
At any rate, it is our wish and hope that Congress will give full weight to
the peace agreements from where the BBL comes. Allow me to speak in our
own tongue for our people.
On this note, we thank again the President for his continued manifestation
of commitment and support to the peace process, the Malaysian Facilitator,
the Independent Decommissioning Body, representatives of the ICG, IMT,
the different structures and institutions of the GPH-MILF peace process,
representatives of UN Agencies, INGOs, NGOs, CSOs, and all those who
in one way or the other contributed to the advancement of the peace process.
Likewise, to all those who came to grace this historic event, thank you.
Assalamu Alaikum Warahmatullah Wabarakatuh.
156
157
158
Talumpati
ilang pambungad, hayaan ninyo pong ibahagi ko ang ilang bagay na naging
palaisipan sa akin sa mga lumipas na taon.
Dagdag pa: Kung ikaw nga ang nasa posisyon ng mga kapatid nating
inagawan ng lupa noong panahong iyon, hindi ka ba mawawalan ng pag-asa kung
lahat ng iyong lapitan ay tila iisa ang tono at ang tugon ay Walang magagawa
diyan? Isipin din po ninyo: Dahil sa alitan dito sa usaping agraryo, na walang
makuhang katarungan, inilagay nila sa kanilang mga kamay ang batas at nagusbungan ang mga grupong armado.
159
160
Sa ganitong sitwasyon, paano tayo aabot sa isang kasunduang katanggaptanggap sa lahat kung ang mga negosyador mismo ay walang tiwala sa isat isa?
Naisip ko nga po na ilang henerasyon ang bibilangin bago magkaroon ng tunay
na diyalogo. Isa nga po sa mga naging mungkahi ang magkaroon ng palitan ng
mga estudyante sa ating bansa. May mga kabataang taga-Mindanao na mag-aaral
sa Luzon at Visayas; at may mga taga-Luzon at Visayas na mag-aaral naman sa
Mindanao. Sa ganitong paraan, makakabuo ng mas matibay na relasyon ang mga
bagong henerasyon, at kapag sila na ang may tangan ng renda ng kapangyarihan,
makakapag-usap sila bilang magkakaibigan, imbis na bilang magkakaaway na
may kanya-kanyang mahabang listahan ng hinanakit. Matagal na proseso ito,
at malamang ay hindi ko na makikitang nagbubunga ng mga tulad kong hindi
na ganoon kabata.
Ito po ang dahilan kung bakit talagang makasaysayan ang araw na ito. Kung
babalik tayo ng ilang taon, isang napakalayong pangarap lang ang makitang
naglalatag ng armas ang isang armadong grupong matagal nang nakipaglaban
sa pamahalaan. Hindi lang isa, dalawa, o isang dosenang piraso ang armas
na pinag-uusapan natin dito. Ito po ay ilan sa pinakamataas na uri ng armas.
Moderno po ang mga ito at hindi pinaglumaan; ang mga armas na ito, kayang
magdulotat talagang nakapagdulot ngang matinding pagdurusa.
Mga Boss, kailangan ko pong bigyang-diin: Ang mga kapatid nating Moro
ay nangako, at heto ang pruweba ng kanilang katapatan sa ating harapan. Kusangloob pong inilatag ng ating mga kapatid ang kanilang armas. Alam nilang
161
nariyan pa rin ang banta ng karahasan mula sa mga private armed groups, pero
sa ginawa nilang ito, tila sinasabi nila sa atin: Kapatid, itong pantanggol namin
sa sarili namin, di na namin kailangan. Buong pagtitiwala naming ipinapaubaya
sa inyo ang aming kaligtasan. Kapatid, itong armas, puwede na naming ibaba
dahil naniniwala kaming kasama namin kayo sa kagustuhan naming baguhin
ang lipunan at buhay namin. Ginagawa nga nila ito kahit nakabitin pa ang
Bangsamoro Basic Law, at mangyayari pa lang ang Bangsamoro Transition
Authority.
162
163
ang lahat ng pagkakataon upang mabago nila ang kanilang buhay at maabot ang
kanilang mga pangarap. Pero ito nga po: Kung ang pananaw mo ay pahirapan ang
pagpasa ng batas, para mo na ring sinabing ipinagdamot natin ang dapat sanay
sa kanila; sinigurado nating wala silang pagkakataong umangat; ginarantiya
nating di na sila bababa sa bundok. Yan ang katumbas ng pagtutol po sa BBL.
Hindi nga puwedeng sasabihin mong para ka sa kapayapaan, pero
pinahirapan mo ang pagbabalangkas ng BBL. Yun bang di ka na nga nakontento
sa siyam na butas ng karayom, nagdagdag ka pa ng pansampu at panlabing-isa;
parang wala ka nang ibang hangarin kundi siguruhing walang puwang para sa
kapayapaan. Tulungan nga po ninyo ako: Ano po ba ang itutugon ko pag may
nagtanong sa akin, Saan ba yung konsensiya ng mga taong nagpapatagal ng
proseso para magkaroon tayo ng kapayapaan?
Daang libo na ang napinsala at namatay, at di na mabilang ang nawalan ng
tirahan at nasira ang komunidad, dahil sa apat na dekadang hidwaan. Kung di
ka pa papanig sa kapayapaan, ilan pa ang mamamatayan ng mahal nila sa buhay?
Ilang pamayanan pa ang maiipit sa putukan at kawalang seguridad? Ilan ang
naghihirap na lalo pang maghihirap? Gaano pa katagal bago kumatok sa sarili
mong pintuan ang kaguluhan at madamay ang sarili mong mag-anak?
n 27 March 2014, we, the Government and the Moro Islamic Liberation
Front (MILF), respectively represented here by myself and Prof. Abhoud
Lingga, signed the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro (CAB).
The Community of SantEgidio was a living witness to this event and
the many rounds of negotiations before the signing. The Community sits as a
member of the International Contact Group (ICG). It was ably represented by
none other than Seors Alberto Quartucci and Roberto Pietrolucci. I note with
honor and pleasure that also represented here is a member of the ICGthe
Indonesia-based Muhammadiyahwhich Prof. Din Samsyuddin, who is also
here with us in this panel, until recently chaired.
The International Contact Group is our own version of the third-party
Friends of the Process who accompanied the peace negotiators and the
Malaysian facilitator as observers, facilitators, advisers, and partners in the journey
to peace. (You can see all of us in this photo as we celebrated the signing of the
last annex to the agreement.)
It took seventeen years of negotiations to get us that peace agreement.
Many mini-wars before and even during the talks had erupted in the southern
part of the Philippines, where the minority Muslims or Moros, live. More than
120,000 people have died since the 1970s up to the 1990s. Millions have been
displaced from time to time. Children missed school, properties were destroyed,
and sickness haunted the evacuation centers.
What made the peace agreement that we are now implementing possible?
How did we get this far in our peace process despite the huge gap that divided us?
Social scientists talk about concepts like the balance of power, a hurting
stalemate, war fatigue, and so on as elements that affect the environment for
peaceful solutions.
All these do come to play. But there were definitely two things that made
the comprehensive peace agreement between us possible. Without these two,
we would not have gone this far.
165
166
MILF Panel Member Prof. Abhoud Syed Lingga (second from left) and GPH Panel Chair Prof. Miriam
Coronel Ferrer (second from right) during their panel discussion on September 7 at the International
Meeting of Peace organized by the Catholic lay organization, Community of SantEgidio in Tirana,
Albania. (Photo by the Community of SantEgidio)
These two elements are none other than trust and faith.
There were good reasons for the two parties to hesitate to trust each other.
Historical distrust due to legacy of Christianization under 500 years of Spanish
colonial rule and fifty years of the American colonial regime bred this distrust.
The Islamic sultanates resisted. Over the centuries, the Moros thus evolved a
different collective narrative and identity, different from the Filipino majority.
Outbreaks of hostilities, breakups of the 1997 ceasefirein 1999, 2000, 2001,
2008made wounds fresh. On and off peace talks did not build confidence in
both parties and among the general public.
When President Benigno Aquino III came to power in 2010, his
administration took extra steps to rebuild the trust.
In August 2011, the first face-to-face meeting happened between the
President and the head of the MILF, Ebrahim Murad. This extraordinary step
opened doors and allowed fresh air in.
167
Chair Ferrer (above) engages the audience with Nigerian Catholic Archbishop Kaigama Ignatius
Ayau (left) and Syrian Orthodox Church Archbishop Kawak Dionysius Jean listening intently. (Right
photo) MILF Panel Member Prof. Abhoud Syed Lingga sits as one of the speakers in the same
session. (Photos by the Community of SantEgidio)
Government has steadfastly defended the process before its many critics.
To the cry, All-Out War! it responded with All-Out Justice.
Government leadership stayed the course amid all the unfortunate violence
in these areas.
This is, after all, not a simple problem. There are many other armed groups
and different stakeholders such as the migrants who have settled here, and the
non-Moro indigenous peoples. Many see the complexity as reason to doubt the
process, or any process for that matter, as all complexities cannot be solved by
one process alone.
For its part, the MILF took pains to show that it was worthy of the trust. It
pledged that it would indeed demobilize and participate in democratic politics
through civic and party organizations.
For example, despite uncertainties, MILF cadres have proceeded with
building their political party called the United Bangsamoro Justice Party. Many
trainings have been conducted to prepare them for their future roles.
168
The many joint activities have kept this trust strong and worthy. Among such
undertakings are: maintaining the ceasefire, cooperatively dealing with ceasefire
violations, launching socioeconomic programs like the Sajahatra Bangsamoro,
repairing school buildings and providing free medical service and haircuts in
remote schools, and taking steps to decommission the weapons and combatants,
among others.
But trust alone was not enough to sustain our process. We needed to have
faith because that trust is challenged by every difficult phase of the process and
unwanted incidents. It can be challenged especially by those others who do not
trustpoliticians, other leaders, or ordinary folk who do not believe in giving
this peace a chance.
To give peace its best shot, we also needed to have faith to see us through.
This faith can be secularthe belief in social justice, in the humanity of all,
in the capacity of the other to deliver their part of the agreement.
It can be religious faithbelief in the sanctity of creation, that God shall help
those who help themselves, that the just shall be rewarded, that His will shall be
done. That in the bigger domain of the universe, there shall be order in chaos.
Without the trust in each other and the faith that our good intentions will
see us through, our process would not have withstood all the challenges. We
would have doubted and waivered.
Without trust in the other we become stingyfor instance in the kind of law
that we will pass to institute the Bangsamoro autonomous government. Or even
begrudge our patience, openness and understanding, and our financial resources.
Only with trust and faith can we have the generosity of spirit and the
compassionate understanding that are essential to make peace in Mindanao
peace on Earthpossible.
Therefore, we continue our efforts to build the trust and the faith in our
peace process on the Bangsamoro, in Mindanao, before the greater Filipino
public and the bigger community of nations.
Thank you for this opportunity to share with your wonderful community
of the faithful our little story from our part of the world.
Negotiating peace is not that easy. The negotiations between the Government
and the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF) took twenty-one years and
seventeen years were spent before an agreement was reached between the GPH
and the MILF. Within that span of time several major wars were fought between
the government forces and that of the MILF.
What made the peace agreement possible? My personal reflections are more
on the process rather than the substance.
169
170
Both the Government and the MILF are committed to the supremacy of
the peace process. They believe that negotiations are the preeminent approach
to resolve conflicts.
Salamat Hashim, the founder and first chair of the MILF, in a policy
statement before he died said that the peaceful and civilized way to resolve
the conflict between the Bangsamoro people and the Philippine Government
is through negotiations. Although both parties have their armed forces, they
learned lessons that the military approach does not only fail to resolve, but in
many cases, fuels conflicts.
When both parties reached the conclusion that the status quo is unacceptable,
they were at the level of similar understanding of the problem and finding the
solution to the problem became easier. Differentiating their interests from their
negotiating positions was easy and led them to come to compromise without
leaving behind their respective interests.
It was easy for both parties to start the dialogue by setting aside preconditions. They agreed that contentious issues like independence and the
Constitution would not be brought out in the discussions. The decisions of the
parties to set aside display of flags and other symbols made them unperturbed by
the denotations of symbols and concentration were focused on substantive issues.
Although the negotiations dragged on for a long time, the parties kept
on talking peace. The conflict between the Philippine Government and the
Bangsamoro liberation fronts is violent and resulted in large-scale wars, but
most of the time they are engaged in peace talks. The destruction to life and
properties would have been incalculable if negotiations were not taking place.
171
With this experience, I can say to you that peace is always possible in the
Bangsamoro, and is possible in all parts of the globe. It is also possible that the
way to peace is peacefulthe way of negotiations; the way of conversation; the
way of dialogue.
Delegates and guests from various religious and cultural backgrounds gather during the closing
ceremony of the three-day international peace meeting. (Photo by the Community of SantEgidio)
Opening statement
Ladies and gentlemen, its a pleasure to see all of you once again, altogether
with our partners in the Bangsamoro peace process.
A blessed morning to all.
Today could have been a much happier occasion, if only we had the law
that would have moved our roadmap forward in leaps and bounds. But we do
not have the lawyet.
Despite the extraordinary efforts of our teams and all the other tireless
peace advocates and congressional allies who travelled with us in this difficult
journey of a thousand miles, we saw the session days in Congress wither away,
without a BBL in sight.
173
174
of our countrymen will have to perish before everyone realizes that the broken
status quo of Muslim Mindanao must change?
From the start of the negotiations, the GPH Panel engaged our legislators.
From the 15th to the 16th Congresses, from then Senate President Juan Ponce
Enrile to Senate President Franklin Drilon, we reported to them, and their
concerned Committees, and sought their advice. Several legislators, moreover,
observed the talks in Kuala Lumpur. A good number also joined exposure trips
in Spain and UK.
With the signing of the CAB, we further saw the honest and faith-full
endeavor to meaningfully engage the legislaturenot by paid lobby groups,
but the people themselves for whom the law mattered, accompanied by their
sympathizers.
As the law entered the legislative mill, MILF leaders in the BTC knocked on
the doors of senators in their offices to seek understanding. They appeared before
congressional hearings, giving a face to the movement that has now effectively
entered the terrain of legislative lobby (and even congressional investigations),
lodged in this other supposedly democratic and representative institution by
which the peoples will can see fruition.
From the battlefields in Mindanao and the Sulu archipelago to the
Philippine Congress in Metro Manilait was a huge leap in mindset and
formative socialization of the bearers of Bangsamoro aspirations who trace their
descent in the long tradition of armed resistance fought on land and waters
against the Spanish and American colonial regimes.
175
the next round of legislative wrestling. But commentators resented this attempt
to reinstate some important provisions. Shouldnt a revolutionary movement
acting as a congressional lobby group in fact be welcomed? The passage of other
controversial laws like the Reproductive Health Law and the Sin Tax Law were
accompanied by the same pushing and steadfastness by lobbyists to preserve
important provisions but they were treated with much less antipathy than the
BBL advocates endured.
Many reasons and theories have been given as to why in the end the
legislative calendar perished without the desired outcome. Luwaran s editorial
cited four reasons. Editorial cartoons tried to capture our thousand sighs in one
freeze frame. I will no longer delve much into this, as the interplay of actors
and action-reaction has been complex, and would require some distance to fully
comprehend.
And so it happened that while the MILF endeavored to exhaust the
legislative process, the 16th Congress simply defaulted.
I remember Mr. Iqbal once describe their situation. We have one foot
inside the door, one foot outside. Help us drag the other foot in, he asked. We
are relieved that we still have that one foot inside the door. But what Congress
(not all the members, but as a collective entity) did was to shut out the other
foot, as if saying: Dyan muna kayo. Huwag nyo kaming madaliin. (Stay
there. Dont rush us.)
Our legislative bout was a fight well fought. We lost several rounds but
each time the peace advocates altogether stood up to continue the fight. Not
for any prize money or fame, but for the just share of the fruits of freedom and
democracy for the Bangsamoro.
My good counterpart, the wise Mr. Mohager Iqbal, also said once: There
is no perfect agreement. I hastened to add: There are no perfect parties to an
agreement, and no perfect bills or laws either.
176
We nurtured our ceasefire and were confident in the utility of our protocols.
But we saw how a major lapse in protocol had unleashed deadly, almost kneejerk instincts. Therefore, we must continue to tame our old ways and change the
mindset of the weapon-bearers on both sides of the fence.
From an angry, tight-knit organization, the MILF has increasingly
opened up to the other segments of societythe other indigenous peoples,
the non-Moros, other political forces. The MILF today is a confident MILF,
not a besieged closed organization. It is aware of the need for inclusivity. It is a
pragmatic organization that carefully balances its idealism with realism. It enjoys
the trust and respect of many people in civil society and government who have
worked closely with their members. It has chosen peace.
Still, of course, many difficulties remain. Many people do not yet see the
difference between one Moro group and another believing that because they
live side by side, they are all alike. Nobody would make that conclusion about
Quezon City where I live among drug syndicates, carnappers, rapists, corrupt
government officials, and petty thieves.
Many do not see that the mistake of one need not embody the whole
organization, nor the whole tribe, nor the whole religion and its faithful for
that matter.
For all these reasons, much remain to be done to build and nurture public
trust through dialogue.
Since all our efforts have not been enough, we should do more. We should
listen more, engage more. This cause is ours, and so the main burden is ours. We
shall prevail if we dont give up now. How many times in the past did events
play out to push us almost to the brink of giving up? But precisely because we
persevered, we have reached this far in the process.
Patience is bitter, but its fruit is sweet is a proverb found in many Philippine
languages. In Bicolano: An paciencia mapait, alangad an bunga mahamis.
Similarly, the Tagalog say: Ang sinumang may tiyaga, may palayok na
nilaga. (S/He who has patience, gets to enjoy the pot of boiled meat.)
As for the sum total of where we are now, we have definitely gained. We
have scored net positive points.
177
We have made life better for the people in the periods of sustained ceasefire,
and through the many capacity development programs and socioeconomic
activities that have flourished.
Our efforts have inspired similarly troubled countries. Our peace
infrastructure is serving as a model. Our peace process has the respect and
support of the international community, and the envy of those struggling for
and seeking their own peace accords.
Many of those who were 10-14 year-old children when we started out in
2010 are now about to enter the cusp of adulthood with a stronger sense of the
value of life and human dignity. Instead of learning the ropes of warfare, they
experienced relative peace. Like most children used to hard life, they have solid
dreams for a better future for their families.
The CAB remains our most viable roadmap, the source of the substance
of the policies and legislation that we will continue to pursue under the next
administration and the 17th Congress.
178
As for the best legislative tack in the next Congress, several questions are
relevant: Would it simply entail a refilling of a BBB (Bangsamoro Basic Bill)?
Which version? Are the prospects rife for constitutional change? What to expect?
Who would be the champions for peace and the Bangsamoro?
We believe we will be able to have a better reading of the prospects and the
best tack after the election and the incoming legislators have been determined.
In any case, in the Senate we generally foresee a majority who will be supportive
of a good BBL being obtained. This estimate is based on those who would stay,
those who are rating well in surveys and, moreover, the fact that several of the
contrary ones would no longer be around.
The House probably remains the bigger challenge given these figures:
almost half are re-electionists, a good number are running unopposed, others
are relatives of incumbents, and the rest new entrants or comebacks. While the
next President may also have less of the leverages traditionally wielded by the
chief executive precisely because of the reforms that have been instituted in the
budget system and the illegalization of the PDAF, s/he will enjoy a honeymoon
period and will harvest many of the turncoats and can therefore heavily influence
the movements in the House.
In due time, decisions would have to be made, risks taken. But we have
shown that we are not averse to risks. How else did we get this far?
The only genuine kind of dignity is one that is not diminished by the
indifference of others, said Dag Hammarskjold, the second Secretary-General
of the United Nations.
We have met with adversity. We have cried out against the indifference. But
the integrity of the CAB remains, and the dignity of those who have persevered
is not diminished.
Padayon!
As Is, Where Is
Mohagher Iqbal
CHAIR, MILF PEACE PANEL
179
180
To the Filipino people, let us work together overcome the barriers to peace,
justice, and reconciliation. Let us end the war, the suffering, the tragedy, and
the pain of our peoples, of the soldiers and our heroic fighters, of our mothers
and sisters, of our children. Let us try to live quiet and peaceful lives. Let us
not continue to live in fear of each other. Let us build a tomorrow for all our
children. We know deep in your hearts that you desire the same things for your
children. You are human. And we are human beings as well. Why cant we treat
each other with dignity and compassion?
To our friends in the diplomatic corps and the international community, we
thank you for your continued solidarity and support to the cause of peace and
reconciliation. Your support, in many ways, helped us forge the Comprehensive
Agreement on the Bangsamoro (CAB), prevent a return to armed conflict and
minimise the horrific impact of war.
In view of this, the MILF and government shall jointly find ways and
means to address this dangerous situation and avoid actions that may increase
the frustrations. We must provide them hope that there is a chance for passage
of a CAB-compliant BBL whoever will be the next president. This must be
in the form of firm and unequivocal commitment from government that it shall
181
continue to comply with its obligations under the CAB, particularly on the passage
of a CAB-compliant BBL, which is a unilateral obligation of government. On the
part of the MILF, we assure everyone including the international community
that we will adhere to the CAB and comply with its obligations. And finally in
order to preserve the gains of the peace process, government and MILF should
journey together in faithfully implementing the CAB, guided by the principle
of as is, where is. In other words, the most immediate step is either the BBL
will be refiled in Congress or a new basic law, faithful to the letter and spirit of
the CAB, will be crafted by the Bangsamoro Transition Commission (BTC),
which will most likely have new faces as members. This is the only way forward.
Thank you, and good morning to all!
Message
Why do we have wars? Why do people have to suffer so much pain in the
hands of their fellow human beings? And how do we make it all stop? How do
we pick up the pieces left shattered in wars aftermath? How do we even begin
to get back to where we were before war left us battered and wounded and
grieving? How do we make peace with each other when decades-old divides,
exacerbated by war, separate us?
How do we get to that point where, as the Psalm 85:10 announces, Mercy
and truth have met together, justice and peace have kissed?
In different parts of the world, countries have looked for answers in peace
processes that have all too often focused on the armed protagonists without
heeding the voice of the countless victims of war desperately crying out for
justice, and without addressing the deep roots of conflict in historical and
cultural divides. In many cases, the decision to establish mechanisms to bring
transitional justice and foster reconciliation have been made unilaterally, usually
by the state party. Rarely, if ever, have the two parties to the conflict taken the
initiative to make a united decision to undertake this long and difficultbut
ultimately indispensibletask.
This is why, as the TJRC puts it, what we have accomplished here is a
global first with the mutual agreement of the government and the Moro Islamic
Liberation Front to include in the peace accords the establishment of an impartial
and independent body mandated to study the legitimate grievances of the
Bangsamoro, historical injustices, human rights violations, and marginalization
183
184
Public Launch of the Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission Final Report
TJRC Chair M Bleeker briefs guests and participants on the TJRC report, a product of rigorous
consultation conducted across Mindanao since the bodys organization in September 2014, in a
public launch held on March 15, 2016 at Alnor Hotel in Cotabato City and witnessed by various
peace partners both from the public and private sectors. (Photo by TJRC)
through land dispossessioneven while they were still traversing the difficult
negotiating table.
Truly, without justice and reconciliation, there can be no true peace.Without
justice and reconciliation, the most we can hope for is nothing but a prolonged
ceasefire, where the wounds of war never heal and the deep divides it worsens
will never be bridged.
And yet, in our countrys long journey to peace, we have not seen serious
efforts at transitional justice and reconciliation.For the longest time, we have
been struggling to build peace without giving due attention to the necessary tasks
of truth-telling, remembrance, and exacting accountabilities regarding the dark
periods of our national history in order to ensure that these are not repeated,
that grievances are attended to, and divisions are bridged. It is a big missing
part of how we have been dealing with our past and, I believe, the reason why
the dark past keeps reinventing and re-inserting itself in the present, as we are
185
again seeing today in the competing narratives of our present national electoral
campaign, threatening and undermining our strivings to achieve a better and
brighter future.
This is why, early on, in the peace process under this administration, the
government had determined that, this time around, we would make sure that
the peace accords we would henceforth sign would include the element of
transitional justice and healing.Thus, as some of you may recall, the 3-for-1
proposal that we proferred during the initial exchange of drafts between the two
parties in 2011 had, as its first component, retelling history.And we, indeed, are
glad that this element found its way, in far clearer, more comprehensive, more
robust terms, in the Normalization Annex, and, thus, fully accept and take on
governments responsibility in this regard.
It is thus our call and our hope that every Filipino would take the time to
read the report that we are launching today. If we are to build the future that
we wantsurely a future where all Filipinos can live in a state of progress and
prosperity under an atmosphere of peace and harmonywe will have to come to
terms with our past. And in dealing with the past, we will have to raise difficult
questions and open conversations on topics we might not all be comfortable
withtopics dealing withquestions of truth, justice, history, and reparations.
We commend and thank everyone who formed part of this whole process,
especially the members of the TJRC: with its chair Ms. M Bleeker, Special
Envoy of the Swiss Federal Department of Foreign Affairs; GPH delegate, Atty.
Cecilia Jimenez; and MILF delegate, Atty. Ishak Matura; together with GPH
alternate delegate, Atty. Mohammed Al-amin Julkipli, who was very newly
appointed as Commissioner of the National Commission on Muslim Filipinos;
and MILF alternative delegate, Atty. Rusty Kalim. We also acknowledge the
invaluable contribution of the TJRC Senior Adviser Mr. Jonathan Sisson, also
of the Swiss Federal Department of Foreign Affairs.
186
Public Launch of the Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission Final Report
We know you consulted more than 3,000 individuals spanning 210 Muslim,
Lumad, and Christian communities in Mindanao and the Sulu archipelago, and
we are truly grateful for every step you took in coming up with this report.We
know that the process could not always have been easy and, particularly for the
community facilitators who worked with you, there are new pains and trauma
that also need healing.The process you chose to undertake is truly a hallmark of
the inclusiveness the Bangsamoro peace process has always striven to embody,
and we have no doubt it will make large strides towards bridging the divides
between our peoples and healing the wounds left by war.
187
We will also work closely with the Peace and Human Rights Desks of the
Armed Forces of the Philippines and the Philippine National Police, respectively.
We will further mobilize the Steering Committee for the National Action
Plan on Women, Peace and Security, pursuant to UNSCR 1325, to revisit their
programs with the additional lens of transitional justice and reconciliation. As
well, we will try to expand our efforts by tapping the expertise and knowledge
base of the academic community and civil society. Certainly, it is our intent to
maintain continuing conversation with the MILF with regards all these efforts.
I cannot guarantee that we will agree with all the points raised in the report, but
I can commit that we will study each point carefully. Before we step down from
office on 30 June 2016, in compliance with the instructions of the Executive
Secretary, we will be ready to report to you in full the progress we will make in
the coming months.
We only have three-and-a-half months left to our term107 days to go,
to be exact. It is not much time but, indeed, time enough to identify strategic
program thrusts and embed these through the appropriate department orders
and funds allocation in the mainstream work of selected relevant agencies. It is
enough time to raise consciousness among the relevant government agencies and
strategic partners in the academe and civil society on the unfinished business of
transitional justice and reconciliation that will have to be pursued under the next
administration and beyond. It is enough time to get a core of our national leaders
to care and to claim their own responsibility in pursuing redress of legitimate
grievances, bridging the divides, and healing the wounds of war.
188
Public Launch of the Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission Final Report
Surely, this work must accompany our efforts in the political track to ensure
the passage of the Bangsamoro Basic Law within the first half of the next
Congress.As we have noted several times over, the bile and vituperation flowing
post-Mamasapano revealed, in the words of a Mindanaoan, the fault lines, the
fundamental hatred and antagonisms that need to be addressed for BBL to
grow deeper roots.We canand we willlegislate a new political entity, but
we cannot simply legislate a change of hearts. For this, we need to undertake
the hard, long-term efforts such as those embodied in the recommendations of
the TJRC Report. As government continues to pursue its political commitment
for the passage of the BBL in accordance with the roadmap laid out by the
Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro, we fully accept the additional
tasks that the TJRC Report calls us to.These are the foundations that will allow
us to translate our vision of peace into realitypeace that is truly inclusive,
lasting, and just; peace that translates to real and tangible changes for families
and communities on the ground; peace that leads to harmony and reconciliation.
The launch of TJRCs Report was done in Cotabato City on March 15 (left) and in Manila on
March 16 (right) with various representatives from government agencies, security forces, CSOs,
the diplomatic community, academe and the media attending the event. Gracing the launch in
Cotabato were members of the BTC: Comm. Akmad Sakkam, Comm. Said Shiek, Comm. Hussein
Muoz, Comm. Maulana Bobby Alonto, and Comm. Raissa Jajurie. (Photos by TJRC)
189
(LR) Brunei Ambassador to the Philippines H.E. Datin Paduka Malai Hajah Halimah Malai Haj Yussof,
MILF Alternate Member to the TJRC Atty. Rashid Kalim, MILF representative to the TJRC Atty. Ishak
Mastura, MILF Panel Member Prof. Abhoud Syed Lingga, TJRC Chair M Bleeker, Swiss Ambassador
to the Philippines H.E. Andrea Reichlin, GPH representative to the TJRC Atty. Cecilia Jimenez-Damary,
GPH Panel Member Senen C. Bacani, and GPH Alternate Member to the TJRC Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin
Julkipli, during theTJRC Report Launch at Dusit Thani Hotel in Manila on March 16. (Photo by TJRC)
There is no question that we must and will continue to uphold the CAB. As
the TJRC so forcefully states, with the implementation of the Comprehensive
Agreement, we now have a Bangsamoro opportunity rather than a Bangsamoro
problema unique and extraordinary opportunity for the Bangsamoro and the
entire Filipino nation to bring to light and embrace the reality that we are a
nation of many identities, and it is this diversity that makes us strong. It is an
opportunity for us to show our country and the rest of the world that there is a
better way to livethat, despite our differences, we can all coexist peacefully in
a democratic, pluralistic society that gives all its peoples, not just the dominant
majority, the political space they need to articulate their interests and manage
190
Public Launch of the Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission Final Report
conflicting views without resorting to violence, and where we can join hands
with each other to promote the rule of law, security, and development. It is
an opportunity to show that our nation is large enough to accommodate the
myriad identities and aspirations of our peoples, especially the Bangsamoro and
the indigenous peoples, who are as vital and vibrant parts of the Philippines as
much as anyone.
This Bangsamoro opportunity is one we ignore at our own peril. And we
take heart in seeing that the parties in this peace process are not ignoring this
opportunity and are in fact doing all they can to make sure we take it and make
the most of it. Despite setbacks and difficulties along the way, and we are sure
that there will be more challenges awaiting in our way forward, no one is backing
out. No one is giving upnot the MILF, surely not the government. And we
ask you not to give up as well. Not now, when we are as close as we have ever
been to bringing peace to our countryso close that we can almost see, with
greater clarity than ever before, that bright new dawn awaiting us all at that
place where mercy and truth are met together, at that place where justice and
peace have kissed.
Thank you and good morning. Shukran.
The TJRC report contains recommendations on how to heal the wounds of war
and historical injustice, and address the legitimate grievances of the Bangsamoro.
(Photo by OPAPP)
192
193
Gayundin ang ating foreign partners from Malaysia, Norway, Brunei, Libya,
Japan and EU, the Mindanao Trust Fund and the World Bank, Forum ZFD from
Germany, mga civil society na kasama natin mula dito sa Central Mindanao, sa
ibat ibang bahagi ng Lanao del Norte, Cotabato, Lanao Sur, Maguindanao,
Davao at iba pa mula naman sa Metro Manila.
Mga student leaders sa high school at college dito sa Cotabato City, local
at national media: Youre all welcome in this event.
Ang ilan sa kanila ay pumanaw natulad nina Aleem Ali Mimbantas, Atty.
Lanang Ali, Atty. Musib Buat, Datu Tony Kinoc, ang first chairman ng MILF
Ceasefire Committee na si Sultan Saiffudin Tomawis, ang dating chairman ng
kanilang Ceasefire Committee na si Tops Julhani, ang ika-apat na chairman
ng Ceasefire Committee nila na si Benjie Midtimbang, at gayundin ang isang
kasapi ng ating JCMP sa Cotabato tulad ni Bapa Keds Manan.
Sa bahagi naman po ng government, wala na rin si GPH panel member
Emily Marohomsar, at dating Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process Anabelle
Abaya, at JCMP member ng government na si Sgt. Roger Emben mula rin sa
JCMP Kitango.
194
195
With all due respect, I disagree with those who are saying that we have
nothing to celebrate because we did not get the BBL. Huwag nating balewalain
ang mga tagumpay na nakamit, ang mga benepisyo nang naramdaman, ang
unti-unti nang pag-usad na nagdala sa atin, sa inyo, kung saan tayo ngayon.
Ipagdiwang natin ang mga kaguluhan na naiwasan, ang mga buhay at ari-arian
na napangalagaan, ang mga umusbong na civil society organization, ang higit
na kahusayan at mga paghahanda para sa naantala pero darating at darating pa
ring transition.
Pag-usapan natin. Suriin natin. Tukuyin natin kung ano pa ang dapat
gawin at hanapan natin ng paraan. Paghandaan natin ang susunod na laban sa
susunod na administrasyon at Kongreso. Magkaroon tayo ng magandang plano.
Magtulungan tayo upang matugunan ang kailangan ng bawat isa. Imbes na
magsisihan, kumuha tayo ng lakas sa isat-isa. Palakasin natin ang ating hanay.
Let us make more friends, let us not make our friends our enemies.
Pananampalataya sa harap ng uncertainty: ito ang ating panangga doon sa mga
nagnanais na madiskaril ang Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro.
We call on our Muslim brothers and sisters to join us on this journey: There
is a place for everyone. This is not just for the MILF. Stop the killing of
Filipinos by other Filipinos. Stand together and share the faith with us. We
call on politicians, decision- and opinion-makers, to know more about the
Bangsamoro and our peace process, what we aim and continue to achieve, to
see our mechanisms in action, and to appreciate what we have accomplished in
building the foundations for peace and progress so that you can help complete
and strengthen this foundation.
To those who will be elected: It will be your duty, your obligation, to continue
this process. Subok na ito; kailangan lamang na palakasin, punuin yung mga
magagaspang pa na bahagi, at higit na palawakin ang mga kasama sa paglalakbay.
Maraming salamat po. Mabuhay tayong lahat!
Welcome Remarks
Mohagher Iqbal
CHAIR, MILF PEACE PANEL
n almost all occasions that I have attended after both Houses of Congress
failed to enact the Bangsamoro Basic Law, the common question raised is:
What to do now?
Even after the Special Meeting of the Peace Panels in Kuala Lumpur last
10 and 11 February, and even as well after MILF Chairman Al Haj Murad
Ebrahim issued an official statement on 18 February, we are still hard pressed
to explain to our fellow Bangsamoro the ways forward.
That they have journeyed with us in every step of the peace process only
raised their expectations. The public consultations, advocacies, information
dissemination of all sorts, and the glaring coverage of traditional and social and
mainstream media have all contributed to the high awareness of the BBL: that
it will pass into law. That is why, when hopes were raised, with good reasons
of course, and those high hopes were dimmed or shut out, we have a flurry
of frustrations, of anger, of doubt, and of fear over a future that is becoming
uncertain again. At the back of their mind, they see this country as not wanting
genuine and permanent peace at all.
196
197
I also take this opportunity, and I do hope it would reach them or their
campaign strategists at the very least, to appeal to all our presidential candidates
and senatorial aspirants to take their unequivocal stand on the CAB and the
BBL. You will surely inherit this political problem. We urge all of you to clarify
to us the policy that your administration will pursue vis--vis the CAB and the
BBL. The Bangsamoro votes may pale in comparison to the votes of Christians,
but even a single vote can make a difference.
Many of us shed tears when the CAB was signed, something hardened
warriors never do in public and rarely in private. But the CAB is the summation
198
of all our aspirations and emotions. Now that our legitimate grievances
and aspirations have already been recognized and affirmed not only by the
Government of the Philippines but by the nations of the world, do we have to
stop in our struggle just because the moment is not favorable to us? No, and I
personally urge everyone to: Stand Up for Peace! Long Live the Comprehensive
Agreement on the Bangsamoro!
Accept my warmest welcome to all of you.
Thank you and good day!
(Clockwise from top) With the theme Stand up for Peace! Long live the CAB!, the GPH and MILF
Peace Panels commemorated the second anniversary of the signing of the CAB on 28 March 2016
at the NDU Gym in Cotabato City. Before the program proper, guests watched a series of short
films produced by the Forum ZFD tackling issues on Mindanao. An exhibit depicting the stronger
partnership between the Parties, as well as the human costs of conflict, was also installed at the
event venue. (Photos by OPAPP and AFP PPO)
199
Representatives from the IMT pose for a group photo after receiving their plaques of appreciation
from the Panel Chairs. Present during the ceremony are representatives from the Governments
of Brunei, EU, Indonesia, Japan, Libya, Malaysia, Norway, Mindanao Peoples Caucus, Moslem
Organization of Government Officials and Professionals, Non-Violent Peace Force, and Mindanao
Human Rights Action Center. (Photo by OPAPP)
MILF Peace Panel Chair Mohagher Iqbal goes around to thank members of the Panels Ad Hoc
Joint Action Group. The event, which commemorated the signing of the historic peace agreement
on 27 March 2014, was also a recognition and appreciation of local and international actors who
have been part of the Bangsamoro peace process throughout the years. (Photo by OPAPP)
200
Sec. Deles, NCMF Sec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, Chair Ferrer, Chair Iqbal, MILF Central Committee
Secretary Muhammad Ameen (2nd from right) and MILF Panel Member Abdulla Camlian
(rightmost) with former CCCH Chairs and Heads of Secretariat: (L-R) Butch Malang (MILF-CCCH
Secretariat Head and OIC), retired BGEN Reynaldo C. Sealana, (GPH-CCCH Chair, 2008-2011),
retired Maj. Carlos T. Sol Jr. (GPH-CCCH Secretariat Head, 2007-present), BGEN Glenn Macasero
(GPH-CCCH Chair, Dec 2015-present), Toks Ebrahim (former MILF-CCCH Chair), retired LTGEN
Rey Ardo (GPH-CCCH Chair, Jan-May 2011), BTC Comm. Said Shiek (former MILF-CCCH Chair),
6th ID Commander MGEN Edmundo Pangilinan (GPH-CCCH Chair, Feb-July 2014), and BGEN
Carlito Galvez Jr. (GPH-CCCH Chair, July 2014-Dec 2015). (Photo by OPAPP)
Ms. Karen Taada (4th from left) receives in behalf of the TPMT the plaque of appreciation given
by the Panels. Also in photo (from LR): OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles, GPH Panel Member
Sec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, GPH Panel Chair Mirriam Coronel Ferrer, MILF Panel Chair Mohagher
Iqbal, MILF Central Committee Secretary Muhammad Ameen, MILF Panel Member Abdulla Camlian,
and MILF Panel Alternate Member Timuay Melanio Ulama. (Photo by OPAPP)
201
Chair Ferrer and Chair Iqbal present the plaques of appreciation to members of the GPH and MILF
AHJAG for their contributions to the GPH-MILF peace process. In the photo are retired MGEN Leo
Cresente M. Ferrer (GPH-AHJAG Chair, May-Dec 2013, second from left), Atty. Abdul M. Dataya
(MILF-AHJAG Chair, 2005-present, 3rd from left), LTC Abdurasad Sirajan (GPH-AHJAG Western
Mindanao Area Action Officer, 4th from left), COL Ceasar D. De Mesa (GPH-AHJAG Team Site 1
Member, 6th from left), and other members of the MILF-AHJAG Team. (Photo by OPAPP)
(Left photo) Members of the ICG represented by Centre for Humanitarian Dialogue,
Community of SantEgidio and Japan take a photo with Sec. Deles and the GPH and MILF
Panels. (Right photo) Chair Ferrer shakes hands with TJRC members Atty. Cecilia JimenezDamary and Atty. Ishak Mastura as they receive the plaque of appreciation recognizing
Switzerlands support to the TJRC and the peace process. (Photos by OPAPP)
Closing Remarks
wo years ago, when the two parties signed the Comprehensive Agreement on
the Bangsamoro, we declared together, with courage and conviction, that a
new dawn has come. It was a time of renewed hope, of optimism, of euphoria, even.
And yet, over the past two years, we have also faced perhaps the greatest
challenges the Bangsamoro peace process has ever confronted. I will no longer
dwell on the whys and the hows and the aftermath of these challenges; today,
after all, is a celebration of peace and hope. But, of course, even then we knew
as we have always knownthat it would not be easy. Yet we also knew how
high the stakes are and how important this work is, especially for families and
communities on the ground. And so we buckled down and, together, kept moving
ever onwards, determined to give this tired, tired land the fresh start it so sorely
needs, and keeping faith that in the end, peace will always win.
Our faith is not misplaced: The peace process, while badly hit, remains intact;
while battered, it has emerged, I daresay, even stronger.
202
203
204
of schoolyear 2015; that instead of anxiously staying awake at night to wait for
the warning sounds of coming danger, mothers and fathers were able to pursue
their livelihoods to provide for their families; that instead of being trampled
and destroyed in firefights, fields were tended and grown; that instead of being
broken yet again, families stayed together and communities finally see the chance
to begin the long process of healing.
It means that a people, especially the youth, who have come to know only
the history of suffering, now have the chance to rewrite their storyinto a
narrative where they live proudly and productively, without fear and want,
without injustice and prejudice, without the immeasurable pain of war, in a
country that accepts and embraces them.
We know that today this measure of peace we have achieved stands on
fragile and vulnerable grounds. The challenges are daunting. There is still so
much we have to do.
We must make the CAB not only intact but indelible. We must ensure the
fulfillment of its political and legal promise in the passage of the Bangsamoro
Basic Law early in the next administration, even as we undertake the difficult,
more long-term task of dealing with the painful past and healing its deep wounds.
We must continue to work on the building blocks of peace and preserve the
gains thereof so that we can keep moving, as one nation, ever closer to a peace
that will thrive and endure.
In closing, let me reiterate: The government remains unwavering in its
commitment to the Comprehensive Agreement and the Bangsamoro peace
process. President Aquino has repeatedly affirmed this commitment to the
peace accord up to his last day in office and beyond. The CAB, after all, is
a commitment to peace that must and will span administrations. Tuloy ang
pagpapatupad ng Comprehensive Agreement. Tuloy ang ating laban para sa
pangmatagalang kapayapaan. Tuloy ang ating trabahong siguruhin na wala nang
batang iiyak pa, na wala nang pamilyang masisira pa, at wala nang buhay pang
mawawala dahil sa giyera.
It has been a truly challengingbut at the same time rewardingtwo years.
And today, with greater courage and conviction, with hope that has been tested
and strengthened by the most severe trials, with renewed and wiser optimism
yes, optimismwe again affirm that this new dawn is here to stay; that we will
not slip back into the darkness of war and division yet again; that, with continued
effort, we have faith that, InshaAllah, we will soon see the sun of peace emerge
from its dawn to its brightest, its most beautiful and amazing zenith.
Thank you and good afternoon. Shukran.
Closing Remarks*
Turning our backs on the peace process would be a mistake. After all,
we have the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro intact, which is
* As delivered by MILF Central Committee Secretary Muhammad Ameen.
205
206
over and above the Bangsamoro Basic Law. This silver lining among the dark
clouds is the legitimacy of the CAB and its binding effect on the GPH and the
MILF that forged the mutually acceptable agreement two years ago. It will take
patience, steadfastness, and leadership on both sides to reach the ultimate goal
of achieving just and lasting peace. And even if the roadmap was not met, the
signed CAB would at least ensure that commitments are kept and compliance
is demandable. Such strong words: commitment and compliance.
It is worth reiterating that the CAB sets up a new relationship between
the Central Government and the Bangsamoro Government that would involve
fulfilling the many legal obligations each party has assumed to put an end to
conflict. To name a few: The Central Government agreed to relinquish some
governmental powers to the Bangsamoro government, and to share in the
revenues generated within the region. The MILF, on the other hand, agreed
to terms of decommissioning where combatants would turn over weapons and
enjoy various developmental and capacity-building programs as part of the
normalization process.
207
which ensures the most reasonable framework for a sustainable basis for
peace, stability, and development. It would be the height of injustice to rob the
Bangsamoro once more of its rights asserted in the CAB. It would likewise be the
height of humiliation for the Government to sidetrack the process especially with
numerous sets of eyes carefully observing and scrutinizing the implementation
of the internationally-acclaimed agreement.
On the part of the MILF, we will continue to seek and work for the final
peaceful settlement of the conflict in Mindanao. In particular, we will continue
to ask government to comply with its unilateral obligation to enact a law that
would give life and realization to the letter and spirit of the CAB. The gains of
the peace process especially the FAB and CAB should be preserved.
Allow me then, at this point, to commend the various personalities and
entities that helped fashion the political dialogue of the peace process that led
to the signing of the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro: first, the
Government of the Philippines through the Office of the Presidential Adviser on
the Peace Process and the GPH Negotiating Panel; and the MILF Leadership
and the MILF Peace Negotiating Panel. This includes all of those who have
been part of the negotiations throughout its more than seventeen years and
even prior thereto.
Our most special thanks go out to His Excellency Prime Minister Dato
Sri Najib bin Tun Haji Abdul Razak; His Excellency Dr. Mahatir Mohamad
under whose term of office as Prime Minister the peace negotiations were
done in Malaysia; His Excellency Ekmeleddin hsanolu, Secretary General
of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, and the Malaysian Facilitator, His
Excellency Tengku DatoAb Ghafar Tengku Mohamed, and their Secretariat.
We also will never forget the tireless efforts and support of all the state and
non-state actors that compose the International Contact Group: the Governments
208
of the United Kingdom, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Japan; and its international NGO
componentsConciliation Resources, Muhammadiyah, The Asia Foundation,
Centre for Humanitarian Dialogue, and Community of SantEgidio; the Third
Party Monitoring Team (TPMT); the International Monitoring Team (or the
IMT) and its Civilian Protection Component (composed of ) Malaysia, Brunei,
Libya, Japan, Norway, Indonesia, and the European Union, the Non-Violent
Peace Force, Mindanao Peoples Caucus, Mindanao Human Rights Action
Center, and Muslim Organization of Government Officials and Professionals;
and to the numerous world organizations and countries that have signified
strong support to the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro such as
the United Nations, the European Union, United States of America, United
Kingdom, Switzerland, Australia, Indonesia, Japan, and the Organisation of
Islamic Cooperation.
We likewise extend our deep appreciation to the organizers of this CAB
2nd anniversary commemoration, which seeks not only to remember but most
importantly, to honor, acknowledge, and recognize that the CAB is active and
alive.
Finally, to our Bangsamoro brothers and sisters, let this occasion be a reason
to stand up and stand strong for peace. We have not come this far to allow the
CAB to be put to waste. Let cool heads and good tempers ultimately prevail.
Remember that the greatest interest of the Bangsamoro is our primordial
concern. We need to solidify as a people and strengthen our resolve more than
ever, for a united Bangsamoro struggle. The struggle does not and may never
end, but every step closer to peace is already progress. We must realize that we
have never been more ready for peace. Stand up for peace! Long live the CAB!
Thank you everyone, and may we have a pleasant rest of the afternoon.
Wasalaamu Alaikum.
Decommissioned Combatants
Skills Training Closing Ceremony
25 April 2016
Old Maguindanao Provincial Capitol, Simuay, Sultan Kudarat,
Maguindanao
Speech
210
Old Maguindanao Provincial Capitol, Simuay, Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao25 April 2016
211
212
Old Maguindanao Provincial Capitol, Simuay, Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao25 April 2016
213
214
Notes:
Last 25 April 2015, 133 of 145 decommissioned combatants (DCs) attended the TESDA
graduation ceremony at the Old Provincial Capital of Maguindanao. On the same day,
TESDA officials distributed the tool kits for the graduates. The DSWD also released
P25,000.00 financial assistance to 64 DCs in support of the latters planned business
activities under the Sustainable Livelihood Program (SLP); 80 DCs received their assistance
earlier on 29 March 2016.
Eleven of the 145 DCs opted not to undergo skills training. On 24 April 2016 at Old Capitol,
Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao the GPHs Socioeconomic Team consulted seven of the
eleven DCs if they have someone in the family whom they wish to take the TESDA skills
training in their behalf. Three of the seven affirmed and recommended their children.
Four DCs declined the TESDA opportunity. The DSWD and DW will facilitate cash-for- work
activities for these four DCs.
One DC from Wao, Lanao del Sur, who suffers from cancer is continuously attending his
therapy. From October 2015 up to January 2016, he completed forty-two radiotherapy
sessions, and one of six sessions for chemotherapy. PhilHealth and DSWD, and the
Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Organization, have beeng providing financial support to
cover the medical fees.
One DC who chose the college education track had already taken the National Assessment
and Equivalency Examination conducted by the Department of Education on 24 April 2016
following two weeks of intensive review facilitated by the DepEd-Cotabato City Division
offices Alternative Learning System (ALS) team. The GPH Panels Socio-Economic Team
provided for his full board and lodging requirement and the daily stipend for the entire
period of his review up to the day of examination.
Within the third quarter of 2016, the Department of Agriculture will distribute the farming/
fishery assistance to the DCs. This is the last common item to be delivered as part of the
package enumerated in the DCs service vouchers.
Old Maguindanao Provincial Capitol, Simuay, Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao25 April 2016
215
(Above) Decommissioned combatants also receive from TESDA toolkits (e.g., carpentry tool box,
sewing machines, toaster ovens, motorcycle tools, electrician tools, etc.) in support of their startup business/livelihood. (Photos by OPAPP)
Speech
216
Old Maguindanao Provincial Capitol, Simuay, Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao25 April 2016
217
Speech
Mahalaga ang okasyong ito dahil naganap ito sa gitna ng isinasagawa nating
malawakan at malalim na pagbabago sa sistema ng pamumuhay sa bansa. Ang
mga skills training na nakumpleto ng mga decommissioned combatants ay
siyang ilalatag sa darating na pasukan, o hindi kaya ay sa darating na pagpasa
ng Basic Law.
Umaasa kami na maihahanda namin kayo nang buong husay upang maayos
ninyong mahanap at mapagtagumpayan ang mga hamon ng pagbabagong ito.
Muling ipinapaalaala sa atin ng temang mujahideen mula sa decommissioned
combatants na tagapagdala ng kaunlaran sa Bangsamoro at sa bansang Pilipinas.
Ang mahalagang papel ng mujahideen upang maitatag nating lahat ang
pamayanan, ang inaasam nating lahat na masayang buhay dahil may nakalaan
na lugar para sa nagsisikap na isaayos ang sariling buhay, at sa mga handang
maglingkod sa kapwa.
Lagi ninyo sanang maalala ang mga tagubilin na kung dumating ang
sitwasyon na may pagkakaiba-iba: Maging tulay nawa kayo ng pagkakaisa. Sa
yugto ng buhay ng kagipitan, matuto pa rin kayong maging mapagbigay. At sa
panahon ng mas maraming suliranin, laging ang katwiran at ang puso ninyo
ang pairalin upang maituwid ang mahirap na daan. Nasa inyo ang lakas ng
katawan at lakas ng isipan upang laging maitaguyod ang pagmamahal sa bayan.
Sa inyong paglabas sa silid paaralan upang harapin ang tunay na buhay, laging
218
Old Maguindanao Provincial Capitol, Simuay, Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao25 April 2016
219
Notes:
On 16 June 2015, 145 BIAF-MILF combatants and seventy five weapons consisting of
fifty one high-powered and twenty four crew-served weapons were decommissioned
and turned over by the MILF to the IDB in a historic ceremony held at the Old Provincial
Capitol Building in Brgy. Simuay, Sultan Kudarat, Maguindanao. As an integral part of
Phase 1 of the GPH-MILF normalization process under the CAB, the decommissioning
processwhere MILF forces and weapons are put beyond use in a graduated program
entails the GPH and MILF parties commitment to transform former combatants into
productive civilians.
Towards this objective, the 145 BIAF members initially decommissioned were provided
immediate cash assistance and health insurance at the ceremonial turn-over in June
2015. They were also given options for further benefits (such as livelihood packages,
college or high school study grants) that would be provided after the conduct of
counselling and needs assessment.
The DCs have continued to undergo various capacity-building interventions, with 133 of
the 145 completing various technical and vocational skills training courses in February
to April 2016 (e.g., automotive servicing, baking, carpentry, cookery, dressmaking/
tailoring, driving, electrical installation and maintenance, small engine mechanics,
welding, and entrepreneurship).
133 decommissioned combatants underwent various technical and vocational skills training under
TESDA in February to April 2016. (Photos by OPAPP)
Statement
GPH Panel Chair Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer on the
Proposed Bangsamoro Basic Law
(Pre-GPH-MILF Special Meeting in Kuala Lumpur)
7 JULY 2014
The Government Panel readily accepted the task. Together with the
MILF Panel, Malaysian Facilitator Tengku Ghafar and the members of the
International Contact Group, we will be meeting in Kuala Lumpur this week in a
workshop that would thresh out the various substantive matters that have arisen
from the BTC submission and the subsequent OP review. The members of the
BTC will also be present, thereby ensuring close coordination and processing.
To begin with, neither the BTC draft nor the OP-reviewed text is so
complete and perfect to leave no more room for discussion, or no other option
but to choose between one or the other.
222
Other Statements
223
Closed options have never been the practice in our past negotiation. It
shouldnt be now in the implementation stage. Then and now, problem-solving
has defined our modalities and this approach has produced the workable results
that brought us this far.
For both the Government and the MILF, the bottom line is set by the signed
documents that make up the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro.
There is no backtracking on either side. Any perception of backtracking can be
duly addressed and rectified during the discussion. On the other hand, details
or aspects beyond the signed documents are policy options that the BTC has
taken and which the OP team took care to study and uphold as much as possible.
But as in any piece of legislation, there are various ramifications to any single
text or gaps that might not have appeared at first instance. The Kuala Lumpur
workshop will help sort out these grey zones.
If we are going through this difficulty now, it is because we want the next
stages to be less difficult not only between the government and the MILF, but
among all the institutions and actors that will be or have been playing a role in
the process. A well-processed bill that goes through the legislative mill, with
the certification of the President as urgent, will stand much better chances of
smooth-sailing passage in both the Senate and the House of Representatives.
As we have said many times in the past, this partnership between the GPH
and the MILF is not for the fainthearted. It is also not for the impatient and
the impetuous who, in the face of difficulty, immediately throw in the towel.
Rather, it is for those who persevere so that when the going gets rough, they
get going. They do not turn back to their old comfort zones or to the familiar
sound of their war cries.
Surely, we are not throwing in the towel because we do need the towel for
this laborious task that is 99 percent perspiration.
Statement
GPH Panel Chief Negotiator Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer on the
Status of the Draft Bangsamoro Basic Law
21 JULY 2014
The GPH stands firm that we want a Bangsamoro Basic Law that can
withstand political and legal scrutiny and be acceptable to various stakeholders,
and the nation as a whole.
We will not and cannot move forward in the roadmap toward the
establishment of the Bangsamoro unless we hurdle this crucial stage. We wish
the MILF to understand the basis for the comments made as part of the review
process by the Office of the President.
From the beginning it was very clear that the BBL will pass through regular
legislation in Congress and, therefore, must fall within the parameters of the
Constitution. We have been trying to stretch these parameters to accommodate
the ideas that have been put in the BBL, in addition to what have been put in
the signed documents. But it is very clear we cannot overstep the boundaries of
the Constitution. That said, the BTC has been given the mandate to recommend
changes in the Constitution all those ideas that could not be accommodated
now under this Constitution. But the BBL must necessarily be constitutional.
This doesnt mean also that key features that will distinguish the ARMM
from the Bangsamoro are not being put forward in the draft law such as the
parliamentary form of government, a parliament with more than fifty members
made up of district, party list and reserved seats; an autonomous government
that will enjoy high fiscal autonomy; and a transition arrangement where the
MILFs brand of leadership will be tested.
224
Other Statements
225
We believe with reason and goodwill, we will overcome this current difficulty.
Notes:
By virtue of Executive Order 120 issued on 17 December 2012, the members of the
Bangsamoro Transition Commission (BTC), composed of both GPH and MILF nominees,
were formally appointed on 25 February 2013. The main task of the BTC is to draft
the Bangsamoro Basic Law, which once enacted, will provide for the creation of the
Bangsamoro political entity.
The BTC completed its draft which it officially transmitted to the Office of the President
(OP) on 22 April 2014. After conducting a rigorous review, the OP returned to the BTC
its comments and suggested revisions. The BTC, finding their draft to be substantially
critiqued by the OP, issued a resolution on 3 July 2014, elevating to the Panels for
clarification, discussion and resolution (the) issues that may have been affected by
the revisions in the proposed BBL, in the higher interest of finding a lasting peaceful
solution to the conflict in Mindanao.1 This led to a series of meetings between the
Panels in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia (July 811), Manila (July 1821 and 2527) and
Davao City (August 110 and 1315).
The four-day special meeting in Kuala Lumpur served as an opportunity for the peace
panels to clarify misperceptions and affirm the intent and sincerity of the parties to
abide by the signed agreements.2 The succeeding meetings in Manila and Davao were
held to arrive at a common language for the draft BBL. In Davao, Executive Secretary
Paquito Ochoa Jr. also met with BTC and MILF Peace Panel Chair Mohagher Iqbal to
1. BTC Resolution No. 002 series of 2014, approved on 3 July 2014 in Cotabato City.
2. Joint Press Statement by the GPH and MILF Negotiating Panels released on 11 July 2014 at
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
226
Other Statements
resolve remaining issues.3 The MILF remained engaged with the OP to finalize the draft
BBL even after these meetings.
After arduous consultations and legal review, a mutually agreed draft BBL was finally
turned over by BTC Chair Iqbal to Senate President Franklin Drilon and Speaker Feliciano
R. Belmonte Jr. at the Malacaan Palace on 10 September 2014 in the presence of
Pres. Benigno S. Aquino III.
The bill was filed in the Senate as Senate Bill 2408,4 with 13 sponsors led by the Senate
President, and referred jointly to the Committee on Local Government chaired by Sen.
Ferdinand Marcos, Jr., and the Committee on Peace, Reconciliation and Unity chaired
by Sen. Teofisto TG Guingona III.
In the House of Representatives (HoR), it was filed as House Bill 4994,5 with 17 sponsors
led by the Speaker. It was referred to the specially formed 75-member Ad Hoc Committee
on the Bangsamoro Basic Law chaired by Cagayan de Oro Rep. Rufus Rodriguez.
3. Joint Statement of Executive Secretary Paquito N. Ochoa Jr. and BTC Chair Mohagher Iqbal.
4. SB 2408 is authored by Senators Franklin M. Drilon, Vicente C. Sotto III, Alan Peter S.
Cayetano, Loren B. Legarda, Ralph G. Recto, Joseph Victor G. Ejercito, Maria Lourdes Nancy
S. Binay, Francis Chiz G. Escudero, Paolo Benigno Bam Aquino IV, Juan Edgardo Sonny
M. Angara, Pia S. Cayetano, Gregorio B. Honasan II, Teofisto TG Guingona III.
5. HB 4994 is authored by Congressmen Feliciano Belmonte Jr., Henedina R. Abad, Rep. Giorgidi
B. Aggabao, Sergio A.F. Apostol, Pangalina M. Balindong, Carlos M. Padilla, Neptali M.
Gonzales II, Senen S. Sarmiento, Enrique M. Cojuangco, Mark Llandro L. Mendoza, Eleandro
Jesus F. Madrona, Elpidio F. Barzaga Jr., Antonio F. Lagdameo Jr., Rolando G. Andaya Jr.,
Nicanor M. Briones, Raymond Democrito C. Mendoza, and Roberto V. Puno.
Statement
Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process Teresita Quintos Deles
on the Draft Bangsamoro Basic Law
8 SEPTEMBER 2014
he Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) and the government have agreed
on a mutually acceptable draft of the Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL) to be
endorsed by President Benigno S. Aquino III for enactment by Congress. This
was confirmed in a meeting between the President and MILF Chair Murad
Ebrahim held last Thursday, 4 September, in Malacaang. Chair Murad was
accompanied by MILF panel and Bangsamoro Transition Commission (BTC)
Chair Mohagher Iqbal while the President was joined by several cabinet
members, led by Executive Secretary Paquito N. Ochoa Jr., and GPH panel
chair Miriam Coronel Ferrer.
Over the weekend, the BTC met en banc to review the final version of the
draft bill. The BTC is poised to submit a letter transmitting the draft BBL to the
Office of the President later today. The letter was signed by all BTC members
yesterday afternoon at the end of their two-day meeting.
As the implementation of the CAB moves to the next stage of the process,
we again ask for everyones prayers and support as we continue to endeavor to
address and overcome all the challenges that surely still lie in our path toward a
just and enduring peace in the Bangsamoro and for the entire country.
227
Statement
Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process Teresita Quintos Deles
on the Transmittal of the Bangsamoro Basic Law to Congress
10 SEPTEMBER 2014
oday, we reach a turning point in our national quest for peace in Mindanao.
228
Other Statements
229
This is the farthest distance we have reached in our peace journey with the
MILF, and the most significant political step we have taken in our political
roadmap for the Bangsamoro.
To our esteemed partners in the peace process, now is not the time to rest or
be complacent. Now is the time to be heard and to listen to the views of others,
as we set aside our differences to unite behind the cause of peace.
Today, our generation holds the key that would unlock the unlimited
potentials of a peaceful Mindanao, of more developed Bangsamoro communities,
and a more cohesive, prosperous, and united Philippines.
Let us pass a Bangsamoro Basic Law that would make past and future
generations proud.
Maraming salamat po!
Statement
GPH Panel Chair Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer on the
Transmittal of the Bangsamoro Basic Law to Congress
10 SEPTEMBER 2014
230
Other Statements
231
With more powers and resources come more responsibilities. This is the
advantage as well as the duty of those who will be leading the Bangsamoro
in the years to come. It is an opportunity that must be made available for the
common good, but also one that must not be squandered.
These and other key features are detailed in the draft BBL that shall very
soon be deliberated on by Congress.
Statement
GPH Panel Member and NCMF Secretary Yasmin Busran-Lao
on the Transmittal of the Bangsamoro Basic Law to Congress
10 SEPTEMBER 2014
232
Other Statements
233
We have to think and act in accordance with what is best for our country
and people, giving paramount importance and relevance to effort towards peace
and development.
Maraming salamat po, at magandang araw sa inyong lahat.
GPH Panel Member and then Presidential Assistant for Muslim Concerns Undersecretary Yasmin
Busran-Lao explains the Bangsamoro peace process in a consultation with IP leaders in 2013.
(Photo by OPAPP)
Statement
International Supporters for Peace in the Philippines
15 OCTOBER 2015
Commitment
We call on all concerned to remain engaged in the peace process to give
life to the Comprehensive Agreement on Bangsamoro, and to the long-term
political, economic, and social pillars that will bring the peace dividend to the
country as a whole.
Continuity
In sustaining the peace effort, it is vital that there is no return to violence
and that long-established institutional safeguard measures remain in place
to monitor and resolve disputes. It is important that work on normalization
progresses credibly.
234
235
Other Statements
The long and difficult history of this troubled region can and should move
to a more positive future agenda. Much work has been done to bring the parties,
activists, politicians, business and civil society to the brink of a settlement. For
the country as a whole, it is essential that setbacks are overcome and people of
vision and faith come together to ensure that the momentum for peace continues.
Common Interests
We have a stake in the Philippines not just as committed friends and
development partners but as investors and members of the community through
our citizens. In a world of conflict and instability which has marred the lives
of so many, we want to support the Philippines to emerge as a nation that is at
peace within itself.
H.E. Ambassador Bill Tweddell
236
Other Statements
Embassy of Palau
in the Philippines
Embassy of Romania
in the Philippines
International envoys sign a statement of support for the Bangsamoro peace process on 15
October 2015. (Photo by the Netherlands Embassy in Manila, Philippines)
Dear Legislators:
ime is short, but there is still time. We ask our legislators to work for the
immediate passage of the draft law on the Bangsamoro.
The passage of the law will pave the way for the decommissioning of
thousands of weapons and combatants of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front
(MILF). It will enable the peaceful transition of an armed group into regular
members of society, participating and competing in free and fair elections.
Let us allow the MILF to proceed to the third and last stage of their struggle:
from pure armed struggle from 1972 to 1997; political struggle from 1997 to
the passage and ratification of the proposed Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL); to
democratic struggle where their rights and aspirations are pursued solely through
civilized and democratic means.
237
238
Other Statements
Secondly, the next Congress will be able to focus on other important laws.
It will be spared the burden of having to go through new rounds of committee
hearings and plenary interpellations on a Bangsamoro law.
Some say that the next administration and Congress will have more time.
Our fear is that it would have lost precious time tooprecious time that could
have closed the door to extreme, violent movements that recruit followers by
exploiting the alienation of segments of the population from government and
society at large.
In the light of the recent horrible spate of violence that we have been
witnessing in Paris, Mali, Syria, and other parts of the world, we call to mind
the words of the National Security Council last 20 October 2014, at the public
hearing of the House of Representatives ad hoc committee on the draft law:
The passage of the Bangsamoro Basic Law has positive national
security implications. For one, this will settle one of the more
serious internal armed conflicts and essentially free up a significant
component of the Armed Forces of the Philippines to shift
resources to focus on external concerns, principally the protection of
our external territorial integrity and maritime domain which is now
being threatened.
Passing the BBL can help in curbing the spread of extremism in
Mindanao. In particular, the Bangsamoro government would be able
to help moderate Islamic leaders to counter the ideology of radicalism
being promoted by the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) and steer
the Muslim community away from ISIS influence.*
From this global lens, the Philippine peace process on the Bangsamoro
has earned the support of the international community for providing a model
whereby an Islamic movement can find redress of its grievances through a
civilized and democratic process, within the countrys territorial integrity and
constitutional framework.
* Letter of National Security Adviser Cesar P. Garcia, Jr., director-general of the National
Security Council, read before and submitted to HoR Ad Hoc Committee Chair Rep.
Rufus Rodriguez on October 20, 2014.
239
Other Statements
We are at the cusp of closing a major armed conflict that has divided our
people for decades. But we cannot reach our destination without the goodwill
and show of statesmanship from our leaders in the august halls of Congress, in
whose hands the legislative power lies.
MOHAGHER IQBAL
Chair, MILF Panel
Statement
OPAPP Sec. Teresita Quintos Deles on the Latest Developments
in Congress Deliberations on the BBL
16 DECEMBER 2015
ast week, the President clearly and thoroughly laid out the challenge as well
as the historic opportunity that lie before Congress in enacting the BBL:
that is, the challenge and opportunity to change the Bangsamoro narrative from
one of deprivation, despair, and violence to one of justice, new opportunities, and
hope; also the challenge and opportunity to bring a just and peaceful resolution
of a long-drawn and vicious armed conflict in a world that is in search of respite
from violence and hungry for a way out of the current quagmire of intolerance
and terror that is taking over more and more spaces of our globe. He stressed
that peace in the Bangsamoro is not an issue of his personal legacy; it is not just
for the Bangsamoro but will bring benefits to the entire country.
We continue to hope that Congress will rise to the challenge and seize this
historic opportunity to make a difference and radically shift the landscape not just
for now but very especially for future generations. The House leadership assures
us that there is still time and a way to complete their task, with the immediate
target of completing and closing the interpellation period this December. It is
a very critical period for peace advocates to let their voices be heard loud and
clear by our representatives in Congress. More than ever, we are called to stay the
course in this time of great challenge and possible peril, which is also a season
of great faith, immense hopeof peace, joy, and goodwill for all.
240
Statement
GPH Chief Negotiator Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer on the
Adjournment of Session of the 16th Congress of the
Republic of the Philippines (for the Christmas Season)
17 DECEMBER 2015
As the saying goes, lets not do tomorrow what we can do today. The delay
may not matter to those who live outside of the conflict areas but it matters
a lot to the people in the region who have been most affected by the conflict.
We call on our Filipino brethren to help us see this through. May the
Philippines continue to serve as a bright light of hope for peaceful solutions to
a turbulent world.
241
Statement
GPH Chief Negotiator Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer
on the Adjournment of Session of the 16th Congress of the
Republic of the Philippines (to give way to the May 2016
National and Local Elections)
3 FEBRUARY 2016
et me state the fact: The proposed Bangsamoro Basic Law, in whatever shape
or form, did not make it out of the 16th Congress.
In the Senate, the intermittent absence of the bill sponsor and the remaining
interpellator stalled the deliberation. Moreover, a belated change in procedure
was entertained. Only last December 2015, the Senate practically conceded that
the Bangsamoro bill is of local application and, therefore, the upper chamber
should have just waited for the House version to be remanded to it.
In all, forty public hearings and fourteen plenary deliberations conducted
by the HoR Ad Hoc Committee chaired by Rep. Rufus Rodriguez, and fifteen
public hearings and fourteen sessions of plenary interpellations led by local
governments committee chair Senator Ferdinand Marcos Jr. amounted to
nothing, along with the millions of pesos of taxpayers money used up to finance
these drawn-out proceedings.
242
Other Statements
243
the implementation of the road map cannot be taken away. The Comprehensive
Agreement of the Bangsamoro (CAB) remains a signed document that binds the
Government of the Philippines and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front to their
respective obligations in order to seal the peace through the legal and democratic
processes and meaningful social and political reforms laid out in the document.
The CAB duly takes into consideration the diverse interests of different
stakeholders in the Bangsamoro region, and provides the guideposts to institute
meaningful autonomy and promote social justice through equitable distribution
of wealth and political power in Muslim Mindanaothe very same obligations
that the 1987 Philippine Constitution mandated Congress to do.
The CAB prescribes the steps and mechanisms for the transformation of
conflict-affected areas and MILF camps into secure, productive communities. The
agreement also provides for a gradual and phased process of decommissioning of
MILF weapons and combatants. It addresses the threat posed by other armed
groups and creates the spaces for the convergence of other Bangsamoro claimants
such as the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF) in the new autonomous
government envisioned.
It took a long time to get to this set of practical steps. We need to take away
the fear and distrust of the Bangsamoro for our country to become whole. We,
therefore, urge our politicians and fellow citizens to take the time to study the
history of the conflict and the peace process so as to get a better understanding
of the road map and our unflinching efforts to see it through.
As members of the GPH negotiating panel, we will do everything in the
remaining time that we have to ensure that the infrastructure for implementing
the peace accord are fully functional so that the next administration will be in
a good position to carry forward the full implementation of the agreement.
The road map laid out in the CAB remains viable even as we shall now be
crafting adjustments in the timeline.
Press Release:
Secretary General of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation
(OIC) Meets Leaders of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front
1 MARCH 2016
244
Other Statements
245
purpose. The Secretary General also called upon the international community,
particularly those involved in the peace process and those that witnessed the
signing of the CAB, to urge the incoming administration to save this process
and guarantee the passage of the BBL as originally agreed upon.
The Secretary General urged the Bangsamoro people to unify, consolidate
and converge together toward the advancement of the peace process and the
final resolution of the conflict in Mindanao. He further urged the leaders of
the Bangsamoro people in particular, the MILF and the MNLF to utilize the
existing mechanism, Bangsamoro Coordinating Forum (BCF), to achieve a more
unified position and a more coherent consolidated and sustainable cooperation
for the benefit of the Bangsamoro people.
The Secretary General urged the rest of the peace loving Philippines people
to stand by their brethren in the south in their struggle to support the peace
process.
The OIC headed by Sec. Gen. Iyad Bin Amin Madani (3rd from left) discuss with OPAPP officials
(including Sec. Deles, GPH Peace Panel Members F/Sec. Senen Bacani and NCMF Sec. Yasmin
Busran-Lao, and OPAPP Undersecretary Jose Lorena) the Philippine governments peace process
with the MILF and the MNLF in a meeting held on 17 April 2015 in Manila. The eight-man delegation
of the OIC had a five-day visit in the Philippines, showing their commitment to support the GPHs
peace efforts. While in Manila, the OIC also paid courtesy calls to DFA Sec. Albert Del Rosario, the
HoR leadership, Senate leadership, and Pres. Aquino. (Photo by OPAPP)
Joint Statement
GPH and MILF Peace Panels at the Special Meeting
in Kuala Lumpur
(30 MAY 2016)
The Parties signed the Terms of Reference for the Establishment of the
Bangsamoro Normalization Trust Fund (BNTF), a multi-donor trust fund
envisioned in the Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro (FAB) and the
Annex on Normalization. They have likewise signed the Terms of Reference
for the Project Board of the Mindanao Trust Fund for the Six Previously
Acknowledged MILF Camps (MTF-RDP Camps Project).
The GPH and MILF Peace Panels congratulate President-elect Rodrigo
Roa Duterte. They express optimism that the roadmap provided for in the CAB
will be fully accomplished under his term.
246
247
Other Statements
to the members of the MILF Central Committee and Chairman Al Haj Murad
Ebrahim for their commitment to continue the path to peace.
The Parties also extend their gratitude to His Excellency Tengku Dato Ab
Ghafar Tengku Mohamed as the Third-Party Facilitator from Malaysia; the
members of the International Contact Group, Third Party Monitoring Team
and the Independent Decommissioning Body who attended the meeting; and
the members of the other peace mechanisms for their invaluable contribution
to the Bangsamoro peace process.
Done this 30th day of May 2016 in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
FOR THE GPH:
MOHAGHER IQBAL
Index
Akbar, Jum, 6, 16
AUSAID, 100
249
250
Index
251
Index
252
Index
INDEX, 119-20
253
Index
Infantry Division, 52
Inquirer, 127
Libya, 12, 14, 32, 45, 75, 134, 193, 199, 208
Korea, 112
254
Index
nuclear weapons, 71
Myanmar, 138
Ramadan, 51-54, 62
255
Index
Sahali, Sadikul, 6
Te c h n i c a l E d u c a t i o n a n d S k i l l s
Development Authority (TESDA),
157, 218
Terms of Reference (TOR), 90
256
Index
Zamboanga City, 37