Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
2273
UponmotionofSenatorAngara,therebeingnoobjection,the
Bodyconsidered,onSecondReading,SenateBillNo.2273
(CommitteeReportNo.45),entitled
AN ACT TO FURTHER STRENGTHEN THE ANTI
DRUG CAMP AIGN OF THE GOVERNMENT,
AMENDING FOR THE PURPOSE SECTION 21 OF
REPUBLICACTNO.9165,OTHERWISEKNOWNAS
THE COMPREHENSIVE DANGEROUS DRUGS ACT
OF2002.
PursuanttoSection67,RuleXXIIIoftheRulesoftheSenate,
with the permission of the Body, upon motion of Senator
Angara,onlythetitleofthebillwasreadwithoutprejudiceto
theinsertionofitsfulltextintotheRecordoftheSenate.
TheCommitteedeemedit fittorecommendtheamendmentof
theexistingprovisionbecausewhileSection21wasenshrined
intheComprehensiveDangerousDrugsActtosafeguardthe
integrity of the evidence acquired and prevent planting of
evidence, the application of said section resulted in the
ineffectiveness of the governments campaign to stop
increasingdrugaddictionandalso,intheconflictingdecisions
ofthecourts.
Toillustratebycitingjustthreeofthemostrecentdecisions
involvingSection21:
SPONSORSHIPSPEECHOFSENATORPOE
a.AcasepertainingtoSection21wherenoncomplianceled
toacquittaloftheaccused:
awitnessasrequiredbylaw.
Therequirementthatinventoryisrequiredtobedoneinpolice
stationisalsoverylimiting.Mostpolicestationsappearedto
befarfrom locationswhereaccusedpersonswereappre
hended. In the Alabang Boys case, for example, the
prosecutionfailedtoshowthatthedrugwasbroughttothe
policeinvestigator,becausethedrugswereinsteadbroughtto
the media. And the entire case was affected by breaching
Section21.
Inthemeantime,drugaddictionhassoaredtoanewheight
endangering the youth and destroying society. Citing the
explanatory noteofSenateBillNo.67,thestatisticsofthe
DangerousDrugsBoardestimatedthat1.7millionFilipinos
arehookedondrugs,representinga200,000increasefromthe
numberofdruguserstwoyearsago.
Panahon na po para susugan ang ating batas para sa
malawakang pagsugpo ng droga. Dahil ito ay sumisira ng
buhay at ng pami/ya. Dahil ito ay problema ng maraming
kabataan.Dahilitoaynagbabaonngatinglipunansalalong
kahirapan.
Hinihingi ko poangpagsangayonngKapulunganparasa
mabilisnopagpasangpanukalangito,parasoalingboyanat
lipunan.
COSPONSORSHIPSPEECHOFSENATORSOTTO
SenatorSottolikewisesoughttheapprovalofSenateBillNo.
2272 under Committee Report No. 45, entitled "An Act to
Further Strengthen the AntiDrug Campaign of the
Government, Amending for the Purpose Section 21 of
Republic Act No. 9165, otherwise known as the
ComprehensiveDrugsActof2002."
HereunderisSenatorSotta'scosponsorshipspeech:
Ithasbeenmorethan12yearsnowsincewe passedthe
Comprehensive Drugs Act of 2002, and our experience
requires certain adjustments so that we can plug the
loopholesinourexistinglaw.
The statistics of the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency
showthattherehavebeen1,538drugrelatedcasesthatwere
either dismissed or resulted in acquittals. Pinpointed as the
basisofthesecourtactionsisSection21ofRA9165;thisis
what the lawyers ofthe drug dealers saw as a loophole. It
readsasfollows:
Section 21. CustodyandDispositionofConfiscated,Seized,
andlor Surrendered Dangerous Drugs, Plant Sources o f
Dangerous Drugs, Controlled Precursors and Essential
Chemicals, Instruments Paraphernalia andlor Laboratory
Equipment.ThePDEAshalltakechargeandhavecustodyof
all dangerous drugs, plant sources of dangerous drugs,
controlledprecursorsandessentialchemicals,aswellas
orofficeoftheapprehendinglawenforcers.Theproposalwill
provideeffectivemeasurestoensuretheintegrityofseized
illegaldrugssinceasafe locationmakesitmoreprobable
foraninventoryandphotographofseizedillegaldrugstobe
properly conducted, thereby reducing the incidents o f
dismissalofdrugtechnicalities.
Nonobservance of the prescribed procedures should not
automaticallymeanthattheseizureorconfiscationisinvalid
or illegal, as long as the law enforcement officers could
justify the same and could prove that the integrity and the
evidentiaryvalueoftheseizeditemsarenottainted.Thisis
theeffectoftheinclusionintheproposaltoamendthephrase
"justifiablegrounds."Thereareinstanceswhereinthere
are no media people or representatives from the DOJ
available and the absence of these witnesses should not
automaticallyinvalidatethedrugoperationconducted.Even
the presence of a public local elected official also is
sometimesimpossibleespeciallyiftheelectedofficialisafraid
orscared.
Ourproposaltoplugthisloopholeinour lawsconveysour
messagetooursocietyandtotheworldaswemovetowards
a drugfree Philippines, a drugresistant Philippines. This
Representation does not agree with the new wave of
toleranceandaccommodationtowardsmarijuanaandother
mindblowingalteringsubstancessweepingafewcountries
inEuropeandastateortwointheUnitedStates.
Westandfirmonthismatterandthisproposalwillproveour
resolvetostayinourcourse.
TERMINATIONOFINTERPELLATIONSPERIOD
TERMINATIONOFTHEOFAMENDMENTS
PERIOD OF THE There being no interpellation, upon
motionofSenatorAngara,therebeingnoobjection,theBody
closedtheperiodofinterpellations.
There being no committee or individual amendment, upon
motionofSenatorAngara,therebeingnoobjection,theBody
closedtheperiodofamendments.
MOTIONOFSENATORANGARA
SenatorAngaramovedtoapproveSenateBillNo.2273on
SecondReading.
SenatorOsmena,however,voicedhisconcernoverthehasty
approval of the bill. Thereupon, he moved that the bill's
considerationbedeferredtogivetheothersenatorsthechance
tointerpellateandloramendit.
MANIFESTATIONOFSENATORSOTTO
Senator Sotto appealed to Senator Osmena to allow the
passage on Second Reading of Senate Bill No. 2278, a
Source:
http://senate.gov.ph/lisdata/1930616439!.pdf