Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Case Analysis
Submitted by
Group 10
22 September 2015
Here
are
the
calculations.
High
surgeon
utilization
rates.
Average
surgeon
conducts
only
25-50
operations
per
year,
as
compared
to
(7500
operations/10
surgeons)
750
operations
per
year.
High
utilization
rates
of
the
nurses.
The
average
ratio
of
nurses-patients
was
1:4.
But
Shouldice
was
able
to
maintain
a
ratio
of
1:15.
Only
2
equipment
were
required
for
administering
anesthesia
for
5
operating
rooms
as
against
a
ratio
of
1:1.
This
reduced
equipment
cost
by
60%.
Nurses
spent
an
unusually
large
proportion
of
their
time
in
counselling
activities.
Secondly,
Shouldice
uses
the
network
of
patients
as
a
support
system.
This
reduced
the
load
on
the
medical
staff
and
the
post-operative
care.
Because
the
patients
don't
stay
in
bed
all
day,
there
is
no
need
to
change
linens
every
day
and
hence,
only
3
housekeeping
staff
is
required
for
the
entire
facility.
Service
Efficiency:
Besides,
it
is
also
mentioned
that
the
recurrence
rate
for
hernia
under
Shouldice
method
is
0.8%
as
compared
to
the
recurrence
rate
in
the
United
States
which
averages
10%.
This
is
a
remarkable
achievement
as
far
as
effectiveness
of
surgery
goes.
And
to
maintain
the
quality
of
service
high,
recurrence
cases
were
sent
to
the
same
surgeons
who
initially
operated
the
patients,
and
thereby
giving
a
chance
to
reduce
mistakes
in
future.
3.
As
Dr.
Shouldice,
what
actions,
if
any,
would
you
take
to
expand
the
hospital's
capacity?
It
is
known
that
Shouldice
Hospital
currently
has
a
backlog
of
2,400
patients
that
increases
by
100
every
six
months.
Hence,
there
is
a
need
to
expand
the
hospitals
practices
for
which
following
options
are
laid
down
before
Dr.
Shouldice
for
consideration:
A)
Running
hospital
services
on
Saturday
B)
Expanding
bed
capacity
by
50%
in
existing
unit
C)
Setting
up
a
new
hospital
in
Ontario
or
United
States
D)
Diversify
into
other
specialties
such
as
eye
surgery,
varicose
veins
or
diagnostic
services
The
preferred
option
should
be
the
one
that
satiates
the
current
backlog
of
2,400
patients
and
also
the
increasing
backlog
of
200
patients
(100
x
2)
per
annum
for
at
least
the
next
10
years.
A)
Running
hospital
services
on
Saturday
Shouldice
Hospital
believes
in
maintaining
good
working
relationships
with
its
surgeons
on
board.
The
idea
of
running
hospital
services
on
Saturday
has
already
been
criticized
by
4
out
of
10
surgeons
and
Dr.
Shouldice
sees
a
possible
rift
among
the
doctors
on
this
issue.
Hence,
going
against
the
consent
of
certain
doctors
is
not
recommended
given
that
Shouldice
Hospital
wants
to
maintain
service
quality
levels
of
its
treatments
and
therefore,
cannot
afford
to
hire
new
surgeons
in
replacement
of
dissenting
doctors.
Even
otherwise,
the
hospital
capacity
would
increase
only
by
20%
i.e.
7600
x
20%
=
1,320
surgeries
as
against
the
current
backlog
of
2,400
patients
which
is
bound
to
further
increase
by
200
patients
every
year.
Hence,
the
option
of
running
hospital
services
on
weekends
is
being
ruled
out
since
it
does
not
solve
the
purpose
of
expansion.
B)
Expanding
bed
capacity
by
50%
in
existing
unit
Given
that
the
bed
capacity
is
a
bottleneck
for
the
firm,
Dr.
Shouldice
may
choose
to
increase
the
bed
capacity
by
50%
with
an
investment
of
$4
million
in
the
new
space
and
thereby,
scale
up
the
number
of
surgeries
by
2,650
(Exhibit
1).
This
is
attainable
even
without
corresponding
increase
in
number
of
operating
rooms
and
staff
resources
(detailed
execution
plan
explained
in
response
to
Q.4).
This
option
will
help
the
hospital
in
not
just
addressing
the
current
backlog
of
2,400
patients
but
also
sustaining
the
increasing
demand
of
200
patients
for
at
least
next
13
years
(2650/200).
Thus,
this
is
a
feasible
option
provided
Shouldice
Hospital
has
sufficient
funds
for
investing
in
expansion
of
bed
capacity.
C)
Setting
up
a
new
hospital
in
Ontario
(outside
Toronto)
or
United
States
By
starting
another
hospital
in
the
US,
Dr.
Shouldice
will
be
able
to
manage
the
backlog
to
a
good
extent,
because
10%
of
its
patients
came
from
outside
Ontario,
mostly
from
the
United
States.
But
the
challenges
with
the
idea
are
recruiting
new
doctors,
maintaining
service
quality
levels
and
government
regulations.
The
existing
government
regulations
like
minimum
wage
rate,
worker
unions,
patient
to
nurse
ratio
etc.
might
not
be
favorable
to
a
hospital
like
Shouldice
which
currently
operates
in
a
business
friendly
environment.
It
is
also
clear
that
even
by
travelling
to
Ontario,
the
patients
are
incurring
a
comparatively
lesser
cost
than
the
average
of
$5,240.
Given
that
60%
of
the
patients
coming
for
treatment
are
from
areas
in
Toronto
outside
Ontario,
Dr.
Shouldice
may
consider
starting
a
new
hospital
in
this
zone.
This
stint
would
entail
higher
capital
investment
as
compared
to
the
second
option;
however,
it
is
at
least
more
practicable
than
directly
starting
a
new
hospital
in
the
US.
The
reason
being
that
starting
a
new
hospital
in
Canada
will
enable
them
to
position
themselves
as
a
stronger
brand
in
the
home
country
first
before
moving
to
a
new
country.
However,
the
issue
of
maintaining
service
quality
service
levels
is
still
not
resolved
and
hence,
this
option
is
also
ruled
out.
D)
Diversify
into
other
specialties
such
as
eye
surgery,
varicose
veins
or
diagnostic
services
This
option
is
clearly
not
an
encouraging
one
as
this
way,
Shouldice
Hospital
will
be
diluting
its
brand
value
and
will
be
losing
its
strategic
focus
to
other
specialties.
4.
How
would
you
implement
changes
you
propose?
The
pros
of
option
B
far
outweigh
the
cons
and
most
importantly
it
helps
the
Shouldice
Hospital
in
addressing
the
current
backlog
of
2,400
patients.
Hence,
we
propose
that
Dr.
Shouldice
should
consider
investing
in
increasing
the
bed
capacity
by
50%
so
as
to
use
the
operating
rooms
more
productively.
For
this
an
extra
floor
could
be
constructed
over
the
existing
unit.
The
main
benefits
of
this
option
are
utilization
of
the
current
staff
and
a
tested
process
with
no
radical
changes
required.
With
increased
bed
capacity
more
number
of
operations
can
be
scheduled.
The
operation
rooms
can
be
utilized
in
the
evening
hours
by
calling
the
available
full-time
surgeons
in
two
shifts
with
5
doctors
in
first
shift
from
7.30
PM
to
3
PM
and
the
second
shift
timings
from
1:00
AM
to
07:30
PM.
This
will
require
employment
of
2
new
part-time
assistant
surgeons,
making
it
5
for
each
shift.
The
number
of
operations
will
go
up
to
40
to
45
operations
per
day
with
surgeons
in
second
shift
performing
4
to
5
operations.
The
increased
number
of
operations
will
help
clear
existing
backlog
and
cater
to
increased
demand
through
advertisements
(The
calculations
are
shown
in
Exhibit
1).
The
above
option
entails
infrastructure
cost
($4
million)
and
increased
salary
expenses
for
additional
part-time
assistant
surgeons.
These
can
be
covered
by
increased
revenues
from
increased
number
of
surgeries.
Recommendations
for
Shouldice
Hospital:
1.
Shouldice
Hospital
should
consider
doing
extensive
advertising
through
brochures,
pamphlets
etc
in
Year
2
after
clearing
the
existing
backlog
in
order
to
utilize
the
excess
capacity
in
proposed
option
i.e.
2,250
beds
(2650-200-200)
through
increased
demand
generated
from
advertising
in
Canada
and
US.
2.
It
is
recommended
that
the
long
term
strategy
of
the
hospital
should
be
to
set
up
a
hospital
facility
in
US
and
capture
a
sizeable
market
share
in
the
growing
demand
for
hernia
operations
in
US
(1
million
operations
in
2,000).
3.
The
hospital
could
patent
its
treatment
process
so
as
to
prevent
its
emulation
by
its
competitors
in
future.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
Exhibit
1
Computation
of
increase
in
number
of
operations
Existing
capacity
Current
number
of
beds
=
89
Number
of
full-time
surgeons
=
10
Operations
carried
out
per
day
=
30
to
36
----->
(A)
With
expansion
in
capacity
by
a
new
floor
Increased
number
of
beds
=
133
(50%
increase)
Maximum
number
of
operations
in
a
day
with
increased
bed
capacity
=
45
Number
of
full
time
surgeons
in
1st
shift
i.e.
7.00
AM
to
3.00
PM
=
5
(Surgery
7.00
AM
to
12.30
AM
and
Examination
1.00
PM
to
3.00
PM)
Number
of
operations
in
1st
working
shift
7.00
AM
to
12.30
PM
=
20
(4
operations
per
doctor)
Number
of
full
time
surgeons
in
2nd
shift
i.e.
1:00
AM
to
07.30
PM
=
5
Number
of
operations
in
2nd
working
shift
=
20
to
25
(4
to
5
operations
per
doctor)
Total
number
of
operations
with
new
capacity
=
44
to
45
operations
----->
(B)
Considering
lower
of
(A)
and
(B),
Number
of
operations
that
can
be
undertaken
in
a
day
=
44
to
45
operations
Net
percentage
increase
in
operations
=
34.84%
Day
2
Increased
Capacity:
20
40
60
80
100
120
Monday
45
Tuesday
44
44
Wednesday
45
44
44
Thursday
45
44
44
Friday
45
44
44
Saturday
45
45
Sunday
45
45
Monday
45
44
140
44
Note
-
It
is
understood
that
the
patients
who
check
in
on
a
given
day
will
leave
the
hospital
on
the
fourth
day
morning
and
new
patients
will
check
in
on
same
day
afternoon.
It
is
further
understood
that
patients
who
check
in
on
Friday
will
stay
in
the
hospital
over
the
weekend
and
will
be
operated
on
Monday.